I think Haewon has the most developed mid range if she drops that cutesy style. I like her full chesty midrange when she belts. Lily remains superior when it comes to 5th octave belt. It comes so easy for her.
Out of these three Lily is the cleanest and most refined, especially when it gets to the 5th octave. She has a more balanced mix while the other two lean into either chestiness or headiness, but she can produce fuller and bolder sounds due to stronger developed and connected cords. Her mid range is indeed light but I'd argue that her voice, even around Bb4/B4 when she really tries, can compete with Haewon's bolder but less settled chesty performances.
honestly if we're being real, most of the time lily doesnt EVEN mix... a lot of her higher notes until the f5 range are usually done in a really nice healthy chest belt...
The fact that Lily never strain all her E5s (+ she once supported it) is amazing She's one of the rare young singer who have some development up to E5 aside Nayul
@@rheynotryan some jealous fan tend to put Nayul in Gen4 to downgrade Lily, don't want to accept Lily is no.1 in her generation. LoL. Nayul is basically gen3 vocalist, not idol. She debuted once and than redebuted in Gen4. A very experienced vocalist, it's an audicity to put her same category with vocalist who 10 years more younger than her. She's even better than Taeyeon in some area.
Ok but the gap between haely isnt big, and I like how they share weaknesses and strengths. Haewon is better in lows and in mid 4th octave than lily, but lily is better than her in handling notes like C5-E5 at best and her headvoice is better than Haewon. I like their dynamic. And Haewon is suddenly now my new favorite Girl alone with Ningning, not only her vocals, but her aura overall caught my attention. Ningning's voice is not on a fully matured yet, but somehow her lows especially for her age is very commendable, her 4th octave is surely underrated for me, i know its not as advance as the other 2 but her belting overall isnt even bad or considered mediocre as she can still project well on A4-B4 and I know im saying this all over again, but I think songs like Black Mamba showcases her potential in producing a bold sound. I little improvement in her mix and hv then shes get to go. Also I like how all of them are 02 liners, well besties. Year end kpop shows is getting near, what if 02liners in kpop collab. 😳
i know haewon's bold chesty approach won't fit in every song but i want her to sing like that all the time lol.... she just sounds so good when she sings like that absolutely my fav vocalist in recent years
ningnings mixing is so amaziing and smooth and nobody is even talking about her..... her low notes are so full too which is usually underdeveloped as most ppl focus on big high notes...
lily is the strongest easily but haewon’s versatile tone is amazing to me how she can give a girly light tone while being able to give a full sound too… they ARE the TOP 2 vocalists in 4th gen
i dont know much about vocal technique, but Ningning vocal is the one i enjoy the most,and her tone is really pleasant to my ears, her voice is so addictive 😌
Lily sounds so good at C5 and above. This video made me realize that her mid range is truly her weakness. I hope she works on this because she has so much potential.
@@muhammaddandi7242 They’re adequate and she has potential to improve it. I think her issue is that she is focused on her 5th octave and therefore hasn’t fully perfected her 4th octave. I think that’s the reason her mid range is not as developed as a lot of other people who have the same range as her. Her lows are also a little underdeveloped. Her upper register is truly where she shines though. She mentioned on a Bubble post that she is trying to improve her weaknesses so that’s a good sign(:
You should include Low and upper registers. Ningning is the best in Low register. Her support is down to Eb3 with consistency at F#3/G3. Also her agility is the best.
Actually she's never supported down to Eb3. The Eb3 you're thinking about, in that one bubble cover, I'm assuming was her lowering her larynx. She caps at F3 for now and starts to show muffled moments around G3 (very typical, even singers like Wendy struggle with this)
I don’t think really think doing upper register is really fair as Lily easily takes the cake as her head voice is noticeable more developed then Haewon and ningning. With current material Haewon can go up to F5 but not consistently and Ningning has a G5 from predebut. Neither the less Lily sounds noticeable more developed in the upper range.
