Nostalgia Critic Doesn't Understand Osmosis Jones or Inside Out
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 มิ.ย. 2022
- Do you ever look at someone and wonder... "What's going on inside their head?" Because I'd sure like to know what was going through Doug's mind when he made this review. Time to utilize Thrax's modus operandi and turn up the heat in here to give Doug's Osmosis Jones review a thorough charbroiling.
I do apologize for any wonky editing toward the end, when several assets are added or sequenced in Vegas my computer chugs to a crawl and the lag prevents me from seeing how well the editing plays out.
YourMovieSucks' Kimba video: • YMS: Kimba the White Lion
Hannibal Buress' interview with Chris Rock: • Video
RebelTaxi's Osmosis Jones review: • OSMOSIS JONES Review [...
Follow me on DeviantART for updates: www.deviantart.com/latigressa...
Join the Discord server: / discord
Wanna donate to my Ko-Fi? Click here: ko-fi.com/F2F6K5WA
TH-cam, this is a video that falls under fair use in line with the criteria laid out for commentary/criticism and any material in here is not a substitute for the content being discussed.
This video is also suited for ages 13 AND UP as it talks about material that may be aimed at children but in a manner that older and more cognoscente audiences may find useful/informative. That said, leave this video alone.
#OsmosisJones #ChangetheChannel - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
As of April 19, 2024, im pinning this comment because FOR THE LOVE OF SWISS CHEESE AND ALL THAT IS HOL(E)Y, SHUT UP ABOUT ZAID MAGENTA. I AM VERY MUCH AWARE OF WHAT HE DID, HE NEEDS TO STAY OFF SOCIAL MEDIA AND ACTUALLY LIVE HIS LIFE AND GET SOME HELP. I'M AT THE POINT WHERE I WILL STRAIGHT UP START DELETING COMMENTS OF "THAT DIDN'T AGE WELL". STOP TELLING ME, I KNOW.
That was my birthday!
imagine deleting comments oof
@@Alizamk1 It's only because I'm getting sick of "Uh, that didn't age well" ones. I'm aware of what happened, Zaid needs to stay off the Internet (or at least social media), with one exception in the skillet I'm not going to mention him anymore, and I can only say it so much before needing to yank the broken record off the turntable and yeet it at someone. And I do not want to sink to ripping the broken record off the turntable and yeeting it at someone.
@@MagmaPaint Stick with Cinematic Excrement, and ElectricDragon505.
was zaid brought up directly in vid ive skimmed it didnt notice any moment
Osmosis Jones: *talks about physical health*
Inside Out: *talks about mental health*
Doug Walker: *has a brain of a peanut*
Don’t you mean “tangerine” 😉?
Zaid the reason why he was so mad with nostalgia critic in the sailor moon review because Zaid helped a teenage girl who was groomed and bad touched by her mothers ex boyfriend
What brain? He barely has a brain half of his reviews.
In his review of tmnt 2007 movie, he made fun of splinter voice actor because his voice was rough. (Witch was the voice of aku and uncle iroh who voice splinter)
So he dose not have a brown half the time because of his stupid reviews.
I especially hate his small soldiers review because he keeping make similarities to it even though small soldiers is mostly like gremlins and have a *few* similarities to Toy Story.
Doug Walker: “They’re the same movie.”
You're a egocentric one, Mr. Doug.
You live solely in nostalgia!
You're not fully honest with your reviews and you nitpick unneeded scenes as some sort of criticism.
Mr. Doug!
You play role as a clown, with full of narcissism!
Rather than calling "Inside out" rip off Osmosis Jones, Both of them should be considered two sides of the same coin and there could be a potential crossover to show the physical, mental and emotional reaction to life changing moments.
I do like the idea that both Osmosis Jones and Inside out exists together, but are completely ignorant of each others existence and totally unable to communicate
And that the mental crew gets really confused when control is taken away from them by the mayors
@@generalalduin9548 Osmosis Jones is rooted in biology. Inside Out is rooted in psychology. Completely different.
@@MrChaotic4 your point?
@@generalalduin9548that they cover different things: one is about CELLS, the other is emotions😅 please learn to read and think for yourself. I’m tired of coming across so many brick-for-brains
@@gracekim25 again, your point? Who's to say they couldn't exist in the same universe? Our psychology and biology exist in the same body
I feel like cell at work fits for more with osmosis jones instead of inside out.
Osmosis Jones came out in August 2001. Inside Out came out in June 2015.
Obviously, both these movies are a ripoff off of that one episode of Fairly Oddparents "Tiny Timmy" which came out in April 2001.
Timmy went to the brain and met with emotions, went to the body to interview Princess Protozoa, hung out with germs that claimed to be The Stomach Flu. He even made it to Kidney World, where he met Walt Kidney lmao /s
My biggest issue is how he says at the end
“ it’s ok if somebody rips you off if they did it better than you “
Oh, man, all sorts of "great" lessons in that episode of Nostalgia Critic! (I may have to do an Extra Dose video to get all the stuff I missed or didn't clarify) But for real, ripping off isn't very cash-money. There may be accidental or unintentional ripping off or something with a similar premise is inevitably going to be accused of being a rip-off, but when those happen it's not a good idea to just go ahead and rip it off anyway since no favors are going to be done, you know.
@@MagmaPaint oh yea!
And then there’s the fucked up joke here, more disgusting than the “ going down “ joke.
Frank says the name of a woman, who I think is his wife, I dunno..
Shane then says
“ no dad, it’s me, Shane! “
To which Doug responds, imitating Frank
“ oh, sorry. Megan was a prostitute from years ago(?) but I’m sure you can understand the confusion “ or something to that effect....
Basically implying that like..
