Is This the Cruelest Execution in Scottish History?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ต.ค. 2024
- Scottish history has many sad events. The story of The Wigtown Martyrs must be one of the most cruel. Scottish history tour guide, Bruce Fummey visits Wigtown to tell the story.
Upcoming Live shows www.brucefummey...
More about Covenanters • Who were The Covenanters?
Buy me coffee at www.buymeacoff...
Three ways to support Scotland History Tours video productions at www.scotlandhi...
...or just buy me coffee here
www.buymeacoff...
Here's a video explaining the three ways to help me make more videos • Crowdfunding Options t...
Join The National Trust of Scotland and experience Scottish history in lots of many National Trust properties worth visiting. You can find out about National Trust for Scotland, it's properties and how to join here tidd.ly/3kuyDg3
Join the mailing list at
mailchi.mp/d2e...
Videography by Matt Ward at www.visualsofs...
Scotland History Tours is here for people who want to learn about Scottish history and get ideas for Scottish history tours. I try to make videos which tell you tales from Scotland's past and give you information about key dates in Scottish history and historical places to visit in Scotland. Not all videos are tales from Scotland's history, some of them are about men from Scotland's past or women from Scotland's past. Basically the people who made Scotland. From April 2020 onward I've tried to give ideas for historic days out in Scotland. Essentially these are days out in Scotland for adults who are interested in historical places to visit in Scotland.
As a Scottish history tour guide people ask: Help me plan a Scottish holiday, or help me plan a Scottish vacation if your from the US. So I've tried to give a bit of history, but some places of interest in Scotland as well.
![ผัวเถื่อน - ยูริ โตเกียวมิวสิค [ OFFICIAL MUSIC VIDEO ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/P08ORRVDGl8/mqdefault.jpg)
Upcoming Live shows www.brucefummey.co.uk/shows.aspx
More about Covenanters th-cam.com/video/4b7viuyaIf8/w-d-xo.html
Buy me coffee at www.buymeacoffee.com/ScottishBruce
Proof of all the Claims made on your channel are required.
@@F4Insight-uq6nt Bruce has been trying to do a niel Oliver a cum fae the land of the covenanted that starts fa barrhill
Such a sad tale but the saddest part Bruce is that today in our so called modern World ,we have those who wish to impose their own fanactical beliefs upon others. Freedom of thought has to be fought for over and over again.
This is true on both sides of the political divide. There are people obsessed with enforcing their mystical beliefs on others and, without irony, those people always cast themselves as freedom fighters.
Absolutely. These folks and those who stormed beaches in ww2 fought for freedoms. We cant let them down and give in to oppression.
Politics are always rough but public execution for your believes are currently illegal.
I don't think there is much comparison.
We just seem to be rerunning the gay debate of the 1980s with the trans.
It's called Woke now and was called Political Correctness then.
@@cyberleaderandy1different freedom then. Freedom to be part of the British Empire, to be locked up for being gay and you could beat your wife as long as she wasn't permanently damaged.
And racism was still science in many people's heads.
Here on Merseyside, plenty realised that the Japanese and Germans did not distinguish between Orange and Green....same on the river Imjin in Korea with the Chinese...yet here were we are with our Bruce..😊
i am a 58 year old Fifer,this is the history that should be taught in our Scottish schools,amazing stuff
Frankly, the Christians who want their religion taught in schools need to be reminded about exactly every act of cultural, language, and literal genocide that their religion has inflicted upon humanity since day one. This story, every woman who was sacrificed during the burning times, Native Americans who were taken from their tribe and raised as "Christian" to "save their soul", etc..😒🙄
My favorite Scottish History Tour Guide, King Bruce! 👑🏴🙌🏿
You're too kind
@@ScotlandHistoryToursno. You are my favourite Scottish history person now. I prefer it when you play it straight and this was a 10/10
Such a sad thing to have happened
All heil!
That is so sad, Bruce but we need people like you to remind us of human’s inhumanity to humankind. You have the words for this; I have none ☹️
what faith, you must not forget their faith, without faith we have nothing.
This is why so many Presbyterians emigrated to New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and Virginia in late 1600s. A Presbyterian prayer used 100 years later during American revolution was "May the lord press the King to the glory of his bosom, as we want no more of him on this earth". - Reverend Caldwell.