@@hinacharmbraceletera283 I wouldn't give a pass on that tbh, development may have been carried down there but for both Wendy and Ningning, the F3/F#3 area and lower starts to get murky (in the sense that support being present isn't a clear cut case anymore)
Haewon in her latest Vlive singing has supported very clear down to F#3 with quality. It just once time so I wouldn't say that her consistent with it. But her low register maybe on par with Ningning. She even did a low note run with G3-G#3-F#3
Haewon is more of a mid belter. Lily has amazing ease in the fifth octave tho. Ningning is great also, her high notes are really clean because of her tone, a great tone to my ears.
I personally like Ningning vocals, there's something unique in her voice it's not too soft nor deep ♥️ Edit: wow people literally showing their toxicity here 👌 like did I say that Ningning is better or something, it's my personal opinion I just like Ningning vocals idc who is better, like bruh everyone have their own choices 🤦
I dont really now about the vocal range.. but when i hear ningning voice is sound good and not so pressure like lily and haewon.. the more higher ningning voice the most she sounded comfortable she is.. no hate ♥️
they use different vocal approaches. ning mainly uses her hv or mix whereas Haewon's strength is her chest voice which makes it powerful and bold. Theres no pressure, they all have good vocal technique for today's kpop standard.
great video!! nice to see haewon's latest material being used for content, was hoping to see ningning's nice attempt at Eb5 on girls in here though! but still great video nonetheless
There is no better or worse among the three, they are simply fantastic, and what they have in common is that companies haven't managed to get the best out of them vocally until now... Brother these girls are a rare gem in the industry!
Mid Range A4: Haewon >>>>> Lily>=Ning: Bb4: Haewon >>>>> Lily>=Ning B4: Haewon >>>> Lily > Ning, Here there are now a difference between ning and lily in terms of quality. NIng is starting to be really heady. But Hae easily takes A4-B4 Upper Range C5: Lily>= Haewon >>> Ning. C#5 Lily >>> Haewon >>> NIng D5: Lily >>>>> Haewon >>> Ning Eb5: Lily >>>>> Haewon >>> Ning E5: Lily >>>>>>>>> Haewon >=Ning In upper range, In C5 between lily and haewon there is a slight difference at least. But when C#5 above a lot issues occur on both Hae and NIng but the support quality and placement Is still better in Hae than Ning Correct me if Im wrong
What surprised me is that I think Ningning is underrated compared to Haewon and Lily. I think her lower register is the strongest, and and she kind of splits the difference between Haewon and Lily through the mid and upper registers - not quite as strong as Lily on the highs, but better than Haewon, and vice versa for the mids. I think NN is underrated compared to those two because she doesn’t have another vocalist who compliments her in her group. Winter is a good vocalist, don’t get me wrong, but I think Ningning laps her in every category, so she can’t do for Ningning what Haewon and Lily do for each other.
For me N2 and Haewon same level on upper register tbh. Both nasal and st sounds airy. N2 tends to sound heady, Haewon both heady and chesty but more nasal. I always thought N2 edges Haewon in Low but recently Haewon went down to F#3 with clear sp(clearer than N2's) but again her problem is uncontrollable nasality, worse than N2. So I would say right now N2=Haewon equally. Mid belt Haewon even stronger than Lily (she sounds light and bit thin compare to her upper).
@@doankimtuananh9317 they won't be the same level, the Fuller of haewon mid range + closest to produce resonance is her big strength, once haewon produce resonance + consistent she move up being low Above average to proficient, if only ningning can be more Fuller with her mid range and less light mix at least she can be low or mid Above average. And Haewon is considered as mid-high Above average then ningning mid average to Above average that's a gap and noticeable
Middle notes: we are not here, we are hallucination... I think because low notes in K-pop songs is sooo criminally rare :c And then we need other video for #1 Monday #2 Bae and #3 Ningning
Hello, Flora Official! do u know LiSA the japanese singer? is she in Average tier like Winter? i just listened to her songs again and reminded me of Winter.
The fact debuted a rookie girl group where they have 2 vocalists who are close in producing resonance: one can resonate in the 4th octave and the other can resonate the 5th one
All lovely vocalists! As a singer, Haewon is my first pick (Haewon-Sullyoon-NingNing-Lily). As a vocalist, very sure, Lily-Haewoon-NingNing-Sullyoon, while Sullyoon is not listed in this clip.