He thinks Frank’s wife was a prostitute
And then saying *his own daughter reminds him of said woman*
That is full of fucked Up implications
@@skylarsworld9477 This is what happens when you watch a steady diet of Family Guy in its decline and worst seasons while thinking you have the finesse of Trey Parker and Matt Stone. I dunno if Doug is still watching Family Guy as bad as it's gotten but it wouldn't surprise me if it was the case.
@@MagmaPaint On your Sonic Forces example, I recall that someone made a video on how Sonic Forces share a similarity with Fleetway's Sonic the Comic; even though the two continuities also have an Apples/Oranges logic going on. BTW, your art is beautiful!
@@MagmaPaint 38:49: Oh you mean like this?:
Victor: The plot has been twisted! Esmeralda has fallen in love with someone else.
Hugo: Yeesh! Talk about being Friend-Zoned!
Laverne: Poor Quasi; they seem like a good couple.
That moment for me where I completely lost all respect for the nostalgia critic and Doug in general is when he completely disrespected the wall by Pink Floyd
He can say he disowned that review all he wants but the internet doesn't forgive and it sure doesn't forget.
@@MagmaPaintWe still remember “Melvin, Brother of the Joker.”
He's a heretic
I love the way you draw the characters from both films. Especially Joy, who looks absolutely adorable in your art style.
Joy, Anger, Fear, Disgust, Sadness, Osmosis, Drix, Leah and Thrax look very good in Magma I love the thumbnail her as Disgust
Yeah... even when I was a fan of _Nostalgia Critic_ and thought he got *most* things right about cinema, I thought the _Osmosis Jones/Inside Out_ comparison was kinda stretching it, as there's been plenty of other media that centred on personifying the mind more specifically. Prolly the most famous example prior to _Inside Out_ was the show _Herman's Head,_ and there's also been a few one-off gags in episodes of TV shows, such as the _SpongeBob_ episode "Squilliam Returns", for example. Not to mention, there was a show called _Inside Eddie Johnson_ that focused on personifying the body, which I guess puts it more in the _Osmosis Jones_ category as opposed to _Inside Out,_ though I can't really fault Doug for not having heard of that show, as it aired on Nickelodeon in the 2000s, and isn't particularly circulated online either.
But yeah - what do you expect from the same guy who compared _Mad Max_ to the Roadrunner cartoons, and thought _The Wall_ was just random visuals for the sake of random visuals?
It's such a weird bit. Because on one hand, I get it, right? They want a framing device for the review. So sure, the others have to do something for a sketch and there's not a lot of popular media taking place inside someone's body outside of just this. But it's also like..... there had to be other ways to do this, right....?
Like, off the top of my head, maybe make the framing like Doug's going to the doctor for a check-up and the other people can play the doctors and nurses and stuff as they try to diagnose Doug getting sick as he just keeps ranting about Osmosis Jones to them. I don't know if it'd be funny, but it'd make way more sense than this and they could probably work some clever jokes in there, right?
The trope of personifying parts of the psyche and the realm (mind/brain) they live in, aside from the memory library (but not dream motion pictures, as film had not been invented yet); It all goes all the way back to Book 2 of The Faerie Queene, a Shakespeare-era fantasy epic. The part with the Castle of Alma. Look It up. So yes, Inside Out and Osmosis Jones share a centuries-old common ancestor.
Somewhat unrelated, but the thumbnail art having Sadness hug Osmosis Jones's leg is REALLY cute!!
As a person who loves pathology, Thrax is 1 of my favorite villains of all time. Most people are disturbed when he kills the white blood cell, but I find it fucking amazing.
Frieza: That’s stupid. You’re stupid. Stop being stupid.
Me: That perfectly sums up every video I’ve seen so far from CinemaSins, TVSins, etc.
53:50: I know Thrax is evil, but man does he have jive.
There are tons of things that Doug doesn’t understand
Almost everything
I dont get it I DONT GET IT. Why Does It Look like Vegas?!
@@hootinthedark Because they designed Hercules to actually have visuals styled after Vegas, like they're holding up flashing signs in the musical number AS Doug talks about it in the review.
The Critic gets a lot of stuff wrong, but this one's baffling because he's unironically correct and nobody seems to care because you aren't seeing the point in context if you just hear it parroted in an OneyPlays joke.
@@dracocrusher 🥺....I dont geddit
He complained about Pirates 3 being long which is why he hated it, but he has no right to complain about that when he made to Boldly Flee, which is THREE AND A HALF FUCKING HOURS LONG. ALL OF WHICH is just him being pretentious and snobbish until he dies and they act like it's the end of the golden age of reviews
Honestly I wasn’t really concerned over whether or not Inside Out was a rip-off of Osmosis Jones, but the whole part about plagiarism being okay as long as the final product is liked just isn’t okay. Imagine you make something and it gets a lot of praise only for someone to plagiarize it and it becomes a great success earning the person who ripped off your work rich and famous but it doesn’t matter because you weren’t popular or the culture you were a part of was opposed to your beliefs. I could probably explain it better.
Nope, you nailed it.
I remember this movie, but I haven't seen it as a kid, even though I've heard it's underrated. I'm not an expert on the human body, but the worldbuilding inside a human is very interesting, I love the police plot-line storytelling giving some character development, and I love the voice acting, even the villain is awesome as he seems to be written like a biological weapon instead of an actual virus. When Doug compares this movie to Inside Out only because it involves living inside a human, that's like comparing Star Wars to Alien only because of the special effects and outer space setting.
Or it's like comparing _HMS Pinafore_ to _Treasure Planet_ because they both take place on some kind of ship.
