See? Their singing live sound super good and stable as same as audio/prerecord. This is what kpop idol real deal. Don’t underestimate aespa live vocal. Every time aespa sing live, lip-sync polices are nowhere to be found.
ah i see there are someone notice this too LOL of course she is the only aespa who kept changing her dance details many times, sometimes she wave to the audience instead doing her routines.
She needs to improve honestly and I am glad she did cux last year because of her weak stage presence, aespa is being called having no stage presence even when Ningning is working double time to not be called a group with no stage presence and thanks to her aespa is saved. Altough Karina is consistent, she needs to step it up more Now, the 3 unnies really improved a TON, but they should not be content with this, they need to keep improving cuz their maknae Ningning has no plans of slacking off and she plans to own the title MAIN SLAYER🔥. that is why I think having Ningning on the group, motivates the other members and I am not saying they have bad presence its just they need improvement. And they definitely did
@@danissegomez7953 bro what r u on? She literally has improved a lot in stage presence lmao especially these past few performances like r u still stuck in the savage era lmao😂
@@danissegomez7953 what improvement do you want her to do when she already prove her stage presence many times 😂 just because she was expressionless back then doesn't mean she doesn't have any stage presence funny cause when other idols do it they are called savage 😂😂 what do you want her to do exaggerate her expressions please I think you don't even know what is stage presence 😂😂 I bet those people who told that doesn't even know what is stage presence and some fans Just rode the hate train and keep on shitting on aespa 😂😂
@@cielphevans she was born in 2001. International age is 22 meanwhile her korean age would be 23 but i read somewhere that korea will be following the standard international age starting year 2023 (correct me if im wrong)
the outfit really so freaking pretty winter and the new choreography of illusion is amazing plus their style giselle hairlights, winter fashion, karina bangs so fit, and ningning presence is fav their endyear for girls and illusion
@@sultanku 4:41 that was not live then.sometimes I don’t like to comment but like y’all piss me off leave these girls alone. Go find a hate page on them and comment that. Like go somewhere
Please stop using the term “main slayer” in kpop groups cuz it’s just discrediting the capabilities of the other members of the groups. All of them make Aespa better in some way, there isn’t JUST one person YALL😭 I love winter but u can praise her some other way without making it sound like she’s doing all the work for aespa
@@rad3886 cmon it’s a obviously meant just to just praise her, they say the same about karina n especially ningning, winter deserves her main slayer comments too
@@mjgoat2366 read the last part of my comment if u haven’t cuz ur first sentence is smth I addressed alr👍 yes I know that that’s why I’m saying don’t use it, doesn’t matter the person!! All of them are all talented and no member should be seen as any less talented than the other, the term main slayer literally is stating that. Just call them ALL main slayers it’s rlly not that hard like they all work hard and try their best on stage.
Give AESPA stylists a raise,all their outfit slaying!!!🔥❤️🔥 Their LIVE vocal/fierce SP silenced all haters. Loudest fanchant,new Illusion choreo and their blinding visual too....."WE THEM GIRLS!" THIS IS HEAVEN! 💙🦋🌙⭐
camera works here are great. they know who’s part it is even the adlibs. aespa keeps on giving better stage this end of year. can’t wait for their comeback!!!
Live vocals, amazing stage presences, perfect outfits and hairstyles, top notch visuals, loud fan chant and nice camerawork THIS IS LITERALLY EVERYTHING
Their vocals, their stage presence, this is just PERFECTION Thank you for this amazing performance there is no better way to start this new year. Happy Birth Day Winter my baby♥ Happy New Year to everyone (specially Mys)🤍
the thing about aespa is even if they’re singing live, they barely open their mouth. it can easily be mistaken as lip-synching but judging by their behind-the-scenes studio sessions, that’s just the way they sing. truly mindblowing and one of a kind.
They know what they lacked and worked on it. Slayspa on the way!! Believe it or not, Aespa came to slay and prove that they are indeed the 4th gen leaders.
