@@stefanomartinelli7344 I still can't wrap my head around what they were thinking. Who could they possibly have thought wanted what was basically an animated recap?
Anime watcher: That was a nice show Manga reader: the manga was better Light novel reader: The light novel was even better Web novel reader: yeah, the light novel was better
Anime Fans: “this is my theory on what’ll happen!” Manga Fans: “haha that’s cute. But seriously, isn’t it crazy that the MC just dies?” Light Novel Fans: “haha yeah totally. He’ll TOTALLY stay dead the rest of the arc” Webnovel Fans: “wait the MC dies? I thought it was the horse. I fucking hate this translation team.”
This moment in the video immediately came to mind when I heard the anime was announced. I am so hyped about the anime. The trailer looks beautiful. It is good to be alive.
@@sincalo I mean depends on who doing the adapting but i feel that it could even be better for a lot of the more emotional scene since we would be able to hear the delivery of a lot of Komi lines. Really, just as long as they dont do what 'Is this a Zombie' did where they had a fake,' voice to dub the lines on Eulicwood's notepad, (while it worked for that show, i just dont think it would fit with Komi humor), it should be fine.
"War has changed. It's no longer about nations, ideologies or ethnicity. It's an endless sereis of proxy battles fought by mercenaries and machines. War, and its consumption of life, has become a well-olied machine. War has changed. ID-tagged soldiers carry ID-tagged weapons, use ID-tagged gear. Nanomachines inside their bodies enhance and regulate their abilities. Genetic control, information control, emotion control, battlefield control…everything is monitored and kept under control. War…has changed. The age of deterrence has become the age of control, all in the name of averting catastrophe from weapons of mass destruction, and he who controls the battlefield, controls history. War…has changed. When the battlefield is under total control, war becomes routine.” ― David Hayter as Solid Snake
Anime fan: “I really like this anime” Manga reader: “the manga was better” Light novel reader: “the light novels better” The manga artist/writer: “fools you don’t know my true power”
Anime reader: oh boy I love this anime Manga reader: I'm 3 seasons ahead of you Light novel reader: I'm 20 seasons ahead of you Doujinshi readers: I'm 5 multiverses ahead of you
I do that. Suzuka, Magi, Rozen Maiden and Slam Dunk are some examples. However, the original medium is generally the better one simply because it's how the work has been thought of and produced in the first place. There may be some exceptions, when the difference in quality is undeniable: for example the first series of Shingeki no Kyojin is visually so much better than the manga that it may be considered superior. Or Kimetsu no Yaiba, where, as far as i know, the anime is widely considered way more polished and refined. Also any manga that revolves around music or singing has obviously potential to be better as an anime.
Holy shit, this resonates with me on such a deep level... Way back in the day when I was a little casual weeb I watched Code Geass, fell in love with it and at an anime convention the same year I saw the manga being sold. I bought all the volumes... Yeah....
@@rautes Well, that sucks. But didn't you know anything about the manga back then? The knightmare stuff and else I mean. Btw, is it true that everyone there has a Geass?
in the case of Shield Hero Anime: I love this show Manga: Definitely better than the anime Light Novel: Have fun with your diluted version Web Novel: I WAS THERE BEFORE THE STARS HAVE SHONE IN THE SKY
if you go watch an anime that was originally a lightnovel or webnovel though, the fans that are light novel readers are so many, like that time I got reincarnated as a slime or mushoku tensei and re:zero
In the light novel, it specifically mentions some kind of streaming service that came from America I never understood how they could change the source material like that.
The one thing that, manga and anime fans can't ruin *Evangelion 3.0+1.0* *Animation studio:* whoops we accidentally put this part of this movie in another movie, I *hope* that doesn't ruin anything.
Gigguk: "KOMI-SAN IS NEVER GETTING AN ANIME" Subtitles: "Comey son is not getting an animal" lol the subtitles censured that phrase because it was too much for us manga readers
@@mateuszkarpacki9331 yeah, but while I would love a Komi-sama anime, I dread the fact that an animation house won't do it justice, I think KyoAni, who are awesome with slice of life manga and can turn a sub par product to a fucking masterpiece K-On!
fuck the nay sayers. they also said kizumonogatari and index s3 would never happen. still hoping for the rest of FMP, haruhi, NGNL, Oregairu, spice and wolf..... one day
@@Healeon In my experience having only watched the anime I personally feel like alot of the enjoyment from the show was taken away because of the fact that I had already been spoiled so much even about parts that haven't been animated yet.
@@phd9335 Some deaths are too apparent in JoJo. Like anyone with the last name of Zeppeli. But anyone who spoils part 6,7,8 outside Japan is an asshole, they literally didn't start getting a good translation of the manga until 2013, and they only have official manga translations of up to part 4. There's no excuse for other parts though, part 5 has had decent translations since 2005. Part 4 had the Duwang scans, but they were better than nothing.
Anime fan: *smiles* Manga reader: *grins* LN Reader: *laughs* WN Reader: *laughs from mars* VN Gamer: *Trespasses space and time itself, merges every reality and laughs like a literal Satan*
live adaptation enjoyers < Normies < people who only watch anime for aesthetic < dub watchers < sub watchers < people who understand Japanese < manga readers < light novel readers < the person who writes the show < people who write and draw doujinish The chain of life
@@rajder656 I feel like the Overhaul arc was adapted over a lot sloppier then ppl were expecting,hence the disappointment amongst all the hype. It rlly is a good arc,but a good majority wasn't executed to the degree of quality the series had in previous seasons,especially Mirios fight. On top of this,I feel like to many were hyping the season up on the chance the Overhaul arc would be higher quality then it was,totally forgetting the arc tht would come after. Fall Festival Arc is rlly just a bore.
