So sad to hear that people aren’t liking their palettes! Hearing that they quality is inconsistent is really disappointing. That being said, this is one of the first palettes to make me feel excited about makeup in a while and I’m so happy I own it. I love the formula and feel so inspired!
I got my palette back in November. Even then it was frustrating how the whole situation was. I can’t imagine people just getting their palettes now! I do have to say that I really enjoy using the palette though. It’s definitely worth the wait, but Chloe really needs to rethink how she does these pre orders.
I adore my palette and the formula! The shimmers work beautifully and I love how the mattes can apply nice and opaquely and I had no issues blending. I think it's one of my favourite matte formulas. I think Betty Jean killed it with the colour story and I'm happy for her. I was overjoyed when I got mine.
I am so happy that you got this palette finally! Mine is awesome the quality is great the pigments are mind blowing. The palette was so worth the wait and Love Chloe the owner she is beyond sweet Love Beautbean!
I got my palette recently and was sadly disappointed :'( I could not get the mattes to work for me and I am pretty used to working with colorful shadows with high pigmentation. The periwinkle blue went on one color and as soon as I touched it or tried to blend it it turned a completely different color, it was so strange (almost reminded me of the issues people had with the original formula of abh subculture). And then the deep plum color is basically unusable for me. It turns grey and muddy on the eye immediately and does not layer well with the other colors. The two matte greens work fine, but nothing to write home about. I'm glad that you had a good experience with the palette, I wish I felt the same way because I LOVE the color story and Betty-Jean!
I snagged one of the initial palettes and to this day it’s my #1 favorite palette ever, not just of 2020-2021. Every single shadow performs amazingly. Every one. So worth the wait for me. For the first 4-6 weeks after getting it, it was all I used everyday. The obsession was real! Even if I’m not using the palette as a stand alone every day now I still pull it out weekly for a deepening up shade or an inner corner highlight, etc. I cannot say enough good things about “It’s Freakin’ Bats”! 😊 ❤️
That was really nice of your subscriber let you purchase the palette from her. I love this palette so much! I know so many people who want this so she needs to hurry and restock.
I loveeee this palette. I have heard other people fans of the brand didn't like it because the formula is a bit different than usual, but I'm really happy with mine. You created a beautiful look btw!
Love the look and your excitement! Even though I was in the very very last batch of orders to be sent out I still couldn't contain my excitement when I finally received my palette too. Apparition is one of the prettiest duochrome shimmers I've ever seen. FYI, Sam and Zero are switched in your palette but I think they are magnetic so you can switch them to their rightful spots :)
I hope you got a good palette! Mine is a dud for all the mattes. All the mattes are not mixed well - so much you can see different spots of color in them.
To be fair I emailed them and they did offer to replace but having waited 4 or 5 months at that point I'm just writing the brand off as a loss. I'm not alone in the palette quality I received either
@@AmyLovesMakeup they wanted me to mail the original palette back first (even after I provided photos of how the eyeshadows looked). I just never got around to sending the palette back because I just put it on the back burner yanno. So no replacement.
I love my palette. The mattes were a bit of a learning curve for me at first, I was using too large of a blending brush and the pigment was going way further than I wanted. But after adjusting my brush and technique it works great. 💚💙💜
Loved your video as always Amy! I got my palette late may and can honestly say it wasn’t worth the wait. Color story is gorgeous that I can’t deny but I also find the shimmers to fall a little flat. I still like it enough to keep it but would never recommend someone to run an get it. As for the experience ordering from the brand it was terrible. And all the customers that got their palette early on didn’t have the misfortune of dealing with the lies, the lack of transparency or at many times lack of communication. And I have no problem waiting for a product so as long as there’s complete transparency and communication. Also i think you rock green looks 💖 at the end of the day I know it’s up to each individuals preference to determine if something is worth spending their money on of course 😉
Betty-Jean said it would be available as long as people wanted it! If you follow Shroud on IG or are on their mailing list, they’ve been really great about keeping everyone in the loop. I’m sure you’ll be able to grab it!! I adore mine! 😊
Shroud said it's not going to do preorders again that once they are fully done with these preorders when they reopen they will have a huge restock so it can ship once it's purchased and then when it sales out this time people will just have to wait on a restock but they plan on stocking tons when they reopen
I honestly haven't really heard or watched anyone that had a bad thing to say about this palette and I hands down still stand by my original opinion...this was the best collab and palette that was released at the time and the quality is just amazing. This is my favorite palette in my collection. I'm so happy you have it, Amy!
