The fact the she took the risk of making a concept like this being a female idol and succeeded amazes me. Moonbyul is really breaking barriers and stereotypes. She pulled it of perfectly, the way that she projects while performing is one of my favorite things about her as a performer. I can really see her winning Artist of the Year and SOTY.
she hasn't "succeeded" in the industry's eyes yet since she hasn't got many views or any wins yet so we have to keep fighting. Just because she pulled it off flawlessly isn't enough for most
Amber Tirbhowan yeah I know. We have a long way to go, I was talking about the fact that she did this concept and it didn’t turned out negative. I really enjoyed it and she did well.
Moonbyul deserves so much more, she's fantastic: she can rap, she can sing, she can dance, she writes songs, she creates chorographies, she is beautiful, she is funny, she is sweet and kind and she is strong. I admire Moonbyul very much, I'm proud of her, she works so hard and I love her songs. I'll always support her ♡
When I heard people insulted this song for its style the first thing that came to my mind is that not all women need to be in the cute and cheezy concept to be amazing.
Hwasa breakes beauty standards, Moonbyul breakes gender stereotypes, Wheein: whatever form it is, its all the same love, Solar breaks male-female idols norms and talking about female genital mutilation and THIS IS MAMAMOO, unique, one and only
Moonbyul's concept is so unique to be honest. I haven't seen any other female kpop idol do this and pull it off so so flawlessly. It's like she's made for this. I think that's also a reason why it isn't that popular, which is disheartening. Because this concept isn't a popular one. But we shouldn't give up! Let's keep on supporting her, Moonbyul deserves it!! 💙💙💙
Yes!! I’m so proud to say that she is the first female idol to do this kind of concept. She tried to break barriers and even though not many notice it there are probably female idols that really appreciate this because they might want to try it but since it’s a different concept/style they can’t. Seeing this is a improvement in Kpop for females.
i think this song speaks a lot about her role in mamamoo, and her personality in general. as said by the members of mamamoo, and other idols, moonbyul really knows how to take care of others. the lyrics tells us about how no matter life has become so dark, full of problems and worries, she won't be defeated by it and will shine for us and her members. she may worry a lot but she often put others above herself. and the song itself is breaking gender stereotypes in music in which we often (fans) see moonbyul do.
I love her, she is so different from other idols. I don’t think anyone can pull off a “rock” and “dark” concept as she can. The song makes me want to run around from excitement :3
I think she and Dami are both the most handsome. I can't choose lol. They are both so amazing.💗💕(I'm not trying to start fanwars) Also I didn't expect this song to be as amazing. I slept on Mamamoo and this song for so long. I'm ready to stan!💕💗💕💗💕
Rap:100% Sing:100% Dance:100% Charisma:100% Visual:100% Song quality:100% MV quality:100% Everything in this comeback and to this Queen is 100% Love And Support Moonbyul 100%
it's not boyish but i dont know how wearing suits is breaking gender stereotypes. girls are allowed to wear suits. it is the double standard that guys cannot wear dresses that needs to be broken.
In the song “HIP” there was something like “while you’re talking shit, I’ll go and write another album” written by Moonstar. And here she is with the new song, amazing visuals, perfect dance. She never stops working and improving her skills which inspires me so so much.
Ksush Zolotareva I thought only Hwasa who contributed in lyrics in hip? Is Moonbyul also wrote? Because so far I know that only hwasa who wrote the lyric with kim do hoon and park woo sang
This is not a "manlish" song, THIS IS A SONG BY A WOMAN that expresses what she wants to express IN THE WAY SHE WANTS to express it. She deserves respect and recognition for her talent, her braveness and the quality of her work. Adore you, Moon Byul.
@@Shiroiek She is brave because she is doing what she likes without caring the stereotyped norms about what a woman "can" do, sing or wear. She is always true to herself and authentic, and I am proud of her for that.
Actually, she was the most underrated even by her agency. She gets confidence onlly this year when she saw how many people loved her solo album. Even her agency was surprised by her solo success.
i am not a Moomoo, but i can't believe this masterpiece only has 8M. All of the Mamamoo members are exceptionally beautiful and unique, but Moonbyul simply has the ability to hypnotize me every time I see her. I can't believe this is so underrated. pd: she also hid my heterosexuality somewhere and now I can't find it
"I don't want to distinguish between men and women by the genre of music." That's what she said and she seems to be proving her brilliant thoughts by 'Eclipse'.
@@betty1053 It doesn't do that, TH-cam just does that on its own because it wants to verify that all views are actual people and not bots. The best thing to do when streaming is engagement, so keep commenting and like the video, don't be scared about what you write, just don't spam.
@@AKAJAYGAY is that so???? If yes then thank you, cause like my friends ( who are Kpop fans and they stream a lot) told me so. So I never use emoji on every comeback they use oops
Betty Lâm It’s a common misconception, I get it though, TH-cam isn’t the best site when it comes to communicating specs. The view stutters and seemingly random deletion of comments can make some things seem bad. Happy streaming, all!
don't call her "oppa" guys she said doesn't like it, she wants to show how a woman can dance and wear what they want regardless of gender stereotypes, please don't misgender her - she is a QUEEN she is EMPRESS she is GODDESS
REVOLUTION means Moonbyul. The song, concept, lyricism, choreography, edits, styling, behaviour and everything in between was Revolutionary. DECLARATION: Only Moonbyul can pull it off and she actually took it personally. If you know how the kpop industry actually works, you know how DIFFERENT this is. As an artist and as an individual she should be praised for creating and delivering all of these. Even if they didn't in the past when it was first releasing, I hope someday soon she'll be recognized and hear the claps that she truly deserves for challenging the industry and becoming part of the wind that should hit it.
I know everyone says this about everyone in kpop but this time I'm serious -- she's doing what no one else is. I've never seen a female idol do this kind of song. She's not just taking a boy group ish concept, she's making her own concept. It's not feminine, but it also doesn't feel like there should be a male idol singing it. It's her song and you can tell, and no one else could do this song like her, male or female.
Carolina, masculinity and femininity defines itself depending on different countries and culture. I really like your comment to Moonbyul, but remember that it differs f rom culture to culture. So I wouldn't officially say that her music is masculine if its in her country. Sorry if this comment offended you in any way.
@@LuklioN44 it didnt offend me dw. And yeah I do know masculinity and femininity are very different, I’ve lived in four different cultures and the difference is really clear. But I was talking about k-pop, so I think it’s implied that that was the context I was talking about. This is probably the most masculine-leaning concept Ive seen a female idol go for. In other contexts I wouldnt say its super masculine, but in context, compared to any girl groups or female kpop artists Ive seen, yeah, its more masculine than usual. I pointed this out specifically because its something that iterests me a lot. All my favorite kpop artists, male and female, are doing something that explicitly challenges the heavy gender norms in kpop. So I really like Taemin and Moonbyul, for example, and Id say a big part of why is that they’re doing things that aren’t conventionally gendered, in context. Out of context, Im a very involved member of the lgbt community and Im used to a lot more gender challenging than what kpop has to offer, trust me.