I know that might sound rich coming from the man who often compares _Pinafore_ to _Titanic,_ but at least then it's not just the ship that makes them similar, but also the basic plot structure of a guy and a girl falling in love with each other but being unable to marry due to misaligned social class rank, and the girl being betrothed to some snobbish old fart who's just in it for the money... and even with those similarities, I feel the need to caveat the comparison by calling it a "Disneyfied" version of _Titanic_ (and caveating *that* caveat by adding "even though it predates both Uncle Walt and the actual _Titanic"),_ as - SPOILERS - everyone lives at the end of _Pinafore._ That, and it's a musical/opera.
I hated it…Osmosis Jones that is.
Doug's biggest issue in defending himself from critique is that he claims the Critic is a character yet the views are his own. It's like he thinks people are just upset over his delivery rather than people taking him to task over his failure to do even simple research, overreaching for terrible jokes, atrocious levels of "special effects," and the laundry list of other problems that have nothing to do with his over-the-top delivery.
Even more rich is that at some point in the past, the whole "character" excuse could be bought to some extent but once the Real Thoughts and First Viewing videos started becoming regular they really killed that notion because Doug in character as the Nostalgia Critic and Doug out of character are barely distinguishable. Not to mention that little bonuses like calling Sailor Moon "Jailbait the Show" at a convention as himself while his Nostalgia Critic review of the anime repeatedly accused it of being spank bank material just keep giving him more rope to hang himself. I'm half expecting him to winge and whine about how he's facing a similar dilemma as the actor who portrayed Geoffrey in Game of Thrones who retired from acting altogether because people couldn't distinguish him from the character but that's not the case here. Geoffrey was an absolute piece of sh1t that was completely irredeemable and while his actor was very effective at portraying him, he's nothing like the character in real life and would probably punch the character in the face given the chance. Doug as the Nostalgia Critic is closer to Heath Ledger's portrayal of the Joker where he slowly molded into the role to the point of becoming just as insane or Weird Al Yankovic as Cheese Sandwich where the actor is playing a character written and designed with the actor's characteristics in mind and now I feel really gross comparing this hack to better characters and actors (plus musician in Weird Al's case) where the two run together.
Kinda like blaming the gun for killing an asshole which in reality is an another asshole who use it.
I'd also like to point out that Deadpool was around BEFORE Rick and Morty and Freakazoid.
I could be wrong but both Deadpool and Freakazoid both debuted in the 90s with the former obviously being out first. It's all superficial comparisons because Doug just can't be arsed to do his homework and shuts his brain off as soon as he finds a surface level similarity and bases the review around that
@@MagmaPaint
You're right, Mag. Deadpool debuted in 1991 while Freakazoid debuted in 1995. Rick and Morty wasn't around until 2013.
That is a major problem with Doug. The only kinds of humor he knows are gross-out jokes, immature jokes, surface-level pop culture references, and jokes where the entire punchline is cruelty (I know he said misery, but it still counts).
Several of his post-revival episodes make it clear to me that Doug never wanted to bring Nostalgia Critic back in 2013 but had to because of the massive failure of his and his brother Rob's dream project Demo Reel. The clipless episodes (including The Wall) especially shows his resentment towards Demo Reel crashing and burning in 2012 by injecting that show's drab, life-less style into NC.
Honestly, the Not So Awesome document and his "review" of The Wall were the breaking points for me with the show.
#ChangeTheChannel
I always felt weird about his comparison. Osmosis Jones seems more like innerspace for kids
Inside out and osmosis Jones are only similar in premise because both take place in the body but they couldn't be more different it's like comparing The Beatles to Nirvana both are considered rock but they are totally different sounding bands with a totally different approach
Like when Award People judged Jethro tull and Metallica together
I must say, it's a good thing I found out that Australia and the US use different rating systems *before* I stumbled across this video, or I'd have been hella confused why a videogame would "only" get an M rating for something that would earn a film an R rating.
For those wondering, M is basically the equivalent of PG-13 and TV-14, while our equivalent of NC-17 is R18+, or "R" for short. And yes, we use the same rating system for both movies and television, though videogames have their own rating system.
Yeah, I used US ratings because that's where I'm from
That "Lion King" bit he acted out makes me cringe every time.
On many Pokémon VHS tapes I had back in the early 2000s. There was always an advertisement for "Kimba the white lion" and I said to myself "kind of reminds me of the Lion King" only I was able to clearly see some differences to make it stand out from the other
I don't understand the point of Doug and Rob's Sibling Rivalry. There's no Rivalry, they pretty much have the same opinions.
Doug’s “going down” “joke” doesn’t surprise me since he’s worked with Jeremy Scott from CinemaSins, a.k.a, the same goof who thought it was ok for him, a grown adult to make those 🤢🤮 worthy comments about Hermione and her “not being old enough to be hot yet.” Jesus Christ, Jeremy! Are you trying to be the new Jared Fogle?? Ok, I doubt it’d go that far, but he should still have kids kept away from him due to his cringe worthy sex comments when covering content aimed at families and audiences of all ages. To sum up, CinemaSins sucks, Jeremy shouldn’t be taken seriously and Doug should mentally face palm multiple times for writing out his “going down” comment, thinking it’d be an ok “joke” to make, recording himself saying it, editing it into the video and posting it online for all to see. The next time he wants to go after someone for doing something creepy or acting like a creep, we can remind Doug that he defended two actual criminals he worked with and, if he tries pulling the “Twitter crap” any more, we can remind him he used the “n word” in one of his older episodes and how that by his logic should be one of the many reasons for him to be “cancelled.”
On the Gore topic. Did that man never play the Halo games. Bruh the Halo games were rated M, because of the gore from the Covenant, who where ALIENS!
