This aid😒 applies to Japan, Taiwan, S. Korea, Hong Kong, Singapore, Philippines, Malaysia , Indonesia, china, India, Vietnam, Isreal, Middle East, Saudi Arabia, Mexico, S. America, Caribbean...no doubt about it, but there's a saying: God helps those who help themselves 🤭...
I am a Taiwanese. Thanks to American for helping Taiwan all the time. We are really appreciated. Now Taiwan is much stronger and happy to help the other countries.
In terms of agriculture infrastructure was pretty much in place after Japan left Taiwan after WWII. From my personal experience from being living through that period where American Aid was present in Taiwan, the American aid was mainly used for the support of government's ability to maintain the military capacity. There were some portions of the American aid did flow into Taiwanese commerce to some extent but not significant. Taiwan's success has its root in its hardworking culture and the emphasis on education.
The help from the United States has indeed made a certain contribution to Taiwan's economic development.But why is the economic development of the Philippines, which also receives help from the United States, far behind Taiwan?I believe that the hard-working, intelligent and ambitious people of Taiwan, as well as the government’s correct economic leadership, are the keys to Taiwan’s prosperity.Generally speaking, the United States has indeed made certain contributions to Taiwan's economy and military. As a Taiwanese, I would like to express my gratitude to the United States. Thank you America.
During the 60’s, US used Taiwan as military base station for Vietnam war and Korean War. There was no economic support for the civilians. All the money went to Chiang Kai Shek to enforce Marshall law and suppress Taiwanese wellbeing thus debilitated economic growth until his passing.
I am Taiwanese, and I do not like this video, as it seems to illustrate America's arrogant charity that supposedly allowed Taiwan to achieve economic growth. In reality, when the Kuomintang was defeated, the United States did not provide active assistance; instead, it attempted to support a puppet regime. The aid given after the outbreak of the Korean War was merely to prevent the expansion of communism that could threaten America's domestic security. Of course, this assistance alleviated the impending credit crisis of the defeated regime, but Taiwan has always been treated as a pawn and a satellite state of the United States. When necessary, there will be exchanges of these pawns, such as during the normalization of relations between the U.S. and China. Any aid that does not generate economic circulation is merely a windfall. This video attempts to create a narrative that Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan became developed countries solely due to American assistance, deliberately ignoring the efforts made by East Asian countries for their own national development. I do not hate the United States, but if Americans take their hegemony for granted, their arrogance will ultimately be detrimental to themselves. In the eyes of the Taiwanese, so-called military assistance is merely the protection money we pay in exchange for a bunch of second-hand and outdated products, without any promises, stationed troops, or any real assistance.
😂😂😂 u should be grateful to someone when they help u. Without the help from the us., tw would not go this far .. don't let urself behave like Chinazi 😅😅😅
@Cloveri Thank you. More than anything else, the Confucian ethos of these nations was and is responsible for their success. A photo of Biden in the thumbnail only shows how clueless this video is.
@@AlphamanKinghey man My question same as well as your but these taiwanese show so much showoff he consider himself a royal and his answer just to want American make happy meanwhile independence completely you also see video or article which show how much taiwanese want reunification with china the data that 20% taiwanese want reunification and 65% be independence or 15% love both options but my opinion if Taiwan reunited with china then they become super power because GDP or security or happiness must be increase instead of destruction like Ukraine or Syria 🇨🇳👹
Sure there's a lot of interest by the US government in Taiwan because it's become a colony (neocolonialism) of the US while America did everything it can to suppressed Japan's economic growth during the 1980's-2020's. Otherwise Japan would be the world's largest economy by now.
It's not precise to say that the ROC government "retreated" to Taiwan since "retreat" means you pull back to where you departed, which is not the case for the ROC government. In fact, they were defeated by the Communists in the civil war so they had no choice but "fled" to Taiwan.
Taiwan was very poor when I was a child, and U.S. aid provided free flour to the Taiwanese people. We are forever grateful for the U.S. help. At that time adults made used Flour bags into underwear. You will know how poor Taiwan was .
At that time, various infectious diseases were prevalent in Taiwan, including cholera, encephalitis, polio... I remember that the United States sent specialists to Taiwan to help eliminate all infectious diseases.
Many people remember the U.S. military aid to Taiwan. At that time, the Air Force fighter planes of the Republic of China were aided by the U.S. government. What I remember is the help the U.S. provided to Taiwanese people in daily life.
