“Is this song tear or tear?” …yes. These mofo geniuses getting their word play on even in a second language. I love learning Korean and about Korean language not in hopes I will ever be fluent (highly doubtful) but just so I can appreciate BTS’ bars. The layers of wordplay is stupid
Both...RM tear (crying).....Suga tear as in (torn)...and J Hope Fear ....Suga wrote this when they were considering disbandment after a really hard year💜
j-hope's part is my favorite, his live delivery and his intense and emotive rapping always move me so much. Love it. He raps like he dances, great flows and great moves, always passionate.
why are you spreading misinfo? All three members have writing/composing credits on this song. All of them wrote their respective verses and the main instrumental theme of this song was composed by Shin Myung-Soo. Most of ARMYS just don't read official credits at all and write whatever they have heard on social media. They think Suga wrote the whole song just because in one interview he said: "this song was written", he didn't say "I wrote it". People are really disrespectful and say lots of misleading stuff. Credits are: writing/composing: Shin Myung-Soo, DOCSKIM, Suga, RM, j-hope producing: DOCSKIM the rap line also has credits as recording engineers. In that interview Suga also talked he made melody for Outro: Tear, but he didn't tell specifically for which part of the song, and again people assumed he composed everything which is not true. As I said the main composer is Shin Myung-Soo. Earlier he made instrumental track to BTS Highlight Reel, a long piece for their Bangtan Universe storyline (a fictional storyline that has all the BTS members playing their own character). And in that instrumental piece, there is a fragment almost identical to this song, with piano notes at the start and orchestration ect. So idk why people never mention him when he is credited 1st (in order) in official credits. Anyway RM in his vlive talked about members' involvement ans said Suga's version of melody line used in chorus (and maybe a bridge part too) was chosen by the producer so that's why Suga said he made melody to this song. But for sure he didn't mean the whole song and for sure he didn't make instrumental track.
@@mono-mq2ph Exatly. There are some seldom cases in their ot7 songs though, like j-hope doesn't have credits in Anpanman or SUGA in Mic Drop , and both don't have credits in Fake Love, but in their subunit songs, the rap line always have songwriting credits at least for their rap verses, all three members.
AHHHHHHH the thing about Suga's use of breath as part of his vocals!!!! THAT!!!! That's honestly one of the things I love so much about listening to his vocal performances, live or in studio.
You should recat to BTS ROOM LIVE for their 2021 FESTA. It was so good and they all had their time to shine, it's about 10 minutes long and they're in a live room, singing short sections of multiple songs.
I really appreciate you reacting to BTS again and especially giving time to the rap line! Not a lot of vocal coach reactors dig into the rappers but it really takes a lot of technique to do what they do and they've spent a decade honing their crafts. They're each so unique too so it's really cool to hear appreciation and understanding of the technicality of their rap. Like they're not just speaking over a beat. They're very nuanced and intentional with their delivery. The least we can do is take the time to examine and appreciate it.
It's both Tear 😢 and Tear -to rip and Fear. 😂😂 Missed you 💜 It is "flowery-ier" 😂. Beautiful, deep and hauntingly sad is how I like to describe it. Loved your Outro 😄
#YOONGI #SUGA wrote #TEAR when BTS considered disbanding.. rap line joined in & added to the song… #SUGA has a powerful POETIC writing skill that always amazes me
Also you've probably already been told this in the comments, but this song was written by Yoongi (Suga) back when BTS was thinking about breaking up. He brought it to them and they all cried over it. I don't know how these three even perform this powerful and deeply emotional, personal song without crying tbh
I was wondering what you would think of a rap-line track, and you knocked it out of the park as usual! Thanks for the breakdown of their vocal techniques while rapping!
People in the comments, please be careful with misinfo. All of the rappers are included as songwriters. The rappers always write their own stuff (save for in foreign language songs). Suga wrote his stuff. RM and j-hope wrote their's. And I think the instrumental was composed by someone else entirely. Look at the song credits. It's right there.
