Tarkus is a masterpice, it has even been played by symphonic orchestras as a piece of Classical music. You should search TH-cam for the Orchestral versions by young Japanese conductors.
I was an early fan of E L P, following Greg Lake from King Crimson. I knew that ELP had something special but when I first heard TARKUS upon its release my mind was blown. I never knew such sonic vistas were possible. The complexity of composition and body of sound coming from just 3 master musicians just blew my mind. As some other comment noted: you have surely just chosen to jump into the deep end of the pool.
Great reaction. I like your open minded approach. This track was a real show stopper when they played live, just the three of them. Greg Lake had one of the best voices in rock and this track also shows his great bass and lead guitar skills. Palmer's drumming is always brilliant and the keyboards still sound great.
Never thought I would ever connect with people in this generation who's playing music that I've been listening to for the past few decades, this is Awesome!!
Wow, I can't believe you did this song. When I was a little boy, early 70s, my uncle was very much into music and he played this for me. I remember listening to this on his reel to reel and just being completely spellbound watching the reels spin, and listening to this music that didn't sound like anything I had ever heard before. It was a key moment in introducing me to music at an early age...like 6-8yrs old. :)
You know listening to this kind of music is like watching a movie. I used to entertain at my home. I'd invite friends, cook a great meal, dim the lights, serve drinks, and we'd share music. Everybody would bring a new CD. Great times!
Good morning Cynthia. To listen to Tarkus as your first ELP track is a brave choice ! Well done for seeing it through. I will allow others to suggest alternative tracks by them which would generally be considered more accessible. Best regards, Cambrian.
Just 3 guys are making all this music, and I saw them do it beautifully in concert (actually thrice during the 70s)... Even more than Yes, ELP experiments with "transitions" (time signature changes, which is one of three hallmarks of prog-rock), so the listener needs to be patient, and let the track play out. Thanx for trying them!
You jumped right in with this one. ELP has always been one of my favorite bands. This song being my favorite song. Give it a listen a few times on your own and you will come to enjoy its absolute brilliance. Love your channel!!!!
Wow Cynthia, you've gone straight after the masterpieces of prog rock. You still have many wonderful pieces of music ahead. I get you love the more ethereal stuff. Wait to hear Hatfield and the North.
haha definitely the deep end of the pool here. The great thing about these epic songs is that the more familiar they become they greater they sound and feel. However, an easier entry to ELP would be 'From The Beginning', or Lucky Man.
In an incredible and unusual way, with much joy and nostalgia, those of us who are over 58 years old see reflected in the reactions of these beautiful and young people those feelings that these beautiful works produced in our time. Feelings that did not include surprise, because at that time this was what was expected and demanded. Complexity, beauty and excellence, often due to simple habit or habit. Those musicians offered things that except for a few very few exceptions emulated or continued. Will young people also have fun watching our reaction to some more modern or current compositions?
ELP is somehow in a category of its own within Prog Rock. Due to the line-up, the music is quite keyboard-heavy. I used to play keyboards in a rock band, that's why I like that. But I also find the drums interesting, which at ELP more than in any other band are not only used as a rhythm instrument but are an essential part of the composition. ELP also made very diverse music. "Lucky Man" for example is a very gentle, melancholy song, with "The Three Fates" the keys fly around your ears, "The Sheriff" is more of a fun song. Another "big song" from ELP "Karn Evil 9" (3 parts that belong together) (album Brain Salad Surgery). You might like it better than Tarkus. Not that long a song, but one that is well suited to getting to know ELP: "Take A Pebble" (Album Emerson Lake & Palmer)
Side note 1: Usually you think of the drummer as the timekeeper, but in ELP's case the timekeeper wasn't Carl. It was Greg. Side note 2: Listen very carefully to the opening of The Sheriff. Carl starts the drum part, screws it up and starts again, and after he messes up the first time, in the background you can hear him yelling, "Shit!"
The drummer's dad (Karl Palmer) was the percussionist for the London Symphon Orchestra and taught his son drums. You can see the influence in "note" striking in ELP drums that you won't find anywhere else (really)... drums are always hitting a note that coincides with the lead.
Decade of the seventies poll in Playboy Magazine ( I only read the articles) Keith Emerson #1 keyboards, Carl Palmer #1 drummer, Greg Lake #2 bass guitarist only behind Paul Mac Cartney. They truly have softer melodic songs also. Closer to Believing, From the Beginning, Trilogy is complex but beautifully done.
So surprised to see you doing this review, it is so brave to do this. It is a long song so very hard to review on a first reaction. Us ELP fans think it is a masterpiece, but we listened to it dozens of times. So jumping into Tarkus is the deep end for prog rock and is the real ELP doing some of their best work. Hey, but for me this was my first ELP album way back in the 70's, loved it and ELP so later I purchased Pictures at an Exhibition, Trilogy then Brain Salad Surgery. While I always found Yes so positive and uplifting, ELP can be darker with gloom and doom but still great stuff. Music with so many layers, time signatures, keys and transitions but it all goes together as a magnificent work and done by a 3 man band, amazing. Immense soundscapes and if you close your eyes you can see battle fields and armies marching to defeat the mighty war-machine called Tarkus. Trying to get into this song while doing a TH-cam video in a first reaction is a really big ask, I could not do it. So thank you very much. Cheers Kevin
I agree with your synopsis of the group they are like the gangster cousin to YES Not that that's a bad thing 😏🤷🏾♂️ I'd put king crimson in that camp also😁
I agree with your comment, though Yes does have their dark moments, too. I'm thinking of their epic "The Gates of Delirium", which, unless I'm mistaken, is based on the War of 1812. But of course, most of their music is positive and uplifting. I mean, look at their name. I can't say "Yes" and not be positive. which Is why they chose that name. Guitarist Peter Banks wanted a name that sounded strong and optimistic.
Also my first ELP album in the early 70's. Went on to buy all their releases. Listened to Tarkus so many times I not only remember all the lyrics but all the chords as well.
