Facts:- 1.rashid sahb sang low notes and high notes with perfections,rahat can not sing low notes cause he has never sang low in his life,years of high singing and no kharaj riyaaz does this to you. 2.rahat realizes his weakness but maintains his composure and tries to sing high but the melody demands him to return to low notes which causes him discomfort and he gets besura. 3.apart from lack of kharaj riyaaz another reason for almost negligible chest voice with rahat is that he smokes which causes shortage of breath when singing low. Hence to all my singers out there nothing replaces imandaar riyaaz.
As a professional singer and especially when you are trained under the great Ustad Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan sahb you don't have right to complian you can't sing at low pitch or scale its so un professional. Ty👍🏻
कोई भी राग गाते हैं या कोई गीत गाते हैं या बंदिश या ठुमरी कुछ भी गाते हैं उस राग या उस लिखे हुए गीत की आत्मा वही रहनी चाहिए , रंग वही रहना चाहिए। यहां मंगल गा रहे हैं , जलजला नहीं आया है सजन आया है। प्रेम गीत है । आक्रामक गीत नहीं। उस्ताद राशिद जी ने शानदार गाया है। बाकी का तो सब राहत साहब के लिए लिखा ही है मैंने।
दो अलग अलग फूल हैं एक खुश्बू हम नहीं पा सकते हैं। खयाल गायकी में राशिद साहब के साथ राहत साहब की जुगलबंदी उचित नहीं है और तेरे मस्त मस्त दो नैन गीत के साथ राशिद साहब की जुगलबंदी उचित नहीं होगी । ऐसे फ़िर भी अच्छा लगा । राशिद साहेब की तान नाभि और गले से था जबकी राहत साहब ने तान करने मे गले ओर शरीर दोनो को हिला दिया ।🙏🌹
Rahat has always gone besura at times when singing live. But this was painful to listen to. I don't know if maybe he doesn't do proper riyaz anymore because he is just singing for movies. Ustad g ka gana bhi kharab kia
Yes he isn't comfortable because rashid khan sahab is main stream classical singer and rahat fateh ali khan is a qawali sufi singer..... and it's not competition between both of them music is just beauty never a competition...but i have to say rashid khan saab has lot more trained vocals.
Ustad Rahat Fateh ali Khan is God for me and I am not eligible to comment for Ustad Rashid Khan but after watched this video I feel high pitch voice is not the main thing for a legendary singer. But still now Rahat ji is my God and Ustad Rashid Khan Sir is proud for all of us and my inspiration also.
@@durranivlog7759 are ek swar bhi taan me sahi ga nahi pae rahat bhai kya bat karte ho aap ki vo type me gaa rahehe are kitne kalonse yahi he classical he aur yahi rahega
looks like since nusrat saab left, rahat stopped riaz of classical, nusrat used to make him practice in every concert. but now hes more into bollywood songs. but its classical with semi classical mosiqui, rashid is better in classical, rahat is better in qawali and bollywood songs. imagine if it was salamat ali khan and rashid khan. i don't belive anyone ever is as great vocalist as salamat ali khan
@@ij_1243 nope, joshi ji was great too, but salamat was extra ordinary, those taans pandit joshi ji and other classical do hardly and their face changes, for salamat those were like piece of cake. crazy vibrations on chrometic level and micro tonal changes.
Ustad Rashid khaan saheb ki gayki lajwab hai ,raht fateh ali ji unke pair ki dhool ke barbar bhi nhi hai, Ustad ke sath gana to chhodiye unke saamne baithhne ke liye bhi bahot Riyaz chahiye ,ustad Rashid Khan Saheb ki to gayki hi lajwab hai ,jai ho
Rashid need not to imitate and bring any ones style to his performance he is a class apart which is clearly visible without lens ,,,,,,,KUCH BHI ,,,,KAMAALHAI YAAR JARA TO SOCHO
OMG... many times I search to find out any jugalbandi in this singers... but I couldn't find out... Today its come to me... I am very happy now... even I just it play now its going...hope full jugalbandi will be enjoyable...
@home multiplex Bhaiya samjh lia Karo Tab bolakaro Rahat Fateh alikhaan playback singer Hain unka andaaaz alaghai unki tayyari alag hai even ustad rashid Khan is not a playback type voice. He is only singing bandish.. Rahat Fateh ali Khan Sahabe ne bht gaane gaayehain acche
@@danishmusic7069 ONLY BANDISH.. tumhe pta bhi h bandish gana kya cheez hoti... Raag m 10 minute tak improvisation bhi mushkil hota h.. ustad Rashid Khan to 1 ghnte tak raag ko gaate h....or rhi baat light gane ki to unhone gaye h eg aaoge jab tum sajna etc pr asal baat ye h ki vo khud hi classical gana psnd krte h kyunki vo unk dil k sabse Kareeb h.. kyunki vo asal or pure cheez h
Both have sung well. But Rahat saab has different field of singing thats why it sounded little bit uncomfortable .But Ustad Nusrat saab was supreme in all types of singing. 🙏🙏🙏🙏
First of all, I don't think they are competing with one another. Secondly one of them is Ustad in pure hindustani classical music so there is no need of comparison. In the end music wins ❤️
संगीत समंदर है और इस समंदर में अलग अलग नदिया आती है यहीं समाहित होती है यही सत्य है। सब अपनी field की ग़ायकी के उस्ताद है 😊 चाहे ध्रुपद ग़ायकी हो, ठुमरी, शास्त्रीय गायिकी हो, क़व्वाली, ग़ज़ल, कर्नाटकी हो। हरि बोल ❤️
2 singers have different genre .... Rashid khan saab never sing qawwali (only singing khayal) ...Rahat saab never sing khayal so do not compare rahat saab to rashid khan sir...👍 I am big fan of rahat fateh ali khan
भाई दोनों ही उस्ताद है लेकिन ये भी सच है उस्ताद नुसरत साहब का कभी भी सुर नही गया लेकिन राहत साहब कई बार सुर से चले गये । नुसरत साहब जैसा कोई भी फनकार अब इस दुनियाँ में आना सम्भव नहीं है। और राशिद खान साहब तो कमाल है सच्चे सुरों के मालिक
Sir excuse me rahat apne zone main bhi nhi gaa rha uski aukaat nursat sahab ki gayaki ko chuna bhi nhi hai bas unke marne ke baad unhi ke naam ka khaa rha hai ye is se zyada sureele to humare chote chote Begginers bache gaa lete hai...
