Why Israel Won't Start a War with Iran? - VisualPolitik EN
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ย. 2024
- Join the VisualPolitik community and support us on Patreon: / visualpolitik
331 devices have struck #Israel from #Iran, Iraq, Libya, Syria and Yemen. The attack, dubbed Operation "True Promise" by Iranian forces, was the largest attack on Israel by another sovereign country in the last 50 years. Of course, this leaves us with a few questions: what are the consequences of this attack, what exactly could be Israel's response now, and could it really have been, as suggested in some media, an attack somehow agreed between the Iranian government and the Hebrew government?
#warzone
💥 No worries, the Third World War isn't starting today, nor is a new conflict in the Middle East. Based on the information we have right now, Israel has ultimately chosen a "cosmetic" response to what was also a "cosmetic" attack by Iran against Israel last Saturday, April 13th. It seems that the Israeli retaliation-which some unconfirmed sources say might have involved drones launched from within Iran itself-focused mainly on non-strategic Iranian targets, specifically an air force base in the Isfahan region where outdated F-14 Tomcats are operational.
These targets are relatively close to some of the leading facilities of Iran's nuclear program, which is why the operation is being interpreted as both a warning to Tehran and a way to test Iranian defenses. It's not the first time Israel has carried out low-intensity attack operations in the country of the ayatollahs, and, certainly in this case, if what we know so far holds, the retaliation seems designed to prevent any escalation, allowing both Netanyahu and the Iranian regime to save face domestically.
In any case, beyond the symbolic nature of this action, the Israeli retaliation is mainly being carried out in third countries, as we've warned before on VisualPolitik. But why is Israel being so restrained? We explain the reasons in this video.
"Cosmetic response"? You mean a "show of force"? WTF does Israel get off doing that anyway? Iran's harmless show-of-force was a response to Israel's ATTACK that actually killed people. Israel was NOT entitled to "revenge". Now Iran HAS to respond again and actually do a lot of damage to try to re-balance the scales, but Netanyaju is just a Jewish Austrian Charlie Chaplin and will "retaliate" again. He's not interested in keeping a balance, he's interested in "winning". 😠
But I want the trilogy to conclude.
Totally ignoring the fact that Israel has always been the aggressor in the Mideast. That was long before, in the 1920s. When the British left in 1947. the original well armed anti-Semites killed and drove the surviving indigenous Semitic people, i.e., "Palestinians," out of their homes and villages and off their lands into the Gaza Strip. That holocaust was the 1947 Nakba. Long before these terrorists got the Truman regime to "recognize" that stolen lands as the "state" of "Israel" in 1948 they had been regularly killing and terrorizing both British and the people whose lands they wanted to seize. This evil intent is why David Ben Gurion resigned as prime minster to arrange the assassination of JFK in retaliation to JFKs insistence the Israelis submit to UN inspection of their plutonium producing reactors at Dimona and the resultin 400 nuclear weapons Israel now has to threaten the world.
IDF killed 7 generals in Iranian consulate in Damascus on 1 April 2024. Headline is intentionally misleading. Better: "Iran retaliates w/ ineffective counter-attack".
Iran and the US has already stated they don’t want any further escalation. You also failed to mention that Iran practically warned Israel hours in advance.
They mentioned it. I’m Surprised they mentioned the attack on the embassy. Channel used to be better but this video isn’t as biased as others.
And that makes it ok?
Don't you this is a propoganda YT channel 😂
I think this video did cover that a couple of times
The title should be: Has Israel triggered a war with Iran?
Lol
Why? Iran is pushing Hamas, Hizballah and the Houtis to attack Israel for 6 months. They are training, giving weapons, just like its helping Russia..so tell me how the Islamic republic didn't start this again
The title is misleading because we all know who started it.
Iranian proxies did
@@JiviteshBakshi and you think Israel proxies didn't attack iran befor ? There huge difference between directly attacking another country and using proxies.
@JiviteshBakshi with that logic Russia is allowed to attack any NATO country that supports Ukraine... and just cuz you claim they're proxies doesn't give you a reason to bomb their consulate lol, then act like the victim when there's a response
@@ayouberriouch5973 what israel proxies? Israel had good relations with iran before the current corrupt iranian regime took power, if you're going to use false phrases might aswell do it right.
