Kostornaia is in a class by herself. Both her short and long programs during last year's pre-corona, figure skating competitions were textbook perfection.
I like Alena’s more because of her more complicated entry and exit and the fact that Tuktamysheva always takes forever to set hers up, but at the same time Alena’s exits can look somewhat uncontrolled
@@user-hh4us9rz2b Вам это кажется. :) Окрас, на самом деле, исключительно аналитический! :) ( Что касается Лизы, то лично мне бы ОЧЕНЬ хотелось, чтобы Лиза таки СДЕЛАЛА этот прыжок. Это будет шаг вперед в понимании возможностей женской части человечества на льду. Говорю аккуратно, дабы не сглазить. Впрочем, Вы, похоже, из стана болельщиков за конкретную фигуру, а потому мои личные "хотелки" относительно другой фигуры, Вам малоинтересны.)
Liza is great at jumps, she's a queen but My Triple Axel Queen is Alena no doubt. It just looks so effortless, specially the first one, just textbook Axel. Beautiful entry and transitions. I hope she can come back with that beautiful 3A again.
Alena's entrances and exits used to be amazing. However, Liza"s jumps are great, smooth with beautiful rotations. Liza continues improving. Alena has to start over again. So my admiration goes to Liza.
Ну тут честно говоря нет смысла сравнивать. Триксель Алёны самый красивый из исполненных за все время фк. Это говорилось не однократно Другое дело, увидим ли мы его ещё когда-нибудь. Надеюсь, что да
Конечно у Алёны был прекрасный 3А ,но в отличии от Лизы она его исполняла в одном сезоне .А Лиза из сезона в сезон идёт со своим трикселем и показывает его на соревнованиях даже в текущем сезоне
alena’s 3a’s are much prettier to look at and have a lot more height and power, she also begins her rotations in the air meanwhile eliza begins her rotations a bit early
Liza's look sooo effortless, it has always intrigued me 'cause her arms on the take off doesn't go like a horse charging at you at full speed instead it's like just a flick or little swoop of the arm then BAM landed
Tuktamyseva has much higher, completely rotated axel, almost like a man is jumping, Alena only relied in speed and fast rotation but as we see that didn't last long, she lost her triple axel and can't do it anymore...unlike Elizaveta who does her triple axel for 10 years.
But E she doesnt lands it all the time... I bet Alena is the same, but she doesnt want to risk it to a fall or injury and its her choice. Dont think she cant do it at all. I've noticed that Alena its that kind of figure skater that doesnt want to fall like at all or do a program with this uncertain feeling of not knowing if she can do everything 100%. In the opposite way we have for example, Trusova, she will always try a quad even risking to a fall... and its ok, everyone has a diff way to perform.. I would do the same as Alena.
@@Aleks0709 you cant compare rotation speed and height. Both have their strenght in this jump. But if u lack of rot speed It can be improved easily. If u lack of height... that depends a lot of how tall u are, ur weight. Its more difficult.
@@Aleks0709 well I'm not ur teacher lol, go and learn about it and it will make sense. What doesnt make any sense is that u only say u cant compare them and give no explanation at all. Its like u just talking from a fan base. And its ok too, Im no one to judge.. but I'll make u know how this works at least 🤭
Which skaters would you like to see next?
Sofia akatyeva VS Sofia samodelkina
Alena has a more complicated entry, but Tuktamysheva's is sooo effortless, it just comes out of nowhere!
Lol?
Kostornaia is in a class by herself. Both her short and long programs during last year's pre-corona, figure skating competitions were textbook perfection.
I like Alena’s more because of her more complicated entry and exit and the fact that Tuktamysheva always takes forever to set hers up, but at the same time Alena’s exits can look somewhat uncontrolled
У Алёны Косторной тройной аксель просто Шедевр - высокий, пролетный, яркий и чистый! Восторг и ещё раз Восторг!
Ключевое слово на сегодня - "был"! Увы.
@@m.yakhlakova4094 у Лизы триксель пропадал на целых два года и ничего вернулся
@@user-hh4us9rz2b Так я и не делаю никаких прогнозов на будущее! Говорю исключительно о настоящем :)
@@m.yakhlakova4094 просто как-то с негативным окрасом вы это говорите...
@@user-hh4us9rz2b Вам это кажется. :) Окрас, на самом деле, исключительно аналитический! :)
( Что касается Лизы, то лично мне бы ОЧЕНЬ хотелось, чтобы Лиза таки СДЕЛАЛА этот прыжок. Это будет шаг вперед в понимании возможностей женской части человечества на льду. Говорю аккуратно, дабы не сглазить. Впрочем, Вы, похоже, из стана болельщиков за конкретную фигуру, а потому мои личные "хотелки" относительно другой фигуры, Вам малоинтересны.)
