ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 มิ.ย. 2024
- For the most part, fans of C.S. Lewis’ The Chronicles of Narnia thought the film adaptations were well-cast. However, there are always people who want film adaptations to be 100% accurate, right down to the characters’ appearances, so it’s time to compare.
Some of the characters fit Lewis’ descriptions almost perfectly, while changes were made in a few cases in regards to hair color and age. From the character who was seriously aged up in the second film to the CGI character who looked exactly as he was described in the books, let’s take a look at how the Chronicles of Narnia cast should really look.
#Cast #Movie #Narnia
The White Witch | 0:00
Lucy Pevensie | 1:02
Edmund Pevensie | 1:39
Peter Pevensie | 2:14
Susan Pevensie | 2:39
Mr. Tumnus | 3:04
Prince Caspian | 4:19
Trumpkin | 4:51
Eustace Scrubb | 5:20
Aslan | 6:05
Read Full Article: www.looper.com/36038/cast-chro... - บันเทิง
![เก่งแต่ลับหลัง (FINSTA) - ส้ม มารี (Zom Marie) Ft. Punch 4EVE [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/OOolBU2aC70/mqdefault.jpg)
Which character had the most surprising look in the movies when compared to the books?
The White witch. She is supposed to be 7' tall. That was specifically mentioned in more than one of the book. I think they should have made her much taller in the movie.
*when you can't correctly pronounce Pevensie
She was also supposed to be extraordinarily beautiful.
Looper Aslan was able to walk on his hind legs like a human and use his front paws like hands
Kristen Stewart as Snow White and Charlize Theron as an Evil Queen "jealous of Snow White's Beauty".
Casting directors are blind as fuck.
I think the casting was actually good tbh. I didn't even care that they raised the ages up.
and they look all good too. :)
The most important is, that they are great actors.
Shannon C. Yeah.... I thought he was younger than 12 :D
I was glad they did! 12-year-old-Peter leading the Narnians... Never worked for me. In the books, they acted older than their years, so that's how I always perceived them.
You're kidding, right? Because if you're not.. Then there's actually someone worse at age estimation as I am! Which is sad.
Yeah, it was. I wonder why the name didn't show up. It was a 'reply'. Oh well.
Love the Aslan compare. "He was described as a big lion, and he...is...a big lion. Great job!" :-)
Brent Dreher I read this comment before I saw it in the video, I thought you were just saying this, when I got to part I started cracking up realizing you were quoting him!!😂
Actually, the movie Aslan was not a particularly big lion. But then, he's supposed to grow along with their understanding.
@@benz_aoe2 in Prince Caspian he tells lucy I grow as you grow
Aslan is the greatest character in this movie in both Graphic effect and voice actor
"Great job!" hahaha!
Can we take a moment to appreciate prince caspian's face
See, I don't find him attractive. At all. His eyes remind me of like, demon eyes. I'm weird though, I have absolutely zero attraction to him. If I was a male, my bits would probably crawl into my body listening and looking at him. There were more attractive persons in this by far.
BlindTruths Haha alright. I thought he was easily the most attractive of the men. Suppose we all have different tastes
BlindTruths shhh my child
Ayy, I actually used to dislike him as a child, but danngggg, he's smokin'
I used to have a massive crush on Ben Barnes a few years ago...
Still do tbh.
Funny how Lucy is described as having blonde hair, but majority of the illustrations have her with brown hair and not one adaptation of the story had her with blonde hair.
Olivia Roberts I believe the original cartoon series did.
Olivia Roberts the original cartoon did, she had two blonde ponytails, blue eyes and a pink dress
Yes thank god for fanfiction
Didn't the colored versions of the Chronicles of narnia portray her hair color black???
1979 animated movie showed her as blonde!
2:13 Pizza Pevensie
lol
HAHAHA
BLESS YOU
So, I'm not the only one...
Fragile As Glass loll
Still waiting for The Silver Chair !!!
In August 2016, it was announced that the Silver Chair will be made by Sony-based TriStar Pictures, The Mark Gordon Company, The C.S. Lewis Company, and Entertainment One (eOne). The film will be financed by TriStar, eOne and The Mark Gordon Company with Sony and eOne distributing the picture. Mark Gordon, C.S. Lewis’ stepson Douglas Gresham, Vincent Sieber, and Melvin Adams will produce the film. Life Of Pi and Finding Neverland scribe David Magee was already writing the script.