I think what happens is that people who are not familiar with the mechanics of song production hear "So-and-so (Suga in this case) brought the song to us..." and think it means the complete song. It really means that he brought something that *became* the song -- a verse, a hook, a beat, some combination -- and then many other hands touched it, added to it, and helped shape it.
@@sarahy1680 one more reason to react and correct them, educate them. Finding excuses for their behavior and turn a blind eye when armys misinform everyone around and spread fake stuff is the worst thing you can do.
@@ninecats5814 I think there's a difference between "fake" information and "incomplete" or "misinterpreted" information. It isn't "finding excuses" to pinpoint *why* people might not understand something and thus pass it on incorrectly. Most people not knowledgeable about the mechanics of music production aren't going to hear the simple quote "Suga brought us the song" and realize that that's just the beginning of a process.
@@sarahy1680 they should never teach others about songwriting not knowing official credits. Credits are the most important and accurate source. You all are just too lazy to read them but spend hours on reading bts fanfics and checking out dating/shipper rumors. If someone is claiming that Suga wrote the whole song by his own it is not a "half truth" it is called discrediting several other people involved including two other BTS members. it is a lie.
@@ninecats5814 For heaven's sake, they're repeating a quote from the members themselves. Members who didn't then clarify how the whole songwriting process works either. This is neither discrediting nor lying. It is how normal people talk and share information. Every interaction need not be a lecture.
In those melodic parts sometimes you can hear a backing track, BTS rappers use it very seldom but in this case because on the album version there was layered heavy "autotune" effect to some parts, probably for "aesthetic" reason that autotune effect was preserved for the live version by adding quite loud backing track in places. It is the most prominent in SUGA's singing parts (chorus and the bridge). So no, that wan't two members singing/harmonizing together.
I think how you described jhopes tone is really spot on. i wonder how much of that is purposeful to go along w the concept of the song and how much is just natural for him. hobi's speaking voice is very distinct in a similar way
O O O O O!!!! What a treat indeed for today. Hi hi, nice to have you back with us. This song is one of my top 3 BTS songs. Thank you!!! This was at Wembley.
I wasn't sure how a vocal coach was gonna analyze a rap, and I was pleasantly surprised. (admittedly, I don't know anything about vocal coaching lol) Enjoyed your reaction!
Wow Tear wasn't expecting this but I love it go you, so much emotion on this track. Literally sent all us fans into tears when we found out why they wrote it 😭💜
The rapline (not just Suga, ALL OF THEM) wrote this song for the members. it is ostensibly a break up song that closes the story of LY Tear, but it was written while the members were considering disbanding
There are three type of TEARs here: (1) Break, (2) Cry, (3) Heal On 3, T.E.A.R. means 4 tasks of mourning. Psychologist J. William Worden provides a framework of 4 tasks that help us understand how people journey through grief. Healing happens gradually as grievers address these tasks, in no specific order, going back and forth from one to another over time. : Task 1: 'T'o Accept the Reality of the Loss : Task 2: 'E'xperience the Pain of Grief : Task 3: 'A'djust to a World Without the Deceased : Task 4: 'R'einvest yourself into the world This song is the perfect outro for whats to come: Love Yourself: Answer album.
Thank you so much for this! 💜 It’s so rare to see a vocal breakdown of rap, and that’s a shame. Such an emotional song, you can tell in both the recording and live performances that they really put everything they had into it.
You should react to The Truth Untold live. One of my favorite live performances, and they do a great job! I love your breakdowns of their voices. I find myself trying to copy the examples you give as well to see how the different anatomy works. Haha! Great videos!
Ugh. I get emotional everytime I hear it, even without knowing the context. The way they emote is powerful. Thank you for choosing a good quality video too!
