Many pro-Hamas/Palestinians just blindly followed the media that Israel is an apartheid state, Israel started genocides on Palestinians and starve Palestinians. In this war, Israel failed to make use of the media to their advantage. When I looked at Israel, they have Arabs and Druze in their country but I don't see Jews in Gaza. So who is the apartheid state? Starvation is all made out by UN. Everyday there are hundreds of food trucks going into Gaza. Some food trucks were hijacked by Hamas as seen in the videos. They have videos of a place like a warehouse where the food in bags were offloaded and kept there. How dare UN said Israel starved Palestinians? Regards to Genocide, Israel gave notices to Palestinians to evacuate to a safer zone before they bombed the place. NO country in a war ever did that. Not even in Ukraine-Russian war. For Genocide to occur, one must show *it has the intent to destroy an ethnic group* according to UN definition of Genocide, yet UN allowed South Africa to rant that Israel committed Genocide. Genocide does not depend on number of people killed, as genocide could happen to a group of only 5 people. Hamas on the other hands, say all Jews must be eliminated. That is already an intent shown.
Yea because all the doctors from various countries and other humanitarian groups who been in Gaza are all lying. Also there tons video showing the level of starvation going in Gaza. But the mainstream media is not showing it. I can pull up tons of videos right now showing children who are literally skin and bones and look like holocaust survivors. Maybe stop watch mainstream media and actually do some home work.
@Karen-nn3jn no they don't im sorry but you don't know what your talking about. Your only looking at what mainstream media is showing which is mostly the Palestine in the south which has been getting humanitarian aide in. Even then there still a food shortage in south. In the north of Gaza it's very different as nothing is getting through. There horrible pictures and videos showing how emaciated the people are especially the children. What they are eating is not health amd making them sick. Please shut your mouth and educate your self beyond what mainstream media is telling you. They are lying to you and not telling you the truth.
In what way is Israel an illegal state? What law did it break by proclaiming its independence in a terra nullius formed by the end of the British mandate?
@@lforlight Are you slow, how could you claim the land was terra nullius you sound like you come from the 14th century, there were more Palestinians than Jews before the first war broke out, let’s not forget the Nakba which expelled 750,000 of them.
@@sufou And you have failed to do any research. Jews bought all the land they settled on and the borders of 1947 were closely related to those lands. Palestinians were given majority palestinian areas while jews were given majority jewish areas. Also there is 0 evidance towards the nakba being done by israel, there is one or two isolated incident (that are even being taught in israel as an example of when not to follow orders) but other then that none, there is actually more evidence towards arab leaders asking palestinians to leave and come back when they win the war. In the creation of Israel it even calls for all palestinians to stay and all of those that did stay got citizenship.
@@FantasticKruH oh no here we go again with the “Jews purchased land and Palestinians sold it” nonsense, the Zionist purchasing power could barely acquire 5-7 percent of land sources form 1945 indicate to be scattered they did not purchase entire towns, this is a common trope Zionist try to portray in order to justify their illegal existence. I can’t believe you claim that the Nakba didn’t happen, congrats you are now on the level of neo-nazi holocaust revisionism. I would recommend Ilan Pappe “An Indicative Archive: Salvaging Nakba Documents” where he uncovers classified documents from the The Yad Yaari archive which houses the documents of the Mapam Party and its youth movement the Hashomer Hatzair, whose members formed the nucleus of the Palmach (the Haganah's commando units), which spearheaded military operations in 1947-49 that orchestrated the Nakba, maybe some research on your end is needed because I don’t wish to go through every single massacre and event that took place. Palestinians to this day still wish to return to their homeland and for the Arabs that become citizens of the Israeli state they will always be second class citizens, what other choice do they have.
@@sufou UN Resolution awarded the Palestinians (they didn't call themselves that then) an independent sovereign state. Why did they reject it and attack the Jewish state instead?
Israel is the ONLY country on the planet where people say "maybe it shouldn't t have been formed in the first place." Gee, what would be the difference between Israel and every other country? Hmh, what could it be? I didn't need to hear anything else from this kid.
There's a checkpoint for people to go through where you checked for weapons etc, a 6 year old girl was checked by soldiers. She was prepared, opened her bag and checked. Took her bag and walked off. He pulled and slammed her against the wall and shouted in her face. You will go when I say you must go. She's 6. Slammed against a wall. Tell me why there should be a checkpoint? To slam kids against the wall. I'm from South Africa. The man who witnessed this is our family. Nevermind abuse of power. If this happened in America you would riot against police for brutality. Israel shouldn't be policing them in the first place but ok. They the terrorists lol they the ones at fault. They stealing land and putting up settlements and arrest thousands and have a fair trial process for them-thays sarcasm if you don't get it but hey you all are educated. You know better
But send more billions in aid to soldiers. Meanwhile they no longer even paying for their own genocide cough sorry I mean war oh wait land grabbing. They using US tax payer money to do it. There's a group of Israeli soldiers called Breaking Free. They somewhere on you tube. They expose the truth as to how fake operations are ran in Palestinian homes to stop them from working, intimidate them. Meanwhile there's no operations. Imagine.