@@imgrimcookie4773 my criticism are similar to what you said but it boils down to two main points 1) overall lower quality animation 2) pacing that looks similar to heart beat monitor. If you take away this two bnha is a generic ass shounen without anything actually good, it's just mediocre without any traits like the mcu style universe that index series created. Characters are the definition of generic,power system boring. Yes it has a few good hype scenes but if that is considered a "great show" then i guess darling in the franxx is 10/10 no questions asked
Anime Watcher: Ok guys this is what happens next Manga Reader: No it not English Light Novel Reader: Yes it is, but it happens a lot letter in the Manga Japanese Light Novel Reader: no it didn't, it was all the MC's plan Author: Why are you even doing this to yourself, just enjoy it, because I can change it to whatever I want Publishing Company: No you don't, it's not up to you, We are your boss, so change to what makes the most money for us
You forgot: "Original Web Novel published on some weird Japanese Website nobody has heard about" Reader: This is all wrong, it was the other guy that told MC but they cut them out the whole story for the official Light Novel!
@@wolfiefenrir9552 I think it could translate pretty well. Especially the more cute/heartwarming scenes would really benefit from some good voice acting.
Light novel reader: closes the door and sees a webnovel reader standing there Webnovel reader: "Hey." Light novel reader: punches webnovel reader in the face
@@alisethera9349 regarding fan translations, not really. Depends on the author/publisher, but if it's out and relatively popular, it can be found easily. Regarding JP sources, not so much. Although sometimes the LN version is different enough to warrant keeping both versions.
Here's my stance: I read the manga and get ahead of the plot, then watch it with color and motion and sometimes less confusing fight coreographies. Manga = Substance Anime = Spectacle
@@derpedarp9041 I meant to say that manga readers get to experience the stories before anime watchers, and that anime is a nice way to relive/refresh the plot for those who'd read it on the manga before. I don't have a personal prefence. "Substance" was a bad choice of words.
Yeahhhhh like when I see the animation in anime it helps me understand a lot more easily what punches, dodges, kicks, and attacks are being thrown. But I also find that manga sometimes has a lot more detail then others like in the singular panels where they go all out with the detail whether it’s a characters face or a setting. I tend to see a lot more detail there. But anime also makes the small funny panels and brings a lot more attention and light to them which you may not notice in the manga.
I enjoy both. Manga more often have more details, character development and easy to speed through. Animate have better cinematic effects and it really helps to draw you into the story. Light novel on the other hand is like a combination of both.
I'm actually kinda glad with that. Mostly because of how wildly the manga has been barreling up and down in 'quality' or 'progression' in the last 50 or so chapters. I can barely handle the now massively flanderized characters in the manga as is, let alone in anime form where *those* annoying side characters will have voices.
Anime watcher: "Im the best" Manga reader: "Im far more superior" ???: "Pathetic." Manga reader/Anime watcher: "WHAT DID YOU SAY?" Visual Novel reader: " *PATHETIC* "
It's the best of both worlds. Not rly but enough time for good story and characters mixed with sound design and usually great OST's is pretty damn good.
as a manga reader, why would a manga not getting an anime be an issue if the manga is always better? also lol translated manga scrubs, gotta read manga and LN/WN in the original japanese
"manga-reading intellectual" Oh god. Fucking geek. Who calls themselves intellectual, really? People who haven't lived a very great social life for sure.
I can't concentrate on a whole anime episode but can easily read all day long that's why I became a manga reader over an anime watcher. I still watch anime but definitely not nearly as much as I read manga. I'm definitely also guilty of reading ahead once I actually watch an anime because yes I'm an impatient person and can't wait literal years for the next season.
You watch 1 hour flims but cant watch 20 minute episode, yea right Go back to your dead forum with 8 people with the same hypocrtial arguments as yourself
@@mantrasharma303 I agree for dbz and dip haven't heard sds dub doesn't change the fact that 99,9999 percent of anime dub is way worse than the original
"This video was pretty all over the place and didn't make much sense."
*Kaneki:* Probably does in the manga.
I'm still crying for Tokyo ghoul.
@@stefanomartinelli7344 I still can't wrap my head around what they were thinking. Who could they possibly have thought wanted what was basically an animated recap?
ChaosDraguss they basically didnt want to do the anime anymore but it wouldve been better if they didnt just do it instead of giving us that
@@ChaosDraguss
I'm not talking about re, I'm talking about the first series.
There Is no way that Is a recap.
Why
Anime watcher: That was a nice show
Manga reader: the manga was better
Light novel reader: The light novel was even better
Web novel reader: yeah, the light novel was better
so true
I mean sometimes its not.
Dub watcher: please just let us watch anime in peace
Anime watcher,Manga reader,Light novel reader, Web novel reader: DIE!!!!
machine translation reader: yeah, it's great when you can actually understand what they're saying.
How very like a light-novel.
Hitler didn't read the manga and that's how he lost ww2.
Actually he did read the manga but he put it off for too long. It's why he committed suicide knowing he would fail.
The WW2 manga was the best. But the anime had that beach episode nobody could ever forget. Much better than WW1’s beach episode.
Oof saber
Hitler just read the wrong manga. Tanya is about ww1, not ww2.
if he did read the manga,
then he would have spoiled it to the people, and be in a state much worse than he actually was.
Well, well, well, looks like Komi-san is getting an anime adaptation after all.