And maharaj ji rashid sahab ne ustad naam kamaya hai gaa kar isliye vo ustad rashid ali khan ji hai Or ye nepotism ke chalte rehete nursat sahab ka ustad kaat kar apne naam ke aage lagata hai 😂😂
Rahat Fateh Ali khan bahot acha nibhaya qawal gawaya ka kam kar gaya bsss app dono ke lie duaa hai yar Rahat khan tan technical kamal kar dia Razshid khan bhi dunia main ek admi gawaya salamat rahen dono khan sahiban
Actually the two legends(Rahat and Rashid) are performing together which is good sign of love and it lefts no doubt in that "An Artist is of Art Not of State". However where its concerned with performance I have reached to the following points after hearing this video; 1) Rahat and Rashid both have different musical backgrounds their melodies, styles, works are totally different and they both are expert in their own music 2) people are criticizing Rahat in their comments that he is even not able to compete with Rashid Saab that wrong. The song they are performing is a Master peace of Rashid Khansab. Most of the people knows him for his this song. 3) I accept that Rahat missed the place(Sum) hardly two times. So this doesn't means he can't this song. He is a legend. Think board mindedly that might be he was not well, might he was tired, etc.
First Time Rahat Fateh Ali Khan seems beaten From legendry singing and soft singing of Ustaad Rashid Ali Khan Only High notes don't make you a great Singer
Ye parking baat ...master Saleem and rahat ki jab performance hui thi tab bhi rahat was only singing high notes ..but mrji or harqtie nai hai inke pass ..or even rahat or hans Raj hans ki bhi jab duo hua tab bhi scale hi tha harqtie ya yaani m hans Raj ji ka bhi koi jawab nai tha ...
Ustad rashid khan sahab legendary level 🔥🔥 maine unhe live suna hai , he is true legend of hindustani classical music , this jugalbandi is great , rashid khan sahab harkatein bade pyaar se lete hain ❤😍
Jugalbandi same type / style of singers k beech hona chahiye, yahan pe Ustad Raashid khan sb. is from pure classic style while Ustad Rahat Khan sb. comes from semi classic qwali hence the difference is obvious. Still it is a good effort, I appreciate. Thanks a lot.
Sur kisi ka bhi utar skta hai.....rahat sabh ke purane videos dekho jisme vo Nusrat saahb ke sath taiyaari krre h ...khud ab smjh AA jayega Kya level h
@@zrockjii2280 pure classical singer ki kabhi sur utar taa hai??.nusrat sahab,kausiki Chakrabarti,rashid khan,Amir khan sahab,Mehndi Hasan sahab inlogo ki kabhi sur nehi hilta hai.Sirf practice is not enough consistency is also required.
As far as live signing is concerned, rahatji always suffers from bad throat..I have listened him many times trying hard on live show...yes in recording version he sounds great 👍...jab ki Rashid sab ka koi sani nahi..true legend of indian claasical...
@@fahadali4793 baap hoon tera aa ja tere ko seekhata hoon Gana kya hota ...sur ki samjh hoti tumko to Gian ni dete ...iska mtlb sur ki samjh hi ni tumko ...
Bahut sahi bola aapne janaab. Jhaato me uljhaa ke patak de .rashid khaa saab aise qawaalo ko . Himmat kaise Hui iski... paas bethne ki rashid khaa saab ke ! Main to heraan hun
@@zuberkgolechha are mere bhai apni apni jagah sabhi theek hain, aise to fir ustad nusrat fateh ali khan ji bhi qawali gaate the fir to wo bhi aapke hisab se kush nahi
I have listened both live. Rashid is ultra legend there voice so deep & meledious , he is ultra legend. On the other hand , sometimes Rahat sir in live sounds little offtune ( Iike someone screaming ) . If you have to choose out one's concert over other , Rashid sir is best anyday . I bet you , you will never be dissappinted.
Great Ustad Salamat ali (late) once said on Great NFAK's 2nd death anniversary about Rahat that NFAK taught him everything now its upto him how he carries his legacy but he turned out to be a crap by leaving his family tradition and legacy.
absolutly right. hope rahat realise that and keep the legacy. he has great voice. Salamat ali khan saab ki to baat hi kya hai. ustadon ke ustad the salamat sahab.
