ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ก.ย. 2024
- Co-directors Ken Burns and Sarah Botstein join ABC News Live to discuss their new documentary, "The U.S. and the Holocaust," which explores America's failure to respond to the humanitarian crisis.
WATCH the ABC News Live Stream Here: • LIVE: Latest News Head...
SUBSCRIBE to ABC NEWS: bit.ly/2vZb6yP
Watch More on abcnews.go.com/
LIKE ABC News on FACEBOOK / abcnews
FOLLOW ABC News on TWITTER: / abc
#abcnews #abcnlupdate #wwii #jewish #history #documentary
![[Watch Party] RoV Pro League 2024 Winter | ( Bacon Time Vs PSG )](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zM25REvnJW4/mqdefault.jpg)
What about the Holodomor?
Is that the starvation of Ukraines by the USSR?
@@toxicgamer6038 by the Bolsheviks.
Ooh, I love Game of Thrones!
Jk.
@@obediahpolkinghorniii564 silly thing to say about the deliberate starvation of millions of people.
The reason we don’t learn about this is because our chewish leaders are planning to repeat this on a global scale.
@@vincentvanmeow Chewish? Never heard of them. Take it down a notch, chentile…
“We fought the wrong enemy”
-George S Patton
@Sexi Beehive
🤮
Patton wanted to side with Nazi Germany against the Soviets...
He also believed that he served under Alexander the Great in a previous lifetime,,,
@@davidhollenshead4892 he wanted to side with them so bad he killed thousands of Germans? Is that what you’re saying?
It wasn’t until after the war when he heard about the atrocities of the eastern front and met many of gods chosen until he realized the fire mistake he had made.
@@vincentvanmeow GODS CHOSEN PEOPLE are not them!
@@vincentvanmeow Revelation 2:9 and 3:9. John 8:44
Finally a documentary to answer age-old question. Can you blame Holocaust on Trump and his supporters? Yes, turns out you can too.
Never give up your firearms, never trust the government.
Agreed the government may have bombers but imagine the political backlash
and never trust the gentiles.
The Jews, a well-armed minority, were overwhelmed by their gentile neighbors who turned on them. The Government was elected by MAGA-style fascists.
@@obediahpolkinghorniii564 well.. Hold on a minute in the situation where this country has more guns than people I think the proletariat should be armed.. .oh and not the right fascists but minority groups and left wing advocates. (Go search up your daddy republican reagan what happened when black people started legally arming themselves.)
@@pako5586 It sound as if we are on the same side… although in Nazi Germany, it’s the proles who helped the Nazis commit genocide.
I live in Germany and every camp I visited, it was the Americans who liberated it.
And we probably turned the tables and war crimed the nazi guards
It was good PR.
Soviet’s liberated the largest and worst camp which was Auschwitz in 1945.
American forces liberated concentration camps including Buchenwald, Dora-Mittelbau, Flossenbürg, Dachau, and Mauthausen.
British forces liberated concentration camps in northern Germany, including Neuengamme and Bergen-Belsen.
@@its_rick_james_bich2575 you’re telling me the Germany economy allocated its resources to build these camps for extermination purposes, meanwhile they’re all fighting the war efforts against the allied forces and USSR?
Isn’t it such a cohencidence that the Americans didn’t liberate a single death camp. All the death camps were liberated by the soviets. Americans liberated only labor camps.
Oh gawd, fighting a world war was NOT enough.
My first thoughts exactly. It’s never going to be enough, for the perpetually neurotic blame America first crowd.
I actually remember seeing on Fox News, some guy claiming to be a Rabbi, complaining that a Priest, during the occupation, who had hid a few hundred of his people from the Nazis, didn’t do enough, because the priest didn’t go out in the streets, to protest the Nazis and their acts in the Holocaust, potentially sacrificing his life, and the lives of the hundreds of hundreds of people he was hiding. Of course, I still haven’t seen this guy lead any rallies against the Chinese, and their genocide of the Uhgyrs. Maybe he doesn’t think their lives matter enough to safely protest on free American streets.
Didn’t do good enough I guess?
Not for the millions of people who died while America twiddled its thumbs, no.
@@obediahpolkinghorniii564write your congressman, and ask them to go to war with China, to stop their atrocities. And why while your at that, stop using all Chinese made products.
@UCn10vb-ocb3PY2MeXAJtDrg Well, not exactly. The President knew what was going on, but he deliberately withheld aid until intervention was politically beneficial to him.
They did that thing in New York in September
Oktoberfest?
This is the grossest fucking thing. We literaly saved Jews but whatever. We are evil
@Israel Goldberg oh don’t worry. I know
You sat on the sidelines for half the war and watched the Germans slaughter the Jewish People.
This documentary was so insightful, sad, and thought-provoking. Always love Ken Burns amazing documentaries!!!!
the youtube comment sections regarding this documentary are as heavily curated as the IMDB and Rotten Tomatoes review pages. go look. both of them have about 9 user reviews total and all of them are positive. totally no censored or anything!
I wonder how many people who think we didn't do enough to help the Jews escape Hitler also think we haven't done enough to help the Rohingya.
Or have we done enough to stop what China does to the Uyghurs and other Turkic Muslims?