I saw them live in 2018 and this song was so intense and emotional, the whole stadium was lit up with green lighting and the song hit us so hard. They're such incapacitating performers
loved this video! even though this is not a singing video, i think you explained the members’ rapping styles really well. rm’s rapping that feels like he’s punching you with the words, suga’s unique sharp intakes of breath and j-hope’s cries at the end of the lines - you captured it all. i always look forward to your bts reactions, hope to see more of them in the future💜
Tear is my favorite Rap Line song! Actually probably my favorite song by BTS ever because of the lyrics and meaning and background behind the song. I love when vocal coaches react to rap songs because there’s so much control and nuance involved in rapping that many people will overlook because they think rappers are just “speaking really fast” or something. Thanks for your reaction💜💜
It is so rare to get a technical description of the vocal qualities of these three rappers. It was so interesting to hear you describe the differences in the three!! I really appreciate your reactions. I have missed them. So glad to have this one. 💜
In case other Army don't tell you, Sam, Suga wrote this song for the BTS members when they were considering disbanding in 2018. When he was done he gathered them together and played it, and they all cried together. We only found out about this after the release.
why are you spreading misinfo? All three members have writing/composing credits on this song. All of them wrote their respective verses and the main instrumental theme of this song was composed by Shin Myung-Soo. Most of ARMYS just don't read official credits at all and write whatever they have heard on social media. They think Suga wrote the whole song just because in one interview he said: "this song was written", not "I wrote it". People are really disrespectful and say lots of misleading stuff. Credits are: writing/composing: Shin Myung-Soo, DOCSKIM, Suga, RM, j-hope producing: DOCSKIM the rap line also has credits as recording engineers. In that interview Suga also talked he made melody for Outro: Tear, but he didn't tell specifically for which part of the song, and again people assumed he composed everything which is not true. As I said the main composer is Shin Myung-Soo. Earlier he made instrumental track to BTS Highlight Reel, a long piece for their Bangtan Universe storyline (a fictional storyline that has all the BTS members playing their own character). And in that instrumental piece, there is a fragment almost identical to this song, with piano notes at the start and orchestration ect. So idk why people never mention him when he is credited 1st (in order) in official credits. Anyway RM in his vlive talked about members' involvement ans said Suga's version of melody line used in chorus (and maybe a bridge part too) was chosen by the producer so that's why Suga said he made melody to this song. But for sure he didn't mean the whole song and for sure he didn't make instrumental track
@@LynnHermione fandom is so disrespectful, always tell reactors that SUGA wrote the whole song. It's been like that since Suga's interview. They never read official credits and spread bullsh1t on social media. Never cite RM who talked so much about the writing process of this song after Tear album was released, RM always talk about all people involvement, he is thoughtful to give credits to all members and in-home producers/composers, and then two years later SUGA said some stuff about Tear, he talked only about himself (didn't mention anybody else) and suddenly he is the main and only songwriter glorified by the whole fandom. I just cant with those fakers.... they all love to teach others, new fans and reactors but are too lazy to even read official credits.
Thank you so so much for reacting to more BTS - fascinating breakdown as always! I'm continuing my quest to get a reaction to Day6 "I'll try". Such beautiful harmonies
BTS lyrics are very poetic with lots of content. This is one of my favorite rapline songs, full of emotion. This song was written by Suga at a time where the boys were contemplating disbandment and is about their parting. The emotion is very real for us all especially when we found out after the fact. Ive seen this performed live 3 times and it is INTENSE. It leaves us all in beautiful tears.
Your videos are a delight. I'm not in this field, but I like how you explain the voice! (I'm studying medicine, so maybe that's why I like your anatomy based style so much)
I rrally enjoyed your breaking down a rapline song. This song makes me cry everytime I hear it. As a lover of Shakespeare, part of the reason I adore BTS is the lyricism. The depth of meaning, the alliteration, the poetry, they pay attention to all those things. Just brilliant. 😘💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Did anyone else just now realize that Suga's line in this song "Yeah yeah burn it" is the same as in his song "Burn It" from his Agust D, D-2 album (the song with MAX)?