Well, that would be a bit silly. Things were a bit different in George III's time.
and 1 of the reasons why having all those religious extremes in a melting pot, has ended up with the twisted versions of religion all in in 1 place! I would have been drowned, refuse allegiance to a king, and don't believe in any god! I have my will and it is free! yet I try and do no wrong to other's!
America's original settlers made a mess thank you very much. If they were welcome anywhere at this point God would smile. There's nothing religious or spiritual about them. Were worse than the Catholics when they got here.
@@andyt5559echo that sentiment too...from an Orange and Green family..life is too short..our enemies do not distinguish between our faith...personally am grateful to our Presbyterian church brethren for restoring Iona.?and of course our intrepid Historian...😊😊😊
@@aaronsinger things like JW, Mormons develop, then you get to the likes off Scientology, they are all basically scams, masquerading as religions!
I must be honest this one brought a tear to my eye 😢..you presented the story very well ❤
Thanks
This is also one example of why people left Europe and came to the colonies in America. This is an example of why the first Amendment says what it does.
One of my ancestors counting 7 generations ago was Margaret’s oldest brother John, who left Scotland for Antrim, Ireland with two of his younger brothers, leaving Margaret, Thomas and Agnes. His great-grand-daughter, who had the gift of “second sight” saw two of her sons leave for a new life in Australia. There they became pasturalists, and the elder became the “Sheep King of Australia”. The younger was also successful and is my great-great grandfather. I always felt I would be called on to be very brave and stand up for my beliefs. When I first learned of Margaret Wilson, her story resonated with me deeply. I could only hope to be brave in the face of such fear. Thank you for telling the story so beautifully.
Brilliant, all the history that I never got at school ..conveyed in such a brilliant way ..Thank you
You're welcome
My school would have loved a story with a public execution in it.
Bruce you’ve made several touching episodes over the past few years, but to me this has to be the most touching to date. While a moving story out of Scottish history, (which is what I know you focus on) sadly such cruelty was not isolated to, or unique to Scotland. Even sadder, martyring teenagers and children because of their, or their parents religious beliefs is still happening in some areas of our world today.
I never thought one of your videos would make me misty eyed. What courage and what shame. Thank you Bruce.
You're welcome
it's their faith we should praise God for, a faith we also need again.
@@eddiepattisonhogg9917Praise God for the faith that led to their horrible deaths? Wouldn’t it be nice if we could praise those who simply do good as opposed to just thanking the Lord for giving people the faith to suffer horribly, as if the withstanding of torture itself is an act of moral superiority over all those who are careful to avoid being tortured right in front of their families? Do you thank the Lord also for the conviction of all the atheists currently being persecuted around the world for their own faith in the value of truth and honesty that prevent them from pretending to believe in a god they don’t believe in?
It’s so sad & cruel. The Martyr of the Solway is one of my favourite paintings, it’s haunting.
Echo that sentiment too, chilling from cruel...😢...E...
As a Portuguese traveller, in Scotland 🌺❤️, I love dearly this beautiful country, thank you so much for sharing the amazing Scottish History Education, so much appreciated x
Your videos always bring the characters from history to life and make them more than a name and date and add context. Thank you
A'reyt Bruce. A sad tale all round, but well told in a beautiful setting, as always.
This is where my family is from. OMG what horrible things we humans do to one another... 😭
Aye
@@ScotlandHistoryTours....well ,some of us former foes share stories...and wounds in these cruel days...thank you for sharing this with us all.❤❤
Heartbreaking. Thank you, Bruce, for sharing this story.
Very welcome
A very emotionally moving story. And so sad. Well worth the watch on many levels.
Thank you so much for making this video. It’s just down the road from me so I always try to leave a flower down on the stone each year.
Bruce makes it easy to listen and interesting. 😊
Good stuff. Dissent is still hated, by you know who. The beauty of the gentle landscape of Galloway lends poignancy to the story of the covenanters. Keep it up.
Great point!
By who?
@@briansullivan5908 Generally by everyone who has power.
Thank you again Bruce, for bringing history to life, and for always treating it with dignity and compassion. Best wishes my brother.
The man who refuses to allow our country to be a forgotten nation as some would like..🏴
Whoever you hate, it must run very deep to make such a comment on a video that tells the story of the brutal execution of young women. for crimes they could not possibly have committed.