_All according to keikaku_
I hope not
Darn. Beat me to it.
Finally
Yeah heheheheeh
"Komi-san will never get an anime"
Translation: Stay out of r/Animemes for the next 24-48 hours
stay away from r/animemes for at least a week just for safety
Wait why?
@@tatmmw1 it'll suddenly get flooded with komi san memes because of gigguk now.
@@tatmmw1 r/animemes basically worships Komi, Satania, thighs, and everything. Gigguk basically just started a gang war
@@SataniaSquid *YES*
Everything changed when the light novel nation attacked.
Void Raider omg so true
Except that light novels are insufferable trash fires. I really don't understand how people manage to read those
@@Relinquished404 its the same as "how can people watch this shitty anime", depends from what you read
@@Relinquished404 have you read, like, even 5 GOOD light novels?
@@cristianardonmonge836 Fair point. The writing style just seems so simple and bare-bones to me.
Edit: change of wording
"Do not cite the deep magic to me witch."
"I was there when it was written"
YOU'RE GODDAMN RIGHT
NARNIA
It's quote from Narnia? The manga was better
@@elbowgrease12 It was in the... You know what? Not my problem. I'm gonna go watch helluva boss.
manga readers: "the manga was better"
Tokyo Ghoul fans: "yes"
jibaku shounen fans: absolutely
Berserk reader: of course it is
Almost all manga that's not shounen fans: "yes"
Oh I love Tokyo ghoul
Please stop hating the anime
I was actually pretty satisfied with it
It was ok
I get so much hate
@@Dehydratedoctopus i mean its fair if you like it
But from an objective standpoint it was trash
And it did the manga so, so dirty
Gigguk: Komi san is never getting an anime
Literally everyone: YOU TAKE THAT BACK YOU LITTLE PIECE OF SHI-
Or better yet... "You better retake your words you piece of uncultured turd!"
but it's the truth
Yes I too watched the video and heard these words that were spoken by the TH-camr that we were watching
i had that exact reaction... and i still do every time i hear this sentence
Good
Anime Fans: “this is my theory on what’ll happen!”
Manga Fans: “haha that’s cute. But seriously, isn’t it crazy that the MC just dies?”
Light Novel Fans: “haha yeah totally. He’ll TOTALLY stay dead the rest of the arc”
Webnovel Fans: “wait the MC dies? I thought it was the horse. I fucking hate this translation team.”
this had me curling up in laughter! ^^ and that akumetsu profile pic ... HUZZA, a man of quality!
too relatable holy shit
Mood
lmao thats pretty funny not gonna lie
I love the webnovel part
Manga readers: The manga was better
Me: The doujin was better
Nice.
Ah... A man of culture as well.
doujiins have the fan created ships and are therefore superior to everything
It was hard to write that with one hand?
The virgin monster musume vs the chad monster musume hentai from 2007 it was adapted from
"KOMI-SAN IS NEVER GETTING AN ANIME-"
Well, that wasn't too long of a wait was it..
This moment in the video immediately came to mind when I heard the anime was announced. I am so hyped about the anime. The trailer looks beautiful.
It is good to be alive.
@@NobleWrot bro I screamed when I saw the announcement I am also very excited
@@shivankarsrijansingh2155 Oh yeah. I watched that reveal trailer on a loop for a solid hour. Maybe an exaggeration, but only slightly.
Well, you were right!!
@@NobleWrot true true
Gigguk: "Komi-san is never getting an anime!"
Later Komi-san gets an anime
Gigguk: "The manga was better"
komi san won't work as an anime imo.... but we will see if it is possible
Nope. Still not anime
@@sincalo I mean depends on who doing the adapting but i feel that it could even be better for a lot of the more emotional scene since we would be able to hear the delivery of a lot of Komi lines. Really, just as long as they dont do what 'Is this a Zombie' did where they had a fake,' voice to dub the lines on Eulicwood's notepad, (while it worked for that show, i just dont think it would fit with Komi humor), it should be fine.
the forbidden cursed doujinshi was better and should never be found
Aluin
If only there was a sequence of numbers that related to your comment. Perhaps on a website beginning with “n”?
"Komi-san is never getting a anime"
Peace was never a option
....
War never changes
Only the victorious write the history books.
@@VaughanRoderick Even if you win, nothing will change the fact that _komi-san is never getting a anime._
"War has changed. It's no longer about nations, ideologies or ethnicity. It's an endless sereis of proxy battles fought by mercenaries and machines.
War, and its consumption of life, has become a well-olied machine. War has changed.
ID-tagged soldiers carry ID-tagged weapons, use ID-tagged gear. Nanomachines inside their bodies enhance and regulate their abilities.
Genetic control, information control, emotion control, battlefield control…everything is monitored and kept under control.
War…has changed.
The age of deterrence has become the age of control, all in the name of averting catastrophe from weapons of mass destruction, and he who controls the battlefield, controls history.
War…has changed.
When the battlefield is under total control, war becomes routine.”
― David Hayter as Solid Snake
That one fuckin hurt
@@ilovekisses5061 I was almost expecting that to be a 40K reference.
"you can't hurt me"
*"KOMI-SAN IS NEVER GETTING AN ANIME!!!"*
Nothing hurts more than this. I underestimated his warning
Drops card: *NO GAME NO LIFE WILL NEVER HAVE A SEASON 2*
This card is a double edged sword
But Nagatoro totally will.
Does it even need an anime? I feel that the manga’s charm is best captured in manga form. Some manga are just better without an adaptation.