Uighur, please
My dad was U.S Navy for 39 years. He said we were still in Depression & could not feed or care for our own people. By 1941 we had a war of our own to fight against Japan.
So you not going talking them owing the slave trade😂😂😂and 500 ships
The eternal victims. It's never enough.
You know, there’s always the option of not victimizing people…
Don't tell me, you're black
@@edwinamendelssohn5129 How many people died in the Holocaust, and how many were Jewish?
@@obediahpolkinghorniii564 15,000,000, 6,000,000 were Jewish.
@@edwinamendelssohn5129 No; six million died, six million of whom were Jewish.
The rest weren’t part of the Final Solution.
They cry out in pain as they strike you and they cry out in pain as you save them.
(Hugs) There, there.
Where is that from? Did you write that?
hopefully you will feel pain in the near future
Based
@@jaeger251 It’s a white supremacist motto. I forget who coined it, but it wasn’t a TH-camr.
Guys we didn’t commit the Holocaust but we still need guilt over it
People who feel guilty about history must have some deep seated hate for the people in the stories that they’re being told.
I don’t feel guilty. I feel sad for those who suffered and angry at those who did it. I didn’t do it. You didn’t do it. But shouldn’t we learn about how terrible that all was so we remember how awful it was so we as a society don’t do it again?
Unless you think what the Nazis did during WWII wasn’t a bad thing.
@@rdear it doesn’t matter. America is about freedom of speech. The opposite of Nazi Germany
@@rdear that’s literally not what’s happening here, they’re trying to shame America because we didn’t do enough, there’s no other purpose of hindsight.
@@chavvy9074 If we learn about how some of our leaders were assholes and didn’t do the right thing when they could, maybe we can hold current and future leaders accountable when we see the same thing again.
Or we can all just remain ignorant. Seems to be working out for you just fine.
Anti-European propaganda
Wooden doors.
Glass houses.
@@obediahpolkinghorniii564 👃
@@Malikav0311 😎
Erm what the sigma 🤓☝🏻
We are all human no matter color you think we should be. You dont turn your back on human that needs help. THATS
That is what I was raised to believe....
How many Venezuelans are you adopting this week? You can save them from the socialism they run from right NOW. Don't turn your back. Cmon man.
Nearly 420,000 American lives were lost in combat to stop it. I don't see how that is turning your back.
That’s not what our current government thinks
dont you know whats right and whats wrong, cant you feel someone pain and want to help them. Im not saying anything about how u were raised .I respect you and what you believe.
How about a documentary about Japanese American internment camps in ww2?
How about a documentary of the Japanese atrocities? The internment camp thing has already been done.
There are many. Look them up. We also had German detainment camps.
@@ruthsaunders9507 I’m not sure about that, but I know that anti-German sentiment was a thing in both of the World Wars and many German speakers ditched their heritages and languages so as not to associate themselves with the Kaiserreich and the Third Reich.
@@aycc-nbh7289 Thousands were arrested and interrogated. If they were considered a danger they were detained. A total of 2,048 were incarcerated for the remainder of the war in two camps, Fort Douglas, Utah, for those west of the Mississippi, and Fort Oglethorpe, Georgia, for those east of the Mississippi.
@@ruthsaunders9507 A meager 2,048 sounds like a drop in the bucket when one considers that more Americans then likely were of German heritage than any other group.
I believe we did a lot we lost tons of men and women fighting Nazis.
Yeah but America bad you know
and a lot of Jews died while America prevaricated.
Now it's time to purge the nazis out of Ukraine
And?
@@FattishWonder you’re ungrateful and didn’t deserve the help
Its illegal to question the holocaust in some countries. Yeah, makes total sense...
If you don’t understand and you’re not from that country, that would be a ‘you’ problem.
More propaganda from a grifter.
Wach Europa the Last Battle
I knew about this and while what we studied in high school barely touched on it. Went to the Holocaust museum in Washington DC and I remember walking through the railroad car and how the hair on the back of my neck stood up and walking over the bridge of shoes. So many times I had to just cry I went through so many emotions. Compassion that will never faulter.
Topics such as the Holocaust are not talked about in our schools and it's very worrying to me as an American how this could me ! It should be talked about very often otherwise we're going to end up like the Jews . The media today has become weaponized by one party (Socialist) and we're all just here listening to them promote the agenda that will lead to our demise . No joke.
Very few know anything about "the HOLODOMOR" ; it happened in Russia under Stalin . Please research
School In America doesn't teach about 80% of American history..
Railroad cars and lots of shoes makes the hair on the back of your neck stand up? Interesting reaction. I get that same reaction when I see American public schools taking grade school children on field trips to bars in the afternoon to watch transexual strippers (yes, that actually has happened, I'm not making that up, although I wish it wasn't true).
@@jackprecip5389 Interesting. I get the same reaction when I see polar bears.
@@jackprecip5389 where was that happening?
Same guy that equated immigrants being shiped to Marthas Vinyard as being in the holocaust
God we know, is why the unhinged Far Right mob is all over the comments. Sad.
@@twt000 You have to be a bot or some entity in a room just typing propaganda on channels. Maybe you have 2 computers and are just filling upnthe internet. Your scentence structure and statement is the wierdest I have ever seen. e.g. Thank you much very!