So it is on it's way! :D
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHH can't wait!
+AichiKitsune It is also planned to be a reboot of the franchise, i'm worried how this work.
Shimei Oriarte my favorite was the last battle
yay!!! Good to hear that.
I always had a crush on Peter when I was younger
I actually remember having a crush on Peter during the first movie, then on Edmund, and finally on Caspian in the third one lol
@@HailG3 same😂
I still have a crush on Peter
I'll be your Peter 🤷♂️🤪 lol
Yup. Peter was definitely one of my literary crushes ... ok, still is...
Will Poulter totally nailed the part of Eustace. Yeah, he was too old, but that was an inspired bit of casting.
He passed for about 11-13. And I never heard anything about him only being 9, though I'm far from a definitive Narnia expert.
The way you pronounce Pevensie is making C.S. Lewis roll in his grave.
Ashley Nichole Thank you for the laugh. I basically died. 😂😂😂Yes, he really needs to learn how to pronounce it.
i had a crush on mr tumnus
AshKetchum442 😂😂😂
Me too! I don't care that he's half goat, he's cute :o)
AshKetchum442 I still do
AshKetchum442 I knew I wasn't the only one!!
We all did
According to a review on this movie, Narnia is the author's fairytale version of the gospel, in which the White Witch and her minions are the pharisees, Aslan the lion is Jesus (who underwent a mock trial, got killed and resurrected), and the four kids are his disciples including Susan (who wept at Aslan's dead body then first witnessed his resurrection, which is very similar to Mary Magdalene at the cruxifiction). This really enlightened me. And it must be true, given to the fact that C S Lewis is a theologian.
The pharisees were largely to blame though. The romans had no beef with Jesus before they dumped him on their door demanding his execution, and the people wouldn't have turned on him if it wasn't for them either. The Roman government was just their hitman. Just because it wasn't their hands that killed him, doesn't mean it wasn't mainly their fault.
Stupid people will always find justification for their stupidity. This does not mean we change facts to avoid this.
Jonathan Chamberlain, just read the final book in the series. The final act has a striking resemblance to Revelation book of the Bible.
Wrong, C.S Lewis never meant to be it a depiction of the gospel, he simply wrote the books for his niece Lucy, I believe. I do agreed, however it is similar to the gospel but that may have been a subconscious decision done by the fact that he is a Christian author.
+Dragon Violin Actually many movies have adopted a gospel theme if you read deep into the story line. You'll notice a formulaic routine - In an ordinary world full of darkness and evil, you got this hero who sees the truth and wants to make a difference, then he preaches his ambition and builds up a team of faithful followers, sometimes he even has a master giving him instructions or a lover supporting him at times of need; then his big plan proceeds to a turning point when he faces some huge setbacks, being put on trial by the villains, which cast some shadow of doubt on him; and at this very moment he gets encouragement from his followers, lover and/or that master, then it reaches the climax of the whole movie as he sacrifices himself in this heroic act that saves the world; during that act, you can see that he almost gets killed, but saved by his followers/lover; or he's really killed, but somehow brought back to life by his followers/lover. Afterwards he dies or fades into ordinary life or prepares to face the next challenge, while his followers and/or lover are left telling his story. I hope what I said makes sense to you. It's very common in superhero and biography movies.
Jonathan Chamberlain That is true, but the true books were never meant to be gospel even if the movies were shown that way.
I'm glad they made the characters older. Peter's supposed to be twelve or thirteen, but I can't imagine a thirteen year old leading an army into battle. It's hard enough believing seventeen year olds lead rebellions in literature now.
And to be honest, I thought Lucy was supposed to be six or seven when I saw the first movie when I was the same age... probably because we looked quite similar. Admittedly I wasn't too far off, but it's probably better that they made the children's ages different.
