Why I Prefer Manga Vs Anime
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ต.ค. 2024
- #manga #anime
Why I like manga more than anime.
intro animator: / _tevaring_
intro and outro producer: / @thebeatmancer
background music: / @theofficialacro
► "Copyright Disclaimer, Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for 'fair use' for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use."
I personally just do both if I like the series that much
Same
Same here.
My brotherrrrr
Say that to tokyo ghoul.
U only want to
Co
Eli
keit
Us Manga and Anime fans can agree that Live Anime movies pretty much suck lmao
There is good live action, but there all for underground manga like Lone Wolf and Cub, Ichi the Killer or more recently the french live movie of City Hunter who was really great
Gintama and rurouni kenshin live action were pretty good actually
@@seanliew7496 and tokyo ghoul (huh for once the live adaptation was better than the anime adaptation)
@@zandi1603
Lmao stop
@@johnjoestar5731 stop what? I literally enjoyed it more than the anime
Some animes really compliment to their mangas ,look at Demon Slayer ,a manga with Ok art was turned into an anime with highly praised animation
I really couldn't stand the art after that glorious animation. It's not bad..... But holy shit
@@anirudhankumble3586 basically why I haven't read the aot manga
@@anirudhankumble3586 i mean ,the author still kept on doing her best to improve the art ,by the end altough it still wasn't anything phenomenal ,i'd say it was pretty good
@Ahmad Hussnain But the art has certainly improved now...
@@ahmadhussnain8523 aot really works well as an anime because of the music,the setting and the animation the hype just works positively for it. I'd say the anime is a better experience than the manga but the manga is amazing on itself to enjoy despite the art.
Better art, better story, better character development, no censorship, no filler, no cut content, no dumbing down of dialogue, there's a lot of reasons I prefer comics, manga and books over their television adaptions.
Don’t forget pacing, I could probably watch an arc of one piece but if I spent the same time reading it that I did watching then I could probably finish 2 full arcs or get close to doing so. Also you get better visuals and intensity in fights along with it since you don’t have to deal with bad or slow animation
Not to mention something like jojo where you can get to some of the best parts and characters early instead of having to wait a year or two for it to get animated or have it finish in the anime
@@Gio90210. That's a very good point as well, sometimes the opposite is also true where they'll take a massive arc from a manga and condense it into a rushed, incoherent mess.
The way the 2016 adaption of Berserk tried to cram the entire Black Swordsman Arc, the Guardians of Desire Arc and the Lost Children Arc into a single episode is one of the most extreme and terrible examples of this lol.
there is nothing known as no censorship.....even "dark" manga like berserk, gantz, kingdom and claymore have censorship
Rey 2375 one piece animation is looking good now a days. The only problem at this point is pacing.
@@whyfi8760
Sometimes, comedy series are benefited from being voice-acted...
The quirks by the actors sometimes add more characters.
I usually read i only watch if the adaptation is fantastic like Hxh, or Mob psycho
I think hxh works so good as an anime because instead of the whole page being filled with words you can actually see the fights and dialogue while they walk or something.
I like to do a little bit of both, I'll read something and only watch the show if I hear it's doing super well, but I also watch things and like them so much I read them. An example of that currently is that I'm reading Kaiju no. 8 and Spy family and will only watch their anime adaptations if they are done well, and I just watched Mob Psycho and loved it so now I'm diving into the manga.
edit* I should say Webcomic
@@Brawlnana Yea I love Togashi's work but HxH's 2011 adaptation is without a doubt superior to the manga.
@Maurice Johnson bruh all the cool shit starts to happen after the anime ends
Plot twist, the manga is the adaptation
aren't doing any favors to anime showing this homunculus of CGI trowup that is berserks adaptation
cody d Yeah I’d say the only awful Adaptations are that, and maybe some others, but JoJo, and One Punch Man, and Mob have amazing animes well aside from season 2 of One Punch Man, but even that wasn’t that bad.
Dunno why OPM season 2 is so underappreciated. It's just as good if not better than season 1. The only thing it did worse is animation and it's still not bad by any means.
