I remember being a kid, feeling lost and unsure about who I am. This woman, that I‘ve never met, taught me that it‘s okay to be different. She’s one of the reasons I have a fulfilling life today and I hope that one day I can thank her. To this day her music gives me strength and I hope all the kids listening to her today and watching these performances for the first time will feel the same way.
You may be smart talented and different in every way you want but the least you can do is to stay respectful to audience which meand putting on your pants, nobody needs to see your ass...shame
This is exactly right, what a great comment! This is why I fucking love this video, it really gives me the feels for that very reason. Brings a tear to your eye it’s so damn good. It makes me happy that it has 14 MILLION views. Hopefully got some younger people into the original.
I took my son to see the Ga as he called her three times in his very short life I have never seen him so happy when she sang. Dad loves Lady Ga Ga and is grateful for her music from the bottom of his heart. Always
Really! Emotions!! 😂😂😂😂. She got a voice but She needs to stops screaming and doing little voices! And orginal is 10000000 better! Even their clothes are better then was she has on. Jeah i dont like her screaming. Who called herself Gaga that is already very artist kind of name 😂😂😂😂sorry let her stop singing this song because it makes me just want to cry. Let her sing pop bullshit
"Jeah im a Gaga hater." That right there made your whole comment totally useless. Good way of discrediting yourself. Well, "Even their clothes are better then was She has on." is were it already got pointless. Besides your lack of basic grammar skills.
I really dont care what you think or write! And that my grammatica is bad! True but care less! Still you understand what I write. And furthermore it is my opinion and if you are not agree with, that is fine! Have a good day or not
Lukas T and Ps discrediting myself! Please, if you like her so much go ahead but I do not give myself a bad name because I dislike her! Cry me a river!
@@menekseT I would like to disagree as I listened to the original after reading your comment. Gaga puts way more Soul and feeling in to this song. She changes up her range and just gives it her all. I am not a big Lady Gaga fan but I like a few of her songs and she is a good actor; not to mention beautiful when she wants to be (no nose septum and looking more lady like).
Her modulation from a sweet melody to the aggressive growl.. is out of this world... thats called control.. Lady Gaga is Blessed with an Amazing Gift.. May she be the voice of change !!!!
I have been a music fanatic since the age of 5 and I'm now 45. I grew up in the 80s and was blessed with the sounds of Early Metallica, Ozzy, Motorhead, Megadeath and the whole hair metal Era. When my wife dragged me with her to see Lady Gaga perform on her Born This Way tour I was anything but anxious to go. It just didn't appeal to me. Or so I thought... after watching her perform live, I developed a whole new appreciation for her talent. And to this day I still tell people the story of how I reluctantly went to see her concert and how it turned out to be one of the best concerts I had ever attended. Since then, my respect for her, both as an artist and as a person has grown tremendously. The entire Joanne album never gets old for me. Thanks for keeping it real!
At the end she shows a middle finger to the military uniform she took off. She even kicks it. I never realized she criticized militarism and patriarchy in this performance. It is also probably related to the trauma she had from that music producer man who raped her when she was 19. Her pain is real.
actually no....I agree with the mental breakdown part though, only it was me having it listening to this.... 4 non blondes version much MUCH better....seriously
I'll never forget the time I was in rehab & my best friend had to come tell me my boyfriend of 5 years passed away. We were in her car and after she told me, I said "gimme your phone". I turned this on, turned the volume up and SCREAMED it at the top of my lungs with her. Now every time i am going through a challenging time, i do the same thing. It has never failed me.
I love Lady Gaga, she’s amazing. She isn’t fake, rude, mean, nasty. She’s a artist, they are all a little different, that’s what makes her so interesting.
Goddamn I knew she had a strong voice but holy shit! As someone who's more interested in heavy music than pop, she has my respect for this. She's more metal than I thought 😂
The original should blow you away then. Notice how lady gaga barely gets the low notes in the opener out, and how her screams sound a bit tight. The original singer's voice is insane. She controls the volume at all frequencies like an expert in full control.
@@dougclendening5896 nope I see all Linda live performances of this song and I think Gaga win for this Linda wins for her originality because she composed this song but Gaga wins because her tehnique absolutely better than Linda Gaga always challenging herself and brave but Linda just play safe for this song !! Sorry for my bad English
@@robzs8388 well she can sing this song in original keys without sounding bad so... idk your definition of good singer in this range. The Sugarland and Sting who are known to be an icon of this genre of music love her.
@@drcommondrate12 idk what you took from my comment but I think she's fantastic, I just think that when we talk about professional singers, Gaga's vocal range isn't necessarily what's standout about her
How versatile is her voice! I literally fucking can't. Every performance she gives it a 110%. I can never find someone else to compare her with. Truly she's one of a kind and definitely the best voice of my generation.
+Mikkyyo matter of opinion teriyaki. Sounds and looks like Billy Joel in Drag. but i apologize for any offense to the sexual deviants i may have offended. But Mostly to Billy Joel
I love this song so much and seeing this performance is just another reason for me to fall in love with Gaga all over again! This is proof that not only is she a pop star & a jazz singer but at her core Gaga remains a rock and roll bad ass through and through. I mean c'mon, that growling voice is so punk! Her talent is seemingly boundless and limitless and moments like this is when I am the most proud of being a monster because it shows to me that this woman is the real deal! A true artist.
never thought of her as punk until now, because i myself became the antithesis of what punk is about: conformity. Great post, going to reevaluate my own musical belief systems now.
‘Whats up’ by 4 non blondes is my favorite song. This is my first time listening to a cover. Originally didn’t like it with all the added riffs. Second time I listened with my eyes closed. I appreciate how authentic she sang this song. She doesn’t put on a performance. She puts her emotions and soul out for everyone to hear and connect with her. Gaga’s artistry is magnificent. Also, she doesn’t lip sync, ever!
I'm sure it's been said but Lady Gaga is one of THE best entertainers ever! Everything she does is magic and I love her for making me feel like it's ok to be different.