@@3941602 You people are the ones spamming the comments and getting outright unhinged on a video for a documentary.
Burns's statement about migrants was slightly correct, but you fail to see it.
@@twt000 How? Explain please.
@@3941602 Unwanted people being moved away........And making it for political gain. Just like the N party did.
Why no mention of FDR turning away Jewish refugees??
Because we only accept boats full of Irish people who only survive off Pringle’s potato chips since they do not know how to cultivate other food sources. Incompetence in rewarded in ‘Merika
NOT ONE MENTION of the Nuremberg code !?!?!?!
I wonder why
Sorry, I don't listen to hip hop.
@@obediahpolkinghorniii564 You took the Kool aid didn't you
@@FJBtV-os2pv It was served in an open container. So, no.
Another US bashing documentary from Comrade Burns
There were Nazis in the us in the 30s and 40s and there are still Nazis here now. And there are plenty of people who just don’t like Jewish people.
He’s not bashing the US to point those things out. He’s shining a light on them so it can be dealt with and not become a problem.
@@rdear what makes them Nazis? You’re afraid of a defunct political party that never had mainstream following in America?
@@chavvy9074 The only didn’t have a mainstream following because Hitler lost his mind and started trying to conquer the world. When you identify with the ideology of the enemy of your country, you tend to take it down a notch and be not sublet with your hate so those around you don’t turn on you.
@@rdear yo whaaaaaaaaaaat lmfao Hitler was crazy but the taking over the world part DEFINITELY ranks below the Genocide part lmfao
I wonder what percent of the Bolsheviks were Jews
Imagine an event so verifiably authentic that you have to put people in jail for questioning it.
The event is about as authentic as the Js claim that Jesus was a J and they have a God given right to Palestine and the now state of Israel. About as authentic as the Js that claim they have any ancestry to Abraham, Isaac, or Jacob (Israel) when in reality, Christ identifies the J**s as being "of their father, Satan", "are of the synagogue of Satan", "Are not even of God."
@@michaelwilliamson4759 (hug)
Al Bundy scored four touchdowns in a single game while playing for the Polk High School Panthers in the 1966 city championship game versus Andrew Johnson High School, including the game-winning touchdown in the final seconds against his old nemesis, "Spare Tire" Dixon.
WTF?😳
It weren't just the JEWS, JEHOVAH WITNESSES were persecuted before the Jews.
But hitters main focus were the Jews
Jew jew jew. What about the Romani s?
Or gays and disabled people
The Holocaust did not target any group other than the Jews.
Anne Frank was a transgendered, wheelchair bound Romani Jew
@@obediahpolkinghorniii564 wrong
@@bilalkurishingal3482 Right, according to the Nazis.
Are they still trying to sell this crap.
Yeah can you believe it!? It’s history guys! Forget about it! My pal Jenn here barely has space in her head for her kids names and whether or not you can eat crayons. She doesn’t have room for stories from our past!! She still has to figure out where the sun goes at night! There’s only so much room in her brain and most of its already full of celebrity gossip and racist jokes.
Yeah to ignorant bigots like you. I think your red hat is too tight
I thought this was gonna be about the shitty response to the pandemic. The future will look at how 1st world nations responded to the pandemic and see how it set us back half a century. Financially, racially, the division, civil rights, freedoms, trust, etc.
scamdemic used by radical democrats to push the not so great reset.
look to the semi fascist biden for satisfaction.
all part of the plan.
The 'pandemic' was a bioweapon that was deliberately released with the *intention* to sow chaos in the western world
@@Le_Dislike_Button the eastern world got pretty fucked up too.
@@forgivemylaughter collateral damage. It is no coincidence for the virus to be released on the Chinese New year, eight months prior to an extremely consequential presidential election which certain parties were planning to 'win' at all costs
They made up 6ft social distancing you muppet.
Sooooo... America quite literally furnished the bulk of the war against Imperial Japan and their war crimes and the war against the fascist forces in Europe. Nearly 420,000 American lives were lost in combat and the near economic ruin that America experienced to correct the poor way the European nations handled the closure of WW I and the Germans, having nearly 1/3 agreeing with Hitler, was apparently not enough of an effort by America? Yes, in hindsight we can always do more, but this quick snapshot of the "angle" pursued by this documentary seems a bit finger-wagging at America. I don't know, I have loved every Ken Burns documentary, though a little preachy in spots, they are always well done. I will still watch it, but I am unsure about this predetermined angle approach that he says they took. There is a reason historians don't go into research with their minds already made up, you can find evidence to support nearly any opinion. Hope I am wrong.
Keep thinking your point of view is the only correct one. Pretty soon people will be treating you like Mike lindell
If you've been to the us holocaust museum and got to the end, you would see photos taken by American planes of concentration camps. Photos taken by bombers that could have destroyed those facilities, their gas chambers and crematoria. There is no excuse. As a Jew who values being American, the fact that Americans allowed Jewish lives to be lost is important.