@@Angel-kc7ck its so weird to me that season 2 gets hate for not have godly animation. it was still easily above average animation.
i see people regularly say season 2 was horrrible.
Josh Shrum why is JoJo so praised for it's anime? They ruined the pacing of Part 1 and took away Johnathan's personality, making it that Part 1 is now seen as boring when the manga isnt, Part 3 battles were so stretched out from two or three manga chapters to 40 minute arcs, Part 5 dragged out the middle so much
The CGI is decent
i prefer anime, but i have zero choice but to read manga, because animes dont be finishing
The goat attack on titan will
HXH one for example.
The Interspecies Reviewer manga of hunterhunter aint finishing either bruh
@Lionard Kirsch plus the anime is sick
Lol same. I don't have patience for some anime. So e anime I will wait for though like AOT, Fire Force, and Demon Slayer.
Pretty much the opposite for me when it comes to what's time consuming. I like reading it slowly. Looking at the artwork, the backgrounds, the expressions of the characters and taking the time to digest the dialogue. Speculate and try to predict what happens next. Trying to analyse certain characters and themes of the story. With the anime, you can of course do all of that as well. But for the pace of how i'm reading, the manga usually takes longer.
I don't like speed reading. Have a friend who does that and he can barely tell the names of the main characters, a lot of the time. For some people, it just seems like they wanna reach the end as fast as possible. I don't really understand how that's enjoyable, but each to their own.
I don't understand it but whenever I read I can't stop myself from wanting to finish it ASAP and rushing through and omg I couldn't read One Piece because i couldn't remember any of the side characters names 😂 had to watch the anime, also my literal Aspergers brain finds the black and white sook fucking hard to discern what's happening in some panels
Bro you have to be writing a book essay for english. That is impressive the only reason why I read slowly is because I'm looking up words sometimes because my japanese is trash but when I can read it I read it fast. I could never go slow and enjoy it seems so boring to me I read manga for the fights and the plot twists or the emotional scenes.
@@tikicantlane Thank you! Do you struggle with english or japanese? Nothing wrong with your english from what i can see.
The action, emotions, plot twists, etc. Is also very important for me as well! But i'd also like to understand the motivations of the characters, how they develop, what messages the author wants to explore with the story. The more i come to understand these things, the more likely i am to enjoy and appreciate the show and it's characters.
@@beastvicious8672 I'm not trying to say how you read is wrong I think it's a very good way to read I think it is impressive. And my english Is fine I started learning japanese about a 2 years and I do it for a language credit for my school so I having to look up words from time to time. I do agree on the part where I forget names when I read to fast. I never remember the names for the characters unless there like main characters that they show alot 😂
@@user-hb7hg2zh7n OnePiece is one anime/manga that i know like 90%of side characters some times i froget some vice admiral names but idk their name catches my attention.Samw with JoJo but when it comes to berserk i fucking love it soo much but i only know crews name and band of the hawks main guys name.
The other version "Why I prefer Doujins VS H3ntai"
Asking the real questions.
Queen Bee that's why!
Doujins no question hentai gets pretty bland after a while
Doujin by far, between sheer amount and actual plot to be found in many, it's just way better.
Hentsi if it is dubbed properly like our favorite succubus
I’ve always watched more than I’ve read, but I do get what your saying about manga being easier and faster.
I watched Tokyo Ghoul, liked it, then the second season came🤢 soooo I went and got the manga. I could still hear the voices of the characters as I read it, lmao and idk if anyone else does this, but I basically go through all the sound effects and stuff. In a way I basically try to animate the manga in my head 🤣
Same
Same. I thought I was the only one.
Everyone does that, If you are not hearing those character voices automatically then that means it a pretty bad manga/book.
Yes I do it as well.
In my opinion, it really expands imagination and creativity by a lot.
I do the same with One Piece especially when the chapter is almost over and a big scene is about to happen the Dun! Dun! Dun! DunDunDunDun! theme goes on in my head lol.
Am I the only one who likes manga because of the black and white art?