In that years everyone put it aside her because she was no longer 'the goose that lays the golden eggs' of the music industry. On the other hand, being famous / 'the fame' also has consequences on a person's daily life and how others perceive you. The fact that you come to a video from 8 YEARS ago to respond to a comment from 6 months ago means that something is quiteee wrong with you, look at it honey💋@@OnceShy_TwiceBitten
Ive been around live music my entire life, play guitar, drums, my father was in bands my whole life. When a performance can bring a tear to my eye, i know its a good one.
Hey David, if you want to hear a song that will hit your soul, check out Beth Hart and Joe Bonamassa doing I'd rather be blind, live in Amsterdam. Beth is the greatest female vocalist going and she is not very well known. Beth also does her own music and does a pretty good job with Led Zeppelin covers. Check out Black Dog to start.
@@rocknroy58 oh man. Awesome. I think it was Eta James that did Rather Be Blind, I've seen a few covers of it, but never that one. I'll be checking it out for sure! Thank you mysterious internet stranger!
@@davidwagner85 You are correct on Etta James being the original for that song. Like you, I have seen a few renditions of Rather be blind, but Beth's version is my fav by far. . Beth and Joe together are a force for sure. Beth can do ballads, rock, blues, etc. Her Zeppelin covers are also good.. best I have seen.
@@5674inCincy Her talent, Awards, recognition from the greats including Stevie Wonder, Sting, Tony Bennett, Cyndi Lauper, Elton John & countless others prove you wrong. Hell Prince & Bowie even said she’s the next big musician. Sorry, you’re entitled to your opinion but you’re wrong.
Every "time" in history has had a great performer. Right now, it's her time. Everything she does is tremendous. We're lucky to be witnessing it while it happens. Incredible amount of talent.
I’m trying to understand how this goddess could muster the strength, energy, and an inability to have pharynx bleeding in any sort after this performance... SHES A LEGEND!
Listening to her sing with Tony Bennett sold it to me that she is probably the best vocalist to ever be recorded in this genre. No tricks, amazing range, impeccable control but also the balls to not hold back.
One of your favs you most likely only know the radio version so you're comparing a radio version with live version. Example of a dumbass. People hate Gaga bc she wears weird clothes and was compared to Madonna. The lemmings cannot think for themselves so they take on the media narrative. Pathetic
renessa maico and you probably know everything😂😂 Ps hate is a big word, I just dislike her! And Im talking about her voice and singing especially this song!!! And the dumbest thing is comparing her with Madonna! Madonna cannot sing at all! Comment before your comment!! And Madonna sorry has made it with her style and looks! And if lady gaga doing the same I care less. Is about the voice! Screaming and raping this song! Hell
if you not hate her and just dislike her... so well it is your choice... im just reply to the comment above why people hate her... not for the people who just dislike her read my comment before you comment down okey
I remember back in ‘08 when I watched her live aol version of poker face where she kicks her foot up on the piano and I would die laughing because I thought she was crazy...now I realize how genius she is. The world needs this type of creativity
Right?!! Like when she wore the "meat dress"!! I was like, "This Chic is on some hard shit!" But, now, I'm like, "Is there anything this Chic CAN'T DO??!!
You just rock, girl! And here I am about to be 64 years old on July 25th 2019, and I'm going to give myself a birthday bash on TH-cam with Lady Gaga songs! Never too old 4 Gaga! XOXO Stefani!!!
I was never into her music until I heard her interviews on The Howard Stern Show and she played "The Edge of Glory" and then when she was back later "Million Reasons". Awsome.
When this song came out in the 90’s I was like “Who the hell knew about the darkest days in a depression that I thought would never end. October missile crisis, JFK dead , civil rights movement, MLK dead, RFK dead Vietnam war. I never thought I’d make it out alive. Now we are here again and the crying disease is trying to make a comeback. My climb up that hill a little bit slower but that little demon will never get me, I wait her out cause I know the crying disease can’t kill me, it just slows me down a little, but never fear I comeback swinging. Thank you Lady Gaga and 4Non Blondes for reminding this old lady how far she has come.
larissa ide right? This is one of mt favorite songs and she hobeatly makes it her own. I didnr think anything of her before as all I had heard was loker face. I'm a tyally going to check her stuff out because of this. What a voice, such passion. You can tell she lpves tgis somg as much as we do and that speaks volumes about her.
I can only forever thank Linda Perry for this iconic song. Her version lives on in my musical brain. I love her version. I think too many of us are unaware that this IS her song! I also love Pink's version - in fact I would say it equals Linda's version. And I love Lady Gaga's version though both Pink and Linda's is tops for me. (P.S. Not Brian her, but spouse Joan).
I am seriously in love with Lady Gaga! I remember the original version of this song and loved it… but THIS!!!?!? Out of this WORLD fantastic!!!!! (I’m SO glad she’s LGBT 🏳️🌈 too)!! I’m an artist, and highly respect REAL singers… she is beyond words fabulous!! Love you, Lady Gaga! 🏳️🌈👑🏙✌️❤️🐉⭐️🌎
God I love her. It appears that NO song is beyond her amazing ability. She gives it everything she's got and often does it better than the original. She covers the songs she loves and her passion along with her immense talent never cease to take my breath away! It's an emotional experience!
Once upon a time, Gaga wrote a song called 'Fever'. She could sing it, fine, whatever, but she felt like it was suited for someone elses voice. As soon as she became "famous" and Adam Lambert came on the scene, she gave the song to Adam, feeling like it fit his voice better. For those people saying 4 Non Blondes version is better, you have no idea what the intention of the song was. The lyrics clearly say, "I SCREAM FROM THE TOP OF MY LUNGS..." Linda might've wanted it to be belted this way but just didn't have it in her to perform it that way. She praised Gaga for this version, so obviously she liked the intensity and rock-ness Gaga gave it! There is a reason artists do renditions of others' songs, to put their spin on it and deliver it the way *they* interpret it!