@@aespa4genleaders584 literally they are the main event, this video likes are even more bigger than the others performance that uploaded 3 hours ago lol
@@boogreeny7794 this is EXACTLY my thoughts!!! Seeing every member trend on the bird app is the only reason I open it (esp during these kind of events) 😉😌
They are singing live guys!! Winter's voice sounded exactly like recording. Ning ning's live vocal is amazing too...and there's Karina, our main dancer who can sing like its nobody's business...Miss G improves a lot in dancing, which is great. In fact all of them are amazing! Edited with additional notes: suddenly haters highlighted the playback exists! Yes, there were playback. Ladies and gentlemen, 99% of kpop stage during tv broadcast use playback. Suddenly when Aespa use it, it becomes a crime. Just stop.
They are singing live, the members are simplifying the movements when it's their time to sing compared to usual (winter is even seen to take some breath in her turn) and you can hear their voice overlapping with the backing track too.
I feel like this is a competition between MYs and AESPA to see who can sing louder 😅 MYs were loud. I’m so proud of MYs for supporting our girls 🥰 Thank you MYs
Live finally!!! SM, they can sing!!! Anyway, Winter stood out on the stage! She is sooooo pretty, cool but cute at the same time!!! Winter at the begging of Illusion is the best!!! And that 'hold up' part is really iconic!!! Happy Birthday, my best girl Winter!
THE AUDIENCE WAS ON FIRE, THE STAGE AND THE GIRLS WERE AMAZING SUCH A PERFECT PERFORMANCE 🔥🔥🔥 plus the cameramen did amazing o using on each member on their part giving each member screen time to shine as I said AMAZING🤩
I‘m just crazy about aespa's vocals, visuals & stage presence. And the fans are supporting loudly with full energy. "Girls" is killing the stage like Rock N' Roll.
![[에스파 aespa Trick or Trick + Drama] NCT DREAM,이영지,라이즈,스테이씨 RIIZE Reaction @231202 2023 mma 멜론뮤직어워드 직캠](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/U0vo2huOqL8/mqdefault.jpg)
![[2023 MBC 가요대제전] 에스파 - 트릭 오어 트릭 + 드라마 (aespa - Trick or Trick + Drama), MBC 231231 방송](/img/n.gif)
OMG Winter’s vocal⋯❤
See? Their singing live sound super good and stable as same as audio/prerecord. This is what kpop idol real deal. Don’t underestimate aespa live vocal. Every time aespa sing live, lip-sync polices are nowhere to be found.
컴백도 안 하고 공백기 기간인데 조회수가 젤 높네 ㅋㅋㅋ 하긴 썸네일 보고 어케 안들어와ㅜㅠ 지젤 랩 쫀득 , 카리나 춤 잘 추지 노래 잘해 닝닝 노래 성량 미쳤고 윈터 음색 미침
aespa is always the MAIN EVENT.
토끼즈 조회수가 제일 높은데…? 뭐지
@@bunnies5180 원래 커버같은 특별무대는 항상 조회수 높게나와서 그런거 빼고 말하는듯
스엠아. 당장 에스파를 컴백 시켜라~~♡
@@user-dw2fr4os6f 커버 제외해도 개나소나 조회수 1위 못찍는데?? ㅋㅋ
요즘 걸그룹중에서 어나더 레벨
Giselle really makes me excited everytime aespa because if her rapping...... I love her deep and high tone voice....
Yes!!! I love watching Giselle perform too!
Me too
Me too
Su voz es única, ojalá sm le diera el trato que se merece 👍
Can't get over with winters playful face whenever she performs 😭 she also has that mocking face telling everyone how amazing she is ♥️
ah i see there are someone notice this too LOL
of course she is the only aespa who kept changing her dance details many times, sometimes she wave to the audience instead doing her routines.
She needs to improve honestly and I am glad she did cux last year because of her weak stage presence, aespa is being called having no stage presence even when Ningning is working double time to not be called a group with no stage presence and thanks to her aespa is saved.