No Man you're not alone lol
Yes only you
Sometimes it can add to the vibe
For some reason the black and white art just makes the faces look so much more expressive .
no man there are millions of people out there who read manga you can't be the only one
Im relatively new to anime/manga but thats one thing that stuck out to me recently. The manga is almost always more detailed (art and story) than the anime, but I still love both!
Manga usually is about visual storytelling and poses angles panels...anime is allowed to add more dialogue to make everything feel more real and so we can feel what they feel and see the truth clearer and understand more of the story
Because it didn't move. Manga was better in most cases, but when anime got everything right, it surpass anything that manga could offer, at least for me.
Try watched Your Lie in April, Haikyuu, People should appreciate the importance of music/vocal in our lives. animation is bonus.
Imagine the world you can't hear?
In a world that can often feel uncertain, music is a source of hope. It's a universal language; one that transcends cultural boundaries and can unite people of different backgrounds. Just a single chord can touch one's innermost being, evoking emotions without uttering a word
My recommendation is to Watch a GOOD anime first. Then read the manga version of it.
Because you are just spoiling yourself. It is like reading a wikipedia and then watching adaptation. You will get disappointed or just get bored because you already know the story.
The surprise factor is gone.
It is like reading a comic book of your Marriage proposal, Surprised confession of love, birthday surprise from the future. then experiencing it in the present.
that just comes with the medium. you if a manga ever has worse looking stillshots than an anime, which is a medium NOT about stillshots then the artists should probably reavulate their expertise
and story is more detailed because they can just cram in text and such without much worry while anime can't.
@@aaronyoghurt9210 yup absolutely, good anime are just outright better than manga, because they just HAVE more (voice acting, animation, music, color and many many many other things)
any manga i read could never bring me to tears ever, and at most make me chuckle at a joke
I love having the book in hand and the fact that you do really get to appreciate the author because there name is on it
Also a lot of the time the author also did all the art themselves so you get to experience their drawing styles and whatnot too. always love reading manga and seeing the various artistic styles.
book?
my jaw dropped when he said such blasphemy abt anime ops and eds
ikr? after hearing this blasphemy i learned, mask was never one of us, but a mere fake weeb :(
@@onee-chansplaytoy5863 TF?
Onee-chan's Play toy we must burn this heretic
yea that was crazy
He is right, ninety percent of ops and ends arent all that
Aight but the Dorohedoro anime is flames though.
damm straight
It's good, but the manga is better
@@flamingwheel9926 really? my rule in life is that if the anime is garbage i'll read the manga but if the adaptation is good i won't read the manga cause i don't like looking at the same thing if it gives me the same enjoyment so i never checked out the dorohedoro manga but i have seen some panels and can definetly say the manga looks better
I actually did buy the manga for season one, and I do agree that the manga is way more detailed in its drawings. I personally like the anime style a little bit more due to how Kimon looks a bit more cuter in that.
Yeah, but the reason why that anime worked so well is because the character designs are so simplistic and easier to animate. Dorohedoro has character designs that rely on details, that’s why they used CG.
like the animation in the new intro but i do miss that old song
Definitely, i was ready to hear ash crow
Same
BIG SAME
MASKU
I was immensely disappointed.
Ahh that music hit that nostalgia spot in my ears just right
My reasons to liking manga more than anime:
- Manga can get away with more. In therms of content manga can get more past the censors than the anime.
- Less filler. Yes manga can have filler chapters (the Inuyasha manga is basically 30 percent or more filler for instance) but in general is more condense than the anime which in some cases have to use crap ton of fillers - basically every shounen jump anime ever.
- Many times the anime airs and ends before the manga and there is no second season so they fill the blanks with original content, the ending is usually awful or a cliffhanger - the original Hellsing for instance.
- Less time consuming, an anime episode is from, on average,12 to 24 minute long, you can get the same amount of content with less padding from a chapter for less time
The last reason is actually the main reason why I became manga only now
@@blank2736 well i can finish 12 ep anime in one day lol
These are adaptation problems, not anime problems.