My Prussian Jewish Grandfather was brought to the US with his family on papers forged by his father. Otherwise they would have been killed in the concentration camps like most of his family. My grandfather also served in a front line field hospital in the US Army and was the only physician of the original eight to survive the war. One of the physicians he trained with lost it on their second concentration camp liberation and went for a short walk and put his 1911 in his mouth and went home. No one has seen the footage shot of the concentration camps at liberation, only the footage taken after a few days of clean up because it was that horrific. My grandfather thought the Soviets got at least one thing right, as they interrogated the SS camp staff and then shot them all...
What Ken Burns did was to doccument what I already knew growing up. That we could have done something, but since American Jews were so hated the government failed to act. Part of the Beauty of America is that we have taken refugees seeking a chance, as these refugees become some of the greatest patriots. Unfortunately this comments section is being hit by the neo-Nazis and Bigots. But to answer your question, we could have taken in refugees like the passengers of the St. Louis and we would have had more dedicated men in US uniform fighting the war. We also would not have had a shortage of translators if we took more of these refugees which would have significantly helped our war effort...
@@eliwhitehouse2104 this is what the OP is talking about. America wasn’t there to bomb concentration camps. We were there to win a war, and did, just barely. You don’t go bombing targets with no military significance. You bomb factories, airports, and even the cities to demoralize the people, but camps out side those areas? Even if you knew exactly what was going on there’s no point.
Wasn't it true ships carrying Jews to US ports were turned away in at least one incident
Open borders for everyone but them
Who's them bigot?
What is the name of this newscaster?
What has happened to us in this country? If we study our own history we find that we have always been ready to receive the unfortunates from other countries, and though this may seem a generous gesture on our part, we have profited a a thousand fold by what they have brought us.
- Eleanor Roosevelt
Eleanor Roosevelt was a subversive POS.
no we havent
@@chuck9483 You have though.
@@twt000 I meant we haven't profited from all of it. Only when the immigration was from Europe.
@@chuck9483 Everywhere. Maybe get out more. Pay attention to who is working. Not just white folks.
This is still happening today to different people in different parts of the world. People are disgusting.
Biden said the Uighyur concentration camps are just part of Xi’s culture
Ironically, in self proclaimed “beacon” of the ME where they are continuing a settler colonialism expansion Lmaoo I bet the documentary will make no mention of the migration there during Germany 1930-1945
😕 it's true. We are too aggressive a species to survive. Testosterone is the fatal curse, the original sin.
@@richiejohnson that ain’t it chief.
@@gooby1926 😕 Think about it. Why is there war? Why is there violence? Why are people "disgusting"?
Hint: it's not estrogen...
Wow, they’re really rewriting history now. We’re really living in some strange fucking times man.
Yep, the leftists at it again.
The liberal new world order is pure evil
@@HagiaFantasia democrats who want you to think they weren’t the party that were incredibly racist and now they hide it better
@@HagiaFantasia I would presume 'they' are the powers that be.
@@twinkle3026 The U.N.?
Unsealed wooden doors.
Wannsee Conference.
@@obediahpolkinghorniii564 If you only knew how dumb your response is. Go watch some more movies made by Jewish people.
@@johnabel5943 Why? You’re so much more entertaining, especially when you peddle Holocaust denial.
@@obediahpolkinghorniii564 Peddle? I'm not Jewish yaknow. The truth shouldn't cost anything. However, the chosen ones have made quite a lucrative business of their story. Haven't they? If I'm mistaken about the massive amounts of money that are doled out, owing to HC guilt by countries/peoples that had nothing to do with the alleged crimes, please let me know.
@@johnabel5943 How many people died in the Holocaust, and how many were Jewish?
Ken has a wealthy privliged outlook. His living room look like a billionaires home. Oh Hollywood you hurtful bunch
Shut up swine
Ken Burns never lets me down. Amazing documentary. May I also say that the timing of it's PBS release in conjunction with the immigration fiasco we're seeing today is not by sheer coincidence.
Interesting take, and you're entitled to your opinion. Mine would be Ken Burns is a left wing hack whose historical distortions and inaccuracies to frame his political narratives are tiresome, and all done in a rather blase style to boot. Even his non- political documentaries on baseball and jazz were terrible. We're in agreement on one thing though, and that's that the DNC propagandists at far left PBS made sure this was released right before the midterm elections. They know they're going to lose the House significantly and are doing everything they can to keep the Senate at 50-50. You bet your butt that was no coincidence.
Irresponsible open borders. We'll be paying the price for decades. Thanks, Brandon.
No policy has changed on the southern border since Trump's last days in office. But do whatever you think you need to because your still out of power after the midterms.
CHUMP 232 SPANKEDs mother was an illegal immigrant by his own standards he should self deport
@@ryanreedgibson 🎯
@@ryanreedgibson how many lies do you expect people to believe.
you are as corrupt as your master biden.
you are a fool and should be treated as such.
@@skankhunt3624
poor little sculking marxist.
no mention of gas chambers?
FDR called for an international conference and when it recessed, no one did anything.
We have people worse than that, here now.
They hate everyone..... Including themselves I think
Call out the actual people, groups and organizations that have and continue to promote this despicable hatred!!!
God damn democrats
MAGA republicans
The US government as a whole
The Trumplicans support a guy who led an attempt to overthrow democracy because he couldn't handle he lost
The democrats are too focus fighting the Trumplicans to realize we the people need humanity to unite against evil in modern day
@Donald Thorpe GOP
That would be progressive democrats
I just watched The Winds of War and War of remembrance on TH-cam. I know it’s a fictional account of historical events,but the filming & mixing of original footage is very good. Herman Wouk is the author.