@@kateraspberry7634 So I do disagree with you. I've taken a lot of courses on gender studies and lgbt studies, and although that doesn't give me any authority on this subject, I do feel like I have some idea of what I'm talking about. So here’s what I think: Gender norms and stereotypes are absolutely connected to terms like femininity and masculinity, but those terms have a function beyond that. A big part of the feminist movement and the lgbt rights movement is based on blurring the lines between gender expectations, and disconnecting sex and gender by defining sex as biological and gender as social, while gender norms are social expectations according to someone's gender. Expecting a woman to be feminine is harmful. Femininity itself is not. I understand what you're saying about the word femininity being connected to "female" and therefore perpetuating gender stereotypes. I'm trying to find a way to phrase this in a clear way... These words don't just exist in my head; they still describe relevant social things (just because something is socially constructed doesn't mean it isn't real; e.g. gender). The lgbt community has been based since the beginning on playing with gender. Drag is probably the best example. If you're lgbt you'll probably be familiar with words like butch and femme to describe lesbians who express gender differently, or bear and twink to describe gay men (femme is also a common word to describe straight men who express more femininity than is socially expected of them). Camp is something completely born out of the lgbt community that describes a theatrical expression of gender through fashion and makeup. These are all very, very important characteristics of the lgbt "wave" I guess you could call it, and I think it's fair to say that the lgbt movement has been heading gender revolutions for a while. These things are all based on femininity and masculinity, and specifically using them to do away with gender stereotypes and norms. I understand what you mean about them contributing to gender norms. But for a very very long time now, they've actually been used to specifically combat these same gender norms, and to be honest that seems to be doing the most effective work up until now. They still describe socially relevant things, specifically *because* gender stereotypes still exist, and they can be and are being used to dismantle those existing connections between gender, sex, and social expectations. And recently femininity and masculinity have also started to blur together, which is also great. Harry Styles in a dress, for example. It’s made a lot of people (including Logan Paul, surprisingly) start questioning what exactly makes someone feminine or masculine, and if that correlates with their gender (it doesn’t). If we refused to acknowledge things like masculinity and femininity, first off, a lot of people (more than usual) would be calling us crazy and unrealistic. More importantly, we wouldn’t be able to play around with gender expectations in a way that has been continuously dismantling them, as we’ve been doing for decades. This was way longer and less organised than I’d like it to be but it’s really early and I have work in a bit, so I’m not gonna go back and clean it up, but I hope it made sense anyway. You’re obviously allowed to disagree and have your own opinion
This song is such a bop! Moonbyul showcasing her individuality and breaking gender norms for female kpop idols. The song is so addictive plus she has such a captivating persona that makes her stand out amongst the crowd of dancers. Respect to RBW for allowing their artist to shine:)
I think the same .......... I also feel that RBW knows its artists very well and knows what they may be capable of ... and with so many successes from Mamamo's background, I think that helped He would be given the opportunity to see how much he can get to shine, which we know and know will go far.
So refreshing to see that the company didn’t pressure her to be half naked or to have a « sexy » choreo in order to make views... I’m so tired of female idols being told to be sexy in order to be strong. Thank you Moonbyul
I like how she took the inspiration of her favorite group TVXQ to gain confidence to make something like this. You can really tell how much she loved TVXQ if she goes as far as to do this kind of concept. You can really feel her confidence in this music video and the way she portrays it shows that she is not afraid of anything. She has grown so much from the shy conservative hamster we all used to know. *I love it. I love her. I admire her. She is literally one of the best soloist of this year. This is absolutely great.*
Wah... She also a big fan of TVXQ?? I'm a new fan of her so I just know now. I'm an EXO-L so... I think she will have a good relationship with Xiumin hshshsh
Amalia Prast she loves them a LOT she’s covered their songs a lot before in mmm concerts she does a tvxq medley as a solo during their concerts its so good!
Fun fact : MAMAMOO is the one of the most talented people in the world who deserve nothing more than the utmost respect and just love . Stan talent . Stan handsome gender stereotype breaking queen , Moonbyul . Stan does what ever she wants and is an monarch , Yongsun . Stan super talented artistic queen , Wheein . Stan confident drop-dead gorgeous beauty standards breaking queen , Hwasa .
MAMAMOO DESERVES HIGHER THAN BP AND BTS MAMAMOO IS MORE TALENTOUS AND TALENT SHOULD BE EQUAL TO POPULAIRTY >:( YES MAMAMOO IS MORE TALENTOUS ARMY/BLINK, THE TRUE HURTS U
@@quememirasfeo Yes you should, all idols work hard so to say that one group deserves more than another would be ignoring the other one's hard work. BTS and black pink made it because they released bops that a lot of people liked. To say that Mamamoo deserves to be on top on them would discard all that BTS and Blackpink did. So basically, just respect other groups' rankings and don't hate on other groups unless they did something to receive hate
@@T355V I'm quite stressed about how slowly the numbers are increasing, I really hope we can make it, Byul deserves to get a lot of views as much as the others :/
@@yazmins.2157 I know... seeing how slowly we're going makes me so disappointed. It also makes me sad because Byul will also never say if she's disappointed in us...
@@T355V exactly. All she says is that she's happy cuz she got to make the music she likes and she chose this concept but i'm pretty sure she would've been happier if we gave her a win for eclipse. Some moos didn't even stre@m the song. Sigh
Moonbyul said in an interview: “If there is a Moonstar to protect you, there will also be a Monster to devour you” Yeah she definitely devoured us with this MV 🔥
Moomoos, Don't get disheartened. Our Moonstar is already shinning in our hearts. She is already ruling our hearts since her debut days. And she will continue to do so. Mamamoo as a group is itself a winner and I am pretty sure that We Moomoos will continue to support them even after. All we can do is give our love and respect to these amazing and gorgeous queens. Cause they deserve the whole world. Moonbyul with her ideology has already shattered the gender stereotypes and that's what I call a WINNER .
@@nikkinikki9029 i guess something wrong with TH-cam. This should be get at least 1 mil views but TH-cam kept freezing ( i think for about 9 hours?) And basically sobataged this
because we didn't hit 1 million/2 million views is she still going to be able to get a win? I dont want to let her down when her other members all got wins
I wish I spoke enough Korean to tell Byul JUST HOW MUCH this song means to me on a personal level. Currently teaching my self the lyrics thru form of Romaji. 🔥🔥🔥
I don't consider myself a moomoo, but I admire them. They look so genuine in an industry that seems kinda fake. I know that they've been somehow "dismissed" and came from a company that is not big, but they have still managed to do their best and they're succeeding. I hope their hard work can be recognized internationally.
Its the same thing especially from a group with small company. They always get dismissed and considered having less chance to succeed. It doesn't help that those from big company sometimes limits their success too. For me Mamamoo is one of kpop group that follows their own style rather than try to fit the stereotype. There's Hwasa not caring about how knetz bashed her body figure, Moonbyul dressing her comfiest clothes and not forcing herself to dress revealing (like some unwilling kpop gg had too). I started liking them because how genuine they are honestly
@Blinkeu FOREVER I used the word dismissed because I remember how non-fan knetz refuse to believe bts won daesang in 2016 and going so far as to say they cheated. Their denial is because bts is from a small company and its impossible for them to beat the top 3 company. Yes it took them 2 years to get recognition but the hate they got ever since they debuted had never lessened. Which why you see army being so protective when someone says something about them. I'm just so glad Mamamoo isn't getting too much hate lately because they are literally my favourite and most respected girl group ever. I can't bear to see the same thing happening to them
Is no one really realizing this is the first time in kpop history where a woman kpop idol has released and a performed a song with a masculine choreo LIKE this? Like ya there were girl groups that went hard, but a choreo like this? Never. I’ve been in this kpop ting since I was a little girl, and never have I seen a choreography like this performed by a female idol. I’ve been waiting for something like this :)
Yeak Amber has kind of a masculine look but this concept???? Never done before by a woman, this is clearly a bg mv but it's Moonbyul! Others have done strong or neutral concepts but she 😍
@@BeaFullbuster you re right this kind of concept is unique for a woman to do, its similar to 2012 concepts used by male groups i havent seen a girl doing this, yes the girlcrush or the "heavy hiphop" concept but not like this.
@@ashley-vs1dn BOA is BOSS LADY!! She one of my favorite soloist but i ve never saw her do this kinda concept(like very dark with some rock and electronic) even tho her works is diverse she did sexy dark concept or electronic dark concept .
I'm so mad choreos and songs this good are always limited to boy groups to the point that it just drags down the style. Like...I've genuinely stopped enjoying BG songs because I keep thinking about that. Her voice REALLY suits this!!
Exactly, if She wants to do a certain style, that's Her, it isn't due to a pressure from the market, She gets and She does what She wants to do because it's Her artistic expression. I hope more girl groups do have things like this, heck, I hope more boy groups have things like this, where they are not limited by the industry's standard or default options if they want to go out of the norm. Moonbyul should show Moonbyul, so that's what She does. And that's what I absolutely love about Her, and Mamamoo in general. They also don't always try to go out of the norm if they don't want to, if there's something they already like, then they'll do that, no need for pressure from one side to tell you to go out of the norm, again, they just do what they want and what they like, and that's what I love about them.