For the people complaining that Rahat sahab is weak than Ustad Rashid, can you sing like Rahat? I'm a musician and i can see clearly the competition on Ustad Rashid's face . Rahat sahab is not not the best but definitely one of the best, he is the student of ustaad Nusrat.
I must want to mention that Ustad Rashid khanji not even compare with Rahat Fateh ali, Ustad Rashid ji is a pure classical legend and Rahat not even compare or even not fit for jugalbandi ...
Ustad Rashid Khan saahb 🙏 rahat fateh ali khan ko sahan kar rahe hai kuchh bol nahi sakte but itna besura pan aur proud kitna hai unke samne rasid Khan saah vinamra 🙏 ye hoti hai shastriya sangeet karo ki tahezib 🙏🙏🙏
I think first of all Rahat has a very high pitch voice and this song is low pitch Secondly he has a little problem in edgy voices but he still manages.
First of all Rahat Fateh Ali Khan shab is not a classical singer. He is a Sufi singer. So why people r comparing him with (Ustaad Rashid Kha). Both are legends in there own jounar 🙏🙏♥️♥️. Jitne log bhi comment kar rahe h. We all are not having the capabilities to earn what they have earned in their time 😊
राहत जी यहाँ पर जैसा गा रहे है वो तो संगीत को समझने वाले जान ही गये होगे,,,पर मै तो ये कहना चाहता हूँ कि ये राशिद सहाब को भी ठीक से गाने नही दे रहे है उनके गायन मे (राहत जी) व्यवधान डाल रहे है,,,
Rahat sahab is a very good singer but somehow he do not seem to be comfortable here. He also tried to add some sargam from his usual songs which sounded bad
In this concert Pt. Subhankar Banerjee on tabla with Usad Rasid Khan and Rahat fateh ali khan, but he is no more, passed away on 25 Aug. 2021, this is a great loss.
नमन करता हूँ उस्ताद राशिद खान साहब को..... जो इतनी देर तक राहत के भटके हुए सुरों को झेल गए!! दो मिनट का मौन राहत साहब के भटके हुए 'षडज' के लिए 😞😞😶😶😶😶🙏🏻
This jugalbandi was such a bizarre idea, because both legends are master of different craft. This criticism would be quite opposite if Rashid Khan Sahab had to sing RFAK Sahab's songs. When Rashid Khan Sahab sang "Naina thag lein gy" he couldn't create the magic RFAK was able to create. But hats off to Rahat Fateh Ali Khan who, despite knowing, sat with Rashid Khan Sahab and sang his songs.
Jisne ye video upload Kiya hai Thanks for that..But in Dono Ustad ne jo gaya hai, uska 1% bhi kar pana v mushkil hai..uske liye Music aur Sargam ki knowledge hona zaruri hai. Please change the title of your Video
Jahan thumri, ghazal, qawwali, bhajan, film sangeet khatam hota, wahan se classical shuru hota hai. We have seen this earlier also when Rashid Khan teamed up with Talat Aziz.
@@kansensangeet8206 Bhai Surr ka style se lena dena nahi hai, Style koi b ho surr na lage to kya faiyda Aur dusri baat Classical me Qawaali gussaoge aur vo bhi besure hoke to ajeeb to lagega he ….
@@kansensangeet8206bhai classical to sabne sikhi hai na rahat ne bhi sikhi hai kawwal log bahut achchha classical gaate hai but raahat ne thik se seekha nahi hai
The range of classical singer voice is unmatchable no matter howmuch high you sing but classical voice will aways be appreciated and soothing to everyones ears... It gives sukoon in every note.. Not the qawwali high pitch voice...
I'm Big Fan Of Rahat Fateh ali khan Sir But Rashid Sir Voice Has More Feel During this Performance.... Sorry edited - Rahat Sir Bidi Cigrattenoshi Bamd Kr Do Abhi
Rashidji you are already an international vocalist. What is the necessity to sit with these commercial clown who is totally untuned. Voice throw is so rough. Rajat is only good for studio where you can take several takes and tune through software. The only commercial artist who can sit with you are Hariharanji and Shankar Mahadevanji.
Rashid: Building Ahir Bhairav Rahat: Destroying Ahir Bhairav. Different genre but still Rahat is way out of tune... And Rahat's performance has too much show off but less music.
Facts:-
1.rashid sahb sang low notes and high notes with perfections,rahat can not sing low notes cause he has never sang low in his life,years of high singing and no kharaj riyaaz does this to you.
2.rahat realizes his weakness but maintains his composure and tries to sing high but the melody demands him to return to low notes which causes him discomfort and he gets besura.
3.apart from lack of kharaj riyaaz another reason for almost negligible chest voice with rahat is that he smokes which causes shortage of breath when singing low.
Hence to all my singers out there nothing replaces imandaar riyaaz.
❤️
Best comment 🖤🌸
As a professional singer and especially when you are trained under the great Ustad Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan sahb you don't have right to complian you can't sing at low pitch or scale its so un professional. Ty👍🏻
@@WhiteFang-oq5dy Nusrat is not a classical musician . Know the difference between a qawwal and a khyal gayak
Yes 100 percent true and besr comment
कोई भी राग गाते हैं या कोई गीत गाते हैं या बंदिश या ठुमरी कुछ भी गाते हैं उस राग या उस लिखे हुए गीत की आत्मा वही रहनी चाहिए , रंग वही रहना चाहिए। यहां मंगल गा रहे हैं , जलजला नहीं आया है सजन आया है। प्रेम गीत है । आक्रामक गीत नहीं।
उस्ताद राशिद जी ने शानदार गाया है। बाकी का तो सब राहत साहब के लिए लिखा ही है मैंने।
As a classical music learner...i have realized it was not rahat saab day...it happens with every musician...no need to judge him🙃
Rahat wanted to match one of the classical music gods. He isn't even a complete singer.