The Memory Hole is an excellent resource
the one about Homeland Security?
He is also connected w the slave labor at Marth Stuarts vineyards
So that makes six million murders alright?
Read "the myth of German villainy", it will change your whole perspective.
Yeah. If your feeble, hate filled mind is susceptible to those lies. You’ve seen the concentration camp pictures. You’ve seen the survivors with numbered tattoos.
How can those things be anything other than pure evil?
Read the past 200 years of German philosophy, it’ll confirm German villainy lmao
@@Torgomasta
Ereget Raschi Erod.22 30
Baba Mezia 114b
Libbre David 37
Sabba Mecia 114,6.
Simeon Haddarsen, fol. 56-D.
Tosefta. Aboda 8, 5,
Schulchan Aruch, Jore Dia
@@patternrecon5271 Ezekiel 23:20.
It is an amazing book by a great author
And which party is trying to take your speech, your guns, and your fossil fuels?
The Supreme Court… which isn’t a party, but whose members tend to skew Republican.
@@obediahpolkinghorniii564 you must have your commiecrat head stuck up your commiecrat ass.
Ken back for some more shekels
Dollars, surely?
This is one example of why we must not let the anti-woke, anti-CRT crowd make it illegal to teach this kind of history. Burying these facts to keep people from feeling ‘guilty’ is idiotic, but we have elected a lot of idiots of late.
It's not illegal and teaching this kind of history is not CRT. You people are the most disingenuous group on the planet, but I guess as long as you get a like or two it doesn't matter if you're wrong or right, does it?
CRT is antiwhite, and so are you.
Nobody is trying to suppress this information
Then why isn’t the democrat controled dept of education pushing for this to be taught in school
CRT and Wokeness is a cancerous ideology that judges everyone based on skin color, sexuality and gender. It's literally for racists, bigots and sexists to covertly hide behind politically correct words and actions, using who they claim to fight for as a shield against any criticism.
Can't blame America for this since we did the best we can to save anyone. What about the rest of the world?
America is Babylon the Whore!
Them too. They were too afraid of Germany’s military might that they were willing to comply with their demands for the sake of their non-Jews.
@@aycc-nbh7289 what does Jew mean?
@@pipkinma According to the Nuremberg Laws, someone who was half ethnically Jewish who was engaged in a Jewish religious community, or someone who was more than half ethnically Jewish regardless of his religious affiliation, was considered a “Jew” and was subject to the atrocities of the Nazis.
@@aycc-nbh7289 it’s interesting that Jewish people say they are Jewish because of their mothers, when the Torah says you are an Israelite according to your fathers. If thy are supposedly GODD chosen people should they follow what GODS says or MAN?
Everyone should go back to where they came from. Running to a different country isn't the answer.
Bye
I agree either that or if they expect America to be their savior all the time they might as well give us their land.
Toodles
How sad this was.
Why does the context window ignore the many millions that died in the holocaust who weren't from a specific ethnic group that wrote the definition?
They’re the eternal victims
No one is being ignored. The Holocaust was the Nazis’ plan for the Jewish People. When gentiles died, it wasn’t part of the Final Solution.
Shhhh. Dont say the quiet part out loud. The holocaust is the most significant unifying event for jews around the world. It’s literally part of their identity. Its like they were 2 holocausts, one for the jews and the other for the rest.
Because they have a sense of superiority over the Gentiles. They get this sense of supremacy from their false notion that they are the "Chosen people of God" and they use the gullibility of the unthinking majority and their sense of guilt over the whole of cost and their (perceived) blame into buying their very imaginative survivor stories, donate to the charities in the name of the whole of cost (that miraculously finds their way into their own pockets), and send money to Israel because, once again.. They are the "Chosen people of God" and "those who bless Israel are surely blessed.".. and because.. "Never again!"
Example: You are called anti-Semitic if you dare to group the Js in with the overall number of 11 million “victims” of the whole of cost.
@@michaelwilliamson4759 …but don’t you realize, the term ‘Holocaust’, in relation to WW2, referred and refers exclusively to the ‘Final Solution to the Jewish Problem’? This is a matter of accurately describing the Nazis’ actions.
At the Wannsee Conference, the Final Solution was architected. It did not mention gentiles. The term ‘Holocaust’ - or Shoah - reflects the Nazis’ attempt to eradicate the Jewish People from the face of the earth.
If you use the term ‘Holocaust’ to refer to the Nazis’ other crimes, you’re missing the point of the Nazis’ plans and the consequences of those plans.
As for ‘chosen’, it has more to do with repairing the world (look up ‘Tikkun Olam’) and less to do with how a white supremacist would define ‘chosen’.
As for Israel, Israel is a country. I’m not sure how it’s relevant to the discussion of antisemitism.
Help me out here. Are you trying to sound as if you’ve read the Protocols of the Elders of Zion once too often?
Who cares.
Emotionally well-adjusted adults.
if you get thrown out of 109 bars, maybe you are the problem
But what if I am genuinely a good person, but all of the bouncers at those bars have problems with me because of my religion or race? Keep in mind that in this scenario, I’m genuinely a good person and have no desire to ruin anyone’s life.