IDK WHAT'S WRONG WITH ME, BUT I REALLY LOVE MOONBYUL NOT ONLY BECAUSE OF HER PERSONALITY BUT ALSO BECAUSE OF HER TALENT AS AN ARTIST. NOT JUST A KPOP GIRL GROUP RAPPER BUT AS AN ARTIST. ILY MOONSTAR 💕
Song: *On point!* Dance: *ON POINT!!!* Visual: *oN pOiNt!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!* There is literally nothing she can’t do. Love you Moonbyul and love you MAMAMOO!
the world was really not ready for this. this defies every gender norm and stereotype so people were not here for this. but, man. this is one of the best release in 2020
If this was a song fr a boy group it would have gained much success & just bcuz a female idol decided to break the stereotype concept ppl r not supporting her ! In my opinion she slayed the song & the concept ! Much respect & appreciation is needed
@@sourwatermelon " feminine " most girl groups go fr the cute or the sexy but not as such moonbyul's one which is close to boy band thing ! I hope u got me
Because of Moonbyul I know just because I’m a woman, I don’t have to be what the world sees as “feminine.” I can dress and act however I want. Thank you Moonbyul.
In today's insta live moonbyul said she is happy with Eclipse's result and told us not to worry about the malicious comments...byul is always so sweet and appreciative to her fans...almost never have i seen her expressing disappointment? it's always her who comforts us. have you realized, she is really the moonstar who protects us from the darkness just as the lyrics have said^^
@@mizuko2001 I think she was talking about malicious comments in general (maybe especially the recent controversies with yongsun's solo outfits, but not limited to these). She was saying the trend nowadays in our society is to respect individuality and not to conform to one single standard. I think she was trying to say we should not worry too much bc mamamoo has a clear attitude in this
THE WHOLE SONG COULD BE GIVEN TO A GROUP BECAUSE OF HOW LIT AND COMPLICATED AND PERFECT IT IS WITH ALL THE DIFFERENT ROLES SHE DID HERSELF ALONE: RAP VOCALS VISUALS DANCE ♥️♥️♥️♥️
I know that everyone is saying this but.... Moonbyul is... One of the rarest kpop artist in the industry who advocate gender neutrality in her music. She's the few people in the industry whose brave enough to try new things and genre that the society tells her that is not fit for a woman to do but MOONBYUL proved it wrong! Eclipse might didn't win but I know moomoos know that this song is rare and you will barely see it on other female artist.
i just want to say thank you to everyone who’s strming to get this to 10million before her birthday. let’s give moonbyul the recognition that she deserves so much!
Gogobebe era: Really, white hair fits Byul with perfection. Hip era: actually, scratch that, purple/gray is totally her color! Eclipse: DAMN GIRL! I CAN'T DECIDE ANYMORE!
After reading the comments, i think the huge reason why the vi3ws are slow is because most of moomoos died in the middle of the video. Byul-ah... You are too COOL in here, how do you want us to survive?? 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️ Ok. Joke aside. Come one moos!! We can do it!! 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
I just want someone with a popular comment in this section to mention the fact in their comment by editing that for a view to count u need to watch at least 30 seconds so one just has to watch 35 seconds or so for streaming. I think some r watching the whole vid while others r just continuously skipping.
I will never forgive Korea for not giving Moonbyul the attention that she deserves neither the whole world Also the Radish fandom who did not str33m the song enough
Imagine the day they're no longer underatted and the new moomoo found out about their old stuffs wondering why didn't they stan them sooner, atleast that's how i felt 😂
@@smile-sq7pt Maybe I didn't watch that episode. I have studies so I usually can't watch the full episodes, I mostly watch some parts. Can you give me a link for this particular one or mention which one it was?
@@smile-sq7pt Also, I just pointed out an instance where this didn't happen. 'Passion Flower' was during their rookie days, and it was an added verse in a cover. Maybe Moonbyul meant for her own songs, then this is probably true
I really wish this mv blows up. She deserves all the attention and praises in the world. I want her to win at least once on music show. I want her to be the living proof that ‘boyish’ concept sells too (not that she hasn’t proved that already). This can be a game changer for future gg gens.
Guys I just want to share this info in a popular comment, please download idol champ and vote for moonbyul in MV promotions coz if she gets no. 1 there will be: 1⃣ 1 million impressions of the promotion banner in the IDOLCHAMP app 2⃣ U Tube Official M/V Play & Promote on 120,000 Computer launch screens in 1,650 internet cafes nationwide in Korea She’s no. 2 right now n lagging behind dream chaser but if all of us can give her a vote each day I’m sure we can turn the tables around :(
I kinda do be missing this era. I lowkey wanna hear songs like this hardcore from her again. But whatever your creative mind wanna create Byul I'm all here for it ❤️
i saw a director reaction video of this. and i also think its really clever on what moonbyul's team did around 1:06 - 1:10 . notice how the proportions of the vid widens vertically and then restricts back to the original. to a casual viewer its easy to miss that, but when its pointed out to you, its visually pleasing and amazing to incorporate it with the beat drop.
I'm living for everything about this comeback. Her look is always on point. THAT BROWN SUIT IS A WHOLE YES. Her voice and her bars and her rapping are a whole yes. Her passion is a yes. The visuals is a yes. The concept is a yes. HER CHOREO IS A WHOLE YES. We need to stress about how moon was given choreo that isn't the typical female idol choreo. Then again moon's style is so unique is rivals male idols at this point. ALSO MOONBYUL STOP IT!! My top male idols are bts. MOONBYUL IM SUPPOSED TO BE LOYAL TO MY BOYS TOO. Rm gonna get mad😭 Mamamoo are definitely my top gg WITH rv and twice following after them. No girlcrush has ever done things like moon unless u count amber❤️ amber is my beautiful llama. But again to moonbyul, she dresses (even on her free time) very casual,always cleanly well put but not in tight skirts and such. Her androgenous style is so natural, the way she has on suits to her feminine points like the bold makeup, hairstyles and jewelry. It all balances who and how she is. She is definitely my ult gcrush.
Completely unrelated, but at this point I'm completely sure any bts Stan who gets out of just bts and ventures into kpop likes mamamoo. I mean although I started from mamamoo, shit never seen many of a combination more than armymoos. Guess who've seen talent once don't settle for anything less
All of that... HARD YES. It’s flawless. I don’t know how to express how I’m impressed I am with Moon, who just bulldozed through the Kpop mold. Mamamoo was already fighting the good fight, but this is... sublime. I don’t even have the words. 😩🙌✨
Here she is making history by breaking all the stereotypes saying to the new generation music genres have no specific gender Women Empowerment Queen did this a hard complex choreography a dark music that mostly done by male idols cool loose conservative outfits that often only men wears !! Seriously this lady is setting an example making history by making a way to other girls to do so
She is not the first to do that. I want to inform you that Amber has done is still doing that in America creating music and still waering the outsifts she likes and feels comfortable on and she still has her beautiful short hair that i love.(boyish outfits and i have you that she has been in the music industry more than moonbyul.she debuted in 2012) They are queens!! Please support both of them!
No one cause the damm MV keeps freezing, for some reason others seems not to care about Viewing it! But oh no, HiP has exploded but not Solars or Byul’s. This is what confuses me about our fan base for those some.
![[문별] 부재 (Absence) Performance Video](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/NXnP06Ial08/mqdefault.jpg)
![[문별] 부재 (Absence) Performance Video](/img/tr.png)
![[Live สด] การออกรางวัลสลากกินแบ่งรัฐบาล งวดวันที่ 16 ธันวาคม 2567](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dNTiBBthKgQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Them: Who's your favorite duo?
Me: Moonbyul and Chair
Oh man🤣😂
True😂
any chair of moonbyul's is a throne now 👑
Moonbyul and Throne**
Don't let solar hear that hahaha
The fact the she took the risk of making a concept like this being a female idol and succeeded amazes me. Moonbyul is really breaking barriers and stereotypes. She pulled it of perfectly, the way that she projects while performing is one of my favorite things about her as a performer. I can really see her winning Artist of the Year and SOTY.
Couldn’t agree more! She has it all
she hasn't "succeeded" in the industry's eyes yet since she hasn't got many views or any wins yet so we have to keep fighting. Just because she pulled it off flawlessly isn't enough for most
Amber Tirbhowan yeah I know. We have a long way to go, I was talking about the fact that she did this concept and it didn’t turned out negative. I really enjoyed it and she did well.
