the prices in the USA or your area must be incredible high or overpriced compared to here in central Europe. 30 kWp on a complicated roof facing south but separated in the middle by a dormer of 7 m width with a chimney for the wood oven and another one for the oil central heating was 22000€ incl. a 15 kWh lfp battery, but of cause no tesla stuff cause they could not even write an offer for a battery. Therefore how long would it take to get a quote for a whole roof from Tesla ? And here in europe there have been shingle cells out for years so Tesla has competition but again those shingles are way to expensive compared to the current solar panel prices which are here below 200€ incl. tax for each kWp , panel only without the under construction which is here about 80€ per kWp, so 280€ or roughly 300$ per kWp without the inverter side. Prices have dropped by 50% since the china is pushing its production into the EU. And they also have been able to conquer heatpump market shares most recently, a 12 kW monobloc heatpump without subsidies is shipped to EU for 2000 $ incl. customs and vat.
The promise of the Tesla roof when it was launched was that you could replace your existing roof with a solar roof and get a better product for about the cost of a new roof plus separate solar panels. That clearly hasn’t worked out. In this guys’ case he could have just as easily put regular panels on top of the metal roof on that same building. Especially because no one can see that roof the aesthetic value is basically wasted.
@@ksnax You can walk on them if you're careful and not too heavy. If you step on the frames no problem. I used to be a solar installer, we walked all over them during large commercial installs, I never broke one doing so.
Another problem is trees being in the way. Our city prides itself as being a Tree City USA from the National Arbor Foundation. No street trees can be removed or pruned without the permission of the City's arborist. There is nothing in the city's ordinance that says street trees can be cut down for solar energy projects.@@ksnax
Calling a 4000+ sq ft single family home environmentally friendly is pretty funny. I would put it more in the "prepper" category, but still pretty cool.
This is the contradiction at the heart of the modern environmentalist movement. Humans have grown used to high energy consumption and materialism. If you want to fix the environmental issues, you need to be less modern. It's as simple as that. Installing your own power plant (solar roof/batteries), water tank, propane generator, etc, imagine if everyone on earth did that? It's so incredibly inefficient per capita. If you actually want to reduce your environmental footprint, go live in a crowded building and stop using transportation, electronics, and hunt for your food.
Pennsylvania has a special new subsidy for retrofitting homes for solar energy. My house is ideal, one of the specialists involved in the program told me. The roof faces south. It has no obstructions such as trees, dormers or nearby buildings. The angle of the sun is appropriate to the climate. He recommended against installing solar. Why? My house is too small. The roof covers 450 square feet. Tiny. The cost of solar electricity and the cost of buying electricity from the grid are identical. But before solar panels can be installed, according to the specialist, I would have to replace my existing shingled roof because the shingles are halfway through their life cycle. I can't afford to re-shingle my roof. So for me, solar energy is dead. I might note that nearly property owners within a half mile of my house face the same situation. Or worse. Like me, they live in a densely built city. Their houses, like mine, are 100 years old or older. Many houses are duplexes. In half the cases, the roofs face north. Most south-facing roofs are obstructed by trees or dormers. The home owners or renters have small backyards, so the choice for the owners is either solar or places for the kids to play. Unless cities demolish densely populated housing and replace the land with McMansions like Ricky's or the gentleman from Texas, no one here can afford solar energy. For most low- and moderate-income folks, solar energy is wishful thinking.
Ricky, what you didn't mention is Tesla requires only Tesla products used with their systems and you can't repair them yourself. You need a Tesla certified repair specialist and they don't come cheap. The average US home can run off a 5-7.5Kw system and that is something most people can install themselves most places and go completely off grid.
I have an older house with a complicated, unhelpful roof. I built a solar porch with 30' x 16' of panels. It's only 6kW - but with 14kWh of batteries, it's enough for 9 months of the year. I'm surprised more people don't do similar. You get a nice shaded porch & deck out of it too. Total cost of the groundworks, steelwork, panels, battery & inverter was about $30k. It will take 6 years to pay for itself - but like you said, the most important thing it gives us is independence from the grid.
A good part of the problem with the porch solar method would be uninformed HOAs. Sadly, the average wage slave in this country can't afford to do this, and that's a shame because we don't have fancy homes that have HOAs.
@@jameswilson5165 Luckily, we don't have HOA's, just the local planning authority. They are sometimes negative about Solar - but this went through planning approval without a hitch.
Clickbait title..Glad to see more about the system, but the title is bad. The owner seems.very happy, so that is not an epic failure. All new technology is expensive until it gets redesigned and cheaper.
Well, I kind of thought we'd get info about what's good, and then a few minutes at least on what isn't going well with solar roof - such as the pathetic number of installs. I completely missed it even though I've watched this twice more or less. I'm honestly wondering if there's a part 2 or some footage that got missed out.
15:55 PLEASE don’t do a title like this again. This was a very good video, and had great production quality w/good facts and numbers, but if I’m being candid, there was never a mention of the roof being a flop or even WHY. So yeah, please don’t do this again. I’ve seen many of your videos, and I can confidently say you can do better than that!
$50,000 above the cost for standard panels is a crazy price premium. If it was $10,000 I'd start to entertain the idea but really I think that the price is a major barrier.
Agreed! As an installer and electrician, I can’t believe what people pay for these Tesla roof tiles. Freaking nuts!! That guy should have a sweet ground mount or outdoor covered space with panels.
“Us Texans value our independence “ I was living in Texas when everything froze over and people were dying. The way the grid is built “independently “ in Texas guarantees that Texans are on their own in an emergency. Politicians left us high and dry too
Just keep a gas or propane generator on the side cost me 5,000. Also people depend too much on the government to take care of them that gets you killed.
Yep. Someone claiming the principle of independence as an end to itself is so short-sighted. We live in a complicated interconnected society and world in so many aspects. And we gain so much value and benefit from our interconnectedness.
I don't know why solar is so expensive in the U.S.. I am in Sydney Australia. I just put in 6.5. kw of Q panels and a 5kw Fronius inverter for $8kAustralian ( about $5,500 U.S.). It generates an average of 25 kwhs per day.
Without solar, the energy on this house would probably cost about $6K-$10K/yr. Let’s call it $8K. After the 30% tax credit, you’re looking at $100K. So +/-12 years? The other thing to think about is that this roof will never have to be replaced again which would eliminate any insurance claims for roofing replacements. Now it’s less than 12 years. Is there any other roofing product that has an ROI?
There's another problem for people who live in snow country: avalanche! If you live where you can get 1 to 2 feet of snow in a storm, be warned that when the sun comes out the next day it warms the snowpack to the point that the entire load cuts lose at once due to the slick surface (asphalt shingle holds it in place for normal melting). Someone below can get hit with hundreds or thousands of pounds of falling snow. Not an issue in San Diego or Texas but a design factor to consider in Colorado and other places.
Depending on roof angle, snow density, etc, those work great for up to about 8" of snow. Not so much when there's 12+" , just not enough bond to the surface like standard shingle provide. Leaving roof space below the panels helps a lot that that isn't a Tesla option.
A lot of people here are pointing out the video title is clickbait. I'd have to agree somewhat, especially since Ricky did not do a good job connecting his content to the title (or vice versa). Most people have a problem with the word EPIC, myself included, but be that as it may, I don't have a problem with "failure," you just have to read between the lines of Ricky's video. .... My take away is that if the roof is not simple, flat, no protrusion roof like the one of the Texas home, the cost of putting on a Tesla solar becomes way too cost prohibitive because of all the extra time (and probably material that gets wasted) from having to make all those special angle cuts when there multiple roof planes that meet up and not a full solar roof panel can be used. I believe that's the failure Ricky poorly explained / tied in with the title. ... Still have not seen any update from @Two Bit da Vinci (Ricky) which is IMHO would go a long way in assuaging those who have complained about the title and the intent of what was meant to be conveyed in the video. ... I'll be darn. Just as I'm finishing writing this up, Ricky puts out an update. Haven't read it yet so this should be interesting. ... Nope, unfortunately nothing useful ,,, yet! ;)
Obvious clickbait title but I knew it would be good. From what I’ve seen lately, Tesla Solar roof has mainly been going on very expensive homes. It’s very expensive so I think they’re using the same approach as far as starting with the high end then eventually driving the cost lower. I don’t like cookie cutter style homes but it would be so much faster, easier and less expensive if all the roofs were the same in a neighborhood. Still, Solar roof is awesome.
3:20 ya basically if youre a multimillionaire you too can have this setup, plan out a couple years while you live in your other mansion. Maybe next time Rick can bring himself down from the clouds and focus on a solar setup practical for the lower middle class and rheir under 160,000 home in or near the Ohio/Tennessee Valley.
I agree. These rich youtoubers love talking about out of reach technology for the common man. Tax incentives don't help unless you make $100 thousand a year.
Don't forget that Rick is from San Diego and he comes from a Tech background. This means that he expects to pay more for the same services that the rest of the country has. Then again because he comes from the Tech industry that he also has the higher income level of the those of us who were Nerds in their youth, thus he has the income to have access to the higher level of tech that he just demonstrated to us. We Need this, it helps us develop our dreams, thus he provides us hope; if not for ourselves then for our children. Go for it Rick.
While I'm enthusiastic about adopting solar energy, the current costs pose a significant barrier, especially considering my power consumption. A $150k solar solution seems excessively expensive, far surpassing the grid cost by a considerable margin. Both times I've consulted with solar contractors in my area to install a grid tie system, they have discouraged solar installation as a cost-saving measure. I hope in the future, we'll witness a significant decrease in the cost of solar solutions, making them more accessible to a broader audience. I'd love to be a customer
The ROI on solar is so highly dependent on local utility rates, climate, orientation and design of your house, that "the cost of solar" is nearly meaningless. "The cost of solar for this specific house" is the better phrase. Moving to a different house may be the only way it works for you. The ROI worked for me out of dumb luck
solar contractors are discouraging solar installation? I think maybe they aren't really solar contractors then.. Did you mean to say your regular utility company discouraged you?
encouraging people to install solar panels is good...but painting tesla out as the answer..? Uncomfortably not good, especially when you can just mount affordable panels pretty much anywhere you want. The best thing about this roof-tile idea, is that if it's any good, it'll be copied and made available at a decent price. If it hasn't been copied, then it'll likely never be owt but niche, but I guess will be pretty good for bragging rights for some time to come. I hope you get a free roof out of it tho...you worked hard enough for it.