I agree Peter could have passed as 16 or 17 in the first movie and was much more believable in the battle as opposed to his age portrayed in the books. Meanwhile Edmund in the movies could have passed as no younger than 13 but the difference between the two was easily seen in the films and made them better in my opinion. You could actually imagine Peter being able to kill in the films and it made Edmund getting wounded a lot more impactful to me. The movie did a good job of portraying Jadis but in the books she was crazy strong. Like superhero strong. Didn’t she like rip a lamp post out of the ground or something in the first book? Either way when you saw Edmund fight her to save his older brother you knew how outmatches he was. She was a lot stronger and more skilled than both of them but you knew from looking at the brothers that Peter had a much better chance in a fight with her. So when she did stab Edmund in the movie you really feel Peter’s older brother need to protect him and pain from failing to do so. That elevates the scene so much when we watch Peter witness Edmund fall and then proceed to go insane and take on Jadis. That emotion driving him to hold his own and attack in hopes of avenging Edmund instead of just defending trying to survive. I really hope Netflix does that battle justice.
Nope I think the movie characters were PREFECT! I couldn't picture them any other way! Tilda Swinton was the prefect White Witch such an amazing villain, Edmund is also prefect. I love Skandar Keynes so much he IS Edmund!!!
The101genco ikr?! I remember when I was a kid, I was so scared of the White Witch, but I can't help staring at her only when she's on screen because she's just so.......otherworldly, idk I just love her, but at the same time I'm scared of her
prefect??? u mean perfect???? sorry to be the grammar police! :P
The101genco I wouldn't have minded Peter Dinklinges character being more accurate and maybe Peter having more blondish hair
Me too 😜
If you think Tilda Swinton did a perfect White Witch, I suggest you watch the original Chronicles of Narnia by the BBC, Tilda as much as I love her, I didnt feel the personality of the witch with her, she didnt feel at all intimidating however, growing up watching the BBC version, the lady who played the witch in that Barbara Kellerman, literally gave me nightmares!! she was absolutely spot on!! kept true to the character right down to the last detail in the books, she looked the part and my god she really had the personality down!!
I don't care what everybody else says. This is my favorite movie of all time.
g2gfaf literally same
Same
dear god that is NOT how you pronounce their last name.
HattieThePirate omg I thought I was the only one
I was almost crying towards the end
IKR
It triggered me so much!!!!!
That's exactly what I thought!
It annoyed me so much every time he said it😂
Holy shit, Professor X was in Narnia?!?
yup. my 1st crush is a faun hahahaha
I just noticed that too haha
after seeing James McAvoy's dong in The Last King of Scottland it was so hard to see him as tumnus
Tony Sanchez it was the reverse for me. I watched him in Narnia first THEN in King of Scotland. I needed a fucking eyebleach
And his character in Wanted, suppose I'm alone in liking that movie...
The Chronicles of Narnia was the first series I ever bought and it increased my interests in reading and writing. So thank you, Narnia!!
I really want The Horse and His Boy to be a movie. It was my favorite book in the series!
It was also my favorite of all the books
I heard the movies are going to be filmed by the order the writer wrote the books in.
if they ever make it they better bring back the original cast.
Aslan's character is perfect then, I suppose.
Alyssa Hansen Yes and no. In the books he is able to walk bipedal.
Rose Harper
Mmm, it must be a while since I've read the books, as I do not recall that detail.
Rose Harper "Bipedal"?
Dave All
It means that he was able to walk on two legs, rather than four.
Well, Aslan is a big lion, but he wasnt big enough. Near the end of "journey of the dawn treader" Aslan is described as being the size of an elephant, so he should have been larger in the movies :P
Ben Barnes is notorious for being randomly casted when it comes to character descriptions - Dorian Gray was also meant to be a blond dude :D
Actually, the Telmarines were designed by the film crew as having a sort of Spanish or Mediterranean aspect. Ben Barnes coloration fit in with this.
Is that how you pronounce Pevensie? I thought you pronounced it like Pev-en-siii not Pev-EN-sie
You do, good catch...
Madicken 70 and then there's me who would put accent on the first syllable, PEV-en-sie.
the emphasis goes on the Pev not the en. But mispronunciations are typical in vids like this as these narrators aren't actually fans.
I winced every time he pronounced it that way. LOL
When i read the books i was quite young and i thought their name was Pensive not Pevensie 😂😂
Peter looks so much like the illustration.
Another major difference of the White Witch in the films vs the books: Her hair should be dark, not blond, as the White Witch’s true identity is Queen Jadis of Charn (idk how to spell that world), who was first introduced in the Magician’s Nephew. She was described to have dark hair, a proud and terrible face, very tall, and wears strange gowns (as she was not from this world, but a dying one).