Personally I've always perfected anime because I connect emotional with stories much better when I can hear them. Which is why I honestly think that music sound design and voice acting are all more important to making a good anime, well, animation. I've tried to do the thing where I imagine a character's voice in my head but I just can't, they always default back to being read in my own voice after a few pages it makes the whole experience feel a lot "flatter" to the point where at least for me only the highest tier of manga art, Berserk, Punpun, etc, are comparable to my favorite voice performances and soundtracks.
Still respect your opinion, great vid.
I agree
I generally feel more immersed in books/manga than TV adaptations
@@tricko8000 you simply nerf
Masked you’re like an anti-weeb with all that “hate anime songs” 😂
I was almost triggered but then I was thinking about it, and I'd have to say I skip at least 75% of the OPs & EDs. It just feels like more because those good ones stick with you.
@@PaizuruInsanal Of all the longform shonens, Gintama and Black Clover have more hits than misses for me. Naruto had several... One Piece and Bleach only had a few each.
Anime songs seems to me, most of the time, "what's popular lately? Let's play the top listed... THAT ONE WORKS! XD
Berserk(98),Bleach , One piece and Zetsuen no tempest has entered the chat with beautiful osts
Thunderbolt fantasy OP would like a word with him.
One thing that anime will always have over manga is music.
Bruh
Its almost like that's how a show would work
@@reservoir4798 ?
Or just look up all the intros and outros of the manga your reading 🤷🏽♀️
I think intros can break the flow, manga reading multiple chapters it just has a good flow
One punch man has insanely good art.
Then there's S2
@@Grimgino he was talking bout the manga
@@basedpluto Understandable, have a nice day
Fr I've caught myself staring at some panels for half an hour because of the amazing attention to detail
So true but it's got nothing on vagabond
I feel like the MHA anime is one of those unicorns that takes everything great about the manga and makes it even better.
This
Man what the heck Bones gonna do in season 6. Horikoshi art is fire right now.
Yeah, I just told my friends to wait for the next season cause I actually ended up enjoying the anime a little bit more. The fight scenes could be sometimes confusing in the manga but *Oh, boy* they did an amazing job in the anime.
@@OsSas3 that’s my problem as well. It can be hard to tell what’s actually going on as far as the action is concerned
@@alifhazmi7341 i hope they add blood in season 6 to make it epic
Masked man hitting us with a new hype intro
And proceeds to talk shit about anime op and eds :/
@Monkey D. Kong dorohedoro
Well there's a stark contrast between the quality of manga being more picturesque and less kinetic than its anime counterpart. Although the former quality is priceless, we like to watch anime for the latter quality, for that's the whole point from animating a manga, watching the very same panels we fell in love with while reading through the whole thing getting in subtle motion.
I thought this was gonna be a Dorohedoro review after the TH-cam post and the thumbnail for this video, but I can't say I was disappointed! Will you be doing a review of it soon I really wanna hear your thoughts it's on my top 10 best manga of all time.
Exactly I saw the anime and had to read the manga finished in 3 days one of favorites as well. Love kaiman
Am I the only one who listens to OSTs while reading manga so the lack of music isn’t such a really an issue? Please say I’m not the only one
my sister does it
I prefer silence
for the most part i agree, but recently some shows like demon slayer, mob psycho, and jujutsu kaisen have had great anime adaptations that really bring life to the source material. especially demon slayer since the quality of the manga drawings progressively decreased as the story reached its final arc (probably due to time constraints on the mangaka unfortunately)
I much prefer manga compared to anime. I feel like manga do a better job at conveying the intended story and tone, whereas anime often change art style or remove narration/exposition. Imo this leads to things like certain Nen abilities and Stands being more confusing.
@Lionard Kirsch Hard disagree on JoJo Part 5. I think the anime is a poor adaptation.
Masked when an anime doesn't have a manga: This is a problem
Edit: the replies will trigger lost of people 🤣🤣🤣
code geass ?
@@bigbodybilly265 didn't they make a code geass manga?
mightdai are you forgetting kill la kill?