Every day with ustad rashid khan sahab is his day
@kuldeep singh Rashid Khan is literally the 2nd Pandit Bhimsen Joshi. This fake ustad rahat wanted to match him. 😂😂
@@satyapriyadarshi93 bhimsen joshi ji to nahi h bhai unke jaisa sirf ek h mere guru pt. Harish Tiwari ji
@@amanpanchal4283 pranam apke guruji ko. And best of luck for learning 🤗
Rashid khan saab is something else. Salute from Pakistan
Ustad Rashid khan is beyond any comparison. He is a superb singer with melodious voice.
🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤
दो अलग अलग फूल हैं एक खुश्बू हम नहीं पा सकते हैं।
खयाल गायकी में राशिद साहब के साथ राहत साहब की जुगलबंदी उचित नहीं है और तेरे मस्त मस्त दो नैन गीत के साथ राशिद साहब की जुगलबंदी उचित नहीं होगी । ऐसे फ़िर भी अच्छा लगा ।
राशिद साहेब की तान नाभि और गले से था जबकी राहत साहब ने तान करने मे गले ओर शरीर दोनो को हिला दिया ।🙏🌹
You don't have that kind of talent to comment on Ustad Rahat Sahab's Singing.. both are gems... Respect others to get respect.. @Soubiri
Bas kar. Total disaster performance by crap Rahat. He does not deserve to be called Ustad.
Who are you to say this ??
Rahat has always gone besura at times when singing live.
But this was painful to listen to.
I don't know if maybe he doesn't do proper riyaz anymore because he is just singing for movies.
Ustad g ka gana bhi kharab kia
Yes he isn't comfortable because rashid khan sahab is main stream classical singer and rahat fateh ali khan is a qawali sufi singer..... and it's not competition between both of them music is just beauty never a competition...but i have to say rashid khan saab has lot more trained vocals.
Kiya kehny apki bat k
Correct @avi
Mry hisab sy dno ka apna apna ground ha lakin mujhy rahat sahab ki awaz ki high bht bhren
exactly
What about swars.?
Ustad Rahat Fateh ali Khan is God for me and I am not eligible to comment for Ustad Rashid Khan but after watched this video I feel high pitch voice is not the main thing for a legendary singer. But still now Rahat ji is my God and Ustad Rashid Khan Sir is proud for all of us and my inspiration also.
Ustad Rashid khan sahb is doing "Jabardast Taan"...
While Rahat is doing " Jabardasti ki Taan"
Hahahaha good one
Sir G bandish ka pta hai apko ya nhe.....ustad rahat us typ m gaa rhy hai
@@durranivlog7759 ye teental ki bandish hai... Isko teentaal me hi gaya jana chahiye jese Ustaad rashid khan gaa rhe h
@@durranivlog7759 are ek swar bhi taan me sahi ga nahi pae rahat bhai kya bat karte ho aap ki vo type me gaa rahehe are kitne kalonse yahi he classical he aur yahi rahega
Yr Lgta hai ap log zyada Bary singer hai Rahat Sir sy
I’m gonna go back to Ustad Rashid Khan’s solo albela and get a detox from this. Rahat Fateh Ali should not try to compete with Ustadji!
looks like since nusrat saab left, rahat stopped riaz of classical, nusrat used to make him practice in every concert. but now hes more into bollywood songs. but its classical with semi classical mosiqui, rashid is better in classical, rahat is better in qawali and bollywood songs. imagine if it was salamat ali khan and rashid khan. i don't belive anyone ever is as great vocalist as salamat ali khan
राहत को रियाज की जरूरत है ताल ज्ञान नही सम नही दे पा रहा 🙏 रासिद जी ने सब संभाला
@@Anuragtiwarimotifs sahi baat
@@sandhunba ji tnx
Just listen pt bhimsen joshi. He is the greatest exponent of Indian classical.
Great respect to salamat Saab but pt joshi is simply the greatest.
@@ij_1243 nope, joshi ji was great too, but salamat was extra ordinary, those taans pandit joshi ji and other classical do hardly and their face changes, for salamat those were like piece of cake. crazy vibrations on chrometic level and micro tonal changes.
Ustad Rashid khaan saheb ki gayki lajwab hai ,raht fateh ali ji unke pair ki dhool ke barbar bhi nhi hai,
Ustad ke sath gana to chhodiye unke saamne baithhne ke liye bhi bahot Riyaz chahiye ,ustad Rashid Khan Saheb ki to gayki hi lajwab hai ,jai ho
राहत साहब ने भी कोई कमी नहीं छोड़ी गायकी म बहुत मुस्किल गायकी हैं ये और उस्ताद रसीद खान साहब की बात ही अलग हैं दोनो बहुत अच्छे सिंगर हैं
Syi kaha
Puri hi kami hi kami rhi h bhai
Kya baat kr rhe ho😂
Absolutely correct Bro,कहा राजा भोज और कहा गंगु तेली
👌👌
सब अपनी जगह ठीक है
Rahat sahab tried enough to bring Ustad Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan Sahab's style...but ...but both sticked to their lines
That's the beauty
Rashid need not to imitate and bring any ones style to his performance he is a class apart which is clearly visible without lens ,,,,,,,KUCH BHI ,,,,KAMAALHAI YAAR JARA TO SOCHO
OMG... many times I search to find out any jugalbandi in this singers... but I couldn't find out... Today its come to me... I am very happy now... even I just it play now its going...hope full jugalbandi will be enjoyable...