The book doesn't say dark hair.
@@melodyclark1944 The Magician's Nephew mentions it
Yes but the events of The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe happen way after The magicians nephew, like a thousand years, so her hair colour could have changed due to the magic apples.
btw, "gay" meant happy and joyously jolly, back in the old days. just for any lil kids of today who may not understand. hehe~………
Someone hijacked the word...
No duh
@@miss8732 for people who are considered to be more creative, they should've been able to come up with a new word
IKR.. You know the song I feel pretty and witty and gay. I was singing that part and someone heard me and was so shocked thinking I mean sexual orientation even they knew I wasn't gay that way
@@kaah5823 in 6th grade we had to do a group project
I did all the work and wrote a poem
I used the word gay as happy cuz it rhymed
My classmates wouldn't say the paragraph and they wouldn't tell me why
I said it instead
We got an A+
Ben Barnes passed for 17 or so, and Eustace's actor looked 11-12. And Georgie might not have had golden hair, but she had three things going for her. One, acting ability. Two, insane levels of cuteness. And three, an older sister to play her as an adult.
Prince Caspian has been the love of my life since i was 7
Lucy: Supposed to be blonde
Edmund: Supposed to be blonde
Caspian: Supposed to be blonde
What do the directors of Narnia have against blondes!?
Probably too boring so they just mixed it up a bit.
I don't think they would have 'worked' as blondes. it would have been too generic and made the movie lose some of its charm. Nothing against blondes, I'm just saying that fantasy has one too many blond characters.
Edmunds features were never specified in the books, and getting good actors is more important
I'm guessing it'd be a nightmare to keep having to dye their hair while filming 😂
I don't think that C.S. Lewis really cared much about the appearances of any of them. If Lucy being blonde was a plot point, he would have brought it up at the beginning of the book, not the end.
Also, the books never actually describe Edmund at all. At one point he is described as being *in a group* that is mostly fair-haired. We don't even know if he's one of the majority in the group, or one of the fewer with dark hair.
STILL WAITING FOR THE MAGICIANS NEPHEW!!!!!!!!!!
long live me yeah it was the first out of all the books written......how narnia was created.....centres around the professor but when he was younger!!!!!
NR B nah..... not the very first one in the chronicles
NR B Neither the magicians nephew nor the horse and his boy were made into movies. Which was really poor planning on their part seeing as how they both have important plot details.
Rose Harper yeah magicians nephew was the most important it set the premise ...... but in this climate of prequel after sequels...., hopefully they'll consider making it.,.., they could do sooooo much to this story!!!!
+Leo Johnson
Yaaaaassssss
Caspian is the best ! 😍😘❤ I love his hair, i can't imagine it gold
Tyrion was in narnia? Oh boy, he must've had some good times.
OVERCRITCAL NERD waiting for someone to comment this 😂😂😂
OVERCRITCAL NERD hahahahahahaa nice noticing there
So, I guess the movies nailed the looks of most of them quite well?
Jadis's Ice crown was a brilliant choice because as the film goes on, it melts and grows smaller, showing that the snow is melting and her power and reign is weakening.
Good video, but I cringed every time you tried to say "Pevensie." >.
Sarah Knuckles same loooool pronouncing it wrong
"there was a boy called Eustace Clarence Scrubbed, and he almost deserved it" - brave words from a man named Clive Staples Lewis
It's been a long time since I have read the books, so pardon me, but if Susan was supposed to be able to fight, why did she have long hair that fell to her feet. That's not really practical
LOL!! Strewth.
correct
She grew it out in times of peace. During the war against Jadis, it was probably only shoulder length. :)
She was not into battles just as Lucy in the books in Prince Caspian says it . She's just the "pretty face".
The girls didn't really fight like that in the books.
I always liked how they did Lucy's hair style because it was very 1930s and putting Georgie Henley along with Skander Keynes made them look very much like real brother and sister.
I would LOVE for someone to try to pull off the Magicians nephew, cause that story was the birth of Narnia :D
Can we take a moment to appreciate the 'movie' Edmund being all handsome while I actually imagined the 'book' Edmund as the 'I don't care how I look right now as long as I'm enjoying this amazingly magic Turkish Delight that came from thin air'. Well, I salute the casting director though, I mean Skandar's kinda cute...