Religion
Your title is misleading, the question should be will Israel not Iran
Title: will Iran trigger.
Discussion: how should Isra el take advantage and att ack Iran ☠️💀
nah it is the same
Iran need an enemy. Before the islamic revolution they were friends with Israel.
The subtitles for the speech were missing.
At 5:50 right
Nothing too much interesting... just the usual Bibi bullshit of "we have the right to defend ourselves" and "whoever will hurt us will be hurt too"
Losing confidence in this channel's framing and reporting with each passing video
one strike away from blocking it from my feed
Just unsubscribed.
I know, it's like in the last few vids he's gone off the deep end. That absurdity he described for taking out the Iranian nuclear facility is absurd to the nth degree. I guarantee Israel could decimate that facility with a dozen ballistic missiles, maybe fewer. Why he thinks Iran's defensive capability will be any better than that offensive cluster**ck we just witnessed is beyond me. It won't.
Then. Stop watching it and stop winging. The other 1.3 million subscriber will not miss you.
@@Oscarcat2212 ah yes, a mindless follower who doesn't want to challenge anything from a channel they follow
Iran just proved to Israel that they punch back they are no Gaza.
Ironically Gaza has dealt significantly more damage to Israel than Iran 😅 if anything the attack made Israelis alot more calm and confident in our air defenses, people are no longer scared of Iran. אדיוטים שימושיים אתם
The title makes it sound as if Iran woke up one day and chose war…
Iran woke up one day to find it's under Islamist extremists that took over. One of the regime's declared goals ever since was the annihilation of Israel. Ever since it's been funding proxy groups that are at war with Israel. Call that what you wish...
kind of did
@@JiviteshBakshi No it didn't clown 🤡
they 100% did, using all their influence and proxies of terror to control the regions around them aswell as using propaganda tools and information war online to try and change the narrative, they absolutely beg for war everyday and you'd be dumb, blind, or both to not see it.
Yeah kind of did when they funded Hamas.
That video aged well 😂
It has already started
It has already started to deescalation.
😂😂
@@omliem5408 true, they're deescalating now. Back when I commented, I only had the info that they bombed back
He changed the title didn't he
The Iranian regime doesn't need a war, such a war would threaten the power of the regime and could start internal uprisings.
It would also mean they have less to sell to Russia, and would likely have to buy equipment from Russia and NK, a massive turn around in their current balance of payment which itself has been a huge boom given sanctions.
On the other hand, a serious Israeli attack may increase support at home. And given the Russian-Ukraine situation and stability issues in the Caribbean, the US can't afford to get involved at the moment or it has no hope of stopping a Chinese invasion.
I would disagree. When Saddam invaded Iran back in the 80s, the support for Khomani and the "Islamic Revolution" grew among Iranians.
Iran will just use this to prop up their failing theocracy under the pretense of holy war. Worked in the past. Religion is all about power and control.
@@neolithictransitrevolution427 Biden can kiss his re-election chances goodbye if Americans get involved in another conflict.
Or the opposite. In totalitärian regimes a war often increase the support, see Russia.
The title alone tells you which side this channel is biased towards.
The title should have been, will Israel trigger a war with Iran
Maybe but Iran is working pretty hard to start that war to by directing hesbollah to attack when everyone knows they are like a part of iran army practically.
@@ExcessumGaming they are as much a part of the Iranian army as the Ukrainian army is part of the US army.
What does Israel do for America again.... 🤷♂️
@@Greatgastly1
Except that the Ukrainian forces are not proxies of the west. They are the legitimate military forces of a sovereign nation. Which can not be said of Iran's actual proxies.
@@thomasridley8675 they most definitely are proxies of the west. They would’ve lost a long time ago with our support. You can argue the nuances about how they’re different all you want. The danger with Israel’s move here is that it opens the door to other countries blaming the US for its proxies actions and bombing its embassies because we have CIA agents running covert operations out of them.
the title is too biased.. try at least to be more objective.