Many pro-Hamas/Palestinians just blindly followed the media that Israel is an apartheid state, Israel started genocides on Palestinians and starve Palestinians. In this war, Israel failed to make use of the media to their advantage.
This is the problem, this guy is not a bad person but like he says "I know very little about the history". Most of them either know nothing or get fed lies. There are the exceptions of actual horrible people.
Its a refreshing change to actually seeing someone willing to listen to another side of the argument and not have the tunnel mindset, well done to the young man for that
I appreciate that he is trying to see both sides and accepts that war is horrible without spewing the G word. But he needs to get his facts right. He seems to think that Israel has initiated conflicts when, in fact, Israel has only defended itself against Arab aggression. He also needs to educate himself about Jewish history and their connection to the land including or especially Judea & Samaria. But kudos to him for trying to be fair minded
@@noname-ip9xe I hope Israel moves the "Palestinians" from Judea & Samaria to join their Gaza "Palestinians" wherever they end up. Israel needs to fully control Judea & Samaria which, strategically, is high ground.
Seems like a really intelligent kid. His facts may be a little hazy in some details, but he's really thinking about things rationally and honestly considering the information as he learns it.
Hey Cam, I like your videos, could you reference the humanitarian aid trucks entering Gaza via Egypt vs Israel. I would like to have a primary source handy. Cheers
He has no sources besides the Israeli officials themselves, every relief agency has been relaying that Israel has not complied with humanitarian law, it controls what flows into Gaza including the Rafa border crossing in Egypt and aid trucks have been sitting there for months. I will provide a good resource that examines the amount of trucks that were allowed to flow through Gaza through October 13-November 13 2024, when the US secretary of defence issued a letter urging Israel to allow 350 aid trucks a day, as all of North Gaza was facing famine and disease, it failed to allow even 1000 over the course of 30 days.
@@sufou The UN admits that two thirds of the hundreds of tons of supplies inserted into Gaza were stolen by Hamas (who then sold them at exhorbitant prices)
@@sufou You are quoting misinformation. Right after Oct 7th attack, Israel stopped aid trucks for only a short time. After that, food and aid was getting to the border. UNWRA themselves actually admitted that Hamas looted / loots the aid trucks, stores it all in overflowing warehouses, takes what they want and sells the rest to civilians that can afford to pay. Markets are full of aid stamped goods being sold which was meant to be free. For that matter, why were the Palestinians getting aid in the first place prior to Oct 7th? Why have the Palestinians been getting foreign aid since 1948? Why is Hamas the second richest terrorist organization in the world accepting the equivalent of billions of US dollars every year for decades?
sweet video and fair enough re the point about aid going in . its easy enough to see in the celebrations of hamas in gaza that the people dont look starved at all but there are some mistakes assumed in the video : any country which is under attacked and ends up taking land in the course of a defensive war is entitled to keep that land (int law) . Israel is not an illegal state any more than Jordan or Lebanon or pakistan who were all formed in the 20th cent with full recognition !
The assertion that a nation's existence should be negated based on its demographic or ethnic composition constitutes a clear manifestation of bigotry. The right of all nations to exist is axiomatic. While disparities exist in governmental efficacy and societal harmony, the fundamental right to national existence remains inviolable. Israel was established under the same legal framework as most other Middle Eastern, South American and African states. Its borders were delineated according to its Mandate and the international legal principle of uti possidetis juris. Denying this fundamental truth constitutes an act of antisemitism.
international law does not explicitly recognize a "right to exist" for any nation as a legal principle. But it does recognizes state sovereignty and self-determination for people, if you were so caught up with the right for peoples to exist why not focus your energy on Palestinian or Kurdish statehood. According to case law “the principle of uti possidetis was formulated to serve a dual purpose: first, a defensive purpose towards the rest of the world, in the form of an outright denial that there was any land without a sovereign (or terra nullius)” Israel's borders were not definitively set by the 47 UN partition plan and the wars that followed, to claim that Israel should occupy all of Palestine under uti possidestis juris a nasty and outdated attempt by you to annex the remaining areas which Israel already does, if you are going to abide by international law Israel must stick to its responsibilities under IL which is neglect and resolutions to withdraw from the west bank and the golan heights. Stop using antisemitism to justify the horrid crimes of the Israeli states.
@@scottwolf8633The “Arabs” have 22 states, if you are referring to the Palestinian there was no offer there was an agreement made by foreign powers and the refusal to abide by them, no country or people on the planet would give up a place they call home and it is extremely naive to say in hindsight they should have.