@Israel Goldberg Please read the last sentence. By your logic, we should also continue to discriminate against those of African descent if the general attitude of doing so was more common than not several decades ago. By your logic, we should be free to discriminate against people of _your_ race or _your_ religion if enough people agree to do so.
I use that analogy all the time.
@@aycc-nbh7289 sounds like democrats
@@aycc-nbh7289 you’re missing the point of the post, it’s not BECAUSE of their race, it’s because of their behavior, you don’t make exemptions for behavior because of someone’s race.
What is past is prologue.
If you google "Voyage of the St-Louis" you will find how the US, Cuba, Mexico and Canada turned away a ship full so they had no choice but to go back to Europe. And if you google "1938 Conference on the International Refugee Problem in Evian, France" you wioll see that everyone recognized that there was a problem but no one was willing to do anything about it, even the leaders of the Jewish communities in the US waited until it was too late, the fact that they were trying to establish a Jewish state in Palestine may have something to do with it.
@@joebrewer4529 The holocaust began when the Germans invaded the USSR, before that there were measures taken to get the Jews to emigrate by making their lives more difficult but without violence, the 1935 Nuremberg Laws and the Transfer Agreement among others. Until then there were only enemies of the state in the camps and since US Jewish Organizations had declared war on Germany and called for an international boycott of all German goods on 24 March 1933, some in Germany were making as much trouble as possible while others were completely against the boycott so it is those trouble makers, the communists and the political opponents who first ended up in camps, they were indeed a threat to society and since a lot of them were Jewish, people outside of Germany may have thought the Jews were targeted but that was not the reason for the incarceration, not before 1941.
Rumours started in 1943 but no official confirmation, as soon as Roosevelt finally had confirmation he created The War Refugee Board on 22 January 1944 and opened the borders in August.
If you can tell me where I could see those newspapers I would appreciate.
Leuchter report!
Bullshit proven bullshit and he died a broken fool
The American response?
Jews were imprisoned in Oswego NY.
That was the response.
Imprisoned? It was a refugee camp.
Ken Burns didn't know when the Vietnam war ended in his earlier documentary.
In the 1920s - you can look them up on the Library of Congress site - there were ads explicity denying job applications to non-English-speaking people or to "No Irish wanted" (those attitude affected some of my ancestors).
I can understand an employer not wanting to have riled-up employees talking trash to his or her face and not knowing what was being said because the speakers did not or do not speak their language. There is a far cry between the worry over that, which can be obliterated by humane practices int he workplaces, and the explicit or implicit discrimination against any group that wants to work.
Also after 2 world wars against Germany, the large German-American population, which was, as Burns-Botstein-Novick wisely point out, was itself divided, caught Hell and has never really recovered.
In California in the 1930s they had signs that said “No dogs or Okies allowed”! Unbelievable. The only work was in a field if any.
Even the movie East Of Eden depicts how Germans and poor people were treated in glorious California.
NINA - no Irish need apply
A-ll B-ullshit C-hannel
Here is another angry, conservative white man who never gets laid...
Second highest number killed at Auschwitz were Catholics. Is that bullshit you stupid right wing swine?
Never built an altar with a golden calf !!
I dare anyone to go to the Jewish center in Jerusalem and talk about YESHUA CRISTO. hitler like persecution (maybe to death) will follow.
…No, we’ll just ask you to leave. I’ve seen it happen.
I'll tell you all what you tell us foundational black folk. "Ugh it was so long ago. Get over it!"
Difference is there’s still people alive today who saw the holocaust and even lived through it
@@toxicgamer6038 and there are people who saw Jim Crow and segregation and lynchings. So.
@@toxicgamer6038 and the Palestinians who are being ethnically cleansed by the said people who want to promote tolerance by settler colonialism. Lol the irony of these people
@@chavvy9074 So... Holocaust bad, Jim Crow bad? Yep.
@@chavvy9074 and it was the democrats who supported it
And you how many have you , already adopted? cmon maan , drop a number..
Now do one on the apartheid state of I S R A E L.
If not, why?
What are you talking about? Arab Israelis have the same rights as Jewish Israelis. They serve in the military, on the musical bench, and in the Knesset. They vote, they go where they want, they marry whom they want, and…
Ohh, you meant the West Bank. Right? Yeah, the residents were offered citizenship four times but the PA said no.
You should check out Final Account
This is going to be one really good pro-2nd Amendment documentary.
First thing Nazi’s did was restrict gun ownership and then finally outlawed gun ownership! A lot like the idiot in the WH and the rest of the Democratic morons are trying to do now! Freedom is precious but teeters on the precipice under Socialist and Fascist leadership!
No it won’t be. What the Germans did was slow and methodical. An armed Jewish population wouldn’t have been able to stave off what the Nazis did. Your gun won’t help you when many of your neighbors hate you or are too afraid to defend you.
How can you hold out in your home against the might of your own government and fellow citizens?
Think about that seriously for a moment.
@@rdear so you don’t think that a bunch of Jews being able to defend their homes and neighborhoods against nazis would’ve been a good thing? You don’t think they could’ve resisted being taken to ghettos? And then being taken out of those ghettos into camps?