I agree. I have zero issues with mine. And I'm not just saying that Betty Jean is one of my favorite content creators. I think she did an excellent job with the color story. I just feel bad that the launch didn't go as well as it could have.
This is one of my all time favorite palettes and I have A LOT. The color story is right up my alley and I have no issues with the formula or blend or anything of that nature. I did the pre-order right when they announced it after it sold out. I didn't get mine till March and I didn't mind at all! All I cared about was I knew I'd eventually get it lol I try to be really understanding when it comes to indie brands especially when they didn't have any idea how high of a demand there was going to be. I got updated very frequently which was nice. It's worth the hype in my opinion 💚
Hi Amy. This is a lovely palette. I never thought I'd be into the neon green but I found a single in my stash. & started wearing it. It's really nice. Your look turned out really stunning. Have a great day.
I love the idea and color story of this palette. I've only used mine twice because I'm having issues thinking of looks to make. The shimmers/metallics are also just very lackluster for me. They remind me of clionadhs regular shimmer shades and they are just super dull on the eye. Someone else in the comments said they are more like satins and I completely agree. I will use the mattes but I'll be bringing in my own shimmers from my singles
I got one of the hand pressed ones in the initial preorder and I can work with the mattes fine, they are very pigmented so they don't blend that easily but they are workable. I find them similar to Menagerie's mattes in that way. I love the colours of the shimmers but I don't find the shine very impactful, I prefer a sparkly shimmer like Kaleidos or Oden's Eye to a subtle satin finish. The best thing about this palette is the colour story, in my opinion. Betty Jean did a great job choosing the colours. I wouldn't buy from Shroud again based on the customer experience, but I like the palette. Just makes it tough to recommend to people.
The metallics are def not my type of metallics either. I prefer sparkly finishes and high shine and shrouds are very dull on the eye. They remind me of clionadhs regular shimmer/metallic formula which I also don't like because they are dull on the eyes (I'm pretty sure I've got a dupe or two between clionadhs alchemy collection and the metallics in this palette)
Loved your video! Would love to see some more looks with this one. The reason "Apparition" sounds funny is because you're switching the first "i" with an "a" sound
I really appreciate this video! I love Shroud's formula and missed out on this and the Arcana palette. A lot going on atm but I plan on picking both up when I settle down if they're available
The co!it's in the palette look so pretty. I missed out on the launch and wasn't able to get it when it first released. The look you did is beautiful. You have been my inspiration to try more colorful looks and slowly break away from my neutrals.
I'm surprised that some people don't like this palette. I found it super easy to work with, the colour story is PHENOMENAL, and it's easily one of my favourite palettes in my collection (I have a weakness for purples and greens for sure)!!
Amy, you created such a fun and cute look with this palette. (: I'm excited for the restock. With their email messages, they said a restock is coming soon mid-June or next month. I will definitely pick this one up. Thank you for the swatches as well. 💛
I missed out on this palette but I really liked Shroud's formula in their Creepy Cute palette. The color story on the Batz palette is super cute tho! That green almost tempted me lol
I love my palette for the shimmers! Unfortunately, I couldn’t get the mattes to not be patchy on me regardless of whether I set my primer or not! But the colour story is so unique that I still love it, beautbean did such a good job curating the colours ☺️
I love this look! I received my palette in March; I love the color story, and the quality of all the shades imo is great. For me it was definitely worth the wait!😊❤️
The colour story and theme are so freakin' cute! Some of the reviews make me a bit wary but I think I'm going to take the risk and get the next pre-order. It's just so original/fun/my aesthetic 💜💚🖤
I have it! Yeah it kinda sucked to not get my Halloween palette until April but I did sign up for that when I placed the preorder with the owner’s caveat that she didn’t know when she could ship so I can’t complain. I do absolutely love the color story and the quality of the palette and I don’t mind the thick metallics, they remind me a bit of the Sydney Grace metallics with that same density. The mattes are amazing.
I wonder if the people that have had problems with their mattes was some of the 1st batch that was pressed with a machine? My palette was one of the ones pressed with the machine but it wasn't the 1st batch I didn't get mine until April I think maybe 1st of May
This pallette is sold out, but I did find two similar pallettes. Juvias the Magic pallette and Lurella On the Edge pallette. They are beautiful as well. 😉
I waited 6 months to receive a 9 pans palette for the first time in my life & I love it with my entire heart ❤️, the mattes blend themselves & the metallics are such a dream ! Even though you said they’re a thicker ones I think I love that too specially with the insane shifts that they have !!! I can’t decide which shade is my favorite because they’re all my favorite starting from : spooky, trapa, Sam, handbook , zero, apparition, grim , Adams & Derry 😂
I was not able to get this one but I did a BYOP on the Lethal site and duped this magical color story! It just came in yesterday and I haven't been able to put it down!