I have been waiting for a reaction video to Tarkus. I remember my reaction almost 50 years ago. It will always be a classic! I also saw them play it in concert, it was incredible.
Diving head first into deep waters with this one! Had the 8 track tape of this when I was in high school - I was familiar with ELP, but didn't totally understand some of the music, but have always been in awe of the writing and musicianship (especially with the odd 7/4 time signature in many spots). The thing I remember most about 8 track is when the songs didn't fit perfectly on the four sections/channels of the tape, the music would fade out, and then resume the song when the track switched (as in 11:00 on this reaction).
If Tarkus is your first listen to ELP, it's really jumping in with both feet. Tarkus took me more than one listen to really warm up to it. Actually, you might really like the live version. It includes an extended version of Aquatarkus that smokes. I would check out the Trilogy album next. ;-) RIP Keith Emerson and Greg Lake.
The thing about ELP, and Tarkus in particular, is that Emerson takes his time to explore every knook and cranny of the musical space to leave no stone unturned, to squeeze that juice for all its worth. This is a big reason why you don't hear a lot of music from this era of prog on the radio, it doesn't fit neatly into a 3 min song format. It's meant for the "kids" who want to be taken for a ride, musically.
You are really diving head first into the top long form songs of the early progressive years, Close to the Edge, Awaken, Suppers Ready and Tarkus. There is plenty more to explore! ELP is much more keyboard oriented than other prog groups and Emerson was one of the early users of the Moog analog synthesizer. I think he was the first to use one in live performances. He was also heavily influenced by classical music. Many ELP songs are rearrangements of classical compositions. Good job on this reaction! Consider the song Take a Pebble for your next ELP reaction. It is very different than Tarkus and another great prog song.
ELP is what you get when you tell a bunch of highly competent jazz musicians to compose and play prog rock in an era where "prog rock" wasn't even a thing yet... It's amazing! Bands like ELP shaped the very foundation of rock, they invented genres, bent them, broke them, and reinvented them again. Writing music like this is a lost art...
I’m amazed you picked this song as an intro into ELP. It’s for hardcore fans. Some good ELP for you start out with would be “From the Beginning” , “Lucky Man”, “Still You Turn Me On”. Those I know you will like.
Prog Rock is supposed to be an experimental, avant garde form. And Tarkus has this in spades which is why this track is not so accessible. And just one reason why I love it so. Certainly one of their best. Anyway, top marks for seeing it through to the end - it's not for the faint hearted.
Pirates is an epic piece that is accessible, you may want to check it out. Also, Pictures at an Exhibition is also incredible. Some other pieces you might want to hear are Lucky Man off their first album, Take a Pebble, Benny the Bouncer and C'est la vie.
Another top prog rock band from when I was a young lad. You should have a look at Emerson, Lake & Palmer - Fanfare For The Common Man ... Live it is just class. All the best from England and stay safe.
That was the theme song from the 1976 Olympics in Montreal, Canada. I always felt that the first ⅓ of that song sounded too "anthemy". As the song moved along it got a lot better through.
I think that is the first time I have ever heard Fela mentioned in the same sentence as ELP. You are doing a great job bringing attention to and learning about these legendary prog records. Keep it up
This is pretty much like jumping to deep end head first. The band's style is very complex and "Tarkus" arguably has the band that reached its creative peak, throwing modest approach to the winds. If you still want to react to this band, "From The Beginning", "I Believe In Father Christmas" present them in more mellow mood.
Wow I am in agreement with the comparison with Fela Kuti during certain sections of this song! I know you have a good ear for music! Like many others who commented that this was a challenging piece of music to attempt at first. May I suggest From the Beginning from their Trilogy album or Still YouTurn Me On from the album Brain Salad Surgery as a more welcoming songs to start your discovery of ELP...
That album is a complete work. Normal people can't handle Alberto Ginastera's "Toccata Concertata," but the rest of the album plays off the sense of terror the piece inspires. God knows no ELP fan wants to 1st Impression (Part 2) by itself.
Keith Emerson's Moog solo at the end of 'Lucky Man' was a 'game changer' for my brain. Have a listen to 'Child in Time' by Deep Purple for more awesome prog rock.
Nice that you brought up Fela Kuti. Ginger Baker was a big fan of his and they hung out quite extensively during the 70's. The segway is obvious, you should react to some Cream. Not prog, but still essential. Try something like "White room", "We're going wrong", "Sunshine of your love" or "Tales of brave Ulysses" for some interesting rythm work from Ginger.
I love Yes, Rush, Genesis, Camel and most forms of prog. Van see Graaf Generator are about as extreme as I go. I've never really got ELP or Gentle Giant though. For King Crimson I have to be in the right mood.
Lol I’m your opposite, I find Genesis and Yes boring (also Jon Anderson has a seriously insufferable voice). Love me some King Crimson, ELP, and VDGG. Though not a fan of Gentle Giant.
You are very brave! This is a difficult listen even for some of us die-hard ELP Fans...... I would suggest Trilogy for a more digestible serving.... Greg Lake's vocals are always captivating and lush...and I feel, a bit of a tease...simply because there is a whole lot of Tarkus lurking beneath the sugar..... Thank you again for diving into the Prog Rock world....... New (old) Artist Suggestion - Tommy Bolin.... "People People," or "Dreamer" are good starting spots..... ...
This piece is advanced and difficult for newcomers, it has odd time signatures, weird synthesizer sounds, dark lyrics and a story that isn't very relatable. And prog rock isn't for everyone, the punk movement came about because this type of music was too skilled and high level. It isn't made to dance to or listen to for 3 minutes before the next pop song comes on. Re-listens will help though, it's hard to get into when you don't know what's coming next. Reading up on it can help too.