That level of spray foam I think they need a full fire mitigation system Or place rock wool over everything. I would be terrified a small spark catching. Stuff goes up like napalm.
All new homes need large 2 to 3 foot roof overhangs. This will help protect the doors, windows and siding from rain and water damage. Water intrusion is a buildings enemy and causes much damage every year.
@@wraith600original1gutters protect the foundation. That’s their main point. And no matter how good they are, enough rain and or wind, and it goes right over the gutter. And god forbid you don’t keep them constantly clean.
The lower 1/3 to 2/3 of any house wall will get hit by rain and water spattered off the surrounding ground surface. This is why bricks are so good. They withstand the water and joints can be repointed every 100 years.
@@Dave5843-d9m or even modified formulas of otherwise typical masonary compounds. Places to put viable recycled materials to reduce Garbage Hill caused by mountains of less than multi platform lego adaptability within design that we not only see, we generate enabling more of it by not demanding meaningful defacto standards on a otherwise repairable only planet in our holdings. The things that should not be overlooked, or we get what we deserve by nobodies default than our own really.
I'm hoping Tesla collaborates with other factory manufactured homes like Boxabl, Cover, and Abodu and maybe even RVs like the Lightship, PebbleFlow, and Northern Lites.
Wow that view of your house has me as a homebhowner thinking wow like all of modern media out of touch. Who can afford this? 85% of people have mo idea what b you are pitching
Two thumbs up on simplicity and orientation. The rest overlooks all the elephants in the house. Not saying people shouldn't have the choice to live remotely or in single-family single-use "neighbourhoods", but those lifestyles drive up energy demand by enormous amounts in the first place. And they are being subsidized by those who live in denser mixed use parts of the region. So many TH-cam videos out there to cover those points. The suburbs are a Ponzi scheme. We've forgotten how to build great cities and walkable neighbourhoods that would slash energy consumption, environmental degradation and air pollution. Most have never known neighbourhoods that foster community and reverse the feeling of isolation plaguing large swaths of North America. I see those aerial views of suburban sprawl and I can't imagine how horrible it would be to live there - where you never leave your home without getting in your isolation tank and swear at others in traffic. Uuugghh! PS. Spray foam has it's place. But it should be used sparingly to solve specific insulation issues. It will be a catastrophic environmental nightmare when it comes to the end of life of the building. Some cities have banned it for that reason.
I agree with you that house design should enable solar. Unfortunately, with 80% of new developments ending up under the control of the 2-bit dictator system known as the "Homeowners Association", whose first and foremost goal is to prevent any possible non-traditional use of your property from occurring, you can forget this from ever happening.
Agreed but that's no reason to give up. People need to show up to homeowners association meetings or get involved in local politics where they can to start changing the policies.
Thanks Ricky for making this video! I've always clenched when saw those intricate roofs, thinking, how on earth will you put solar on them? Therefor, when it came to designing my home I told the architect to just design the simplest roof, maximizing the area I'll be able to put solar on.
@@TwoBitDaVinci A rectangular house oriented towards yhe sun generally has more cost benefits than other house styles like lower taxes, less building costs, less maintenance, etc. Feng shui advocates square houses as well...
Tesla needs to have partnerships with new home and subdivision builders. It is more cost effective to put solar roof panels and a new roof and not have to spend labor to tear off and prep and old roof. Designing the home for solar make solar more cost effective.
I mean, yes. But also, the tear down was already going to happen…. How many people are spending this much money, and tearing down a good roof? They are replacing their old roofs, so that cost was already going to happen anyways. And if you are tearing down a good roof, you CLEARLY don’t care about costs.
@@jamesbizs Extra labor cost for the tear off and prep of the old roof adds to the cost of the roof replacement. Much cheaper to do a new house. People are not tearing off good roofs.. They are getting solar when their old roof is near the end of its life expectancy and needs to be replaced anyway.
@@KJSvitkothat’s literally what I said…. Tear off isn’t an EXTRA cost. It’s a cost that already had to happen, whether you do solar or not. I’m not sure why you’re even bringing it up, when you clearly understand and agree that no one is tearing off a good roof . Yet you still some who think tear down cost is a consideration? Compared to what?
Good Faith Energy works with architects and home builders to do just that. The challenge in Texas will be for the customer to make it clear to the architects and builders that that’s is what they are looking for as the earliest stages of the design process.
My 11kw system in New Jersey cost me $33k installed with the electrical panel upgrade. I didn't do batteries because NJ does net metering and gives you credits if you grid-connect. Also at $10k per battery, adding batteries really extends the break-even date on solar installations. With tax credits, my system will pay itself off in 6 years. One battery would push that breakeven point to 9-10 years. I will hold out for a solid state battery if I'm going to put it on my house.
Only problem with net metering and a grid connection is that we already see energy companies, and their pet politicians, working to either undermine adoptions and/or find ways to make you pay in fees and taxes for being connected to said grid, instead of the other way around. And, they could also "require" you to be grid connected to install at all, if you do so via something like tax credits, or the like, thus forcing you to pay those fees. It's inevitable that energy companies will, at some point, become backup for your own power, or a source only for those that the solar can't scale to, like companies that use massive amounts of power, but there is no way in hades they will give up making hone owners pay through the nose somehow during that transition. Mind, currently something like the Tesla power walls has the same problem as electric cars- the biggest long term cost is replacing the batteries. So.. maybe a better bet wpuld be for energy companies to solve this issue by "renting" the batteries. Something like that, or a core exchange, like with lead acid batteries will have to happen soon, or the cost, both to anyone trying to adopt such, never mind, ironically, a whole new class of environmental damage, will also become inevitable, erasing all gains made by installing it in the first place.
@@patrickelliott2169 It depends on your state. New Jersey is a solid blue state and has green energy mandates in place for the power companies as well, and I think home solar counts toward the power company mandates, so my power company is encouraging solar adoption. There is a grid connection fee every month, but for me it's $5 per month. On Long Island, NY, its' $15 per month, but they have a similar program.
How does the efficiency of Tesla solar compare to traditional solar? How does it compare to when the glass tiles first came out, and how does it compare to gaf timberline solar regarding cost durability efficiency? Good video but those are the questions I have.
GAF is nowhere near as hail resistant. Efficiency claims are close. The GAF system lays down right on the deck/waterproof barrier just like a shingle and they don't recommend an air gap or mesh. A lot of questions about how hot they get and does that hurt power production. I have the GAF system (10kW) and it doesn't seem to be a problem for me. Tesla has more air circulation. GAF has a nice looking warranty, untested by me. If you like apps, Tesla's is way better. My GAF system was maybe half the cost of Tesla, installed in one day, wired in another day, price didn't change. GAF has no social media presence that I see. I think it looks a little weird. Works for me. I was interested in Tesla but availability and price were big factors.
@@davidstewart1153just curious how much of that roof is the solar cell part? I've been wondering how good that GAF product is and haven't really found lots of reviews for it. Maybe you would like to do one:-). Or maybe get Ricky to do one!
@@laughinggas5281 About 60% of the total area for my installation. The GAF shingles are 5 feet wide and would work better on a simpler roof. Tesla tiles are easier to cram into complex roof shapes. GAF seems to market to roofers and let them sell the system, so there's no social media, influencer, referral codes etc.
I would deepen that pond because that reduces the water's heat, and hence evaporative loss. I would include swales or other rainwater harvesting structures made from onsite materials because hundred-year weather events happen. I prioritize resiliency and value-for-the-money rather than solving for one problem. I can relate to his POV. Good-to-know stuff without being annoying. I would like to install a bifacial solar panel roof over an oversized carport for my initial build.
Good stuff. Growing trees is supposed to help regulate water fluctuations better too. Permaculture builds up soil from leaf litter. This soil absorbs water better than dry hard sun baked soil. Increasing absorption and retention of water…
I can't believe that solar is so expensive in US, I'm from Croatia (EU), mostly everything is cheaper in US then EU, especially in Cro. We dont have yet Tesla panels what i know, but i worked on houses with regular solars and its about 1000e per 1kw. Worked on 20kw solar power plant it cost 20000e but firm that sale it they do all documents, permits and even apply to EU subvention witch go to 80%, other then solar panels in same subventions go, heating pumps, batteries etc.
When I hear installation numbers like that I just tune out. Who can justify that wild estimate. I don't think those people have any real idea what it will actually cost.
In a perfect world Ricky, you can design for that type of roof. As a designer I only have to keep that in the back of my mind as I'm working with my clients. My State (Washington) has a strict energy code that does have this carbon credit system which would allow near half the credits required, IF we add a solar roof. So it is coming or pushing against the tide of what residential design should look like. It is a notoriously slow industry to change.
Sorry, but I think I missed something. In what way is the "Tesla Solar Glass Roof Is an EPIC Failure"? Aside from high installation costs for complicated roofs, this seemed like a very positive assessment.
Why couldn’t a computer program be created that takes a 3D laser scan of any existing roof, finds the geometry, fills in the area as best as possible with energy producing panels and fills in the remainder with geometry of cut non producing tiles, exports that to a water jet table, and makes a bill of materials of the assembly? I’m pretty sure all of the necessary programming components already exist to do this right now.
@@TwoBitDaVinci - I do, but unfortunately you clearly did not explain that well enough in the video, hence all the "clickbait" related comments. You see that, right?
@@TwoBitDaVinci All you said in the video is how great the solar tiles are and how great this home & roof design are. Then you blamed all the problems on existing roof designs and never said "the major fail is that these panels are not designed for existing roofs" but rather "existing roofs were poorly designed to accept these panels and going forward roofs need to be designed differently to accommodate these panels" which has the causality of the problem completely backwards.
