ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ค. 2021
- I have a WD19 and a WD19DCS, they're rather expensive. Do I recommend you get one though?
My website - tech3d.world/
Autodesk offers - tech3d.world/autodesk
InvMark - invmark.cadac.com/#/
------------
FACEBOOK: / tficadtips
TWITTER: / tficadtips
------------
Outro design by TGODdesigns: / tgoddesigns - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
No your not losing the plot, this is a re-upload! Just modified the part at the end where originally I looked like a zombie, felt like I needed to add in a slightly modified conclusion based on how badly I had put this video together ha
The reason why you would use a dock is for portability. For example you have to jump to meeting rooms every hour or 2. Now you only have to do is disconnect a single cable and you can go, instead disconnecting 2-3 monitors, keyboard, mouse, ethernet, etc
And without a dock, it's not only a matter of time but you are simply unable to hook up 2 or 3 screens to the laptop due to lack of ports
Thank you. This was by far the most simple and easy to understand no-nonsense explanation of this dock.
I found this video 2 years late but I will add this. The main reasons to purchase a dock over a hub are power and ports. If you have a big enough power supply and a laptop that supports charging through the port you connect the dock to, you can use the dock without a separate power supply. It will also power the devices connected to the dock station instead of pulling the power from your laptop which means less draw on the PC. The other option is ports. Docking stations tend to have more ports for monitors, USB, etc. than a hub. Which one you need depends on your use case.
I purchased the Dell Precision 7550 because of your review on it. I also purchased the 49 inch monitor because of your review. I remembered that you hated the dock so I figured it would work seamlessly. I called Dell when I didn’t get the resolution, I found out that even with the best specs and GPU that the monitor output is limited from the motherboard regardless of GPU. So then I had to purchase the dock to get the resolution. So I’m not sure how you’re able to use your precision and 49 inch together at full res without the wd19dc?
Great video! can you please tell me where you got the magnetic twin/parallel usb-c cable shown at around 17:20?
A big THANK to you, sir, for all this good information you are sharing here, now I see, said the blind man, I do not need this DOCK! Thank you so very very much for helping me out in process of purchase or not! Wishing you all the very Best and stay blessed! Best regards from Sweden!
I received the WD19 for FREE, (accidentally, but maybe on purpose), I was provide a laptop during Covid for 50/50 Telework. I also was provide with the dock and two monitors, when everything was starting to slow and most employees returned to work, I returned the laptop and monitors, but did not return the dock, I left it on my desk at home, I had plan to turn it in later. Then I resigned (Covid Mandate). Well, I have found it very useful with my Alienware 17 R4 with my two monitors that I have connected to my old Desktop (GEN 4 CPU and GTX 970), so if I have game that I can on run on the 970, I run on the 1060 and the dock works great.
I agree with you on the cost. Unfortunately, with the recent global pandemic, teleworking is now taking on more permanence. I wofl for local government in Los Angeles. My IT department basically said, all of our or equipment is dell and you do not have administrative credentials to download drivers, etc., and no support, so make your home work station look like our work office offices (part where I eyeroll...) That is expensive....very expensive.
You are also right about the Dell confusing letters and how any minor detail will affect your other devices. I have (2) U27220Q monitors. Both 4K. Now is where I need your help- because I have lost the battel on purchase other better/cheaper docking stations. What is the difference (if any) between the Dell WD 19S and the WD 19? and do will either support using each of the DP ports 45 at 60 Hz? Thoughts? LOVE YOUR COMMENT ON THE DELL NOMENCLATURE!!! no need to keep the same name where only the power delivery changes- simply offer it as an option at check out. Thank you!
for the single USB-C cable connection, how many watts does the dock send to the laptop for charging? 30w? 45w? Does the 240W adapter increase this number over the 180W model? So many questions but Dell doesn't have this info on their site
I have a DELL dock at work, and just connect the one cable (as you have described) upon arrival. Cannot tell you which one, as I'm working remotely due to COVID-19 restrictions in AUS. I don't suppose there's any hard & fast answer, but I would prefer to put the notebook aside given everything I need is run off the dock (incl. the wireless Logitech keyboard and mouse off a unifying receiver). The USB-C lead exits the dock on the left, but to put the notebook next to it you must reverse it because the USB-C ports are also on the left! (HOWEVER, I do realise this works if you sit the notebook in front of the dock). The only way to cater for both would be to split the USB-C ports (one on each side).