Altough Karina is consistent, she needs to step it up more
Now, the 3 unnies really improved a TON, but they should not be content with this, they need to keep improving cuz their maknae Ningning has no plans of slacking off and she plans to own the title MAIN SLAYER🔥. that is why I think having Ningning on the group, motivates the other members and I am not saying they have bad presence its just they need improvement. And they definitely did
@@danissegomez7953 bro what r u on? She literally has improved a lot in stage presence lmao especially these past few performances like r u still stuck in the savage era lmao😂
@@wingofwinter888 yes 😭 can't get over with her expressions she's interpreting the song with her expressions mocking black mamba
@@danissegomez7953 what improvement do you want her to do when she already prove her stage presence many times 😂 just because she was expressionless back then doesn't mean she doesn't have any stage presence funny cause when other idols do it they are called savage 😂😂 what do you want her to do exaggerate her expressions please I think you don't even know what is stage presence 😂😂 I bet those people who told that doesn't even know what is stage presence and some fans Just rode the hate train and keep on shitting on aespa 😂😂
그냥 완벽한데? 개깔끔하고 화려하고 이걸 가능하네 컴백 안하고도 조회수1위인 이유가 있다
ㅇㅈㅇㅈ
에스파 욕 너무 많이 먹었었는데 이 무대로 라이브 잘하는거 입증하고 지젤 춤실력도 늘고 다 더 예뻐져서 진짜 너무 좋다 에스파 악플러들한테 당한거 생각하면 진짜 눈물남ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
ONLY ONE HOUR LEFT BEFORE WINTER TURNS 22! HAPPY BIRTHDAY BABY GIRL! 🍾🥂🎉
Also, our leader Kun from WayV (NCT) turns 27. I'm sooo happy!!! 🎂🥳
Isn't she gonna turn 23?
YOO MY BABY BIRTHDAY 🔥
YEAYYY😍✨ Me too next January is my birthday 6 January Turns to be 16 years old
@@cielphevans she was born in 2001. International age is 22 meanwhile her korean age would be 23 but i read somewhere that korea will be following the standard international age starting year 2023 (correct me if im wrong)
the outfit really so freaking pretty winter and the new choreography of illusion is amazing plus their style giselle hairlights, winter fashion, karina bangs so fit, and ningning presence is fav their endyear for girls and illusion
라이브 하니깐 진짜 잘하는 실력 다 드러나는데 지금까지 왜 안하게 한걸까… 어쨌든 비주얼 미쳤고 라이브도 개잘하고… 이대로만 가서 쭉쭉 성장했으면
애들 아끼려고...? 아님 신비주의...?
@@user-ny7hm3xd5g 수만리가 에스파 욕 먹는꼴이 좋은건가 뭔 뭐지
라이브로는 격한 춤을 추기가 힘드니까 그렇겠죠
@@didij14 ㄹㅇ로
our ace karina slay the stage!!
How satisfying it is to hear them singing totally live
Same❤❤❤
Yes 😢
진짜 다 얼굴 미쳤다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 라이브 하는 것도 너무 잘해서 좋아죽겠음
ㄹㅇ
카리나 앞머리 내린거 진짜 예쁘다 원래도 이뻤지만
THE CAMERA WORK WAS SO GOOD!! THEY ACTUALLY FOCUSED ON THE MEMBER WHO'S PART IT WAS 😭😭
Tbh, this gayo has the best camera works out of three (kbs, sbs, mbc)
YES YOU'RE RIGHT
Karina is a god! I was mesmerized when she went at the center!
에스파는 공연할 때마다 항상 입소문이 났거나 유행했습니다. 작년 12월 그들의 모든 공연은 모든 소셜 미디어 플랫폼에서 입소문이 나고 유행했습니다.
애들 라이브하는 것도 다들리고 춤도 대박,,
ㄹㅇ
OMG THE LIVE VOCALS ARE SO GOOD!!! Aespa has proven themselves as one of the best ggs exists right now! I'm so proud of them! ^^d
@@sultanku 4:41 that was not live then.sometimes I don’t like to comment but like y’all piss me off leave these girls alone. Go find a hate page on them and comment that. Like go somewhere
@@sultanku better check you hearing. Its a new year better spread your hate elsewhere.
