Mark Carney did not talk about several big issues: declines in GDP per capita (in the context of massive immigration), declining industrial productivity (post and pre-pandemic), relatively low research and development spending (compared with other industrialized countries), ballooning federal deficits funded by Bank of Canada money printing- along with massive increases in government debt serving costs. Too many easy questions to a guy who's polling at twice the popularity of Trudeau.
Because some of the things you are making noise about aren't big issues. Case in point Bank of Canada printing money and connecting it to ballooning deficits. One ballooning deficits begin with the previous Conservative government because it was a Liberal government that had balanced budgets. Printing money came into prominence as a result of the credit crisis that came as part the Great Recession in 2008 and again was a consequence not of this Liberal government but the previous Conservative government. While I agree with you that ballooning deficits under the Liberals are a problem, voters chose higher deficits when they brought in Trudeau in 2015. He didn't hide the fact that was going to be policy.
the amount you get back in a rebate doesn't even compare to how much it actually costs. you got $122 back, but I'm confident it costs you more for the price of goods inflated from the carbon tax
No implication, he stated a fact that 70% get more back than they pay in carbon taxes. I get $275 every quarter, way more than I’m taxed. BTW, the carbon tax is a Canadian Alliance concept…thank Preston Manning!
When most Canadians are struggling that their prime minister is so insensitive or indifference is appalling and akin to rubbing salt where they are hurting
Two Canadians out of three are disapproving of the Justin Trudeau government! The two Canadians out of three are saying that the Justin Trudeau government has done a poor or very poor job to help make housing more affordable! The Liberals MPs have a short-sighted vision if they still believe in a Justin Trudeau come back ! One Liberals MP from NL had the courage to raise the issue about the elephant in the room! But he received no support from other MPs! The courageous MP was forced to back down! A true leader is not afraid to answer questions about his leaderships! During a cabinet retreat, all issues, all questions must be debated! The Liberals still have to the time, before the 2025 election, to find a new leader. A true leader, with governance skills, who can rally Canadians toward common shared objectives! This true leader has to be an outsider because there is no leader in the Justin Trudeau cabinet!
If a family pays on average $500 more towards the carbon tax to potentially mitigate our overall impact I can understand if it's done responsibly (which it isn't). What I can not understand is why oligopolies like Rogers & Bell are allowed to do as they please in the telecom space without competition. We have a few phones within my immediate family and a 25% reduction in those service fees would more than cover the carbon tax. Further, a reduction in data rate fees would reduce the need for broadband services in several hard to reach areas. Rocket Science. In Canada cell phones are more important than climate change apparently.
Canada can't absorb and safely accommodate half million newcomers a year. We don't have such a vast housing supply, and never will be. Our immigration system worked perfectly before Trudeau, when quantity of newcomers could safely find a rent within an acceptable price range. And also most of the newcomers were skilled trades or with degree and ability to adapt and find occupation without putting strain on a system and taxpayers.
Carney is not nearly as politically centre needed to be giving financial and fiscal prudence advice about our country. He’s basically spewing all the liberal talking points. He’s Trudeau 2.0.
This guy needs to be in jail. A despicable character. Printed money, promotes the carbon tax, and made millions during Covid printing money while farmers and working class Canadians are being taxed into bankruptcy.
Do you all think the rebate is a cheque you get in the mail? It comes off your income tax payment at the end of the year. Pretty obvious most of you do not do your own taxes.
The heat pump does work, especailly the cold climate heat pump available now. It worked all winter and switched to furnace at -4C. The saving from reduced natural gas use is about the same as the increased cost of electricity.
Moving interest rates up or down, it does NOT really change the basic economy. Creating value of goods and services is what drives the real economy. Not just increasing the money supply by reducing the interest rates.
I don't trust Mark Carney. He speaks the language of Trudeau ( more eloquently perhaps) but the same old same old " nothing to see here, nothing wrong with the unaccountable bloated beaucracy"
Hey, it's called Climte Action Incentive. If you have direct deposit, you might have seen it from that CRA a couple weeks back. If not, definitely check your CRA account. I've been receiving it for years. I think you get it a couple times a year. When you file your taxes too, I check the box for it. Not sure if it's auto evaluated otherwise.
Stop peddling carbon tax, do something for real. Why charge carbon tax and claim we got a larger rebate? It almost sounded like wealth is generated by taxing followed by a rebate larger than the tax.