@@vinny142pretty sure that is praise to the storyteller.
Indeed, high praise to the storyteller.
Exactly who whats Scotland to be a forgotten country?
@@johnmulligan912
Who wants Scotland to be forgotten? 🤔
I forget. 😄
Thank you for telling story about Scotland.😊
A shocking story and makes me feel sad and ashamed that humans display such cruelty to each other.
Beautiful story telling. I could only imagine what living in those times was like.
Thanks for telling this story as it was Bruce,so many atrocities and the despicable stories which have been passed down through the years at these times seem to be hidden from what we are taught at school. Like yourself in not religious but always interested in the history of our beautifully country.Keep the good work up,always enjoy your videos.
A powerful piece of history 😢
Powerful video Bruce, well presented. Sad part of our history yet it shouldnt be forgotten nor they who made it, unfortunately.
Always easier to empathize with chaotic times when they are distilled down to personal harship and tragedy..
Thanks for the tellin'..
thanks for having the courage to put this on here, these are facts that our people need to know, we indeed live in a time of great darkness.
Again, this is a great video and always amazing storytelling. It is so sad that this story has been repeated multiple times all over the world. Religion has held people together, but also tore them apart. Brave young children ❤❤
“God is the leading cause of death” ~ George Carlin
As usual Bruce a great piece of storytelling.
I used to drive past the Maggie Wall memorial when visiting my brother who used to live in Dunning. Every time I couldn't help thinking that humans have thought of a lot of cruel ways of killing each other in the name of religion and how they think of more every century.
That is probably amongst the worst, although there are a few to choose from
It's not really about religion though is it, other than as an instrument of power? The two sides to this story are not equal, nor do they have comparable motivations; the martyrs were standing by their faith, but their crime was essentially political.
An absolutely invaluable presentation, Bruce - QUALITY😎👍
The truth has never any space for patronizing - even self-aggrandising exploits... must be faced, warts n all.
And, 'let's face it', many/most (world-wide) only reckon the more romanticized, 'Walkers tin' version of things.
I've a mate whose father used to tend to many Covenanters graves and memorials all throughout the southwest
(He always used to remind me, "They'd no much use for royals - or any o they Jacobites neither!")😁
My ancestors served under a Covenanter General ( the Marquis of Montrose ) ...O Cahan, s regiment of foot..most ended being hung..today my blended ,Orange and Green family still talk of those cruel days...cheers/slainte...E..
A traagic history, beautifully retold. Thank you.
Thanks
I like the way you don't shy from telling the good and the bad.
Thanks again Bruce! The truth of our past and lessons not to be forgotten. Supposedly my 9th ggf Rev William "the Martyr " Duncan of Perth was executed around 1690 and the family being ousted fleeing to the virginia colony. See you in Perth 👊🏼
Wow, you tell some incredible stories, yet, this story, along with the way you have of sharing it with us, I don't believe can be surpassed.
A sad and beautiful testimony to faith and courage
And the brutality that is justified for Jesus Christ.
Loved learning more about Scottish history. We visited last year and thoroughly enjoyed the entire country. I especially loved meeting all the people and, of course trying the many single malts. We hope to revisit in the near future.
Thank you for this story Bruce. Incredible.
My pleasure!
Thank you for sharing their story! I first came across the Martyrs of Wigtown last September whilst visiting the area. I wanted to know more about them and have just finished writing a short book on them which is part fact, part fiction.
Oh wow!
Well told sir! Good to finally learn what “Covenanters” were all about.
'Tis a bitter and sorrowful Tale you tell Bruce. Brought tears to my eyes.
😢
I wish we humans could seem to hold one faith, whatever it might be, without feeling the need to crush anyone who holds another. A sad story for many reasons, but the saddest aspect to me is the use of so much power to frame and obliterate an old lady and a young woman. I'm glad their memory lives on. Thanks for this post.
If we were all one faith anyone who isn't would be persecuted
Great video ✌️ Scottish and proud
Thanks 👍
I am a simple person. I see Bruce post, I click. Asap.
Love you😍
I've visited the Martyr's Post a few times. It's always an eerie experience
That’s the 1st time you’ve made me cry. I was close with Glencoe , but I controlled myself 😢
Still love your “stories”,Bruce. Thank you for this one.
Love learning via your videos Bruce.