This guy knows nothing about being objective and political science. He just duplicates western mainstream propaganda
true
Iran has committed numerous acts of war in the past 6 months so it would be Iran triggering the war. If the war starts it is on Tehran.
Like come on dude, we know you guys like picking sides but the title is literally so obvious.
Maybe try to be less obvious next time?
I don't speak Hebrew... Please subtitles on
Perhaps you'd prefer Farsi or Arabic ? You still wouldn't like the news
@@ShalomMFwhat? We want to hear him but we don’t understand cause we speak English. He’s serious we really just want to hear what he’s saying
😂😂😂😂 I see what you did there
They are trying to tell you who this channel is funded by and for.
Shame on you. This is disingenuous and not remotely objective.
@williamsmith5462 Any points you wanted to rebut?
I dont get it, people with big mouths but can't actually argue.
@_artemixx no time stamps most likely a bot
it wasn't Iran who started this thing. your titled is super biased.
This is only true if you completely ignore the Iranian regime’s words and actions. Thus, false.
@@Flunko97Proxy wars occur all over the world. The cold war itself was a massive proxy war
It is not a question of Iran starting a war. It is a question if Israel will start it. The only two countries who don't want to start a war with Iran is USA and Iran.
hahaha. Israel to Iran is like mice to elephant by number of population and size. But never the less Israel isn't scare of Iran , because it is existential treat to Israel.
Israel cannot start war with iran without US, supports.
Will Israels actions trigger war with iran?
kind of did already
Iran choose a full scale war when they pushed for hamas to commit the oct 7th stuff in order to stop peace agreements between saudi arabia and israel, they deserve no sympathy for whats coming for them
If Iran continue to use their pawn proxies in The Mandate of Palestine, Yemen, Somalia, Lebanon. Then yes
Which attack you hypocrites
Who provoked who??
.
Don't you this is a propoganda YT channel 😂
Iran via their proxy on October 7
*Will Israel trigger WW3? Title corrected.
Firstly, send netanyahu to iran. Secondly, leave him there and elect somebody who genuinely acts for the good of all people
They should do a 1 to 1 exchange. Supreme leader for netanyahu
Israel probably should not have struck an Iranian consulate, which is the same as attacking Iran itself, regardless of who or what was happening there. Most diplomatic posts of any country are hotbeds of intelligence operations. This behavior puts every country's diplomatic posts at risks. It was stupid and the well publicized Iranian "retaliation" was entirely expected and should be the end this incident, but knowing the Israeli government's track record, it won't be.
Who attacked the us embassy again and took hostages? Must be a strange unknown land.
Yeah, because netanyahu escaletes so he can be the "savior" afterwards
@@serrael-182 Let's "both sides" the issue, that always makes it better.
@@serrael-182 Happened years ago.
@@serrael-182you mean during the 1979 revolution that happened because US overthrew a democratically elected leader?
Iran has the right to defend itself! 🇵🇸🇮🇷
In what way were the IRGC officers coordinating Hezbollah's attacks on Israel defending Iran?
@@eranir1do you have any idea how many CIA officers the US has stationed in its consulates and embassies doing the exact same thing?
@@eranir1 imagine Iran targeting one of Israeli generals, they would respond too. Or just because they say they were the bad guys makes it okay to kill them?
Iran and its paramilitary branches Hamas and Hezbollah have been attacking Israelis and US embassies for decades - against the Geneva convention but with no consequences and very little reprisals from US or Israel. Iran and Hezbollah were running war strategies from their embassies, something the Geneva convention expressly points out removes diplomatic immunity from that embassy and makes a valid military target
Iran has no rights, specifically not even women rights, go live there so you can't use the internet anymore
Thanks for assuming that we understand Hebrew
I was thinking the same thing 😅😅
Ridiculous title
Roaring 20s, more like "War"ing 20s
Corny
Iran has a rightto defend itself
What are you talking about dude Iran attacked Israeli territory clearly just using buzzwords to show us you're incapable of being constructive
It can try. Well see what happens.
Ok, than Europe also has the right to defend itself from Arabic immigrants.