Hello cynthia ,greetings from Italy,please check of the same group "pictures at an exibition",Brian salad surgery" ,and the First self/titled all amazing.elp were,are and and Will be for the eternety my Heroes,my spitual musical friends
The point is that most young people are used to the idea that music is divide in songs, and there is nothing that teach them that this is like ask you for the rest of your life to speak with a vocabulary that has only 50 words. But the vocabulary has 171,000 plus words 49,000 plus obsolete and so many more still to be invented, that is what classical, jazz, etc musicians knew and what most of musician up until not long ago knew. Music is free expression, shouldn't be put in a small box on 3 minutes, shouldn't be limited to only one category, songs, there is so much more. That concept of freedom will take your mind to think outside the box, to see that there are possibilities you've never consider before and will train your brain to expand and let go, because you don't know how to abandon yourself to music completely because after few minutes you feel unsettle, and uncomfortable because you don't know what to do, you don't know what to think, and you shouldn't do either, but you never done it. By the way classical music and progressive music change the wave pattern of your brain, the more you listen to it the more your mind expand.
You dove into the deep end of the pool. I would no more recommend this suite than I would recommend Prokofiev or Bartok to someone interested in tasting Classical music for the first time. Keith composed this after an challenging conversation with Frank Zappa on the use of non-standard time signatures and dissonance in music. "Trilogy" would have been a better first time reaction. For me, the more esoteric stuff - Tarkus, Three Fates, Fugue, Piano Concerto are golden. But these latter should more appropriately be considered "classical" music vs rock. The Greg Lake stuff is very beautiful. C'est le Vie, From the Beginning, Lucky Man, Affairs of the Heart.... more like ballade rock.
ELP ca be very confronting ..... repeat listening's are required to understand what is really going on there.... just think this is only 3 guys.... a very brave choice to start with.... Tarkus is like a piece of modern art. They have lots of great innovative music that draws from many sources... keep exploring please.
I think you'd probably like"Lucky Man" or "Still"(You Turn Me On) by Emerson, Lake, and Palmer, that's there heavier Prog stuff that you heard, and the songs I mentioned was there more mainstream music.
Tarkus is a tough one although a great one. Bu Cynthia, I tell you, you will love two songs which are Greg Lake dominated (this one is Keith Emerson): From the beginning and c'est la vie. Because you can take complicated prog music well - but the parts that get you are the emotional songs and these two examples are that. Also Take a pebble as someone else here mentioned, you're gonna like that.
Haha yes indeed you know it's funny George Gershwin he wrote many great compositions back in the 20s and his dad what do you out in the audience when he would perform these great compositions and his dad would look at his watch to see how long it was and he would say this was a very important piece well this one right here is a very important piece there are chordal and harmonic structures that I swear have never ever been done before or so it seems I would stake my reputation on it the more you listen to this and familiarize yourself with this song or is this I don't know what you call this concept masterpiece you will just keep hearing new things I mean myself as a musician I still can't understand a lot of the harmonic variances and chord progressions and all things involved I just noticed there there wow I love the fact that you mention Fela kuti because there was a drummer from England put it in one of my favorite bands he played with Eric Clapton and Jack Bruce his name was Ginger Baker may he rest in peace he was a great drummer and they played with Fela kuti yeah there are so many styles and different modes of Music being played there's Ragtime and Blues rock and roll and classical jazz it's all there Keith Emerson wow I was lucky enough to see stand after their last really great album I saw them at Long Beach Arena what an epic concert that was I really the message clear the battlefield anyhow it's not an easy listen but it's some of the most awesome music ever made interior my dear gal I will check you on next drop take care
You could try the Scottish band that most people know little about, they are called Beggar's Opera, they were great live as a 5 piece with a girl on Hammond organ, another organ player, drum, bass and lead guitar, and a singer who has a great voice but his moves make him look silly ( sorry) for starters have a listen to the track "Time Machine", is starts weird but is a great song, the vocals are excellent. hope you try it, cheers. This album is much better than i remember it. It is great to see the music has your undivided attention, you're definitely a true prog head..
I'll be happy to add my two cents. ELP has always been hit and miss with me. With very little in the way of lead guitar parts, it is bound to sound much different than just about anything else. While enjoying their frequent re-working of classical symphonic music pieces, I always found it odd that they would spend time and album space doing so rather than creating new music. Keith Emerson is arguably the greatest rock keyboardist of all time. His immense talent shines on everything they do. Greg Lake and Carl Palmer are more than competent additions to this three-man ensemble, but I've never considered them to be fabulous. I'd speculate that Emerson, if he loved anything in music, loved avant-garde symphonic music, which oftentimes was the same sort of dissonant and quirky journey into the anti-classical as Tarkus is to symphonic prog. ELP is properly cited as a band responsible for the birth of the entire progressive rock genre, I'll give them that much. They were always eager to test the limits of popular music back then, and when they pulled back from those limits a bit, they produced a lot of hauntingly beautiful songs that will pass the test of time. If you reacted to "From the Beginning" next, you might have a hard time believing it's the same band.
It's a lot to take in the first time you hear it. I know I didn't get it the first time I listened, but there was something in there that made me want to go back time and time again. ELP were top drawer musicians and it's bloody complicated stuff in parts, kind of like 20th Century classical music. There is other stuff in their catalogue (like the Endless Enigma or Pirates) that's long-ish, but not so intimidating on first listen.
That is a very penetrating insight, thank you. I never realized that until I read your comment (seriously). The first time I heard Tarkus, I was somewhat bewildered, but there was something in it that fascinated me, and made me come back to it again and again and again. ELP has been my hands down favorite band since forever. They truly deserve their own unique category within the genre of music known as 'progressive rock'. While other bands may be more polished (Genesis), or more precise (Rush), or more melodic (YES), ELP had the incredible and unique combination of phenomenal talent, amazing compositions (and arrangements), Greg Lake's angelic voice, cutting edge equipment, and an extremely entertaining (and physically demanding) live stage presentation. These facts, along with their focus on keyboard centric classical music put to rock, puts them in their own special category, all by themselves. To say that 'ELP is better than {fill in the blank}' doesn't get to the truth. The truth is that comparing ELP to YES or Genesis or King Crimson or any of the other giants of Prog, is like comparing Cognac to Champagne to Fine Wine to Craft Beer. Yes, they are all alcohol based beverages, but they could not be more different from each other. Each of the giants of Prog need to be appreciated for their own unique contributions to the world of music, none more so than Emerson, Lake & Palmer.