@@sufou Muda'rat, read what Clinton and Barak offered. Olmert offered ALL of the lands won from Transjordan and Egypt's Gaza and included 65 square miles of 1949 Armistice Border Land from Israel.
@ While international law may not explicitly codify a singular, freestanding "right to exist" in the same way it protects specific human rights, the principle is deeply embedded within the framework of statehood and sovereignty. The Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States (1933), a cornerstone of statehood recognition, establishes criteria including a permanent population, defined territory, government, and capacity to enter into relations with other states. Implicit in meeting these criteria is the acknowledgment of a state's right to exist as a functioning entity within the international system. Furthermore, the UN Charter, particularly Article 2(4) prohibiting the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state, 1 presupposes the existing right of states to maintain their existence. This is particularly relevant considering that many modern sovereign states were established through the League of Nations mandate or protectorate system. These mandates, often delineating borders based on prior administrative divisions, were formalized through international agreements. The principle of uti possidetis juris, which holds that newly formed states inherit the administrative boundaries of their predecessor entities, further solidified these borders in international law. The very concepts of self-determination, territorial integrity, and sovereign equality, foundational principles of the international legal order, are predicated on the inherent right of states to exist and function within defined borders, often established through mandates and solidified by uti possidetis juris, free from external aggression or dissolution. Therefore, while not explicitly labeled as such, the “right to exist” is a necessary and fundamental corollary to the established principles of statehood and sovereignty in international law.
im happy to see a young guy trying to understand the subject, but the way he spoke at the start showed he has no idea of this conflict. i wish him the best of luck in learning about this
That’s like starting “ it was pretty nice the mugger actually gave me back my wallet even though I ended up in the hospital and required multiple surgeries “ 🧐
I am an Egyptian, and story of 67 that arrived to us is very different from what you said hahah, so it is very nice to hear the other side, as for us we were told that Israel took Sinai purely for expansion reasons, and they started the attack on 67 under the false flag of a need for a preemptive attack. The story for us also includes that if we hadn't made our surprise attack at 73 and took half of Sinai back, Israel would have never agreed to the peace and given up Sinai back. * But what is interesting to know is that when we got Sinai back after the peace, there was actually development done by Israel in Sinai, as they had actually built hotels and apartments complexes by the red sea (which still exists until this day and some still owned by the Israelis), they also added roads and added some basic infrastructure. Which to be honest collaborates the expansionist idea, but who knows maybe they only decided to develop since it was at the time theirs anyway and thought why not, but this definitely refutes the idea that they had plan of giving it back for peace.
Israel preemptively attacked Egypt because Egypt closed or was going to close the strait of Tiran to ALL sea traffic going to Israel. Egypt also kicked out UN peacekeepers in the Sinai and started building military forces there, which was an indication of plans to attack Israel.
Omg!!!! Pleeeeeease find some history not written by Egyptians and read it. That is so crazy what they taught you, wow. Seriously read up on thr story. Its a really thrilling story!! And one note for you: israel has NEVER started a war. Never. The arab nations around it have had very big ambitions to annihilate it from thr start. So they kept starting wars with israel. And losing. And then when they lose they blame israel.
19 June 1967 - the National Unity Government of Israel voted unanimously to return the Sinai to Egypt and the Golan Heights to Syria in return for peace agreements. 1 September 1967 - Khartoum Resolution adopted by the Arab League, stipulating no recognition of Israel, no negotiations with Israel, and no peace with Israel ("Three Noes"). Israel had no reason to assume peace would be negotiated any time soon. Till this day they have no peace agreement with Syria.
Never in history was palestinian poeple or nation called palestine. Palestine was geographic region name for the land its including jordan in the time off the british mandate also name trans jordan.palestine is latin name not arabic.the arabs take the palestinian identity in 1964 by yaaser arafat egyptian man like many off these arabs caling themself palestinian came from.in the 19 centery 1878 the ottoman sultan bring arabs from the suranded arabs country as working immigrat.the same with the british mandate in 1923.these are the arabs caling themself palestinian.you can tel wish arabs country the came from by the family name.el masry from egypt.el baghdadi from iraq.tamimi from yemen.jewish poeple was always in the land off israel.before 1967 west bank was jordan not palestine.the same with gaza was egypt before 1967.is many physical evidence this land belong to the jewish poeple archeologic.in the quran israel mention 43 time palestine 0 time.