@@sultanku You wish your favorites had the talent that aespa has left over
Do you like 💜aespa so much that you are so aware of his movements?
@@sultanku bacot ajg
MYs are daebak!!!! Fan chants are amazing and also my girls voices are😭
it's awesome hearing their fan chants❤❤
라이브 무대 진짜 너무 좋다 ㅜㅜ 앞으로 안무를 더 간단하게 만들어서라도 라이브 더 많이 시켜줬으면 좋겠음 ,, 무대 보는 재미가 훨씬 더 있자나
ㄹㅇ
윈터 미모 라이브 춤 다 무슨일임 미쳤네
Winter main slayer! Her vocals got a chance to shine and I’m so proud!! The girls were incredible!
Please stop using the term “main slayer” in kpop groups cuz it’s just discrediting the capabilities of the other members of the groups. All of them make Aespa better in some way, there isn’t JUST one person YALL😭 I love winter but u can praise her some other way without making it sound like she’s doing all the work for aespa
@@rad3886 agree, but winter isn't the main slayer of aespa. one of them carried the whole aespa. but they improve alot.
btw agree to you.
@@rad3886 cmon it’s a obviously meant just to just praise her, they say the same about karina n especially ningning, winter deserves her main slayer comments too
@@mjgoat2366 read the last part of my comment if u haven’t cuz ur first sentence is smth I addressed alr👍 yes I know that that’s why I’m saying don’t use it, doesn’t matter the person!! All of them are all talented and no member should be seen as any less talented than the other, the term main slayer literally is stating that. Just call them ALL main slayers it’s rlly not that hard like they all work hard and try their best on stage.
@@rad3886yes !!! I agree so much with this
their live vocals are very gooddd
👑💜🤘💯Aespa best vocal Queens💜👑
Yesss😍
Ikrr
와 진짜 이 무대는 모든 맴버라 레전드 찍었네ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 미쳤다 진짜 가장 저평가 받는 여돌인듯 ㄹㅇ
카리나 오늘 잠 잘자서 컨디션완전 좋고
미모 레전드 찍었는데 본인도 그걸 알고 후훗 하고 있는 느낌ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
오늘 스타일 레전드닼ㅋㅋㅋ
윈터 레전드다 진짜... 저 얼굴에 노래도 잘하고 춤도 잘 춰
Karina visual vocal dance and rap 😭😭❤️
karina's bangs is just so iconic. her stage presence was off the roof too. she's such an amazing performer.
걸스 안무 바뀐것도 개좋고 걍 사랑해 에스파...
I'm sure i'm not the only one who keep watching this performance
Ofc, keep streaming go 3M!!
giselle keeps getting my attention like her stage presence is out of this world
Give AESPA stylists a raise,all their outfit slaying!!!🔥❤️🔥
Their LIVE vocal/fierce SP silenced all haters. Loudest fanchant,new Illusion choreo and their blinding visual too....."WE THEM GIRLS!" THIS IS HEAVEN! 💙🦋🌙⭐
Happy Birthday MINJEONGIE,Happy New Year 2023 Aespa and all the MY reading this.
Queens 😊
May the 2023 be Aespa & MYS,May all our DREAMS COME TRUE
Their stunning outfits are from LaLune (a Vietnamese’s local brand), give them a visit @_lalune_offical_ guys 🖤
yes
윈터 스타일링 쩔어 십덕들 눈물흘리게 하는 미모 ㅠㅠ ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
십덕 X
페미&레즈 O
ㄹㅇ.. 넘존예임..
광광 우는중
ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
@@Sibagyeon ㅇㅈ
지젤 브릿지 잘어울린다
My girl karina owned bangs frrr she looks so pretty
Their performance is the most viewed and liked and commented for a reason!