Liza is great at jumps, she's a queen but My Triple Axel Queen is Alena no doubt. It just looks so effortless, specially the first one, just textbook Axel. Beautiful entry and transitions. I hope she can come back with that beautiful 3A again.
Tukta's hands at entrance are so cute
Alena's entrances and exits used to be amazing. However, Liza"s jumps are great, smooth with beautiful rotations. Liza continues improving. Alena has to start over again. So my admiration goes to Liza.
Yup. She's a lifer. That's where good technique really matters. It is not as dependent on chance.
Aliona super 3A 💖
Ну тут честно говоря нет смысла сравнивать. Триксель Алёны самый красивый из исполненных за все время фк. Это говорилось не однократно
Другое дело, увидим ли мы его ещё когда-нибудь. Надеюсь, что да
Liza looks effortless, I like her jumps.
Aliona super 💖
У Лизы он силовой, вверх, а у Алёны просто Космос! Высокий да ещё и какой пролётный! Браво, девочки!!!
Both correct technique - Alena has a more elegant skating and style
Liza's 3 Axel is much cleaner. Alena's is always a bit underrotated
her rotation speed is always her drawback
No
Конечно у Алёны был прекрасный 3А ,но в отличии от Лизы она его исполняла в одном сезоне .А Лиза из сезона в сезон идёт со своим трикселем и показывает его на соревнованиях даже в текущем сезоне
Лиза на 3 или 4 сезона его теряла как бы.
Алена!!!
Алёна конечно❤️ у Лизы как-то обрубленно выглядит
У Лизы великолепно исполненный,классический сложный прыжок и выезд из него идеальный.Но как прыгает его Алена,это конечно ФЕНОМЕН 🤩
Liza’s jump technique is better but Alena is obviously a much better skater with far superior skating skills.
alena’s 3a’s are much prettier to look at and have a lot more height and power, she also begins her rotations in the air meanwhile eliza begins her rotations a bit early
Aliona's 3A is higher, the altitude she reaches is higher than Liza's.
Tecnica corretta - Alena ha una pattinata e uno style più elegante
Alena´s 3A has a good entry but it loos like a 2A, Liza´s 3A really looks like a 3A. I choose Elizaveta.
Yes! Agreed. Liza's jump better technically. Her technique is also obviously more long-lived
Why could not Alena do 3A any more after October, 2020?
She did jump 3A after October, check out test skates and 2021-2022 comps
Tuktamysheva technically better
Can't choose :)
👑👍🌈🇮🇹💯
@Single loop how can you allow that dun h. Is insulting someone on your channel and using profanities???
Liza's look sooo effortless, it has always intrigued me 'cause her arms on the take off doesn't go like a horse charging at you at full speed instead it's like just a flick or little swoop of the arm then BAM landed
Not just axel, Elizaveta is generally much better skater.
@S K sure, that stuff is called "rules and techniques of figure skating"... Try it
@S K no, not new, not fan, no craziness, just plain figure skating, basics all of us should know. When you educate more you will realise. Cheers
@S K yeah you won the competition you're the most clueless one about the figure skating
Tuktamyseva has much higher, completely rotated axel, almost like a man is jumping, Alena only relied in speed and fast rotation but as we see that didn't last long, she lost her triple axel and can't do it anymore...unlike Elizaveta who does her triple axel for 10 years.
But E she doesnt lands it all the time... I bet Alena is the same, but she doesnt want to risk it to a fall or injury and its her choice. Dont think she cant do it at all.
I've noticed that Alena its that kind of figure skater that doesnt want to fall like at all or do a program with this uncertain feeling of not knowing if she can do everything 100%. In the opposite way we have for example, Trusova, she will always try a quad even risking to a fall... and its ok, everyone has a diff way to perform.. I would do the same as Alena.
@@caamigart the quality of these axels is incomparable
@@Aleks0709 you cant compare rotation speed and height. Both have their strenght in this jump.
But if u lack of rot speed It can be improved easily.
If u lack of height... that depends a lot of how tall u are, ur weight. Its more difficult.
@@caamigart that doesn't make sense
@@Aleks0709 well I'm not ur teacher lol, go and learn about it and it will make sense.
What doesnt make any sense is that u only say u cant compare them and give no explanation at all. Its like u just talking from a fan base. And its ok too, Im no one to judge.. but I'll make u know how this works at least 🤭
I can't stand watching Tuktamysheva's 3a. Her entry looks so bad when she holds hands like this. Her movements are sloppy as if she's half asleep