Boss Moonbyul YESS
Couldn't have said it any better
Moonbyul deserves so much more, she's fantastic: she can rap, she can sing, she can dance, she writes songs, she creates chorographies, she is beautiful, she is funny, she is sweet and kind and she is strong. I admire Moonbyul very much, I'm proud of her, she works so hard and I love her songs. I'll always support her ♡
She takes photos too
Too many ppl are sleeping on her 😔
Thanks for putting my feelings into words
Yeah she so talented
When I heard people insulted this song for its style the first thing that came to my mind is that not all women need to be in the cute and cheezy concept to be amazing.
She really is the ultimate girl crush isn’t she
Yup, the fiinal boss sksksksk
Yyyeeeeesssssssss
Yupppp... 😉
Annika Arora yes she is
So true
Hwasa breakes beauty standards, Moonbyul breakes gender stereotypes, Wheein: whatever form it is, its all the same love, Solar breaks male-female idols norms and talking about female genital mutilation and
THIS IS MAMAMOO, unique, one and only
Thanks, i dont know English, just be little tolerant
@@bdaarmy9736 ... it's 'breaks' 😂
wheein break the gender norm of love by singing to goodbye that shows lgbt love on the mv
Right! damn how I forget?!
Solar be ripping shirts off
for those who said that this is a boy group-like concept, you're wrong.
this is moonbyul's concept.
It's more than just a concept for her....IT'S MOONBYUL!!
PERIODT! That...YOU ARE CORRECT
YAS
PERIODTTTTTT
periodt
Moonbyul's concept is so unique to be honest. I haven't seen any other female kpop idol do this and pull it off so so flawlessly. It's like she's made for this. I think that's also a reason why it isn't that popular, which is disheartening. Because this concept isn't a popular one. But we shouldn't give up! Let's keep on supporting her, Moonbyul deserves it!! 💙💙💙
Yes!! I’m so proud to say that she is the first female idol to do this kind of concept. She tried to break barriers and even though not many notice it there are probably female idols that really appreciate this because they might want to try it but since it’s a different concept/style they can’t. Seeing this is a improvement in Kpop for females.
I bet Byul-yi and Soyeon would get along GREAT! Imagine these two building a company together.
Nine million views is plenty 👀
@@chatsnoirblamo Not enough for me. She deserves so much more!
@@chatsnoirblamo not when compared to other K-pop mvs and the time it's been uploaded for though. 😔
i think this song speaks a lot about her role in mamamoo, and her personality in general. as said by the members of mamamoo, and other idols, moonbyul really knows how to take care of others. the lyrics tells us about how no matter life has become so dark, full of problems and worries, she won't be defeated by it and will shine for us and her members. she may worry a lot but she often put others above herself. and the song itself is breaking gender stereotypes in music in which we often (fans) see moonbyul do.
You put it beautifully moomoo!
shes literally the most handsome woman in girl groups
She's forever a living Barbie to me
@oreo and orion you are right ♥️♥️♥️♥️
I love her, she is so different from other idols.
I don’t think anyone can pull off a “rock” and “dark” concept as she can.
The song makes me want to run around from excitement :3
@@lioness6995 yass🤓🤓😎😎
I think she and Dami are both the most handsome. I can't choose lol. They are both so amazing.💗💕(I'm not trying to start fanwars) Also I didn't expect this song to be as amazing. I slept on Mamamoo and this song for so long. I'm ready to stan!💕💗💕💗💕
Rap:100%
Sing:100%
Dance:100%
Charisma:100%
Visual:100%
Song quality:100%
MV quality:100%
Everything in this comeback and to this Queen is 100%
Love And Support Moonbyul 100%
U forgot grease : 100%
So true tho
@@eli-uv6io stan the true queen
YG FAM Nahh 1000000000.000000000
I have heard this song before and like okay whatever but it just hit me in the soul and I'm so happy it is moonbyul
I don't think this song is "boyish". We just see a female idol breaking gender stereotypes and doing something that's unique
@j it has girl crush energy
@j please explain what is "masculine energy"
well said
it's not boyish but i dont know how wearing suits is breaking gender stereotypes. girls are allowed to wear suits. it is the double standard that guys cannot wear dresses that needs to be broken.
@@LittleB1RDY this isnt western society soooo false
In the song “HIP” there was something like “while you’re talking shit, I’ll go and write another album” written by Moonstar. And here she is with the new song, amazing visuals, perfect dance. She never stops working and improving her skills which inspires me so so much.
OMFG I FORGOT ABOUT THAT
I listen to Hip literally everyday so I was just WAITING
ʚ Strawberry Kiwi ɞ hahahah me too
Ksush Zolotareva I thought only Hwasa who contributed in lyrics in hip? Is Moonbyul also wrote? Because so far I know that only hwasa who wrote the lyric with kim do hoon and park woo sang
25beee ah really? I heard that Moon Byul always helps with writing lyrics so I thought like that) but anyway she’s very hard working:)
SOLAR NEVER DISAPPOINTS✓
MOONBYUL NEVER DISAPPOINTS✓
WHEE IN NEVER DISAPPOINTS✓
HWASA NEVER DISAPPOINTS✓
MAMAMOO NEVER DISAPPOINTS✓✓
Couldn't agree with you more🙌🖤❤💜💖🎶
Yasss
You're definitely right 💯🙌🏼
*Period.*
언니 진짜 해냈다.. 너무 사랑하고, 그냥 이 수만 댓글중에 하나 되고 싶어요, 같이 응원한 힘
moonbyul: * breath *
me: THIS IS TALENT, SEE HOW SHE IS A TRUE ARTIST. INCREDIBLE! BEAUTIFUL! PERFECT! * applauding wildly *
Same
Exactly me
Literary everyone
That's me
This is legit me lmao
Director: how many people you want to
attract?？
Moonbyul: YES
Girls?
Excuse me Moonbyul attracts everyone!
Not only girls..
I swear she’s like a magnet. Attracts everything in her way.
she's actually such eye candy
This is not a "manlish" song, THIS IS A SONG BY A WOMAN that expresses what she wants to express IN THE WAY SHE WANTS to express it.
She deserves respect and recognition for her talent, her braveness and the quality of her work.
Adore you, Moon Byul.
Could you explain "braveness" in that one please?
@@Shiroiek She is brave because she is doing what she likes without caring the stereotyped norms about what a woman "can" do, sing or wear.
She is always true to herself and authentic, and I am proud of her for that.
It gave me huge BoA and History vibes so I'm happy lol
Guys don't forget to vote for Moonbyul in Mwave pre voting ! 🌟
pls take down emoji it freezes views
1st time listening: this is a masterpiece.
2 nd time listening : yup definitely a masterpiece.
100 th time listening : this is legendary masterpiece.
This song is the most underrated solo song from among all members. It deserves more!!
Actually, she was the most underrated even by her agency. She gets confidence onlly this year when she saw how many people loved her solo album. Even her agency was surprised by her solo success.
@@mihailgavrishchiv7972 we can still show her some love before her birthday. Let's promote this song together with Aya and Dingga.
Exactly
@@michita7838 leggo
@@mihailgavrishchiv7972 really? How do you know that?
Stylist: how many looks you wanna serve?
Moonbyul: don't care, get me a cape, there must be a cape.
and make it handsome
i am not a Moomoo, but i can't believe this masterpiece only has 8M. All of the Mamamoo members are exceptionally beautiful and unique, but Moonbyul simply has the ability to hypnotize me every time I see her. I can't believe this is so underrated.
pd: she also hid my heterosexuality somewhere and now I can't find it
Thank you for appreciating our Moonstar! ♡
This happened to me from the very first second I saw her. Now I am a moomoo😁 The hypnotizing part, I mean🤭
Lmaooo
1人で頑張ってる時、めっちゃこの曲聴く
このテイストでまた曲出して欲しい…
ずっと待ってる…
❤
Them: What's your plan on Valentine's?
Me: Uhm imma stream Moonbyul's MV til dawn.
relatable my dude
@@TheCassMtz yup, makes my Valentine's day worth celebrating.
@@christy1127 Well a Happy Valentine's day to you!
@Blue Hazel just play the music video over and over
"I don't want to distinguish between men and women by the genre of music." That's what she said and she seems to be proving her brilliant thoughts by 'Eclipse'.
Please delete the emoji it's gonna freeze the view
@@betty1053 Thank you! I deleted the emoji (Now I also think that the emoji freezed the view)
@@betty1053 It doesn't do that, TH-cam just does that on its own because it wants to verify that all views are actual people and not bots. The best thing to do when streaming is engagement, so keep commenting and like the video, don't be scared about what you write, just don't spam.
