ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
Berlioz: Symphonie fantastique / Nézet-Séguin · Berliner Philharmoniker
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 เม.ย. 2011
- Full-length concert: www.digitalconc...
Hector Berlioz: Symphonie fantastique / Yannick Nézet-Séguin, conductor · Berliner Philharmoniker / Recorded at the Berlin Philharmonie, 23 October 2010
The Berliner Philharmoniker's Digital Concert Hall:
dch.berliner-ph...
Subscribe to our newsletter:
www.digitalconc...
Website of the Berliner Philharmoniker:
www.berliner-ph...
you can see how nezet-seguin loves music, he does not perform by brain, he performs by heart and i love that
INDEED... LOVE!
Whoever is playing bass trombone in this deserves a metal, if you dont know what I mean then buy a subwoofer for your speakers
a "metal"?
It’s Thomas Leyendecker
Un peu de chauvinisme... notre Yannick Nézet-Séguin ;-) Montréalais et québécois...
Phénoménal ♥
Awesome brass section!!!!
This is absolutely fantastic, best interpretation I have ever heard! When Sir Simon leaves the Principal Conductor position, keep Nézet-Séguin in mind for the new principal conductor, he is absolutely amazing! But please do keep Sir Simon for a long time to come!
A melhor Orquestra Filarmônica do Mundo. BERLIM.
Wonderful!
@ThePanpan7 Unfortunately, there are no plans for a DVD at this time
I love how you can hear artist's head bouncing down from the gallows at 2:44
How energetic!!!!
LOVE!
@SpottyDorsord: Exactly, I can confirm that the orchestra (at least very many of them) loved his conducting and also the work in the rehearsals. They were glad that his debut was so succesful :-). And I support your comment that people should watch the entire concert to get an idea of the big palette of expressions and colours HE could get from the orchestra (watch i.e. also the Messiaen piece). Why do youtube viewers have to criticize in a so arrogant way? Enjoy the good music!
@GregHales of course of course, a mix between brain and heart is essential!
My point is that i see soooo many performances that contains a lack of feelings ( not in the berlin phil ofc ) on an amateur level. i just love to see some true feelings!! balance is as you say extremely important, no balance, weird music and less focus on feelings. :-)
I'm sad to see that nowaday youtube comments are about clothing and gesture, never mind the actual beauty of the music or the length of the standing ovation. In the words of Patrick Stearns, "The orchestra had played not just well, but interestingly, with a spontaneity that sometimes teetered on the edge of chaos in ways that suited the music and were encouraged by the guest conductor."
@curlyman217 Why is it important what he's wearing? Just listen to the fantastic music. He's doing a great job!
@PDQGorby As someone how has studied you should know that the most of the work for a conductor awaits in the rehearsal. An orchestra like the BerlinPhil doesnt need a conductor who shows the 1 and 3 of a bar...
super-
@PDQGorby I especially suggest you to hear the beginning of the symphony :-) It's so beautiful you could cry.
I still think it might make sense for the orchestra to have its own DVD/CD label. So if DG or Euroarts does not want to do something the orchestra can still do it anyway. This would be good on DVD or the Abbado one done early today be even better for CD & DVD issue. LSO and Congertgebouw have run their own labels very well. The BPO should use its own label to supplement EMI, DG, etc.
This is a very different style of conducting then the BPO is used to seeing!
@noirvalentin indeed he conducts cruel, and looks cruel, but much more important is, that his interpretation is good, and that he has to be qualities if the berliner invite him..
This one is good, the one Abbado did today with Berlin was even better and perhaps the best I've heard since James Levine recorded with Berlin in the early 90's on DG.
Greg Hales Gennady Rozhdestvensky's version is worth hearing for sure. It's exists on TH-cam, but it's from a live performance. Still, probably best one I ever heard!
What about Karajan's version? I find Karajan's version from 1975 to be superior in my opinion
@winrx I think Rainer Sonne is seated with Daishin Kashimoto. He joined the Berliner Philharmoniker in 1976.
@PDQGorby Just watch and HEAR the entire concert at the dig. concert hall. Not amateurish AT ALL. Watch the parts with soft piano colours and also the technically "virtuoso" parts. I'd be surprised if you also see "noise" there. And you won't HEAR "noise" during the entire program.
Quite right! One does not get up in front of one of the world's greatest orchestras in the capital city of their home country and not even put on a shirt!
@TFreckle I think the thin sound from the brass may be due to his interpretation. Especially at the end, it makes it sound more fake and sarcastic. Certainly and interesting effect
@TFreckle sound is just fine. the piece doesn't climax until the next movement
@wienerfan You are right!
@atomicmrpelly and Abbado, in my mind, is almost all I admire of the "Abbado generation;" a rubric inadequate for Carlos Kleiber.
@curlyman217 next a conductor will walking in with a T-shirt and shorts. Karajan's dress was fine...what he wore, though I think part of that might have been do to his health, but it still looked very professional.
@TFreckle What I'm saying is not to be understood as "absolute truths" but as my personal oppinion. I like this movement with a more volumptuous sound.