@@evo683 i think the H better than the manga
Underestinated lol
Light novel readers: I'm a whole dimension ahead of you.
I read Lns mangas and watch animes
@@L.L4041 the pacifier
laughs in re:zero
Visual novel readers:
These *f o o l s* don't know what they're going into
Hahahaha Doing all Three really puts you ahead.
Anime fan: “I really like this anime”
Manga reader: “the manga was better”
Light novel reader: “the light novels better”
The manga artist/writer: “fools you don’t know my true power”
You forgot, Web novel reader: "the web novel was better"
Yusuke Murata drawing One Punch Man: "Ehh, that one scene wasn't good enough...Imma redraw the entire chapter"
Fools all of you. the xxxxxx was better.
@@alainpiera7139 Obviously the hentai was best, that goes without saying.
Goverment: Allow us to introduce ourselves.
Anime reader: oh boy I love this anime
Manga reader: I'm 3 seasons ahead of you
Light novel reader: I'm 20 seasons ahead of you
Doujinshi readers: I'm 5 multiverses ahead of you
lol
@@Animetor I see you are a man of culture as well
My man really said anime reader😂...wait...he outsmarted me...
The author: I am god
@@cyanidemonkey3957 😂😂😂😂😂
Anime only: breathes
Manga reader: YOU KNOW WHO ELSE USED TO BREATHE [INSERT DED CHARACTER]
not the person who sent you link on chat dead*
I do believe all Hamon users
Dude, that new movie trailer for Demon Slayer. I go into the comments and IMMEDIATELY get spoiled on a death...giga mad
@@infintecatvids8860 same thing happened to me, that is the reason why I hate manga readers.
Spoiler -> your next favourite Manga/Anime will end.
;)
"Komi-san will never get an anime".
-Gigguk, 2019
I just appreciate and glad how this joke didn't age very well.
Say cheese
and a second season as well
On the other hand, his statement on The Promised Neverland aged phenomenally.
"can't a guy enjoy both manga and anime?"
everyone: "sorry but that's illegal"
Thats why gigguk exist
I enjoy both
I do that. Suzuka, Magi, Rozen Maiden and Slam Dunk are some examples.
However, the original medium is generally the better one simply because it's how the work has been thought of and produced in the first place. There may be some exceptions, when the difference in quality is undeniable: for example the first series of Shingeki no Kyojin is visually so much better than the manga that it may be considered superior. Or Kimetsu no Yaiba, where, as far as i know, the anime is widely considered way more polished and refined. Also any manga that revolves around music or singing has obviously potential to be better as an anime.
I do it
i enjoy both versions of some series
while sometimes i do prefer the manga over anime
"Komi san is never getting an anime"
This hurt man.
But why??
@@divyanshkumar4762 Its a very popular manga that people really want an anime for, but currently has not been announced for one
@@domquixote9975 kyoto animation is best for making this legendary manga into the ANIME
"I liked Jojo's"
"The manga was better"
"I liked FMA"
"The manga was better"
"I liked Code Geass"
"..."
What about Hellsing!?
Code Geass sucks!
THE MANGA WAS BETTER.
Holy shit, this resonates with me on such a deep level...
Way back in the day when I was a little casual weeb I watched Code Geass, fell in love with it and at an anime convention the same year I saw the manga being sold.
I bought all the volumes...
Yeah....
@@rautes Well, that sucks.
But didn't you know anything about the manga back then? The knightmare stuff and else I mean.
Btw, is it true that everyone there has a Geass?
Gigguk: “manga readers”
Captions: _mArgaRiTas_
😂
Gigguk: Anime fans
Captions: Enemy fans
th-cam.com/video/2l7Lfi0lCFg/w-d-xo.html
in the case of Shield Hero
Anime: I love this show
Manga: Definitely better than the anime
Light Novel: Have fun with your diluted version
Web Novel: I WAS THERE BEFORE THE STARS HAVE SHONE IN THE SKY
my take on this was: first the manga then i read the WN, then watched the anime and finally the LN... that was a fucking roadcoaster
i loved the anime, fucking HATED the manga, read bits and pieces of the LN and somewhat enjoyed it
Life script:
Allow me to introduce myself.
I felt so fucking old when the anime came out. its been 6 fucking years since I read the WN
@@blazeheathciff2190 good old days
"Komi-san is never getting an anime" is truly the most offensive sentence ever spoken. 😔😂
Yes, but consider what would happen if they Jistu wa Watashi wa it.
The only reason komi San isn't getting an anime is because there is no voice actor good enough for komi
@@khaosgod7029 lmao, she's speaking a lot in the recent chapters though
@@nightshade7092 No voice actor is good enough, talking or nay
Just as I heard that line I was going to angrily type in the comments. But yours was the first one. xD
I'm so fed up with Game of Thrones fanboys. The manga was better.
Ln was better
Imagine actually being a live action-only. That’s what HBO GOT normies are.
I'm fed up with Game of Thrones. RRM was a better sci-fi writer.
The novel is better
novel is better
I honestly respect light novel readers cause there aren't enough of them to spoil
if you go watch an anime that was originally a lightnovel or webnovel though, the fans that are light novel readers are so many, like that time I got reincarnated as a slime or mushoku tensei and re:zero
Some light novel covers spoil the damn story
bruhh I tried to read a light novel and never ever have been so confused in my life
@@sunshineblues4424 obviously you can't read
@@joshua_prime3743 I know how you feel. I got spoiled real hard when the light novel version of Endgame had dead Batman on the cover.
"Komi-san is never getting an anime!!"