You should also do "Song of Scheherazade" by Renaissance; "In Held Twas in I" by Procol Harum"; "Pirates" by Emerson Lake & Palmer; "The Revealing Science of God (Dance of the Dawn)" and "The Gates of Delirium" by Yes.
ELP have some beautiful meditative songs - but Tarkus ain’t one of them. Most beautiful in order: 1. Closer to Believing 2. Memoirs of an Officer and Gentleman 3. Take a Pebble 4. Pirates 5. The Endless Enigma (Parts 1&2) ELP is my favorite band ever - and I don’t like Tarkus. It has some great moments, but I am seldom in the mood for the whole thing. A few other prog songs up your meditative alley: 1. Turn of the Century-Yes 2. Day of the Dreamer - Renaissance 3. Ripples - Genesis 4. Smallcreep’s Day - Mike Rutherford Your videos are delightful. It’s a joy to watch a budding progger.
Whew! You really chose something that requires some serious listening here! I enjoyed listening to ELP back in the day but I found their music to be quite indulgent at times - even for my tastes, and this is one example. It's still an immense piece of music though and deserves respect. For a novice it might be better to have a co-listener with some musical background to provide a different insight. This is the first time I've listened to this song in quite a few years so it was refreshing to hear once again. As I was listening, I actually had the conscious thought that some parts of this did remind me of some of the Nigerian music that I've followed over the years. When you mentioned that this was reminiscent of Fela my jaw dropped! I would like to think that the members of ELP would take that as a compliment! ELPs music was never quite as, uhmm..."political" as Fela's though.
Karn Evil 9 First Impression, Part One and Two (Second and Third Impression, the whole piece, if you're feeling brave)...................you'll be surprised.
Like most of prog rock monuments, you often need several listenings to get the quintessence of it and finaly really enjoy. This number is no exception to this. You'll love it sometime. You loved Supper's Ready by Genesis right at first and will love it more as you'll accumulate listenings. I'd like you to taste this band : th-cam.com/video/xzKfuzot4nc/w-d-xo.html Thank you for sharing good taste ! Love.
This is a piece that you kind of have to build up to. Yes, the keyboards go on a bit long. If you don't know what happens next, it is easy to get lost. An honest reaction, so you are doing good. That's all we ask.
Even if you didn't like the song, at least you gave a sincere opinion and it's no small thing in a format where many reactions are fake where everyone appreciates all the music they hear so as not to receive criticism and insults from the fans of the artists in question.
While this one may have been a bit much for you, I appreciate you even giving Prog Rock a chance. This one is hard to digest for someone not used to it and is the prog rock of prog rock, the more intense of them. Still good that you took it in.
Cynthia with Emerson Lake and Palmer this is not a good place to start. Kieth Emerson was influenced by the classics. I suggest you try a track 'Lucky Man'...It's clear you like Greg Lake's voice. Sadly Kieth Emerson or Greg Lake are here any longer.
If you think this is "different", you should try listening to some Tangerine Dream. Albums like Force Majeure, Ricochet, or Stratosfear....then you will really see DIFFERENT.
I would define this type of music more as fusion jazzrock than progressive rock. I compare it to Return to Forever and bands like that. About this song I personally find it a little boring and i would go for more like Genesis, Weather Report, Brand X, Pink Floyd and so that to me is a class higher
For my taste one the most incredible track ever made on pop/rock music,from the magic trio called ELP, nothing ,really nothing to compare with the nowadays so called stars ,expecially the trap/rap "stars" only bullshit.from Treviso Italy Cattarin Luciano
![กิโลเมตรที่ 0 เดินทางรอบโลกไม่ใช้เครื่องบิน [Around The World Ep. 1]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/toJG9oofLFY/mqdefault.jpg)
the golden rule of Prog rock is "listen to it at least 4 times before to say -it is confusing- likely it is only complex" ;)
LOL I like it.
The golden rule is
Listen at least 4 times, then you can listen for 1.000 times without getting bored 😉
Mi oído no entendía nada pero estaba encantado. Efectivamente lo vuelves a oír y a oír y woooow ELP los padres del rock prog
I only had to listen to it once~ Fact...
Tarkus is a masterpice, it has even been played by symphonic orchestras as a piece of Classical music. You should search TH-cam for the Orchestral versions by young Japanese conductors.
I was an early fan of E L P, following Greg Lake from King Crimson. I knew that ELP had something special but when I first heard TARKUS upon its release my mind was blown. I never knew such sonic vistas were possible. The complexity of composition and body of sound coming from just 3 master musicians just blew my mind.
As some other comment noted: you have surely just chosen to jump into the deep end of the pool.
Great reaction. I like your open minded approach. This track was a real show stopper when they played live, just the three of them. Greg Lake had one of the best voices in rock and this track also shows his great bass and lead guitar skills. Palmer's drumming is always brilliant and the keyboards still sound great.
This song takes some time to sink in. The interplay of percussion, keyboards, guitar, and Lake's voice is wonderful. It's beautifully complex.
Never thought I would ever connect with people in this generation who's playing music that I've been listening to for the past few decades, this is Awesome!!
Wow, I can't believe you did this song. When I was a little boy, early 70s, my uncle was very much into music and he played this for me. I remember listening to this on his reel to reel and just being completely spellbound watching the reels spin, and listening to this music that didn't sound like anything I had ever heard before. It was a key moment in introducing me to music at an early age...like 6-8yrs old. :)
2:33 At that moment my soul soared.
You know listening to this kind of music is like watching a movie. I used to entertain at my home. I'd invite friends, cook a great meal, dim the lights, serve drinks, and we'd share music. Everybody would bring a new CD. Great times!
I am so grateful this is out on TH-cam call Palmer they would be so happy modern drummer Hall of Fame
Good morning Cynthia. To listen to Tarkus as your first ELP track is a brave choice ! Well done for seeing it through. I will allow others to suggest alternative tracks by them which would generally be considered more accessible. Best regards, Cambrian.