Here are some heart-warming Islamic sources that rarely get quoted, but Hams quotes them: Quran 98:6 "Verily, those who disbelieve (in the religion of Islam, the Quran and Prophet Muhammad) from among the people of the Scripture (Jews and Christians) and Al-Mushrikun will abide in the Fire of Hell. They are the worst of creatures." Narrated Abu Huraira: Allah's Apostle said, "I have been sent with the shortest expressions bearing the widest meanings, and I have been made victorious with terror (cast in the hearts of the enemy) - Sahih al-Bukhari 2977 "Messenger of Allah said: I will expel the Jews and Christians from the Arabian Peninsula and will not leave any but Muslim." -Sahih Muslim 1767a Allah's Messenger said, "The Hour will not be established until you fight with the Jews, and the stone behind which a Jew will be hiding will say. "O Muslim! There is a Jew hiding behind me, so kiII him." - Sahih al-Bukhari 2926
Here's what I don't get about the "Israel starves Gazans" argument. Why is it Israel's responsibility? Is every man, woman, and child in Gaza an invalid? Are they completely incapable of growing their own food? In what universe is infantilizing an entire country a good idea?
Usually your responses are pretty on-point. HOWEVER you said the words "took the West Bank" #1: not "took" rather Took Back...Judea/Samaria from Jordan's occupation as well as the Gaza strip from Egypt since 1949. BOTH were part of the British Mandate. #2: not "West Bank" That was a term that the British applied to the ENTIRETY of the Mandate Territory west of the Jordan. Judea/Samaria. The ONLY area under Israeli control is the Golan Heights which, under international law was legal as it was land taken in a defensive war.
I live in Mexico and I am not 100% educated on this conflict, which I understand goes back for several decades. Mexico and Israel hold excellent Diplomatic relations. In fact, Israel was amongst the countries who sent a Brigade to rescue civilians after Mexico City's earthquake in 2017. As an attempt to educate myself, I would appreciate if IDF or an informed party, could fill me in on the following questions: 1) On pro-Palestinian posts, I have read the term "Occupation" and "Settlers" a lot. Is there such a thing as "Occupation"? Is there in present day, any occupation from Israel on Palestinian territory? Are there any Israeli Settlers building homes and neighborhoods on Palestinian soil? If so, how would THAT, not fuel the RESENTMENT on Palestinians? How could imposing my Settlements on my neighbor's territory, help reach a peaceful relatipnship with such neighbor?
roof knocks are not mandated by international law,you dont need to warn your enemy if its a military target,even if there are civilians there. check international law. and yet israel has been doing it for years because israel truly doesnt want to hurt those arab "civilians" even though they dont show the same courtesy back
Young & Naive. We’ve all been there, let’s hope these students start really putting in the work to understand what’s going on.
Especially the kid who is making a failed sales pitch for Isreal
@ 🤡
Many pro-Hamas/Palestinians just blindly followed the media that Israel is an apartheid state, Israel started genocides on Palestinians and starve Palestinians. In this war, Israel failed to make use of the media to their advantage.
When I looked at Israel, they have Arabs and Druze in their country but I don't see Jews in Gaza. So who is the apartheid state?
Starvation is all made out by UN. Everyday there are hundreds of food trucks going into Gaza. Some food trucks were hijacked by Hamas as seen in the videos. They have videos of a place like a warehouse where the food in bags were offloaded and kept there. How dare UN said Israel starved Palestinians?
Regards to Genocide, Israel gave notices to Palestinians to evacuate to a safer zone before they bombed the place. NO country in a war ever did that. Not even in Ukraine-Russian war. For Genocide to occur, one must show *it has the intent to destroy an ethnic group* according to UN definition of Genocide, yet UN allowed South Africa to rant that Israel committed Genocide. Genocide does not depend on number of people killed, as genocide could happen to a group of only 5 people. Hamas on the other hands, say all Jews must be eliminated. That is already an intent shown.
Universities are fundamentally Communist right now, so all they teach is pro-terrorist lies.
@@GuyIncognito-mw8mr. He’s the only one using facts. You consider facts an inconvenience?
If its war, then why are we feeding the enemy? When in history has an army fed the enemy? No ceasefire only unconditional surrender.
th-cam.com/users/shortssJneRvZlVoU?si=TooPGBB19BwaS2iA
At least he is open to listen
You only have to glance at any of the footage coming out of Gaza to see none of these people are "starving".
Yea because all the doctors from various countries and other humanitarian groups who been in Gaza are all lying. Also there tons video showing the level of starvation going in Gaza. But the mainstream media is not showing it.
I can pull up tons of videos right now showing children who are literally skin and bones and look like holocaust survivors.
Maybe stop watch mainstream media and actually do some home work.
Starving ....they are obese they get 3200 calories per day , more than I eat. AM YISRAEL CHAI ❤❤❤
@Karen-nn3jn no they don't im sorry but you don't know what your talking about. Your only looking at what mainstream media is showing which is mostly the Palestine in the south which has been getting humanitarian aide in. Even then there still a food shortage in south.