에스파 컴백 빨리 했으면... 진짜 스봉도 많고 응원법 커서 뿌듯하다
지젤 춤 실력 늘었네.. 다들 지젤 아무도 언급 안해서 슬프다. 랩도 쫀득해서 좋아하게 되었는데 이번 지젤 너무 이쁨
나도 찐 지젤파인데 지젤도 완전 이쁘고 춤도 완전 잘추는데 상대적으로 카리나 윈터가 너무 큰 산봉우리라 많이 묻힌거 같아서 조금 속상함 그래도 나는 지젤 너무 좋음 ㅋ
@@user-jr5lp9uu6f 지구젤리..ㅜㅜ 춤 실력 는 거 언급 많이 해줌 조켓다
ㅇㄱㄹㅇ
ㄹㅇ 지젤 미쳐따~~
ㅂㄹ..
THE LIVE VOCALS😭🔥🔥🔥🔥
That killer intro/Karina's new choreo/live vocal/everyone's outfit/unbelievable BEAUTY/fan chants.... MY GIRLS ARE THE MAIN SLAYER!!!
this is what we called the 4th gen leader
yes. talent!!
IVE
지금까지 본 에스파 직캠중에 제일 감격스러워진다....
camera works here are great. they know who’s part it is even the adlibs. aespa keeps on giving better stage this end of year. can’t wait for their comeback!!!
Live vocals, amazing stage presences, perfect outfits and hairstyles, top notch visuals, loud fan chant and nice camerawork
THIS IS LITERALLY EVERYTHING
👑💜🤘💯Aespa best vocal Queens💜👑
Outfit of Ningning and Giselles mediocre
Not live.
@@valeriamarquez4114 live gila
@@valeriamarquez4114 sweetie u have got a lot of free time on your hands! please go and touch some grass or get ur ears checkedd
Winter's highnote ♾️❤️
저때 윈터 진짜 너무이쁘고 퍼스널컬러 진심 버건디인 줄 알았음 ... ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Winter vocal omg
Live vocals y'all
썸넬 윈터가 자꾸 쳐다봐서 지금 5천만번째 보고있네.... 안들어올수가없잖아..
ㅋㅋ
드디어 라이브여???? 드디어???? 감격스럽다진짜
이대로 논란없이 쭉쭉가자...
Karina is really born to be an idol. She just oozes much energy and charisma that you wouldn’t be able to take your eyes off of her.
them live vocals!!
Yes, definitely live but there is something wrong with the audio that it sounds robotic.
@@orangebutblue yeeah it’s doubling
@@orangebutblue mbc known for bad audio
@@orangebutblue backtrack + live vocals
@@mp-fx8nt it's usually like that, backtrack is always there lol
Aespa are the most viewer mbc festival 😀😃
카리나 미모가 절정을 찍었네!!
Aespa at MBC GAYO 100% 💯❄️
ILLUSION - 100%
GIRLS - 100%
Visual - 100%
Vocal - 100% (LIVE 🔥)
Lyrics - 100%
Dance - 100%
Choreo - 100%
Costume - 100%
Fan Chant - 100%
Instrumental - 100%
Stage Presence - 100%
Lovely - ....................???%
Are they the main event? Hell yeah!!! 100% 💯💕
Shut up omg.. comment like a normal person
Happy Birthday Day MINJEONGIE,Happy New Year 2023 Aespa and all the MY reading this.
May the 2023 be Aespa & MYS,May all our DREAMS COME TRUE.
HBD WINTER,HNY ALL!!!
@@Lisa.stanw1 bro you stan jisoo 💀💀 you cant speak on aespa’s stage presence
@@Lisa.stanw1 yeah their stage presence are getting better everyday, go cry in the corner.
Theyre so stable esp. Winter.. my girlss im proud of u..happy new year!! Happy Birthday Minjeong Kim!!
진짜ㅋㅋㅋ 하나 같이 다 왜 이렇게 이쁘냐ㅋㅋ
댄브없이 안무만 바꿨는데도 너무 좋았음...
They singing live!! And Karina's stage presence!!