One of my favorite things Yoongi does is take those super loud sharp breaths! I never ever enjoyed hearing that and now, it isn’t a Yoongi verse or song until I hear him do it. When he does it throughout Daechwita it’s music to my ears. It’s definitely his trademark. I can understand some people might not like it and others have pointed it out that they are trained not to do that but it definitely makes his delivery unique.
I’ve been with you since you started doing BTS reactions....and...I’m so happy you are finally doing this song live! The rappers are as amazing as the singers.
I am so thankful that you did this reaction, even tho it was the rapping live. I am always on verge of tears when I listen to Hobi's end line. So emotional! I truly appreciate every BTS video you do! I very much enjoy your commentary and facial reactions to their performances. You as a personality are just my cup of tea (I know it is maybe a weird thing to say, but I hope you understand). Once again, thank you! Hope to see another one in the future. Greetings and love from Serbia.
I love it that you analyze rap vocals. A lot of people think there isn't any special technique or training needed to rap. Isn't that crazy??? 😋 You are spot on with SUGA's breath. It's one of his signatures to add gasps, hums, growls, spits, trills, and laughs. He's like the bjork of rap. Ha only joking.
I missed you! didn't get the notifications for any of your videos and when I saw you, you made my day. Btw, this song is amazing, and the first time I heard it without knowing its true meaning, still made my heart ache.
I knew it was a smart idea to turn your notifs on even if they come late😢. And to answer your questions the song is about both meanings of "tear" it was written during the time they thought they're gonna disband (but we didn't know that at that time, we thought it's a breakup song😅) and it was written by the rap line (they always write their own verses) they always write verses with really deep meaning. Oh and yes you got j-hope and suga right.
Hello nice reaction. Dam it is soooo cool to hear a vocal teacher react to rapper with solid technique. I loved it ! Maybe you ve heard it but they released an Anthology album PROOF before focusing on their solo careers and their personal lives even though they will still have some group activity but less than before. They performed a mini PROOF concert with a live band and chorus in the middle of Las Vegas desert. They sung 3 songs : Born singers (old song but remixed), Yet to come (new title track) with Anderson Paak at drums and For Youth (New song). It was fantastic, great vibes. So if you have some time maybe you could react to it. Thank You 💜
Hello i really enjoy how u explain each members' voices it's captivating 🤓 Have u listened to the HUG ME cover with V and J.Hope ? I noticed that u react to lives. So sad there is no live of Christmas tree and Snow Flower by V. I would have loved hear u dive into those beautiful songs. Ty for your work i love it 👍💜
Great to hear you review BTS again. This is one of my favourite rap songs. Who would have thought at my age I would come to love rap but as you said the lyrics to me are what make their raps special and worth listening to.The vocals have released some work worth your review lately. V and Jin both released an OST a song that is used in a Korean dram and soon will be released a Jungkook/Suga collaboration of an OST of their new Webtoon. V is a lovely song very modern, very V, blends well with the drama. Jin's is more a dramatic song to match the drama and is my personal favourite. Waiting patiently for Suga/Jungkooks. Would love you to review them. Glad your well. Regards Alwena 😍
Good to see you in the bts universe again. There are alot of good live performances with ot7. Maybe try the live from the latest LA concerts (audecity has a dynamite /butter version)
It was so nice to see a return to BTS content. If you're looking for something with more vocals, I suggest "Film Out". It's been so long that I don't really remember which songs you have already reacted to, but I do know you haven't reacted to Jin's recent OST, "Yours" and it's really gorgeous. I'd love to hear your thoughts on it.
Interesting that you should mention the lyrics...ALL of BTS lyrics are deep..at least all of the songs they write and produce. This one is especially raw because of when and why it was written. BTS is the only rap I like. They've wrecked me for all others.
J-Hope's part at the end always gets me 100% :(( so heart breaking
“Is this song tear or tear?”
…yes.
These mofo geniuses getting their word play on even in a second language.
I love learning Korean and about Korean language not in hopes I will ever be fluent (highly doubtful) but just so I can appreciate BTS’ bars. The layers of wordplay is stupid
I can’t stop laughing at your first paragraph🤣 Facts!