You cant fake that emotion. She feels this song deep in her soul She does all of this with crippling fibromyalgia She does all of this with crippling fibromyalgia
You'd be surprised how many 'artists' nowadays cannot sing and perform like this. Yes you can sell multi-platinum albums and have numerous number 1s but only a few really do have this raw talent. Gaga is in the select handful of artists who can actually sing and perform with raw emotion and talent. Ain't no dark horse singer gonna pull something like this off ;)
Dharmabum9287 Actually, only your taste is horrible. I don't even want to know what kind of terrible singers you listen to, if you think Lady Gaga can't sing, while she's one of the greatest vocalists of our generation, If not the best. Clean your ears kid.
That was amazing. As a fan who bought the 4 non blondes cd when it came out, I have to say she put so much into this that it's amazing she didn't collapse at the end under those 120+ degree oven lights. Does anyone know what live video it is where she is on the piano giving an inspirational speech while singing and talking about her mother telling her that she was beautiful and not to give up?
Wang Chung if I'm correct, you're referring to her 2015 women in music billboard performance, it was initially on her vevo although now I think it's on billboards channel, not hard to find.
She is this generations Edith Piaf. I KNOW that is such a hyperbolic cliche thing to say but seriously… no one brings passion or emotion like she does. And I’ve heard her credit Edith for that numerous times. Wether it’s rage, lust, love, pain, fear, sadness… Gaga brings it ALL and leaves nothing behind. One of the absolute greatest. Hands down.
***** she's experimenting, that's what makes a good artist. You can't expect everything to come out gold. I'm loving her collaboration with Tony Bennett, have you heard their songs? It makes me feel so happy :p
What a moving performance. I must say, she did so much to honor the meaning of the song itself than trying sing "perfectly" to please those "American idol judges wannabe". Study the song, it's about sexism; the jacket itself represents "authority" runs by a majority of man.. Etc. she's singing for equality! All those anger rage, can't you guys think why n what is she trying to express? It's just so sad that u haters being so shallow. You really thinks that she can't sing? Type applause acoustic , or even better, tony Benette Gaga, all those live rendition. U think she can't sing "better" in this so-called "horrible" cover? But why she sing it this way? Think about the effort she put in this song, the emotions and scream for equality, so strong, putting herself lower than the song itself. She made me cry, I now really feel the meaning of the song so strongly
exactly! Its so real and raw and captures the essence of rage and injustice that the song is about its really beautiful actually, and Im not even a huge Gaga fan but she nailed a great song
When you see a HUGE crowd of people at a music concert on their feet, not singing along, not talking or doing anything but watching the performer…there is something very special going on. I imagine she gave them something that they won’t ever forget. Can you imagine being able to do that on a level like this?!
I wished she would get in touch with metal or at least rock here and there for sure. It would be perfect for her temper and energy :D She started in a little rocky style actually th-cam.com/video/3b5mgPmw2zw/w-d-xo.html
You have no idea. Ive waited so long for a good album with more rock undertones. When she sings like that it's truly magical. Idk how people can hate it. It sounds so good
Trash Princess Honestly i don't know much abt her as i listened to her 1st witj metallica and this coz it was in suggestion as i was listening the original song.
Definitely I can relate today when I was at the stoplight my eyes watered. The emotion in the words in the song runs really deep. Linda Perry is definitely outstanding vocalist❤
She puts EVERYTHING into EVERY performance she does. She leaves nothing off the stage. Damn. I love her.
Yaggering into a microphone is not entertaining.
@@fabursoul Good point 🤣
And then some!! wait for it... LEGENDARY!
No, she karaokes her way throw a song that she strips to make it her song.
@@JoeMama-gj7id Please learn proper spelling
This song and her anger as she sang it just summarized the year 2020 for me.
Amen!
ok you made me feel the song :D
preach.
But when Linda sings it, she is smiling.and having fun. LADY has to force the song w anger, it just dont work. Pink did it better
@@skinnydog4 She is threatrical like Freddie Mercury hence her name Lady Gaga, she interpreted the song her own way.
I am 52 years old. I've seen and heard many many singer and performer of any style and age of music. Lady Gaga is at the top of my list.
You have TASTE!
Try to listen the version of P!nk😊
My dad just turned 68, and he is in love with her, and has been ever since I forced him to listen to her Tony Bennet colab
God yes WoW
I totally agree
My baby brother passed away. He loved him some Lady Gaga. I have grown to love her music. It helps me to deal with the his loss. Thank you Lady Gaga
I’m sorry for your lose sweetheart 😢
Tight hugs 🫂 He's memory loves in Gaga forever.
Sorry for your loss.
So sorry for your loss! Lady Gaga has a full heart. She would be honored, I’m sure!
sorry friend.. i hope things get better for you
I remember being a kid, feeling lost and unsure about who I am. This woman, that I‘ve never met, taught me that it‘s okay to be different. She’s one of the reasons I have a fulfilling life today and I hope that one day I can thank her. To this day her music gives me strength and I hope all the kids listening to her today and watching these performances for the first time will feel the same way.
This comment!! Ditto. ❤️
I am crying at this comments
Thanks so much dear
Gaga absolutely an Angel ❤️
Wow! What a compliment to an amazing woman.
You are amazing yourself ❤
You may be smart talented and different in every way you want but the least you can do is to stay respectful to audience which meand putting on your pants, nobody needs to see your ass...shame
@George Glass The only pathetic one here is you. Get a job loser
That's not an artist doing a cover, that's a fan singing the song that influenced her in to what she is today.
True!
So fucking well put
This is exactly right, what a great comment! This is why I fucking love this video, it really gives me the feels for that very reason. Brings a tear to your eye it’s so damn good. It makes me happy that it has 14 MILLION views.
Hopefully got some younger people into the original.
She's better than good.
@@neebs929 I thought the brings a tear to the eye comment established that.
Agreed
The way she sang this song describes all my pain, suffering, depression I've felt this past 2020 and 2021. You're truly one of a kind Lady Gaga
Be strong, i hope you will be better soon 🤗 It's been a very hard period for everyone...