Ustad Rashid khan tolerated a lot 🙏🙏
@home multiplex Bhai ustad Rashid Khan classical singer Hain
Aur aap Kya jaano classical music Kya Hain...
@home multiplex Bhaiya samjh lia Karo Tab bolakaro Rahat Fateh alikhaan playback singer Hain unka andaaaz alaghai unki tayyari alag hai even ustad rashid Khan is not a playback type voice. He is only singing bandish.. Rahat Fateh ali Khan Sahabe ne bht gaane gaayehain acche
Fact is different.Rashid khan is good classical singer in India.
@@danishmusic7069 ONLY BANDISH.. tumhe pta bhi h bandish gana kya cheez hoti... Raag m 10 minute tak improvisation bhi mushkil hota h.. ustad Rashid Khan to 1 ghnte tak raag ko gaate h....or rhi baat light gane ki to unhone gaye h eg aaoge jab tum sajna etc pr asal baat ye h ki vo khud hi classical gana psnd krte h kyunki vo unk dil k sabse Kareeb h.. kyunki vo asal or pure cheez h
Yes
Sehnai player got so much confused whom to follow 😂😂😂
😅😅
Shehnai kaha hai bhai?
Shehnai nahi sexophone
Kisi aam shehnai waadk ki itni aaukat nhi ki 2 great legend ko easily follow kr ske,,,sir ji
😂😂😂
Rahat is no competition for him. Its not about style of singing its the riyaaz you hear in there singing. Rahat doesn't sound as good as he used to.
So true ..😭
Nusrat saahb gave him all he got...but he wasted all that😭
Sutta jo Marta hai 24ghante charsi
After such performance Rashid khan ji ne backstage main rahat ko khoob dhoya hoga.
Both have sung well. But Rahat saab has different field of singing thats why it sounded little bit uncomfortable .But Ustad Nusrat saab was supreme in all types of singing. 🙏🙏🙏🙏
First of all, I don't think they are competing with one another. Secondly one of them is Ustad in pure hindustani classical music so there is no need of comparison. In the end music wins ❤️
I wish we had our legend ustaad Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan sahab performing live in todays time 😭🙏
Yaar fir toh baat he kuch or hoti
Sahi me
राहतजीने पुरी बंदीश का खून किया है और,उस्ताद रशिदखान साब ने,कितने प्यारसे गाया है फक्र है,उनपर हमे🙏🙏
Rahat’s best performances were with nusrat sahab, he always brought the best out of rahat, unfortunately now he is no match for rashid khaan.
I agree
Excellent
राशिद ख़ान साहब के बारे मैं अल्फाज
नहीं मिलते 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Yahan Javed Bashir aur Rashid ki jugalbandi honi chahiye thi
Dil ki baat keh di bhaiya. Maza aa jayega ustad Javes bashir aur Ustad Rashid khan sahab ji k sath ganay ka.
राग रसोई पागड़ी कभी कभी बन जाये
उस्ताद राशिद खान साहब जबरदस्त एंड उस्ताद राहत साहब जबरदस्ती
इतना दिमाग कहा से लाते है
😂
संगीत समंदर है और इस समंदर में अलग अलग नदिया आती है यहीं समाहित होती है यही सत्य है।
सब अपनी field की ग़ायकी के उस्ताद है 😊
चाहे ध्रुपद ग़ायकी हो, ठुमरी, शास्त्रीय गायिकी हो, क़व्वाली, ग़ज़ल, कर्नाटकी हो।
हरि बोल ❤️
Rashid Khan is a maestro and class. Raahat Is a qawwal. You can clearly distinguish in their rendition.
No rahat fateh ali khan is no more Qawwal
One is riyazii , while other is Auto tuner wala
both have diff style....its ustad rashid song so its easy for him
2 singers have different genre .... Rashid khan saab never sing qawwali (only singing khayal) ...Rahat saab never sing khayal so do not compare rahat saab to rashid khan sir...👍 I am big fan of rahat fateh ali khan
If Rahat Sahab never sings khayal then he should not sing jugalbandi with an expert like Rashid khan Sahab.
hahahah
यार राशिद जी के साथ राहत का कोई मिलन नही है। एक तरफ बंधी हुई सुरीली आवाज़ दूसरी तरफ क्रोध रस की चीखती आवाज । बहुत नाइंसाफी है।
बिलकुल सही कहा जी
I am big fane of ustad g rasheed
I am from pakistan .
Rahat even cannot touch rasheeds
Melody
Ustad Rashid Khan is a classical singer and ustad rahat Fateh Ali Khan is a qawali artist , both are good in their field
भाई दोनों ही उस्ताद है लेकिन ये भी सच है उस्ताद नुसरत साहब का कभी भी सुर नही गया लेकिन राहत साहब कई बार सुर से चले गये । नुसरत साहब जैसा कोई भी फनकार अब इस दुनियाँ में आना सम्भव नहीं है।
और राशिद खान साहब तो कमाल है सच्चे सुरों के मालिक
I tell you one thing both singers are from different zone and here rahat ji is singing in the zone of rashid khan ji,so do not disrespect ustad ji.