I recommend both The Endless Enigma Part 1 and Take A Pebble as a good intro to ELP!!
Still... You Turn Me On from Brain Salad Surgery is a good place to start with ELP I feel...
@@willhous19 you can't forget From the Beginning
@@adriennechallinor1600 yes!!!
Jerusalem is also a very good place to check out.
Just 3 guys are making all this music, and I saw them do it beautifully in concert (actually thrice during the 70s)... Even more than Yes, ELP experiments with "transitions" (time signature changes, which is one of three hallmarks of prog-rock), so the listener needs to be patient, and let the track play out. Thanx for trying them!
I got to see the Works tour. They had a few more than three that round - a full orchestra.
You jumped right in with this one. ELP has always been one of my favorite bands. This song being my favorite song. Give it a listen a few times on your own and you will come to enjoy its absolute brilliance. Love your channel!!!!
Wow Cynthia, you've gone straight after the masterpieces of prog rock. You still have many wonderful pieces of music ahead. I get you love the more ethereal stuff. Wait to hear Hatfield and the North.
haha definitely the deep end of the pool here. The great thing about these epic songs is that the more familiar they become they greater they sound and feel. However, an easier entry to ELP would be 'From The Beginning', or Lucky Man.
In an incredible and unusual way, with much joy and nostalgia, those of us who are over 58 years old see reflected in the reactions of these beautiful and young people those feelings that these beautiful works produced in our time. Feelings that did not include surprise, because at that time this was what was expected and demanded. Complexity, beauty and excellence, often due to simple habit or habit. Those musicians offered things that except for a few very few exceptions emulated or continued. Will young people also have fun watching our reaction to some more modern or current compositions?
ELP is somehow in a category of its own within Prog Rock. Due to the line-up, the music is quite keyboard-heavy. I used to play keyboards in a rock band, that's why I like that. But I also find the drums interesting, which at ELP more than in any other band are not only used as a rhythm instrument but are an essential part of the composition. ELP also made very diverse music. "Lucky Man" for example is a very gentle, melancholy song, with "The Three Fates" the keys fly around your ears, "The Sheriff" is more of a fun song. Another "big song" from ELP "Karn Evil 9" (3 parts that belong together) (album Brain Salad Surgery). You might like it better than Tarkus. Not that long a song, but one that is well suited to getting to know ELP: "Take A Pebble" (Album Emerson Lake & Palmer)
Side note 1: Usually you think of the drummer as the timekeeper, but in ELP's case the timekeeper wasn't Carl. It was Greg. Side note 2: Listen very carefully to the opening of The Sheriff. Carl starts the drum part, screws it up and starts again, and after he messes up the first time, in the background you can hear him yelling, "Shit!"
@@toddfrank3344 Rush? Possibly more melodic drums...
The drummer's dad (Karl Palmer) was the percussionist for the London Symphon Orchestra and taught his son drums. You can see the influence in "note" striking in ELP drums that you won't find anywhere else (really)... drums are always hitting a note that coincides with the lead.
I never expected anyone to play this, ever... Love your reactions and thank you!
Decade of the seventies poll in Playboy Magazine ( I only read the articles) Keith Emerson #1 keyboards, Carl Palmer #1 drummer, Greg Lake #2 bass guitarist only behind Paul Mac Cartney. They truly have softer melodic songs also. Closer to Believing, From the Beginning, Trilogy is complex but beautifully done.
When Greg Lake sings "How can you know where you've been ....in time?" always hits me like a brick!
My 2 favorite pieces by ELP are Trilogy and The Endless Enigma. I think you'll love both of them.
Closer To Believing will bring you to tears
Absolutely! A breathtaking song
So surprised to see you doing this review, it is so brave to do this. It is a long song so very hard to review on a first reaction. Us ELP fans think it is a masterpiece, but we listened to it dozens of times. So jumping into Tarkus is the deep end for prog rock and is the real ELP doing some of their best work. Hey, but for me this was my first ELP album way back in the 70's, loved it and ELP so later I purchased Pictures at an Exhibition, Trilogy then Brain Salad Surgery. While I always found Yes so positive and uplifting, ELP can be darker with gloom and doom but still great stuff. Music with so many layers, time signatures, keys and transitions but it all goes together as a magnificent work and done by a 3 man band, amazing. Immense soundscapes and if you close your eyes you can see battle fields and armies marching to defeat the mighty war-machine called Tarkus. Trying to get into this song while doing a TH-cam video in a first reaction is a really big ask, I could not do it. So thank you very much. Cheers Kevin
I agree with your synopsis of the group they are like the gangster cousin to YES Not that that's a bad thing 😏🤷🏾♂️ I'd put king crimson in that camp also😁
I agree with your comment, though Yes does have their dark moments, too. I'm thinking of their epic "The Gates of Delirium", which, unless I'm mistaken, is based on the War of 1812. But of course, most of their music is positive and uplifting. I mean, look at their name. I can't say "Yes" and not be positive. which Is why they chose that name. Guitarist Peter Banks wanted a name that sounded strong and optimistic.
@@melvinwomack3717 Greg Lake was in both bands.
Also my first ELP album in the early 70's. Went on to buy all their releases. Listened to Tarkus so many times I not only remember all the lyrics but all the chords as well.
I have been waiting for a reaction video to Tarkus. I remember my reaction almost 50 years ago. It will always be a classic! I also saw them play it in concert, it was incredible.
Classical Classic .
Thoroughly imbued with centuries of tonalities , time signatures , and lyricism .
Copland , Stravinsky , Brahms , Beethoven , Mozart & Bach would've shared the stage .
ELP also have a gentle side. Songs like "From The Beginning", "Lucky Man" or "Take A Pebble" are good for relaxing.
Diving head first into deep waters with this one! Had the 8 track tape of this when I was in high school - I was familiar with ELP, but didn't totally understand some of the music, but have always been in awe of the writing and musicianship (especially with the odd 7/4 time signature in many spots). The thing I remember most about 8 track is when the songs didn't fit perfectly on the four sections/channels of the tape, the music would fade out, and then resume the song when the track switched (as in 11:00 on this reaction).