I highly doubt he touched a Halo game since his main media diet consists of Family Guy, Super Mario Bros on the NES, Looney Tunes, Animaniacs, and Tom and Jerry with the occasional horny times binge. There might be the occasional Iron Giant for nutritious thinking movies but look at this guy's sense of humor and outlook on anything and try to tell me with a straight face he's internalized anything more complex than a Wil E Coyote cartoon.
Doug Walker: "Wow. I mean... Wow. This movie made a fart joke, about a normal bodily function that everyone does. This movie is basically the next H!t£€r!"
Also Doug Walker: *casually makes jokes about banging a 10-year-old*
And also makes fart jokes
And praising Ren and Stimpy for having gross out jokes
Let not forgot about him being sexist in his “review” sailor moon
@@pennysanchez7656 Ren and Stimpy wasn't just gross out, it's also known for characters going off model for extreme expressions. The Canadian Yaks-men episode is a good example.
@@orangeslash1667 True, but I feel like we all know about John K and his.....let's just say creepy obsession with children that led to his downfall among other things he did.
I really like these hand drawn thumbnails you did. Their well drawn. How long does it take to draw up these thumbnails?
When I'm in the zone, it probably takes me 4 hours from start to finish to make my hand drawn thumbnails
@@MagmaPaint with some thumbnails their either coloured or left coloured.
How long does it take to colour them?
I just love the art in this video. It makes me want an Osmosis Out crossover. Psychosomatic.
Thanks, I drew it myself!
I totally headcanon the emotions are a sentient AI program developed by the brain cells in the OJ universe.
Yeah this comparison was weird to me. I always saw Osmosis Jones as a cinematic parody of those cartoony bodily functions educational videos. Inside Out never gave off that vibe
I was not a fan of his review of the 1999 remake of "The Mummy", especially with him thinking that the establishing shot of Thebes in the prologue was just CGI, when in reality; with some excep-tions; most of the foreground effects (the Sphinx and the Plaza) were practical miniature effects by ILM, with certain live-action humans (including
a lady walking her dog) shot on a green screen; and the stone wall, kneeling guards, and Pharoah Seti I riding his horse chariot were actually shot on lo-cation in Morocco.
I luved this movie to growing up as a kid and being an adult now I get the more adult jokes that skipped over my head as a kid XD! I dont get why he did a comparison between these 2 Movies as one is about the Emotions of a Child and the Other is a about a White Blood Cell and Pill trying to stop a deadly virus.
It's like comparing _The Loud House_ to _Summer Heights High_ just because they both have a character with Down syndrome.
In an adult body, no doubt.
In a nutshell: the key difference between the two is that one is about *mental* health while the other is about *physical* health
48:52 HEY! Don't you diss on my boy Chris Rock! His performance as Jones was amazing in this movie and Marty The Zebra from The Dreamworks Madagascar series was GREAT as well!
That was not me dissing Chris Rock's performance, that was merely acknowledgement of critical reception to his roles in films that generally weren't great. You can possibly bounce back from bad roles (as in the case of Robert Pattinson going from Cedric Diggory to the infamous Edward Cullen back to Batman/Bruce Wayne) but that's a combination of luck and production quality.
18:04
Ok,
Can I say your drawings are really well done.
Apparently NC never passed health class.
Or even picked up an anatomy book.
Seriously, there exist anatomy books written with *7-year-olds* in mind. How TF does a then-30-something-year-old flunk biology that hard?
@@ARCtheCartoonMaster Clearly people who were kids were told these things in school, and this guy tries to be funny, ends up being offensive, creepy and annoying. Not to mention not doing the fucking research
What's sad is that this movie happens tochave a major plot hole involving Thrax's plan. See, when your body temp goes up, it gives your immune system an even better chance to fight viruses, so by increasing Frank's temperature, Thrax would not kill him like he wanted and instead kill himself essentially. It's sad because Doug never brings this up, making this review look even lazier as a result.
Lots of people pointed out that Thrax doesn't behave like a virus detached from Doug's review and the heat contradiction isn't the only flag. Triggering Cytokene Storm (a body's last resort of fighting infection by raising internal temperature to fatal levels) and killing his victim as quickly as possible was Thrax's first, last, and only priority which would make him hella deadly. But any virus that does this is going to have a hard time spreading the infection to other people because there's no time to multiply (not that Thrax would be the kind to share the glory with clones of himself created a la Invasion of the Bodysnatchers). I might have to address this when I get to the Q&A video.
@@MagmaPaint Reminds me of how Rothbart tried to kill Odette despite, you know, that going against his plan of marrying her to take over William’s kingdom.
@@ARCtheCartoonMaster It's been AGES since I seen the Barbie version of Swan Lake but the villain also threatened to kill Odette too
Your artstyle for Inside Out and Osmosis Jones look adorable!
Despite the movie bombed at box office I still enjoy watching it including spin off series Ozzy and Drix. It’s clear Doug is losing his taste on commentary and nitpicks small details just for his tasteless humor/jokes.
I can count on *one hand* how many legitimate dissections and thought provoking essays Doug has put out... and they got shot in the head later down the road regardless.
the main problem i have with nostalgia critic is that it feels like he forgets to add punchlines to most of his jokes
I also saw this in my sophomore biology even though I saw five years earlier in theaters
Also fun fact osmosis jones had a tv series believe it or not
Ozzy and Drix
42:41 - 44:29
Now I feel even worse having been a Doug Walker fan.
Another comment because I'm enjoying this video so much and grasping new info, I'm currently at the part mentioning the movie played once a year in school...
I was in middle school, and the teacher said we were moving on to learning about cells. And I asked if maybe AFTER the lesson, could we watch Osmosis Jones... I was surprised when she decided to play the movie BEFORE the lesson. That made me glad to fill in the Osmosis Jones movie questions.