No it is far from the same thing. You see that your comment got Zero likes and everyone else did. It's quite a strong message. It would be good if you listened and I might not have to unsub again because of it @@TwoBitDaVinci
A little off topic, with spay insulation how is it recycled once the house gets demolished or renovations are done? This would be a good topic to do a video on.
Tesla already has their own construction crews at Giga Texas. The company should absolutely hire some architects to design modular housing made for solar roofs. If they want more employees in Sparks, Nevada, they need to build housing and offer it as a perk. Just like the Optimus team found they had to design their own actuators, Tesla Solar should have new home designs. Modular self-powered homes are another trillion dollar upcoming market.
Excellent video! Thanks for sharing. Remember that this pricing is prior to the 30% tax credit which makes it more affordable than a luxury roof of the same size. Also this product will eventually pay itself off and basically turn a profit on energy savings from then on. No other roofing products cover your energy cost, back up your home, or pay themselves off.
I agree completely about updating the way we build homes, and Lou's desire for independence deeply resonates with me (as do the environmental and cost savings aspects). My solar system is only 7kw, though I've about 38kwh in battery storage. Even charging my EV, I generate slightly more than I consume over the entire year, but I _love_ being energy independent (for the majority of the time anyway). I hired Tesla to do the PV / battery system in my previous home, and they did a great job, but for this home I chose a more DIY approach for various reasons. The inverter I chose is the Sol-Ark 8k specifically for its off-grid and backup generator support, and it rocks.
I had a contract to install back in 2020. The company installed two Tesla roofs and then stopped. The price was high but so was Tesla stock. 2023 I found another, bigger company and was really excited about moving forward. The price - pretty much double. So I’m going with panels and powerwalls.
Gees Rick you couldnt point out that the owner didnt want ro rely on ERCOT becuse Texas isnt part of the US grid they have their own privitized grid to totally not maximize profits.
Great video. Kind of an inaccurate title for the positive review... Ricky makes some very important points: the best roof is one flat plane, angled to the south, with no vents poking through. Stop making home roofs that are shaped like two origami swans mating! The modern style designs look better than the McMansion style that seems to be the only thing big housing developers can do. I would love to see Tesla take there solar products to the next level: a modular roof panel that has everything: structural roof, insulation, glass solar tiles, power wall inside the panel. These should be big panels, maybe four would cover the entire house. A truck shows up with four panels, a crane places them on top of the walls, plug the connectors into the house wiring - done.
Biggest issue with any in roof system is is cooling of the panels. In roof solar panels get crazy hot which can easily drops efficiency 25%. Normal COTS frameless panels mounted with a 15cm ventilation/confection gap will be much more efficient for a fraction of the cost. As long there is no active thermal cooling (integrated water system, etc) these systems are an engineering mistake. Costwise it's also impossible to compete with COTS pannels, price have dropped to 0,10$/wp or less than 25$/m2, i mean that's that's even less than the underlayment/OSB used for the roof. No way one can compete with those numbers. Just as reference i'm diy installing 40kW of frameless solar icm 60kwh of LFP for less than 10K euro, go figure....
PV panels are cheaper than windows $m² in Australia. The government loves all the homes that are not using grid electricity. As the grid generation ages and grid capacity does not have to expand the government is saving $TRILLIONS on the national grid new works.
The Title was a little "click baitey" but the content very good. Like you, I installed a 12.4 Kw Solar Panel, 2 Powerwall system on my very complex tile roof and I agree all new housing being built should use smart energy design. My Tesla solar panel system has been fantastic and is paying itself off over the 10 year Tesla Purchase ($49K at 1.9% interest rate). I am replacing all of the house appliances and going electric as they age out. Since the house and the dual HVAC are 24 years old we will be doing a Heat Pump based replacement on that which will eliminate all of my need for natural gas. That will be the last piece of my true off grid energy independence. I'm hoping that Tesla builds a residential heat pump system so that all of my energy consuming and generating systems can be controlled by a single application and I believe that good comprehensive data is an important aspect of true energy independence. The Tesla software provides that. Rather than more powerwalls, my plan is to use our 2 EV's as a storage resource for the overall home energy and so bi-directional charging (vehicle to home) will be a factor in all of my EV purchases in the future. Keep up the good work Ricky ... 👍
Solar seems to be very expensive in the US. In Australia, I put in 13.2kw of solar on our roof which cost about $8,000 (AU), this includes the inverters (2 x 5kw inverters) and installation cost. We have a subsidy scheme, but it's fading away year by year as the rebate scheme decreases. The market is so mature we pretty much don't need it anymore. Without the rebate, I would have paid about an additional $4,500 (AU), being $12,500 (AU) in total; which is about $8,396.25 (US). There is so much competition in the US, I would have expected even better prices.
It does get South and West shading from those trees that are fairly close. Depending on the system, a small percentage of shading can greatly reduce the solar collection.
35 years in the Industry…The elimination of all cutting of solar tiles was needed. Start with ‘’New Construction Only’’ 1. Produce about 3 continuous sizes, example: 6’ 10’. 14’. 2. Mandate contractors build houses in sections to those exact sizes. 3. Channel all pipes ect. in attic to 1 or more decorative fireplaces with hinged tops for access. 4. Optional application would be VERTICAL for allowing different lengths & heights of given sections. This mimics standing seam metal roofs. Any competent roofing crew could prep the roof beforehand hand & finish any roof up to approximately 5,000 in 1 day. -“Some’’ Existing houses could be converted by construction companies to channel pipes through Attic to false chimneys & re configure roof..
Better than most of his other clock bait titles. It’s literally all he and many other creators like him are capable of doing. Literally every single thing ever, is ground breaking or revolutionary or insert another overused phrase
Won't be log till i'm triggered in to a protest unsub then. I'm sure I was subbed here previously, but it's been so long I've forgotten. I can't remember why i unsubbed previously.@@jamesbizs
I find the topics you pick for your show really interesting and relevant. On solar roofs, it seems that house design needs to change. The focus needs to change from curb appeal to practicality. Subdivisions need to be oriented in such a way that the predominant roof needs to face south for use with solar panels or solar roofs. This is a municipal requirement issue. It may take a private developer to jump start this type of development.
Home design is virtually unchanged since colonial times; before plumbing and septic, heating and cooling, let alone electricity and Internet. We can do much better.
I think when they spray foam the attic like that - it is considered part of the conditioned envelope even if not directly conditioned. It would be interesting to put a heat pump water heater in that attic and see what the ambient temperatures are…
Great intentional design. However, solar will not cover you entire energy usage during winter months unless you 3-5x the system size. Works great on high irradiance days but solar will not be a single source of off-grid power during all months of the year without drastically oversizing your system, defeating the ROI term.
I’ll “challenge the argument” that this video title is not representative of the video, but we could have already anticipated that by the clickbait title, “here’s why”.
In Florida I received a discount on insurance for the opposite type of roof. Lots of hips and valleys. I guess it makes it harder for hurricanes to peel them off.
I’ve been saying this forever, why are we trying to retrofit old homes with solar. This is a product for new homes where the roof is designed for solar. That is how to make solar work. There are just so many inefficiencies in retrofitting and existing home.
I cashed a roofer about my roof about 3 years ago. I have an old home - built 1926. It was $50k for the roof, and a single Powerwall. I did Euroshield instead, even that was $25k.
I have often seen overly complicated roof designs on newer builds. Or roofs facing the wrong way. I object to them not only because of the difficulty for solar installs, but any shingle replacement is more expensive with extra labour needed with more potential for failure and water intrusion. Ironically, houses built prior to the 2000s are often better suited for solar. Our house has a huge south facing area. There is an 8.9 kw system on there now with room for another 6 kw as our electrical needs increase. It is possible to retrofit an older home for energy efficiency. My rental was made of 2 by 4 construction with cheap r12 insulation. Probably not even that. I first upgraded the siding which gave me another r5. Upgraded the windows at the same time. Whenever I upgrade a room I add a 2 by 2 on the studs making it 2 X 6. I can fill this space with roxul (r22). I then add 1 inch of foam which is also a vapour barrier (r5) and a thermal break. So go from r 8 or 12 to r32. I did this not only to save money, but also to make the house more comfortable. It was hot in the summer, cold in the winter.
The Tesla solar roof quote for my house was $228K for about 13 KW and 3 powerwalls. I think my roof was more complicated than yours! I'm hoping their prices will drop a bit in the future...
From everything I’ve heard the real problem with Tesla roofs were incomplete installations. My sister put up the big bucks for a system on her existing house in the Boston area. They installed the panels and left without finalizing the installation. She was forced to wait several years for them to come back and finish the installation. The installer had gotten paid for the roof. She had to wait for the electric to be finished and without that there is no payback and the low profits on that section left no incentive to the installer to come back. In retrospect I’m sure she would have had the contract written differently, just saying buyer beware and read the fine print.
Hunh. A contractor who leaves enormous gaps in the job timeline while they pursue other work, screwing their existing clients. Never heard of that happening before.
Our Tesla solar roof was installed October 2021, in SW Washington state. I agree about roof design for solar, but I wouldn't go as extreme as this guy. Personally I hate shed roofs. One thing I did to make more clear space on the south plane was move a vent from the south to the north plane. It isn't hard to do in most cases. But I think houses should be designed with no vents on the south planes, i.e. put the vents on gable ends or the north planes. Tesla actually installed a lot of PV tiles on the north plane as well, fortunately my "new" vent did not interfere with those. In terms of ROI, if I can skip a roof replacement in 21 years (which I think is likely), the extra cost is definitely worth it. Or if I get invited to participate in a VPP (not yet, but very likely), the ROI will be much better. Part of the problem with Tesla solar roof is Tesla seems to lack a clear commitment to making them profitable and successful. Elon doesn't give them much love - but then again he is a wildcard, so that may be a good thing. I do think Tesla solar roofs make sense, but not on complex or shaded roofs. Our setup: 10.6kW + 2 powerwalls, total cost $79k minus 27% tax rebates. 2300 ft^2 house, nothing fancy, built 1990. Produces more than we use, even here in the cloudiest part of the country. Including the $12/month connection fee, our power bill last year was $5.10. We have been extremely happy with the roof and its performance.