@@jean-loupposkin3834 ❤️❤️❤️
Agree!
Fuerza, amigo, todo va a ir mejor. Un fuerte abrazo!
I hope you are feeling better these days...🤗🤗
I'm 85 and still enjoying Lady Gaga!
Надеюсььвы живы
me 73 and yes me too..rock us
I wish you many more years to enjoy Lady Gaga! She is a once in a lifetime
Hope u r still here
and I simply love you
Crazy how her voice can sound like heaven but also sound like hell... I LOVE IT!!! One of the best vocalists of this generation
Hell is right. She sucks.
i know right
@@picklefish74 Lmao but you have no life...
Yeah you right, she killed it. I love the way she sang in the very beginning
look up Pisces by Jinjer
I took my son to see the Ga as he called her three times in his very short life I have never seen him so happy when she sang. Dad loves Lady Ga Ga and is grateful for her music from the bottom of his heart. Always
That's a great experience and moment that cherish the rest of your life. Bless you. Music is healthy and memorable.
@@vernonmeadows9117 thank you I smile every time I hear her ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Aww I'm so sorry about your boy 😪
So happy he got to see Ga!
You cant fake that emotion. She feels this song deep in her soul
Really! Emotions!! 😂😂😂😂. She got a voice but She needs to stops screaming and doing little voices! And orginal is 10000000 better! Even their clothes are better then was she has on. Jeah i dont like her screaming. Who called herself Gaga that is already very artist kind of name 😂😂😂😂sorry let her stop singing this song because it makes me just want to cry. Let her sing pop bullshit
"Jeah im a Gaga hater." That right there made your whole comment totally useless. Good way of discrediting yourself.
Well, "Even their clothes are better then was She has on." is were it already got pointless. Besides your lack of basic grammar skills.
I really dont care what you think or write! And that my grammatica is bad! True but care less! Still you understand what I write. And furthermore it is my opinion and if you are not agree with, that is fine! Have a good day or not
Lukas T and Ps discrediting myself! Please, if you like her so much go ahead but I do not give myself a bad name because I dislike her! Cry me a river!
@@menekseT I would like to disagree as I listened to the original after reading your comment. Gaga puts way more Soul and feeling in to this song. She changes up her range and just gives it her all. I am not a big Lady Gaga fan but I like a few of her songs and she is a good actor; not to mention beautiful when she wants to be (no nose septum and looking more lady like).
Her modulation from a sweet melody to the aggressive growl.. is out of this world... thats called control.. Lady Gaga is Blessed with an Amazing Gift.. May she be the voice of change !!!!
I’m waiting for her metal album
This woman can scream like a beast
Lady Gaga singing metal it's something I never knew I needed and now desire so much
Imagine a Metal Album Lady Gaga ft Miley Cyrus. That’ll be a mindblowing piece of art imo 👍🏼
RIGHT? it would SLAY
@@chicaskas2 i read that "SLAY" in Bebe Rexha
She used to be in a Zeppelin cover band.
My life is about Rock, and I can tell.. This Lady is pure ROCK AND ROLL!!! So powerful, so intense... What a voice, what a attitude. Incredible!!!
Bravo.
+Antonio Felipe Lopez She can probably sing OPERA to! xD
+Tobias Gustafsson lo
The more I learn about Lady Gaga, the more I love her. She’s a brilliant artist and a wonderful human.
Marina Abramovich
Her songs, her shows, her outfits, everything is so artistical
I'm twice her age and she's my hero.
❤
Late. But we love 😅 Welcome,
I have been a music fanatic since the age of 5 and I'm now 45. I grew up in the 80s and was blessed with the sounds of Early Metallica, Ozzy, Motorhead, Megadeath and the whole hair metal Era. When my wife dragged me with her to see Lady Gaga perform on her Born This Way tour I was anything but anxious to go. It just didn't appeal to me. Or so I thought... after watching her perform live, I developed a whole new appreciation for her talent. And to this day I still tell people the story of how I reluctantly went to see her concert and how it turned out to be one of the best concerts I had ever attended. Since then, my respect for her, both as an artist and as a person has grown tremendously. The entire Joanne album never gets old for me. Thanks for keeping it real!
Hello from México ❤
She is so good here. Her passion. It's like watching a mental breakdown, and I mean that in the best way
I get what you mean! The original singer of this song poured her pain into those lyrics. The song needs angst to be sung.
At the end she shows a middle finger to the military uniform she took off. She even kicks it. I never realized she criticized militarism and patriarchy in this performance. It is also probably related to the trauma she had from that music producer man who raped her when she was 19. Her pain is real.
Xavier Yilmaz Yes all these years ive watched this without realizing it
Just like watching Linda Perry then
actually no....I agree with the mental breakdown part though, only it was me having it listening to this.... 4 non blondes version much MUCH better....seriously
This is so stefani, her talent is not only for pop, she is dance,pop,r&b,hip hop, jazz and rock, pretty good Gaga!!! Queen of music
Hey Gabriel Puerto.how are u cutie
Louis Linson Pretty good thanks :)
I super agree on 'Queen of music' i mean, yaaaaaaas!!! Who needs the throne for queen of pop when she's already the Queen of music! :D
Gabriel Puerto do u have twitter or any other apps
Louis Linson instagram.com/gabrielpuerto9606 :)
Seriously her range of vocals and genres is mind blowing and she can do it barely wearing anything. She's freaking amazing.
you say that like more clothes improve the voice lol
Ahahahha
rofl
DeathValleyDebbie
There was a certain note she couldn’t reach... and that bothered me. The highest note
what does that have to do with what you’re wearing
I'll never forget the time I was in rehab & my best friend had to come tell me my boyfriend of 5 years passed away. We were in her car and after she told me, I said "gimme your phone". I turned this on, turned the volume up and SCREAMED it at the top of my lungs with her. Now every time i am going through a challenging time, i do the same thing. It has never failed me.