Me watching this video not knowing what all the letters and numbers mean and then looking at the comments not knowing what all these vocal terms are tryna understand everyone 😂
They all have space for improvement. Out of these 3 girls, Haewon is the closest to resonating and as of now, Lily has wider and supported range. So NO, Ningning is not better than them.
@@yazan1317before nmixx debuted jype only have twice and itzy 😂plus niziu if u count them But no there are better female vocalist from jype before jihyo like sunye and jamie
@@jovenaceron5849 giselle is the weakest if im correct. and im pretty sure karina only better than jiwoo and bae (formerly jinni but shes not in the group anymore).
![[PART 2] K-POP 4TH GENERATION FEMALE VOCALISTS HIGH NOTES - HIGHEST MIXED NOTES 「ÆSPA, NMIXX, IVE…」](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ECA2uEgjdK8/mqdefault.jpg)
![[C.C] NMIXX watching their past video together😂 so cute! #NMIXX](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/deMmgCldUcs/mqdefault.jpg)
![[UNCUT] ย้อนฟัง 2 บิ๊กตำรวจปะทะกัน "บิ๊กโจ๊ก VS รองแต้ม" ฟ้องเรียก 10 ล้าน!! I คนดังนั่งเคลียร์](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vNpTtVjdcBo/mqdefault.jpg)
Mid belt is def Haewon's own range. Her quality and tone shines.
I think Haewon has the most developed mid range if she drops that cutesy style. I like her full chesty midrange when she belts. Lily remains superior when it comes to 5th octave belt. It comes so easy for her.
Out of these three Lily is the cleanest and most refined, especially when it gets to the 5th octave. She has a more balanced mix while the other two lean into either chestiness or headiness, but she can produce fuller and bolder sounds due to stronger developed and connected cords. Her mid range is indeed light but I'd argue that her voice, even around Bb4/B4 when she really tries, can compete with Haewon's bolder but less settled chesty performances.
The way I wish I could have the tone and support that Lily and Wendy have when they sing???
honestly if we're being real, most of the time lily doesnt EVEN mix... a lot of her higher notes until the f5 range are usually done in a really nice healthy chest belt...
lily for ease on 5th octave, hae in 4th, ning for lows and tone
Yep
Personally, Haewon's tone is the best among them
@@zzz7103 people have preference like my fav tone out of three of them is Lily's
who has the best agility?
@@thatoneperson731 haewon
A4-B4 is Heawon note, she has the best sound around this area.
I think her best notes are C5-C#5
Haewon tones do it for me, her voice is just potent, balanced and unique.
I feel like each of them shine bright in their own areas tho, love them all.
The fact that Lily never strain all her E5s (+ she once supported it) is amazing
She's one of the rare young singer who have some development up to E5 aside Nayul
Lilly most probably will develope resonance first in the 4th gen she'll be one in a million with practice in the idol industry .
nayul isnt even that young
nayul isn't even that young she's pushing 30 💀
Yeah but in fact nayul is older than many 3rd gen idols 😭
@@rheynotryan some jealous fan tend to put Nayul in Gen4 to downgrade Lily, don't want to accept Lily is no.1 in her generation. LoL. Nayul is basically gen3 vocalist, not idol. She debuted once and than redebuted in Gen4. A very experienced vocalist, it's an audicity to put her same category with vocalist who 10 years more younger than her. She's even better than Taeyeon in some area.
Ok but the gap between haely isnt big, and I like how they share weaknesses and strengths. Haewon is better in lows and in mid 4th octave than lily, but lily is better than her in handling notes like C5-E5 at best and her headvoice is better than Haewon. I like their dynamic. And Haewon is suddenly now my new favorite Girl alone with Ningning, not only her vocals, but her aura overall caught my attention.
Ningning's voice is not on a fully matured yet, but somehow her lows especially for her age is very commendable, her 4th octave is surely underrated for me, i know its not as advance as the other 2 but her belting overall isnt even bad or considered mediocre as she can still project well on A4-B4 and I know im saying this all over again, but I think songs like Black Mamba showcases her potential in producing a bold sound. I little improvement in her mix and hv then shes get to go.