In the north of Gaza it's very different as nothing is getting through. There horrible pictures and videos showing how emaciated the people are especially the children. What they are eating is not health amd making them sick.
Please shut your mouth and educate your self beyond what mainstream media is telling you. They are lying to you and not telling you the truth.
@@Karen-nn3jn 💙
In what way is Israel an illegal state?
What law did it break by proclaiming its independence in a terra nullius formed by the end of the British mandate?
Used to be a caliphate, so jews on Islamic land is unconscionable for the Muslim brotherhood. Israel is every bit as legitimate as every other nation.
@@lforlight Are you slow, how could you claim the land was terra nullius you sound like you come from the 14th century, there were more Palestinians than Jews before the first war broke out, let’s not forget the Nakba which expelled 750,000 of them.
@@sufou
And you have failed to do any research.
Jews bought all the land they settled on and the borders of 1947 were closely related to those lands.
Palestinians were given majority palestinian areas while jews were given majority jewish areas.
Also there is 0 evidance towards the nakba being done by israel, there is one or two isolated incident (that are even being taught in israel as an example of when not to follow orders) but other then that none, there is actually more evidence towards arab leaders asking palestinians to leave and come back when they win the war.
In the creation of Israel it even calls for all palestinians to stay and all of those that did stay got citizenship.
@@FantasticKruH oh no here we go again with the “Jews purchased land and Palestinians sold it” nonsense, the Zionist purchasing power could barely acquire 5-7 percent of land sources form 1945 indicate to be scattered they did not purchase entire towns, this is a common trope Zionist try to portray in order to justify their illegal existence.
I can’t believe you claim that the Nakba didn’t happen, congrats you are now on the level of neo-nazi holocaust revisionism. I would recommend Ilan Pappe “An Indicative Archive: Salvaging Nakba Documents” where he uncovers classified documents from the The Yad Yaari archive which houses the documents of the Mapam Party and its youth movement the Hashomer Hatzair, whose members formed the nucleus of the Palmach (the Haganah's commando units), which spearheaded military operations in 1947-49 that orchestrated the Nakba, maybe some research on your end is needed because I don’t wish to go through every single massacre and event that took place. Palestinians to this day still wish to return to their homeland and for the Arabs that become citizens of the Israeli state they will always be second class citizens, what other choice do they have.
@@sufou UN Resolution awarded the Palestinians (they didn't call themselves that then) an independent sovereign state. Why did they reject it and attack the Jewish state instead?
Israel is the ONLY country on the planet where people say "maybe it shouldn't t have been formed in the first place." Gee, what would be the difference between Israel and every other country? Hmh, what could it be? I didn't need to hear anything else from this kid.
Hamas is "sick of this crap." We're on a downward trajectory where people form opinions not knowing a damn thing about what they are talking about.
The fact that it's wholly and completely a colonial product founded upon ethnic cleansing and ethnosupremacy, for one.
There's a checkpoint for people to go through where you checked for weapons etc, a 6 year old girl was checked by soldiers. She was prepared, opened her bag and checked. Took her bag and walked off. He pulled and slammed her against the wall and shouted in her face. You will go when I say you must go. She's 6. Slammed against a wall. Tell me why there should be a checkpoint? To slam kids against the wall. I'm from South Africa. The man who witnessed this is our family. Nevermind abuse of power. If this happened in America you would riot against police for brutality. Israel shouldn't be policing them in the first place but ok. They the terrorists lol they the ones at fault. They stealing land and putting up settlements and arrest thousands and have a fair trial process for them-thays sarcasm if you don't get it but hey you all are educated. You know better
You tube won't delete my comments eventually either. I'll be flagged for an anti Semetic comment lol what a joke.
But send more billions in aid to soldiers. Meanwhile they no longer even paying for their own genocide cough sorry I mean war oh wait land grabbing. They using US tax payer money to do it.
There's a group of Israeli soldiers called Breaking Free. They somewhere on you tube. They expose the truth as to how fake operations are ran in Palestinian homes to stop them from working, intimidate them. Meanwhile there's no operations. Imagine.
It's crazy how these kids just trying to unsuccessfully repeat what their teachers were telling them
Teachers? I think it’s what they learned from TikTok
And the one sitting there with the camera isn’t a parrot by chance is he ?
@@McLovin-ko3ff Neither of you are wrong. Sadly, these kids receive much of their instruction from TikTok.
Many pro-Hamas/Palestinians just blindly followed the media that Israel is an apartheid state, Israel started genocides on Palestinians and starve Palestinians. In this war, Israel failed to make use of the media to their advantage.
Thank you for spreading your ideas and challenging others ideas.
Yeah we saw yesterday on the release how much the gazans and hamas starved... 🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
This is the problem, this guy is not a bad person but like he says "I know very little about the history".