5:00 Anyone seen Phelous’s Next Mutation reviews? This is making me think of the “Michelangelo is Braindead” gag.
yeah it kind of does
Nostalgia Critic is a content farm, and should be treated as such.
God I def lost brain cells from his "analysis"
Wow, didn't realize NC had a few beginning cracks before the whole ChangeTheChannel movement happened. Though I gotta hand it to you for stating facts about Osmosis Jones & Inside Out while also savagely roasting the hell out of Walker.👏
I'm pretty sure Osmosis Jones is the USA version of Cells at Work or Hataraku Saibou. And yeah Inside Out is definitely a mental health movie and NOT a sequel to Osmosis Jones. Correct me if I'm wrong.
Ah, I see you are a gal of culture as well.
Doug's logic of Inside Our ripping off Osmosis Jones and doing it better on the metric of taking place inside the body is about as sound as Mickey Mouse ripping off Felix the Cat or Bimbo Beagle because they're anthropomorphic animal cartoons.
Starting at 31:56, what music is playing in the background?
What really gets me about the whole thing with people taking Doug's word as gospel is that he himself has stated time and time again that it's just schtick, yet people continued to do this. And Doug seems blissfully unaware of it. I remember in his audio commentary on the Adventures of Sonic review, he mentions the comments from people who say now as adults, they hate it, but he doesn't even acknowledge the possibility that most of them only said that because he said the show was bad in his NC review.
For the 2D animations, as petty as that complaint is, you'd think by this point, he would have hired a professional 2D animator considering he can afford it now.
Since he's more or less become the face of internet reviews and he and the Critic character are one and the same at this point, I feel justified in holding him to the standard of the title of the former. It's also on the individual to come to their own conclusion, but I think responsibility should be exercised on the reviewer's end as well. And with what was revealed in the Not So Awesome document, responsibility appears to be something he and especially Mike Machaude are allergic to.
Quick side note, this video is currently down due to copyright claim and going through an appeal. Did you come from Odysee by any chance or did you manage to catch it before it got blocked? Just out of curiosity.
@@MagmaPaint Funny, it's not down for me. Maybe it just got blocked in the states and I can see it because I live in Canada. Weird.
@@slashermaster28 Huh. I have a friend in Canada who caught it on upload and after refreshing the page she saw it was blocked. Weird.
EDIT: I've just been informed it's back up, but USA users are gonna have to use VPNs or mirror links for the time being.
@@MagmaPaint Is it wrong to ask if you would do a "Nostalgia Critic Doesn't Understand" video on Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog? While AoStH and SatAM also have the “Apples and Oranges” logic of compare and contrast, and that AoStH itself is a crazy attempt at turning Sonic into a tribute to Classic Cartoons, AoStH is not far from what Naoto envisioned (at the time of the cartoon's release). AoStH only focused on Sonic 1 and 2, and that includes both the Genesis and Master System versions, as there were concepts from the Master System version of Sonic 2 that became part of AoStH's episodic formula, like Tails being kidnapped by Robotnik.
Other than Sonic 2 for the Genesis, which introduced the importance of the Chaos Emeralds, as well as the Death Egg, AoStH only went with the simplicity of the dynamic between Sonic, Tails and Robotnik (as well as Robotnik's Badniks, Scratch, Grounder and Coconuts). Also, upon my research, I took note that AoStH is one of those shows that has good continuity, and I even did a video dedicated to it, called [Continuity Nods in "Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog"] highlighting things that were called back in future episodes, or a continuing stream of episodes highlighting character relationships.
I don't know why Doug would think "AoStH is not as good as SatAM", when in reality, they were originally meant to be one show, based on the *Archie Comics* continuity of Sonic at the time of the comics' publication, but before SatAM got cancelled, resulting in that storyline retconned back to the comics... until Ian Flynn said "screw you, I'm rewriting the comics, because I can do what I want."
@@robbiewalker2831 I don't know about the Archie Comics connection, but I might do a response for completionist's sake. I'm in the minority of people when I say I admit that SatAM is a good show but I myself do not like it because of my own hangups (it's entirely because of Sally; she didn't leave a good impression on me and issue #134 and the whole 30 Years Later storyline did the character no favors)
I wouldn't call Ian Flynn the comics' patron saint like a lot of people but some of his worst writing days are exacerbated by the precedent Ken Penders left and Sega restraining and restricting the series too much and writers have to work around that
I wasn't able to watch your review on time yesterday due to the copyright claim. This was great! Your points are insanely valid and just further prove how much Doug doesn't do his research nor care to understand movies properly. By the way your art is AMAZING!!👍
What's that song playing in the background 27:57
Fill Me In by Craig David
18:04 you drew joy so cutely🥺💕
I should like to say that Danganranpa, featuring humans with pink blood, feels like a better example than Homestuck's trolls.
If only I had any experience with Danganronpa.
@@MagmaPaint*Cracks knuckles*
Would you like to take a look at Doug's Untitled Review Show of Sonic the Hedgehog 2?
I'm still working towards that one but it's on the hitlist. Expect production to get underway when Sonic 2 comes out on physical release that way I can get my footage.
@@MagmaPaint Okay then. Keep it up.👍
I didn’t know that about Walt disney so rip Walt’s mom your son changed the world
Actually, I read somewhere that that’s not actually true.
Hey look, its the review that started my distaste for NC. If you watched anyone else on CA back in the day, you saw the others who started on the site (my favorites being Linkara, Todd In the Shadows and Marzgurl) you saw them growing and evolving as creators... meanwhile, Doug felt like a recycle of jokes and commentary lazily cut and pasted into relatively unique scripts, with some at best weak and at worst, actually asinine commentary of someone who had not refined their tastes or style in almost a decade of this work. Then change the channel poisoned any good will and i followed the CA creators i liked (and who spoke out) in their exodus.