Manga that are based off anime originals are usually worse or manga that is based off other source material like LNs.
mightdai nah not even close both cowboy bebop and gurren lagann are better by far in pretty much any aspect of he show. The only aspects code geass has them beat is its laugh ability and number or plot holes
There ain’t no shortcuts with reading manga.....this medium isn’t something you can digest by listening to an audiobook
There if it is a web novel by their stories tend to turn to shit after a few volumes
I don't think I understand what you are trying to say.
I usually prefer watching anime, but there are just some things and emotions that carry over better on manga than anime. I don't really know how to explain it lol, its just that some emotions i feel when reading a good manga is exclusive to the manga only.
There’s litterally nothing different Your just a weeb
ITS author's original charm. Even when anime adapt manga very faithfully, the author's charm can not be adapted, especially if the animators are ordinary workers while the author has genuin love for their works
Bro, you should try picking up some modern fantasy books. Most of them feels like a manga, cool fight scenes with well thought magic systems. If u wanna try i would recommend mistborn by Brandon Sanderson
Literally my favourite series of all time, an incredible read
i like sandersons stormlight series much more but im rereading mistborn rn, im noticing alot of stuff that i missed initially when i read it years ago
Brandon Sanderson, Joe Abercrombie, George RR Martin
@@alejandrobarrios7460 A Little Hatred is so good I'm reading it now waiting for Trouble With Peace to arrive
The new intro is 🔥
I'm not gonna wait to see how the story continue in the anime
The only time i was extremely hyped reading a manga is in the beetle fight in jojolion
I have read berserk, devilman, kny, chainsaw man, dragon ball, and others but i never felt so excited to the point of sweating like with the beetle fight
Maby that's just me
Man, that Beetle Tendancy is so god-tier.
Araki is a godtier writer
I've gotten more excited with the Berserk manga than any anime I've ever watched
Read solo leveling its hype as fuck
@Bobby Hill hes the creator of sbr and jjl so he is
oh myy the intro with the ludwig theme
lit.just lit
also yeah i 100% agree manga is >>>anime specially that i read everything i find interesting whether its a classic book , modern webtoon or a blackwhite badass manga. it just feels so smooth
Ahhh this new intro tho, wtf it’s sick 😂
Melancholy Man na na father Gascoigne is where it’s at
I sorta agree wit ya but I disagree I actually like the Anime opening themes to Anime it doesn't feel cheesy it feels right I can listen to Yu yu hakusho or even your thumbnail Dorohedoro OP too many times! Plus just to see a series in motion is hype for me not just the seiyuus the voice actors but the passion the fight scenes the amount of sakuga etc I will say Manga is better when it comes to Berserk and even Dorohedoro but i actually enjoyed the hell outta dorohedoro. And Vinland saga and Blade of the immortal hell all of jojo it just depends on the people making the series and the way they actually utilize the series
I play music during action scenes to help make it more bad ass, but my only 2 gripes with comics and manga is that manga are not usually colored and both are not voiced. Of course voices are not everything but I would not be able to read 300 chapters of a manga if its all black and white. I usually wait for colored versions or fan colored. I read JoJo parts 1-7 in a few weeks and was able to blitz through them all since they have great colored versions of the manga.
The best thing about Manga is that it has freedom to go to places where anime wouldn't dare
4:03 And there's me for whom music(osts) is one of the most important thing in an anime, then art work and lastly story.
Watching anime is so time consuming indeed, although watching a well done fight scene in an anime is an unmatched experience. However I do prefer manga over anime as manga really sucks you into the story and also leaves a lot of room for imagination. Love your content though, especially the Beserk content, hopefully we can get a new chapter in the next 10 years lol ;)
noob
i can finish 12 ep in one day without forgetting characters name
Dorohedoro on the thumbnail nanii, where is the review 😶
Great video btw, i agree with every point because I am starting to prefer manga over anime myself but i get trashed for being a manga reader from time to time.
Majority of the time its:
Watch all the anime
Can't wait for next episode
Read the manga
Saw the title and thumbnail and remembered instantly the debates of One piece
and now having the hobby of collecting manga I’m appreciate a lot more manga and understand every point a manga lover has
I learned to love reading again too when I read 320 chapters of berserk in 9 days...