100% right you are they’re incredible with words it’s ridiculous
This is one of my ABSOLUTELY FAVOURITE songs by BTS. It's so captivating and mesmerising... Thanks for the reaction!
This song is a masterpiece
Both...RM tear (crying).....Suga tear as in (torn)...and J Hope Fear ....Suga wrote this when they were considering disbandment after a really hard year💜
j-hope's part is my favorite, his live delivery and his intense and emotive rapping always move me so much. Love it. He raps like he dances, great flows and great moves, always passionate.
I agree. J Hope raps exactly as you described. He’s so unique to me.
Get's me too.
tear was written for the members when they almost disband. all the members were literally in tears after they heard the guide/ read the lyrics.
why are you spreading misinfo?
All three members have writing/composing credits on this song. All of them wrote their respective verses and the main instrumental theme of this song was composed by Shin Myung-Soo.
Most of ARMYS just don't read official credits at all and write whatever they have heard on social media. They think Suga wrote the whole song just because in one interview he said: "this song was written", he didn't say "I wrote it". People are really disrespectful and say lots of misleading stuff.
Credits are:
writing/composing: Shin Myung-Soo, DOCSKIM, Suga, RM, j-hope
producing: DOCSKIM
the rap line also has credits as recording engineers.
In that interview Suga also talked he made melody for Outro: Tear, but he didn't tell specifically for which part of the song, and again people assumed he composed everything which is not true. As I said the main composer is Shin Myung-Soo. Earlier he made instrumental track to BTS Highlight Reel, a long piece for their Bangtan Universe storyline (a fictional storyline that has all the BTS members playing their own character). And in that instrumental piece, there is a fragment almost identical to this song, with piano notes at the start and orchestration ect. So idk why people never mention him when he is credited 1st (in order) in official credits.
Anyway RM in his vlive talked about members' involvement ans said Suga's version of melody line used in chorus (and maybe a bridge part too) was chosen by the producer so that's why Suga said he made melody to this song. But for sure he didn't mean the whole song and for sure he didn't make instrumental track.
@@uvayakone9281 yes, that right
all 3 wrote it . none of the rapline rap on smth somoene else wrote
@@mono-mq2ph Exatly. There are some seldom cases in their ot7 songs though, like j-hope doesn't have credits in Anpanman or SUGA in Mic Drop , and both don't have credits in Fake Love, but in their subunit songs, the rap line always have songwriting credits at least for their rap verses, all three members.
@@uvayakone9281 im just pertaining to this th-cam.com/video/wFNmiUSJg4I/w-d-xo.html
thanks for the clarifications.
AHHHHHHH the thing about Suga's use of breath as part of his vocals!!!! THAT!!!! That's honestly one of the things I love so much about listening to his vocal performances, live or in studio.
It actually rhymes in Korean, so it's not prose, it's more - it's poetry...
You should recat to BTS ROOM LIVE for their 2021 FESTA. It was so good and they all had their time to shine, it's about 10 minutes long and they're in a live room, singing short sections of multiple songs.
I really appreciate you reacting to BTS again and especially giving time to the rap line! Not a lot of vocal coach reactors dig into the rappers but it really takes a lot of technique to do what they do and they've spent a decade honing their crafts. They're each so unique too so it's really cool to hear appreciation and understanding of the technicality of their rap. Like they're not just speaking over a beat. They're very nuanced and intentional with their delivery. The least we can do is take the time to examine and appreciate it.
It's both Tear 😢 and Tear -to rip and Fear. 😂😂 Missed you 💜
It is "flowery-ier" 😂.
Beautiful, deep and hauntingly sad is how I like to describe it.
Loved your Outro 😄
#YOONGI #SUGA wrote #TEAR when BTS considered disbanding.. rap line joined in & added to the song… #SUGA has a powerful POETIC writing skill that always amazes me
Also you've probably already been told this in the comments, but this song was written by Yoongi (Suga) back when BTS was thinking about breaking up. He brought it to them and they all cried over it. I don't know how these three even perform this powerful and deeply emotional, personal song without crying tbh
also the start about whether it’s called tear or tear and me knowing it’s both 😂 hahahaha
Thank you for the technical breakdown of the vocal dynamics.