I got $337.75.... ooohhh!!!! that will change my mind and vote for the Libs in the next elections.... NNAAHH!!! I don't think so. AX THE TAX!!!! and I will be making more then $337.75
Canadians respond to reality..and reality is we living paycheck by paycheck and in lots of cases living in debt..things gone worse since Trudeau took over
And Carney is not nearly as politically centre needed to be giving financial and fiscal prudence advice about our country. He’s basically spewing all the liberal talking points. He’s Trudeau 2.0.
Clearly you are dumb. Everyone gets it. If you do your own taxes you can check a box to get it off your income tax, otherwise it gets direct deposited quarterly. If you don't do your taxes then maybe your accountant checked it for you. Check your Income tax return when you get it.
Canadians understand FACTS all right - start listening to them and become the public servant you are supposed to be!
Mark Carney did not talk about several big issues: declines in GDP per capita (in the context of massive immigration), declining industrial productivity (post and pre-pandemic), relatively low research and development spending (compared with other industrialized countries), ballooning federal deficits funded by Bank of Canada money printing- along with massive increases in government debt serving costs. Too many easy questions to a guy who's polling at twice the popularity of Trudeau.
Because some of the things you are making noise about aren't big issues. Case in point Bank of Canada printing money and connecting it to ballooning deficits. One ballooning deficits begin with the previous Conservative government because it was a Liberal government that had balanced budgets. Printing money came into prominence as a result of the credit crisis that came as part the Great Recession in 2008 and again was a consequence not of this Liberal government but the previous Conservative government. While I agree with you that ballooning deficits under the Liberals are a problem, voters chose higher deficits when they brought in Trudeau in 2015. He didn't hide the fact that was going to be policy.
Firts QE by bank of canada was in 2020.
You are soooo right. These are much more fundamentals issues that Trudeau does not understand ….well how can he….
@@professorakiba434 Are you trying to pin the 2008 recession on conservatives?
Seems like he is staying in JTs back pocket, hence the cryptic answers.
Agree
Well he just said he would like to run for the Liberal leadership so clearly his opinion is biased! 😂
He doesn’t have that dog in him to fight. He’s made more than enough. If he stepped up, he would lose
He actually implied that getting a pittance of a rebate is better than not paying a carbon tax at all!
I have yet to meet anyone who got a carbon tax rebate. It's all a con
I got a rebate of $122 a week back. Keeping it in a separate account.
@@MollyMarineI’ve got mine alright
the amount you get back in a rebate doesn't even compare to how much it actually costs. you got $122 back, but I'm confident it costs you more for the price of goods inflated from the carbon tax
No implication, he stated a fact that 70% get more back than they pay in carbon taxes. I get $275 every quarter, way more than I’m taxed. BTW, the carbon tax is a Canadian Alliance concept…thank Preston Manning!
When most Canadians are struggling that their prime minister is so insensitive or indifference is appalling and akin to rubbing salt where they are hurting
Liberals and ndp gotta go now
One party system 👍👍
PBO report clearly states 8 of 10 Canadians are worse off with the carbon tax. And will be way worse off when they increase April 01,24
Facts are nonsense to liberals.
And that's because the PBO correctly address the issue that Canadians pay Carbon Tax directly and indirectly.
Carney's had his day in the sun. Time to move on imo. Vassy so tickled to have his majesty grace the studio.
Sure came across that way, not impressed!
Yes embarrassing as so sycophantic.
Goo goo eyes used only for Liberal. men .Pathetic.
Canada needs to audit and interrogate him and his colluders.
canadians need to have the patience to listen to his policies and not expect Trump like slogans
He doesn't have a clue how much carbon tax costs throughout the system
Was I ever wrong about Mark Carney! He is just regurgitating the same rhetorics as Justin Trudeau!
What a joke!!
i dont get the rebate... ive never gotten anything, except having to pay more for everything
I've never met anyone who got a rebate. It's a con
Once I can afford to rent a half decent place , I ll start worrying about the environment.
Carney wants to address the housing problem
Two Canadians out of three are disapproving of the Justin Trudeau government!
The two Canadians out of three are saying that the Justin Trudeau government has done a poor or very poor job to help make housing more affordable!
The Liberals MPs have a short-sighted vision if they still believe in a Justin Trudeau come back !
One Liberals MP from NL had the courage to raise the issue about the elephant in the room!
But he received no support from other MPs! The courageous MP was forced to back down!
A true leader is not afraid to answer questions about his leaderships!
During a cabinet retreat, all issues, all questions must be debated!
The Liberals still have to the time, before the 2025 election, to find a new leader.
A true leader, with governance skills, who can rally Canadians toward common shared objectives!
This true leader has to be an outsider because there is no leader in the Justin Trudeau cabinet!