Damn you a fucking beast for that
Don't rush too hard man. You gotta take your time and take it in
I mean like for me watching any helps me connect with characters better. Also an anime helps me get invested in the story faster. In a manga I do not get really invested in a story till a major arc or plot point. In anime I do not really have that problem.
I just want mention this but gintama is fucking amazing and finish watching it.
Art work in berserk manga is really magnificent.
I love both manga and anime.
Anime alerts my parents when they see me in headphone.
With my kindle manga plays perfect stealth mode.
In my case, I have adhd, and even though animation and music are my favorite art forms, they are both really distracting for me, I often feel the need to go back a few minutes in an episode because I focus a lot on them or just space out.
Manga makes it a lot easier, I can just look at all the drawings in the page first and then read the dialogue, or even stop mid-chapter and finish it later.
Someday he'll have millions of followers I'm certain, and I can proudly say i have been here since he had only 5k followers. Just love his content so much
Greetings from Russia. I’m not sure if you still read comments but i’ve started watching anime from time to time 5 years ago and then i discovered manga. I’ve watched anime “immense ocean” and reading second part of manga now. i must agree with you, manga is more interesting than anime cause we save our time i also bought ranobe “Sword Art Online” and will read it as well in future (it shows the story more clear). keep going with your videos you’re doing well (i didn’t understand everything you said cause i learn English like a hobby) but i got for about 70% and i’m glad that i did it ^^
Am i the only one Who reads mangas with music (sometimes) I read kingdom with gangsta paradise and gang up and it was perfect
I read kingdom with berserk ost in the background
Yo I totally agree with pretty much all of your points!! I dont hate anime and the first season of attack on titan is what actually got me into manga in the first place. I hope one day, if you haven’t already lol, you can check out the Webtoon app and manhwas and the like! There are some absolutely exceptional webcomics on Webtoon such as “Eleceed”, “Omniscient Reader”, “Sweet Home”, “Your Throne”, “Purple Hyacinth”, “Like Wind on a Dry Branch”, “The God of High School”, “Humor Me”, “In The Bleak Midwinter;”, and sooo much more. There are so many well fleshed out stories with incredible art styles that I just had to mention a few haha. Great video as always!! 💖💖💖
There are some anime's that can get me interested into reading the manga. In Demon Slayer, i watched up to the latest episode, which was just after meeting Kyogai, then started reading because I couldn't wait till next week. I pretty much binge read the rest of the manga after that.
Bro that new intro 🔥🔥🔥 but that’s ash crow remix is so synonymous with your channel😭 keep up the great content tho(best anime channel on TH-cam)
As a reader I enjoy manga more. Anime is still interesting but I agree with most of your points
I like dark/gory series more in a manga than in a anime.
What do you think about combining the two? Imagine a manga that at certain points has animated scenes. Perhaps instead of animating an entire fight, it’s just a short clip of the finishing move. Idk, just a thought.
That could be a new business idea, although some webtoons have idea
Bruh dont fucking spoil the future
Just stay with the amnga
If you have a vr headset, try looking at some vr comics/manga.
So, a motion comic?
I love both really, if I read something and I like it I’m excited to see how they put it on the screen. I think what drives anime is the voice acting, animation and the music. The manga has better pacing and beautiful visuals. They both have strong things about them so there is no point in me deciding which one I like more. I just enjoy the series itself as a whole
Damn I was writing this while watching and literally after I finished you said the three things anime has going for it is voice acting, animation and music 😂😂😂😂😂
This reminds me what happened with Blame and It's movie adaption where it tells a entirely different story from Manga
Don't know if I should count the Blame! Log mini series.
they did it dirty
A quote that I heard from someone else's video, and one that I think sums it up accurately, is, "There is a lot more that can go wrong in anime adaptations before it can go right."
I never got problem with music because I always play different OSTs of anime in background while reading manga
This. When I know I read an apocalyptic story ill pop on some Cyro Chamber. When its more action ill do whatever fits the vibe to me
doesn't make sense, that would never be better than the specifically created or carefully chosen music from an anime, when a scene changes in a sudden motion it immediatly falls flat cuz you still got your animal crossing ost playing. or you'll never have a beat drop right as a cool thing happends or smth.
no ost ever could give the feeling that the made in abyss anime ost brings to scenes
@@jeffboy4231damn can't believe it's already been 3 years now.