If Tarkus is your first listen to ELP, it's really jumping in with both feet. Tarkus took me more than one listen to really warm up to it. Actually, you might really like the live version. It includes an extended version of Aquatarkus that smokes. I would check out the Trilogy album next. ;-) RIP Keith Emerson and Greg Lake.
It's not for rookies this one. But there's a reason it's regarded as a classic 50 years on.
I never get tired of it, that much I can tell.
That live recording of Aquatarkus. Oh, man! That monster Moog.
The thing about ELP, and Tarkus in particular, is that Emerson takes his time to explore every knook and cranny of the musical space to leave no stone unturned, to squeeze that juice for all its worth. This is a big reason why you don't hear a lot of music from this era of prog on the radio, it doesn't fit neatly into a 3 min song format. It's meant for the "kids" who want to be taken for a ride, musically.
Outstanding! 😎👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
You are really diving head first into the top long form songs of the early progressive years, Close to the Edge, Awaken, Suppers Ready and Tarkus. There is plenty more to explore!
ELP is much more keyboard oriented than other prog groups and Emerson was one of the early users of the Moog analog synthesizer. I think he was the first to use one in live performances. He was also heavily influenced by classical music. Many ELP songs are rearrangements of classical compositions.
Good job on this reaction! Consider the song Take a Pebble for your next ELP reaction. It is very different than Tarkus and another great prog song.
Keith Emerson was actually involved in the development of the first MOOG synthesizer.
elp hybrid chord changes on turn arounds , jazz, rock,classical. all was amazed me
🇨🇦
Best hit by
E, L, P
Is
Lucky man
Very good song
ELP is what you get when you tell a bunch of highly competent jazz musicians to compose and play prog rock in an era where "prog rock" wasn't even a thing yet... It's amazing!
Bands like ELP shaped the very foundation of rock, they invented genres, bent them, broke them, and reinvented them again. Writing music like this is a lost art...
I’m amazed you picked this song as an intro into ELP. It’s for hardcore fans. Some good ELP for you start out with would be “From the Beginning” , “Lucky Man”, “Still You Turn Me On”. Those I know you will like.
Prog Rock is supposed to be an experimental, avant garde form. And Tarkus has this in spades which is why this track is not so accessible. And just one reason why I love it so. Certainly one of their best. Anyway, top marks for seeing it through to the end - it's not for the faint hearted.
Thanks! I love prog rock but I felt the same as you when I first heard this song
'Take A Pebble' by Emerson, Lake & Palmer from their first album.
Pirates is an epic piece that is accessible, you may want to check it out. Also, Pictures at an Exhibition is also incredible. Some other pieces you might want to hear are Lucky Man off their first album, Take a Pebble, Benny the Bouncer and C'est la vie.
Another top prog rock band from when I was a young lad. You should have a look at Emerson, Lake & Palmer - Fanfare For The Common Man ... Live it is just class. All the best from England and stay safe.
That was the theme song from the 1976 Olympics in Montreal, Canada. I always felt that the first ⅓ of that song sounded too "anthemy". As the song moved along it got a lot better through.
I think that is the first time I have ever heard Fela mentioned in the same sentence as ELP. You are doing a great job bringing attention to and learning about these legendary prog records. Keep it up
Kudos to you for listening to something that is very eclectic. God bless
This is a very cup of tea
Masterpiece, masterpiece, masterpiece, masterpiece, masterpiece, masterpiece, masterpiece, masterpiece
This is pretty much like jumping to deep end head first. The band's style is very complex and "Tarkus" arguably has the band that reached its creative peak, throwing modest approach to the winds.
If you still want to react to this band, "From The Beginning", "I Believe In Father Christmas" present them in more mellow mood.
Wow I am in agreement with the comparison with Fela Kuti during certain sections of this song! I know you have a good ear for music! Like many others who commented that this was a challenging piece of music to attempt at first. May I suggest From the Beginning from their Trilogy album or Still YouTurn Me On from the album Brain Salad Surgery as a more welcoming songs to start your discovery of ELP...
I never liked Tarkus, but I love "Brain Salad Surgery". Everyone's right to their opinion, Cynthia. That's why it's a reaction channel. You're honest
That album is a complete work. Normal people can't handle Alberto Ginastera's "Toccata Concertata," but the rest of the album plays off the sense of terror the piece inspires. God knows no ELP fan wants to 1st Impression (Part 2) by itself.
One of Classic Prog's Great songs !!!!!!!
war mongering challenged by logic and humanity intense chaotic and resolute. Keith's organ masterpiece
Top 5 prog rock song, in my humble opinion!
Keith Emerson's Moog solo at the end of 'Lucky Man' was a 'game changer' for my brain. Have a listen to 'Child in Time' by Deep Purple for more awesome prog rock.
Nice that you brought up Fela Kuti. Ginger Baker was a big fan of his and they hung out quite extensively during the 70's. The segway is obvious, you should react to some Cream. Not prog, but still essential. Try something like "White room", "We're going wrong", "Sunshine of your love" or "Tales of brave Ulysses" for some interesting rythm work from Ginger.
THESE 3 GUYS WILL EAT ANYONE ALIVE IN THE PROG ROCK GENRE........THANX FOR THE POST.
An epic piece of music.
I love Yes, Rush, Genesis, Camel and most forms of prog. Van see Graaf Generator are about as extreme as I go. I've never really got ELP or Gentle Giant though. For King Crimson I have to be in the right mood.
Lol I’m your opposite, I find Genesis and Yes boring (also Jon Anderson has a seriously insufferable voice). Love me some King Crimson, ELP, and VDGG. Though not a fan of Gentle Giant.
Keyboards are mostly Hammond Organ and Moog synthesizer, with a bit of piano here and there. And guitar, bass, and drums.
Damm, you are diving into some serious shit. Well done. subscribed.
I saw them live in 1992. That was A W E S O M E!
You are very brave! This is a difficult listen even for some of us die-hard ELP Fans...... I would suggest Trilogy for a more digestible serving....