Yahan baat zone ki nahi hai sir yahan par baat sur aur taal ki ho rahi hai jo ki basic hai..
Rahat ki chatni ban gyi sargam me bhi sur nhi lag rha hai
Bhai. Sur hi thik ni lag rhe h...zone to baad ki baat h..
Sir excuse me rahat apne zone main bhi nhi gaa rha uski aukaat nursat sahab ki gayaki ko chuna bhi nhi hai bas unke marne ke baad unhi ke naam ka khaa rha hai ye is se zyada sureele to humare chote chote Begginers bache gaa lete hai...
And maharaj ji rashid sahab ne ustad naam kamaya hai gaa kar isliye vo ustad rashid ali khan ji hai
Or ye nepotism ke chalte rehete nursat sahab ka ustad kaat kar apne naam ke aage lagata hai 😂😂
Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan aaj zinda hote to rahat fateh ji ko ghar se bhar kr dete
Great singer
Great patience
Great tolerance
Salute to Rashid khan sabh
Rahat Fateh Ali khan bahot acha nibhaya qawal gawaya ka kam kar gaya bsss app dono ke lie duaa hai yar Rahat khan tan technical kamal kar dia Razshid khan bhi dunia main ek admi gawaya salamat rahen dono khan sahiban
Actually the two legends(Rahat and Rashid) are performing together which is good sign of love and it lefts no doubt in that "An Artist is of Art Not of State". However where its concerned with performance I have reached to the following points after hearing this video;
1) Rahat and Rashid both have different musical backgrounds their melodies, styles, works are totally different and they both are expert in their own music
2) people are criticizing Rahat in their comments that he is even not able to compete with Rashid Saab that wrong. The song they are performing is a Master peace of Rashid Khansab. Most of the people knows him for his this song.
3) I accept that Rahat missed the place(Sum) hardly two times. So this doesn't means he can't this song. He is a legend. Think board mindedly that might be he was not well, might he was tired, etc.
First Time Rahat Fateh Ali Khan seems beaten
From legendry singing and soft singing of Ustaad Rashid Ali Khan
Only High notes don't make you a great Singer
Ye parking baat ...master Saleem and rahat ki jab performance hui thi tab bhi rahat was only singing high notes ..but mrji or harqtie nai hai inke pass ..or even rahat or hans Raj hans ki bhi jab duo hua tab bhi scale hi tha harqtie ya yaani m hans Raj ji ka bhi koi jawab nai tha ...
Agr jahan saleem hota to uski kya haalt hoti☺
Ustad rashid khan sahab legendary level 🔥🔥 maine unhe live suna hai , he is true legend of hindustani classical music , this jugalbandi is great , rashid khan sahab harkatein bade pyaar se lete hain ❤😍
Maine khud ne year 2007 mein Tansen mein and then in the year 2014 at Indore 😍😍😍
Maine even unka autograph bhi liya hai
@@vighneshshirdhonkar2592 ❤🙌
Rashid Khan jaisi shakhsiyat se kash mujhe b sikhne ka mauka milta wo mere bahot hi favourite hai
Jugalbandi same type / style of singers k beech hona chahiye, yahan pe Ustad Raashid khan sb. is from pure classic style while Ustad Rahat Khan sb. comes from semi classic qwali hence the difference is obvious. Still it is a good effort, I appreciate. Thanks a lot.
Your justice
Yeah..but see ustad Rashid Khan and Hariharan ... even Hariharan come from semi classical..but it was a great Between the legends
Definitely bollywood singers can't compete with pure classical artist.But it's ok ho jaa ta hai kabhi kabhar👍👍
Btw rahat sabh is not a full time Bollywood singer
@@zrockjii2280 also not full time classical singer
@@tariniprasad6827 yes ...u even know what's his style is?
Sur kisi ka bhi utar skta hai.....rahat sabh ke purane videos dekho jisme vo Nusrat saahb ke sath taiyaari krre h ...khud ab smjh AA jayega Kya level h
@@zrockjii2280 pure classical singer ki kabhi sur utar taa hai??.nusrat sahab,kausiki Chakrabarti,rashid khan,Amir khan sahab,Mehndi Hasan sahab inlogo ki kabhi sur nehi hilta hai.Sirf practice is not enough consistency is also required.
As far as live signing is concerned, rahatji always suffers from bad throat..I have listened him many times trying hard on live show...yes in recording version he sounds great 👍...jab ki Rashid sab ka koi sani nahi..true legend of indian claasical...
I appreciate your work..
You are right..
Thanks sharing for right thing...
Kuchh log comment box me bakwas kar rahe hain
Kaise bardashat kiya khan saab apne itne besure admi ko ...salute n regards to you gurudev
Beta agli baar khud beth k sath de dena khan sahab ka .
@@fahadali4793 baap hoon tera aa ja tere ko seekhata hoon Gana kya hota ...sur ki samjh hoti tumko to Gian ni dete ...iska mtlb sur ki samjh hi ni tumko ...
Bahut sahi bola aapne janaab.
Jhaato me uljhaa ke patak de .rashid khaa saab aise qawaalo ko .