Many Taiwanese do thank US for the helps all these years. Other than some of these arguments in this video, one of the much influential factors provided by the US are those Taiwanese obtaining high level education (including those engineering training from US). Adding these and the highly motivated Taiwanese people, these factors do help Taiwan becoming one of the major important roles in today's economic world. However, there are still a lot of important aids that Taiwanese are needed from the US. Among them, the most important thing is that US shall back up Taiwan by formally recognizing the status quo that Taiwan is a truly independent country requiring US's formal recognition and the support of the formal international legal back up from all the democratic international society.
Frankly it is like a long term investment. By selling weapons to Taiwan at an unreasonable high price, the U.S. would have gotten the aid back already. Not that I am not appreciate, without the U.S., Taiwan would have lost to China long ago.
Getting really concerned with how all these online videos are portraying Taiwan is well offed. In reality any industry with exception of chip manufacturing is not doing well. Not everyone has the income of that industry.
How important do you think was the U.S. in Taiwan's economic development?
1971 UN seat loss for PRC??? 1986 US imposing regulation on Taiwanese currency?
你知道世界各國包括台灣在中國的經濟發展中所扮演的角色嗎？
美國對中國經濟的挹注遠勝過對台灣的幫助，為什麼？
This aid😒 applies to Japan, Taiwan, S. Korea, Hong Kong, Singapore, Philippines, Malaysia , Indonesia, china, India, Vietnam, Isreal, Middle East, Saudi Arabia, Mexico, S. America, Caribbean...no doubt about it, but there's a saying: God helps those who help themselves 🤭...
@@BIOH2NO3 是的，但中國人總認為別人的投資都是他給別人的恩惠，台灣人不一樣的地方是會感恩。
不信你比較疑美的滯台中國人，因為美國人的拯救保命到現在，卻還仇美。
I am a Taiwanese. Thanks to American for helping Taiwan all the time. We are really appreciated. Now Taiwan is much stronger and happy to help the other countries.
Are you sure you're not stationed in Taiwan?
In terms of agriculture infrastructure was pretty much in place after Japan left Taiwan after WWII. From my personal experience from being living through that period where American Aid was present in Taiwan, the American aid was mainly used for the support of government's ability to maintain the military capacity. There were some portions of the American aid did flow into Taiwanese commerce to some extent but not significant. Taiwan's success has its root in its hardworking culture and the emphasis on education.
都是美國栽培訓練的，包括大學的成立!全世界只有中國人受益最多最大，或是人口多吧!台灣人對美援的感覺來自基督教會，國民黨才是最大受益者，敢講美國沒道義也只有國民黨!
The help from the United States has indeed made a certain contribution to Taiwan's economic development.But why is the economic development of the Philippines, which also receives help from the United States, far behind Taiwan?I believe that the hard-working, intelligent and ambitious people of Taiwan, as well as the government’s correct economic leadership, are the keys to Taiwan’s prosperity.Generally speaking, the United States has indeed made certain contributions to Taiwan's economy and military. As a Taiwanese, I would like to express my gratitude to the United States. Thank you America.
Philippines is more protectionist
During the 60’s, US used Taiwan as military base station for Vietnam war and Korean War. There was no economic support for the civilians. All the money went to Chiang Kai Shek to enforce Marshall law and suppress Taiwanese wellbeing thus debilitated economic growth until his passing.
I am Taiwanese, and I do not like this video, as it seems to illustrate America's arrogant charity that supposedly allowed Taiwan to achieve economic growth. In reality, when the Kuomintang was defeated, the United States did not provide active assistance; instead, it attempted to support a puppet regime. The aid given after the outbreak of the Korean War was merely to prevent the expansion of communism that could threaten America's domestic security. Of course, this assistance alleviated the impending credit crisis of the defeated regime, but Taiwan has always been treated as a pawn and a satellite state of the United States. When necessary, there will be exchanges of these pawns, such as during the normalization of relations between the U.S. and China.
Any aid that does not generate economic circulation is merely a windfall. This video attempts to create a narrative that Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan became developed countries solely due to American assistance, deliberately ignoring the efforts made by East Asian countries for their own national development.
I do not hate the United States, but if Americans take their hegemony for granted, their arrogance will ultimately be detrimental to themselves.
In the eyes of the Taiwanese, so-called military assistance is merely the protection money we pay in exchange for a bunch of second-hand and outdated products, without any promises, stationed troops, or any real assistance.
😂😂😂 u should be grateful to someone when they help u. Without the help from the us., tw would not go this far .. don't let urself behave like Chinazi 😅😅😅
Do you support the independence of Taiwan, or do you consider it as part of china? What's the public sentiment there?