What I like about anime is the music it really lets me get into a scene better also the voices can make you feel something but I usually read manga because of how good the art is and the I get to see what the story is supposed to be from the creator basically I prefer manga because it’s how the author imagine the work to be
animes i prefer over manga
1 hunter hunter
2 attack on titan
3 JBA
Jojo parts 1-3 in the anime kinda suck but manga is good
I concur with these three.
4:16 except for the berserk 1997 anime opening , that song slaps ( also NGE which has a great one too )
I think to get the most out of manga, you need to have the kind of mind that's capable of bringing the images on the page to life and giving it all interesting profound meaning... something that I don't think the average person is actually very good at, hence anime being more popular.
Except manga is more popular in Japan. Americans just don’t like comics.
@@thomasffrench3639 yeah probably because the average Japanese person is more imaginative than the American, different culture, consumed and produced differently too. Though manga is becoming more and more popular outside of Japan, sales are higher than they have ever been and that upwards trend seems to be increasing year on year.... outselling comics last time I checked.
@@anab0lic which is dude entirely to anime and how western comics have confusing continuities. I don’t buy the politics being the reason, because other political media is really popular.
@@thomasffrench3639 nah its not just the continuity thing, manga being free of all the 'woke' bullshit makes a big difference for sure. Also, manga is drawn in a way where the moment to moment sequencing, in each panel, flows in a much more cinematic way.
@@anab0lic people all the sudden change their minds, and blame the comic industry for it. I call bullshit.
My biggest problem with manga is fight scenes. Even in Berserk, i have a pretty tough time figuring out whats going on. I think it mostly has to do with the Black/White color scheme. Getting a perception of speed and power is very difficult to understand in the manga format.
I generally start with an anime then continue on to the manga
Sometimes I like when an anime adaption is slightly different from the manga source material, ie Sailor Moon and Lupin iii respectively. It’s fun to pick apart the differences in terms of content, storytelling, or even in art styles.
hopefully one day we will have anime that has the same detail and beauty that manga has
I like to think of it like this: an anime is that specific director's vision and what he thinks it's important to focus on. When you read the manga, you decide what to focus on
Does TheMaskedMan have an Instagram or Twitter? Gotta send him love for the amazing content he's been putting out.
Honestly I agree, there is great room of imagination for the reader to have when reading because I ordered some Yu Yu Hakusho manga and read it and it was just as enjoyable as the anime imo.
My personal rule. Watch the new intro for a series. Remember how long it is, so I know how much to skip to get to the show.
I will give you a hint, it is always 1 minute and 30 seconds
Well, Manga vs Anime is a never ending battle but we need to acknowledge the fact that there are a ton of amazing stories that don't even have an Anime.
Yeah man, or they have an anime but the manga ends up being way better
*laughs in monogatari with a good manga, anime and lightnovel*
Manga: A terrifying monster attempting to eat a man's head.
Anime: Derpface lizard man in an awkward situation.
Yeah bro you had me on the first half and then you started capping when you said you hate the op and endings.
Bruh when he said that, it hurt 😞
when you were naming characters that you can instantly here their voice, i was ready to hear spike.
I recommend reading jagaaaaan
i feel that jagaaaaan is a good manga but the story isn't that compelling, okay the "horror" and the action are dope but the plot feels a bit light. I feel that the owl is just a way to introduce smoothly elements that make little if not any sense. The story is good but i think the standards it gave itself is too high.
the artwork is compelling and all but the themes that it rises are a bit too "light" ( they only scratch the surface of ningen's true) or too generic to really be a must read manga. The tree man is a great exemple of that ( trying to jibber some nonsense to seem like a phylosophical vilain such as the white haired guy from mob psycho, but falling flat very quickly )
If u want a rly good manga no one has watched yet check out T(it is slow passed, doesn t have much action but is great through and through )
btw sry for the poor grammar
@@bigbodybilly265 You didn't need to type a whole essay lol. But yeah it's a good manga and has it's twisted sense of justice that makes it memorable.