My husband just gave me this palette as a gift and I absolutely love it! The color story is so beautiful and the mattes blend together really well (even Derry into Trapa) I hope you love the palette! 💜💜💜
I received mine back in March (I think). I loooove the color story! I had some trouble with Spooky fading when I blended, but other than that I enjoyed the quality. I'll definitely bring it back out in the fall!
Good morning Amy! Missed your face! Excited to watch this! I wasn't able to get my hands on this, but I'm sure I will in the future 😊💜💚 Love your channel ❤ Hope you are having an amazing week
Love mine! I'm not as talented as you are, but I'm pleased with what I come up with!😁 I made it into the initial launch and received mine the end of November.
It’s crazy how people’s opinions are so polarizing on this palette! I think it’s one of the most high quality palettes in my collection. The only shadow that I had some issues with was the periwinkle but I used the ABH primer with it and didn’t really have issues. I used the pack and blend method. I barely touch the shimmers and it’s pigment for days! The mattes are so buttery. I think Betty Jean is a talented and wonderful influencer, but I don’t watch her much these days due to lack of time and me watching other influencers more who focus on a different style of content. Therefore I’m not biased in liking this palette just for the person behind it. I think there’s inconsistencies with production and I wish everyone was able to get the high quality palette I got. 😕
This palette is probably my favorite Shroud palette, and definitely my favorite collab palette (I think it's my only collab, lol). The wait was long, but I was OK with it. I do wish that the launch went better for Betty Jean, as I think it took away from the incredible joy she had felt. It's sad to see that the formula seems to be inconsistent. My palette is fine, although I don't know if I got a hand-pressed one vs a machine pressed one.
I love certain shades in this palette, but I don’t like the overall color story together, so I wonder if Shroud plans to release them as singles in the future like they’ve done with previous non-collab palettes. Even if they did though, I don’t think I’d get them for a long time, given how chaotic this launch went.
I’ve had this palette for awhile but haven’t gotten around to using it. I’m kind of worried that I’m not going to like it. I’ve seen a lot of people say they don’t like it. I know that they didn’t hand press all of the palettes so maybe that’s why some people don’t like it? I completely understand why they got the machine to press the pigments, I just can’t help but wonder if it’s different from the first ones. I have to try find mine. I’m still unpacking my apartment, my makeup area is a mess! Love the look you did!
I received one of the machine pressed ones, and the palette that I got had no compromise in the quality or pressing. Chloe made sure that her new machine was calibrated to mimic the hand pressed ones, and BeautBean gave her approval before manufacturing commenced. Now whether this is consistent across all the remaining ones in the preorder I have no idea, but I can only say the one I got is the same, rich, pigmented quality as all the other Shroud Cosmetics palettes and singles I own. 🙂
@@SH-wk6po Thank you! I think a lot of people aren’t used to Indy brands or the quality and pigment most of them have. I haven’t seen any videos of anyone disliking this palette. It was comments on posts from Instagram. I’m excited to try mine now.
Seeing the comments I guess I was lucky with the quality. mine works very well, and the shimmers are super pigmented even without glitter glue. honestly one of the best quality palettes that I own (though truly I don't own many lol)
It was not worth the wait. The quality was okay, especially considering these colors are difficult to produce. However, it was not worth a 6 month wait. In the interim the Angelica X Kaleidos palette launched successfully, and now the Annette X Menagerie palette has launched, and between them and my existing collection, I have this color story. This palette is still displayed in the glass case of my vanity, and I would have your collab there too if not for the controversy, but I do not think this was worth the delay which did result in uncertainty as to where my money had gone as this was my first experience with this brand.
What is the small flat brush that you used on the inner half of your bottom lashline and in the tearduct area? I'm on the hunt for smaller-than-usual shader brushes.
Hi Amy! I don't know if you'll see this at all. I left a comment I'm not proud of in a previous video you uploaded (I don't even remember which one, it was actually months ago, I only remember that I came across like a jerk in hindsight). I wanted to apologise for that today. Thank you for your videos! You're an inspiration!
