Ranking Every Company's Best Approach Discs!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 มิ.ย. 2022
- Today we're putting approach discs to the Swanky Tier List test!
Thank you for watching! Be sure to Subscribe for new videos every Monday!
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @swankydiscgolf
Cop the merch!
www.swankydiscgolf.com/shop
Follow us on Instagram TikTok and Facebook!
@SwankyDiscGolf
Song: MBB - Takeoff (Vlog No Copyright Music)
Music provided by Vlog No Copyright Music.
Video Link: • MBB - Takeoff (Vlog No...
Match Play Championship
2022 Disc Golf
Disc Golf technique - กีฬา
I'm commenting that there better as heck be a DGA disc in this video before watching it. Will reply to this after the video.
Okay I'm back. There were TWO of our discs in this video, you guys outdid yourselves. 12:33
I can confirm that the BlowFly floats about it and also that YOU are wrong about it. I used to think it was gimmicky, but that was before I actually played with it for a round (funny how actually using a disc can affect your opinion of it, give this a try!)
In summary: Thanks for including our discs and liking our stock stamps, screw you for dishonoring Ed's BlowFly legacy, and yes the BlowFly floats so that category is perfect for it 😂
Hahaha I will definitely have to give it a more fair chance!!
@@SwankyDiscGolf one of my buddie's dad's putts and approaches mainly with a old blowfly. takes a lot of touch since the soft disc will fight chains and lost power but man he is accurate and doesnt get bad groundplay from misses
Berg is most definitely Swanky! I understand how some people don't like it, but for some of us it is a staple. Not as much as the Zone, but it's close!
It’s not for beginners. Requires a big arm and accuracy.
I love it
Thanks, this was interesting, but I think many of the discs you selected to this list were more like throwing putters than actual ”approach discs”. For example you included Prodigy´s PA-series/P-model but not approach series discs like A2 or the new Distortion (which is great btw). Also missing Toro (Innova´s new Zone), Rat, Suspect (I know it is OOP but awesome disc nevertheless), P3X, Anvil, Jokeri, Caiman, Gator3 (ok Caiman and Gator might fall more to the midrange category, but many ppl use those as approach discs), Rhyno. Clash Discs Mint is btw more like approach disc than Popcorn, good discs both though. But of course it is very subjective which discs are best and how they are categorized. Thanks for your entertaining videos. :)
The A2 is definitely Prodigy's best approach disc. Can't understand how this isn't on the list. Especially cause I'm pretty sure they just had a video or two recently where they were throwing one.
If you're not approaching with putters(
@@djfinesse1 well of course I'm using putters for approaching, but you did not seem to get what I meant (or did not want to). If there are discs literally in the "approach" category (like A-series) then why not include those in the approach discs video.. It also depends much about the playstyle, players personal skillset and throwing distance, what he/she considers as approach throw, disc and style. Someone might be using Firebird sidearms for approach when other is jump putting same distance approaches. So like I said, it is very subjective how you categorize discs and what is best for you. But yeah, generally of course all putters are also approach discs. I just thought that this list included many good "throwing putters", but were missing some great approach discs (like A2, Toro, Suspect, Distortion).
@@Hydz00r i was just joking, i got what you were saying.
Thanks for doing another tier list-these are awesome vids. I agree with some of the comments about distinguishing between approach putters and driving putters. The judge, for example, is a fantastic driving putter, but on this list, it didn’t stand a chance against the zone and the harp. Off the tee, though, I’m reaching for the Judge over those two in calm conditions. I’d definitely be interested in seeing a list of driving putters from the different companies. Thanks again!
I love these tier lists you guys do. Wish you throw some Gateway Discs in the mix. The Wizard and Devil Hawk are awesome for approach
Agreed, the wizard is my primary putter but I use it a LOT for approaches
Don't sleep on the Chief, it's super nice. I actually switched from putting with Wizards to the Chief because the rim-depth was more comfortable for me.
You have to include the Prodiscus Jokeri on any Approach Disc list. Love my Jokeri, one of my most thrown discs. Have had several throw-ins with it from 75-175 feet.
just got one shit is nice
mine is the x tho
was wondering were this one was. jokeri is pretty sweet and comes in killer plastic.
My first one is coming in the mail and am wondering how it compares to my rancho rocs, jarns, and pilots. Kinda excited.
My favorite throwing putter. Just lost mine and I'm devastated
I recently started using the Rhyno for my approaches. Definitely worth a mention👌🏾
I completely echo your sentiments… great list! Thanks for more awesome disc content… my favorite!
I put with the Berg exclusively. I have 5 same weight same run bergs for putting.
I'm interested to know why you guys chose the popcorn from clash discs but not the mint?