Also I like how all of them are 02 liners, well besties. Year end kpop shows is getting near, what if 02liners in kpop collab. 😳
Haewon born in 2003. Lily and Ningning born in same month, October.
Nah, Haewon was the youngest in this 3
So basically
Ningning is better in low range
Haewon is better in midrange
While lily is better in 5th octave
please Ningning can do all those😂😂😂 just update, Ning can probably do whistle notes
@@danissegomez7953so can Haewon and Lily
@@danissegomez7953yeah and damage all her vocal cords in the process 😂😂😂😂
@@danissegomez7953they said "better", that wasn't mean ningning cant do whistle or higher notes
i know haewon's bold chesty approach won't fit in every song but i want her to sing like that all the time lol.... she just sounds so good when she sings like that absolutely my fav vocalist in recent years
dude same literally i was abiut to say this
5th octave of Lily never hurt my ears 🥰
Hope to see Haely as a subunit in the future
Ningning for lows, Haewon for mids, Lily for highs.
Stan Nmixx and Aespa for better vocals in life, Pray to godess Lily for blessing of good vocals upon you.
ningnings mixing is so amaziing and smooth and nobody is even talking about her..... her low notes are so full too which is usually underdeveloped as most ppl focus on big high notes...
Ningning=best lows
Haewon=mid range belter
Lily=flies through the 5th octave
Head voice = haely? Or lily?
Head voice only Lily
@@Netaliatwiceonce Yeah, Fuller on support and chest engagement Lily's hv than haewon. But haewon can still constantly support hv
Only Lily. Tbh NN and Haewon's HV are still very iffy.
only lily, she has better support on her hv and she has amazing transitions from chest-head like in tank, but haewon still supports hv yes
lily's c#5 never fails to impress me. that was the closest she's ever been to resonance, right? sounds great.
lily is the strongest easily but haewon’s versatile tone is amazing to me how she can give a girly light tone while being able to give a full sound too… they ARE the TOP 2 vocalists in 4th gen
A4-B4 Haewon>Lily>ningning
C5 > All of them
C#5 Lily≥Haewon>ningning
D5-E5 Lily>Haewon>Ningning
I think the C#5 should be higher. Of Ning
@@zeroc00k14 she’s good but not to the level of haewon and lily
Lows = Ningning
Mixed = Haewon
Upper = Lily
Also loved how you put Ningning's best C#5 and Lily's closest resonance moment
please Ning is excellent in mids and high or upper❤
@@danissegomez7953 yeah but others are better than her
For me ningnig is more pleasant to listen to.
Lily literally is the queen of vocals for 4tg gen alongside with haewon beat vocalist FR
i dont know much about vocal technique, but Ningning vocal is the one i enjoy the most,and her tone is really pleasant to my ears, her voice is so addictive 😌
For me ningning’s voice is the most enjoyable. SM’s style and technique are the best
same i prefer her voice, i love her tone so much.
The difference between just singing loud and actually making a pleasant sound
@@cuttiecrazy11 exactly 😂😂
@@cuttiecrazy11 don't trash on powerful voices thank you🥰
@@martacastillo6272 I didn't trash on powerful voices love. Singers with powerful voices can sound pleasant with the right technique.
Lily sounds so good at C5 and above. This video made me realize that her mid range is truly her weakness. I hope she works on this because she has so much potential.
Not weak. But I agree her singing style right now not highlight her mid range compare to Haewon,Ning2, sounds kind of heavy.
@@doankimtuananh9317 I said weakness, not weak.
@@selmm2023 Her mid range has always been her weakness since Kpop Star, is there a possibility that Lily's vocals aren't adequate for the mid range?
@@muhammaddandi7242 They’re adequate and she has potential to improve it. I think her issue is that she is focused on her 5th octave and therefore hasn’t fully perfected her 4th octave. I think that’s the reason her mid range is not as developed as a lot of other people who have the same range as her. Her lows are also a little underdeveloped. Her upper register is truly where she shines though. She mentioned on a Bubble post that she is trying to improve her weaknesses so that’s a good sign(:
@@selmm2023 ohh good to hear Lily wants to train her weakness 😁
You should include Low and upper registers. Ningning is the best in Low register. Her support is down to Eb3 with consistency at F#3/G3. Also her agility is the best.