Tear is so emotional 😭😭😭😭😭but the live is 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
I was wondering what you would think of a rap-line track, and you knocked it out of the park as usual! Thanks for the breakdown of their vocal techniques while rapping!
People in the comments, please be careful with misinfo. All of the rappers are included as songwriters. The rappers always write their own stuff (save for in foreign language songs). Suga wrote his stuff. RM and j-hope wrote their's. And I think the instrumental was composed by someone else entirely. Look at the song credits. It's right there.
I think what happens is that people who are not familiar with the mechanics of song production hear "So-and-so (Suga in this case) brought the song to us..." and think it means the complete song. It really means that he brought something that *became* the song -- a verse, a hook, a beat, some combination -- and then many other hands touched it, added to it, and helped shape it.
@@sarahy1680 one more reason to react and correct them, educate them. Finding excuses for their behavior and turn a blind eye when armys misinform everyone around and spread fake stuff is the worst thing you can do.
@@ninecats5814 I think there's a difference between "fake" information and "incomplete" or "misinterpreted" information. It isn't "finding excuses" to pinpoint *why* people might not understand something and thus pass it on incorrectly. Most people not knowledgeable about the mechanics of music production aren't going to hear the simple quote "Suga brought us the song" and realize that that's just the beginning of a process.
@@sarahy1680 they should never teach others about songwriting not knowing official credits. Credits are the most important and accurate source. You all are just too lazy to read them but spend hours on reading bts fanfics and checking out dating/shipper rumors.
If someone is claiming that Suga wrote the whole song by his own it is not a "half truth" it is called discrediting several other people involved including two other BTS members. it is a lie.
@@ninecats5814 For heaven's sake, they're repeating a quote from the members themselves. Members who didn't then clarify how the whole songwriting process works either. This is neither discrediting nor lying. It is how normal people talk and share information. Every interaction need not be a lecture.
In those melodic parts sometimes you can hear a backing track, BTS rappers use it very seldom but in this case because on the album version there was layered heavy "autotune" effect to some parts, probably for "aesthetic" reason that autotune effect was preserved for the live version by adding quite loud backing track in places. It is the most prominent in SUGA's singing parts (chorus and the bridge). So no, that wan't two members singing/harmonizing together.
I think how you described jhopes tone is really spot on. i wonder how much of that is purposeful to go along w the concept of the song and how much is just natural for him. hobi's speaking voice is very distinct in a similar way
OMG YES
OUTRO: TEAR SUPREMACY
its rare for a vocal coach to talk about hiphop/rap songs. i know there a lot of vocal technique etc that they can share with the viewer. thanks!!!!
Thanks for the reaction. Tear is a work of art, I love this rap, RM, JHope, Yoongi were epic in this stage.
O O O O O!!!! What a treat indeed for today. Hi hi, nice to have you back with us. This song is one of my top 3 BTS songs. Thank you!!!
This was at Wembley.
Let's go so happy you are back and what a way to come back.
I wasn't sure how a vocal coach was gonna analyze a rap, and I was pleasantly surprised. (admittedly, I don't know anything about vocal coaching lol) Enjoyed your reaction!
Wow Tear wasn't expecting this but I love it go you, so much emotion on this track. Literally sent all us fans into tears when we found out why they wrote it 😭💜
The rapline (not just Suga, ALL OF THEM) wrote this song for the members. it is ostensibly a break up song that closes the story of LY Tear, but it was written while the members were considering disbanding
There are three type of TEARs here:
(1) Break, (2) Cry, (3) Heal
On 3, T.E.A.R. means 4 tasks of mourning. Psychologist J. William Worden provides a framework of 4 tasks that help us understand how people journey through grief. Healing happens gradually as grievers address these tasks, in no specific order, going back and forth from one to another over time.
