I love how you captured the true nature of Anakin's obsession, which ultimately is what drives him to the dark side and he always has a "hope for the best, expect the worst" mindset", which seems to justify his OCD. A happy ending for Anakin must have been a first for him. It also gives him a debriefing from the manipulation and mental abuse from a narcissistic evil surrogate father in Palpatine. Now, the real question we all want to know...did Palpatine survive? Dun dun duuuuunnn.... Yoda and Mace should be looking for him in the Force. So should Anakin, since he was the closest to him but Mace felt Sidious' signature in the Force first hand.
@@starwarsquill Hi, just an idea: What if Boba Fett stayed with the Clones instead of trying to kill Windu. I know its not totally possible but I find it intressting
I've seen this question/debate over the years, and I have always said this is the moment Stars Wars broke its own lore. By this time in lore via books, comics, films, and TV series 1) Anakin knows about the Sith and how they are and can't be trusted 2) obeys the Jedi Order when it really matters the most, or he is given a direct order 3) is not stupid or naïve enough that he would not challenge or question all past interactions with Palpatine as soon as he knew he was a Sith and was trying to play him...not to mention the Sith Lord they have been looking for. I know we needed the story to happen. Yes, he was concerned for Padme. But nothing about Anakin even suggests that he would not have stayed, or at least not interfered with Mace. More than likely, had he not been able to stay and wait out of nerves in the chambers, he would have gone to Padme since his only 3 trusted people are Palpatine (now can't be trusted and he knows it), Obi-wan who is out doing Jedi stuff, leaving only Padme. This is the moment Star Wars said the plot is more important than the Anakin we have created so far. A more realistic or believable situation that would lead to the same outcome as the film...is if Mace brought Anakin with him to confront Palpatine. That way had Mace determined Palpatine is a Sith and decided he had to die...then Anakin could have been like, "That's not the Jedi way, he needs to be brought in for justice." Then there could have been a fight between Anakin, Palpatine, Mace, and the other grandmasters leading to the same outcome. No only is the more lore friendly, it makes more since for it to happen that way.
What If Obi-Wan saved Anakin on MustaFar before he burned (let's assume Kenobi had cut off both of Vader's arms and not his legs and didn't leave him there to burn and die)
a different youtube channel once called screwattack now called death battle briefly went over the force ability shatterpoint in the luke vs harry potter death battle it lets the user find their opponents weaknesses
If Anakin stayed at the Jedi temple Palpatine wouldn’t have “given up” and may have won the duel with Mace. However, the Jedi at that time would’ve been exactly who they were and kicked him out once they found out about him being married. So this thumbnail would never happen
You gotta remember that free falling from that height would go by really fast. He might also hit his back or head on an object knocking him out or paralyzing him. He was an old man after all
I love how you captured the true nature of Anakin's obsession, which ultimately is what drives him to the dark side and he always has a "hope for the best, expect the worst" mindset", which seems to justify his OCD. A happy ending for Anakin must have been a first for him. It also gives him a debriefing from the manipulation and mental abuse from a narcissistic evil surrogate father in Palpatine.
Now, the real question we all want to know...did Palpatine survive? Dun dun duuuuunnn.... Yoda and Mace should be looking for him in the Force. So should Anakin, since he was the closest to him but Mace felt Sidious' signature in the Force first hand.
I should’ve added a post credit scene where Palpatine survived haha
@@starwarsquill Haha! "The Force is strong with this one." 😂
@@starwarsquill
By essence transfer : Palpatine's idea was to transfer himself to Anakin. If Window was the only option, use him.
The Force to Anakin: I SAID NO!!!!!!
I loved how you utilized windu’s shatterpoint. This is top tier writing for a Star Wars what if.
Good alternative story! May the Force be with you and other Star Wars fans like I used to be during my childhood!
Glad you liked It, Man :)
I liked how fate kept Anakin away from Palpatine by the temple being bombed it did save him.
Or in the Star Wars galaxy, how The Force kept Anakin away from the Senate Building.
Also if anakin had stayed in the council chambers there would be no one to stop mace from killing palpatine meaning order 66 would have never happened
Nice Vid once again
Thanks :)
Can you do part 2 this is good also keep up the good work
Thanks for watching, man :) I’ll do part 2 soon :)
@@starwarsquill Hi, just an idea: What if Boba Fett stayed with the Clones instead of trying to kill Windu. I know its not totally possible but I find it intressting
Great Video!
Thanks :) Means a lot:)
Obi-Wan new about Anakin and padme at the Battle of geonosis
ooooh i got it: what if palpatine was a sith lord, but genuinely did nothing wrong?
I've seen this question/debate over the years, and I have always said this is the moment Stars Wars broke its own lore. By this time in lore via books, comics, films, and TV series 1) Anakin knows about the Sith and how they are and can't be trusted 2) obeys the Jedi Order when it really matters the most, or he is given a direct order 3) is not stupid or naïve enough that he would not challenge or question all past interactions with Palpatine as soon as he knew he was a Sith and was trying to play him...not to mention the Sith Lord they have been looking for. I know we needed the story to happen. Yes, he was concerned for Padme. But nothing about Anakin even suggests that he would not have stayed, or at least not interfered with Mace. More than likely, had he not been able to stay and wait out of nerves in the chambers, he would have gone to Padme since his only 3 trusted people are Palpatine (now can't be trusted and he knows it), Obi-wan who is out doing Jedi stuff, leaving only Padme. This is the moment Star Wars said the plot is more important than the Anakin we have created so far.
A more realistic or believable situation that would lead to the same outcome as the film...is if Mace brought Anakin with him to confront Palpatine. That way had Mace determined Palpatine is a Sith and decided he had to die...then Anakin could have been like, "That's not the Jedi way, he needs to be brought in for justice." Then there could have been a fight between Anakin, Palpatine, Mace, and the other grandmasters leading to the same outcome. No only is the more lore friendly, it makes more since for it to happen that way.
What if Jedi master Anakin skywalker took Ben solo as his Padawan
I hope you do a what if with Anakin's descendants sooner or later especially since you seem to lean to the EU which has grown rare it's sad.
What If Obi-Wan saved Anakin on MustaFar before he burned (let's assume Kenobi had cut off both of Vader's arms and not his legs and didn't leave him there to burn and die)
a different youtube channel once called screwattack now called death battle briefly went over the force ability shatterpoint in the luke vs harry potter death battle it lets the user find their opponents weaknesses
If Anakin stayed at the Jedi temple Palpatine wouldn’t have “given up” and may have won the duel with Mace.
However, the Jedi at that time would’ve been exactly who they were and kicked him out once they found out about him being married. So this thumbnail would never happen
Heresy !!!!!!
Sacrilege !!!!!
There must always be a Darth Vader !!!!
Good story but bounces around to much
fisto only died because he sensed Skywalker coming
He could have been killed by clones if he had stayed… Highly doubtful. But there was a slim chance it could have happened.
I just don't think Palpatine would fall to his death. I think he would stop his fall with the force, or land on a speeder.
Possibly because he didn’t expect it? I don’t know, I think this is fun regardless! :)
You gotta remember that free falling from that height would go by really fast. He might also hit his back or head on an object knocking him out or paralyzing him. He was an old man after all