I honestly don’t remember the comment but I appreciate you. We all have those days and sometimes with written text it’s hard to see the full picture. Thank you for watching ❤️❤️
I have this palette, I have mixed feelings about it, I think the mattes are excellent but the metallics are just not my favorites, not intense enough. I really like my metallics molten like the Kaleidos formula or very glittery and sparkly, these to me are almost satin, which is not my preference, I just have to use toppers to intensify them.
@@AmyLovesMakeup I'm going to try them with glitter primer, cause I think I've only wet them. I only used this palette a couple of times *shame, shame, shame* I'll pull it out today 😜
i felt like the quality of this palette was okay.., the shimmers were much thicker than I expected. the main problem I had with it was the 6. month. wait. I ordered the palette on the first launch and only just got my palette in March. I know that they got a lot more orders than they anticipated, but wow. by the time I got it and saw the shimmers were not to my liking and the mattes blend a little weird, I was SO disappointed. one of my most disappointing purchases ever which sucks because I love the colors and the theme.
If you all want this palette, I could name dupes for these shades with Give Me Glow and other indie brands. I would never give Shroud my money after how they’ve botched this launch and handled everything.
I love Beautbean and the palette is nice enough, but for all the good things I’d heard ab the formula I expected more tbh. :/ I got it to work but it was way more effort than I’m used to, especially the matte shades re: Patchiness and fallout
This was my first time trying shroud and I struggled heavily with this formula. The mattes are so hard to build up and then they blend away. I couldn't build it up on the eye without it looking uneven. Disappointing because the color story is gorgeous. The shimmers are nice, but not that unique?
@@AmyLovesMakeup yeah. I wonder if the difference is from the palettes that were hand pressed vs the palettes that were pressed with the pressing machine.
i have to say i adore the color story but sadly the shimmers just dont do it for me anymore, they almost appear flat compared to most of my others shimmers in my collection. but i love the color story enough to still keep the palette.
sadly, i was disappointed in the palette🙁 spooky and derry are sooo patchy that i hate my look if i ever use them in my crease/outer corner. since i was most excited about those shades it bums me out
You’re the cutest omg! I adore this look & I’m so glad you had fun with it! I was so excited to see this on my feed!
Thank you 💙💙
So sad to hear that people aren’t liking their palettes! Hearing that they quality is inconsistent is really disappointing. That being said, this is one of the first palettes to make me feel excited about makeup in a while and I’m so happy I own it. I love the formula and feel so inspired!
That’s weird some people didn’t like this palette. I think it’s good. The whole pre-order debacle was bad, but the palette is well done.
I got my palette back in November. Even then it was frustrating how the whole situation was. I can’t imagine people just getting their palettes now! I do have to say that I really enjoy using the palette though. It’s definitely worth the wait, but Chloe really needs to rethink how she does these pre orders.
Not gonna lie, the first day I used this palette, I used every dang shade. One of the prettiest color stories I own
You and me both 😂
I adore my palette and the formula! The shimmers work beautifully and I love how the mattes can apply nice and opaquely and I had no issues blending. I think it's one of my favourite matte formulas.
I think Betty Jean killed it with the colour story and I'm happy for her. I was overjoyed when I got mine.
I am so happy that you got this palette finally!
Mine is awesome the quality is great the pigments are mind blowing. The palette was so worth the wait and Love Chloe the owner she is beyond sweet Love Beautbean!
It's so fun and pretty. I hope they eventually release these shades as singles! 💜💙💚
I got my palette recently and was sadly disappointed :'( I could not get the mattes to work for me and I am pretty used to working with colorful shadows with high pigmentation. The periwinkle blue went on one color and as soon as I touched it or tried to blend it it turned a completely different color, it was so strange (almost reminded me of the issues people had with the original formula of abh subculture). And then the deep plum color is basically unusable for me. It turns grey and muddy on the eye immediately and does not layer well with the other colors. The two matte greens work fine, but nothing to write home about. I'm glad that you had a good experience with the palette, I wish I felt the same way because I LOVE the color story and Betty-Jean!
Wow that’s so strange 😔
That sux I haven't had any issues with my mattes at all the blue periwinkle works amazing for me
I was in the original pre-order and my palette is great! I love how smooth and beautiful the shadows are.
I love this palette !!! To me it was worth the long, long,long,long wait lol. So happy you got it!
Im glad you’re enjoying yours 😊
I snagged one of the initial palettes and to this day it’s my #1 favorite palette ever, not just of 2020-2021. Every single shadow performs amazingly. Every one. So worth the wait for me. For the first 4-6 weeks after getting it, it was all I used everyday. The obsession was real! Even if I’m not using the palette as a stand alone every day now I still pull it out weekly for a deepening up shade or an inner corner highlight, etc. I cannot say enough good things about “It’s Freakin’ Bats”! 😊 ❤️
That was really nice of your subscriber let you purchase the palette from her. I love this palette so much! I know so many people who want this so she needs to hurry and restock.