Most of them either know nothing or get fed lies.
There are the exceptions of actual horrible people.
Its a refreshing change to actually seeing someone willing to listen to another side of the argument and not have the tunnel mindset, well done to the young man for that
WHY THE HELL ISRAEL GIVES GAZA FOOD AND WATER! WHYYYYY!?!?
I appreciate that he is trying to see both sides and accepts that war is horrible without spewing the G word. But he needs to get his facts right. He seems to think that Israel has initiated conflicts when, in fact, Israel has only defended itself against Arab aggression. He also needs to educate himself about Jewish history and their connection to the land including or especially Judea & Samaria. But kudos to him for trying to be fair minded
This, I study Islamic history, they have a history which continues as the largest colonizers, juedea was always Jewish.
@@noname-ip9xe I hope Israel moves the "Palestinians" from Judea & Samaria to join their Gaza "Palestinians" wherever they end up. Israel needs to fully control Judea & Samaria which, strategically, is high ground.
Cam you are doing a great job.
Seems like a really intelligent kid. His facts may be a little hazy in some details, but he's really thinking about things rationally and honestly considering the information as he learns it.
gaza-aid-data.gov.il/main/
Think the same😊
He’s having an honest discussion as opposed to the bigots who have their left winged ideology and they aren’t prepared to discuss it.
Hey Cam, I like your videos, could you reference the humanitarian aid trucks entering Gaza via Egypt vs Israel. I would like to have a primary source handy. Cheers
He has no sources besides the Israeli officials themselves, every relief agency has been relaying that Israel has not complied with humanitarian law, it controls what flows into Gaza including the Rafa border crossing in Egypt and aid trucks have been sitting there for months. I will provide a good resource that examines the amount of trucks that were allowed to flow through Gaza through October 13-November 13 2024, when the US secretary of defence issued a letter urging Israel to allow 350 aid trucks a day, as all of North Gaza was facing famine and disease, it failed to allow even 1000 over the course of 30 days.
@@sufou The UN admits that two thirds of the hundreds of tons of supplies inserted into Gaza were stolen by Hamas (who then sold them at exhorbitant prices)
@@sufou You are quoting misinformation. Right after Oct 7th attack, Israel stopped aid trucks for only a short time. After that, food and aid was getting to the border. UNWRA themselves actually admitted that Hamas looted / loots the aid trucks, stores it all in overflowing warehouses, takes what they want and sells the rest to civilians that can afford to pay. Markets are full of aid stamped goods being sold which was meant to be free. For that matter, why were the Palestinians getting aid in the first place prior to Oct 7th? Why have the Palestinians been getting foreign aid since 1948? Why is Hamas the second richest terrorist organization in the world accepting the equivalent of billions of US dollars every year for decades?
sweet video and fair enough re the point about aid going in . its easy enough to see in the celebrations of hamas in gaza that the people dont look starved at all but there are some mistakes assumed in the video : any country which is under attacked and ends up taking land in the course of a defensive war is entitled to keep that land (int law) . Israel is not an illegal state any more than Jordan or Lebanon or pakistan who were all formed in the 20th cent with full recognition !
The assertion that a nation's existence should be negated based on its demographic or ethnic composition constitutes a clear manifestation of bigotry. The right of all nations to exist is axiomatic. While disparities exist in governmental efficacy and societal harmony, the fundamental right to national existence remains inviolable. Israel was established under the same legal framework as most other Middle Eastern, South American and African states. Its borders were delineated according to its Mandate and the international legal principle of uti possidetis juris. Denying this fundamental truth constitutes an act of antisemitism.
international law does not explicitly recognize a "right to exist" for any nation as a legal principle. But it does recognizes state sovereignty and self-determination for people, if you were so caught up with the right for peoples to exist why not focus your energy on Palestinian or Kurdish statehood.
According to case law “the principle of uti possidetis was formulated to serve a dual purpose: first, a defensive purpose towards the rest of the world, in the form of an outright denial that there was any land without a sovereign (or terra nullius)” Israel's borders were not definitively set by the 47 UN partition plan and the wars that followed, to claim that Israel should occupy all of Palestine under uti possidestis juris a nasty and outdated attempt by you to annex the remaining areas which Israel already does, if you are going to abide by international law Israel must stick to its responsibilities under IL which is neglect and resolutions to withdraw from the west bank and the golan heights.
Stop using antisemitism to justify the horrid crimes of the Israeli states.
@@sufou The arabs were offered a, "State", but have refused at least 5 times.
@@scottwolf8633The “Arabs” have 22 states, if you are referring to the Palestinian there was no offer there was an agreement made by foreign powers and the refusal to abide by them, no country or people on the planet would give up a place they call home and it is extremely naive to say in hindsight they should have.