I have my own dock for working remotely - it's a HP thunderbolt with the audio module. Now that's a good piece of kit, although it doesn't talk to the DELL as well as the HP (my personal laptop) - I have to power on the DELL on the notebook keyboard, whereas the HP just powers on by the switch on the dock. And off, as well.
Docking stations are aimed at speedy arrival and departure times at a work station. Nothing more and nothing less Just to keep laptop mobile really fast. I run a docking station and 2 chargers. One stays in my bag and the other on the desk with the docking station. Just plug and play.
The new Precisions (5000 series) we currently have only come with 3 USB-C ports, a 3,5mm and a micro SD cardslot. We also go between office (programming Hypermill), workshop (CNC machining) and occasionly home with the laptops.
Plugging one cable is a bless, 5 not possible and a horrorscenario. The double USB-C version is only nescesary for 7000 series laptops because they need 180W, the power source is 240W.
All the others work fine with the 180W, giving 130W to the laptop through one USB-C, that is a Dell special.
The 130W version are meant for the Lattitude series that need 65 to 90 Watt.
One thing to know, USB-C adds up the power from multiple ports, so my Precision runs on 130W, but only recieves 90W from the monitor, a second powersupply gives the additional needed power. That basicly the principle of the 240W power dock as well.
how do you get sound now without the jack being there? is there a dongle or adapter?
Just curious, what do you use your 4k tv for in comparison to you regular monitors?
Netflix, Plex, watching my Ezviz cameras, and sometimes sim racing at 120Hz when I'm not in VR :) It's a 1440p 120Hz panel as well as 4K, I should give a work reason why I have it but that's kinda how it is!
In an office. you setup a dock. 2 monitors Keyboard Mouse... End users are stupi.... not technical ... mess things up. getting non-technical 55 year old to unplug and re-plugging in 5 cables is a pain, one cable is a massive thing from a support perspective, IT set the desks up, user plugs 1 thing in.. USB type C can't even get it upside down now! reduced our support calls by many hours over the course of 3 years.. like can't get my mouse to the left monitor (because they plugged them in in a different order) one of my monitors is not working (because they didn't push the cable all the way in or knocked it out back of the monitor because they have to keep fafing with the cables) there also not £400... get a quote we paid £150 each for them.
From a business perspective they are great.. from a home user perspective... not much point.. but then again.. i didn't buy a coffee machine because I like orange juice!
i was wondering if this dock is usefull to power quest 2 and deliver data to pc at same time without delays or any problems..
Hey, need some help on getting a dock for my work dell latitude 3400 laptop (Type C supports DisplayPort HBR2)
So my use case atm requires me to use multiple external displays.
Right now I am using 2 displays (1 via hdmi and 1 via type c to hdmi adapter) and am able to get full res on both but not hz (not too important).
The issue arises when I want to connect a 3rd monitor, the laptop has a vga port which I have tried to use but whenever the type c port is connected to a display the vga is disconnected (disabling laptop display has no affect)
From what I’ve read online, I should be looking at the D3100/D6000 which uses Display link.
But I don’t have admin access to the laptop to install the drivers, which leaves one of the WD19 models.
So would it make sense to purchase the D3100/D6000 and hope I can get IT to install drivers or go for one of the WD19 models to run 3 external monitors running at full res (display 1 is 1920x1080, display 2 is 3440x1440 and display 3 is 2560x1080)
will this work with an asus g15 ryzen processor when it doesnt have thunderbolt?? I have 2 1440p monitors that I want to hook up too
does the power button work on the system? of course after connecting the thinkpad
I didnt even buy one with the company money. I went for the almost identical hub you showed, so have to plug in the hub and the power....Simples!! Then wasted the money I saved on a pillar drill! Rock and Roll.
Hi. Is it possible to connect ultra wide 34” we had and 27” hd to the wd19 at the same time? Of course all of this connected to the windows laptop
Absolutely
The dock station gives you good power delivery, while most dongles have problems delivering enough power to power my Audient ID4 or to power my Sony A7 IV in web-cam mode.