Yep, also there’s another putter out from Clash named Butter 2/3/0/1.
I don't think you've thrown a Polecat if you think most people are throwing it as a joke. I was skeptical too, but it's got a really unique flight. The P-Model US is also not as understable as you might think. I was pleasantly surprised by that disc.
Me too. I keep it in my bag and it does exactly what I expect it to do. I really like it
anvil is mad underrated from westside. I'm not a big diameter fan so this small diameter os approach has been sick, great all around and helps w forehand rollers too. the plastics you can pick it up in help since bt beats quickly if you need that
Berg for 90% of my upshot’s - goes as far as you throw it. A2 for overstable duties.
I literally do this with both, backhand and forehand
The berg is a horrible putter but a great approach disc!
I Guess I am a berg fanboy. Theres like 10% of my shots that I just cant do with another disc. Short stabel shots where you can put it on any line. Without to think so much about how Hard you gonna throw. Or when you have a tree infront of you and 30 feet to throw. Just lean out and give it a chance with a forehand. If you miss you have a tap in after.
You have to test it for whats its supoce to do.
Anyway good list.
The DD Justice deserves a mention in (very) OS approach discs. Don't let the 5 speed fool you into thinking you can throw it far.
If you miss long with Justice, then Troija is for you 😆
I love the yikun hammer (chui) in tiger plastic. I'm bagging four because they are super cheap in price. Double thumb track feels amazing to me. Not as over stable as a pig, slammer, or zone. Worth checking out and the price is ideal. Not afraid to run any hole because of the cost to replace.
Yikun is GOAT
Really enjoyed the breakdown this video gave! Great work overall!
it's a bummer that for the socki slammer that we first hear "i haven't thrown this". can't really look at the ranking the same as the other discs then, especially since y'all didn't really agree on it's spot.
even just giving it a few throws in the area this video was shot in could be enough to change that ranking up or down.
Innova's Luster Invader and Star Aviar3 are fantastic approach discs
Love my Aviar3’s. I feel like I can park any hole from 150 in with them.
I'm a huge fan of the invader. Love my luster invader and just ordered a new halo invader.
The Streamline Pilot in Neutron plastic feels amazing. Took a few throws to get used to the depth and that micro bead, but I wouldn't trade it for anything.
The flight is so predictable even for my noob self. If I need a dead balls straight shot with a mild fade, this is the disc I'm reaching for every time. Holds whatever line I put it on very well. And again, the Neutron plastic feels so luxurious. It's super smooth and glossy, but has plenty of grip. How that works is beyond me. Glad I decided to give it a shot. Hoping Streamline expands their line a little more. Also love how there's not a sharp edge or hint of flashing to be found. They really seem to care about the look and feel of the end product. Respect for that.
Can you guys do time stamps on these?😄great videos
My envy got replaced by premium plastic Lunas. They fly so awesome for me. The proxy on the other hand is by far my favorite Understable approach disc
i use the harp and the anode as approach discs. harp is obviously a staple but the nice backhand flip approaches i get out of my anode are great. adding a doomsday landmine as a more stable backhand approach when it becomes pdga approved
in my oppinion, Berg is in category "god likes" in one higher category than sweaky. Maybe with Zone. I also use Pure, and that one just cant be in higher category than Berg.
I love my electron and plasma envys and my tactics. I also throw pures and putts with keystones
I have a puddle top Exo Soft Tactic. It feels great in my hand and is actually more overstable and reliable forehand for me than the zones that I tried. I'd at least put it at great for me.
I LOVE my very beat up exo hard tactic. Very straight with a tiny fade and sneaky glide. Holds any angle I put it on for those sneaky woods approaches
the tactic might be ok on its own, but eagles razor claw version is a very great stable disc for many purposes!
prodigy a2! the best
300 or kjusa 350 flattops are money
Coming hard at my Polecat.... No tupperware is safe around my bag!
ringer and ringer gt are great as well if you like a zone but have slight smaller hands
My approach discs are primarily a Lucid Justice and a K1 Soft Berg. I use them constantly. I have a Zone that just sits in my bag and is available for water shots if needed lol
Right up my alley. Tryna iron out exactly which mid and approach discs I like the most and work best for me. I'e found I really like a micro bead on my throwing putters.
Been throwing a Reko X recently. Nudged my Jokeri out of the bag. Prefer it in the hand for bh, fh just as happy with it, awesome plastic of course but the Jokeri is a great disc in its own right.
How did you miss the entire Prodigy A series (approach)? A2 especially!
My sockibomb glow harp is definitely more overstable than my zones. But it would never replace my zones
I was throwing all Prodigy for a couple of years, and I added the BERG to my bag for one round because it was given to me. It convinced me to mix my bag. Dead straight. Sticks where it lands. Game changer for inside 150', especially in the Texas wind.