Actually she's never supported down to Eb3. The Eb3 you're thinking about, in that one bubble cover, I'm assuming was her lowering her larynx. She caps at F3 for now and starts to show muffled moments around G3 (very typical, even singers like Wendy struggle with this)
I don’t think really think doing upper register is really fair as Lily easily takes the cake as her head voice is noticeable more developed then Haewon and ningning. With current material Haewon can go up to F5 but not consistently and Ningning has a G5 from predebut. Neither the less Lily sounds noticeable more developed in the upper range.
@@zhejiwooinkwangya she has a supported Eb3, its in one of Ally Kelly's video in vocal battle of sm main vocalists
@@hinacharmbraceletera283 I wouldn't give a pass on that tbh, development may have been carried down there but for both Wendy and Ningning, the F3/F#3 area and lower starts to get murky (in the sense that support being present isn't a clear cut case anymore)
Haewon in her latest Vlive singing has supported very clear down to F#3 with quality. It just once time so I wouldn't say that her consistent with it. But her low register maybe on par with Ningning. She even did a low note run with G3-G#3-F#3
In my opinion, Ningning's vocals are not in doubt💞
ningning for me
1: Lily
2: Haewon
3: Ning ning
Haewons Bb4 note gives me life
Haewon is more of a mid belter.
Lily has amazing ease in the fifth octave tho.
Ningning is great also, her high notes are really clean because of her tone, a great tone to my ears.
"Ninging" ~ ✨
I personally like Ningning vocals, there's something unique in her voice it's not too soft nor deep ♥️
Edit: wow people literally showing their toxicity here 👌 like did I say that Ningning is better or something, it's my personal opinion I just like Ningning vocals idc who is better, like bruh everyone have their own choices 🤦
Her voice is more nasal
@@muhammaddandi7242 hater, the nasal is not problem.
@@muhammaddandi7242 and?
@@muhammaddandi7242 she is one of the strongest vocalist of the 4th generation💀
@@muhammaddandi7242 nasal isn’t her main issue. Learn to sing bro.
I dont really now about the vocal range.. but when i hear ningning voice is sound good and not so pressure like lily and haewon.. the more higher ningning voice the most she sounded comfortable she is.. no hate ♥️
Because she uses light approach. And no, what kind of pressure did you mean?
You’re probably deaf Luna Larra
they use different vocal approaches. ning mainly uses her hv or mix whereas Haewon's strength is her chest voice which makes it powerful and bold. Theres no pressure, they all have good vocal technique for today's kpop standard.
Your totally biased
1- Lily(B)
2- Haewon(B-)
3- Ningning(C+)
Haewon all the way 😭 I just like Haewon so much
jesus.. this comment section. it's like people can't let talented vocalists co-exist without comparing or degrading them 24/7.
Idc if ningning's Eb5 in once again is "light" i love it and i listen to the bridge an unhealthy amount of time just for that djskfkkedks
Ningning : Heady
Haewon : Chesty
Lily : Balance
@Fabian S to you
@@Fishy_flops.OBJECTIVELY.
great video!! nice to see haewon's latest material being used for content, was hoping to see ningning's nice attempt at Eb5 on girls in here though! but still great video nonetheless
Missed opportunity to showcase Lily's Time for the moon night Eb5 but this is good video regardless
HAEWON AND LILY 🥰🥰🥰 best vocal 4th gen🥰🥰
i love how all of them are unique
I don't understand much about vocals but when ning ning and winter sing highnotes, I feel like my eardrums are going to explode😅
Haely is way ahead
That song INSAAAaa EEeeE by LILY is pure CHEFS KISSUE 🗿
That's not song mate. It was just Lily's improv and even then it amazed me 🗿
*insahae
NMIXX best of the best ❤gen voice and visual ❤
2:00 omg that was so pretty
There is no better or worse among the three, they are simply fantastic, and what they have in common is that companies haven't managed to get the best out of them vocally until now... Brother these girls are a rare gem in the industry!
