'Look don't make me state what my initial thoughts were, because that's of such little importance. Of course you have a working theory as you always do when you do something. But it would be utterly stupid to then superimpose that upon other people's perceptions. Each person should experience it the way they feel. And that's very important for me, the idea that you can never understand a film like this. It isn't even about understanding. It's about experiencing it emotionally... It's like with music. ' Brilliant film. Brilliant director. ❤
wow, the mood is really intense in this sitting of the ledendary trio. Like they are being kept as hostages and calmly awaiting interogation LOL . Shyness at a very swedish level (I know I live there)
Så attraktiv hon var, Bibi Andersson. Och så ung Ingmar Bergman verkar fortfarande. Men bara femtontalet år senare när han filmade Fanny och Alexander så var han en gammal gubbe. Och ännu mer genial.
13:55 He hated Godard as much as i did. That s so relatable. They make you watch his movies in film school and they treat him as the Michael Jordan/ Napoleon of filmmakers...he did nothing but bore the fuck out of me.
godard is a pretentious mf....but can't deny the fact he is one of the most influential filmmaker of 20th century....he really break the rules like nobody has ever did or nobody will ever
@@MarcusLangbart yes, it’s obvious. She has a Norwegian rhythm in her speech and mixes both Norwegian and Swedish words freely throughout. In movies though, she speaks pure Swedish.
funny how defensive he gets on the Godard question, as he was chasing him through the 60s with persona, shame, and the touch, very godardian works. It is not hard to say they're both giants now but it is an unquestionable influence in those Bergman works, they had a restless experimental energy unlike his usual style.
I honestly doubt Godard was an influence on anything Bergman did, especially consciously. He says in this interview that he dislikes Godard’s work, but that doesn’t fully do it justice. Bergman absolutely hated Jean luc Godard. I genuinely don’t know if I’ve ever seen a respected film director say more scathing things about another respected film director than Bergman did about Godard. He loathed the guy. I doubt he had any admiration for his work, or felt any desire to replicate what he did in the slightest.
“I've never gotten anything out of his movies. They have felt constructed, faux intellectual and completely dead. Cinematographically uninteresting and infinitely boring” - Ingmar Bergman talking about his feelings toward Jean Luc Godard
@@francesca1769 i mean… yes. Im not personally a big fan of Godards work but I recognize that he is literally one of the most influential filmmakers of all time. From Tarantino to Wes Anderson to Martin Scorsese, as well as countless others have been directly influenced by his work and speak very highly of him.
@@ianbeach23 I agree, tho I don´t like Godard as a person and I find it kind of funny when another director mocks him. He is a great director anyways, but I only like the works of Godard when Anna Karina is in them (except for vivre sa vie). Sorry if there is any mistake, English is not my first language.
![Liv Ullmann on Persona (50th Anniversary Screening) | Full Q&A [HD] | Coolidge Corner Theatre](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XmvBBfgq2l8/mqdefault.jpg)
'Look don't make me state what my initial thoughts were, because that's of such little importance. Of course you have a working theory as you always do when you do something. But it would be utterly stupid to then superimpose that upon other people's perceptions. Each person should experience it the way they feel. And that's very important for me, the idea that you can never understand a film like this. It isn't even about understanding. It's about experiencing it emotionally... It's like with music. '
Brilliant film. Brilliant director. ❤
People learn how to live by observing others. It's not morally reprehensible or crazy. Everyone does it, consciously or not.
Beautiful Liv ❤️
He fffff her AND Bibi AND Harriet AND many many more...
@@markonahtigal1927 And? What's your point?
Gosh. What an interview! Better call it a cinema lesson
Happy this was posted, great perspectives from those involved on an absolute classic film
wow, the mood is really intense in this sitting of the ledendary trio. Like they are being kept as hostages and calmly awaiting interogation LOL . Shyness at a very swedish level (I know I live there)
At 5:35 Liv Ullmann was at the full flower of her beauty. What a face, not like anyone else.