It's fun
The new chapters just got crazy me hype
@@PaizuruInsanal lmao. Well he hasn't appeared in a while. And I do agree it gets kinda dumb sometimes
Its bad, the main plot and characters are not bad but their is this one character in the manga thats not even a perv but simply a criminal. Its disgusting and repulsive and not even in a natural or good way. The character is the most hideous thing i have read its like the author added his NTR fetish to the story.
At the rate you’re growing I have no doubt that you’ll get 100k by the end of the year. Also the new intro animation is sick, though I will miss the old song
You low key gave a reality check for Demon Slayer fans
I think the main factual thing that actually plays the case of why I always prefer manga, it is that there will always be more manga than there is anime by an imaginable amount, there are so many amazing unheard of gems out there that are barely known let alone able to get an adaptation, also a lot of manga that are pretty much impossible to adapt like Koku no Hito, Innocent and Vagabond.
Also manga is the purest way to experience how an author envisioned their story. Anime is like experiencing a story from the goggles of another fan/individual, a lot of things that the author intended could easily be missed and/or removed be it by mistake or on purpose.
I think this rule only works on great mangas . For me I can't read trash manga but I can watch trash anime all the time
@@PaizuruInsanal very true
that thumbnail just express a difference from earth to sky, one is like junji ito suprarealism horror Maybe, and the other is a parody
Wow. nice
For me it depends on my lazy level at the time 😂
Very well put. I used to watch the anime before starting a series and found out in time it’s better the other way around
Thank you for stating the truth. The manga just gives the originals feelings and thoughts to us. And I totally agree with you demon slayer is a series that works better as an anime. The manga on the other hand isn't all that great
this is exactly what i was thinking before i watched love is war and demon slayer, both of them changed my mind on anime when i could unconciously noticed how the directing and animating could elevate the manga into a whole new level
Well shit, dorohehoro (or how the fuck it's written) is 1000 times more badass as a manga
I’m not really a manga guy at all tbh, just because i find the plot twists and fight scenes to be very anti-climatic. I’m also not much of a reader either. Attack on titan is the only manga i ever read, just because i couldn’t wait for the next season.
if perriot is adapting a manga I'll read the manga first lol. The studio sucks at adapting the art style of manga and also they tend to make it childish and stupid(except ost). Boruto,BC,TG could've been better if they were seasonal but ...😣
I'm going to say right now to the mask man my favorite intro wish I when I say that's probably one of the best ones on TH-cam is the intro you had for berserk with the really cool screenshots of a sores Raff and everything going on I mean I just really love that beat 😆
this a question I have to all the manga readers so after yall watch the anime do yall start reading the manga from the beginning or do you continue where the anime left off?? because sometimes I cant decide what to do
It depends, there are mangas where the anime skipped chapters that greatly affected the plot like servamp. If the anime did a great job adapting all the chapters and even adding more content like owari no seraph then I just read from where the anime left off
It depends. With Aot i start where i left off on the anime. However, with Tokyo Ghoul i started from the beginning. It really depends how accurate the adaptation is.
D P it depends but for most manga you should just read it from the beginning
I usually
Continue from where the anime left
But rn with berserk and the movies i just restarted the manga from the start
You should look at whether the anime skips stuff. Take Berserk. The 1997 anime skips a lot of good stuff by the time its finished and doesn't even have Puck. So in that case starting from the beginning is necessary
Manga sometimes has more things than the anime. But it's still cool to see how they look animated.
Misleading title. It should be "why I prefer manga vs its anime adaptation", because those points aren't valid for anime in general
Imagine how dope it would be if when you read a Manga there was a composer and an orchestra playing music perfectly in sync to the panel you were reading and levels of hype at every moment.
Manga pays so much more attention to detail, and strangely enough is more sensible then most animes
Personally I prefer it because I can get a sense of what's going on and I can imagine voices and appreciate each panel because that's whats being presented
the AOT fights are better in the anime (animation goes a long way when it's done right)
the OPM fights slap in the manga much respect