Also you use Shadow the Hedgehog music for angry rants and as somone who likes that edgy mess of a game, faults and all, i love that
As for the blood color thing, one example I could give is a movie my friends and I made called “Mindworms,” which is on my channel. The alien worms in my film have green blood, since they’re alien, and when they take over the humans, their green blood mixes with the humans’ blood since the anatomy is mixing, giving an in-universe reason for the zombies to have some green slime as blood. However, due to the carnage, dismemberment, swearing, and crass humor, it still wouldn’t make the film “less gory” as Doug Walker claims. Also, as for you mentioning that “Osmosis Jones” was originally PG-13, even though Doug pretty much never does his research, this one baffles me the most because he could’ve figured that out with just a simple read of the Wikipedia page or IMDB trivia section. I learned that back when I first watched the movie in around tenth or eleventh grade. I also think Doug was trying to make a point that nothing is 100% original, but he doesn’t do a good job of explaining it. The best way to word it is that “Osmosis Jones” wasn’t the first film to personify the immune system and “Inside Out” wasn’t the first to personify emotions, but both do creative ideas with their concepts.
So far, my first introductions to dug has been him making 2 sex/sexual jokes about underage girls.
(From your channel)
*How the actual f*ck does he still have supporter's* 💀💀💀
I wouldn't say Doug has no nostalgia for 90s media. I am also an 80s baby and I hold more nostalgia for 90s media than 80s media. That said, Doug is a few years ahead of me, so he probably relates only to early 90s media and remembers the rest from a teenage perspective. Teenagers tend to have contempt for media aimed at children and families.
Not usually 😅
47:27 so true. In freshman year, we watched this movie in biology class along with GATTACA.
Once I unsubscribed from nostalgia critic, I never EVER came back. And I never did.
Good choice
this one is some of your best yet sis!
Oh, you're her sister, KristinaPatton193? Cool.
Osamis jones and Cell works is about biology and inside out is about psychology/ emotions😅 those are different things 😶 Doug has the understanding of a child 😆
It sure seems like it. And in worst case scenario, he'll actively lie about scenes to make his point, as demonstrated in in The S.E.A's series criticizing Doug's Pirates of the Caribbean reviews
Onistly, the movie wasn't even bad and aldo I had some issues like some gross jokes and the live action scenes were kinda boring, it's still a decent film and even doe Inside Out is better it still dosen't mean Osmosis Jones is a awful film and these films aren't similar
Also that "joke" that Walt Disney had Bambi's mom killed off is cruel to the man's legacy. Walt Disney always regretted being indirectly responsible for the death of his own mother. It just shows Doug Walker doesn't do the most basic of research
Also, the whole pointless "Lion King ripped off Kimba the White Lion" claim? Really?
The joke was about because Disney always kills off the mother. It had nothing to do with Walt Disney himself. But again, Disney always kills off the mother in a lot of their movies.
@@mrslasher2954 there's a huge difference between Walt Disney, the man himself, and the modern Disney company that's been going in different directions ever since his death. Doug needs to leave the man out of it out of such a cruel disrespect joke.
And Disney always kills off the Mother?! The mother of at least Aurora, Tiana, Rapunzel, and Merida would like a word with you
And I never said that *you* personally had anything to do with the joke. Since when was this about you? Don't put words in my mouth or in this case, comment!
@@Wiiguy1606 those are the couple of movies where the mothers are alive but most of them are dead. Honestly it's not that serious. It was just a joke. Bamia isn't a real deer. He didn't make fun of Walt Disney's mother's death.
@@mrslasher2954 I saw your comment literally say I had nothing to do with Walt Disney themselves before you obviously edit it
@@Wiiguy1606 yep, made a mistake but doesn't change my point. Again he did not say anything about Walt Disney the man himself and his mom. Just a bambi joke.
i expected him to go “OH MY GOD THEY PUT GORE IN A KIDS MOVIE!”
Nostalgia Critic is like the mayor of Frank.
I'm actually curious what you think about his other "reviews" like The Lorax, Ferngully, Foodfight!, The Grinch, The Cat In The Hat, Horton Hears A Who!, Hop, The Boss Baby and literally every other reviews he's done. Can they be worse than this? I did see his review of Puss In Boots: The Last Wish and I didn't like it and I also saw his review of A Troll In Central Park and I thought it was complete shit.
I think after my Rango review response I'm going to try a different approach to talking about Doug not understanding a damn thing about anything. Which, spoilers, he clearly doesn't understand that one either.
What's wrong with his review on _Puss in Boots: The Last Wish?_ I thought it was pretty good, especially considering this is Doug "Is Not Funnie" Walker we're talking about. The only real error I noticed was when he didn't understand why people were comparing the movie to _Velma_ when he could have, you know, *Googled* it.
@@ARCtheCartoonMaster OK, that's a valid point. But I think what bothers me about the review is the skits where he's doing an impression of Death being colorblind after he says "I came here for an arrogant little legend who thought he was immortal! *sigh* But I don't see him anymore." It made me cringe so hard where Doug impersonating Death says this "But that could be because I'm colorblind. Everything looks red to me. What color are you? I'm looking for an orange cat! Are you orange?" His reviews are all the same, nothing has changed. If you think his review of Puss In Boots: The Last Wish is one of his better reviews, that's great.
Magma, you're a really good reviewer!
Well damn, I've been refreshed about the differences between psychology and physiology.
"Jokes on the both of them, Bionicle did human biology before either of them!"
-Doug Walker logic.
Somewhat related comment, your art is awesome, I especially love the one at 18:05
46:40 Dang, and to think I used to justify Doug's videos where he just talks about what happens in the movie then gives a half-baked review at the end by saying it's like in high school when you did the "introduction/body/conclusion" shtick.