You can retrofit your current traditional vented attic into a conditioned space by sealing it up with spray foam, I've done it in my current property. When it was built, it had a vented attic and the problem with this design is that not only is it not energy efficient, it was letting bugs in and also causing issues with truss uplifting that resulting in cracking on walls and doors not closing properly during certain season. I had a contractor come in and seal off the attic with spray foam and all those problems go away. One thing you will want to consider is that you don't have to use spray foam for the entire insulation. It can be a lot cheaper to have them use spray foam to seal up the attic first, then have batts attached behind the foam secured using twine. You will get the same resulting R value for insulation and it'll be a lot cheaper.
IMO, a single plane roof with no protrusion is actual ideal for regular solar panels. The panels can be installed in the exact center of the roof to enhance the aesthetics. The fact that it would be much less expensive just makes it a no-brainer to me.
The price point is 3x what it should be... They said leasing, or paying over time would make these affordable. I have 21+ square & it is more than the value of my home to put this on... Impossible~
Well, if you can and want to remodel your roof to be designed to all face south, like Lou’s house; why not? It might be expensive initially, BUT being energy independent is priceless. Yes, I’m from Texas. Yes, we did go through the snowpocalypse. It was three days with no power. Worst experience of my life. No heat, food went bad, no burst water lines, but it was pretty ugly. How much would a person be willing to to pay to not experience that again? 🤔
Great video. I don't think they're going to give up. They just really need to work on producing these at scale much more affordably. My neighbor just got a tesla solar roof. It looks awesome. Haven't gotten an update from them on how they like it they've only had it for a couple months. But I will definitely be interested in finding out
Elon always thinks in decades, might have a slow ramp up but it would make sense if they partnered up with more and more companies that build houses from scratch.. bound to happen
I've had a Tesla solar roof since 2019, with panels made in New York and 2 x 3rd gen Powerwalls. We've had no physical problems with the system, only some software issues with the solar inverter that were solved after a firmware update obtained from the inverter manufacturer and installed by a Tesla employee. The only negative aspect I have, upon reflection, is that we get quite a bit less energy from the roof than we thought. It's about 30% less than the estimates Tesla gave us. I guess, if you want to go with a system like this, don't worry about things like roof leaks, that shouldn't happen. But you're going to be disappointed if you expect to get ALL of the kilowatts as stated in your contract, even on a perfectly sunny day at noon on the longest day of the year. The solar we get is still useful, but if we ever end up disconnected from the grid for an extended outage, we will only be able to power our refrigerator and microwave off of the solar, and charge our phones. No computers, TV, washer, dryer, dishwasher, HVAC - they use too much energy.
The only thing this video made me realize is that on a new home build trying to buy a 25kw solar roof setup would be WAY out of reach. That is insane that his cost that much with that simple a setup.
The Texas grid would be just fine if we disconnect the windmills that do not put out reliable amounts of power and make it a slow process of firing up a natural gas power plant to take the load.
Solar panels should be built at different angles for different latitudes, all flat, with water cooling/hot water heating as one. So, rooves first, then build beneath them. Of course, building the roof would be in a factory, BIG panels, so build delivery trailers that can lean them over to pass low bridges or make the factories movable to build an entire subdivision, pre-insulated at the factory, pre-wired at the factory, pre-piped for hot water at the factory, modular. Making solar shingles is suboptimal.
The urethane foam was not applied in a remotely uniform manner. The brief spray installation demonstration showed no attempt to fill the wall pocket corners first, and left a visible void at the bottom of the wall. . A good operator using application equipment like Grayco brand and 2 pound per cubic foot high lift foam can fill 2x6 wall cavities in 2 pases with a much smoother job.
🙄I'm a devoted fan of your channel, Ricky; but I'm rolling my eyes right now! It is possible to have a traditional house with a traditional roof (I'm building a hacienda-style home in Arizona with a red clay tile roof) and put your solar array with perfect orientation, etc. elsewhere on the property! I only have a quarter acre lot and I'm an avid gardener, so preserving sunlight for the garden is important to me and I still managed to figure it out. I flatly refuse to live in an Uber-modern, shed-roof or flat-roof house! Nope, barrel tiles and charming historic details for me and I will STILL be independent of the grid.
Freedom is choice. I'm glad you have the freedom to roll your eyes and enjoy a more rustic character to your hoe, but please don't deny the rest of us the freedom to also choose what we like. Including the channel owner, who puts more time and energy in to making these than you probably realise. This content isn't made just for you. Take your rolly eyes and roll on.
My wife and I are in the process of building a new home. It will be a shed roof and there will be solar exposure. So this Tesla roof may be the ticket. But I wonder about how they handle necessary protrusions like plumbing vents, etc. We also have not been able to get a reply from Tesla regarding doing a project in our area. Union, Washington
Ricky, did the quoted cost reflect the 30% IRA deduction? $120k for a monster sized durable roof + 17kwh solar + 4(!) Tesla PW battery storage is compelling for Premium homes.
Please take a look at GAF and other solar roof products. Still, I would LOVE a Tesla Roof, but my house isn't reasonable for it. We need Retrofit roofs too!
There's only 2 things holding tesla solar from being huge: 1. The company doesn't have enough installers. 2. The price is about 50% to high; regular solar panels are so much cheaper, so tesla needs to streamline their process to get prices down.
RICKY!!!!!!! Stay away from the click-bait titles!!!! Epic failure? Really? Come on. Every time you do this, respect and trust is lost in you and your videos.
@@TwoBitDaVinci - Sorry, Ricky, it is not clear. An what is that reason? Because 99% of roof lines are too challenging for Tesla solar roof panels to be installed thus increasing the cost? (See my post attempting to explain your possible intent. I could still be wrong. An update from you that's more than 10 or so words IMO would be helpful.) None the less, thanks for the video and agree the design and construction of the roof could and should be better going forward, but I fear that won't be enough, soon enough to make a difference. According to the National Association of Realtors (NAR), only 15% of homes bought today in the US are new. In other words, at least 85% of homes probably have undesirable roofs for Tesla solar roof panels, which is not Tesla's fault.
@@TwoBitDaVinci Ricky, the Tesla roof as a product is not a total flop. It’s a good but expensive product for those with the pockets to utilize it as it was designed. The problem with ALL solar power is, homes in the USA were never built with solar in mind. This means many homes are NOT good candidates for solar. For the homes that might be able to utilize solar, angled panels are the only real cost-effective option. Tesla roofs are either for the new construction crowd (such as this property), or for owners who can afford the expense of such a roof and associated equipment/batteries/panels. My point is, putting “TOTAL Flop” in the title of your video is clear click-bait. I’ve been following your channel for years and for the most part have found them, and most importantly YOU, trustworthy and informative. These titles (yes you have done it several times and I’ve commented each time) waters down a respectable product. PLEASE STOP IT!!!
I'm surprised you didn't talk about how this same technology will be used by the Australian government to stabilized their electric system. Tesla solar and battery are doing massive strides in Australia leaving this out of the conversation suggesting it's a failure just seems in bad faith for clicks.
Buying a Tesla? Use my link! geni.us/GoTesla
the prices in the USA or your area must be incredible high or overpriced compared to here in central Europe.
30 kWp on a complicated roof facing south but separated in the middle by a dormer of 7 m width with a chimney for the wood oven and another one for the oil central heating was 22000€ incl. a 15 kWh lfp battery, but of cause no tesla stuff cause they could not even write an offer for a battery.
Therefore how long would it take to get a quote for a whole roof from Tesla ?
And here in europe there have been shingle cells out for years so Tesla has competition but again those shingles are way to expensive compared to the current solar panel prices which are here below 200€ incl. tax for each kWp , panel only without the under construction which is here about 80€ per kWp, so 280€ or roughly 300$ per kWp without the inverter side.
Prices have dropped by 50% since the china is pushing its production into the EU.
And they also have been able to conquer heatpump market shares most recently, a 12 kW monobloc heatpump without subsidies is shipped to EU for 2000 $ incl. customs and vat.
The promise of the Tesla roof when it was launched was that you could replace your existing roof with a solar roof and get a better product for about the cost of a new roof plus separate solar panels.
That clearly hasn’t worked out. In this guys’ case he could have just as easily put regular panels on top of the metal roof on that same building. Especially because no one can see that roof the aesthetic value is basically wasted.
Yes plus factor in $150K for a meager 17 KWH of solar and only 50 KWH of storage, this is a $10K system, not $150K.
You can install traditional solar panels with water-proofing in between them, thus serving as roof, saving money on roofing materials and work too.
@@NeblogaiLT I could be wrong, but conventional panels are generally not walkable - and that may be a code requirement for some situations.
@@ksnax You can walk on them if you're careful and not too heavy. If you step on the frames no problem. I used to be a solar installer, we walked all over them during large commercial installs, I never broke one doing so.
Another problem is trees being in the way. Our city prides itself as being a Tree City USA from the National Arbor Foundation. No street trees can be removed or pruned without the permission of the City's arborist. There is nothing in the city's ordinance that says street trees can be cut down for solar energy projects.@@ksnax
Calling a 4000+ sq ft single family home environmentally friendly is pretty funny. I would put it more in the "prepper" category, but still pretty cool.
Everything is bigger in Texas.
This is the contradiction at the heart of the modern environmentalist movement. Humans have grown used to high energy consumption and materialism. If you want to fix the environmental issues, you need to be less modern. It's as simple as that. Installing your own power plant (solar roof/batteries), water tank, propane generator, etc, imagine if everyone on earth did that? It's so incredibly inefficient per capita. If you actually want to reduce your environmental footprint, go live in a crowded building and stop using transportation, electronics, and hunt for your food.
@bloong1080 then bring your gutted, tongue out deer home on public transportation.
welcome to Texas where everything is bigger.
Pennsylvania has a special new subsidy for retrofitting homes for solar energy. My house is ideal, one of the specialists involved in the program told me. The roof faces south. It has no obstructions such as trees, dormers or nearby buildings. The angle of the sun is appropriate to the climate. He recommended against installing solar.