@@PizeFish dude...isreal attacked its embassy...period...stop beeing a lil baby crying on behalf of isreal diaper force
@@PizeFish you got my comment removed...lol...clearly a mossad asset...isreal should stop makin strikes outside its terretory and it wouldnt have problems
The position of the Visual Politik as a whole about Israel since October 7th is very one-sided, but this video is just ridiculous. Anyone with some critical thinking knows that Iran retaliated an attack without provocation to bring them to a war that would keep the Netanyahu regime going. I have to stop following these channels that I once liked.
This channel has gone down the toilet. Their analysis on Ukraine war has been piss poor
Everyone with critical thinking would know Iran (Islamic republic) supports Houtis hizballah and Hamas:)
This video doesn’t age well haha
Israel has attacked Iran already 😂
I would be tempted to say Israel won't attack, as it has more to lose than to gain.
But then again, that was exactly what I said about Putin and Ukraine some two years ago. Having much to lose didn't stop the Russians.
Ohhh boyyy… wrong video at wrong time 😂😂😂😂😂 Israel just returned in kind … now ball is on Iran side…
So Israel attacks an Iranian Embassy. The Iranians respond and Israel is the victim 🤦🏾♂️🤦🏾♂️🤦🏾♂️
So Iran sends money, weapons and consultants to Hezbollah, which been attacking Israel daily since 7/10, Israel attacks weapons deliveries and military consultants and Iran is the victim?
The eternal victim.
Der Ewige. The Germans helped them to get that status. And then were called 'evil'.
Stop lying! It wasn't an embassy. Just building near embassy filled with troops in foreign country which supposed to make it the safe heaven for the top generals and cannot be considered as a diplomatic facility.
@@lennyshalmer7309you paid to spam the same lie in every comment reply? 😂
There is defacto a war between them. Iran activates Hezbollah, the Hutties and other proxies, they trained Hamas before the attack, and they're building an atomic bomb while saying they'll destroy Israel soon. So yes. Israel is the defending one here and they were right to strike the Iranians in Syria.
No... this attack did not "put fear in the heart of all Israelis"
Some stayed up to see the fireworks but most kept sleeping. This does raise concerns, not fear
the question should be: is Israel provoking a War with Iran?
This video did not age well. Israel Just started a war with three countries in the mideast.
How is this even a question??? Israel is unilaterally escalating with the bombing of the embassy, which is a classic terrorist move.
Iran's response to the embassy attack was small, broadcast ahead of time to allow israel to prepare air defenses, and was less than proportional. Shaheed drones have literally been taken down by small arms fire. This was clearly a face saving measure for a domestic audience.
Stop lying! It wasn't an embassy. Just building near embassy filled with troops in foreign country which supposed to make it the safe heaven for the top generals and cannot be considered as a diplomatic facility.
If Iran’s response was “small”, please name any larger attacks that exceeded over 100 ballistic missiles plus 30 cruise missiles and 80 drones over a time span of 5 hours. For perspective, it was far larger than any other attack in recent memory (30+ years) and far more than the US launched during the first day of the Irak war. If it wasn’t for Israel’s air defenses (which are uniquely capable of destroying ballistic missiles in space before they reenter the atmosphere) and the support of its allies the civilian life loss and infrastructure destruction would have been devastating. It’s widely understood that just the defensive missiles launched to destroy the incoming missiles cost Israel in excess of 1.2 billion. No small number either.
Destroying a building disguised as a consulate building but used as a military command center were senior generals were planning their next attacks to Israel with Iranian proxy’s (most terrorist organizations themselves) is not terrorism. Prove is not a single civilian died in the attack. If this was a diplomatic building as you claim, one has to wonder why no diplomats or civilians were killed or injured when the building was destroyed as a result of the attack.
BTW, Argentina just declared Iran a terrorist state for the bombing Israel’s embassy killing 29 diplomats and civilians in 1992 (after years of delays resulting from payoffs to corrupt local authorities and the assassination of the lead investigator assigned to the case). Never mind the assault of the American Embassy in Teheran and hostage taking of diplomatic personnel in 1979.