I don't really see why their eyes or hair colour would be such a problem because it doesn't really make any difference to who the characters are as people. In my opinion I think it's better that they got older actors for the roles because I really can't imagine characters such as Peter going to battle at the age of 13 but that's just what I think :)
who heard Pizza Pevensie?
William Moseley (the guy that plays Peter pevensie) confirmed that silver chair is in 'work' , they will start film it this fall (2017) and will be out around Christmas 2018...
And btw you pronounce Pevensie wrong:)
Classic Mochi thanks
;-; thank you
so much for that huh
Bloody Barnes this didnt age well
Not true
If they said something was wrong with Aslan I would say "A LION IS A LION OK" 🦁
I needed this ❤❤👌 forever will be in love with Narnia
I like that Edmund has brown eyes instead of blue like the rest of his siblings because it makes him different
He took the longest to cast, if I remember right. I have the Making Of book sonewhere.
she could have outgrown the brown hair. people do start out with different hair color and grow into another. not too uncommon amongst european decent
Blond can turn to brown. Hair doesn't usually lighten with age.
Melody Clark yeah usually. but could happen. plus you know bleaching was a thing for royalty and high fashion.....
My brother was totally light blonde as a little child. Now he has that ashy dark blond hair.
Yep. I've seen people who were pale as children and darker as adults, or darker as children and lighter as adults. My hair used to be more RED red-brown as a child, now it's more brown brown.
You don't change brown the blonde though. I, my brother, and both my parents were blonde when younger and then changed to brown hair, but nobody changed the other way, at least not at that age (some babies have dark hair then go blonder)
Interesting name, Pevensie. It's actually an anagram of pensieve, the basin-like device used for memories in the Harry Potter books. I don't know if that's where J.K. Rowling got the word from, but it is a strange coincidence.
I love the Narnia books and movies! 😍
The narrator can't say "Pevensie" to save his life.
pronounce their surname properly, it's pronounced correctly in the movies countless times clear as crystal
ooh how happy i am to hear ur voice, dex.
My childhood crush Edmund 💘
It's PE-ven-sie! Not Pe-veen-sie! *Hermione's voice*
Honestly I can’t be the only person who never imagined Cas with blonde hair or 13 years old? I always imagined him the same age as Peter. Same with Eustace. I imagined him the same age as Lucy in Voyage. I feel like these ages almost fit my mental image better.
They are the same age, they problem was more to do with the actors aging more than the characters in the book.
Therefore, adjustments had to be made.
Such a underrated fantasy movie/book. And its true, I remember reading these and putting my self as the characters due to them not being described. Such a wonderful story. Very magically
Great edit
Eustace is getting/was recast in Silver Chair, so I'm interested to see if they changed his appearance in any way.
peev-ence-ceee please please please pronounce it correctly😲🙃
this is the video I didn't know I needed.
No matter what I think they did a great job casting.
You missed Reepicheep! He's described as having very dark fur, with a scarlet feather stuck in a circlet around one ear. He spoke in a high, shrill voice. They got his proud mannerisms and courteousness right, but they totally missed on the rest of his appearance!
Also the white witch should have had long dark hair, as described int he first book the magicians nephew :) ( also explained why she wasnt human and how she got there and the lampost etc)
the magic apples could have changed her hair
Thank you! Finally someone talks about the different hair colors. I know people are gonna say "Calm down, hair colors aren't that big of a deal." Then I am perplexed as to why they felt a need to change them. To the complete opposite of what they were in the book. "Lucy is golden-haired? Caspian is golden-haired? Well, I guess we know we're casting brunettes then"
the way you said Pevensie tho. Made my day
The FuCking MEMORIES!!!!!
mr mumnus, movie version looks like ALEX HIRCH
It's one of my favourite movie........
I love it 😘🤩
We need more Narnia movies. We need a conclusion for the series. It was my favourite movie series.
My goodness Ben Barnes is beautiful
Me: Im off
Mam: Where are you going
Me: To Narnia
Mam: Ok Well just dont betray us
Hey, not complaining with Ben Barnes! XD one of the *Main* reasons I keep re-watching the movies than reading the books! *Although I love my books*
I think that Will Poulter portrayed his role extremely well. His appearance is perfect for it 😂
Is everyone ignoring the fact that trumpkin is not only a character name in Narnia but also what people call our president?