An extraordinary beauty.
Thank you for sharing! I m delighted with the possibility to see this interview!
Så attraktiv hon var, Bibi Andersson. Och så ung Ingmar Bergman verkar fortfarande. Men bara femtontalet år senare när han filmade Fanny och Alexander så var han en gammal gubbe. Och ännu mer genial.
Bergman var närmare 50 här.
Man får väl säga att han var ganska stilig på den tiden.
Greatest movie ever: PERSONA
Thank you for this
Bergman is so true and so progressive as an artist and a person...
thanks for uploading the video Paolo!
fantastic interview oooooof
1:53 Bergman and Antonioni both died on 30 july 2007
John Adams and Thomas Jefferson died on the same day as well. 50th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence.
13:55
He hated Godard as much as i did.
That s so relatable. They make you watch his movies in film school and they treat him as the Michael Jordan/ Napoleon of filmmakers...he did nothing but bore the fuck out of me.
🤣🤣🤣 funny comment and I agree
Yep soulless shit
godard is a pretentious mf....but can't deny the fact he is one of the most influential filmmaker of 20th century....he really break the rules like nobody has ever did or nobody will ever
He was all fucking style, very little if any substance.
originally Bergman stan, and Godard hater, I've learnt that you can appreciate both.
Jeg elsker Liv Ullmanns “svorsk” ☺️☺️ Så søt
does her norwegian accent is evident for you? 1) here in the interview 2) in the movies? I can't tell sorry
@@MarcusLangbart yes, it’s obvious. She has a Norwegian rhythm in her speech and mixes both Norwegian and Swedish words freely throughout. In movies though, she speaks pure Swedish.
@@vikingsailorboy thanks. Yes I can hear the typical norwegian melodical up and down here!
@@vikingsailorboy Nja, hon pratar smånorska i hela Utvandrarsviten.
13:51
2:30 and he admires The Saint TV programme. Robert Bresson liked For Your Eyes Only. That's a lot of highbrow Roger Moore love.
Bibi Anderson ciddi ve soğuk, Liv Ulmann tam tersine güleryüzlü ve sıcak.
thanks
👍
The subtitles are not beyond reproach here
❤ bibi qui mrt le doigt dans sa bouche et liv qui caresse son oreille ❤ aie aïe je vais encore rêver d' elles cette nuit
13:15
🙌💖🙌
funny how defensive he gets on the Godard question, as he was chasing him through the 60s with persona, shame, and the touch, very godardian works. It is not hard to say they're both giants now but it is an unquestionable influence in those Bergman works, they had a restless experimental energy unlike his usual style.
I honestly doubt Godard was an influence on anything Bergman did, especially consciously.
He says in this interview that he dislikes Godard’s work, but that doesn’t fully do it justice. Bergman absolutely hated Jean luc Godard. I genuinely don’t know if I’ve ever seen a respected film director say more scathing things about another respected film director than Bergman did about Godard. He loathed the guy. I doubt he had any admiration for his work, or felt any desire to replicate what he did in the slightest.
“I've never gotten anything out of his movies. They have felt constructed, faux intellectual and completely dead. Cinematographically uninteresting and infinitely boring”
- Ingmar Bergman talking about his feelings toward Jean Luc Godard
@@ianbeach23 I wonder if is there any director that doesnt hate or hated Godard.
@@francesca1769 i mean… yes. Im not personally a big fan of Godards work but I recognize that he is literally one of the most influential filmmakers of all time. From Tarantino to Wes Anderson to Martin Scorsese, as well as countless others have been directly influenced by his work and speak very highly of him.
@@ianbeach23 I agree, tho I don´t like Godard as a person and I find it kind of funny when another director mocks him. He is a great director anyways, but I only like the works of Godard when Anna Karina is in them (except for vivre sa vie).
Sorry if there is any mistake, English is not my first language.