Incredibly sad story. I had no idea of any of this. Thanks for relating the tale. 😢😢😢
Thanks for listening
Fascinating (and heartbreaking) history. Some 30 years ago, my dad came across a book called the Willson family tree, which traced the descendants of Thomas Willson up to about the 1940s-1950s IIRC. He is among the descendants via his mother, so I will be sharing this video with him, as he is fascinated by family history.
Just did the same thing to my family
@@ivorwillson623 Sounds like we're distant cousins.
Well written, very well spoken !
Thank you
Enjoying your work. Looking forward to the Dunfermline show. Many thanks
Thank you so much for sharing this story. I was unfamiliar with it. It's very moving.
You are so welcome
Great story Bruce. It illustrates why the separation of church and state was so important to the writers of the US constitution. Man should have the right to worship according to his own conscience, not forced to have beliefs that are not his or her own. Such bravery is amazing.
You are so right!!
Problem is, we are losing it, slowly but surely.
The most religious country in the western world, extremism flourishes in the USA.
All of your videos are amazing. I get myself comfortable and just listen. Your storytelling is beautiful and it brings the history alive. You always bring the humanity to history. You bring the people of the past alive so I feel the empathy. Thank you so, so much for what you do! ❤️
I cried at the end of this one.
Thank you Bruce for reminding us of our history it is sad to hear it but we have not to forget it
Thank again Bruce.👍🏴
Bruce you are bloody amazing man, I love your work. Just a lonely Scot living abroad, but you bring me home. Love you man.
Love your vids Bruce, your an excellent historian 😊 would be fab if you did a video about the witches of Fife. Edinburgh Uni have an interactive map that shows who was killed and the why and the where, dates etc. It's quite interesting😊x
Seconded, that’d be awesome!
The capacity for wanton cruelty is something never far away ( Bucha..) , a debt of gratitude to you for sharing this with us all,best wishes from the wirral peninsula...😮...😢...E...
You are welcome!
@@ScotlandHistoryTours....😢...
This brought back memories from 20 years ago when we had holidays regularly in a farm cottage in the hills above Creetown. We used to enjoy going to Wigtown for the book shops and tours of Bladnoch distillery ending with the purchase of a bottle or two. Having visited once we came back each year for a few years. Every time we found something else to enjoy in the Machars triangle.
Also we found Gatehouse of Fleet and Kirkcudbright to be favorite spots.
I remember this history and it's where I rediscovered the Covenanters, first heard about at high school in the 1970s and also the Stuartry. I always found something new every visit and apart from London there's not many places like it. Only thing I hated was the midges in the Forest of Galloway.
What a sad tale... and so well told.
Well that's cheered me right up!
😍
Excellent video, well presented. Very interesting.
Thank you for how beautifully you handled the end of video and for video with your sister and brother in law on legacy of the enslaved people and Aberdeen
Thank you so much!
walked out to see the post a few times, knew roughly what had happened, but didn't know the whole story. Thanks very much for filling in the blanks.
You're welcome
Thanks for sharing this very sad tale, on a lighter note I look forward to seeing you on tour when you climb the wall and bring your show to Newcastle at the end of August.
Good morning Bruce, thanks for another great video, thought provoking, to say the least, 🏴👍🏻
Evening😊
History can be frustrating and compilcated. I am disgusted by how these ladies were treated because of their beliefs, but on the other end as an American, I'm also painfully aware of how people are treated if they aren't affiliated with some form of christianity.
Nevertheless, my heart aches at the cruelty forced upon these people.
Thank you for this ❤
Please give an example of people treated badly because they are not Christians in the present day. It is an undisputed truth that Christians are the subject of persecution today and will be until the end times, as Jesus our Lord told us.Thank
Read about the situation in Africa and in the UK in which Christianity is being slowly and sleekitly strangled by an atheist government.
I enjoyed your video. Plus I love history. Greetings from the West of Ireland 😁
Brilliant bit of sad history. Nice presentation
My husband's ancestor the Rev. Turner ended up in Maryland (after a bit in N. Ireland ) in the 1700s. He was holding to his beliefs and thus brought Scotland with him.😊
Thank you
You're welcome
Well done
Great video, really appreciated how you 'walked back' the clan dispute from the most virulent historical event to the various other 'known' events that form part of the chronology of that dispute.