That would imply that Doug actually paid attention in school.
Bruh, you should make a tv show. You're art is amazing.
I've actually been trying to get at least one comic series off the ground for some time now. It's just that work is kind of a soul drainer
@@MagmaPaint ugh, I feel you there. It's especially annoying when you want to draw but you can't find a way to accurately portray it on paper.
I have stumbled upon the #1 Nostalgia Critic op and I'm here for it. Love these videos!
49:27 Exactly. It would be like calling _HMS Pinafore_ a much better satire on British government than _Iolanthe,_ despite the former only focusing on the navy, and the latter actually focusing on the Parliament itself, even if one finds _Pinafore_ to be better written overall.
Hi, I came across the video. I like the thumbnail art, very cute! I am still currently watching the video by the time I'm commenting, and I have a question.
Who made the art? I really do like the art style.
Glad you like the art :3 The thumbnail and three additional pieces featured were made by me (Comet's Light cover, recreation of the Take a Shot punchline, and Gathered Concern)
@@MagmaPaint My compliments go to you! The art style is really cute!
@@MagmaPaint finished the whole video, and I'm wondering if you have a deviantart page.
@@frenzywild2890 I do have a DeviantART page, the link to which is in the description box. Updates and uploads are slow because of other obligations but I've been trying to get back in the habit of making and uploading art on a regular basis.
The way you argue reminds me sooo much of ponder sprocket! If you know who ponder sprocket is and her influence you'll understand that that's a very flattering compliment
I do know who Ponder is, she's a pretty neat person. Not sure if she critiques bad reviews, tho, commentary is her specialty
My first videos I had distaste on him were New cartoons being better than Old without him going to a deeper dive on both the positives and the negatives and claiming you can get what you want when you something on the internet when it requires a lot of people to do it and not you and only you or a small group and the Kranks video that can’t get the old critic right
The Christmas with the Kranks video is a special kind of disgusting because not only has his craft not improved but he's using his past self as an insert of the audience and anyone who ever took issue with the clipless reviews. The finest instance of sticking your fingers in your ears and going "LA LA LA LA I'M NOT LISTENING TO YOU STINKY CRITICS" if I ever seen one.
@@MagmaPaint That and it says “we all improve. We changed” and yet there really isn’t a difference especially when claiming the movie is awful because of it not changing but… what are the cliches? How does it not get Christmas exactly? Krank was a jerk and he’s trying not to be one. If he say’s it’s executed poorly, I can understand but… he doesn’t. And O think the real reason why people subscribe to him isn’t because they love him but making fun of him and the crap he produces
@@MagmaPaint And also the baffling idea of “is weird the new brilliant” when like… FICTION IS ALWAYS WEIRD AND BRILLIANT WHEN DONE RIGHT EVER SINCE GREEK TIMES!!! You’re really gonna tell that now… FUCKING NOW from cartoons which some do execute their messages poorly (cough White Diamond) even though that Disney has been doing the whole message learned while having fun thing in the renascence era and stuff like Rocco’s Modern Life talks about… well… LIFE!?
@@ToonBoom788 I mean, the guy basically equates Mad Max: Fury Road to Roadrunner cartoons so I don't expect him to have any level of thinking and information processing beyond a six year old learning that his mother's real name isn't "Mom" and that the teacher doesn't actually live at the school. Doug rotates between slow, ignorant, and apathetically incurious a lot.
He has short generally 12 minute actual reviews for some movies. These are characters he's playing a character he does a sketch show in most of his reviews
U know he MIGHT have had something if he compared this to the anime Cells at Work
Thank God he doesn't cause man
Him and Rob hate Anime
Inb4 some brainlet responds with "B-but-but they like Studio Ghibli stuff! They don't hate ALL anime!" because in the Ponyo review Doug couldn't refrain from a wAcKy AnImE hIjInKs joke for one video.
I have a question, are you going to talk about Nostalgia Critic's The Wall, or do you feel like that terrible 40 minute "review" has been talked about enough and you don't need to add your 2 cents into the subject?
I alluded to this in my response to his PPG movie review and no, I don't think it's necessary for me to throw my hat in the ring on the discussion because everyone and their Uncle Clyde has already dissected and shredded it thoroughly. Maybe I'll bring it up as an example in future Doug Walker Doesn't Understand videos but no deep dive. Now, if he tries to do a retrospective on Gorillaz, on the other hand... You'll definitely want to grab some snacks and your waifu pillows and buckle in but I hope that day never comes (the joke about Ace in that review doesn't count, it's a sign of "You're treading on thin ice, buddy")
@@MagmaPaint oh trust me, I'll be preparing a baked chicken, 20 gallons of orange juice with extra pulp, 10 gallons of Mountain Dew, multiple pallet cleansing albums (such as Thriller, Dark Side of the Moon, Illmatic, The Chronic, Kid A, Damn, The Eminem Show, Pet Sounds, Graduation, The Super Mario Galaxy soundtrack, 30, The Moon is my Sun and He Look Just Like Me II, ETC), a bowl of broccoli, a Wendy's Baconator, and it's going to be good.
@@charliep7112 Oh, damn, you ain't getting just snacks, you're gathering a whole-ass FEAST
People say Osmosis Jones and inside out
Oh well tomato tómáto
But in reality it's fuckin tomato potato
Fun fact: tomatoes and potatoes are part of the same botanic family (nightshades) and it's possible to graft one of each and grow both from one plant
@@MagmaPaint oh
@@MagmaPaint also how did you reply in barley a second when I made this
@@Stewie400th because the comment wasn't very long and I'm watching a tutorial video for something before work
@@MagmaPaint explains
Anyways the vid very good very yummy
33:24 NGL, it's pretty funny to hear Slim/Doppler team up with Marty the zebra.