Their vocals, their stage presence, this is just PERFECTION
Thank you for this amazing performance there is no better way to start this new year.
Happy Birth Day Winter my baby♥
Happy New Year to everyone (specially Mys)🤍
sing with pre record. not vocal live
@@sultanku you were the sound tech? sounds live to me lmao
@@Ksheriffi illision not live vocal, girls live vocal combain pre record
@@sultanku whatever you need to tell yourself to sleep at night buddy!
진짜 완전 라이브 정말 잘한다 비주얼도 갓 라이브도 갓
역시 대형 sm 가수 답다. 비주얼부터 ㄹㅇ 완벽함
They're serving on vocal. I love when they have this energy
👑💜🤘💯Aespa best vocal Queens💜👑 stream🦋🌟🌙💖
Lipsync?
@@libniguzman4962 they're singing over a backtrack
@@libniguzman4962 nope, there may be a backtrack but they are singing live, you can hear it so well
@@anisaafsar4528 lol the backtrack cant even keep up winter ningning and karina voices
Finally live vocals Aespa please do this all the time. We love you
이거 찐 라이브네 라이브 원래 잘하는데 자주 해줬으면
AR 깔았구만
ㅈㄴ막귀네
@@user-yv5yp6dl7o 쌩라이브라고 안했다~ ar보다 라이브 소리가 훨씬 더 크고 원래 ar립싱크 하는데 ar 작게 깔아놓고 라이브 한 거라고. 독해력 무엇?
AR mr 차이도 모르노 ㅋㅋㅋ@@user-yv5yp6dl7o
the thing about aespa is even if they’re singing live, they barely open their mouth. it can easily be mistaken as lip-synching but judging by their behind-the-scenes studio sessions, that’s just the way they sing. truly mindblowing and one of a kind.
I think that’s because they have really great technique ☺️
@@flowers_n_kisses yes and that really says something about sm’s vocal trainings
Wendy the queen herself said that aespa vocal is very high...
YASSS SAY IT LOUDER
Hahahaa true
Karina’s live vocals at the end hitting those high notes is heavenly. She’s insanely good 😭
karina is the best performer for real
와............. 카리나 진짜 너무 예쁜거 아니야??
윈터 진짜 너무 이뻐서 숨 넘어갈 것 같음;;;;
숨 쉬세요
진짜 .. ㅠ 엠알 뚫고 나로는 성량 보세요 ;;;;
I think this is one of the best for aespa's stage because they're singing live in here. I hope SM will be let aespa singing live more in 2023
Live Vocals!!!
지젤 대박이였따..
사람들아 이게 이세대 최고의 여성들이다!!
They know what they lacked and worked on it. Slayspa on the way!! Believe it or not, Aespa came to slay and prove that they are indeed the 4th gen leaders.
Fact
FACTS SPOKEN
Fact💥
aespa devoured all the award shows they've attended to this year and we're all here for it 😩😲
theyve been the main event for every award show im livin for it
They're always trending when their performance is out to watch 🤧🎉
@@aespa4genleaders584 literally they are the main event, this video likes are even more bigger than the others performance that uploaded 3 hours ago lol
@@xjohnj tru
@@boogreeny7794 this is EXACTLY my thoughts!!! Seeing every member trend on the bird app is the only reason I open it (esp during these kind of events) 😉😌
눈물나게 예쁘네 움직임 하나하나가 다 레전드 사진이야
존나 ㄹㅈㄷ다 ..... 빨리 컴백 주라..
Karina's visual and stage performance never disappointed
My karina best performer Winter best vocalist for me her voice is loud and my Gigi is the best 4th rapper. Happy birthday to Winter ❣
No ningning??😒
Ningning.....u left her out :(
Ot3 I see 😮💨. How pathetic
I believe that this presentation is the most viewed of all the Gayos 2022🤔😍
지젤은 헤어가 이번에 미쳣네 계속 이런 머리 해주라.. 그리고 저런 빵빵한 치마는 입히지 말고;; 비하하는게 아니라 다른 멤버에 비해 다리가 약간 두꺼워 보이는 대신 롱다리니께 바지가 훨씬 지젤을 돋보이게 해줌!! = 앞머리, 머리 풀기, 바지 이렇게 가자 ㅇㅇ
They are singing live guys!!