@Cloveri Thank you. More than anything else, the Confucian ethos of these nations was and is responsible for their success. A photo of Biden in the thumbnail only shows how clueless this video is.
@@AlphamanKinghey man My question same as well as your but these taiwanese show so much showoff he consider himself a royal and his answer just to want American make happy meanwhile independence completely you also see video or article which show how much taiwanese want reunification with china the data that 20% taiwanese want reunification and 65% be independence or 15% love both options but my opinion if Taiwan reunited with china then they become super power because GDP or security or happiness must be increase instead of destruction like Ukraine or Syria 🇨🇳👹
你無法代表台灣人，我就非常不同意你的言論
Sure there's a lot of interest by the US government in Taiwan because it's become a colony (neocolonialism) of the US while America did everything it can to suppressed Japan's economic growth during the 1980's-2020's. Otherwise Japan would be the world's largest economy by now.
Asia's people very hardworking
More like slavery
I am Taiwanese and I am very grateful for the help the United States has given to Taiwan.😊
Are you sure you're not stationed in Taiwan?
It's not precise to say that the ROC government "retreated" to Taiwan since "retreat" means you pull back to where you departed, which is not the case for the ROC government.
In fact, they were defeated by the Communists in the civil war so they had no choice but "fled" to Taiwan.
How the us help built china and now india and vietnam except helping themselves. No one thanking them and instead despise them
Taiwan was very poor when I was a child, and U.S. aid provided free flour to the Taiwanese people. We are forever grateful for the U.S. help.
At that time adults made used Flour bags into underwear. You will know how poor Taiwan was .
You must not be a Taiwanese person.
@@philipjh6789 You guessed wrong.
At that time, various infectious diseases were prevalent in Taiwan, including cholera, encephalitis, polio... I remember that the United States sent specialists to Taiwan to help eliminate all infectious diseases.
Many people remember the U.S. military aid to Taiwan. At that time, the Air Force fighter planes of the Republic of China were aided by the U.S. government. What I remember is the help the U.S. provided to Taiwanese people in daily life.
I Googled WIKI to proof my words: 貧苦百姓還會將麵粉袋改作爲內衣內褲，因上面的「中美合作」握手標識，還戲稱為「中美牌」內褲，成爲了台灣的時代縮影.
"made use of"; "exploited"; "abused"; "profit from".
Many Taiwanese do thank US for the helps all these years. Other than some of these arguments in this video, one of the much influential factors provided by the US are those Taiwanese obtaining high level education (including those engineering training from US). Adding these and the highly motivated Taiwanese people, these factors do help Taiwan becoming one of the major important roles in today's economic world. However, there are still a lot of important aids that Taiwanese are needed from the US. Among them, the most important thing is that US shall back up Taiwan by formally recognizing the status quo that Taiwan is a truly independent country requiring US's formal recognition and the support of the formal international legal back up from all the democratic international society.
America doesn't give away freebies unless there's a string attached. In this case, America sends money, Taiwanese give away their land.
"help" is a very subjective term.
and that is the fact.
早期美國協防台灣丶提供援助，幫助穩定台海局勢，改善台灣民生。美國的幫助是起了重要作用。但土地改革與美國沒什麼關係。1960丶1970年代，台灣人從最原始的加工業發展，那個時候，政府呼籲客廳即工廠，大家努力做簡易的加工，賺取家用，後來紡織業及製鞋丶腳踏事．…．塑化業逐步發展，1980前後才有像樣的電子公司，在電子業廣泛投入之前，二三十年的加工出口帶來不少外匯，台灣一直很少有外債，不像韓國。出口的主要地方還是美國，很長一段時間，台灣政府每年都派出採購團去美購買產品，以平衡過多的貿易順差。台灣人民很勤奮，1976年我在軍中服役，旁邊一家紡織廠24小時不停運作，三班制，那時大家都拼命幹活。
Frankly it is like a long term investment. By selling weapons to Taiwan at an unreasonable high price, the U.S. would have gotten the aid back already. Not that I am not appreciate, without the U.S., Taiwan would have lost to China long ago.
ppp gdp is because the Taiwan government has lowered the basic cost of living.
其實韓國和日本也是這樣，他們付給美國的駐軍費用，根本就是低到很簾價
Getting really concerned with how all these online videos are portraying Taiwan is well offed. In reality any industry with exception of chip manufacturing is not doing well. Not everyone has the income of that industry.
Unite states are truly the most supportive ally that Taiwan has so far and even in the future!
我們愛美國🇺🇸謝謝美國🇺🇸