Himmat kaise Hui iski... paas bethne ki rashid khaa saab ke ! Main to heraan hun
@@zuberkgolechha are mere bhai apni apni jagah sabhi theek hain, aise to fir ustad nusrat fateh ali khan ji bhi qawali gaate the fir to wo bhi aapke hisab se kush nahi
@@ParamjeetSingh-sy8lwBhai Unki Classical Gayki Sune Aap, Ustad Rashid Sahab Ke Bhi Pasine Chhuta Denge Nusrat Sahab
Rashid Khan sahab very nice singing 👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌
They both are unreachable than the listeners....they are just great....dont judge rahat bhai by just this....!!😊 just enjoy n feed ears💐
jabardast ustad rashid khan sahab aapki awaz me ajib si attraction hain
I have listened both live. Rashid is ultra legend there voice so deep & meledious , he is ultra legend. On the other hand , sometimes Rahat sir in live sounds little offtune ( Iike someone screaming ) .
If you have to choose out one's concert over other , Rashid sir is best anyday . I bet you , you will never be dissappinted.
Ustad Rashid Khan ji hats up🙏🙏
Great Ustad Salamat ali (late) once said on Great NFAK's 2nd death anniversary about Rahat that NFAK taught him everything now its upto him how he carries his legacy but he turned out to be a crap by leaving his family tradition and legacy.
Exactly
Very true brother appreciate your comment 😊👍
You're absolutely right brother
absolutly right. hope rahat realise that and keep the legacy. he has great voice. Salamat ali khan saab ki to baat hi kya hai. ustadon ke ustad the salamat sahab.
For the people complaining that Rahat sahab is weak than Ustad Rashid, can you sing like Rahat? I'm a musician and i can see clearly the competition on Ustad Rashid's face . Rahat sahab is not not the best but definitely one of the best, he is the student of ustaad Nusrat.
Bhi tum do no ustad ko pasnd karty ho ya Main nhi janta lakin thumr video ka Tital bhut hi sarmnak hai
Ye dono Boht baray log hain ,vedio uploader ko shayad koi ghalt fahmi ya koi or masala lagta hay
😂😂
Kyu bhai aaisa kya laga jo sharmnak ho?
@@yashmusicon Ustad Rahat Sir ko disrespect kiya hai.
Bhai yeh comment karne walon ko sur ki koi samajh nahin hai tabhi aapko aisa bol rahe hain.
I must want to mention that Ustad Rashid khanji not even compare with Rahat Fateh ali, Ustad Rashid ji is a pure classical legend and Rahat not even compare or even not fit for jugalbandi ...
Har baap ka ek baap hota hai...
No offense to Rahey Sahab. but unhone Aisa jugalbandi kyon accept kiya 😑
It is really a suicidal decision.
Vo bhi ustad Rashid Khan k sath 😂😂...he is upto level of ustad amir khan pt Bhimsen Joshi...he is living legend...how can somebody dare to do that 😂😂
@@sharmaji4154 aapki puri baat se me sehmat hu bhai Lekin aap ye nahi kah skte ki pandit Bhimsen joshi ji se bhi upar hai
@@sharmaji4154 mai khud Rashid ji ka bahut bada fan hun
@@sharmaji4154 You can't compare URK with UAK or PBJ
Atad rahat fateh ali khan sahab ne Har tarah se surr lagaye hain... Hats off
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣Himmat ki Daad h rahat ji ap ko,, jo ap ne Himmat ki sath me baithne ki,,
😂😂😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣rahat jee ki gaane ki harkaton se lag raha hai ki wo jaldi bhaagna chahte hai par ustad rashid jee ne pakad ke rakha hai
Rashi khan sahab ka mazaak yani sangit ka majak rahat unka 1% bhi nahi
🤣🤣
Ustad Rashid Khan saahb 🙏 rahat fateh ali khan ko sahan kar rahe hai kuchh bol nahi sakte but itna besura pan aur proud kitna hai unke samne rasid Khan saah vinamra 🙏 ye hoti hai shastriya sangeet karo ki tahezib 🙏🙏🙏
I think first of all
Rahat has a very high pitch voice and this song is low pitch
Secondly he has a little problem in edgy voices but he still manages.
@@A.J.54 wait what😂😂😂
First of all Rahat Fateh Ali Khan shab is not a classical singer. He is a Sufi singer. So why people r comparing him with (Ustaad Rashid Kha). Both are legends in there own jounar 🙏🙏♥️♥️.
Jitne log bhi comment kar rahe h. We all are not having the capabilities to earn what they have earned in their time 😊
Rahat ji is shouting and Rashid ji is singing...that's all the difference there is.
राहत जी यहाँ पर जैसा गा रहे है वो तो संगीत को समझने वाले जान ही गये होगे,,,पर मै तो ये कहना चाहता हूँ कि ये राशिद सहाब को भी ठीक से गाने नही दे रहे है उनके गायन मे (राहत जी) व्यवधान डाल रहे है,,,
जी सही बात
Ustaad Rashid Khan is as ultimate as classical music 🙏🙏
Beautiful track brother thanks anyway
ऊस्ताद रशीद खान साहब ❤
God bless Sir🙏🇮🇳🚩
I think other instruments disturbed them because western players don't know the Ahir bhairav so sometimes it broke the atmosphere of particular raga.
Always Great Ustad Rashid Khan Sahab ❤️🥰💝🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Rahat is putting his best effort. For Rashid khan sahab ye to roz ka hai mere liye.