3:54 i love how he's leaving how the specifics to make them sound similar
Wait. People unironically watch Nostalgia Critic? I thought people watched him for his witty comments and his high pitched screams. I never actually care about the review itself tbh.
I only watched it so I could have something playing in the background when I’m drawing.
@@diegobareno5820 interesting
I really love your drawings!
There really good, and better then mine. Not saying your better then me. My drawing have improved since I was 13.
But what I’m trying say is your art style is really good and better then horrendous art of the Doug brothers.
oooooo.. the misanthropony one didn't age well.. it's alright, I understand, I used to be a fan of him too before he went batshit
If I had a nickel for every "Wow, that Zaid shout-out didn't age well", I'd have enough to donate to him for a full year of counseling sessions.
@@MagmaPaint like I said, I do understand, I defended him for so long.. too long in fact, sorry if I made you upset, I've shouted out people who turned out to be nefarious too
Well, i must say you earned yourself a new subscriber
Also the dream part. If anything you could see a crossover with NiGHTS and Klonoa as those two have a better connection, more then Sonic and Megaman. Sure the crossover-One time-can work, but if not respecting the sources or doing your research, can lead to some awkward or poor choices and results.
I kinda wanna see that as a crossover game now.
Though I sh1t you not, Doug actually made the Sonic/MegaMan comparison in his Sonic OVA review and it was entirely on surface level similarities. Heck, I'd take a stab at saying that Sonic and Crash have more in common what with having protagonists that fight an evil scientist completely fucking up nature, sidekicks that do more intellectual heavy lifting and are the literal or figurative sibling of the protagonist, allies that are physically stronger and initially debuted as rivals, and the games deciding when to shake up the formula to keep things interesting even when doing so doesn't always pan out.
@@MagmaPaint Exactly the point, that would've been a much better comparison, as those were points that people should've taken a look into. I'm guessing cause they think Crash is crazy or can't talk normally or something like that. But still that there makes much more sense. And plus Megaman dosn't have magical gems that turn him super and I won't go into the Archie comics, cause that's something I rather avoid the bag of worms.
21:05 Don't forget Carlos Alazraqui also voiced El Chupacabra in Disney's "Planes". He did somewhat of a fantastic voice job there, as well as Cedric the Entertainer and Sinbad. :3
I saw this movie in school at my science class. I like this movie as a kid and i still like it today.
10:48 he's not, it's just a meme that disney is most prominent for killing off parents. Listen I don't value nostalgia critic's reviews either but you don't have to take every joke he makes ultra seriously, unless it's directed explicitly towards the movie, and it's point is blanatly obvious, I don't think it's worth mentioning.
There are similarities whenever Osmosis Jones involves the brain. Memory library, dream motion pictures, the subconscious, and decisions made by characters who personify parts of the psyche using a control panel/manual override with eye-vision screen/view window of the outside world.
Alright, but beyond that (and those are miniscule parts of Osmosis Jones to begin with), what other beats constitute Inside Out a better rip off?
The trope of personifying parts of the psyche and the realm (mind/brain) they live in, aside from the memory library (but not dream motion pictures, as film had not been invented yet); It all goes all the way back to Book 2 of The Faerie Queene, a Shakespeare-era fantasy epic. The part with the Castle of Alma. Look It up. So yes, Inside Out and Osmosis Jones share a centuries-old common ancestor.
Adding on Doug's comment about different blood color changes rating. Explain how in the Halo games all them (except 5 & Infinite) where rated M? Cause of the blood, gore, violence, and language, and half of the blood was from aliens that the blood was a blue/purple color.
This would've been a better example for me to use, I just went with HomeStuck because I've never played any of the Halo games and the absolutely absurdly brutal ways the roster bit the bullet
This was such excellent video Magma I watch this 3 times already it's that so very well done, you did a lot of research on both Inside Out (my favorite Pixar Movie of all time) and Osmosis Jones (Very Underappreciated WB animated movie which I remember enjoy a bit) yeah Nostalgia Critic review on Osmosis Jones was so fudging terrible from the jokes to the edit to the shitty demo reel segments to not giving the movie fair criticism, I remember watching his review back in 2015 yeah those 2 movies are not similar at all I knew Osmosis Jones was about the human body how everything hell I remember decent how Ozzy and Drix from germs, smoking, cavities and other stuff how effects the human body which very cool to see and I watch Inside Out 3 times once in the theaters and twice on DVD rent from the library it was about psyological of the human mind and how the emotions effect people lives, like you say in your video the only thing that Osmosis Jones and Inside Out have in common is take place in the body that's it, Nostalgia Critic reviews has been getting worse before and after change the channel conversy after watching your videos on Nostalgia Critic I'm definitely done I'm no longer going to his videos even the older ones and the fans need to stop asking him to movies and cartoons from the 90s and 2000s.
Am I the only 1 that's feels they can't be the same simply because 1 is about crime fighting white blood cells and medicine trying to heal a body and inside out is about emotions trying to preserve a growing child's happiness....... same how?????
I think the wildfire part wasnt a good counter argument because its fictional and they could simply not have included a wildfire???
Here's another one, Minuscule: Valley Of The Lost Ants is SO OBVIOUSLY a rip-off of A Bug's Life. How crazy is that?
The 'cop cliche' thing... that was one. All of those things together are one trope. "The cop precinct", But honestly Doug's complete lack of understanding that a trope is not a cliche is unfathomable, with depths the likes of which might contain a Great Old One without anyone, including him, even knowing.
It his lack of understanding could snugly fit in the Marianas Trench and still spill out over the full Pacific seafloor.