@@sufou Muda'rat, read what Clinton and Barak offered. Olmert offered ALL of the lands won from Transjordan and Egypt's Gaza and included 65 square miles of 1949 Armistice Border Land from Israel.
@ While international law may not explicitly codify a singular, freestanding "right to exist" in the same way it protects specific human rights, the principle is deeply embedded within the framework of statehood and sovereignty. The Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States (1933), a cornerstone of statehood recognition, establishes criteria including a permanent population, defined territory, government, and capacity to enter into relations with other states. Implicit in meeting these criteria is the acknowledgment of a state's right to exist as a functioning entity within the international system. Furthermore, the UN Charter, particularly Article 2(4) prohibiting the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state, 1 presupposes the existing right of states to maintain their existence. This is particularly relevant considering that many modern sovereign states were established through the League of Nations mandate or protectorate system. These mandates, often delineating borders based on prior administrative divisions, were formalized through international agreements. The principle of uti possidetis juris, which holds that newly formed states inherit the administrative boundaries of their predecessor entities, further solidified these borders in international law. The very concepts of self-determination, territorial integrity, and sovereign equality, foundational principles of the international legal order, are predicated on the inherent right of states to exist and function within defined borders, often established through mandates and solidified by uti possidetis juris, free from external aggression or dissolution. Therefore, while not explicitly labeled as such, the “right to exist” is a necessary and fundamental corollary to the established principles of statehood and sovereignty in international law.
At least he was respectful and willing to listen, and admitted he didn’t know the history. Not like the other nutters.
Challenge: Name a single war in history, where the enemy brought humanitarian aid to the opposing side.
This is the first war Ive seen where a combatant provides aid to the enemy with swathes of far fighters in an are claimed to be food deprived.
He says war is bad. Except he has no idea of what a war actually entails. Just the idea of not sending enough food to your enemy!!!
TITLE is SOOO Much Better! Much Love.
Golan Heights were conquered from Syria and not Lebanon in 1967
im happy to see a young guy trying to understand the subject, but the way he spoke at the start showed he has no idea of this conflict. i wish him the best of luck in learning about this
Annoying as hell with him saying like every 9 words at most, he did it so much it was contagious
The young Mr Higby reminds me of Charlie Kirk. And all he does is to use facts and logic in the face of misguided opinion. Bravo.
Thank you for sharing
Also gave southern Lebanon back which was taken as security buffer, after it was consistently attacked from Lebanon
That’s like starting “ it was pretty nice the mugger actually gave me back my wallet even though I ended up in the hospital and required multiple surgeries “ 🧐
Taqqiyya should loudest and gullable people believe.
What a thoughtful young man
Maybe you need a little tent to shield you from the sun?
I am an Egyptian, and story of 67 that arrived to us is very different from what you said hahah, so it is very nice to hear the other side, as for us we were told that Israel took Sinai purely for expansion reasons, and they started the attack on 67 under the false flag of a need for a preemptive attack.
The story for us also includes that if we hadn't made our surprise attack at 73 and took half of Sinai back, Israel would have never agreed to the peace and given up Sinai back.
* But what is interesting to know is that when we got Sinai back after the peace, there was actually development done by Israel in Sinai, as they had actually built hotels and apartments complexes by the red sea (which still exists until this day and some still owned by the Israelis), they also added roads and added some basic infrastructure.
Which to be honest collaborates the expansionist idea, but who knows maybe they only decided to develop since it was at the time theirs anyway and thought why not, but this definitely refutes the idea that they had plan of giving it back for peace.
Israel preemptively attacked Egypt because Egypt closed or was going to close the strait of Tiran to ALL sea traffic going to Israel. Egypt also kicked out UN peacekeepers in the Sinai and started building military forces there, which was an indication of plans to attack Israel.
Omg!!!! Pleeeeeease find some history not written by Egyptians and read it. That is so crazy what they taught you, wow.
Seriously read up on thr story. Its a really thrilling story!!
And one note for you: israel has NEVER started a war. Never.
The arab nations around it have had very big ambitions to annihilate it from thr start. So they kept starting wars with israel. And losing.
And then when they lose they blame israel.
19 June 1967 - the National Unity Government of Israel voted unanimously to return the Sinai to Egypt and the Golan Heights to Syria in return for peace agreements.
1 September 1967 - Khartoum Resolution adopted by the Arab League, stipulating no recognition of Israel, no negotiations with Israel, and no peace with Israel ("Three Noes").
Israel had no reason to assume peace would be negotiated any time soon. Till this day they have no peace agreement with Syria.
Yah kalb
Egypt blocked the red sea, not allowing ships from or to Israel, this is an act of war.
Painful to watch him trying to make a point.