I love using all the metallic shades as quick one shadow looks.
Zéro and Sam are switched in your palette ;)
I was wondering if I was crazy haha, so glad you pointed it out
Oop I didn’t even notice!! I’ll have to fix that 😂
I was thinking that too 😂 because I know that I love the icy green shade in the center 👌🏾🤤
i was gonna say lol Thank you
I am so excited that you used every single shade and it looks as amazing as it does😍💚💜
I want this palette SOOOO bad!!! The color story is amazing!
I loveeee this palette. I have heard other people fans of the brand didn't like it because the formula is a bit different than usual, but I'm really happy with mine. You created a beautiful look btw!
Love the look and your excitement! Even though I was in the very very last batch of orders to be sent out I still couldn't contain my excitement when I finally received my palette too. Apparition is one of the prettiest duochrome shimmers I've ever seen. FYI, Sam and Zero are switched in your palette but I think they are magnetic so you can switch them to their rightful spots :)
I hope you got a good palette! Mine is a dud for all the mattes. All the mattes are not mixed well - so much you can see different spots of color in them.
To be fair I emailed them and they did offer to replace but having waited 4 or 5 months at that point I'm just writing the brand off as a loss. I'm not alone in the palette quality I received either
The shimmery colors ARE very nicely made though in my palette
Im sorry to hear that. Did they never sent the replacement then?
@@AmyLovesMakeup they wanted me to mail the original palette back first (even after I provided photos of how the eyeshadows looked). I just never got around to sending the palette back because I just put it on the back burner yanno. So no replacement.
Trappa is probably my favorite shadow in my collection!
Very pretty with your glorious red hair!
I love my palette. The mattes were a bit of a learning curve for me at first, I was using too large of a blending brush and the pigment was going way further than I wanted. But after adjusting my brush and technique it works great. 💚💙💜
I loooooove my Bats palette!!! Definitely worth the wait to me.
Loved your video as always Amy! I got my palette late may and can honestly say it wasn’t worth the wait. Color story is gorgeous that I can’t deny but I also find the shimmers to fall a little flat. I still like it enough to keep it but would never recommend someone to run an get it. As for the experience ordering from the brand it was terrible. And all the customers that got their palette early on didn’t have the misfortune of dealing with the lies, the lack of transparency or at many times lack of communication. And I have no problem waiting for a product so as long as there’s complete transparency and communication. Also i think you rock green looks 💖 at the end of the day I know it’s up to each individuals preference to determine if something is worth spending their money on of course 😉
JEALOUS! I want this to restock so bad!
I definitely wanted this but was too late to the game. Hopefully there’s multiple preorder times so I can catch it.
Betty-Jean said it would be available as long as people wanted it! If you follow Shroud on IG or are on their mailing list, they’ve been really great about keeping everyone in the loop. I’m sure you’ll be able to grab it!! I adore mine! 😊
Shroud said it's not going to do preorders again that once they are fully done with these preorders when they reopen they will have a huge restock so it can ship once it's purchased and then when it sales out this time people will just have to wait on a restock but they plan on stocking tons when they reopen
@@amandawright9790 thank you! That’s good to know.
I have this pallete and i think it's amazing! So worth the hype and the waiting . I'm having so much fun with this pallete.
I could watch your vids forever! Love your creativity very inspiring.
I honestly haven't really heard or watched anyone that had a bad thing to say about this palette and I hands down still stand by my original opinion...this was the best collab and palette that was released at the time and the quality is just amazing. This is my favorite palette in my collection. I'm so happy you have it, Amy!
I agree. I have zero issues with mine. And I'm not just saying that Betty Jean is one of my favorite content creators. I think she did an excellent job with the color story. I just feel bad that the launch didn't go as well as it could have.
The spooky shade didn’t work for me at all. Maybe people aren’t saying anything because they don’t want to upset Beautbean
@@CASSIE_COLE Betty-Jean is a sweetheart and I don't think she'd be upset but more sad for people if it didn't work.
Love your stunning eye look! I really hope to purchase the palette in the next restock. I’ve been drooling over it for a while now.
I'd love a video on how to clean a pallette to pass along. How do you get shadows ready for resale? Or a gently used gift...