*Ay que puto*
Lol
"Komi-san is never getting an anime!"
Me: "But oyasumi punpun is, right? Right?"
You're pfp makes this comment so much better
I figure it's most likely because they can't properly make a popular manga where the main protagonist barely talks into a popular anime.
@@OggerFN I thinks better if it shouldn't have. It's pretty tough to adapt.
Manga reader: Who are you?
Light Novel reader: *I’m you but better*
Anime: I'm you but even further beyond.
@Momo-San Thats true.
*webnovel reader enters the room*
Webcomic reader: Finally, a worthy opponent!
webnovel reader:
"Komi - san is never getting an anime"
So you have chosen death
That hurts
"KOMI SAN IS NEVER GETING AN ANIME"
Me:TAKE THAT BACK YOU PEACE OF SHI-
That cuts deep
Truly a devastating reality
Im so hurt
*Light novel reader sticks head out door*
The novel is better
*closes door*
"Komi-san will never get an anime"
*The council will decide your fate*
I had to laugh, but it's "the council will decide your fate"
@@rryumi oh right, my bad
Wasn't it the senate?
'Cause...
*I am the Senate!*
He's to dangerous to be left alive!
Anyone who objects of disgreeing shall be punished by crusifixion
Deep down we all know that the doujin readers are superior.
Lmao
No denying that
A man of culture
The real galaxy brain people are the ones who spoil a doujin anime adaptation for anime only watchers.
wise words
In the manga he said "Komi-san is getting a Netflix adaptation" but the phrase was so offensive the anime production staff had to replace it
I see what u did there
In the light novel, it specifically mentions some kind of streaming service that came from America I never understood how they could change the source material like that.
Meanwhile, visual novel readers: “You know there’s like.. 10 different endings right?”
then you have people like me that are very defensive on what constitutes a game, verses people that say visual novels and simulators are games.
POV you're a fate fan
@@DankRobotyes unironically, fate has a vn-only direct sequel
Manga Readers: *SPOIL EVERYTHING*
Light Novel Reader: Hold my paragraph
Not all anime has light novel
@@snayperkill6218 Not all of them but a pretty great number has. Almost all non-shounen anime or manga has.
**Enjoying the video**
"Komi-san is never getting an anime"
**gets up of the chair abruptly** WHAT DID YOU SAY?
God I hope he's wrong
The one thing that, manga and anime fans can't ruin *Evangelion 3.0+1.0*
*Animation studio:* whoops we accidentally put this part of this movie in another movie, I *hope* that doesn't ruin anything.
Komi san like Komi san can’t communicate?
@@jokerkingss9037 boo that was a bad joke, and you should feel bad! *yelled from back of the audience*
AConfusedPerson who are you??
Gigguk: "KOMI-SAN IS NEVER GETTING AN ANIME"
Subtitles: "Comey son is not getting an animal"
lol the subtitles censured that phrase because it was too much for us manga readers
true sadness is within the dark abyssal depths of my heart
Dammit, poor kid. I knew he only wanted a puppy 😭😭
Are you happy now that Komi-san won the competition for "The most wanted manga to be made into anime"?
@@mateuszkarpacki9331 yeah, but while I would love a Komi-sama anime, I dread the fact that an animation house won't do it justice, I think KyoAni, who are awesome with slice of life manga and can turn a sub par product to a fucking masterpiece K-On!
It really hurt.....
I came back to this video just so I could say that Komi-san is getting an anime adaptation
same bro
Yeah
The video was okay. Gotta say though.
The manga was better.
Nice
The WordPress article was the best
the script was better
nice manga but to be honest
the light novel was better
Sukotto21 nah I think the webtoon was best
"Komi-san is never getting an anime"
Peace was never an option
*But war is...*
*Kaguya-sama*
Are goddess Life must survive
I really fucking need an anime for "Vertical Country"
fuck the nay sayers. they also said kizumonogatari and index s3 would never happen. still hoping for the rest of FMP, haruhi, NGNL, Oregairu, spice and wolf..... one day
You take that back
Spoiling in plain sight: exists
Jojo fans: Why not just outright spoil everything?
What I find funny is that jojo fans do that and no one bats an eye at that. If it were any other series tho...........
@@Healeon In my experience having only watched the anime I personally feel like alot of the enjoyment from the show was taken away because of the fact that I had already been spoiled so much even about parts that haven't been animated yet.
Me: Why let anyone spoil it for you if you can SPOIL IT BY YOURSELF.
@@phd9335 Some deaths are too apparent in JoJo. Like anyone with the last name of Zeppeli. But anyone who spoils part 6,7,8 outside Japan is an asshole, they literally didn't start getting a good translation of the manga until 2013, and they only have official manga translations of up to part 4. There's no excuse for other parts though, part 5 has had decent translations since 2005. Part 4 had the Duwang scans, but they were better than nothing.
Spoiler: 4 balls
4:56
Gigguk: Komi-San will never get an anime
2021: KOMI-SAN IS GETTING AN ANIME CONFIRMED!!!
For a series so popular that it dragged a non-anime-fan like me into the realm of the weebs, I'm surprised that its adaptation came so late.
“An Honest Breakdown”
**press X to doubt**
X
Zesty SpinachSama X
Cross
F
BREAKDOWN BREAKDOWN
Anime fan: *smiles*
Manga reader: *grins*
LN Reader: *laughs*
WN Reader: *laughs from mars*
VN Gamer: *Trespasses space and time itself, merges every reality and laughs like a literal Satan*
Actually so true. The VN gamers are on an actual other level.