They save vocals for 4th gen😁❤
HAPPY BIRTHDAY 🎉NINGNING
Haewon y Lily sus vocales, AMOOO😻😻😻
Mid Range
A4: Haewon >>>>> Lily>=Ning:
Bb4: Haewon >>>>> Lily>=Ning
B4: Haewon >>>> Lily > Ning, Here there are now a difference between ning and lily in terms of quality. NIng is starting to be really heady. But Hae easily takes A4-B4
Upper Range
C5: Lily>= Haewon >>> Ning.
C#5 Lily >>> Haewon >>> NIng
D5: Lily >>>>> Haewon >>> Ning
Eb5: Lily >>>>> Haewon >>> Ning
E5: Lily >>>>>>>>> Haewon >=Ning
In upper range, In C5 between lily and haewon there is a slight difference at least. But when C#5 above a lot issues occur on both Hae and NIng but the support quality and placement Is still better in Hae than Ning
Correct me if Im wrong
Feel like Ningning is better in lower range
@@neon09 Yeah her lower regular is chef kiss
@@neon09 obvs, she has the best lower register in the female 4th gen vocalist category rn
flora you got some insane commentors damn they going crazy under here
must mean the channel been HITTING ☝🏿☝🏿
We love Lily's open A5s and shallow support on F#5s 😍 People really just say absolutely anything on here...
😂
3:17
If ningning will be consistent with this boldness she will defenitly be AA
She will move to Mid/High AA if she consistent with that boldness
isn't ningning already at mid/high C+ which is AA or above average?
@@apworjdjswn7156 C+ is a-AA, B- is AA
@@Dimyixx oh. i see, my bad and thanks for the info.
she is def heady and light wuth her mix, she indeed would need to be more balanced but idk if she will improve under sm in the future
So basically:
Lower Range- Ningning
Mid Range- Haewon
High Range- Lily
What surprised me is that I think Ningning is underrated compared to Haewon and Lily. I think her lower register is the strongest, and and she kind of splits the difference between Haewon and Lily through the mid and upper registers - not quite as strong as Lily on the highs, but better than Haewon, and vice versa for the mids. I think NN is underrated compared to those two because she doesn’t have another vocalist who compliments her in her group. Winter is a good vocalist, don’t get me wrong, but I think Ningning laps her in every category, so she can’t do for Ningning what Haewon and Lily do for each other.
For me N2 and Haewon same level on upper register tbh. Both nasal and st sounds airy. N2 tends to sound heady, Haewon both heady and chesty but more nasal. I always thought N2 edges Haewon in Low but recently Haewon went down to F#3 with clear sp(clearer than N2's) but again her problem is uncontrollable nasality, worse than N2. So I would say right now N2=Haewon equally. Mid belt Haewon even stronger than Lily (she sounds light and bit thin compare to her upper).
EXACTLY
@@doankimtuananh9317 they won't be the same level, the Fuller of haewon mid range + closest to produce resonance is her big strength, once haewon produce resonance + consistent she move up being low Above average to proficient, if only ningning can be more Fuller with her mid range and less light mix at least she can be low or mid Above average. And Haewon is considered as mid-high Above average then ningning mid average to Above average that's a gap and noticeable
They're definitely top 3 off tone and vocal placement imo. They're not too nasal. Let's see as time goes by
i love LILY and HAEWON
FINALLY!
Haely the best 4th gen vocal duo 👏🏼💕✨
Haewon and Lily are the best 4th gen vocalist but HaeLy are the best duo in KPOP for sure.
@@saving_graciela9203haely in gen 4
Nah, EXO's and Super Junior vocal trios are wayyyyy stronger than Haely
@@LaraVergara what?? We said in gen 4.
Why everyone is comparing high?low notes also matter.i love NN lows
Middle notes: we are not here, we are hallucination...
I think because low notes in K-pop songs is sooo criminally rare :c
And then we need other video for #1 Monday #2 Bae and #3 Ningning
Try to watch Lily, Ailee and Yuju this is me. Thank you.