@@AKAJAYGAY is that so???? If yes then thank you, cause like my friends ( who are Kpop fans and they stream a lot) told me so. So I never use emoji on every comeback they use oops
Betty Lâm It’s a common misconception, I get it though, TH-cam isn’t the best site when it comes to communicating specs. The view stutters and seemingly random deletion of comments can make some things seem bad. Happy streaming, all!
don't call her "oppa" guys she said doesn't like it, she wants to show how a woman can dance and wear what they want regardless of gender stereotypes, please don't misgender her - she is a QUEEN she is EMPRESS she is GODDESS
Amen
Yes!!!
Please delete emoji, they freeze vi3ws
Yes girl, i love you 💕
it's a lesbian thing ok it's not about gender, girls wish she was their oppa
REVOLUTION means Moonbyul. The song, concept, lyricism, choreography, edits, styling, behaviour and everything in between was Revolutionary. DECLARATION: Only Moonbyul can pull it off and she actually took it personally.
If you know how the kpop industry actually works, you know how DIFFERENT this is. As an artist and as an individual she should be praised for creating and delivering all of these. Even if they didn't in the past when it was first releasing, I hope someday soon she'll be recognized and hear the claps that she truly deserves for challenging the industry and becoming part of the wind that should hit it.
True
Lets make this 10M views
I know everyone says this about everyone in kpop but this time I'm serious -- she's doing what no one else is. I've never seen a female idol do this kind of song. She's not just taking a boy group ish concept, she's making her own concept. It's not feminine, but it also doesn't feel like there should be a male idol singing it. It's her song and you can tell, and no one else could do this song like her, male or female.
Carolina, masculinity and femininity defines itself depending on different countries and culture. I really like your comment to Moonbyul, but remember that it differs f rom culture to culture. So I wouldn't officially say that her music is masculine if its in her country. Sorry if this comment offended you in any way.
@@LuklioN44 it didnt offend me dw. And yeah I do know masculinity and femininity are very different, I’ve lived in four different cultures and the difference is really clear. But I was talking about k-pop, so I think it’s implied that that was the context I was talking about. This is probably the most masculine-leaning concept Ive seen a female idol go for. In other contexts I wouldnt say its super masculine, but in context, compared to any girl groups or female kpop artists Ive seen, yeah, its more masculine than usual.
I pointed this out specifically because its something that iterests me a lot. All my favorite kpop artists, male and female, are doing something that explicitly challenges the heavy gender norms in kpop. So I really like Taemin and Moonbyul, for example, and Id say a big part of why is that they’re doing things that aren’t conventionally gendered, in context. Out of context, Im a very involved member of the lgbt community and Im used to a lot more gender challenging than what kpop has to offer, trust me.
so true like gurl i didnt know how to use words to explain this U SAID IT ALL!! good job
femininity/masculinity exists in people' heads only. using these terms = supporting gender stereotypes. strike them out of your dictionary.
@@kateraspberry7634 So I do disagree with you. I've taken a lot of courses on gender studies and lgbt studies, and although that doesn't give me any authority on this subject, I do feel like I have some idea of what I'm talking about. So here’s what I think:
Gender norms and stereotypes are absolutely connected to terms like femininity and masculinity, but those terms have a function beyond that. A big part of the feminist movement and the lgbt rights movement is based on blurring the lines between gender expectations, and disconnecting sex and gender by defining sex as biological and gender as social, while gender norms are social expectations according to someone's gender.
Expecting a woman to be feminine is harmful. Femininity itself is not. I understand what you're saying about the word femininity being connected to "female" and therefore perpetuating gender stereotypes. I'm trying to find a way to phrase this in a clear way...
These words don't just exist in my head; they still describe relevant social things (just because something is socially constructed doesn't mean it isn't real; e.g. gender). The lgbt community has been based since the beginning on playing with gender. Drag is probably the best example. If you're lgbt you'll probably be familiar with words like butch and femme to describe lesbians who express gender differently, or bear and twink to describe gay men (femme is also a common word to describe straight men who express more femininity than is socially expected of them). Camp is something completely born out of the lgbt community that describes a theatrical expression of gender through fashion and makeup. These are all very, very important characteristics of the lgbt "wave" I guess you could call it, and I think it's fair to say that the lgbt movement has been heading gender revolutions for a while. These things are all based on femininity and masculinity, and specifically using them to do away with gender stereotypes and norms.
I understand what you mean about them contributing to gender norms. But for a very very long time now, they've actually been used to specifically combat these same gender norms, and to be honest that seems to be doing the most effective work up until now. They still describe socially relevant things, specifically *because* gender stereotypes still exist, and they can be and are being used to dismantle those existing connections between gender, sex, and social expectations. And recently femininity and masculinity have also started to blur together, which is also great. Harry Styles in a dress, for example. It’s made a lot of people (including Logan Paul, surprisingly) start questioning what exactly makes someone feminine or masculine, and if that correlates with their gender (it doesn’t). If we refused to acknowledge things like masculinity and femininity, first off, a lot of people (more than usual) would be calling us crazy and unrealistic. More importantly, we wouldn’t be able to play around with gender expectations in a way that has been continuously dismantling them, as we’ve been doing for decades.
This was way longer and less organised than I’d like it to be but it’s really early and I have work in a bit, so I’m not gonna go back and clean it up, but I hope it made sense anyway. You’re obviously allowed to disagree and have your own opinion
She know that we gonna be alone today, so this is our date today.
EXACTLY. She is our date today :)
Hey how did you know : )
Amy B hot date if i do say so myself
i just love how moonbyul breaks gender stereotypes. Byul isntt being boyish, she is just being herself.
nat natnat I’m hoping they would give her a short haircut one day
@@Otakuwonder98 As soon as byulie is comfortable with that, im all supportive haha
this is why she is my bias. i love her so much.
@Luz Maria Barradas Perez i know right?? I just hope she gets the attention and recognization she deserves.
Very much agree. We need more artist like moonbyul T^T telling people that people should be their true selves
Wayyy ahead of its time. I hope she does this concept again in the future ♡
Talent: Unquestionable
Visual: Stunning
Raps: Ultimate
Vocals: Amazing
Dance: Superior
Personality: Charming
Lyrics: Meaningful
Message: Powerful
Production: High Quality
Concept: Distinctive
Song: Unique
Overall: 💯♾
Moonbyul: Queen👑 🌙 ⭐️
Moonbyul : KING
i was thought that you'll end up with hotel: trivago IM SORRY-
Fact!
@@iamrealham8209 she is a girl
@@iamrealham8209 she's a queen. A queen isn't inferior to a king
Song: top
Performance: top
visual; top
mv: top
MOONBYUL: TOP
Listen To your heart YESSSS THIS IS A MOOD
😆😆
She can top anytime
This is the first comment. I cant stop smiling
Me: BOTTOM
This song is such a bop! Moonbyul showcasing her individuality and breaking gender norms for female kpop idols. The song is so addictive plus she has such a captivating persona that makes her stand out amongst the crowd of dancers. Respect to RBW for allowing their artist to shine:)
I think the same .......... I also feel that RBW knows its artists very well and knows what they may be capable of ... and with so many successes from Mamamo's background, I think that helped He would be given the opportunity to see how much he can get to shine, which we know and know will go far.
IM STILL HERE STREAMING THIS MASTERPIECE 🔥🔥🔥
YES!!!
So refreshing to see that the company didn’t pressure her to be half naked or to have a « sexy » choreo in order to make views... I’m so tired of female idols being told to be sexy in order to be strong. Thank you Moonbyul
I mean she cant rly do sexy shes flat af
@@ZAJETANAZWANIEEEE Curves are not the only thing that can make a woman sexy though?
Well that wouldn't fit the image she has in Mamamoo anyway so why would they enforce it
ZAJETANAZWANIEEEE just cause she doesn't go by your expectations and has more of a flat chest, doesn't mean she can't be sexy...
@@ZAJETANAZWANIEEEE MB is so sexy and attractive for me, as a /straight/ girl. Sexiness is something more mental that physical.
i don’t know how to explain but..
honestly this queen has an energy of a WHOLE BOY GROUP ????