Will this work with thinkpad t14s gen 1 and dell wd19tb. I have two dell monitors ultrasharp u2419h
I’ve had these docks for the last 5 year and think they truly terrible. I’ve had 3 different ones and all had problems with connecting to my laptop and serval faults. I can’t say they make loads of noise but the main issue is connectivity. I can’t say the the dell laptop wasn’t much better it battery expanded and blow out my mouse pad and keyboard. Is it worth the it I the laptop I has had only 2 USB’s so yes but if I had more usb and docking on the laptop I had I certainly wouldn’t have one.
The WD19S Dock is terrible?
I have a question for all you, I have a work laptop with 1 hdmi and 1 usb c. The usb c is not thunderbolt. I also am not allowed to install any software or drivers on the laptop. With that being said, I would like the option of powering two external monitors for better productivity. Is this possible? I have tried dock after dock and spent 100’s of dollars trying to make this work. If anyone sees this and has a option for me I would greatly appreciate it!
Monitor 1- Acer KA272
Monitor 2- Lg 34WQ500
Laptop- HP RTL8822CE
Can i use 130W for the WD19?
I use wd19tb in my office. It connects to xps 13 and with a single cable i get 2 external 4k monitors, ethernet connection and power supply. But If i was buying today i would go for caldigit 3ts plus
Will this work with Samsung a7 tablet? I m Tryna connect my tab to external touch screen monitor but type C to HDMI not working on my tab
Can you power a Dell laptop on these without opening the lid?
I took the plunge after finding a WD19DCS on eBay for 170 Quid........ 30 minutes in and it works well!
To be honest, to me personaly Hub is not for convenience. And I strongly believe that the main buyers are those who want to connect multiple monitors (like myself). I have a laptop and a desktop with 3 QHD monitors. BUT. I really don't like having 2 computers. 2 different systems. I really want to be able to connect my laptop to those 3 monitors and get rid of that desktop pc. This is my main convenience. If we talk about band width, refresh rates and so on... Let's be honest. Gamers would not run any games over a laptop with 3 monitors and refresh rates for me is not a problem at all. Let's say, one day I'll decide to play the FPS game. I would run HDMI directly from my laptop to one of those 3 monitors. But definitely not through the hub.
Even though the price is steep, I would want to dissagree with you here as this is the ONLY way to run 3 monitors from a laptop. (as far as I know)
Does it work with Microsoft Surface 3 laptop
The laptop charges through the dock USB c?
We use these at work. Just to have your desk be like having a desktop but you can still run out to the lab, meetings or take your laptop home. It’s gimmicky but hey whatever lol.
Can anyone tell me if this the WD19 works with a MBP with a single 4k@60hz, please? I won't watch a full random 18min video with no chapters or structure
You are probably the only person in the World who buys docks for the increasing amount of USB ports. All the rest buys them for simplification of connection 2-3 external 4k displays + all peripheries with just 1 or 2 cables.
Thank you I almost buy the wrong docking station for my precision 5560!
Hey Neil,
Thanks for sharing your thoughts and experiences with the Dell WD19 dock. It's always helpful to hear real-world experiences before making a purchase decision.
I completely get where you're coming from regarding the price of these docks. They can be quite expensive for what they offer, especially if you're not someone who frequently switches between different laptops and requires the convenience of just one cable connection.
You made a great point about the value of these docks in terms of convenience and portability for people who come and go from a workspace. It can indeed save time and make the workspace cleaner and more organized. However, for someone like you who primarily uses laptops as secondary devices and has a well-connected main computer, it might not be as essential.
It's good to know that the dock is well-built and quiet, though. These are important factors to consider for anyone looking to invest in one.
Overall, your video provides valuable insights into the Dell WD19 dock, and your honesty about its cost-effectiveness is appreciated. It's essential for viewers to make an informed decision based on their specific needs and priorities.
Also the 3 monitor thing.... most OFFICES don't have 4k monitors or ultra-wides... they have 22 inch widescreen 1080p monitors. which all the line of docks handles 3 no issues. 4k monitors and high-res screen are edge cases in majority of dock use cases.... lets face it most people that need multiple 4k monitors are using a desktop anyway. with a heaving big GPU in it...
overpriced but probably because its aimed at corporates who just pass costs on to their tenants or clients
fast fwd to 5:19, stop and close it at 12:35 - thank me later
I know this is old, so I wonder if your opinion on these docks has changed yet, but each person in our office has either a WD19 or a D3100 so that we can run multiple monitor setups easily, and I'm sorry to say we've decided to ditch all things DELL over this junk. I'm sure there will be just as many anecdotal reports of perfect operation, but whether it's poor design, poor build quality or abysmal after sales support, I just can't see us ever buying DELL again. Every single dock has some sort of problem - fan failures (though it appears to work ok), random fan start/stop (neither hot nor busy, at all, but REALLY irritating), Ethernet ports that don't work - they are just rubbish, and reading other fault reports we're definitely not an unusual case.