Why? My house is too small. The roof covers 450 square feet. Tiny. The cost of solar electricity and the cost of buying electricity from the grid are identical. But before solar panels can be installed, according to the specialist, I would have to replace my existing shingled roof because the shingles are halfway through their life cycle. I can't afford to re-shingle my roof. So for me, solar energy is dead.
I might note that nearly property owners within a half mile of my house face the same situation. Or worse. Like me, they live in a densely built city. Their houses, like mine, are 100 years old or older. Many houses are duplexes. In half the cases, the roofs face north. Most south-facing roofs are obstructed by trees or dormers. The home owners or renters have small backyards, so the choice for the owners is either solar or places for the kids to play.
Unless cities demolish densely populated housing and replace the land with McMansions like Ricky's or the gentleman from Texas, no one here can afford solar energy. For most low- and moderate-income folks, solar energy is wishful thinking.
Ricky, what you didn't mention is Tesla requires only Tesla products used with their systems and you can't repair them yourself. You need a Tesla certified repair specialist and they don't come cheap. The average US home can run off a 5-7.5Kw system and that is something most people can install themselves most places and go completely off grid.
I have an older house with a complicated, unhelpful roof. I built a solar porch with 30' x 16' of panels. It's only 6kW - but with 14kWh of batteries, it's enough for 9 months of the year. I'm surprised more people don't do similar. You get a nice shaded porch & deck out of it too. Total cost of the groundworks, steelwork, panels, battery & inverter was about $30k.
It will take 6 years to pay for itself - but like you said, the most important thing it gives us is independence from the grid.
my electric bill is less than 50/ month from the utility. so solar would never be worth it
That’s amazing!!
Thinking about adding a porch system to my system as our current system is close but not quite enough
A good part of the problem with the porch solar method would be uninformed HOAs. Sadly, the average wage slave in this country can't afford to do this, and that's a shame because we don't have fancy homes that have HOAs.
@@jameswilson5165 Luckily, we don't have HOA's, just the local planning authority. They are sometimes negative about Solar - but this went through planning approval without a hitch.
Clickbait title..Glad to see more about the system, but the title is bad. The owner seems.very happy, so that is not an epic failure. All new technology is expensive until it gets redesigned and cheaper.
It actually made me not want to watch it on that basis. I'd have missed an interesting vid, if the quality of the channel hadn't swayed me.
It is a failure vs what was actually promised.
Well, I kind of thought we'd get info about what's good, and then a few minutes at least on what isn't going well with solar roof - such as the pathetic number of installs. I completely missed it even though I've watched this twice more or less. I'm honestly wondering if there's a part 2 or some footage that got missed out.
Wake up from your Musk cult
@@jonevansauthoryeah that’s the question. Why has Tesla failed to ramp it up?
15:55 PLEASE don’t do a title like this again. This was a very good video, and had great production quality w/good facts and numbers, but if I’m being candid, there was never a mention of the roof being a flop or even WHY. So yeah, please don’t do this again. I’ve seen many of your videos, and I can confidently say you can do better than that!
$50,000 above the cost for standard panels is a crazy price premium. If it was $10,000 I'd start to entertain the idea but really I think that the price is a major barrier.
Agreed! As an installer and electrician, I can’t believe what people pay for these Tesla roof tiles. Freaking nuts!! That guy should have a sweet ground mount or outdoor covered space with panels.
@@MGiosparky yep. Never pay more than $2/watt installed or you’re getting robbed
“Us Texans value our independence “ I was living in Texas when everything froze over and people were dying. The way the grid is built “independently “ in Texas guarantees that Texans are on their own in an emergency. Politicians left us high and dry too
Just keep a gas or propane generator on the side cost me 5,000. Also people depend too much on the government to take care of them that gets you killed.
Yep. Someone claiming the principle of independence as an end to itself is so short-sighted. We live in a complicated interconnected society and world in so many aspects. And we gain so much value and benefit from our interconnectedness.
Sure, Texans value independence, unless you are a pregnant woman.
Did you vote for the people representing you?
PV panels on rail mounts stay cooler on hot days and so produce more electricity. Cooling air beneath the panels is good. 😊
I don't know why solar is so expensive in the U.S.. I am in Sydney Australia. I just put in 6.5. kw of Q panels and a 5kw Fronius inverter for $8kAustralian ( about $5,500 U.S.). It generates an average of 25 kwhs per day.
Exactly. Installers here a robbing homeowners. The panels racking balance of system and inverter should be less than $2 per watt installed
how do the financials look for this install? how many years to pay off? looks great but expensive.
Without solar, the energy on this house would probably cost about $6K-$10K/yr. Let’s call it $8K. After the 30% tax credit, you’re looking at $100K. So +/-12 years?
The other thing to think about is that this roof will never have to be replaced again which would eliminate any insurance claims for roofing replacements. Now it’s less than 12 years.
Is there any other roofing product that has an ROI?
@@pablovial11 thanks for the reply. doesn’t 8K seem high though? i live in 3300 sq ft in minnesota and average about $3K/year.
There's another problem for people who live in snow country: avalanche! If you live where you can get 1 to 2 feet of snow in a storm, be warned that when the sun comes out the next day it warms the snowpack to the point that the entire load cuts lose at once due to the slick surface (asphalt shingle holds it in place for normal melting). Someone below can get hit with hundreds or thousands of pounds of falling snow. Not an issue in San Diego or Texas but a design factor to consider in Colorado and other places.
That's what snow guards are for. You'll need them for metal and slate roofs, as well.
Depending on roof angle, snow density, etc, those work great for up to about 8" of snow. Not so much when there's 12+" , just not enough bond to the surface like standard shingle provide. Leaving roof space below the panels helps a lot that that isn't a Tesla option.
A lot of people here are pointing out the video title is clickbait. I'd have to agree somewhat, especially since Ricky did not do a good job connecting his content to the title (or vice versa). Most people have a problem with the word EPIC, myself included, but be that as it may, I don't have a problem with "failure," you just have to read between the lines of Ricky's video. .... My take away is that if the roof is not simple, flat, no protrusion roof like the one of the Texas home, the cost of putting on a Tesla solar becomes way too cost prohibitive because of all the extra time (and probably material that gets wasted) from having to make all those special angle cuts when there multiple roof planes that meet up and not a full solar roof panel can be used. I believe that's the failure Ricky poorly explained / tied in with the title. ... Still have not seen any update from @Two Bit da Vinci (Ricky) which is IMHO would go a long way in assuaging those who have complained about the title and the intent of what was meant to be conveyed in the video. ... I'll be darn. Just as I'm finishing writing this up, Ricky puts out an update. Haven't read it yet so this should be interesting. ... Nope, unfortunately nothing useful ,,, yet! ;)
Hardly "an epic failure"...!
“Tesla solar has been a total flop”
…
“Use our referral link when ordering Tesla solar!”
Obvious clickbait title but I knew it would be good. From what I’ve seen lately, Tesla Solar roof has mainly been going on very expensive homes. It’s very expensive so I think they’re using the same approach as far as starting with the high end then eventually driving the cost lower. I don’t like cookie cutter style homes but it would be so much faster, easier and less expensive if all the roofs were the same in a neighborhood. Still, Solar roof is awesome.
Not clickbait. Watch launch event
100% intentional clickbait. What are you talking about!@@justinr9753
The click bait title is really disappointing. I expect more of this channel
3:20 ya basically if youre a multimillionaire you too can have this setup, plan out a couple years while you live in your other mansion. Maybe next time Rick can bring himself down from the clouds and focus on a solar setup practical for the lower middle class and rheir under 160,000 home in or near the Ohio/Tennessee Valley.
I agree. These rich youtoubers love talking about out of reach technology for the common man. Tax incentives don't help unless you make $100 thousand a year.
Don't forget that Rick is from San Diego and he comes from a Tech background. This means that he expects to pay more for the same services that the rest of the country has. Then again because he comes from the Tech industry that he also has the higher income level of the those of us who were Nerds in their youth, thus he has the income to have access to the higher level of tech that he just demonstrated to us. We Need this, it helps us develop our dreams, thus he provides us hope; if not for ourselves then for our children. Go for it Rick.
While I'm enthusiastic about adopting solar energy, the current costs pose a significant barrier, especially considering my power consumption. A $150k solar solution seems excessively expensive, far surpassing the grid cost by a considerable margin. Both times I've consulted with solar contractors in my area to install a grid tie system, they have discouraged solar installation as a cost-saving measure. I hope in the future, we'll witness a significant decrease in the cost of solar solutions, making them more accessible to a broader audience. I'd love to be a customer
No one said you have to get a solar roof…. People have been installing affordable solar panels for quite awhile
The ROI on solar is so highly dependent on local utility rates, climate, orientation and design of your house, that "the cost of solar" is nearly meaningless. "The cost of solar for this specific house" is the better phrase. Moving to a different house may be the only way it works for you.
The ROI worked for me out of dumb luck
@@tedmcdaniel2951you missed the biggest aspect. Rebates and Tax incentives…. Oh and, whether you do, and how much you get back from the utilities
solar contractors are discouraging solar installation? I think maybe they aren't really solar contractors then.. Did you mean to say your regular utility company discouraged you?
@@TylerFernandes94he stated they discouraged framing solar as solely a cost saving measure
encouraging people to install solar panels is good...but painting tesla out as the answer..? Uncomfortably not good, especially when you can just mount affordable panels pretty much anywhere you want.
The best thing about this roof-tile idea, is that if it's any good, it'll be copied and made available at a decent price. If it hasn't been copied, then it'll likely never be owt but niche, but I guess will be pretty good for bragging rights for some time to come.
I hope you get a free roof out of it tho...you worked hard enough for it.
That level of spray foam I think they need a full fire mitigation system Or place rock wool over everything. I would be terrified a small spark catching. Stuff goes up like napalm.
All new homes need large 2 to 3 foot roof overhangs. This will help protect the doors, windows and siding from rain and water damage. Water intrusion is a buildings enemy and causes much damage every year.
good gutters do the same thing and better an overhang will only protect a small part of the wall unless the rain is vertical
@@wraith600original1gutters protect the foundation. That’s their main point. And no matter how good they are, enough rain and or wind, and it goes right over the gutter. And god forbid you don’t keep them constantly clean.