This is one of my all time favorite palettes and I have A LOT. The color story is right up my alley and I have no issues with the formula or blend or anything of that nature. I did the pre-order right when they announced it after it sold out. I didn't get mine till March and I didn't mind at all! All I cared about was I knew I'd eventually get it lol I try to be really understanding when it comes to indie brands especially when they didn't have any idea how high of a demand there was going to be. I got updated very frequently which was nice. It's worth the hype in my opinion 💚
I am definitely picking it up when it restocks!
This pallet is stunning I’ve never heard of it. I would use every color in the pallet if I had it .
Hi Amy.
This is a lovely palette.
I never thought I'd be into the neon green but I found a single in my stash. & started wearing it. It's really nice. Your look turned out really stunning.
Have a great day.
I love the idea and color story of this palette. I've only used mine twice because I'm having issues thinking of looks to make. The shimmers/metallics are also just very lackluster for me. They remind me of clionadhs regular shimmer shades and they are just super dull on the eye. Someone else in the comments said they are more like satins and I completely agree. I will use the mattes but I'll be bringing in my own shimmers from my singles
Most unique palette released in the last 6+months and the palette I have major FOMO over. Definitely picking this up on a restock.
Thank you so much for posting this palette I got mine towards the end of May!!!
I got one of the hand pressed ones in the initial preorder and I can work with the mattes fine, they are very pigmented so they don't blend that easily but they are workable. I find them similar to Menagerie's mattes in that way. I love the colours of the shimmers but I don't find the shine very impactful, I prefer a sparkly shimmer like Kaleidos or Oden's Eye to a subtle satin finish. The best thing about this palette is the colour story, in my opinion. Betty Jean did a great job choosing the colours. I wouldn't buy from Shroud again based on the customer experience, but I like the palette. Just makes it tough to recommend to people.
The metallics are def not my type of metallics either. I prefer sparkly finishes and high shine and shrouds are very dull on the eye. They remind me of clionadhs regular shimmer/metallic formula which I also don't like because they are dull on the eyes (I'm pretty sure I've got a dupe or two between clionadhs alchemy collection and the metallics in this palette)
Loved your video! Would love to see some more looks with this one. The reason "Apparition" sounds funny is because you're switching the first "i" with an "a" sound
I’m so glad you got this palette. I love mine.
I really appreciate this video! I love Shroud's formula and missed out on this and the Arcana palette. A lot going on atm but I plan on picking both up when I settle down if they're available
The co!it's in the palette look so pretty. I missed out on the launch and wasn't able to get it when it first released. The look you did is beautiful. You have been my inspiration to try more colorful looks and slowly break away from my neutrals.
I love your content! I just bought since it came back in stock! ❤️❤️❤️
Ive been enjoying this palette
SO STUNNING
I used mine today lol. My favorite shades are Spooky, Zero, Apparition, and Sam. They’re so unique to me.
Green REALLY is your color Amy!! Beautiful 💚
I'm surprised that some people don't like this palette. I found it super easy to work with, the colour story is PHENOMENAL, and it's easily one of my favourite palettes in my collection (I have a weakness for purples and greens for sure)!!
Amy, you created such a fun and cute look with this palette. (: I'm excited for the restock. With their email messages, they said a restock is coming soon mid-June or next month. I will definitely pick this one up. Thank you for the swatches as well. 💛
I missed out on this palette but I really liked Shroud's formula in their Creepy Cute palette. The color story on the Batz palette is super cute tho! That green almost tempted me lol
I love my it’s freackin bats palette 🖤 I’m so happy you have found one too ☺️ Enjoy !!
The matte formula isn’t as good as I thought it’d be, but the colors are so unique I’m dealing with it lol. Spooky and trapa are my fave colors!
Yasss! I love these small brands coming out with more makeup. So beautiful 😍💖💗♥💕❤
I love my palette for the shimmers! Unfortunately, I couldn’t get the mattes to not be patchy on me regardless of whether I set my primer or not! But the colour story is so unique that I still love it, beautbean did such a good job curating the colours ☺️
I love this look! I received my palette in March; I love the color story, and the quality of all the shades imo is great. For me it was definitely worth the wait!😊❤️
Haven't watched the video yet but I have it and it's 100% worth the hype. The formula is amazing. Pigment is insane. Excited to see your reaction!
I love mine so much :) its the only eyeshadow pallete I’ve gotten this year.
The colour story and theme are so freakin' cute!