Did I see you in a movie about finding Richard 111’s remains? I was so excited to see you!🇦🇺
Aye, that was me
Another well told history. I’m particularly saddened to hear of the treachery of the supposed friend who entrapped the sisters.
True
The more cruel the rulers, the less power they have. They live in fear.
Those were some mighty tough women.
Another amazing story we'll presented keep it going loving your work how about a short on battle of santa cruz 1797
I recognise so many of the places from videos that I drive by without second thought when fishing
It's good to see you doing well Mr Fummey! I remember you were always the favourite supply teacher at our school ^^
🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣
The story of the witch hangings in Pittenweem are, just like so many others, heartbreaking. But nothing to do with overbearing authorities, just the usual story of lifetime friends and neighbours turning against one of their own because someone said something etc etc.
Quite the contrary, state religions in that general time period were very overbearing. A shame that real history is not taught in schools. People died all over Europe for not accepting the state religion where they were living! It might be family, friends, or neighbors who turned them in, but it was the church or government (often the same thing) that killed them.
My surname is Campbell. My father is Scottish and English. My ancestors came to Canada a couple of centuries ago. We slowly moved into the US. I now live in Vermont and do my best to learn Scottish history.
I'm doing live shows in Canada in 2024. Shows in Halifax, Annapolis, New Glasgow, Moncton, Montreal, Perth , Ottawa, Toronto, Fergus, Seaforth, Calgary, Vancouver and Victoria. Most of the details are here www.brucefummey.co.uk/shows.aspx
Thanks!
Thanks
We were Covenanters in Muirkirk (Kirk on the moor of Kyle) we and others fought at Drumclog and won.
It's what Jesus would have done.
My ancestors changed religion, like you and I change electric supplies...we Hibernian's and Caledonians should focus on the crucial things like our housing and health..native of Limavady now an adopted son of Birkenhead..❤❤😊😊
10 thumbs up! Sharing this widely. Direct descendant of Malcom III here, who’s also directly descended from 3 Native American nations (incl 2 tribal chiefs). You’re the best resource, hands down, for learning the history of my Scots ancestors.
America again. Been binge watching during our artic blast. The history is explaining to me some of the the foundational division that has found its way out in the open here. I watched "division between church and hate" and feel like I have a much better understanding of these extreme cycles. Also, makes complete sense with our fiercely independent, Appalachia folks. So many say they dont know where their people came from but the likeness seems obvious. Brother, you are making a difference. Thank you!
Amazing tale, thank you ❤😊
Our pleasure!
I always wanted to go to Scotland. I the history and legends and folklore
I subscribed. 🙂
I actually read this in my family history book when I was but a boy, definitely cruel and horrific
Just remembered 😂 ma maw's name's Margaret Wilson,
What an amazing rendition of that bit of ur history…I believe ur made to teach this to all bro. Good luck in future and I’ll always b happy to hear more from ur videos
So sad, it just goes on and on in every country😢
Stories like this are exactly why we need to safeguard the total and permanent separation of church(es) and state. Let's not harm each other over who has the best imaginary friends in the sky.
Sadly we'll probalby find other reasons to harm each other
@@ScotlandHistoryTours Aye, unfortunately this is true as well...
@@ScotlandHistoryTours ...yes, those pesky electric scooters for example.
Hi Bruce! As always, your excellent videos cover much more than history. In bringing this family and old woman into the light, you've made them and what they died for live again. Both women may have died for the Church of Scotland, but their killings bring to bear the fact that such deaths were so unnecessary! In fact, there is never a reason to kill a good person. Not ever. You may disagree with them, you may not like them, but there is never a reason to kill or even hurt someone who bears you no ill will! That you're wishes for peace and harmony between peoples are the same as mine gives me hope that someday it might actually happen. Wouldn't that be wonderful?!
The martyrs died for the church of Christ, at the time of these events the Church of Scotland was an apostate, erastian church.
Thank you so much. I’m going to systematically go through all your videos. I’m never to old (at 73) to learn more about my country’s history. I’m going to try to introduce them one by one to my granddaughters. (8/10yo).
Brilliant. Some of the older videos are less polished though
I’m not a religious person myself, but I have nothing but awe and respect for young children who found their literal comfort and strength in a particular faith. Honestly, I myself couldn’t get to a place of deeper forgiveness and acceptance with anyone until I finally broke away from religious dogma. Namaste