The lower 1/3 to 2/3 of any house wall will get hit by rain and water spattered off the surrounding ground surface. This is why bricks are so good. They withstand the water and joints can be repointed every 100 years.
I understand that, perspective is everything.
@@Dave5843-d9m or even modified formulas of otherwise typical masonary compounds. Places to put viable recycled materials to reduce Garbage Hill caused by mountains of less than multi platform lego adaptability within design that we not only see, we generate enabling more of it by not demanding meaningful defacto standards on a otherwise repairable only planet in our holdings.
The things that should not be overlooked, or we get what we deserve by nobodies default than our own really.
"Tesla Solar Glass Roof Is an EPIC Failure - What Happened?" Please explain the "epic failure".
I'm hoping Tesla collaborates with other factory manufactured homes like Boxabl, Cover, and Abodu and maybe even RVs like the Lightship, PebbleFlow, and Northern Lites.
Wow that view of your house has me as a homebhowner thinking wow like all of modern media out of touch. Who can afford this? 85% of people have mo idea what b you are pitching
Finally a clickbait title that is kind of true. 😂
Your video title is CLICKBAIT. Sad because your content is good. You do not resort to clickbait .
Two thumbs up on simplicity and orientation. The rest overlooks all the elephants in the house. Not saying people shouldn't have the choice to live remotely or in single-family single-use "neighbourhoods", but those lifestyles drive up energy demand by enormous amounts in the first place. And they are being subsidized by those who live in denser mixed use parts of the region. So many TH-cam videos out there to cover those points. The suburbs are a Ponzi scheme.
We've forgotten how to build great cities and walkable neighbourhoods that would slash energy consumption, environmental degradation and air pollution. Most have never known neighbourhoods that foster community and reverse the feeling of isolation plaguing large swaths of North America. I see those aerial views of suburban sprawl and I can't imagine how horrible it would be to live there - where you never leave your home without getting in your isolation tank and swear at others in traffic. Uuugghh!
PS. Spray foam has it's place. But it should be used sparingly to solve specific insulation issues. It will be a catastrophic environmental nightmare when it comes to the end of life of the building. Some cities have banned it for that reason.
False advertising with title. Didn’t see any mention of failure
It’s been a total commercial flop… what do you mean?
I agree with you that house design should enable solar. Unfortunately, with 80% of new developments ending up under the control of the 2-bit dictator system known as the "Homeowners Association", whose first and foremost goal is to prevent any possible non-traditional use of your property from occurring, you can forget this from ever happening.
Agreed but that's no reason to give up. People need to show up to homeowners association meetings or get involved in local politics where they can to start changing the policies.
Thanks Ricky for making this video! I've always clenched when saw those intricate roofs, thinking, how on earth will you put solar on them? Therefor, when it came to designing my home I told the architect to just design the simplest roof, maximizing the area I'll be able to put solar on.
I thought the same thing!
@@TwoBitDaVinci
A rectangular house oriented towards yhe sun generally has more cost benefits than other house styles like lower taxes, less building costs, less maintenance, etc. Feng shui advocates square houses as well...
Those intricate roofs are dumb for a lot of reasons.
@@dustman96
Not sure much intricate but compound, but essentially agreed.
Tesla needs to have partnerships with new home and subdivision builders. It is more cost effective to put solar roof panels and a new roof and not have to spend labor to tear off and prep and old roof. Designing the home for solar make solar more cost effective.
I mean, yes. But also, the tear down was already going to happen…. How many people are spending this much money, and tearing down a good roof? They are replacing their old roofs, so that cost was already going to happen anyways. And if you are tearing down a good roof, you CLEARLY don’t care about costs.
@@jamesbizs Extra labor cost for the tear off and prep of the old roof adds to the cost of the roof replacement. Much cheaper to do a new house. People are not tearing off good roofs.. They are getting solar when their old roof is near the end of its life expectancy and needs to be replaced anyway.
@@KJSvitkothat’s literally what I said…. Tear off isn’t an EXTRA cost. It’s a cost that already had to happen, whether you do solar or not. I’m not sure why you’re even bringing it up, when you clearly understand and agree that no one is tearing off a good roof . Yet you still some who think tear down cost is a consideration? Compared to what?
Good Faith Energy works with architects and home builders to do just that. The challenge in Texas will be for the customer to make it clear to the architects and builders that that’s is what they are looking for as the earliest stages of the design process.
My 11kw system in New Jersey cost me $33k installed with the electrical panel upgrade. I didn't do batteries because NJ does net metering and gives you credits if you grid-connect. Also at $10k per battery, adding batteries really extends the break-even date on solar installations. With tax credits, my system will pay itself off in 6 years. One battery would push that breakeven point to 9-10 years. I will hold out for a solid state battery if I'm going to put it on my house.
Only problem with net metering and a grid connection is that we already see energy companies, and their pet politicians, working to either undermine adoptions and/or find ways to make you pay in fees and taxes for being connected to said grid, instead of the other way around. And, they could also "require" you to be grid connected to install at all, if you do so via something like tax credits, or the like, thus forcing you to pay those fees. It's inevitable that energy companies will, at some point, become backup for your own power, or a source only for those that the solar can't scale to, like companies that use massive amounts of power, but there is no way in hades they will give up making hone owners pay through the nose somehow during that transition.
Mind, currently something like the Tesla power walls has the same problem as electric cars- the biggest long term cost is replacing the batteries. So.. maybe a better bet wpuld be for energy companies to solve this issue by "renting" the batteries. Something like that, or a core exchange, like with lead acid batteries will have to happen soon, or the cost, both to anyone trying to adopt such, never mind, ironically, a whole new class of environmental damage, will also become inevitable, erasing all gains made by installing it in the first place.
@@patrickelliott2169 It depends on your state. New Jersey is a solid blue state and has green energy mandates in place for the power companies as well, and I think home solar counts toward the power company mandates, so my power company is encouraging solar adoption. There is a grid connection fee every month, but for me it's $5 per month. On Long Island, NY, its' $15 per month, but they have a similar program.
How does the efficiency of Tesla solar compare to traditional solar? How does it compare to when the glass tiles first came out, and how does it compare to gaf timberline solar regarding cost durability efficiency? Good video but those are the questions I have.
GAF is nowhere near as hail resistant. Efficiency claims are close. The GAF system lays down right on the deck/waterproof barrier just like a shingle and they don't recommend an air gap or mesh. A lot of questions about how hot they get and does that hurt power production. I have the GAF system (10kW) and it doesn't seem to be a problem for me. Tesla has more air circulation. GAF has a nice looking warranty, untested by me. If you like apps, Tesla's is way better. My GAF system was maybe half the cost of Tesla, installed in one day, wired in another day, price didn't change. GAF has no social media presence that I see. I think it looks a little weird. Works for me. I was interested in Tesla but availability and price were big factors.
@@davidstewart1153just curious how much of that roof is the solar cell part? I've been wondering how good that GAF product is and haven't really found lots of reviews for it. Maybe you would like to do one:-). Or maybe get Ricky to do one!
@@laughinggas5281 About 60% of the total area for my installation. The GAF shingles are 5 feet wide and would work better on a simpler roof. Tesla tiles are easier to cram into complex roof shapes. GAF seems to market to roofers and let them sell the system, so there's no social media, influencer, referral codes etc.
I would deepen that pond because that reduces the water's heat, and hence evaporative loss. I would include swales or other rainwater harvesting structures made from onsite materials because hundred-year weather events happen.
I prioritize resiliency and value-for-the-money rather than solving for one problem. I can relate to his POV.
Good-to-know stuff without being annoying. I would like to install a bifacial solar panel roof over an oversized carport for my initial build.
Good stuff. Growing trees is supposed to help regulate water fluctuations better too. Permaculture builds up soil from leaf litter. This soil absorbs water better than dry hard sun baked soil. Increasing absorption and retention of water…
@@michaelsmithers4900
Agreed. I follow Brad Lancaster and am hoping bioswales become a bigger thing.
Thanks, Ricky! I’m not offended by the title of your post. I’ve been wondering about this very issue. I clicked it first thing.
Glad to hear it! I changed it… Tesla fans can get so sensitive. I love this thing… but there’s a story here! Cheers Sir!
I can't believe that solar is so expensive in US, I'm from Croatia (EU), mostly everything is cheaper in US then EU, especially in Cro. We dont have yet Tesla panels what i know, but i worked on houses with regular solars and its about 1000e per 1kw. Worked on 20kw solar power plant it cost 20000e but firm that sale it they do all documents, permits and even apply to EU subvention witch go to 80%, other then solar panels in same subventions go, heating pumps, batteries etc.
It's not, these quotes noted in the video are ridiculous and way too high.
When I hear installation numbers like that I just tune out. Who can justify that wild estimate. I don't think those people have any real idea what it will actually cost.
In a perfect world Ricky, you can design for that type of roof. As a designer I only have to keep that in the back of my mind as I'm working with my clients. My State (Washington) has a strict energy code that does have this carbon credit system which would allow near half the credits required, IF we add a solar roof. So it is coming or pushing against the tide of what residential design should look like. It is a notoriously slow industry to change.
Sorry, but I think I missed something. In what way is the "Tesla Solar Glass Roof Is an EPIC Failure"?
Aside from high installation costs for complicated roofs, this seemed like a very positive assessment.
Why couldn’t a computer program be created that takes a 3D laser scan of any existing roof, finds the geometry, fills in the area as best as possible with energy producing panels and fills in the remainder with geometry of cut non producing tiles, exports that to a water jet table, and makes a bill of materials of the assembly? I’m pretty sure all of the necessary programming components already exist to do this right now.
yeah, this is a good question. Elon should know more about this than anyone else. He better be solving it.
Clickbait title vs content. So, the Tesla solar panels are not an epic failure but rather existing home & roof designs are not ideal.
You see why that’s the same right? A market is the prime source for a product. Hope that’s clear. Cheers
@@TwoBitDaVinci - I do, but unfortunately you clearly did not explain that well enough in the video, hence all the "clickbait" related comments. You see that, right?