@Aloise Dawdle
Web novel
Know story from hcg. Heh
@@eruno_ What the fuck is the difference
Finally some recognition
"the manga was better"
"wtf is wrong with you man, I'm reading light novel"
"... the manga was better"
For some story, somehow it really works like that tho. One that I know is Youjo Senki.
hafizh makmur dafaq?
The light novel is always the best narrative experience.
Guren TGC that’s subjective
Abderian well every form of art IS subjective.
johnny depp there are some bad shit novels out there just as manga and anime.
live adaptation enjoyers < Normies < people who only watch anime for aesthetic < dub watchers < sub watchers < people who understand Japanese < manga readers < light novel readers < the person who writes the show < people who write and draw doujinish
The chain of life
True dat
what about the people that only read manga but not anime
@@vodkasion8325 they fall under manga readers
Huh I’m pretty high up on this list.....
I love how the entirety of the Japanese population has more respect from the community than regular anime watchers
"komi-san is never getting an anime" i laughed, then i cried
i doubt u have red it it pains me seeing u guys claming to know what its about
Light novel readers: “how cute, the monkeys are playing with sticks!”
Web novel readers: "hey, did you see those idiots entertaining themselves watching monkeys fight over there ?"
machine translation readers: "uh... yeah... good for them..."
Author : hah
XD
@@siragon756 Also Web novel readers: "Shit, his horse isn't named Mother? Fucking translation team."
"Who's here after chapter (insert number)?"
-every manga reader ever
Daamn you said it not me
Who’s here after aot chapter 138
@@kintama3453 whos here after 139
@@dontask7409 very sad times :(
@@dontask7409 sad
4:56 so fucking happy this aged poorly
but now I'm concerned about how the adaptation will be handled and the quality of the official subs
*"YOU ARE NOT READY FOR SEASON 4 NEXT YEAR! BELIEVE ME! IM NOT READY EITHER! YOU ARE NOT READYY FOR IT!"*
-Manga readers 2019
Every single bnha manga reader. And guess what i enjoyed this season the least cause it was shit apart from few scenes
@@rajder656 you will be a lot more not readier this Fall. Yes. A lot. More. Not readier.
@@rajder656 I feel like the Overhaul arc was adapted over a lot sloppier then ppl were expecting,hence the disappointment amongst all the hype. It rlly is a good arc,but a good majority wasn't executed to the degree of quality the series had in previous seasons,especially Mirios fight. On top of this,I feel like to many were hyping the season up on the chance the Overhaul arc would be higher quality then it was,totally forgetting the arc tht would come after. Fall Festival Arc is rlly just a bore.
@@rajder656 *Dramatically pushes up glasses in manga reader*
@@imgrimcookie4773 my criticism are similar to what you said but it boils down to two main points 1) overall lower quality animation 2) pacing that looks similar to heart beat monitor. If you take away this two bnha is a generic ass shounen without anything actually good, it's just mediocre without any traits like the mcu style universe that index series created. Characters are the definition of generic,power system boring. Yes it has a few good hype scenes but if that is considered a "great show" then i guess darling in the franxx is 10/10 no questions asked
"Komi-san is never getting an anime!"
*ugly sobbing in the distance*
Stop, stop, he's already dead
"Komi san is never getting an anime"
Me: i didn't hear anything,did you hear anything?
Y'all hear summ? I ain't hear nothing
I heard Motley Crue with my vampire hearing
I heard George Lucas. Did anyone else hear George Lucas?
Kuro AMV i mean, if anything this just hurts the anime onlys
Hellsing is great
"Komi san is never getting an anime adaptation"
MY FELLOW WEEBS, IT IS TIME TO REJOICE, THE ADAPTATION HAS BEEN CONFIRMED!!!
Broke: "The manga was better"
Woke: "The visual novel was better"
the doujin was better
Super Woke: ^
ENLIGHTENED COSMIC WOKE: *Offbrand was better*
Trash Broke: *Netflix Adaptation was better*
INFINITE COSMIC WOKE: *MEMES ARE BETTER*
The Umineko anime is why I drink.
@@AceHalberjt We will get our full detailed movies of each part, just you WAIT!!! *proceeds to break down and cry*
“The hentai was better”
T R A N S C E N D E D
C O N C I O U S N E S S
Anime Watcher: Ok guys this is what happens next
Manga Reader: No it not
English Light Novel Reader: Yes it is, but it happens a lot letter in the Manga
Japanese Light Novel Reader: no it didn't, it was all the MC's plan
Author: Why are you even doing this to yourself, just enjoy it, because I can change it to whatever I want
Publishing Company: No you don't, it's not up to you, We are your boss, so change to what makes the most money for us
Basically eren in the manga
What about the original Shield Hero ending? Sometimes fans can be really pushy
Author identity is Wataru Watari.
Facts 😂
You forgot: "Original Web Novel published on some weird Japanese Website nobody has heard about" Reader: This is all wrong, it was the other guy that told MC but they cut them out the whole story for the official Light Novel!
“KOMI SAN IS NEVER GETTING AN ANIME”
You take that back...
I was more triggered when vagabond came into the background when he was talking about anime without manga
@@MyAce8 manga without anime
4:57 I have never forget this line and now... the tables have been turned dear gigguk and now you can't hurt me anymore
everyone is coming back to this video for that reason XD
Manga Readers "I already know the next season"
Tokyo Ghoul Season 2 exists
Fuck...
Too bad its trash... shoulda just adapted the manga
Tokyo ghoul anime fans: Wow! √A ended in a cliff hanger, I wonder what happens next!