Winter's voice sounded exactly like recording. Ning ning's live vocal is amazing too...and there's Karina, our main dancer who can sing like its nobody's business...Miss G improves a lot in dancing, which is great. In fact all of them are amazing!
Edited with additional notes: suddenly haters highlighted the playback exists! Yes, there were playback. Ladies and gentlemen, 99% of kpop stage during tv broadcast use playback. Suddenly when Aespa use it, it becomes a crime. Just stop.
It is technically live but the dominant sound is still pre recorded
True. Giselle really improved a lot in dance by working hard and I love watching her perform.
Aespa really did very this stage. Very proud of them! 💚
@@user-pq4dq6bj2u There is something wrong with their mics, but the performance was live. That's the fact.
@@user-pq4dq6bj2u yeah like in the chorus the back track is loud but in the other parts u can hear them clear
@@user-pq4dq6bj2u does not matter...there were parts were they sang on top of the play back. Still most of the parts were live
They are singing live, the members are simplifying the movements when it's their time to sing compared to usual (winter is even seen to take some breath in her turn) and you can hear their voice overlapping with the backing track too.
And some changes too
닝닝은 진짜 성량부터 메보네
제일 안정적임
딴애들은 원래 예뻤는데 지젤은 진짜이번에 너무 예뻐짐...
Giselle has always been pretty, it's just that other members has better outfits and styling compared to hers.
I feel like this is a competition between MYs and AESPA to see who can sing louder 😅
MYs were loud. I’m so proud of MYs for supporting our girls 🥰
Thank you MYs
Live finally!!! SM, they can sing!!!
Anyway, Winter stood out on the stage!
She is sooooo pretty, cool but cute at the same time!!!
Winter at the begging of Illusion is the best!!!
And that 'hold up' part is really iconic!!!
Happy Birthday, my best girl Winter!
She is so talented
SM Always Can singing okey
걸스 라이브 미쳤다 갈수록 잘해
지젤 무슨 공주같네... 우리 닝깅이는 늘 이뻐 ㅠㅠ 카리나 말해모해 웨입 머리도 넘조아 윈터 기영웡 아기말티쥬 개쉽덕포인트 라이브인것
KOREAN MAYS THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING AESP THANKS TO YOU THEY SHOWED THEIR STRENGTH AND POWER❤❤
THE AUDIENCE WAS ON FIRE, THE STAGE AND THE GIRLS WERE AMAZING SUCH A PERFECT PERFORMANCE 🔥🔥🔥 plus the cameramen did amazing o using on each member on their part giving each member screen time to shine as I said AMAZING🤩
04:30 :o
와 역대급이다 너무 예뻐서 대가리 빡빡 때리는중임 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
옳지 라이브 하니까 얼마나 좋아 더 많이 경험 쌓아 줬으면 좋겠어요~~!!
They were like "It's the end of the year, better give them a BLAST!" and they did! I'm so happy 😭
I‘m just crazy about aespa's vocals, visuals & stage presence. And the fans are supporting loudly with full energy. "Girls" is killing the stage like Rock N' Roll.
where are the people's who's calling winter doesn't have a stage presence 😵
윈터 라이브는 진짜 할말이 없다 너무 잘한다
도대체 어디가 라이브인거임? 나만 안들리나
@@user-yk7dr4so7q ㅇㅇ너만 안 들림 존나 잘 들리는데 다시 한번 들어보셈
@@user-pi6fp7op9u ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ누가봐도 AR인데 굳이 다시 듣고싶지 않다 너나 많이 들으세요~
@@user-yk7dr4so7q 라이브아님? 다 라이브라그러던제
@@user-yk7dr4so7q 우리 잘 듣고있는데 왜 참견이세요 뚱남아