@@TwoBitDaVinci All you said in the video is how great the solar tiles are and how great this home & roof design are. Then you blamed all the problems on existing roof designs and never said "the major fail is that these panels are not designed for existing roofs" but rather "existing roofs were poorly designed to accept these panels and going forward roofs need to be designed differently to accommodate these panels" which has the causality of the problem completely backwards.
No it is far from the same thing. You see that your comment got Zero likes and everyone else did. It's quite a strong message. It would be good if you listened and I might not have to unsub again because of it @@TwoBitDaVinci
A little off topic, with spay insulation how is it recycled once the house gets demolished or renovations are done? This would be a good topic to do a video on.
It’s not. If you’re looking for recyclable insulation you’d have to use EPS or other rigid foam. Spray foam has lots of drawbacks.
Tesla already has their own construction crews at Giga Texas. The company should absolutely hire some architects to design modular housing made for solar roofs. If they want more employees in Sparks, Nevada, they need to build housing and offer it as a perk. Just like the Optimus team found they had to design their own actuators, Tesla Solar should have new home designs. Modular self-powered homes are another trillion dollar upcoming market.
Excellent video! Thanks for sharing.
Remember that this pricing is prior to the 30% tax credit which makes it more affordable than a luxury roof of the same size. Also this product will eventually pay itself off and basically turn a profit on energy savings from then on. No other roofing products cover your energy cost, back up your home, or pay themselves off.
How does the solar roof operate with part shade. Are there multiple micro inverters?
Bad title, btw. Should be EPIC SUCCESS
I agree completely about updating the way we build homes, and Lou's desire for independence deeply resonates with me (as do the environmental and cost savings aspects). My solar system is only 7kw, though I've about 38kwh in battery storage. Even charging my EV, I generate slightly more than I consume over the entire year, but I _love_ being energy independent (for the majority of the time anyway). I hired Tesla to do the PV / battery system in my previous home, and they did a great job, but for this home I chose a more DIY approach for various reasons. The inverter I chose is the Sol-Ark 8k specifically for its off-grid and backup generator support, and it rocks.
I had a contract to install back in 2020. The company installed two Tesla roofs and then stopped. The price was high but so was Tesla stock. 2023 I found another, bigger company and was really excited about moving forward. The price - pretty much double. So I’m going with panels and powerwalls.
Gees Rick you couldnt point out that the owner didnt want ro rely on ERCOT becuse Texas isnt part of the US grid they have their own privitized grid to totally not maximize profits.
I think an added advantage of a single slope is that it's easier to run the rainwater into a cistern for water collection.
Great video. Kind of an inaccurate title for the positive review... Ricky makes some very important points: the best roof is one flat plane, angled to the south, with no vents poking through. Stop making home roofs that are shaped like two origami swans mating! The modern style designs look better than the McMansion style that seems to be the only thing big housing developers can do. I would love to see Tesla take there solar products to the next level: a modular roof panel that has everything: structural roof, insulation, glass solar tiles, power wall inside the panel. These should be big panels, maybe four would cover the entire house. A truck shows up with four panels, a crane places them on top of the walls, plug the connectors into the house wiring - done.
Biggest issue with any in roof system is is cooling of the panels. In roof solar panels get crazy hot which can easily drops efficiency 25%. Normal COTS frameless panels mounted with a 15cm ventilation/confection gap will be much more efficient for a fraction of the cost. As long there is no active thermal cooling (integrated water system, etc) these systems are an engineering mistake. Costwise it's also impossible to compete with COTS pannels, price have dropped to 0,10$/wp or less than 25$/m2, i mean that's that's even less than the underlayment/OSB used for the roof. No way one can compete with those numbers. Just as reference i'm diy installing 40kW of frameless solar icm 60kwh of LFP for less than 10K euro, go figure....
PV panels on rail mounts stay cooler on hot days and so produce more electricity. Cooling air beneath the panels is good. 😊
PV panels are cheaper than windows $m² in Australia.
The government loves all the homes that are not using grid electricity.
As the grid generation ages and grid capacity does not have to expand the government is saving $TRILLIONS on the national grid new works.
Rooftop PV panels shade hot roofs. Shade 😎 is good. 😅😊😊😊
The Title was a little "click baitey" but the content very good. Like you, I installed a 12.4 Kw Solar Panel, 2 Powerwall system on my very complex tile roof and I agree all new housing being built should use smart energy design. My Tesla solar panel system has been fantastic and is paying itself off over the 10 year Tesla Purchase ($49K at 1.9% interest rate). I am replacing all of the house appliances and going electric as they age out. Since the house and the dual HVAC are 24 years old we will be doing a Heat Pump based replacement on that which will eliminate all of my need for natural gas. That will be the last piece of my true off grid energy independence. I'm hoping that Tesla builds a residential heat pump system so that all of my energy consuming and generating systems can be controlled by a single application and I believe that good comprehensive data is an important aspect of true energy independence. The Tesla software provides that.
Rather than more powerwalls, my plan is to use our 2 EV's as a storage resource for the overall home energy and so bi-directional charging (vehicle to home) will be a factor in all of my EV purchases in the future. Keep up the good work Ricky ... 👍
Solar seems to be very expensive in the US. In Australia, I put in 13.2kw of solar on our roof which cost about $8,000 (AU), this includes the inverters (2 x 5kw inverters) and installation cost. We have a subsidy scheme, but it's fading away year by year as the rebate scheme decreases. The market is so mature we pretty much don't need it anymore. Without the rebate, I would have paid about an additional $4,500 (AU), being $12,500 (AU) in total; which is about $8,396.25 (US). There is so much competition in the US, I would have expected even better prices.
It’s worth noting the cost of a regular roof in the math bc the Tesla roof saves you the cost of a roof as well! Great vid!
It does get South and West shading from those trees that are fairly close. Depending on the system, a small percentage of shading can greatly reduce the solar collection.
35 years in the Industry…The elimination of all cutting of solar tiles was needed.
Start with ‘’New Construction Only’’
1. Produce about 3 continuous sizes, example: 6’ 10’. 14’.
2. Mandate contractors build houses in sections to those exact sizes.
3. Channel all pipes ect. in attic to 1 or more decorative fireplaces with hinged tops for access.
4. Optional application would be VERTICAL for allowing different lengths & heights of given sections. This mimics standing seam metal roofs.
Any competent roofing crew could prep the roof beforehand hand & finish any roof up to approximately 5,000 in 1 day.
-“Some’’ Existing houses could be converted by construction companies to channel pipes through Attic to false chimneys & re configure roof..
how is this an epic failure? a typical thing of CLICKBAIT...
For the rest it's a nice video, pretty interesting.
Better than most of his other clock bait titles. It’s literally all he and many other creators like him are capable of doing. Literally every single thing ever, is ground breaking or revolutionary or insert another overused phrase
Won't be log till i'm triggered in to a protest unsub then. I'm sure I was subbed here previously, but it's been so long I've forgotten. I can't remember why i unsubbed previously.@@jamesbizs
I find the topics you pick for your show really interesting and relevant. On solar roofs, it seems that house design needs to change. The focus needs to change from curb appeal to practicality. Subdivisions need to be oriented in such a way that the predominant roof needs to face south for use with solar panels or solar roofs. This is a municipal requirement issue. It may take a private developer to jump start this type of development.
Home design is virtually unchanged since colonial times; before plumbing and septic, heating and cooling, let alone electricity and Internet. We can do much better.
I would be very concerned about that foam insulation if it’s the stuff that burns and gives off cyanide gas.
It's not an either/or situation. You can have both, and both are important. It's a matter of problem solving.
I think when they spray foam the attic like that - it is considered part of the conditioned envelope even if not directly conditioned.
It would be interesting to put a heat pump water heater in that attic and see what the ambient temperatures are…
Great intentional design. However, solar will not cover you entire energy usage during winter months unless you 3-5x the system size. Works great on high irradiance days but solar will not be a single source of off-grid power during all months of the year without drastically oversizing your system, defeating the ROI term.
yeah simplicity is needed and the price as much as a small home in some states does not help
I’ll “challenge the argument” that this video title is not representative of the video, but we could have already anticipated that by the clickbait title, “here’s why”.
Good video, it's a shame to see how much more it costs to retro fit an existing roof. You talk about roof does that include Tesla panels too.
In Florida I received a discount on insurance for the opposite type of roof. Lots of hips and valleys. I guess it makes it harder for hurricanes to peel them off.
I’ve been saying this forever, why are we trying to retrofit old homes with solar. This is a product for new homes where the roof is designed for solar. That is how to make solar work. There are just so many inefficiencies in retrofitting and existing home.
I cashed a roofer about my roof about 3 years ago. I have an old home - built 1926. It was $50k for the roof, and a single Powerwall. I did Euroshield instead, even that was $25k.
Apply GMG's Thermal-XR onto the A/C elements and the efficiency would greatly improved.
Yeah, bait and switch title, time to bail. Used to be a good channel.
i though of solar tiles/shingle back in 2008. I could have been a millionaire...
I have often seen overly complicated roof designs on newer builds. Or roofs facing the wrong way. I object to them not only because of the difficulty for solar installs, but any shingle replacement is more expensive with extra labour needed with more potential for failure and water intrusion.
Ironically, houses built prior to the 2000s are often better suited for solar. Our house has a huge south facing area. There is an 8.9 kw system on there now with room for another 6 kw as our electrical needs increase.
It is possible to retrofit an older home for energy efficiency. My rental was made of 2 by 4 construction with cheap r12 insulation. Probably not even that. I first upgraded the siding which gave me another r5. Upgraded the windows at the same time. Whenever I upgrade a room I add a 2 by 2 on the studs making it 2 X 6. I can fill this space with roxul (r22). I then add 1 inch of foam which is also a vapour barrier (r5) and a thermal break. So go from r 8 or 12 to r32. I did this not only to save money, but also to make the house more comfortable. It was hot in the summer, cold in the winter.