Greg Lake's vocals are always captivating and lush...and I feel, a bit of a tease...simply because there is a whole lot of Tarkus lurking beneath the sugar.....
Thank you again for diving into the Prog Rock world....... New (old) Artist Suggestion - Tommy Bolin.... "People People," or "Dreamer" are good starting spots.....
...
This piece is advanced and difficult for newcomers, it has odd time signatures, weird synthesizer sounds, dark lyrics and a story that isn't very relatable. And prog rock isn't for everyone, the punk movement came about because this type of music was too skilled and high level. It isn't made to dance to or listen to for 3 minutes before the next pop song comes on. Re-listens will help though, it's hard to get into when you don't know what's coming next. Reading up on it can help too.
When I cross myself, I say Emerson,Lake& Palmer.🗿
Hello cynthia ,greetings from Italy,please check of the same group "pictures at an exibition",Brian salad surgery" ,and the First self/titled all amazing.elp were,are and and Will be for the eternety my Heroes,my spitual musical friends
The point is that most young people are used to the idea that music is divide in songs, and there is nothing that teach them that this is like ask you for the rest of your life to speak with a vocabulary that has only 50 words. But the vocabulary has 171,000 plus words 49,000 plus obsolete and so many more still to be invented, that is what classical, jazz, etc musicians knew and what most of musician up until not long ago knew. Music is free expression, shouldn't be put in a small box on 3 minutes, shouldn't be limited to only one category, songs, there is so much more. That concept of freedom will take your mind to think outside the box, to see that there are possibilities you've never consider before and will train your brain to expand and let go, because you don't know how to abandon yourself to music completely because after few minutes you feel unsettle, and uncomfortable because you don't know what to do, you don't know what to think, and you shouldn't do either, but you never done it. By the way classical music and progressive music change the wave pattern of your brain, the more you listen to it the more your mind expand.
You dove into the deep end of the pool. I would no more recommend this suite than I would recommend Prokofiev or Bartok to someone interested in tasting Classical music for the first time. Keith composed this after an challenging conversation with Frank Zappa on the use of non-standard time signatures and dissonance in music. "Trilogy" would have been a better first time reaction. For me, the more esoteric stuff - Tarkus, Three Fates, Fugue, Piano Concerto are golden. But these latter should more appropriately be considered "classical" music vs rock. The Greg Lake stuff is very beautiful. C'est le Vie, From the Beginning, Lucky Man, Affairs of the Heart.... more like ballade rock.
Mmmm Tarkus is a Mental maze! critically acclaimed but hard to digest from the start,
Patience with ELP
ELP ca be very confronting ..... repeat listening's are required to understand what is really going on there.... just think this is only 3 guys.... a very brave choice to start with.... Tarkus is like a piece of modern art. They have lots of great innovative music that draws from many sources... keep exploring please.
I think you'd probably like"Lucky Man" or "Still"(You Turn Me On) by Emerson, Lake, and Palmer, that's there heavier Prog stuff that you heard, and the songs I mentioned was there more mainstream music.
Tarkus is a tough one although a great one. Bu Cynthia, I tell you, you will love two songs which are Greg Lake dominated (this one is Keith Emerson): From the beginning and c'est la vie. Because you can take complicated prog music well - but the parts that get you are the emotional songs and these two examples are that. Also Take a pebble as someone else here mentioned, you're gonna like that.
Haha yes indeed you know it's funny George Gershwin he wrote many great compositions back in the 20s and his dad what do you out in the audience when he would perform these great compositions and his dad would look at his watch to see how long it was and he would say this was a very important piece well this one right here is a very important piece there are chordal and harmonic structures that I swear have never ever been done before or so it seems I would stake my reputation on it the more you listen to this and familiarize yourself with this song or is this I don't know what you call this concept masterpiece you will just keep hearing new things I mean myself as a musician I still can't understand a lot of the harmonic variances and chord progressions and all things involved I just noticed there there wow I love the fact that you mention Fela kuti because there was a drummer from England put it in one of my favorite bands he played with Eric Clapton and Jack Bruce his name was Ginger Baker may he rest in peace he was a great drummer and they played with Fela kuti yeah there are so many styles and different modes of Music being played there's Ragtime and Blues rock and roll and classical jazz it's all there Keith Emerson wow I was lucky enough to see stand after their last really great album I saw them at Long Beach Arena what an epic concert that was I really the message clear the battlefield anyhow it's not an easy listen but it's some of the most awesome music ever made interior my dear gal I will check you on next drop take care
You could try the Scottish band that most people know little about, they are called Beggar's Opera, they were great live as a 5 piece with a girl on Hammond organ, another organ player, drum, bass and lead guitar, and a singer who has a great voice but his moves make him look silly ( sorry) for starters have a listen to the track "Time Machine", is starts weird but is a great song, the vocals are excellent. hope you try it, cheers. This album is much better than i remember it. It is great to see the music has your undivided attention, you're definitely a true prog head..
I'll be happy to add my two cents. ELP has always been hit and miss with me. With very little in the way of lead guitar parts, it is bound to sound much different than just about anything else. While enjoying their frequent re-working of classical symphonic music pieces, I always found it odd that they would spend time and album space doing so rather than creating new music. Keith Emerson is arguably the greatest rock keyboardist of all time. His immense talent shines on everything they do. Greg Lake and Carl Palmer are more than competent additions to this three-man ensemble, but I've never considered them to be fabulous. I'd speculate that Emerson, if he loved anything in music, loved avant-garde symphonic music, which oftentimes was the same sort of dissonant and quirky journey into the anti-classical as Tarkus is to symphonic prog. ELP is properly cited as a band responsible for the birth of the entire progressive rock genre, I'll give them that much. They were always eager to test the limits of popular music back then, and when they pulled back from those limits a bit, they produced a lot of hauntingly beautiful songs that will pass the test of time. If you reacted to "From the Beginning" next, you might have a hard time believing it's the same band.