@@chavvy9074 I think it would have been a great thing, but it just wasn’t possible. No matter how well armed they were.
Imaging thinking you could prevent the police from arresting you and dragging you off to jail because you’re armed.
You being armed and standing up against the government only works if your neighbors also defend you. That’s not how it was in Nazi germany.
There weren’t fortified, independent, self sufficient areas of Jewish citizens. They were intertwined and integrated into the county.
There weren’t large groups of them together until they were taken to the ghettos and forced to live in small cramped areas and I seriously doubt the Nazis would have let them keep their guns.
@@rdear imagine thinking people can’t fight for the good of themselves and their neighbors. I guess everybody needs to be saved. Taking down 1 officer with you does SOMETHING. And okay so no Jews lived in the same neighborhoods? I thought they were pretty segregated. They had their own businesses, neighborhoods, schools, etc there were absolutely places where they could’ve met and organized.
I still haven't received a reason why everyone hated the Jewish aside from after ww2 and the war between Israel and the Palestinians
Good look having someone explain it on TH-cam without it getting immediately deleted by the algorithm
Biblically it is because they are God's chosen race. Historically it is a very long answer, but I will give you a brief summary. By the time WW II came around antisemitism was a large case of the have and have nots and the socialist movements across Europe following the turn of the century. Now include they were unchristian in Christian lands, and many Germans blamed stereotypical greed for the poor conditions in Germany during WW I and the poor terms they received from the Treaty of Versailles. As for America, America hated even Catholics at this time in history. They hated any group that may bring foreign influence into their culture that could not or would not assimilate. Italian and German immigrants brought their prejudices over from Europe in the mid-1800s and again in the first half of the 20th century. So there was a massive amount of European baggage entering the borders, regardless of how America wanted to perceive the forced assimilation measures instituted by Theodore Roosevelt. You also had the money and cultural influences of Hollywood at the time, where many major studios were being created, owned, or purchased by people with Jewish backgrounds. This is one reason J. Edgar was so distrustful of them. Disney disliked them for this reason as well. Henry Ford and other venture capitalists around the globe feared that the Jewish money could buy political favor more readily and their ties with the European unionization also created an atmosphere of distrust. As I said the answer is quite lengthy, and these are only some of the reasons most of the western world was anti-semitic in the 19th and 20th centuries.
Psychologically is also quite simple. If you want to see people enraged, or turn against their neighbor let them be in or near the majority and then present a threat to them. The more precise you can be with how to identify the threat the more extreme the majority will turn. The German and Soviet propaganda machines knew this all too well. Same as our political leaders in the west know it today. Hope this answers your question.
Because some global conspiracy says they control everything and are secretly some mafia organization that prides itself on sexual assault. It’s like saying that all black dogs should be banned because one of them bit someone or that one needs a new car every time one runs out of gas.
@@aycc-nbh7289 agreed it just sounds like losers looking for someone to blame kind of like politicians who blame losses on fraud
USS Liberty, 911, open borders, gun control, LGBTQ agenda, etc
The professional victim strikes again...
“But her emails…”
@@obediahpolkinghorniii564 russia collusion 🤡🤡🤡
We coulda shoulda done more
Are you serious the holocaust there’s so much going on right now sheesh
You forgot.
You must know, THEY are the only victims in the world. Nobody else...
This ties today to that period.
Except you did it again.
My former boss was a holocaust survivor. She watched her father, brother, and uncles murdered for refusing to join Hitler's army. The youngest brother was six and he was shot for the hell of it. Three days later she, her mother and two sisters were taken to the concentration camps. She never saw her mother again. One other sister survived. She met and married an American soldier. She came to the U.S. and together they raised a beautiful family. I never knew why she always wore long sleeves until I was standing next to her one day and she reached for a patients chart and her sleeve slipped up her arm. There were the numbers they tattooed on her when she was thrown into that horrible camp. The Jewish people are NOT our enemies, yet we have crap like this that is following Hitler's ideology.
Hitlers father was Jewish. Hitler wanted a pure white race an was confused why Jewish Converts wanted to be BLACK.
So Hitler was trying to force your Jewish teacher's Jewish parents to join his army?
Do you think guarding the border is racist? Do you think keeping millions of convicted felons out of the country is the same as being a racist Nazi sympathiser?
What crap? How about you stay quiet on Jewish matters?
@@impeachbiden2398 this imbecile is everywhere 😂
The US State Dept knew. They have a habit of not rescuing others--even their own citizens--Jonestown.
See: Benghazi
They didn't teach us this in High School.
CANT LET HISTORY REPEAT ITSELF
SAVE AMERICA FROM CHUMP 232 SPANKED
*TRUMP20TOLIFE* 🇺🇲
And if DiSantis and the other MAGA Fascists have their way, they never will. They’ve already started banning books and dehumanizing minorities and immigrants.
because American history classes are the equivalent of a Law and Order episode.
Hero Washed lies to make you feel proud to be an American.
But find no pride, because your country has done worse to innocent people.
Southern state?
21% of Americans are illiterate, 54% read and write below a 6th grade level, I would be surprised if they taught you to write your own name in high school.
so what? now they want reparations from america too?