Never in history was palestinian poeple or nation called palestine. Palestine was geographic region name for the land its including jordan in the time off the british mandate also name trans jordan.palestine is latin name not arabic.the arabs take the palestinian identity in 1964 by yaaser arafat egyptian man like many off these arabs caling themself palestinian came from.in the 19 centery 1878 the ottoman sultan bring arabs from the suranded arabs country as working immigrat.the same with the british mandate in 1923.these are the arabs caling themself palestinian.you can tel wish arabs country the came from by the family name.el masry from egypt.el baghdadi from iraq.tamimi from yemen.jewish poeple was always in the land off israel.before 1967 west bank was jordan not palestine.the same with gaza was egypt before 1967.is many physical evidence this land belong to the jewish poeple archeologic.in the quran israel mention 43 time palestine 0 time.
An excellent presentation of a Greek salad 🧐
Thank you
Free Israel!
From who
If you mean from God then that's not happening
had trouble making it 2min of this video
lol did you hear his justification for occupying the Golan territory 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Here are some heart-warming Islamic sources that rarely get quoted, but Hams quotes them:
Quran 98:6 "Verily, those who disbelieve (in the religion of Islam, the Quran and Prophet Muhammad) from among the people of the Scripture (Jews and Christians) and Al-Mushrikun will abide in the Fire of Hell. They are the worst of creatures."
Narrated Abu Huraira: Allah's Apostle said, "I have been sent with the shortest expressions bearing the widest meanings, and I have been made victorious with terror (cast in the hearts of the enemy) - Sahih al-Bukhari 2977
"Messenger of Allah said: I will expel the Jews and Christians from the Arabian Peninsula and will not leave any but Muslim." -Sahih Muslim 1767a
Allah's Messenger said, "The Hour will not be established until you fight with the Jews, and the stone behind which a Jew will be hiding will say. "O Muslim! There is a Jew hiding behind me, so kiII him." - Sahih al-Bukhari 2926
Since when are wars humanitarian
why would he sit down if hes got no more than 5 min?😆
Here's what I don't get about the "Israel starves Gazans" argument. Why is it Israel's responsibility? Is every man, woman, and child in Gaza an invalid? Are they completely incapable of growing their own food? In what universe is infantilizing an entire country a good idea?
Yes, they are incapable because of what the white and blue bastards are doing
Usually your responses are pretty on-point. HOWEVER you said the words "took the West Bank"
#1: not "took" rather Took Back...Judea/Samaria from Jordan's occupation as well as the Gaza strip from Egypt since 1949. BOTH were part of the British Mandate.
#2: not "West Bank" That was a term that the British applied to the ENTIRETY of the Mandate Territory west of the Jordan. Judea/Samaria.
The ONLY area under Israeli control is the Golan Heights which, under international law was legal as it was land taken in a defensive war.
Isreal sends food in.
I live in Mexico and I am not 100% educated on this conflict, which I understand goes back for several decades. Mexico and Israel hold excellent Diplomatic relations. In fact, Israel was amongst the countries who sent a Brigade to rescue civilians after Mexico City's earthquake in 2017. As an attempt to educate myself, I would appreciate if IDF or an informed party, could fill me in on the following questions:
1) On pro-Palestinian posts, I have read the term "Occupation" and "Settlers" a lot. Is there such a thing as "Occupation"? Is there in present day, any occupation from Israel on Palestinian territory? Are there any Israeli Settlers building homes and neighborhoods on Palestinian soil? If so, how would THAT, not fuel the RESENTMENT on Palestinians? How could imposing my Settlements on my neighbor's territory, help reach a peaceful relatipnship with such neighbor?
At least he was willing to listen and now hopefully he’ll go and educate himself rather than rely on his Hamas supporting lecturers
Is this at Washington State University or is this dude just wearing a WSU shirt?
CogAT numbers are a lot better than UNRWA's
he should read history
Yeah, that guy on the left is very ignorant
@FarisMohammed-ib1wm proof it
Is English your first language
@FarisMohammed-ib1wm yes. so tell me one lie he said?
@bendolinko6315 you meant prove
Why is this on TH-cam?
i like this guy . most normal person you ever interviewed
hes all over the place
@@nicolascastillo6319 Yes, but at least he's trying, which is more than you can say for most of these indoctrinated fanatics.
I'm pro-Israel, but this is clickbait.
Som people have a qwis snd som people hostage 😢
Israel largely stopped doing roof knocks
proof??
roof knocks are not mandated by international law,you dont need to warn your enemy if its a military target,even if there are civilians there.
check international law.
and yet israel has been doing it for years because israel truly doesnt want to hurt those arab "civilians" even though they dont show the same courtesy back
Like he Like needs to Like go and Like read some history like and Like get his like facts right Like.
God bless Israel and the USA
He has to go to class? He will learn more debating than all semester learning useless material