As you say, for the price, I would expect something that is essentially pretty simple to work for many years - not fail just around warranty expiry.
I've also had a saga with DELL support which, as soon as I can find a way to easily export the iMessage conversation I've had over the past 3 months, I will be posting online. Talking to a wall would have been more productive. Conversely I've just had a great conversation with Lenovo - yes, they may turn out to be just as bad - but I know I will never recover the wasted time, money and grief I've had with DELL (they did replace my Precision 5550 when I received a _physical burn_ from it trying to self-destruct in my laptop bag, but the replacement has been just as bad).
what is the difference between WD19DCS and WD19DC ?
S is for "simplified". It doesn't have an audio port. Kindof ironic that the "s" doesn't have sound... Anyway it's because the audio chipset provider had huge supply chain problems and Dell wanted to keep selling these docks, so they released one without the audio chipset.
These types of docks are really nothing more than glorified USB hubs, with a whole host of potential issues... not to mention bloody expensive. You can't beat the older D/Port and E-Port family of docking stations that interface directly with the laptop's motherboard, require no firmware updates or drivers, and genuinely add more and useful ports. Docking stations and port replicators were really all about adding legacy functionality to a laptop, but the newest stuff does away with legacy ports altogether so the fundamental purpose of a dock apart from the 'one click' and you're connected is now dead. In this day and age they're more about replacing essential ports to otherwise ridiculously thin and impractical laptops that are now natively without. I actually did a load of research and testing and made a list of advantages of the older D- and E-family docking stations versus these new ones and the results speak for themselves. Another thing to consider nowadays is that if you just want extra USB ports, a lot of monitors basically have a USB hub built right in.
All I want to do is run 2 monitors off one computer, one for work and the other for gaming. What do I do, / use. Other than unplugging and plugging the other in. Thanks
You are missing the point of the docking station, the idea is that you have one cable to rule them all, plug and play, ready to go. Also, you trying to plug in both a massive 40 inch 4K tv and an ultra wide does not make sense at all…seems like you are not even aware that these docks work with thunderbolt…really good technology, 40gbps throughput capability in the form of a USBC port. In other words, the bandwidth is not sufficient to support both the displays’ resolutions at 4K 60 or even 30hz. Who ever knows the product, knows it would not be reasonable or make sense at all to pair these displays with the dock, you would know its not reasonable to even attempt it and expect it to work.
Do your research better? There must be a reason why docking stations are globally used by organizations.
Thanks you! A righteous man! Much appreciated. I use them at work, but wanted one for home. didn't want to foot the cost if it wasn't universal. Boom, you used a Lenovo and what do I have? .... A Lenovo. I agree with you on the cost. I'm trying to get the company to cover.
How does your opinion change when you can get them on ebay for £50? I have just bought a couple for home and work for convenience of 1 cable connection between desks.
I think you can condense this video to 3' 😄
Some people have more money than sense 🤷🏻♂️400 quid for a hub 👀
I do not recommend these at all. I work in an IT department and all our clients use these. First they do not have good build quality, the usb-c cable is very fragile and can easily lose connection or break. Second we have went through TONS of defective units, from display issues to overheating/fan issues. To top it all of these are WAY over priced. You can get a docking station of higher specs for a quarter of the price. If you can avoid these please do.
Can you tell us examples of high specs docking stations? Tnks
Any others you recommend
If I’m not mistaken, they have a THREE year warranty. I screwed mine up and they sent me another. I’ve had it at work and now I’m home office and it’s been great. If you do your updates, that fan issue isn’t a problem. I couldn’t pay $400 but $150 is worth it big time. It’s the easiest thing for someone that’s not too computer savvy.
You took almost 5 mins to actually get to what people went to the video for. Seriously?????
Slb,💎
Dell sells different docks because they are a capitalist business. Get my meaning?