😂😂😂😂crazy timed
We were in the middle of a war and there was no way we could have gotten them out of occupied Europe!!!
The document you showed was from 1942 and Hitler had a firm hold on Europe.
I would love to know what they are implying we could have done.
In the words of the new captain America: do better
Join sooner?
Oy vey! We could have sent our best plastic surgeons so they could blend in better like they do today.
@@generaleerelativity9524 You're jealous.
@@obediahpolkinghorniii564 we wanted nothing to do with Europes problems due to the consequences we had to deal with from the first time we helped with Europe’s problems (WWI).
You might also say we had other things to worry about! Japan, Russia who is going to get the bomb first!
FDR dragged his feet getting the US involved in WW2, as US had a policy after WW1 of “Laissez-faire” which in context was US not interfering in European issues.
Churchill begged him on numerous occasions to join the war. FDR refused, but Japan changed all that as Ben Affleck so brilliantly re created for us..lol!!
That's true but they did send supplies like we're doing it now to the Ukraine. If we didn't, Britain would've been talking German by now. Also on Japan, it has something to do of them not getting enough ' oil ' in their country. That's what I heard.
th-cam.com/video/so4v_2zq35k/w-d-xo.html
But they shouldn't done that in the first place since someone mentioned that
' they woke up the sleeping giant.'
Alias: the birth of Godzilla.
Well... not exactly... although on the books the us wasn't involved they loaned out a lot of money to the allies. Not to mention gave them arms with the loaned money working as payment. FDR also tried to diplomatically stop tensions in asia by cutting off oil to japan. Which caused japan to launch a suprise attack to seize the resource rich colonies in south east Asia. Although the US public was very against another war fdr saw hitler for what he was
@@pako5586 excellent context..but your comment seems to have got deleted?
@@its_rick_james_bich2575 TH-cam’s algorithm is based on popularity, not truth, I guess.
@@obediahpolkinghorniii564 hence why I added Ben Affleck into my comment 👍🏽
So sick of all the negativity.
Uh oh sounds like someone got their feelings hurt.
YES! We see it, and were taught about it in HS (whether we remember is different) about the similarities bet the race issue in the 60''s, compared to Europe in the 30's vs the issues now. But the Black community doesn't remember it. They don't remember that the Jews stood shoulder to shoulder with the black community and MLK, and that is a travesty. I hope this film touches on it as we can still do something about it NOW!!!
I remember the Jews and White Americans, marching with the Civil Rights Movement. Some of them lost their lives. And I'm a Black woman, who marched with Hosea Williams, in Savannah, Georgia.
I remember how conservatives opposed civil rights, and still do to this day.
@@barbram8001 What do you mean by White Americans? I was speaking of the American Jews who stood with the Black community in the 1960's when they were marching for civil rights together. All were Americans.
NO MORE WOKE.🐑
@@skankhunt3624 ignorant.
the democrats are the slave owners fool.
learn history smooth brain.
But please don't teach CRT! OMG (sarcasm). Our children should know these details so that they are prepared to defend this from ever happening again!!!!
I’m not overly fond of Marxist ideologies such as CRT, given Marx’s antisemitic beliefs, but it beats Holocaust denial.
@@obediahpolkinghorniii564
But... Marx is a J himself...
@@michaelwilliamson4759 A self-hating Jew, you say…? I’m as shocked as you are. Meanwhile, Marx argued that the only way to end class warfare was to eradicate the Jews. Shame, eh?
Hail Brandon, FJB!
Americans have always been 4chan
What about America’s response to the vaccine Holocaust?
There was no vaccine Holocaust! Fucking morons. Do you know entire families that were wiped out because of the vaccine!? Of course you don’t. You don’t know a single person who died from complications because there were so few. D
Actual fucking idiot
You mean, when a million people died from a mishandled epidemic...? As I recall, vaccines were made available, mask mandates were imposed, and people were too stupid to act in their own best interest.
Go eat your red hat
Black Captain America: DO BETTER
A lot more people died from slavery right here in America!!!
Malaria killed even more.
You are really stupid to make that demonstrably false claim like that.
Roughly around 400,000 Africans were brought to N. America, and there were around 4,000,000 freed slaves after the war. It certainly doesn't make the case for that claim at all.
But where’s the Slavery museum? There are holocaust museums scattered all across the major cities in the US, but no slavery museums presented in that same exact manner….
@@velocirshtr3756 I used my favorite search engine and found five. Would you like directions?
@@obediahpolkinghorniii564 Get an Uber and visit each one.
bro pause-
Ken burns a goat I love his documentary series
I don’t watch anything bs point of view from Burns.
Your loss. I guess you are only receptive to things that support your ignorant views. How toddler of you...
Then why'd you comment on this?????????
We did more than enough but we really should have stayed out of it.
Nothing has changed
enough of talking about the Jews enough crying and complaining there is a lot of suffering all over the world and precautions not just the Jews they survived anyway good for them enough of that it becomes politically motivated subject to gain influence and power by making the world feel sorry for them using the history to achieve a lot of power and support
A fake history at that.
it’s only a documentary. If you don’t want to watch it, don’t watch it. Stop whining.
Jesus wasn't a Christian after all ...