Very true. Failure on many fronts.
Marc Carney would be the best true leader to replace Justin Trudeau !
@@lambertois11he’d still lose to Pierre
@@arkcon714
Take a step back and look at all the faux pas Poilievre has done in the past months!
There are still many months to go !
How in the world would Mark Carney get any carbon tax rebate , his wage is way to high to get anything carbon tax rebate
My thoughts too. If he is receiving a rebate, there is a problem with this program!
I didn’t get rebate cheque and he did get , interesting
Very interesting. I'm yet to get one neither. There's no way this guy makes less than I do.
They said there wouldn’t be any consequences to lockdowns and massive spending. They said we had to do it, remember? I do.
If a family pays on average $500 more towards the carbon tax to potentially mitigate our overall impact I can understand if it's done responsibly (which it isn't). What I can not understand is why oligopolies like Rogers & Bell are allowed to do as they please in the telecom space without competition. We have a few phones within my immediate family and a 25% reduction in those service fees would more than cover the carbon tax. Further, a reduction in data rate fees would reduce the need for broadband services in several hard to reach areas. Rocket Science. In Canada cell phones are more important than climate change apparently.
Wasn't that another broken promise of Trudeau lowering our costs for internet and phone services
How were Bell and Telus allowed to merge.
He got a rebate cheque?
Canadians know that the rebates don’t include all the money that it costs them on the goods and services that are hidden that others pass onto them
Canada can't absorb and safely accommodate half million newcomers a year. We don't have such a vast housing supply, and never will be. Our immigration system worked perfectly before Trudeau, when quantity of newcomers could safely find a rent within an acceptable price range. And also most of the newcomers were skilled trades or with degree and ability to adapt and find occupation without putting strain on a system and taxpayers.
carney agrees with you
What a schill!
Carney move on
Out of touch with on the ground issues
We won’t vote Trudeau no matter what
Funny she never asked about how his trip to Davos was.😮
Nice to hear him speak on the lack of competition in industries such as telecoms. Canadians pay a huge price by allowing these oligopolies.
Reduce carbon taxes where there would be no need for rebate!
Pierre Poilievre definitely has my vote, i love common sense. I love Canada 🇨🇦
You have a crush on him, don't you. Admit it, Donna. You think he's a pretty boy, don't you.
Justin Trudeau loves Canada no doubt about it, he just hates the Canadian population.
a populist? .. Albertas mini Trump
The rebate is a farce - I can't recall getting a rebate ever. An I don't make a lot of money, below 80k per year.
We really need Pierre in power asap, to save Canada and have our Freedoms back.❤❤❤
Pierre has to promise Canadians that he will make the criminal Liberal/NDP Politicians face justice and long prison terms
Conservatives have been known to do a poor job too, just go back before Trudeau. That's why governments change from one party to the next.
Agree
1:08 so yes means no?
Immigration at 3:00
Hey Mark
They All need housing, it’s ridiculous to focus on students
Not even a mention in passing on the important role the Oil & Gas sector could play in our economic future! This is confirmation of his position!
The longest lieberal commercial I’ve seen.
Vassy in her glory!
Mark Carney had my respect UNTIL he suported trudeau.
A smarter more dangerous Trudeau 😬
Carney is not nearly as politically centre needed to be giving financial and fiscal prudence advice about our country. He’s basically spewing all the liberal talking points. He’s Trudeau 2.0.
He doesn’t give direct answers to questions.
I don't make anywhere near a fraction of what Carbon Tax Carney makes and I don't get the rebate. How the heck does he qualify for it??
This guy needs to be in jail. A despicable character. Printed money, promotes the carbon tax, and made millions during Covid printing money while farmers and working class Canadians are being taxed into bankruptcy.
What about government spending?
Can't believe anything.
The economy is struggling because of the government not because of the pandemic. Other G7 countries are doing much better despite the pandemic.
Do you all think the rebate is a cheque you get in the mail? It comes off your income tax payment at the end of the year. Pretty obvious most of you do not do your own taxes.
Introducing the new leader of the LPC. Warm intro from Vassey back into Canadian living rooms.
i never got a rebate, and i'm broke as f**k!
The heat pump does work, especailly the cold climate heat pump available now. It worked all winter and switched to furnace at -4C. The saving from reduced natural gas use is about the same as the increased cost of electricity.
LOL
Michael Ignatieff 2.0
How does millionaire get carbon rebate ?
Wake up 🇨🇦🤬
Carney got a rebate? I didn’t get a rebate living in BC
this girl is a govenment emp[oyee !