@atomicmrpelly I am not exaggerating my opinion of him - I believe what I wrote. Obviously you disagree with what I wrote and you think my appraisal is excessively complimentary. I don't think this music is adolescent either. It's not the Mass in B Minor, but it's also not Rach 3. His interpretation and the commitment of the playing can't really be fairly discredited by the minor faults in ensemble during a live performance, especially based on a three minute clip...
@SpottyDorsord i agree :)
@curlyman217 I am embarrassed how superficial many commentators are. The conductor has to be creative, has to communicate his idea of the music and shall radiate his emotions. Here the conductor is very young and his explosiveness is shown by his clothing as well. Why should every conductor be conservative and introverted? Watch some older conductors: Maybe they have a wealth of experience but you hope that they dont fall asleep while conducting... Please dont be that superficial!!
okay i get that he should be in concert dress but other than that what is the problem with his conducting exactly? His interpretation of Berlioz is quite impressive if you ask me and he looks to be extremely passionate about his music.
@JC5268 Well you're talking about one the best bass trombonists in the world, and this piece calls for exactly that kind of sound. I've heard even more from the bass in this movement, and when you're playing loud pedals you can't exactly expect some pure sound.
@curlyman217 I think he's trying to show that "classical" music doesn't have to be all about dressing up fancy and making yourself look sophisticated. Sure, it may have been a bit too casual, but at least it's an attempt to spread this great music to a wider audience.
@curlyman217 You are right. He should wear a tuxedo.
❤❤❤❤❤❤👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Orang indo? :v
What is the name of the concertmaster's stand partner? I've noticed him in a lot of Maestro Karajan's videos from the seventies.
Is that Jens Plücker on first horn in this clip?:)
ゲスリングがアルト吹いてる！！
@danielhoganmusic Really? To soon for that. I also want to see what he can do with composers like Bruckner, and operas like Elektra, Tristan etc...not sure based on this concert he is ready for Berlin.
Does that really have anything to do with music making? It's really a detail in my view.
That class being upper class! Surely it's much better he wears something comfortable that he can conduct well in as opposed to some weird penguin suit. It isolates more people than you think that orchestras still dress like Victorians. I wouldn't say he was dressed down anyway!
The conductor is dressed down by classical music world standards. I think it is a good compromise as I find as a violinist the tux is a hindrance and I would play with more freedom were I not so trussed up. Then again I find it adds to performing experience, makes it feel more authentic.
So true the both!
@atomicmrpelly I can't hear any glaring problems. At which point in the video can they be heard?
@bachboy111 Indeed...I think no one in the orchestra can follow either...fortunately it´s the Berliner so they can just play by themselves.
@SpottyDorsord Good point! lol
@SpottyDorsord Bit of an over-reaction if you ask me. He's quite energetic but he doesn't have the grace of the Abbado generation, he makes this sort of adolescent music sound very lively (although a little rocky ensemble wise if I'm honest; this is the Berlin Phil, the tiniest discrepancy is a big deal!) but I think you are exaggerating slightly!
@noirvalentin don't watch his conducting then. Listen to his results..that says it all.
I'm sorry, but talk about OVERCONDUCTING! Jeez, I like the fact that he's into the music, but wow......To me it looks like he's a guest audience member who won a bid to conduct TO the music of Berlioz by the Berlin Phil.
LoL Envy Living In The Moment! Beautiful Madman with Precision!
Yep
you can tell the orchestra is not watching him...too much information for them to follow & the attire is offensive... despite all this, the philharmonic, as usual, sounds fantastic..
I see they're using piston valve trumpets instead of their usual rotary valve instruments
It shouldn't matter what the conductor wears, but as a musician, I'm a little resentful if I have to do aerobic exercise for two hours in white tie (wool coat, heavy starched shit, collar, tie, vest, undershirt!) while my boss shows up in whatever.
And why does that matter?
What is this movement ?
March to the Scaffold - Movement 4 :-)
Thanks :-D
It should be obvious that I don't agree that they play as if he wasn't there. Did you think that I thought they loved him while also thinking that they played as if he wasn't there?
I don't accept the premise of your question.
Don't get too supercilious by insinuating your rarified appreciation for Kleiber. He was a genius, but it doesn't take a genius to know that. He's been a recherché poster boy for pretentious poseurs in the mainstream for too long. You're no arbiter of the Kleiber scale.
@TFreckle It's not very fragile...
@TNEFMUB You must have balance...brain and heart...Karajan had the perfect balance. Bernstein did all heart and often lost imporant aspects of the music and had sloppy concerts. Karajan and Szell had the right balance, which often seems to be lacking today.
The orchestra members are dressed more respectably than the conductor. No hindrance towards the music however.
Meh, a slightly thin cuppa tea here. It seems like a very fragile sound coming from this version...
I'm all for more casual clothing in concerts for both performers and patrons, but there should still be coordination of attire between orchestra and conductor. For example, in this case he should've just put on a black buttoned shirt. Or if he wants to stick with the black tshirt, the orchestra should wear dark shirts instead of white shirts. Otherwise the whole presentation just looks awkward and the conductor ends up looking amateurish.
There´s something wrong about this conductor. Looks like me "conducting" in my living room. This is terribly awful. Berlin Phil, why did you invite him? On this one I have to say it seems you made a mistake.
you can tell the orchestra is not watching him...too much information for them to follow & the attire is offensive... despite all this, the philharmonic, as usual, sounds fantastic...