It's a lot to take in the first time you hear it. I know I didn't get it the first time I listened, but there was something in there that made me want to go back time and time again. ELP were top drawer musicians and it's bloody complicated stuff in parts, kind of like 20th Century classical music. There is other stuff in their catalogue (like the Endless Enigma or Pirates) that's long-ish, but not so intimidating on first listen.
That is a very penetrating insight, thank you. I never realized that until I read your comment (seriously). The first time I heard Tarkus, I was somewhat bewildered, but there was something in it that fascinated me, and made me come back to it again and again and again. ELP has been my hands down favorite band since forever. They truly deserve their own unique category within the genre of music known as 'progressive rock'. While other bands may be more polished (Genesis), or more precise (Rush), or more melodic (YES), ELP had the incredible and unique combination of phenomenal talent, amazing compositions (and arrangements), Greg Lake's angelic voice, cutting edge equipment, and an extremely entertaining (and physically demanding) live stage presentation. These facts, along with their focus on keyboard centric classical music put to rock, puts them in their own special category, all by themselves. To say that 'ELP is better than {fill in the blank}' doesn't get to the truth. The truth is that comparing ELP to YES or Genesis or King Crimson or any of the other giants of Prog, is like comparing Cognac to Champagne to Fine Wine to Craft Beer. Yes, they are all alcohol based beverages, but they could not be more different from each other. Each of the giants of Prog need to be appreciated for their own unique contributions to the world of music, none more so than Emerson, Lake & Palmer.
You should also do "Song of Scheherazade" by Renaissance; "In Held Twas in I" by Procol Harum"; "Pirates" by Emerson Lake & Palmer;
"The Revealing Science of God (Dance of the Dawn)" and "The Gates of Delirium" by Yes.
I suggested Novella by Renaissance.
OMG it dont get ANY BETTER than KEITH THE BEAST EMERSON!
ELP have some beautiful meditative songs - but Tarkus ain’t one of them.
Most beautiful in order:
1. Closer to Believing
2. Memoirs of an Officer and Gentleman
3. Take a Pebble
4. Pirates
5. The Endless Enigma (Parts 1&2)
ELP is my favorite band ever - and I don’t like Tarkus. It has some great moments, but I am seldom in the mood for the whole thing.
A few other prog songs up your meditative alley:
1. Turn of the Century-Yes
2. Day of the Dreamer - Renaissance
3. Ripples - Genesis
4. Smallcreep’s Day - Mike Rutherford
Your videos are delightful. It’s a joy to watch a budding progger.
Karn Evil 9 is another landmark from ELP.🗿
Whew! You really chose something that requires some serious listening here! I enjoyed listening to ELP back in the day but I found their music to be quite indulgent at times - even for my tastes, and this is one example. It's still an immense piece of music though and deserves respect. For a novice it might be better to have a co-listener with some musical background to provide a different insight.
This is the first time I've listened to this song in quite a few years so it was refreshing to hear once again. As I was listening, I actually had the conscious thought that some parts of this did remind me of some of the Nigerian music that I've followed over the years. When you mentioned that this was reminiscent of Fela my jaw dropped! I would like to think that the members of ELP would take that as a compliment! ELPs music was never quite as, uhmm..."political" as Fela's though.
Karn Evil 9 First Impression, Part One and Two (Second and Third Impression, the whole piece, if you're feeling brave)...................you'll be surprised.
my favorite part of the song is 16:43 (18:18 in video)
just love the keyboards at that timestamp
also i could listen to this song for hours
Hello Friends,greetings from Treviso Italy.hello Cynthia ,please check "a time and a Place" from the same album of ELP,bye bye all progressive fans
Prog on!
Like most of prog rock monuments, you often need several listenings to get the quintessence of it and finaly really enjoy. This number is no exception to this. You'll love it sometime. You loved Supper's Ready by Genesis right at first and will love it more as you'll accumulate listenings. I'd like you to taste this band : th-cam.com/video/xzKfuzot4nc/w-d-xo.html Thank you for sharing good taste ! Love.
This is a piece that you kind of have to build up to. Yes, the keyboards go on a bit long. If you don't know what happens next, it is easy to get lost. An honest reaction, so you are doing good. That's all we ask.
I'm not particularly for or against this track but there's a few gems on this album
musical iQ grew 20%
Even if you didn't like the song, at least you gave a sincere opinion and it's no small thing in a format where many reactions are fake where everyone appreciates all the music they hear so as not to receive criticism and insults from the fans of the artists in question.
While this one may have been a bit much for you, I appreciate you even giving Prog Rock a chance. This one is hard to digest for someone not used to it and is the prog rock of prog rock, the more intense of them. Still good that you took it in.
Ambrose, could you react to "El desastre de Hésperus" by Palmira Romano, please? (Recommended for ELP and Deep Purple fans). Greetings from Chile!
Keith's favorite.
React to mexican singer "Jose Jose" singing "El triste".
Try the band Asia....
Heat of the Moment...
with Lake and Palmer...you will like it
Cynthia with Emerson Lake and Palmer this is not a good place to start. Kieth Emerson was influenced by the classics. I suggest you try a track 'Lucky Man'...It's clear you like Greg Lake's voice. Sadly Kieth Emerson or Greg Lake are here any longer.
Roundabout... Then Tarkus... I see you, JoJo fans ! ^^
ELP is a different breed of prog to Yes and Genesis. Don't know if that's a good thing lol
If you think this is "different", you should try listening to some Tangerine Dream. Albums like Force Majeure, Ricochet, or Stratosfear....then you will really see DIFFERENT.
Please do "Can't you hear me knocking?" by the Rolling Stones.
Bad trip licergic!!!
I would define this type of music more as fusion jazzrock than progressive rock. I compare it to Return to Forever and bands like that. About this song I personally find it a little boring and i would go for more like Genesis, Weather Report, Brand X, Pink Floyd and so that to me is a class higher
For my taste one the most incredible track ever made on pop/rock music,from the magic trio called ELP, nothing ,really nothing to compare with the nowadays so called stars ,expecially the trap/rap "stars" only bullshit.from Treviso Italy Cattarin Luciano