❤❤
I love Lady Gaga, she’s amazing. She isn’t fake, rude, mean, nasty. She’s a artist, they are all a little different, that’s what makes her so interesting.
True
This is a man pretending to be a man. About as fake as fake can be
@@RegenaHartman How is she a fucking man??
@@dariuskomzak9053 don’t mind them, they clearly haven’t touched grass in a decade
@@RegenaHartman OMG that it's so 2010...
Metal head here, I've never heard her voice live....what a Rockstar she could be. That's a voice with passion and soul. What a voice that is.
She IS a rockstar!
Goddamn I knew she had a strong voice but holy shit! As someone who's more interested in heavy music than pop, she has my respect for this. She's more metal than I thought 😂
When she first started professionally singing she was the singer in a Led Zeppelin cover band called The Stefani Germanotta Band.
She is a rockstar
The original should blow you away then. Notice how lady gaga barely gets the low notes in the opener out, and how her screams sound a bit tight.
The original singer's voice is insane. She controls the volume at all frequencies like an expert in full control.
@@dougclendening5896 nope I see all Linda live performances of this song and I think Gaga win for this
Linda wins for her originality because she composed this song but Gaga wins because her tehnique absolutely better than Linda
Gaga always challenging herself and brave but Linda just play safe for this song !!
Sorry for my bad English
@@dougclendening5896 Yes, 4 non-blondes and Linda Perry. Original is one of my favorite songs.
Thank you, Lady G. For lending your incredible voice to a timeless song.
Her vocal range is INSANE ❤️🥰
Isn't it? This lady has pipes for days!
struggled a bit with the 'I cry' bit but still excellent :)
yo i think she's a genius but her range isn't really her strong suit tbh. Not that it's BAD, just that it's not particularly standout.
@@robzs8388 well she can sing this song in original keys without sounding bad so... idk your definition of good singer in this range. The Sugarland and Sting who are known to be an icon of this genre of music love her.
@@drcommondrate12 idk what you took from my comment but I think she's fantastic, I just think that when we talk about professional singers, Gaga's vocal range isn't necessarily what's standout about her
The audience is pretty chill for someone who's seeing LADY GAGA perform an ICONIC song RIGHTT in front of them!
They are listening in rapt attention, mesmerized by her epic performance.
@@BoomerLoveforGenZ that makes more sense
@@BoomerLoveforGenZ They probably didn't know the song. I would have screamed to death the second the song started.
@@bodomita yessss! I was waiting for the screaming to start when they realised and they never did, what a waste 😭
Acho que não estão entendendo o que está acontecendo!kkkk.
How versatile is her voice! I literally fucking can't. Every performance she gives it a 110%. I can never find someone else to compare her with. Truly she's one of a kind and definitely the best voice of my generation.
Billy Joel in Drag, wake up ass hat
Steve Adams Did Billy Joel in drag sing exactly like Julie Andrews for the Sound of music tribute at the oscars? Don't think so 'asshat'
never mind Steve, the guy has posted that comment many times, the guy has no life.
+Mikkyyo matter of opinion teriyaki. Sounds and looks like Billy Joel in Drag. but i apologize for any offense to the sexual deviants i may have offended. But Mostly to Billy Joel
You will love Sia and Regina Spektor! "Muh ha-ha-ha-ha-heart" LOL
That is Just an INSANE performance out of this world !! Never seen this kind of cover of this song ! THIS IS THE BEST BY FAR ! She is outstanding!!
She is great❤
Go and see Pinks cover.... not even close
I love this song so much and seeing this performance is just another reason for me to fall in love with Gaga all over again! This is proof that not only is she a pop star & a jazz singer but at her core Gaga remains a rock and roll bad ass through and through. I mean c'mon, that growling voice is so punk! Her talent is seemingly boundless and limitless and moments like this is when I am the most proud of being a monster because it shows to me that this woman is the real deal! A true artist.
wow your commen is so deep im agree
I said from the first time I saw and heard her that at her core, Gaga is kickass rock n roll. I can't wait for her first R&R album. Mind blown!
Agree! She's a complete artist, the best!
I find the best words to describe gaga now, she is so iconic!!
never thought of her as punk until now, because i myself became the antithesis of what punk is about: conformity. Great post, going to reevaluate my own musical belief systems now.
This song evokes an emotion that I cannot even describe. Definitely the best performance I’ve ever heard in my life.
I agree... ;) she put her whole dam soul into this shit right here!!
‘Whats up’ by 4 non blondes is my favorite song. This is my first time listening to a cover. Originally didn’t like it with all the added riffs. Second time I listened with my eyes closed. I appreciate how authentic she sang this song. She doesn’t put on a performance. She puts her emotions and soul out for everyone to hear and connect with her. Gaga’s artistry is magnificent. Also, she doesn’t lip sync, ever!
I would recommend Pink's cover of this song live at Wembley stadium. TH-cam it.
❤❤❤❤❤
And Dolly Parton's version
Dolly Parton did it with Linda Perry and it brought me to tears!!
@@mariak.chalmers2577Amen!!!! SOOOOO good it gives you chills!👍
One of if not the best female artist. Unreal
I'm sure it's been said but Lady Gaga is one of THE best entertainers ever! Everything she does is magic and I love her for making me feel like it's ok to be different.
Yes, and one of the historically BEST VOCALISTS.
She's an artist, and she's art herself.
The pain she was enduring during this time - the entire ARTPOP era, for that matter. You can actually hear her rage! She's spectacular.
literally💔
Her rage may b in some things she has learned about this world
What pain was she going through then?
what fucking pain? lmao. Being rich and famous? please.
In that years everyone put it aside her because she was no longer 'the goose that lays the golden eggs' of the music industry. On the other hand, being famous / 'the fame' also has consequences on a person's daily life and how others perceive you.