I get it, she´s azome
THAT BIG DICK ENERGY
ikrrr. this can literally be a boyband song.
moonstar did that. asdfghjkl
Nah fam, she just has her own Moonstar energy
Her name explain it all *moon+star energy*
I like how she took the inspiration of her favorite group TVXQ to gain confidence to make something like this. You can really tell how much she loved TVXQ if she goes as far as to do this kind of concept. You can really feel her confidence in this music video and the way she portrays it shows that she is not afraid of anything. She has grown so much from the shy conservative hamster we all used to know. *I love it. I love her. I admire her. She is literally one of the best soloist of this year. This is absolutely great.*
Wah... She also a big fan of TVXQ?? I'm a new fan of her so I just know now. I'm an EXO-L so... I think she will have a good relationship with Xiumin hshshsh
@@amaliaprast2112 people say Byul and Xiumin look very similar.
Amalia Prast she loves them a LOT she’s covered their songs a lot before in mmm concerts she does a tvxq medley as a solo during their concerts its so good!
Wait is that it? I thought I saw it somewhere
@@amelie7318 wahh thank you for the information^^ I just watched it and wow! She performed the song really well ´∇`
Byul you are loved
Fun fact : MAMAMOO is the one of the most talented people in the world who deserve nothing more than the utmost respect and just love .
Stan talent .
Stan handsome gender stereotype breaking queen , Moonbyul .
Stan does what ever she wants and is an monarch , Yongsun .
Stan super talented artistic queen , Wheein .
Stan confident drop-dead gorgeous beauty standards breaking queen , Hwasa .
MAMAMOO DESERVES HIGHER THAN BP AND BTS MAMAMOO IS MORE TALENTOUS AND TALENT SHOULD BE EQUAL TO POPULAIRTY >:( YES MAMAMOO IS MORE TALENTOUS ARMY/BLINK, THE TRUE HURTS U
@@quememirasfeo No, don't bring down other groups to make mamamoo look better. That's not how us moomoos act, and it makes us look bad
@@imachubbygod1121 Should I act to any specific form if I´m a fan? Then the toxic is me, wow...
@@quememirasfeo Yes you should, all idols work hard so to say that one group deserves more than another would be ignoring the other one's hard work. BTS and black pink made it because they released bops that a lot of people liked. To say that Mamamoo deserves to be on top on them would discard all that BTS and Blackpink did. So basically, just respect other groups' rankings and don't hate on other groups unless they did something to receive hate
@@quememirasfeo don't bring other groups down,to make mmm better,moomoos aren't like this,and we don't like fan wars
Not even 10M views.
This deserves the whole world
we're trying to get 10M views by byul's birthday this month but I don't think it's going to happen tbh 😭
@@T355V same...
@@T355V I'm quite stressed about how slowly the numbers are increasing, I really hope we can make it, Byul deserves to get a lot of views as much as the others :/
@@yazmins.2157 I know... seeing how slowly we're going makes me so disappointed. It also makes me sad because Byul will also never say if she's disappointed in us...
@@T355V exactly. All she says is that she's happy cuz she got to make the music she likes and she chose this concept but i'm pretty sure she would've been happier if we gave her a win for eclipse. Some moos didn't even stre@m the song. Sigh
Shout out to all the moos that str3aming hard, also get this to 10M pls she deserves more than that
LEGGOOO
The vi3w is barely increasing tho
@@hwasaismamamoosmaknae2400 yep sadly..
Lesgoo
Preach fellow radish, preach!
내 입덕곡~~~ 뮤비 올만에 또 보니까 넘 멋지고 또 반하네❤
Moonbyul said in an interview:
“If there is a Moonstar to protect you, there will also be a Monster to devour you”
Yeah she definitely devoured us with this MV 🔥
Syd where would she devour me tho? 👀👀
😍
moonbyul pls choke me Looking at your username, I think she’ll grant your wish instead lol
@@overthrowthegovernment7215 maybe MMTG from SBS
@@overthrowthegovernment7215 hahaha I know where I want her to devour me 👀
Moomoos, Don't get disheartened. Our Moonstar is already shinning in our hearts. She is already ruling our hearts since her debut days. And she will continue to do so. Mamamoo as a group is itself a winner and I am pretty sure that We Moomoos will continue to support them even after. All we can do is give our love and respect to these amazing and gorgeous queens. Cause they deserve the whole world. Moonbyul with her ideology has already shattered the gender stereotypes and that's what I call a WINNER .
what happened
@@nikkinikki9029 i guess something wrong with TH-cam. This should be get at least 1 mil views but TH-cam kept freezing ( i think for about 9 hours?) And basically sobataged this
@@udontknowmyname8714 yes, that's what happened.
because we didn't hit 1 million/2 million views is she still going to be able to get a win? I dont want to let her down when her other members all got wins
@@luthientinuviel101 We can't undo that. But we can still give our unconditional support!
girls: girl group
boys: boy group
moonbyul: moonbyul
moonbyul says screw labelling
moonbyul: chair
so is like tomboyish?
just asking cuz' i just found them
THE standard, cheers !!
Hotel:Trivago :)
I wish I spoke enough Korean to tell Byul JUST HOW MUCH this song means to me on a personal level.
Currently teaching my self the lyrics thru form of Romaji. 🔥🔥🔥
She can sing
She can rap
She dances
This girl is perfect👌
WOMAN
And she's a such visual
She can act
She can compose
She can create choreo
Also 😉
I don't consider myself a moomoo, but I admire them. They look so genuine in an industry that seems kinda fake. I know that they've been somehow "dismissed" and came from a company that is not big, but they have still managed to do their best and they're succeeding. I hope their hard work can be recognized internationally.
What do you mean vanished? They're still together right?
Its the same thing especially from a group with small company. They always get dismissed and considered having less chance to succeed. It doesn't help that those from big company sometimes limits their success too. For me Mamamoo is one of kpop group that follows their own style rather than try to fit the stereotype. There's Hwasa not caring about how knetz bashed her body figure, Moonbyul dressing her comfiest clothes and not forcing herself to dress revealing (like some unwilling kpop gg had too). I started liking them because how genuine they are honestly
@Blinkeu FOREVER they have said that, in some award ceremonies they have been treated like that :/
@Blinkeu FOREVER I used the word dismissed because I remember how non-fan knetz refuse to believe bts won daesang in 2016 and going so far as to say they cheated. Their denial is because bts is from a small company and its impossible for them to beat the top 3 company. Yes it took them 2 years to get recognition but the hate they got ever since they debuted had never lessened. Which why you see army being so protective when someone says something about them. I'm just so glad Mamamoo isn't getting too much hate lately because they are literally my favourite and most respected girl group ever. I can't bear to see the same thing happening to them
Moonbyul's relationship with the chair is a better love story than Twilight.
PERIOD
221292% agree!!!!
100% cierto
Others : it's BoY GRouP coNcePT
Me : it's Dreamcatcher concept
Right answer : It's Moonbyul slaying
Is no one really realizing this is the first time in kpop history where a woman kpop idol has released and a performed a song with a masculine choreo LIKE this? Like ya there were girl groups that went hard, but a choreo like this? Never. I’ve been in this kpop ting since I was a little girl, and never have I seen a choreography like this performed by a female idol. I’ve been waiting for something like this :)
I thought Amber is kinda masculine, too. Global Icon, D-UNIT, too. Maybe you're too new for K-Pop.
edit: I love Moonbyul, tho! ❤️
Yeak Amber has kind of a masculine look but this concept???? Never done before by a woman, this is clearly a bg mv but it's Moonbyul! Others have done strong or neutral concepts but she 😍
@@BeaFullbuster you re right this kind of concept is unique for a woman to do, its similar to 2012 concepts used by male groups i havent seen a girl doing this, yes the girlcrush or the "heavy hiphop" concept but not like this.
only my HanPretty Byulie can do this!
@@ashley-vs1dn BOA is BOSS LADY!! She one of my favorite soloist but i ve never saw her do this kinda concept(like very dark with some rock and electronic) even tho her works is diverse she did sexy dark concept or electronic dark concept .