Number 2 disc all time in other top 100 is the Aviar which got the low end of the good category in your approach/putt only list.
Did you leave out a better Aviar than the x3?
Also, I am having a hard time finding your list in text format. Where can I locate that?
Hey guys I should really put the culprit from DD in there it’s really similar to a zone! Also the stabilizer from streamline is a good overstable approach disc! Thanks for the vids love ‘em
I use my polecat for a water tray for the pup out on the course
Yhe DGA Breaker is seriously underrated! got one in a players pack years ago and now I bag 3 to 4 during any given round.
Missing out on Jokeri is almost criminal 😕 and if your looking for the most underrated approach disc then you should test the Cosmic Kea by RPM they're awesome 🤩👌
I've tried em all and for me it's the RPM Kea..and I just lost mine.
Ah me too! Threw over well.... most of the water. >
I don't think these guys have discovered RPM yet. I love my Kea as well. I need to get it in a winter plastic.
Yes, Atomic and Magma Kea’s are fantastic. They pair really well for straighter and more overstable approaches.
It's dizzying how many approach discs there are when including straight up putters (luna, judge, keystone, nomad...) - the glaring omissions were the A-line discs from Prodigy (I think those are their main "approach" discs) - where would you rank those?
Love the rankings. In my short, 14 month career as a disc golfer, I have progressed from Keyston to Harp to Zone to Envy. I still bag the Zone for some shots but I use the Envy a lot more. I also just aced holes 11 and 13 at Suwanee Creek with it!
Thats awesome! Dude Suwanee Creek was made for the Envy lol
@@SwankyDiscGolf Definitely, I use it for every throw on 13 or 14 of the holes. The Envy can pretty much read my mind and hit all the lines
@@SwankyDiscGolf have you guys ever tried the Yikun Hammer? I just got one from Dog Gone, and I really like the feel of it. It's like a Zone with a thumbtrack and a little less speed and glide
You all need to try throwing the EV7 lineup. I love throwing the Phi, in particular and I putt with Penroses.
That's the most praise you've ever given my beloved Berg. lol.
For me and my hands I’d have to disagree with the Tactic/Zone comparison. The Tactic fits my hand dang near perfect for forehand and releases with no wobble for me every time. The Zone in my hand doesn’t feel as good and comes out on wobble on some throws. I would have put the Tactic in great. The Zone can stay in swanky due to it’s history but I personally don’t feel the same level of euphoria a lot of others seem to have when throwing it.
Tactics FTW
is there any good mids with no bead and overstable
Hard disagree on the polecat.
I used to think it was a meme disc, but I played in a fun, "Polecat Only" tournament and it changed my mind.
Not a great driving putter, but it's a dream for approachs in the woods. It holds any line you throw it on softly, so if you need to get around a corner and can't forehand something around, and are worried about the disc hyzering too early, the Polecat will just hold.
As you beat it in it gets more turn, which for me is perfect because then I can throw it even softer and maintain the same shot shape.
I LOVE the sakibomb slammer . ever been in a situation where you have a huge tree ten feet in front of you, with the basket twenty to thirty feet behind that and no way to make it around the tree? that is what this disc is for. it is an extremely short range meat hook. its the only disc I Can make hook violently from short range.
Entropy is my favorite disc in the bag. Such a good utility disc
Soft Pure, R Pro Pig, Hybrid Anvil, K1 Soft Berg, and Lucid Justice are all in my bag.
I love the aviarx3 for upshot’s
The Berg is A+, how dare you! I don't even bag one!
The berg has an unbelievable torque resistance for such a slow disc, side arm. Also it will not go over 150’ very useful ranging disc. Wouldn’t putt with it but it very quickly became my go to approach, replacing the pro pig.
Glow envy and neutron soft envys are the best I can throw my glow envy as far as any of my mids and it handles so much torque
I was hoping for some info on the jokeri
Armadillo is the best disc on the PLANET! Lonestar = Best plastic in the UNIVERSE!!!
I usually like making it ironic if I lose a disc in the water. The two discs I will throw are either a westside warship or an innova shark.
War spear from gateway and devil hawk are my favorites
Where would you guys put the gateway chief?
How do you leave the Toro off this list. One of the best overstable approach disc I have ever thrown
So approach discs are just throwing putters apparently? Okay
Why no A3, A2 or Distortion from Prodigy?
A putter ranking video would be awesome
Cale Leviska bottom stamp P model S the "S" is for slept on its so good for putting and both back hand and forehand approach
yoooooo i need that slammer my guy
There is a clear distinction between throwing putter and approach disc imo. Rhyno, Gator, Cayman, Clash Discs Mint etc. should be included. Remove the putting and somewhat neutral throwing putters and make a new list.