The fact that you come to a video from 8 YEARS ago to respond to a comment from 6 months ago means that something is quiteee wrong with you, look at it honey💋@@OnceShy_TwiceBitten
Seriously. Why didn’t I know about Lady Gaga live before? Her and a piano is pure gold and this covers rocks. 🤘🎧🔥
She is one of the best performers I've ever seen
lol
missed half of your life
Ive been around live music my entire life, play guitar, drums, my father was in bands my whole life. When a performance can bring a tear to my eye, i know its a good one.
Hey David, if you want to hear a song that will hit your soul, check out Beth Hart and Joe Bonamassa doing I'd rather be blind, live in Amsterdam. Beth is the greatest female vocalist going and she is not very well known. Beth also does her own music and does a pretty good job with Led Zeppelin covers. Check out Black Dog to start.
@@rocknroy58 oh man. Awesome. I think it was Eta James that did Rather Be Blind, I've seen a few covers of it, but never that one. I'll be checking it out for sure!
Thank you mysterious internet stranger!
@@davidwagner85 You are correct on Etta James being the original for that song. Like you, I have seen a few renditions of Rather be blind, but Beth's version is my fav by far. . Beth and Joe together are a force for sure. Beth can do ballads, rock, blues, etc. Her Zeppelin covers are also good.. best I have seen.
@@rocknroy58 most excellent!
This woman is a pop culture, mean that she has a versatile voice for doing a lot of genre and a fantastic singing technique.
This woman is nothing but an act appropriator
Y
@@5674inCincy Her talent, Awards, recognition from the greats including Stevie Wonder, Sting, Tony Bennett, Cyndi Lauper, Elton John & countless others prove you wrong. Hell Prince & Bowie even said she’s the next big musician. Sorry, you’re entitled to your opinion but you’re wrong.
@@5674inCincy you're such a hater
@@5674inCincy yet you are here watching her performances lol
This woman saved my life with her music. I will forever be grateful.
Kandy Krush amen. Same with you
I'm glad you're alive!!
same with me, if it wasn't for her I wouldn't be here today. I love her ❤️
Kandy Krush wow CHRIST JESUS can save your soul HE IS THE ONLY WAY TO BE SAVED THE ONLY WAY TO GOD
If there isn't anything else to live for, you live for music :) Glad she saved you.
I love that she's screaming so much. She's so into the music she sings it's incredible.
I am not even slightly a Lady G (well I wasn’t)fan and I’m speechless. This cover is amazing. The pipes on this beautiful woman!!
What a voice, what an artist, what a woman.
ur profile pic is everything
she didn't kill it..she murdered it.. then aye it and shat it out.. haha
HATER!!!
i love the performance.. not sure if that is a woman though..sometimes her ding a-ling falls out..
nick harris Because it's bigger than any mans that women got big balls all power and strength incredible person great role model and example
Just her "screaming" sounds way better than a lot of singers
So true 😊🎤🎵🎶😘
Well I think she can sing heavy metal 😱
Shes singing the song the way its supposed to be sung. She nailed it!
Haa true I am dead laughing on this
It certainly does. I reckon she could sing any genre. she is so amazing
Every "time" in history has had a great performer. Right now, it's her time. Everything she does is tremendous. We're lucky to be witnessing it while it happens. Incredible amount of talent.
it s not a talent it is a hard work
Crazy. One of the BEST vocal performance I've ever heard.
I’m trying to understand how this goddess could muster the strength, energy, and an inability to have pharynx bleeding in any sort after this performance... SHES A LEGEND!
The passion Gaga puts into this is absolutely amazing! Chills listening to it.
She’s literally insane. I love her so much
Listening to her sing with Tony Bennett sold it to me that she is probably the best vocalist to ever be recorded in this genre. No tricks, amazing range, impeccable control but also the balls to not hold back.
I absolutely love how she actually uses her beautiful voice like an instrument...it blows my mind every single time!
Lady Gaga has such an amazing and powerful voice. Not only that, she can play piano like a goddess. I don't know why she gets so much hate.
Cheo Wesley because She is horrible and fucking screaming. This songs is one of my favorite and She just raped it.
One of your favs you most likely only know the radio version so you're comparing a radio version with live version. Example of a dumbass. People hate Gaga bc she wears weird clothes and was compared to Madonna. The lemmings cannot think for themselves so they take on the media narrative. Pathetic
they hate her because they all know nothing
renessa maico and you probably know everything😂😂 Ps hate is a big word, I just dislike her! And Im talking about her voice and singing especially this song!!! And the dumbest thing is comparing her with Madonna! Madonna cannot sing at all! Comment before your comment!! And Madonna sorry has made it with her style and looks! And if lady gaga doing the same I care less. Is about the voice! Screaming and raping this song! Hell
if you not hate her and just dislike her... so well it is your choice... im just reply to the comment above why people hate her... not for the people who just dislike her read my comment before you comment down okey
to me it dosnt matter if she sounds good or not because she sings it with such emotion it gives me chills
yes she brought alot of energy to the song
She definitely didnt do too bad.. & yes, i totally agree. She brought in more emotion than the
(4 non blondes) lol
chiils to me too, but the execution is definitely excessive
you can tell the adrenaline is high the emotion is in every word
same
Love Lady Gaga. You are the most talented artist I have ever heard. Love you!!!!
I remember back in ‘08 when I watched her live aol version of poker face where she kicks her foot up on the piano and I would die laughing because I thought she was crazy...now I realize how genius she is. The world needs this type of creativity
Kimberly Chancellor bruh I was fucking there for that!!! I was like “this chick is crazy, I love it”
Kimberly Chancellor yesssss
Right?!! Like when she wore the "meat dress"!! I was like, "This Chic is on some hard shit!"
But, now, I'm like, "Is there anything this Chic CAN'T DO??!!
You were dumb
Still the best version of Poker Face!
This woman give me so much emotions, so much chills. You feel that she deeply feels music in her heart. Amazing.
You just rock, girl! And here I am about to be 64 years old on July 25th 2019, and I'm going to give myself a birthday bash on TH-cam with Lady Gaga songs! Never too old 4 Gaga!
XOXO Stefani!!!