This aged like fine milk
Subtitles would be helpful on Netanyahu's speech. 4:35
This aged well
You guys do such a great job
Who is here after todays strike by Israel
you failed as a journalist to give unbiased information, unsubscribed
Good to know the Iranians are the reasonable ones and don't want to start a needless war😅
I believe it is extremely naive to say that the Iranians hoped for no damage in their attack...
It could be considered if the strike was a few missiles, one or two dozens, but more than 300 attacking units, from 5 different regimes, that is not a "let me punch you while you duck, and say we're even" scenario...
Stance on Ukraine and Israel hypocritical?
Israel: winner can take the spoils..
Russia : human rights knock knock
Russia is not the winner Zelensky still in the presidential Palace in Kiev 3 years into “special” operation e
Israel did not take anything, its being constantly attacked. While Russia already took quite a bit and want way past what Iran and Isreal combined was doing so not exactly best comparison.
@@ExcessumGaming I srael wasn't a thing 100 years ago. They colonised.
@@ExcessumGamingIsrael has expansionist policies, why else do you think Palestinians are attacking them? They literally have no way of defending them selves, they aren’t recognised as a country, they had a part of their lands taken from them in the 40’s to create a State of Israel, and they’ve lost land ever since….
@@aashaikh8532 110 years ago there was the Muslim Ottoman Empire. A colonialist entity by definition. There were no Palestinian people. Any Muslim who settled in the Lend of Israel during the occupation of the Ottoman Empire is a Colonialist. His descendants cannot claim being indigenous.
This video aged like fine milk.
Which is actually insulting to milk, since the video is only 1 day old
Thanks for the subtitles
It's cute that you think that Israel couldn't take out that nuclear facility with a dozen or so ballistic missiles. Iran's offensive weapons are absolute trash, their defensive weapons will be, as well. The scenario you laid out for them attacking that plant is BEYOND ludicrous.
Where's the subtitles at 5:50 ?
VisualPolitik: "Conflict between Iran and Israel escalates, Ukraine hardest hit."
Is VisualPolitik EN drunk, stupid or both?
😂😂😂😂
Maybe it is just you?
The Israeli’s would need to use heavy bunker buster bombs to get at Iran’s nuclear programs. This would be at multiple underground sites as well as multiple mountain sites. We are talking heavy, repeated use, bunker busters. Without US B2’s dropping MOAB’s they are down to conventional options.
Dude, I LOVE the music you use in your videos.
Can create some videos like this of the different battles and operations in Iraq?
If you could, I'd love to see a video of Operation Pericles?
If I were Israel, I would finally decide to become human and treat other humans with dignity and respect. Otherwise, the 'Hebrew State' will always be surrounded by enemies until its own inevitable demise.
This aged well + Isreal had no business bombing that embassy
Western propaganda
Yeah because people dont have eyes and ears themselves. If you think this is propaganda you need some mental health, as you have no idea what it means. I recommend living under Russian ocupation or in most muslim countries.
Your comment is Eastern propaganda!
😂
It was basically just upfront agreed military exercise for all parties involved.
5:46 thanks for the translation💀
Can we get an update with the Israel attack on Iran this morning?
12:46 So you’re telling us the best option for Israel is full scale war? Please tell me you’re joking.
Propaganda and biased channel this has become. Reporting false inaccurate news. It use to be a neutral factual channel
Israel attacked Iran today. 😮
Within few hours after your video. Are you the reason for the attack? 😅
By reading the comments about "who started this," it would seem people have little knowledge of the relationship between Israel and Iran before the recent killing of the Iranian general... Try going back a bit further in the timeline.
Netanyahu is the only impediment to peace process.
This bloody conflict didn't start on Oct 7th!
And remember, this has been happening for 75 years, not just since October 7! NAKBA IN 1948 IS THE START OF VIOLENCE & CRUELTY
The Hebrew word hamas in the Old Testament is most frequently translated as. "violence".
So it took 4 other Air Forces to fend this retaliation off and they want to claim it as a victory.
Do a better job for the title next time.!
You forgot B52's from diego garcia after air defences are wiped out
Well this didn't age well
Qrwa, the biggest consequences of the escalation would not be economy, gas prices or travel. What about millions of ppl living in the region, they are sentenced to suffer because some guys in the us want to be richer :(((
What do you mean is there going to be a war in the MidEast, it is just so unprecedented
😂😂
😂😂😂
Over 100 muslim on muslim wars in the last 100 years. "Peace" in islam seems to mean " time to reload".