The Tesla solar roof quote for my house was $228K for about 13 KW and 3 powerwalls. I think my roof was more complicated than yours! I'm hoping their prices will drop a bit in the future...
From everything I’ve heard the real problem with Tesla roofs were incomplete installations. My sister put up the big bucks for a system on her existing house in the Boston area. They installed the panels and left without finalizing the installation. She was forced to wait several years for them to come back and finish the installation. The installer had gotten paid for the roof. She had to wait for the electric to be finished and without that there is no payback and the low profits on that section left no incentive to the installer to come back. In retrospect I’m sure she would have had the contract written differently, just saying buyer beware and read the fine print.
Hunh. A contractor who leaves enormous gaps in the job timeline while they pursue other work, screwing their existing clients. Never heard of that happening before.
@@eyesuckle right - that is why you can pay the contractor 100% upfront, rather than keep some back until the project completes ;-)
That totally sks ! Who's brilliant idea was it to pay the roofer before installation was complete?
if you pause on 1:00 youll see the drydock concrete wall is just sitting on dirt or whatever it is it should have been all the way down not like that
Our Tesla solar roof was installed October 2021, in SW Washington state. I agree about roof design for solar, but I wouldn't go as extreme as this guy. Personally I hate shed roofs. One thing I did to make more clear space on the south plane was move a vent from the south to the north plane. It isn't hard to do in most cases. But I think houses should be designed with no vents on the south planes, i.e. put the vents on gable ends or the north planes. Tesla actually installed a lot of PV tiles on the north plane as well, fortunately my "new" vent did not interfere with those. In terms of ROI, if I can skip a roof replacement in 21 years (which I think is likely), the extra cost is definitely worth it. Or if I get invited to participate in a VPP (not yet, but very likely), the ROI will be much better. Part of the problem with Tesla solar roof is Tesla seems to lack a clear commitment to making them profitable and successful. Elon doesn't give them much love - but then again he is a wildcard, so that may be a good thing. I do think Tesla solar roofs make sense, but not on complex or shaded roofs. Our setup: 10.6kW + 2 powerwalls, total cost $79k minus 27% tax rebates. 2300 ft^2 house, nothing fancy, built 1990. Produces more than we use, even here in the cloudiest part of the country. Including the $12/month connection fee, our power bill last year was $5.10. We have been extremely happy with the roof and its performance.
that's amazing. Cheers and thanks for sharing. I hope to build my dream home someday with all these advancements to enjoy and hand down to my kids
You can retrofit your current traditional vented attic into a conditioned space by sealing it up with spray foam, I've done it in my current property. When it was built, it had a vented attic and the problem with this design is that not only is it not energy efficient, it was letting bugs in and also causing issues with truss uplifting that resulting in cracking on walls and doors not closing properly during certain season. I had a contractor come in and seal off the attic with spray foam and all those problems go away.
One thing you will want to consider is that you don't have to use spray foam for the entire insulation. It can be a lot cheaper to have them use spray foam to seal up the attic first, then have batts attached behind the foam secured using twine. You will get the same resulting R value for insulation and it'll be a lot cheaper.
IMO, a single plane roof with no protrusion is actual ideal for regular solar panels. The panels can be installed in the exact center of the roof to enhance the aesthetics. The fact that it would be much less expensive just makes it a no-brainer to me.
The price point is 3x what it should be... They said leasing, or paying over time would make these affordable. I have 21+ square & it is more than the value of my home to put this on... Impossible~
Well, if you can and want to remodel your roof to be designed to all face south, like Lou’s house; why not? It might be expensive initially, BUT being energy independent is priceless. Yes, I’m from Texas. Yes, we did go through the snowpocalypse. It was three days with no power. Worst experience of my life. No heat, food went bad, no burst water lines, but it was pretty ugly. How much would a person be willing to to pay to not experience that again? 🤔
Great video. I don't think they're going to give up. They just really need to work on producing these at scale much more affordably. My neighbor just got a tesla solar roof. It looks awesome. Haven't gotten an update from them on how they like it they've only had it for a couple months. But I will definitely be interested in finding out
Elon always thinks in decades, might have a slow ramp up but it would make sense if they partnered up with more and more companies that build houses from scratch.. bound to happen
@@AWESEM0designing a house, with these panels in mind, would sure cut down the costs
I've had a Tesla solar roof since 2019, with panels made in New York and 2 x 3rd gen Powerwalls. We've had no physical problems with the system, only some software issues with the solar inverter that were solved after a firmware update obtained from the inverter manufacturer and installed by a Tesla employee. The only negative aspect I have, upon reflection, is that we get quite a bit less energy from the roof than we thought. It's about 30% less than the estimates Tesla gave us. I guess, if you want to go with a system like this, don't worry about things like roof leaks, that shouldn't happen. But you're going to be disappointed if you expect to get ALL of the kilowatts as stated in your contract, even on a perfectly sunny day at noon on the longest day of the year. The solar we get is still useful, but if we ever end up disconnected from the grid for an extended outage, we will only be able to power our refrigerator and microwave off of the solar, and charge our phones. No computers, TV, washer, dryer, dishwasher, HVAC - they use too much energy.
"Beauty is in the eye of the beholder" but for this beholder, that architecture is far from beautiful.
Your Videos are always great.
The only thing this video made me realize is that on a new home build trying to buy a 25kw solar roof setup would be WAY out of reach. That is insane that his cost that much with that simple a setup.
The Texas grid would be just fine if we disconnect the windmills that do not put out reliable amounts of power and make it a slow process of firing up a natural gas power plant to take the load.
Solar panels should be built at different angles for different latitudes, all flat, with water cooling/hot water heating as one. So, rooves first, then build beneath them. Of course, building the roof would be in a factory, BIG panels, so build delivery trailers that can lean them over to pass low bridges or make the factories movable to build an entire subdivision, pre-insulated at the factory, pre-wired at the factory, pre-piped for hot water at the factory, modular. Making solar shingles is suboptimal.
The urethane foam was not applied in a remotely uniform manner. The brief spray installation demonstration showed no attempt to fill the wall pocket corners first, and left a visible void at the bottom of the wall. . A good operator using application equipment like Grayco brand and 2 pound per cubic foot high lift foam can fill 2x6 wall cavities in 2 pases with a much smoother job.
That’s the attic an unconditioned space
🙄I'm a devoted fan of your channel, Ricky; but I'm rolling my eyes right now! It is possible to have a traditional house with a traditional roof (I'm building a hacienda-style home in Arizona with a red clay tile roof) and put your solar array with perfect orientation, etc. elsewhere on the property! I only have a quarter acre lot and I'm an avid gardener, so preserving sunlight for the garden is important to me and I still managed to figure it out. I flatly refuse to live in an Uber-modern, shed-roof or flat-roof house! Nope, barrel tiles and charming historic details for me and I will STILL be independent of the grid.
Freedom is choice. I'm glad you have the freedom to roll your eyes and enjoy a more rustic character to your hoe, but please don't deny the rest of us the freedom to also choose what we like. Including the channel owner, who puts more time and energy in to making these than you probably realise. This content isn't made just for you. Take your rolly eyes and roll on.
My wife and I are in the process of building a new home. It will be a shed roof and there will be solar exposure. So this Tesla roof may be the ticket. But I wonder about how they handle necessary protrusions like plumbing vents, etc. We also have not been able to get a reply from Tesla regarding doing a project in our area. Union, Washington
Agree please change the Titel
Misleading title.
Ricky, did the quoted cost reflect the 30% IRA deduction?
$120k for a monster sized durable roof + 17kwh solar + 4(!) Tesla PW battery storage is compelling for Premium homes.
Please take a look at GAF and other solar roof products. Still, I would LOVE a Tesla Roof, but my house isn't reasonable for it. We need Retrofit roofs too!
The GAF product isn’t good and I’d recommend against it. They had a big recall or something.
Do your research on GAF before making a huge mistake like many have already…
There's only 2 things holding tesla solar from being huge: 1. The company doesn't have enough installers. 2. The price is about 50% to high; regular solar panels are so much cheaper, so tesla needs to streamline their process to get prices down.
Think of combining a passive solar greenhouse as a basement with a building above it with solar roof tiles. Electricity and heat all year round.
RICKY!!!!!!! Stay away from the click-bait titles!!!! Epic failure? Really? Come on. Every time you do this, respect and trust is lost in you and your videos.
DITTO!
Updated. My point is… it has been a flop so far and there’s a reason why. Hope the video is clear!
@@TwoBitDaVinci - Sorry, Ricky, it is not clear. An what is that reason? Because 99% of roof lines are too challenging for Tesla solar roof panels to be installed thus increasing the cost? (See my post attempting to explain your possible intent. I could still be wrong. An update from you that's more than 10 or so words IMO would be helpful.) None the less, thanks for the video and agree the design and construction of the roof could and should be better going forward, but I fear that won't be enough, soon enough to make a difference. According to the National Association of Realtors (NAR), only 15% of homes bought today in the US are new. In other words, at least 85% of homes probably have undesirable roofs for Tesla solar roof panels, which is not Tesla's fault.
@@TwoBitDaVinci Ricky, the Tesla roof as a product is not a total flop. It’s a good but expensive product for those with the pockets to utilize it as it was designed. The problem with ALL solar power is, homes in the USA were never built with solar in mind. This means many homes are NOT good candidates for solar. For the homes that might be able to utilize solar, angled panels are the only real cost-effective option. Tesla roofs are either for the new construction crowd (such as this property), or for owners who can afford the expense of such a roof and associated equipment/batteries/panels.
My point is, putting “TOTAL Flop” in the title of your video is clear click-bait. I’ve been following your channel for years and for the most part have found them, and most importantly YOU, trustworthy and informative. These titles (yes you have done it several times and I’ve commented each time) waters down a respectable product. PLEASE STOP IT!!!
I'm surprised you didn't talk about how this same technology will be used by the Australian government to stabilized their electric system. Tesla solar and battery are doing massive strides in Australia leaving this out of the conversation suggesting it's a failure just seems in bad faith for clicks.
why not usimg the hot Air for a Heatpump?
So you generate a Airstream that cooling the Roof abd your Heatpump have more Effizienz.