Marilyn Hill happy late Birthday to you!
Mine 53rd is in a few months and Gaga is my gift to me!
U 64 years old? Is this tour picture nos?😮😲
I was never into her music until I heard her interviews on The Howard Stern Show and she played "The Edge of Glory" and then when she was back later "Million Reasons". Awsome.
When this song came out in the 90’s I was like “Who the hell knew about the darkest days in a depression that I thought would never end. October missile crisis, JFK dead , civil rights movement, MLK dead, RFK dead Vietnam war. I never thought I’d make it out alive. Now we are here again and the crying disease is trying to make a comeback. My climb up that hill a little bit slower but that little demon will never get me, I wait her out cause I know the crying disease can’t kill me, it just slows me down a little, but never fear I comeback swinging. Thank you Lady Gaga and 4Non Blondes for reminding this old lady how far she has come.
We can hold onto one another as we tread water.
💗
Stay safe Sister. It's going to be a bumpy ride.
this performance gives me a new impression on lady gaga.... she's quite amazing in so many ways
larissa ide Did you see the video of Gaga singing New York New York or singing with Tony Bennett. A must see. She nails it. I was so impressed.
larissa ide right? This is one of mt favorite songs and she hobeatly makes it her own.
I didnr think anything of her before as all I had heard was loker face. I'm a tyally going to check her stuff out because of this.
What a voice, such passion. You can tell she lpves tgis somg as much as we do and that speaks volumes about her.
The smile on her face... her range... the way she just exists... perfection.
Ela é Perfeita em tudo !!! Maravilhosa!
I can only forever thank Linda Perry for this iconic song. Her version lives on in my musical brain. I love her version. I think too many of us are unaware that this IS her song! I also love Pink's version - in fact I would say it equals Linda's version. And I love Lady Gaga's version though both Pink and Linda's is tops for me. (P.S. Not Brian her, but spouse Joan).
I don't like this version at all by Gaga. It makes me gagag
She sang it with Dolly Parton and it's amazing!!! Linda, lol not Gaga
2021 and crying 😭💜 such a gift this woman has.
*sana all !! Right ?*
2020 july , same
@@VeloZelo I-
Fr
I am seriously in love with Lady Gaga! I remember the original version of this song and loved it… but THIS!!!?!?
Out of this WORLD fantastic!!!!!
(I’m SO glad she’s LGBT 🏳️🌈 too)!!
I’m an artist, and highly respect REAL singers… she is beyond words fabulous!! Love you, Lady Gaga!
🏳️🌈👑🏙✌️❤️🐉⭐️🌎
God I love her. It appears that NO song is beyond her amazing ability. She gives it everything she's got and often does it better than the original. She covers the songs she loves and her passion along with her immense talent never cease to take my breath away! It's an emotional experience!
Eu a amo e sua voz é incrível d linda e forte e poderosa !
Better than original 😂 not this one so far away
Once upon a time, Gaga wrote a song called 'Fever'. She could sing it, fine, whatever, but she felt like it was suited for someone elses voice. As soon as she became "famous" and Adam Lambert came on the scene, she gave the song to Adam, feeling like it fit his voice better. For those people saying 4 Non Blondes version is better, you have no idea what the intention of the song was. The lyrics clearly say, "I SCREAM FROM THE TOP OF MY LUNGS..." Linda might've wanted it to be belted this way but just didn't have it in her to perform it that way. She praised Gaga for this version, so obviously she liked the intensity and rock-ness Gaga gave it! There is a reason artists do renditions of others' songs, to put their spin on it and deliver it the way *they* interpret it!
l.p.
I hear you, it's a great version. I simply prefer the way Linda Perry sings it.
OMG! I never saw this. I just listened to the original and now Lady Gaga. She is just a master!!! What a voice!!!
A total vocal masterclass. Maybe the most naturally talented singer of this generation.
Pink and Gaga should collaborate. They've both done excellent covers of this song.
hugh jorgan fame aside. listen to Aleksandra Josic's cover. she'd definitely give them a run for their money. they're all good though.
Lady blabla isn't even in the same league as P¡nk!!
***** Agreed for style Pink does have range and vocal quality on her.... Love the Lady Gaga
Brad Smith It's because one of pink's idols and influences is Linda Perry.
pink is a great artist
You cant fake that emotion. She feels this song deep in her soul
She does all of this with crippling fibromyalgia
She does all of this with crippling fibromyalgia
Gaga has fibromyalgia? Serious?
@Odell..... We heard you the 1st time & agree💥
@@deanchampion6777 it's very common. More than 3 million new cases a year in america alone. It's basically just being human lol
Jim Lahey that doesn’t mean it isn’t debilitatingly painful
@@charlotteoconnell6105 it's not debilitating cuz it's easily treatable and most humans go through it
She's no Linda Perry but she did the song major justice, as you'd expect from an artist as big as Gaga is. She didn't just sing it, she performed it.
You'd be surprised how many 'artists' nowadays cannot sing and perform like this. Yes you can sell multi-platinum albums and have numerous number 1s but only a few really do have this raw talent. Gaga is in the select handful of artists who can actually sing and perform with raw emotion and talent. Ain't no dark horse singer gonna pull something like this off ;)
League of her own!!
Dharmabum9287 Actually, only your taste is horrible. I don't even want to know what kind of terrible singers you listen to, if you think Lady Gaga can't sing, while she's one of the greatest vocalists of our generation, If not the best. Clean your ears kid.
I appreciate that shade. We don't do fakes here. I'd love to see a vocal competition between her and some of today's pop singers
Not many artists can sing and perform like this. Because they choose to actually sing and not scream
Dharmabum9287 She’s doing this on purpose
..."gaga it"...should be the term for an artist who puts their heart & soul into their performance..."gaga it"...
fuck yes
The most emotional performance of this song. It makes me cry.
Love her voice and her energy. Great rendition of this song
Proof that Gaga is undeniably the most versatile and talented performer of this generation.
This comment is SPOT on!
she literally cant do anything wrong.