When Moonbyul said "It's okay if you're single for Valentine's Day because you have me" SHE WASN'T LYING OMG THIS IS PERFECTION
C'est tellement ça 😂
Oh si rare de voir des commentaires fr 😀
@@mel9178 ahah on est beaucoup de moomoo français mais pas assez à commenter sur YT 😂
She is a whole group by herself singing, rapping and dancing perfectly who is doing it like her
KTH VANTE
pls take down emoji it freezes views
Please take off the emojis they freeze the views
@@sowhat5399 ?the emoji hv problem?
@@sowhat5399 okay sorry
888 like
why is Moonbyul so underrated, she is a complete artist, very talented, she and mamamoo deserve more recognition with all the members
I think Moonbyul was the first female artist who did this kind of genre for her music. Respect you Moonstar. You are the star that protect us
She's the female version of David Bowie.
Yess
Vocal-check
Rap-check
Visual-check
Dance-check
Queen?? -check
I LOVE U MOONBYUL♡´･ᴗ･`♡
Making us choke with her gorgeousness-check🙂
She is just perfect
This is not a boyish concept not a boy group mv not a male choreography this is MOONBYUL herself it’s not a concept No this is a side of MoonByul
I'm so mad choreos and songs this good are always limited to boy groups to the point that it just drags down the style. Like...I've genuinely stopped enjoying BG songs because I keep thinking about that. Her voice REALLY suits this!!
Exactly, if She wants to do a certain style, that's Her, it isn't due to a pressure from the market, She gets and She does what She wants to do because it's Her artistic expression.
I hope more girl groups do have things like this, heck, I hope more boy groups have things like this, where they are not limited by the industry's standard or default options if they want to go out of the norm. Moonbyul should show Moonbyul, so that's what She does. And that's what I absolutely love about Her, and Mamamoo in general. They also don't always try to go out of the norm if they don't want to, if there's something they already like, then they'll do that, no need for pressure from one side to tell you to go out of the norm, again, they just do what they want and what they like, and that's what I love about them.
I just love your comment. And yes this is a side of Moonbyul that I think most aren't ready to see yet.
IDK WHAT'S WRONG WITH ME, BUT I REALLY LOVE MOONBYUL NOT ONLY BECAUSE OF HER PERSONALITY BUT ALSO BECAUSE OF HER TALENT AS AN ARTIST. NOT JUST A KPOP GIRL GROUP RAPPER BUT AS AN ARTIST. ILY MOONSTAR 💕
Gosh this is so me. I literally watched every yt video that she's in it
@@janinemarbella9052 Yeah. The more u know her, the more u deep in love with her.
My bias since 2015. She being true to herself since debut until now make me stay as her stan forever
VISUALS LYRICS OUTIFIT EVERYTHING IS SO LIT
THE WAY SHE PULLED SUCH A DARK CONCEPT
THE AURA THIS LADY SPEARS IS NO JOKE
Song: *On point!*
Dance: *ON POINT!!!*
Visual: *oN pOiNt!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!*
There is literally nothing she can’t do. Love you Moonbyul and love you MAMAMOO!
Yeah !!! Our Moonstar !!
@@tobotobi6991. wharf
the world was really not ready for this. this defies every gender norm and stereotype so people were not here for this. but, man. this is one of the best release in 2020
Interesting, if it would be released in US, could it be different, could it get more recognition or it wouldbe the same.
I'm still here, because I know that this song deserves to reach 10M and more 🫶
You are right
Yes~~This deserves
And whoever created Moonbyul outfits deserve a raise immediately
If I got the right info, she actually went out and bought them herself! I swear to god she’s perfect. No wonder everyone loves her
Olivia Kaldus omfg are you serious!!? That’s even better and yess I am obsessed with her dude
Maybe she found it on internet
🥵🥵🥵
she chose all of her outfits for this to make sure she felt comfortable!
If this was a song fr a boy group it would have gained much success & just bcuz a female idol decided to break the stereotype concept ppl r not supporting her ! In my opinion she slayed the song & the concept ! Much respect & appreciation is needed
We will support her forever
I agree except I feel like my eyes hurt after watching this. Personally was hard to keep up with
@@rachael3946 that's bcuz she slayed hard !
Wait what's the stereotype?
@@sourwatermelon " feminine " most girl groups go fr the cute or the sexy but not as such moonbyul's one which is close to boy band thing ! I hope u got me
I'm not gonna get tired of saying this: "this was the best concept ever but y'all weren't ready for her"
PERIOD
👏🏼EX👏🏼AC👏🏼TLY👏🏼 YES
I'm totally new to the kpop world and after several years listening western music, i've NEVER saw a concept like this
@@LeonatorHastaMorir SAME IKK
This song gives me goosebumps... simply amazing
PERIOD
She is rapper, singer, lyricist, performer,. She can do everything!!!
Because of Moonbyul I know just because I’m a woman, I don’t have to be what the world sees as “feminine.” I can dress and act however I want. Thank you Moonbyul.
Yes, moonbyul is changing the world 🔥
Or at least korea
In today's insta live moonbyul said she is happy with Eclipse's result and told us not to worry about the malicious comments...byul is always so sweet and appreciative to her fans...almost never have i seen her expressing disappointment? it's always her who comforts us. have you realized, she is really the moonstar who protects us from the darkness just as the lyrics have said^^
underrated comment 😭😌
@@T355V ^^wanna make sure everyone realizes that moonbyul is not just a cool girl who turns everyone gay, but she is a real angel
@@lac_rosa7439 exactly so right you got the point she is a real angel
What malicious comments? Just curious...
@@mizuko2001 I think she was talking about malicious comments in general (maybe especially the recent controversies with yongsun's solo outfits, but not limited to these). She was saying the trend nowadays in our society is to respect individuality and not to conform to one single standard. I think she was trying to say we should not worry too much bc mamamoo has a clear attitude in this
THE WHOLE SONG COULD BE GIVEN TO A GROUP BECAUSE OF HOW LIT AND COMPLICATED AND PERFECT IT IS WITH ALL THE DIFFERENT ROLES SHE DID HERSELF ALONE:
RAP
VOCALS
VISUALS
DANCE
♥️♥️♥️♥️
Yeah !!! Our Moonstar !!
요즘같은세상 사랑사랑 타령하는 노랫말 보다 인상쓰지말고 웃으면살자는 작사작곡 넘넘좋아요. 넘넘좋아요 티비에서보고싶어요 ^^
Here after watching "Spit It Out". Mamamoo deserves more than this.
Reu Jean Bacabac agreee! And same
Agreeee especially Moonbyul, she is really underrated, this is a bop but seems not a lot of people recognize and appreciate it.
Z Kayla it's literally my favorite song! Let's stream Eclipse!
This actually deserved a lot more😔😔
I know that everyone is saying this but.... Moonbyul is...
One of the rarest kpop artist in the industry who advocate gender neutrality in her music. She's the few people in the industry whose brave enough to try new things and genre that the society tells her that is not fit for a woman to do but MOONBYUL proved it wrong! Eclipse might didn't win but I know moomoos know that this song is rare and you will barely see it on other female artist.
Hidden Gem and extraordinary...
@@citrakumala7178 exactly
This is so true
i just want to say thank you to everyone who’s strming to get this to 10million before her birthday. let’s give moonbyul the recognition that she deserves so much!
Let's stream
let's do our best!
doing our best, she deserves it.
Let's do it 🔥🔥
We still have days
문별이 최고야 두말할 것 없이 이 여자 너무 좋아 노래 볼 때마다 처음 보는 느낌이야
How many people would you turn gay on Valentine's Day?
Moonbyul : *yes*
Not if you're a boy :D
Fortunately, i dont have a boyfriend. I am too busy streaming today xD
Wyvern Swiftwing but boys already have a hard time defending against Ricardo Milos 😂
@@kosaken1207 lol who's that
😅
Wyvern Swiftwing search it up, and you’ll wonder how YT kept it up 😏
Other people: Happy Valentine!
Moomoos: HAPPY MOONBYUL'S 2ND SOLO ALBUM ECLIPSE!
Gogobebe era: Really, white hair fits Byul with perfection.
Hip era: actually, scratch that, purple/gray is totally her color!
Eclipse: DAMN GIRL! I CAN'T DECIDE ANYMORE!