: Task 1: 'T'o Accept the Reality of the Loss
: Task 2: 'E'xperience the Pain of Grief
: Task 3: 'A'djust to a World Without the Deceased
: Task 4: 'R'einvest yourself into the world
This song is the perfect outro for whats to come: Love Yourself: Answer album.
the fact that he didn't even know it was the rapline only😆 Sir you're so hilarious without even trying... that's so RM😆
Oh my god! Tear!!!!!! You made my day with this reaction.
Rm sing from the brain 💜
Jhope sing from the heart 💜
Suga sing from the soul 💜
Thank you so much for this! 💜 It’s so rare to see a vocal breakdown of rap, and that’s a shame. Such an emotional song, you can tell in both the recording and live performances that they really put everything they had into it.
I looove this song! The meaning behind it is really emotional and deep! thank you for reacting to this :)
You should react to The Truth Untold live. One of my favorite live performances, and they do a great job!
I love your breakdowns of their voices. I find myself trying to copy the examples you give as well to see how the different anatomy works. Haha! Great videos!
Ugh. I get emotional everytime I hear it, even without knowing the context. The way they emote is powerful. Thank you for choosing a good quality video too!
All three put their heart in their verses.. its so beautiful
The beginning of that video gives me CHILLS! I WANT TO BE IN THAT CROWD 😭
I saw them live in 2018 and this song was so intense and emotional, the whole stadium was lit up with green lighting and the song hit us so hard. They're such incapacitating performers
I've missed your bts reactions!
loved this video! even though this is not a singing video, i think you explained the members’ rapping styles really well. rm’s rapping that feels like he’s punching you with the words, suga’s unique sharp intakes of breath and j-hope’s cries at the end of the lines - you captured it all. i always look forward to your bts reactions, hope to see more of them in the future💜
Saw their performance live in London, 2018, and this song was amazing
Really interesting to hear your perspective as a vocal coach on this even though it was rap! It made me understand it quite differently
omg im so excited for this
Tear is my favorite Rap Line song! Actually probably my favorite song by BTS ever because of the lyrics and meaning and background behind the song. I love when vocal coaches react to rap songs because there’s so much control and nuance involved in rapping that many people will overlook because they think rappers are just “speaking really fast” or something. Thanks for your reaction💜💜
It is so rare to get a technical description of the vocal qualities of these three rappers. It was so interesting to hear you describe the differences in the three!! I really appreciate your reactions. I have missed them. So glad to have this one. 💜
In case other Army don't tell you, Sam, Suga wrote this song for the BTS members when they were considering disbanding in 2018. When he was done he gathered them together and played it, and they all cried together. We only found out about this after the release.
All of them wrote it, the rapline writes their own verses
why are you spreading misinfo?
All three members have writing/composing credits on this song. All of them wrote their respective verses and the main instrumental theme of this song was composed by Shin Myung-Soo.
Most of ARMYS just don't read official credits at all and write whatever they have heard on social media. They think Suga wrote the whole song just because in one interview he said: "this song was written", not "I wrote it". People are really disrespectful and say lots of misleading stuff.
Credits are:
writing/composing: Shin Myung-Soo, DOCSKIM, Suga, RM, j-hope
producing: DOCSKIM
the rap line also has credits as recording engineers.
In that interview Suga also talked he made melody for Outro: Tear, but he didn't tell specifically for which part of the song, and again people assumed he composed everything which is not true. As I said the main composer is Shin Myung-Soo. Earlier he made instrumental track to BTS Highlight Reel, a long piece for their Bangtan Universe storyline (a fictional storyline that has all the BTS members playing their own character). And in that instrumental piece, there is a fragment almost identical to this song, with piano notes at the start and orchestration ect. So idk why people never mention him when he is credited 1st (in order) in official credits.