So many putters instead of actual approach discs. I would love to hear thoughts on approach discs rather than putters used for approaches. Prodigy has a while line of “A” discs. Plus, Jokeri, Gatekeeper, Anvil, Ghost, Distortion, Toro and many many other 4-speed types designed as approach discs.
Ice cream lid discs are really good, you just have to be used to throwing with the rim. I prefer the polecat a lot over the berg but the best one is the Rattler. Those discs aren't "objectively bad" as you claim, you just aren't good at throwing them.
I have a Pure, Judge, Envy, Proxy and 7 other putters
We need a “feels good in the hand” / “Hand-feel” counter for this video 😂
I throw the Luna big Z off the tee alot. Anything 300 ft straight it is my go to. If I have a dog leg 300ft or shorter I go zone.
Rage…. I’m gonna rage….
Yes RaGE'n over here too
The guys have clash discs which just had the popcorn and a bunch of other putting putters on the list and leave out the king company when it comes to putters... Gateway. Guys now have to do a full video reviewing all the gateway putters. 😂
Devilhawk, chief OS, wizard, chief, warlock, shaman, voodoo, magic
I was thinking the same thing the Devilhawk is my personal favorite approach disc I think its far superior to a Pig.
What would you change about the list??
Luna in swanky and sockibomb slammer in good at the very least
have you guys thrown the Streamline Stabilizer 3,3.5,0,3. its fills the over stable approach slot in my bag
@@coryrandow8074 it’s also really good for a forehand upshot
Maybe actually having prodigy A series discs instead of putters. Might be too crazy of an idea though 🤯
The Polecat is a great disc. Hating on it and loving super overstable stuff leads me to believe you have no touch and probably can't play catch or Ultimate and can only throw far.
I have one tiny issue. I bag 5 of these, and 4 of them are in the good category. I give three of them that spot though. Dillo definitely should at least be great.
Also the pilot is essentially a deeper version of the envy. So it comes down to hand feel but I think they’re the same.
Pilot is not similar to an envy and not deep lol
DGA Breaker is Swanky IMO. compliments the zone INSANELY well
I think you sold the Luna short. Consider your own points about it’s glide/distance and how it holds any line. Add to that the fact that many people putt with it and it belongs at the top just behind the Zone. Best distance with dependability as a thrower and commonly used for putting. Enough said.
Tell me you’ve never thrown a polecat without telling me you’ve never thrown a polecat.
Active Premium Sensei’s go so far. Straight as an arrow, excellent disc.
I'm surprised you included the Sensei and not the P2 :O
Check out the Storm Crater. Forehand,backhand, it's better at being the pig than the pig. Stable in a headwind and tailwind. Yeah right. It's true.
Can’t believe you didn’t rank the Mako3. Classic approach disc.
That's definitely in the mid-range catagory
I putt with keystones but it’s way too much glide for approach
How do U make this video without the A2
I think the Link flies WAY WAY better than the Luna lol. Just as much glide but way more torque resistant
I putt with a sensi, but is belongs in the approach disc category. Base plastic is better than premium imho. The premium is a domey mess.
I love the halo and gstar polecat for touch approaches... I loath the berg, worst feeling disc ever (maybe beats the zephyr lol) jk if you like it throw it.
Except from paul mcbeth’s lunas i have never seen an overstable luna but i wont judge your opinion
Clash Mint should be in here, Nikko has been parking the Mint and i think its a zone clone
sensei Premium plastic is fantastic
Seriously needs to be remade. I love the Pure but this was supposed to be about APPROACH DISCS, not THROWING PUTTERS. Some of these overlap, yes, but there are way too many wrong choices of molds for this video here and not enough of the right ones. Wheres the A2? A3? Distortion? Slammer? Suspect? Justice? Gator? Caiman? Md5? Mutant? Sinus? Loki? Troija? (Troija by Prodiscus is something you have to try tho, seriously. It is ridiculous.)
My 6 year old nephew literally threw the brand new slammer I bought straight in the water and gone forever before I even had a chance to know if I liked it or not
43 discs, and you don't even have the very best one in the comparison at all...the R-Pro Dart is the best non-overstable approach disc ever...by a long shot...put it on any line you want...it is the most predictable disc of all time...get one and throw it...and you're right Skylar - the Rhyno does deserve consideration as well...
Such disrespect for the polecat
As a pull cat paretaker this really erked me.
Berg is above swanky! best disc ever made!
What happened to the Ryno???
Berg is swank-nasty … K3!!! … I’ll try the Jarn once they release it in K3. Harp is my second favorite, and I use them when the shot feels a little too long for a Berg.
Banger GT?