Moving interest rates up or down, it does NOT really change the basic economy.
Creating value of goods and services is what drives the real economy.
Not just increasing the money supply by reducing the interest rates.
I found my new bedtime story. Completely uninspiring…..and now so sleepy…..can’t stay awake…..yawn
We need Pierre asap!!
Move on Mark Carney, don’t bother, go please!!!
I would like to see this guy as PM.
Axe the carbon tax NOW!!
He is just older Trudeau. Liberals are just hopeless.
Where we’ve gone off course is putting idiots at the helm. What’s in it for you Mark?
I don't trust Mark Carney. He speaks the language of Trudeau ( more eloquently perhaps) but the same old same old " nothing to see here, nothing wrong with the unaccountable bloated beaucracy"
What rebate. I haven’t got no rebate
Hey, it's called Climte Action Incentive. If you have direct deposit, you might have seen it from that CRA a couple weeks back. If not, definitely check your CRA account. I've been receiving it for years. I think you get it a couple times a year. When you file your taxes too, I check the box for it. Not sure if it's auto evaluated otherwise.
This guy sounds dangerous.
Stop peddling carbon tax, do something for real. Why charge carbon tax and claim we got a larger rebate? It almost sounded like wealth is generated by taxing followed by a rebate larger than the tax.
He looks like my undertaker.
No way I could ever vote for someone who says he supports Trudeau.
I got $337.75.... ooohhh!!!! that will change my mind and vote for the Libs in the next elections.... NNAAHH!!! I don't think so. AX THE TAX!!!! and I will be making more then $337.75
Carney is much better than the Poilievre ! Canada is not for sale ♥️🇨🇦🇪🇺🇬🇧💪
Never voting for u bud
the fact is the liberals are done !
Mark what is your net worth and was that not built from illegal activities. At the expense of Canadians taxpayers
AXE THE TAX
Will housing and then inflation take off again like a rocket?
In a word, yes.
Surprise Mark Carney crawling out of the woodwork, just waiting in the wings for Trudeau to resign or get kick out.
Ouch, more of the same Liberal crap with Carney, Canada beware!
How does imposing taxes and increasing the amount of those taxes make things more affordable in Canada?
He wants to build oil pipelines in South America
This guys carbon footprint per day is probably bigger than a family for a year
This guy is far more dangerous than Trudeau
Canadians respond to reality..and reality is we living paycheck by paycheck and in lots of cases living in debt..things gone worse since Trudeau took over
Big Davos buddy
True
He was the key reason why Canada was ok in 2008
Yeah but now he's greedy for power
And Carney is not nearly as politically centre needed to be giving financial and fiscal prudence advice about our country. He’s basically spewing all the liberal talking points. He’s Trudeau 2.0.
That was Harper..he has a Masters Degree in Economics. Carney destroyed the economy in the UK too....and is closely associated with the W EF!
How can anyone support Liberal ?
how can anyone like PP ? sloganeer . over simplifying
@@lelahferguson9221 Get serious
You are failing Canadians period! You should be fired!
He sounds like another Liberal
elitist
Mark Carney, Captain Carbon Credit, just as bad as Trudeau.
Bank does not care lol. They want all mortgages to renew before they drop the rate. They must be rolling in the money! Lol
What kind of crap is being spoken everybody gets the rebate , most do not get any rebate
Clearly you are dumb. Everyone gets it. If you do your own taxes you can check a box to get it off your income tax, otherwise it gets direct deposited quarterly. If you don't do your taxes then maybe your accountant checked it for you. Check your Income tax return when you get it.
The Carney is coming, the Carney is coming. 🤡🤡🤡
-----Mark Carney--- For PM 0:11 0:11 0:12 0:12 2025 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊 PM
Three is no way I got back as much as I paid and especially when you consider higher prices of everything and additional GST on the carbon tx
That was quite the “thirsty” intro Vassy gave Marc Carney. ❤❤
Who are you kidding liberals told you to say what your talking about
if you listen to him you will understand he has better policies than JT
I agree what a joke !!!
Oola la. Is Mr Carney making his presence in time for Liberal leadership considerations. This is something we need to think about
Used to think this guy was intelligent. I no longer am a supporter.
With all due respect....there is zero integration
Pierre is the best
I don't receive anything I file everyear
I didn’t either!
Carney would be a superior option to Trudeau, though I’d prefer a different government altogether.
Same cloth as Trudeau.
Another Progressive.
Close your eyes and listen to Trudeau.
Lookin like she would give him a hug.
No bias here, folks.