Some of the reviews make me a bit wary but I think I'm going to take the risk and get the next pre-order. It's just so original/fun/my aesthetic 💜💚🖤
I have it! Yeah it kinda sucked to not get my Halloween palette until April but I did sign up for that when I placed the preorder with the owner’s caveat that she didn’t know when she could ship so I can’t complain. I do absolutely love the color story and the quality of the palette and I don’t mind the thick metallics, they remind me a bit of the Sydney Grace metallics with that same density. The mattes are amazing.
I waited about 6 months to get the palette but I do really enjoy it so far. I havent used every colour yet but so far I am very glad I have this :)
I like the palette. Mine was hella pigmented and there was a ton of fall out, but that doesn't bother me. One of my favs in my collection.
Wish I had gotten the palette
I wonder if the people that have had problems with their mattes was some of the 1st batch that was pressed with a machine? My palette was one of the ones pressed with the machine but it wasn't the 1st batch I didn't get mine until April I think maybe 1st of May
This pallette is sold out, but I did find two similar pallettes. Juvias the Magic pallette and Lurella On the Edge pallette. They are beautiful as well. 😉
I waited 6 months to receive a 9 pans palette for the first time in my life & I love it with my entire heart ❤️, the mattes blend themselves & the metallics are such a dream ! Even though you said they’re a thicker ones I think I love that too specially with the insane shifts that they have !!!
I can’t decide which shade is my favorite because they’re all my favorite starting from : spooky, trapa, Sam, handbook , zero, apparition, grim , Adams & Derry 😂
I was not able to get this one but I did a BYOP on the Lethal site and duped this magical color story! It just came in yesterday and I haven't been able to put it down!
I cant wait to order this once shroud opens up again. I love those type of metallics
I wish i could get my hands on this
I love my “Freakin’ Bats”. The colors are so pretty. I think my favorite is Trapa. I also love Spooky. And….what am I saying? I just love them all!
In my palette zero and Sam are switched. I love this palette!
My husband just gave me this palette as a gift and I absolutely love it! The color story is so beautiful and the mattes blend together really well (even Derry into Trapa) I hope you love the palette! 💜💜💜
What an amazing gift!
@@AmyLovesMakeup yeah he's so good to me 😭😭
I received mine back in March (I think). I loooove the color story! I had some trouble with Spooky fading when I blended, but other than that I enjoyed the quality. I'll definitely bring it back out in the fall!
Good morning Amy! Missed your face! Excited to watch this! I wasn't able to get my hands on this, but I'm sure I will in the future 😊💜💚 Love your channel ❤ Hope you are having an amazing week
Good morning ❤️
I only used mine once. I have to admit I was salty about waiting 5 1/2 months for it.
Love mine! I'm not as talented as you are, but I'm pleased with what I come up with!😁 I made it into the initial launch and received mine the end of November.
It’s crazy how people’s opinions are so polarizing on this palette! I think it’s one of the most high quality palettes in my collection. The only shadow that I had some issues with was the periwinkle but I used the ABH primer with it and didn’t really have issues. I used the pack and blend method. I barely touch the shimmers and it’s pigment for days! The mattes are so buttery. I think Betty Jean is a talented and wonderful influencer, but I don’t watch her much these days due to lack of time and me watching other influencers more who focus on a different style of content. Therefore I’m not biased in liking this palette just for the person behind it. I think there’s inconsistencies with production and I wish everyone was able to get the high quality palette I got. 😕
This palette is probably my favorite Shroud palette, and definitely my favorite collab palette (I think it's my only collab, lol). The wait was long, but I was OK with it. I do wish that the launch went better for Betty Jean, as I think it took away from the incredible joy she had felt. It's sad to see that the formula seems to be inconsistent. My palette is fine, although I don't know if I got a hand-pressed one vs a machine pressed one.
I look forward to owning this one day
It such a good palette!
It looks cool!
I have this and love it! 🤩 Would totally watch a video with those monochrome looks you plan on doing... Just saying! Haha 🤭😁
I love certain shades in this palette, but I don’t like the overall color story together, so I wonder if Shroud plans to release them as singles in the future like they’ve done with previous non-collab palettes. Even if they did though, I don’t think I’d get them for a long time, given how chaotic this launch went.
I’ve had this palette for awhile but haven’t gotten around to using it. I’m kind of worried that I’m not going to like it. I’ve seen a lot of people say they don’t like it. I know that they didn’t hand press all of the palettes so maybe that’s why some people don’t like it? I completely understand why they got the machine to press the pigments, I just can’t help but wonder if it’s different from the first ones.