Ning❤
i love ningning
First
Not related, how can I easily understand which note is supported or resonated or strained??
their combined vibratos at 2:47 omg 😭😭
Haewon and lily 💖
Hello, Flora Official! do u know LiSA the japanese singer? is she in Average tier like Winter? i just listened to her songs again and reminded me of Winter.
My haely ❤
3:21 That was a D#5
haewon ❤
Ningning ❤ she’s my fav vocalist here
Lily is good just her voice isn’t my style so she’s 3rd
Haewon is my second fav here
Lily
Haewon
Nirngning
Ning Ning
The fact debuted a rookie girl group where they have 2 vocalists who are close in producing resonance: one can resonate in the 4th octave and the other can resonate the 5th one
Haewon voice is so attractive
omg lily
LILY OUTSANGG
Ningning beat every female vocalist in term of lower notes
Obviously not. Wendy, Ailee, Monday
All lovely vocalists! As a singer, Haewon is my first pick (Haewon-Sullyoon-NingNing-Lily). As a vocalist, very sure, Lily-Haewoon-NingNing-Sullyoon, while Sullyoon is not listed in this clip.
Ningnig is the best
Obviously not, stop be so biased. You should write "I like her voice" or something like this.
Ningninggg kerenn bgt
Me watching this video not knowing what all the letters and numbers mean and then looking at the comments not knowing what all these vocal terms are tryna understand everyone 😂
1:26 what song is this, ningning sounds so good here omg
S.e.s - I'm your girl
@Say Trufsman Once Again (ost by Ningning and Winter)
Omg ningning❤u❤
Ningning better then both of them
She left still there is room for vocal
But they forcing with no room left
They all have space for improvement. Out of these 3 girls, Haewon is the closest to resonating and as of now, Lily has wider and supported range. So NO, Ningning is not better than them.
NingNing is still a lot worse than them lol
Question: who has the best quality in terms of support ?
Mid range: Haewon
5th octave: Lily
Low: Ningning
@@zeroc00k14 this is about mix
@@sanatmanhare5912 she/he/ they is an aespa Stan and tries to push Ninging into every convo. Just ignore that person
Low range: Ning
Mid range: Haewon
high range: Lily
best support: Lily> haewon> Ning
i don't really blame haewon for losing support on that E5, it IS a closed vowel belt
I need to say this
Lily vocal>ning2
Haewon>ning2
Jihyo
Why bring Jihyo? LOL
@@muhammaddandi7242 because winter is 4th gen and still better. But why bring winter? Yeah they can bring anything to compare for examples.
@@muhammaddandi7242same company i guess? Plus she was the best female vocalist in jyp before nmixx debuted i think
@@yazan1317before nmixx debuted jype only have twice and itzy 😂plus niziu if u count them
But no there are better female vocalist from jype before jihyo like sunye and jamie
Haewons lower end seems to be stronger than lily's
Does anyone know the song name of Haewons first Bb4?
It's ITZY's song 'LOCO'
is it me or Haewon is close to achieving RESONANCE
She’s actually pretty close. It’s just one of the things holding her back is her slight nasality.
4:04 what song?
Beyonce - Move Your Body
Lilyyyy
Nmixx’s second strongest vocalist is on par with aespa’s strongest vocalist, that’s mad bruh…
Not even on par a whole tier over aespas strongest vocalist. (No bad intentions intended btw)
However, aespa’s weakest vocalist (Karina) is better than half of Nmixx. Like, these groups are insane, vocally!!
@@jovenaceron5849 She is better than only 2 members🧐
@@jovenaceron5849 giselle is the weakest if im correct. and im pretty sure karina only better than jiwoo and bae (formerly jinni but shes not in the group anymore).
Ning2 range B-/C+
Haewon B/B-
Lily is literally near by B+ which is wendy level
There's been a mistake at 2:14, the one singing the B4's was Lily, not Haewon.
It’s a harmonization between both
@@floraofficial7357 I know. But the notes that Haewon were singing were the low ones.
Lily The Queen 👑
ningning