Everytime Walt is feeling uncomfy with what he's saying, he has this reflex to wave hands as if he's trying to get away with it. This makes him a terrible liar.
"I would be able to tell that person and only that person" So if I said I was going to murder a baby, you would just tell the baby, "hey, somebody's coming to kill you"? 😂
@@vincentvaleur3573 Either the writers didn't completely understand patient confidentiality or they wrote it differently to make more sense to the viewers. You're right, a therapist is a mandatory reporter. That means if their patient comes in and expresses any desire to harm themselves or anybody else they must report it to the authorities, not to the person the threat was made towards. The person who was threatened would probably then be contacted by authorities, but I can almost guarantee that conversation wouldn't happen between the therapist and the person being threatened.
Doctor patient confidentiality doesn’t work like that. If you tell a psychiatrist you committed a violent crime, or threaten to do so, they are required to report it to the police.
It's particularly weird that they presented it in this way, as it's a simple thing to research and implement into a script. Doing so also doesn't present any sort of plot discrepancy either, because when Walter comes clean he reveals it wasn't because of an illegal or violent act. Including the proper declaration of Doctor-Patient confidentiality doesn't write them into a corner.
Depends on the psychiatrist. Someone I might have known did the same thing in the past tense multiple times and got away with it. Not pulling your leg. Depending on the situation, if you withhold who and when, there's not much they can do.
After doing some research I found that NM's duty to warn laws are not mandatory. So they can breach confidentiality if the patient threatens violence, but they are not required to. Also the psychiatrist was clearly aware of what Walt was asking. Even though Walt by this point was most definitely a criminal with secrets, as far as the psychiatrist knew he was just a family man with cancer. He probably didn't feel the need to mention that if Walt confesses to committing a crime he would have to breach confidentiality.
"There was no fugue state doc, I spent days cooking meth with my partner, he messed up the battery of the van we got stuck..it's hard being a drug pimp doc"
The first time I watched it about a year ago I couldn’t believe that they started filming it in 2009 and stopped in 2013. This show truly seems like something you’d see get released today
Cast and crew of Breaking Bad were given more Award's than any other show in TV history. But CSI Miami at the time was the most popular TV show, with the world's highest viewing figures. Due to the number of TV channels on offer now, no other show could equal CSI. One episode alone, was watched by 200.000.000. people around the world.
@@chobochobus He doesn't have one, he just has a fragile ego and can't understand that recognition isn't all about popularity. Popularity does not equal quality.
Alternate ending: Walter wakes up in a hospital, having fully survived the cancer and injuries from the last scene of the series finale. Even tho it's never gonna happen, it's just something good to think about.
the doctor asked him "why run away? what did you feel you had to run from?" but Walt was answering the question "Why did you start cooking meth?"
Exactly
Most people in his situation would either kill themselves, or invent Flubber
this is the moment the doctor asked Heisenberg why Iran
Bravo Vince!
Everytime Walt is feeling uncomfy with what he's saying, he has this reflex to wave hands as if he's trying to get away with it.
This makes him a terrible liar.
"I would be able to tell that person and only that person"
So if I said I was going to murder a baby, you would just tell the baby, "hey, somebody's coming to kill you"? 😂
From what I know therapists are mandatory reporters so they would have to tell someone if their client is or is about to harm a child.
@@vincentvaleur3573 Either the writers didn't completely understand patient confidentiality or they wrote it differently to make more sense to the viewers. You're right, a therapist is a mandatory reporter. That means if their patient comes in and expresses any desire to harm themselves or anybody else they must report it to the authorities, not to the person the threat was made towards. The person who was threatened would probably then be contacted by authorities, but I can almost guarantee that conversation wouldn't happen between the therapist and the person being threatened.
Doctor patient confidentiality doesn’t work like that. If you tell a psychiatrist you committed a violent crime, or threaten to do so, they are required to report it to the police.
It's particularly weird that they presented it in this way, as it's a simple thing to research and implement into a script. Doing so also doesn't present any sort of plot discrepancy either, because when Walter comes clean he reveals it wasn't because of an illegal or violent act. Including the proper declaration of Doctor-Patient confidentiality doesn't write them into a corner.
Depends on the psychiatrist. Someone I might have known did the same thing in the past tense multiple times and got away with it. Not pulling your leg.
Depending on the situation, if you withhold who and when, there's not much they can do.
After doing some research I found that NM's duty to warn laws are not mandatory. So they can breach confidentiality if the patient threatens violence, but they are not required to.
Also the psychiatrist was clearly aware of what Walt was asking. Even though Walt by this point was most definitely a criminal with secrets, as far as the psychiatrist knew he was just a family man with cancer. He probably didn't feel the need to mention that if Walt confesses to committing a crime he would have to breach confidentiality.
If someone tells a doctor they committed a crime and goes to court, based entirely on a TV show, that's on them.
@@EGRJ hello BRÖTHER
"There was no fugue state doc, I spent days cooking meth with my partner, he messed up the battery of the van we got stuck..it's hard being a drug pimp doc"
This is after Tuco kidnapped them iirc.
@@bachelorgoosy9145 oh...sbhh
It's good to see that people still watch breaking bad
The first time I watched it about a year ago I couldn’t believe that they started filming it in 2009 and stopped in 2013. This show truly seems like something you’d see get released today
I started watching it a couple of weeks ago
@@Joe-jj3ohthe show came out in 2007?
@@Joe-jj3oh i belvie if it would came out today, it would be way worse. Jesse saying Skibidi Sciene! Hell yeah! wouldnt stick good with me
The name of this show is Walt and the Doc
1:45 is probably the same answer Walt would have given that doctor about cooking meth and breaking bad
Breaking Bad is one of the goated shows of all-time like The Sopranos 😤.
sopranos washes this
@@jordyjohnathan5123sure buddy
You could just say goated
Is this the same doctor as the one in GTA V?
Yes
Walt is such a bad liar
Such an excellent series... I just left his acting
Why leave it? U said its excellent.
I, too, vacated his acting.
It was too raw to handle. : )
Tucco
jesse
i dont know any taco.
I dont think this would work in real life
Why wouldn’t it?
@@theduke9292 because that's not how it works silly, also Google exists look up patient confidentiality 😋
Heisenberg
Walter
Put
Your
Weiner
Walter White is too relatable for me
elaborate.
@nchappy16 the bitterness, frustrations, thinking that life is boring, regrets. Socially akward, fear of everything. Season 1 walt is me
@@DanteTrajano-t4p not the meth part? that's disappointing
@nchappy16 Not yet
Why is a SHOW clip on MOVIEclips?
Gonna cry?
@Mikol_Billy
Do you want me to??
@ ….no 🥺
Cast and crew of Breaking Bad were given more Award's than any other show in TV history. But CSI Miami at the time was the most popular TV show, with the world's highest viewing figures. Due to the number of TV channels on offer now, no other show could equal CSI. One episode alone, was watched by 200.000.000. people around the world.
what's your point?
@@chobochobus He doesn't have one, he just has a fragile ego and can't understand that recognition isn't all about popularity. Popularity does not equal quality.
CSI is tv slop. Breaking bad is art. That’s the difference
Second
Under 10 minute gang
👇
Alternate ending: Walter wakes up in a hospital, having fully survived the cancer and injuries from the last scene of the series finale. Even tho it's never gonna happen, it's just something good to think about.
The only reason I’d want that ending is so that he could go to jail for the rest of his life. Walt didn’t deserve happiness.