Alex Eli So true :o
She's the best performer of this generation including Beyonce, Pink , etc etc
She's definitely up there with the best. Most of today's music doesn't impress me, but damn she can sing, she's got it!
That was amazing. As a fan who bought the 4 non blondes cd when it came out, I have to say she put so much into this that it's amazing she didn't collapse at the end under those 120+ degree oven lights. Does anyone know what live video it is where she is on the piano giving an inspirational speech while singing and talking about her mother telling her that she was beautiful and not to give up?
Wang Chung if I'm correct, you're referring to her 2015 women in music billboard performance, it was initially on her vevo although now I think it's on billboards channel, not hard to find.
She is only shouting.
Srta. Muse would love to see you shouting like her ;)
Srta. Muse would love to hear you sing this, fat ass.
Fabio Oliveira It's easy jajajaja 😂
Straight kills this.. the emotion is AMAZING.. live band.. everything about this
it's a crime that she is called "pop star" , she truly is ROCKSTAR 🖤
Okay, the way she sang this sent chills up my spine. That husk in her voice, the passion with which she sang the song - *CHILLS*.
She is this generations Edith Piaf. I KNOW that is such a hyperbolic cliche thing to say but seriously… no one brings passion or emotion like she does. And I’ve heard her credit Edith for that numerous times. Wether it’s rage, lust, love, pain, fear, sadness… Gaga brings it ALL and leaves nothing behind. One of the absolute greatest. Hands down.
I'm here listening to one of the greatest vocalist of all time. We are so blessed to have Lady Gaga.
This song is not for bland voices. She nailed it.
PURE TALLENT ❤❤❤❤
"LADY GAGA CAN'T SING"
Wow, the queen of pop is amazing. Looking forward to Gagas new album!
***** she's experimenting, that's what makes a good artist.
You can't expect everything to come out gold. I'm loving her collaboration with Tony Bennett, have you heard their songs? It makes me feel so happy :p
***** "Artshit" was amazing bitch
***** actually ARTPOP is my favorite album of her ... it's very Catchy and Versatile ... but i personally don't know why some people hate it so much
*****
"already"? Dude it's a year old.
and you don't know how to complete a youtube channel.
What a moving performance. I must say, she did so much to honor the meaning of the song itself than trying sing "perfectly" to please those "American idol judges wannabe". Study the song, it's about sexism; the jacket itself represents "authority" runs by a majority of man.. Etc. she's singing for equality! All those anger rage, can't you guys think why n what is she trying to express? It's just so sad that u haters being so shallow. You really thinks that she can't sing? Type applause acoustic , or even better, tony Benette Gaga, all those live rendition. U think she can't sing "better" in this so-called "horrible" cover? But why she sing it this way? Think about the effort she put in this song, the emotions and scream for equality, so strong, putting herself lower than the song itself. She made me cry, I now really feel the meaning of the song so strongly
You nailed ! People are just shallow and quick to judge before paying attention
exactly! Its so real and raw and captures the essence of rage and injustice that the song is about its really beautiful actually, and Im not even a huge Gaga fan but she nailed a great song
Love or hate her or the choices she makes in the way she sings this song, she has an amazing singing voice.
When you see a HUGE crowd of people at a music concert on their feet, not singing along, not talking or doing anything but watching the performer…there is something very special going on. I imagine she gave them something that they won’t ever forget. Can you imagine being able to do that on a level like this?!
Lady gaga is super duper Cute! :D
PIG is more accurate !
Dogs and pigs are way cuter than humans.
Cuter than Lady Gaga for sure ! Can you IMAGINE living with her and having to look at her EVERY DAY! UGH !
She's a stunning woman. Her talent alone makes her a 10.
Daniel Hollingsworth Yes, actually. I fancy her. ^u^
Good God, that was FAN-TASTIC! I feel sorry for those who don't take the time to appreciate Gaga, no matter what music you're into.
i love this. she sings perfectly.
not even close to Linda.LMAO
Goosebumps! This Lady is unique! ❤
GAGAGAGAGAGAGAGGAGAGAGAGGA
This is such a powerful performance, I can't. She's perfect, I'm crying.
I wish I had the words to describe my communication with this being. it's beyond comprehension. I am one with her whenever I see her perform.
best artist in the history of music!!
Im a metal head and im sure after watching this and he performance with metallica that if she comes into rock....
She will shake everyone.
I wished she would get in touch with metal or at least rock here and there for sure. It would be perfect for her temper and energy :D
She started in a little rocky style actually th-cam.com/video/3b5mgPmw2zw/w-d-xo.html
Piece of cake true man that was rocky performance....
Rock suits her more in my opinion.
You have no idea. Ive waited so long for a good album with more rock undertones. When she sings like that it's truly magical. Idk how people can hate it. It sounds so good
Trash Princess Honestly i don't know much abt her as i listened to her 1st witj metallica and this coz it was in suggestion as i was listening the original song.
abhiraj singh what song did she do with metallica?
This song is nothing short of emotional catharsis!❤❤❤
One of the most talented women to ever hold a mic. INCREDIBLE!
Woman?
YES A FUCKIN GORGEOUS WOMAN
gaga winner of an oscar and one of the best singers in the world, a musical genius
Breathtaking her range gets NUCLEAR
Lord, she is killing me. I almost can't watch cause I'll cry at work.
idk why. the emotion is too strong. i'm crying in my bed now
Definitely feeling you. Whatever it is you are not alone and thanks to Artists like her there is hope.
Definitely I can relate today when I was at the stoplight my eyes watered. The emotion in the words in the song runs really deep. Linda Perry is definitely outstanding vocalist❤
Me too
same
Me too!
All the pain and sadness and madness and frustrations that I felt this 2020 is THIS SONGGGGG!
Same!
BLM
Covid
ALWAYS ALL IN. LEGEND. UNICORN❤👍
She makes people feel the music. Not only listen to it. I love her ❤
Shut up bitch
I didn't feel anything just screaming
i felt something, a headache..