Yeah typical monday in the middle east.
Peace in islam seems to mean time to reload.
They just responded and attacked back...
Hard not to hate palestine
🇷🇺
This video hasn't aged well...
The title … Gaslighting much ??
that's what I thought aswell
Title with question mark = i will skip your click bait
one thing that usually get ignored is if war happen, oppositions or unrest get momentum & they will get access to arm or use of the opportunity ignited by focused outside and helps foreign armies such as usa or EU members into toppling unpopular & corrupted regime which can't bear the fallen economy then which means it war could end within a week or two because of Iranian's majority support for foreign interventions or help and disarming mentally so-called frontline military in capabilities
There was no subtitles in the Netanyahu's speech ( ?)
They just bombed each other
Dude, they've just attacked Iran, wtf? 😂
The Hebrew state...? Israel has never been called that. 😂 Why is Iran not called the Persian state if the excuse could be language?
The Hebrew state???...where the people speak Jewish???
And arabic, russian, english, french and many other languages.. yes, if you can't figure it out get a dictionary and a map.
‘Jewish’ isnt a language. The language is called Hebrew
Yes, I speak Hebrew... No such language as "Jewish"... also arabs in Israel speak Hebrew. Israel can be called "the jewish state" or "the hebrew state"... same meaning
Hahaha I see what you did there, those other comment just didn’t get it
Yea you’re in a small minority we call wrong side of history by using a title that exonerates Israel
Because they know the Muslims will make sure it’s they last day eating a 🥯 😂
iran is too far from israel to invade the re are two nations in bettween syria and iraq they all syria iraq lenbanon and kuwait all ahvde to unite first before they do that and establish a unified arab currency or oil dollar!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Help regime change.
next Iranian regime by default would have 180 Degrees view on most stuff. Including Israeli Palestine relationship and 2 state solution.
But again good enemy is far more useful than a friend.
Case in point this incident.
It's called Islamic Republic. The people of Iran do not want war, but the islamo fascist Mullah regime does. the Mullahs are not Iran
You guys have such a bias caption. Like Israel started this shit, they always have since they got to that land.
I stand with the Israel's who want to kick out Netanyahu!!! Throw him in jail for war crimes.
Iran doesn't attack but retaliate.
Surely they don't attack they're such a good guys they're just misunderstood
Well israel is retaliating bigger
@@PizeFish lol they ain't good guys Israel aint always aint always good either but Iran's govt is evil
Stop lying! It wasn't an embassy. Just building near embassy filled with troops in foreign country which supposed to make it the safe heaven for the top generals and cannot be considered as a diplomatic facility.
@@lennyshalmer7309not relevant, Israel had no right to bomb there anyway…
You are a good actor. It's very obvious that you don't have a clue about what you are talking about.
You can leave and don't come back
This aged like milk
Where is the translation
Where is Fonseca?
Look at all these hamas supporters in the comment section crying 💀
wow ... this was very biased! Didn't expect that at all here ...
So is it already World War 3 or are we waiting for Taiwan to join the party? Also, how is that USA deescalation going? Any luck?
Didn't the israli occupationle regime first Targeted Iranian embassy is Syria first!?
The diplomatic premises are considered part of the country
But ofcourse what else to expect from Anglo saxons
Iran and its paramilitary branches Hamas and Hezbollah have been attacking Israelis and US embassies for decades - against the Geneva convention but with no consequences. However Iran and Hezbollah were running war strategies from their embassies, something the Geneva convention expressly points out removes diplomatic immunity from that embassy and makes it a valid military target. Iran are hypocritical according to international law
Iran and it’s paramilitary branches Hamas and Hezbollah have been attacking Israelis and US embassies for decades - against the Geneva convention but with no consequences, Iran and Hezbollah were running war strategies from their embassies, something the Geneva convention expressly points out removes diplomatic immunity from that embassy and makes a valid military target
You: 🤡
@@lefton4ya In another countury.