Big mood, Moonbyullie is amazing
She shines no matter what
yes i am era was the best for her I think
Let us not forget about decalcomanie byul coz that hit hard
Everyone agrees that moonbyul is the girl crush
After reading the comments, i think the huge reason why the vi3ws are slow is because most of moomoos died in the middle of the video. Byul-ah... You are too COOL in here, how do you want us to survive?? 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
Ok. Joke aside. Come one moos!! We can do it!! 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
But for real I can't finish the video😭 the badassery is far too much
I'm not giving up on this masterpiece, I'm sharing it everywhere! (but yes actually she kill half of the fandom lol)
I just want someone with a popular comment in this section to mention the fact in their comment by editing that for a view to count u need to watch at least 30 seconds so one just has to watch 35 seconds or so for streaming. I think some r watching the whole vid while others r just continuously skipping.
@@potathoe2608 why would anyone skip?
@@amazonz8590 skip as in I mean fast forwarding it to get more views in less time
I will never forgive Korea for not giving Moonbyul the attention that she deserves neither the whole world
Also the Radish fandom who did not str33m the song enough
geneveve rrr yes but not enough for me if Moonbyul was American Korean people would appreciate her more she didn't get no 1 on melon
i will never forgive the japanese !!!!!! ( okay sorry- )
This should be a crime
Imagine the day they're no longer underatted and the new moomoo found out about their old stuffs wondering why didn't they stan them sooner, atleast that's how i felt 😂
i know right...
To be honest, this concept is the coolest thing I’ve ever seen and being done by Moonbyul?! Thank you queen
No emojis
@@user-hh8vj2pj8x girl-
really slayed this one, it's too bad it's too underappreciated.
did you know that moonbyul writes her lyrics without specifying male or female pronouns so everyone can relate to her songs
I didn't know :o
A line of hers in the 'Passion Flower' stage was "I love you my boy!", but I can't say about the rest since I don't know korean
@@honeybeemoo she said herself that she keeps her lyrics gender-neutral in her own radio show😬
@@smile-sq7pt Maybe I didn't watch that episode. I have studies so I usually can't watch the full episodes, I mostly watch some parts. Can you give me a link for this particular one or mention which one it was?
@@smile-sq7pt Also, I just pointed out an instance where this didn't happen. 'Passion Flower' was during their rookie days, and it was an added verse in a cover. Maybe Moonbyul meant for her own songs, then this is probably true
I really wish this mv blows up. She deserves all the attention and praises in the world. I want her to win at least once on music show. I want her to be the living proof that ‘boyish’ concept sells too (not that she hasn’t proved that already). This can be a game changer for future gg gens.
THISSS
Guys I just want to share this info in a popular comment, please download idol champ and vote for moonbyul in MV promotions coz if she gets no. 1 there will be:
1⃣ 1 million impressions of the promotion banner in the IDOLCHAMP app
2⃣ U Tube Official M/V Play & Promote on 120,000 Computer launch screens in 1,650 internet cafes nationwide in Korea
She’s no. 2 right now n lagging behind dream chaser but if all of us can give her a vote each day I’m sure we can turn the tables around :(
@@arctic_corner have you made an actual comment to the video or just peoples comments?
Sophia Man so do we try to get her to no 1? To be honest I’m a little bit confused. Do we want her at no 1? If so I can download the app
Harry Bird i left this at a few peoples comments coz it’s hard to make a lot of people see it if I put an actual comment
"If you like the group, you like the whole group instead of just one member". - Hwasa 👑💕 so pls moos support their solos too... Equally ☺️👍🏻
LOUDEEEER
LOUDER BBY:(
I kinda do be missing this era. I lowkey wanna hear songs like this hardcore from her again. But whatever your creative mind wanna create Byul I'm all here for it ❤️
she's not gonna repeat a concept that even her members didn't like.
Byul literally said: These moos are single af that I'm gonna release the best solo comeback so they're not lonely this valentines
Who's here after solar's spit it out? Queens, indeed.
Me 👋
Streaming everyone's solos :3
me 🙋🏻♀️
Me! Me! 🙋♀️
ME
This song still hits me hard, sad because it didn't get the attention it deserves :(
same 😭
Yeah.. We cannot force them though because we have our own preference. But then, let's keep stream this video ang Solar's Spit it Out. 💜
Its because it not catchy
Although I loved this song but people will forget about this song sooner
I afraid she won’t have nominating at the end of the years which other three members esp solar and hwasa may have more than one nominations :(
@@zkayla9648 So true but didn't hwasa got her solo twit?
i saw a director reaction video of this. and i also think its really clever on what moonbyul's team did around 1:06 - 1:10 . notice how the proportions of the vid widens vertically and then restricts back to the original. to a casual viewer its easy to miss that, but when its pointed out to you, its visually pleasing and amazing to incorporate it with the beat drop.
I'm living for everything about this comeback. Her look is always on point. THAT BROWN SUIT IS A WHOLE YES. Her voice and her bars and her rapping are a whole yes. Her passion is a yes. The visuals is a yes. The concept is a yes. HER CHOREO IS A WHOLE YES. We need to stress about how moon was given choreo that isn't the typical female idol choreo. Then again moon's style is so unique is rivals male idols at this point.
ALSO MOONBYUL STOP IT!! My top male idols are bts. MOONBYUL IM SUPPOSED TO BE LOYAL TO MY BOYS TOO. Rm gonna get mad😭 Mamamoo are definitely my top gg WITH rv and twice following after them. No girlcrush has ever done things like moon unless u count amber❤️ amber is my beautiful llama. But again to moonbyul, she dresses (even on her free time) very casual,always cleanly well put but not in tight skirts and such. Her androgenous style is so natural, the way she has on suits to her feminine points like the bold makeup, hairstyles and jewelry. It all balances who and how she is. She is definitely my ult gcrush.
Completely unrelated, but at this point I'm completely sure any bts Stan who gets out of just bts and ventures into kpop likes mamamoo. I mean although I started from mamamoo, shit never seen many of a combination more than armymoos. Guess who've seen talent once don't settle for anything less
Hey-HO im armymoo tooo, and i adore amber so much too 😄 , lets give more love for them 💜💚
All of that... HARD YES. It’s flawless. I don’t know how to express how I’m impressed I am with Moon, who just bulldozed through the Kpop mold. Mamamoo was already fighting the good fight, but this is... sublime. I don’t even have the words. 😩🙌✨
I’m an armymoo ^_^
@@majabrakas8241 @laio laio hence proves my earlier point?
Here she is making history by breaking all the stereotypes saying to the new generation music genres have no specific gender Women Empowerment Queen did this a hard complex choreography a dark music that mostly done by male idols cool loose conservative outfits that often only men wears !!
Seriously this lady is setting an example making history by making a way to other girls to do so
She is not the first to do that. I want to inform you that Amber has done is still doing that in America creating music and still waering the outsifts she likes and feels comfortable on and she still has her beautiful short hair that i love.(boyish outfits and i have you that she has been in the music industry more than moonbyul.she debuted in 2012)
They are queens!! Please support both of them!
She's not just a girl crush. Please support her music as well, she deserves the recognition for her solo's too.
Yepp
Real
True
She's literally the BEST!
mmm isnt really a girl crush concept tho, and moon is def not either
문벼리 미모 미쳐버렸고, 뮤비 느낌 돌아버렸고, 카리스마 미쳐버렸고, 춤선 돌아버렸고..가사 왜이렇게 위로되나요...♡♡♡달 달 무슨 달 너를 지킬 Moonstar~노래들으면서 울컥하는 나 정상인가요ㅠㅠ
How many international fans here to support Moonbyul ????⬇️
wish I could like this twice
Portugal
Yo
No one cause the damm MV keeps freezing, for some reason others seems not to care about Viewing it! But oh no, HiP has exploded but not Solars or Byul’s. This is what confuses me about our fan base for those some.
China!
And that, ladies and gentlemen, is how I started liking women.
yup, same. I don't think it was specifically this song but it was Moonbyul. On second thought I think it was her voice in Egotistic that made me fall.
BWHAHAHAHA THIS IS ICONIC
I feel you .....😤
@@fae91 same LOL
Please help streaming for her birthday :(
Byul's a badass that isn't afraid to be herself. I stan.
I never thought I could see you here but nonetheless I'm happy and totally agree with you
Omg you're here. I never expected to find you in a kpop section xD
I thought you were the real Just Some Guy With a Moustache lol
She is from other world
Her personality absoluetly makes my heart melt
WINNER OF SECOND WORLD OUR MAIN VOCALIST