Rahat sahab is a very good singer but somehow he do not seem to be comfortable here. He also tried to add some sargam from his usual songs which sounded bad
Absolutely correct.
He was not feeling himself comfortable.
Salute for Ustad Rashid Khan shahab indian music is best in the world jai bharat
Two legends with their different singing genre i reaaly enjpyed ❤
Both are great, we can't compare to each other among them 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
In this concert Pt. Subhankar Banerjee on tabla with Usad Rasid Khan and Rahat fateh ali khan, but he is no more, passed away on 25 Aug. 2021, this is a great loss.
Ustad Rashid khan ki melody Ka koi jawaab Nahi Hain voice chubhti Nahi Dil ki chhune wali voice Hain ❤️
नमन करता हूँ उस्ताद राशिद खान साहब को..... जो इतनी देर तक राहत के भटके हुए सुरों को झेल गए!!
दो मिनट का मौन राहत साहब के भटके हुए 'षडज' के लिए 😞😞😶😶😶😶🙏🏻
😅😅matlab sur kisi ka rishtedaar nahin hota he
Rasid.apne.lye.gate.honge.lekin.nusrat.or.rahat.logo.k.lye.gate.aa.rahe.hy
This jugalbandi was such a bizarre idea, because both legends are master of different craft. This criticism would be quite opposite if Rashid Khan Sahab had to sing RFAK Sahab's songs. When Rashid Khan Sahab sang "Naina thag lein gy" he couldn't create the magic RFAK was able to create. But hats off to Rahat Fateh Ali Khan who, despite knowing, sat with Rashid Khan Sahab and sang his songs.
Jisne ye video upload Kiya hai Thanks for that..But in Dono Ustad ne jo gaya hai, uska 1% bhi kar pana v mushkil hai..uske liye Music aur Sargam ki knowledge hona zaruri hai. Please change the title of your Video
Jahan thumri, ghazal, qawwali, bhajan, film sangeet khatam hota, wahan se classical shuru hota hai. We have seen this earlier also when Rashid Khan teamed up with Talat Aziz.
True bro. I don’t understand how Rashid khan can sing so effortlessly.
Rathat ke jega sham 84 ya patyla garnye ka ka bacha b latye to vo ap ky hosh goma daty vo 1 no ustad log hain safaqat ali khan zanda abad
Rahat Fateh is chillam chilli..
Ustad rahid saab is divine ❤️❤️
Bhai Dono hi singer's ke gayaki ki styal alag hai Kisi Ko judge Karna galat hai . 🙏
Chillam chilli 😂😂😂 😅
@@kansensangeet8206 Bhai Surr ka style se lena dena nahi hai, Style koi b ho surr na lage to kya faiyda Aur dusri baat Classical me Qawaali gussaoge aur vo bhi besure hoke to ajeeb to lagega he ….
@@kansensangeet8206bhai classical to sabne sikhi hai na rahat ne bhi sikhi hai kawwal log bahut achchha classical gaate hai but raahat ne thik se seekha nahi hai
The range of classical singer voice is unmatchable no matter howmuch high you sing but classical voice will aways be appreciated and soothing to everyones ears... It gives sukoon in every note.. Not the qawwali high pitch voice...
Actually Ustad Rahat is singing Qwalli style....
And Ustad Rashid Singing in orignal songs style!
That's why Rahat saab isn't looking great here!
Baap aur bete wala hi level dikha raha hai ustad rashid aur rahat fateh ali khan me...compete aur wo bhi baap se 😁😁😁😄😄
Ustad Rashid Khan sahab truly a legend ♥ 😇🙏
Rahat fateh ali khan sur se kitna jaate hain....keval chillam chilli lagae hain..sargam bolna...or sargam suro me bolna....bahut fark hai...
*Ustad Rashid khan ke samne rahat abhi student hai
*yes, if Nusrat fateh Ali Khan Saab have there than match/beat condition for ustad Rashid khan
Whose idea was it to mix coffee with horlicks? Ustaad rashid is so far ahead. Rahat is no where near comparable to him!
I'm Big Fan Of Rahat Fateh ali khan Sir But Rashid Sir Voice Has More Feel During this Performance.... Sorry
edited - Rahat Sir Bidi Cigrattenoshi Bamd Kr Do Abhi
Ustad Rashid Khan ka badappan hai ki unhone 10 minute itna besura rahat fateh ali khan ko bardasht kiya.
Rashidji you are already an international vocalist. What is the necessity to sit with these commercial clown who is totally untuned. Voice throw is so rough. Rajat is only good for studio where you can take several takes and tune through software. The only commercial artist who can sit with you are Hariharanji and Shankar Mahadevanji.
very good performance.rahat fateh ali khan is great artist.
Rashid: Building Ahir Bhairav
Rahat: Destroying Ahir Bhairav.
Different genre but still Rahat is way out of tune... And Rahat's performance has too much show off but less music.
Classical m zero h ye to ab pata chala
It's not easy to sing pure classical song without practice for ustad rahat fatehali ❣️
Every time in rahat's sargam after 5:30 he was out of the raag.. He didn't keep himself in the raag.. Its bhairavi.. Good work by ustad rashid
Are you joking about raag?😄
@@HimmatSinghTaksal no i am serious this song is in raag bhairavi
I think it's Ahir bhairav
yes @@rajeshgadhvi3772 its ahir bhairav
Salute to ustad rashikhan saab...superb at handling nuances so seamlessly...great voice quality too