Tokyo ghoul:re: *looms in the distance*
@@adrianj6795 More like im about to end this anime's whole career
@@creativename152 honestly tho
"Komi-san is never getting an anime!"
Mah hart, mah sole...
Your shoe sole?
:)
Its okay, ngnl never getting second season
@@saymynamerick9181 So you have chosen death
It will both Komi-san and NGNL will get another season or have an anime adaptation
Or I will start the Apocalypse
and for OPM, there's another level of fan we have to take into consideration
"ONE's original sketchy manga was better"
It is. ONE's original series feel like a sarcasm towards the shounen genre, and the sketch just amplify that.
@@archiebellega956 agree. I loved reading mob psycho
I admire ONEs writing skills however I prefer yusuke murata ( sorry if I spelt it wrong) art.
4:56 well well well grant, how the tables have turned
"Komi san is NEVER getting an anime!"
Ouch, I felt personally attack'd
F*ck me too
*"Komi-san is never getting an anime!"*
WHY DO YOU HAVE TO DO US LIKE THAT?!
Why is komi san so popular, *_i_* dont get it
no u
You heretic!
@@zzdahaewae cause its gud thats why
I was literally thinking “I’m surprised he didn’t bring up any kind of Light Novel stuff”
End of the video “Lol read my mind” 😆! Nice video though!
I knew it was coming all along. I am a web novel reader
*worship my supreme power*
@@aidanmattys7488 we all know that the light novel is still generally better translated than the web novels xDD
Andrei ddrhckrzz
And it's just not just the translation that's bad, web novels are basically just the beginning drafts of a LN and read terrible...
@@LeynaSept yeah, it's typically worse than the light novel version
I was gonna start reading death note tomorrow and you just put a sign on screen saying “L Dies”
Thanks 😂
"Komi-san will never get an anime"
*EVERYONE DISLIKED THAT*
I liked it
I fully support that statement
I never read the manga so I can't relate
I hope it never will.
I mean, how they would transform the scenes in the manga into anime?
I can't even imagine it.
@@wolfiefenrir9552 I think it could translate pretty well. Especially the more cute/heartwarming scenes would really benefit from some good voice acting.
I really liked that video but the script was better
AhahahhahHHha
sums up people who compare Light Novels/Manga and Anime
Well black and white letters are far better then a actual visual presentation
Said some manga stan
"And that one person that only watched Dragon ball Z"
LMAOO
Ngl this is pretty much everyone at my school.💀💀
Along with Pokemon and Naruto
@vohn 2x I mean the anime and the main manga for Pokemon are completely different. Though once again "the manga was better"
I feel like that's supposed to be 50 percent but lol
@@STANLL Yeah lol
4:55 Komi-San's getting an anime adaption in Oct, 2021
Light novel reader: closes the door and sees a webnovel reader standing there
Webnovel reader: "Hey."
Light novel reader: punches webnovel reader in the face
ilvanezzo Don’t the webnovels usually get taken down once the story is published?
@@alisethera9349 regarding fan translations, not really. Depends on the author/publisher, but if it's out and relatively popular, it can be found easily. Regarding JP sources, not so much. Although sometimes the LN version is different enough to warrant keeping both versions.
Jojo NICEEEE
@@ilvanezzo I like your profile pic. Are you still a Fallout fan, or are you something else, now?
@@FunZies. Of course I'm a fan, too bad it's been a whole 4 years since a new game has been released. I like both 2D and 3D Fallout, BTW.
Here's my stance: I read the manga and get ahead of the plot, then watch it with color and motion and sometimes less confusing fight coreographies. Manga = Substance
Anime = Spectacle
>Manga = substance
In context, that statement makes some degree of sense.
Out of context, and in general, that statement is nothing more than a joke.
@@derpedarp9041 I meant to say that manga readers get to experience the stories before anime watchers, and that anime is a nice way to relive/refresh the plot for those who'd read it on the manga before. I don't have a personal prefence. "Substance" was a bad choice of words.
@@pedrosobral4335 oh, good. Then I see we're in agreement, and that you are a fellow man of culture.
Yeahhhhh like when I see the animation in anime it helps me understand a lot more easily what punches, dodges, kicks, and attacks are being thrown. But I also find that manga sometimes has a lot more detail then others like in the singular panels where they go all out with the detail whether it’s a characters face or a setting. I tend to see a lot more detail there. But anime also makes the small funny panels and brings a lot more attention and light to them which you may not notice in the manga.
@@pedrosobral4335 agreed
The only series I can think of where anime and manga fans get along, is JoJo.
Just because there's no such thing as hating on Jojo, no matter how it is presented to you
That's because no one reads the manga.
we only get along until someone spoils part 6, 7 or 8. which happens all the fucking time
@@salman6254
Do you live on a cave or something?
@@salman6254 best part is part 7 duh
I enjoy both. Manga more often have more details, character development and easy to speed through. Animate have better cinematic effects and it really helps to draw you into the story. Light novel on the other hand is like a combination of both.
"Komi san is never getting an anime"
Everyone: SAY SIKE RIGHT NOW
I'm actually kinda glad with that. Mostly because of how wildly the manga has been barreling up and down in 'quality' or 'progression' in the last 50 or so chapters. I can barely handle the now massively flanderized characters in the manga as is, let alone in anime form where *those* annoying side characters will have voices.
@@Valanway ok boomer
Who is Komi san?
@@londonboi5135 komi san wa komyushou desu - Komi san can't communicate
That hurt me more than I want to admit
Anime watcher: "Im the best"
Manga reader: "Im far more superior"
???: "Pathetic."