If only Trump were an eighth as noble as Trumpkin...
@@brumbybailey6599 ikr
I love The Chronicles of Narnia 😍😀
these movies, have and will always, a place in my heart and imagination. I can't complain.
I hate every single company that advertises online....hope they start getting the point that they are wasting money....if i can't "skip ad" I literally turn off the volume and wont even look at screen until the ad is over
G E you could download ad-blocker, it'll remove any ad on the screen.
They're actually making money and making your favorite youtubers money. You're getting completely free entertainment, could you sound a little less entitled?
no, i dont wanna
G E Without those ads, a lot of channels wouldn't exist. That's the main source of income for a lot of big youtubers. If you don't watch them, fine. But you should at least understand that they are important. and right now a lot of youtubers are actually in trouble because a lot of companies are pulling their ads from youtube.
good
Ahhh one of my favorites close to Lord of the Rings
damn it, now I have to go watch them all, this is gonna take a while. 😁
I never read all the books, but I watched the first two movies between the ages of 4 and 6, and I watched the Dawn Treader when I was 8. My dad has all the books, though, and I've read the first book.
"The Turkish Delight fiend".
Well, that's not something you hear every day...XD I liked this, gonna sub.
The 1988 BBC Mini Series was closer. Minus the epic CGI stuff. (It was 1988, after all. Blue screens!!)
Looper, luv your accent! what region are you from?
miss this series and the time it came out
Kind of sad we will never see the fourth one.
We will! They confirmed Silver Chair and there are rumors that Magician's Nephew is also being made :)
they will!!!! Both the silver chair and maybe Magician's Nephew! i'm super excited
Due to the many similarities with Snow White (and the Ice Queen), I always imagined Jadis the White Witch to have very dark hair. After all, she is pale, has red lips, is affiliated with snow, dwarves are loyal to her and she wanted an apple imbued with magical properties (in The Magician's nephew). Jadis is an evil mirror image of Snow White. Why isn't she portrayed with dark hair, as well ?
wow that's a good analogy I never thought of it like that
I think she is confirmed to be based of Satan from Paradise Lost, Ayesha from She, the Queen of Babylon from The Story of the Amulet, Lilith from Jewish mythology and finally the Snow Queen from the story of the same name.
I would not be surprised if it turns out she was a corrupted Snow White that got her hair dyed. That would be hilarious!
When I first read the book, I think of Aslan as not only great big old lion but a lion that seemed like the very embodiment of the golden sunrise because Aslan came upon Narnia with the sun upon his back...but I read this book when I was 8-9 so my memory might be a bit muddled...could be another book I was reading...
I watched Narnia back in 2006.
I grew up on this movie.
I hadnt watched it in about 10 years, until today...
Now Im sad that it's over.
After reading the books, and learning the fate of everyone (specifically Susan)
I'm just sad
PIZZA PEVENSIE!
Beoncea that's what I heard too 😂
TYRION WAS IN NARNIA XD Any GoT fans
Was Caspian thirteen in Prince Caspian or The Voyage of the Dawn Treader? I am rereading the Narnia books and I like to keep the everything true to canon in my head.
THANK YOU SO MUCH for pointing out Prince Caspian's completely random age difference between the book and the movie. It doesn't make sense at all as he being just a young boy is an important detail in his narrative in the original story.
" there was once a boy called eustace clarence scrubb and he almost deserved it." thats brave coming from a man named clive staples lewis.
also if you read the magician's nephew you'd know why the witch has pale skin and a very red mouth.
Will Poulter is a great actor.He was perfect as Eustace.
I Really Missed Mr.Tumnus,Mr.,&,Mrs.Beaver in Prince Caspian
Hey, can you do one on the old bbc Narnia compared to the books?
the witch also had black hair
A list Tilda Swinton is just about the most exotic actress in the world. Odd thing, she is almost a ringer for Elisabeth the 1st but never cast as her.
LOVE NARNIA!! Cant wait for Silver Chair to come out OMG
I forgot how much i loved this movie gosh such memories
How was I screaming, bc they start film series from second book of series. I am just so angry every time bc every time when I see fan of Narnia he doesnt know nothing about how world starts exist
the second was the most famous and the first to be published, but yeah, I get your frustration