I have to try find mine. I’m still unpacking my apartment, my makeup area is a mess! Love the look you did!
I received one of the machine pressed ones, and the palette that I got had no compromise in the quality or pressing. Chloe made sure that her new machine was calibrated to mimic the hand pressed ones, and BeautBean gave her approval before manufacturing commenced. Now whether this is consistent across all the remaining ones in the preorder I have no idea, but I can only say the one I got is the same, rich, pigmented quality as all the other Shroud Cosmetics palettes and singles I own. 🙂
@@SH-wk6po Thank you! I think a lot of people aren’t used to Indy brands or the quality and pigment most of them have. I haven’t seen any videos of anyone disliking this palette. It was comments on posts from Instagram. I’m excited to try mine now.
Seeing the comments I guess I was lucky with the quality. mine works very well, and the shimmers are super pigmented even without glitter glue. honestly one of the best quality palettes that I own (though truly I don't own many lol)
It was not worth the wait. The quality was okay, especially considering these colors are difficult to produce. However, it was not worth a 6 month wait. In the interim the Angelica X Kaleidos palette launched successfully, and now the Annette X Menagerie palette has launched, and between them and my existing collection, I have this color story. This palette is still displayed in the glass case of my vanity, and I would have your collab there too if not for the controversy, but I do not think this was worth the delay which did result in uncertainty as to where my money had gone as this was my first experience with this brand.
What is the small flat brush that you used on the inner half of your bottom lashline and in the tearduct area? I'm on the hunt for smaller-than-usual shader brushes.
I think it’s a Morphe M508
@@AmyLovesMakeup, thanks!
Hi Amy! I don't know if you'll see this at all. I left a comment I'm not proud of in a previous video you uploaded (I don't even remember which one, it was actually months ago, I only remember that I came across like a jerk in hindsight). I wanted to apologise for that today. Thank you for your videos! You're an inspiration!
I honestly don’t remember the comment but I appreciate you. We all have those days and sometimes with written text it’s hard to see the full picture. Thank you for watching ❤️❤️
My Derry arrived a little broken shroud was great tho offered to send me a new single of it but I said it was fine I just repressed it.
I have this palette, I have mixed feelings about it, I think the mattes are excellent but the metallics are just not my favorites, not intense enough. I really like my metallics molten like the Kaleidos formula or very glittery and sparkly, these to me are almost satin, which is not my preference, I just have to use toppers to intensify them.
I understand. These are definitely more just intense metallics but super nice with a glitter primer. I need to try them wet too.
@@AmyLovesMakeup I'm going to try them with glitter primer, cause I think I've only wet them. I only used this palette a couple of times *shame, shame, shame* I'll pull it out today 😜
i felt like the quality of this palette was okay.., the shimmers were much thicker than I expected. the main problem I had with it was the 6. month. wait.
I ordered the palette on the first launch and only just got my palette in March. I know that they got a lot more orders than they anticipated, but wow. by the time I got it and saw the shimmers were not to my liking and the mattes blend a little weird, I was SO disappointed. one of my most disappointing purchases ever which sucks because I love the colors and the theme.
I really want this palette but the polarizing reviews are putting me off☹
If you all want this palette, I could name dupes for these shades with Give Me Glow and other indie brands. I would never give Shroud my money after how they’ve botched this launch and handled everything.
I’d love to hear some dupes!
I love Beautbean and the palette is nice enough, but for all the good things I’d heard ab the formula I expected more tbh. :/ I got it to work but it was way more effort than I’m used to, especially the matte shades re: Patchiness and fallout
This was my first time trying shroud and I struggled heavily with this formula. The mattes are so hard to build up and then they blend away. I couldn't build it up on the eye without it looking uneven. Disappointing because the color story is gorgeous. The shimmers are nice, but not that unique?
It’s so strange that the reviews for the mattes are so back and forth. Mine were so pigmented. ):
@@AmyLovesMakeup yeah. I wonder if the difference is from the palettes that were hand pressed vs the palettes that were pressed with the pressing machine.
i have to say i adore the color story but sadly the shimmers just dont do it for me anymore, they almost appear flat compared to most of my others shimmers in my collection. but i love the color story enough to still keep the palette.
sadly, i was disappointed in the palette🙁 spooky and derry are sooo patchy that i hate my look if i ever use them in my crease/outer corner. since i was most excited about those shades it bums me out
Dang I’m sorry to hear that ):
Hellooo💖💗💖💗💕💕💕
369th like with no dislikes, nice!
The spooky shade is very patchy, so disappointing