Manga reader/Anime watcher: "WHAT DID YOU SAY?"
Visual Novel reader: " *PATHETIC* "
Wed Novel Reader: *quietly stands behind VN reader Big Brother while simultaneously judging everyone*
It's the best of both worlds.
Not rly but enough time for good story and characters mixed with sound design and usually great OST's is pretty damn good.
*coughuminekocough*
doujin reader: "the doujin was better"
@@kyuu_09 it's the superior form ain't no one gonna ever argue to that
"Here's an out of context image to tell you how foolish you are."
*High school flashbacks*
Loving the Julius Seizure reference 😂 it’s just so creative! Subscribed 👌🏻
Me, a manga-reading intellectual: "Ha, Gigguk cant say anything to hurt me!"
Gigguk: "KOMI-SAN IS NEVER GETTING AN ANIME!"
Me: cries
Its okay, the manga was better
as a manga reader, why would a manga not getting an anime be an issue if the manga is always better?
also lol translated manga scrubs, gotta read manga and LN/WN in the original japanese
:((
"manga-reading intellectual" Oh god. Fucking geek. Who calls themselves intellectual, really? People who haven't lived a very great social life for sure.
@@TOMOTOMOA Hopefully it was.
"Komi-san is never getting an anime "
I cried .
Honestly, komi san is best enjoyed in manga format instead of becoming adapted and would feel like a generic slice of life show
Gigguk: *"Komi-san is never getting an anime"*
Me and the anime community: Sir, it's him right there.
Arrest him.
Fucking weeb.
Weeb fucking.
Jaym Prado feeb wucking
King fuweeb
Weebing fuck
4:57 Oh, has times changed and how so wrong we have been
I can't concentrate on a whole anime episode but can easily read all day long that's why I became a manga reader over an anime watcher. I still watch anime but definitely not nearly as much as I read manga.
I'm definitely also guilty of reading ahead once I actually watch an anime because yes I'm an impatient person and can't wait literal years for the next season.
see thats fine but when they start spoiling this is where we hate them
Other way around for me
You watch 1 hour flims but cant watch 20 minute episode, yea right
Go back to your dead forum with 8 people with the same hypocrtial arguments as yourself
"Komi san is never getting an anime"
It's sad cause we know it's true.
Heitor Nihongo that part was both painful but hilarious
@@supportpossum5672 In 2:18 What Anime Is That?.
NINJA H.Q. I think you meant to comment that rather than reply, but it’s rascal does not dream of bunny girl senpai
@@AUselessGod one punch man
So komi-san cant get an anime, but redo of healer can get one. This are dark times we live in.
Manga Readers: We are Superior Beings
Light Novel Readers: Allow us to Introduce ourselves
Web Novel Readers: Would you like to talk about our lord and saviour Machine Translation?
@@laujie6470 haha I like that
normies: degenerates
Webtoon: waiting in the shadows
@@ren96706 notice me senpai
That Julius Caesar joke slayed me so hard, it was like I was stabbed 23 times by the punchline.
"Komi san is never gettting an anime"
A little part of my soul died right then and there
"For good boys and girls of all ages"
Nice nintendo reference jokes
Gigguk - “manga that don’t have an anime adaptation”
Gigguk - **shows Vagabond**
Me: REEEEEEEE
They won't be able to animate something that will do justice to the manga's art
As a manga elistist prick, I'm more triggered that Vagabond is on permanent hiatus.
@Jafr. apparently he's busy on other projects.
@Jafr. Cries in HxH
@@adityapathak5761 except that the art of HxH's manga is shit compared to Vagabond's
4:56 welp, look at the news bois
*_"KOMI-SAN IS NEVER BECOMING AN ANIME!"_*
so you have decided war...
Our troops are ready, general.
It's treason then
So, you have chosen death.
Execute Order 66
Ikr ,SHE IS AN ACTUAL GODESS
"Komi San will never get an anime"
It's time for another crusade
thank god
8:05 "...and laughing at anyone who decided to watch dubbed anime"
*This man is spitting facts*
Dubbed anime doesn't compare to the original in 99,9999% of cases
@@willywonka7932 you just proved his point XD
@@stefanbroers8146 it's like saying I proved you need oxygen to breathe and that's somehow weird because he ridiculed the statement
Dbz sds and devil is a part timer were all really good dubs
@@mantrasharma303 I agree for dbz and dip haven't heard sds dub doesn't change the fact that 99,9999 percent of anime dub is way worse than the original
Came back now that Komi-san is getting animated
"Komi San is never getting an anime"
*Silent stares*
Call 911 someone is about to die
GustavTheRailwayGun 😂😂😂
Man that hurt a lot!
Now I sad!
@#$$&!!!!!
*silent stare intensified*
i doubt u have red it it pains me seeing u guys claming to know what its about
Manga and anime fans: *exists*
Light novel fans: "I'm about to end these people's whole careers"
-This comment was made by the Goblin Slayer novel readers gang
NAMLES Slime Tensei lets go
Mushoku Tensei ftw
Can I know where to read light novel?
I want to ascend to whole new level.
Anime fans: Pre-hiatus ending
Manga fans: The True Ending
Light novel readers: ALL THE ENDINGS!
This video isn't bad, BUT
THE SCRIPT WAS BETTER
Rofl dude why this comment don't have thousand likes
Not a valid 1:1 comparison, but ok
4:07 Hey Gigguk, why are you spoiling what happened with Eren? Can you see the FUTURE???
Spoiler:
4:42