Anyway RM in his vlive talked about members' involvement ans said Suga's version of melody line used in chorus (and maybe a bridge part too) was chosen by the producer so that's why Suga said he made melody to this song. But for sure he didn't mean the whole song and for sure he didn't make instrumental track
@@LynnHermione fandom is so disrespectful, always tell reactors that SUGA wrote the whole song. It's been like that since Suga's interview. They never read official credits and spread bullsh1t on social media. Never cite RM who talked so much about the writing process of this song after Tear album was released, RM always talk about all people involvement, he is thoughtful to give credits to all members and in-home producers/composers, and then two years later SUGA said some stuff about Tear, he talked only about himself (didn't mention anybody else) and suddenly he is the main and only songwriter glorified by the whole fandom. I just cant with those fakers.... they all love to teach others, new fans and reactors but are too lazy to even read official credits.
just quick correction for those saying suga wrote the song. he came up with idea but all 3 write their own verses
MY FAVORITE SONG BY THE RAP LINE OF ALL THE TIME
As for the question at the beginning: yes.
Thank you so so much for reacting to more BTS - fascinating breakdown as always! I'm continuing my quest to get a reaction to Day6 "I'll try". Such beautiful harmonies
I'm fascinated that you chose to react to a rap line song!
BTS lyrics are very poetic with lots of content. This is one of my favorite rapline songs, full of emotion. This song was written by Suga at a time where the boys were contemplating disbandment and is about their parting. The emotion is very real for us all especially when we found out after the fact. Ive seen this performed live 3 times and it is INTENSE. It leaves us all in beautiful tears.
I love hearing you use vocal terminology.
Your BTS reactions are my favourite.
Your videos are a delight. I'm not in this field, but I like how you explain the voice! (I'm studying medicine, so maybe that's why I like your anatomy based style so much)
I rrally enjoyed your breaking down a rapline song. This song makes me cry everytime I hear it. As a lover of Shakespeare, part of the reason I adore BTS is the lyricism. The depth of meaning, the alliteration, the poetry, they pay attention to all those things. Just brilliant. 😘💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Did anyone else just now realize that Suga's line in this song "Yeah yeah burn it" is the same as in his song "Burn It" from his Agust D, D-2 album (the song with MAX)?
One of my favorite things Yoongi does is take those super loud sharp breaths! I never ever enjoyed hearing that and now, it isn’t a Yoongi verse or song until I hear him do it. When he does it throughout Daechwita it’s music to my ears. It’s definitely his trademark. I can understand some people might not like it and others have pointed it out that they are trained not to do that but it definitely makes his delivery unique.
I really love the way you explain! You're amazing! Thank you! 💜
I’ve been with you since you started doing BTS reactions....and...I’m so happy you are finally doing this song live! The rappers are as amazing as the singers.
More BTS reactions please!
I am so thankful that you did this reaction, even tho it was the rapping live. I am always on verge of tears when I listen to Hobi's end line. So emotional! I truly appreciate every BTS video you do! I very much enjoy your commentary and facial reactions to their performances. You as a personality are just my cup of tea (I know it is maybe a weird thing to say, but I hope you understand). Once again, thank you! Hope to see another one in the future. Greetings and love from Serbia.
aaaaaahhh how i missed your accent, i love your BTS reactions
I love watching your breakdown of their songs and singing. Your videos are always so informative.. Thank you Sam ☺
as always, I really enjoyed watching your analysis of bts' vocal work. and I loved that it was this song!
I love it that you analyze rap vocals. A lot of people think there isn't any special technique or training needed to rap. Isn't that crazy??? 😋
You are spot on with SUGA's breath. It's one of his signatures to add gasps, hums, growls, spits, trills, and laughs. He's like the bjork of rap. Ha only joking.
Thank you so much for reacting to BTS again!💜
I missed you! didn't get the notifications for any of your videos and when I saw you, you made my day. Btw, this song is amazing, and the first time I heard it without knowing its true meaning, still made my heart ache.
I knew it was a smart idea to turn your notifs on even if they come late😢. And to answer your questions the song is about both meanings of "tear" it was written during the time they thought they're gonna disband (but we didn't know that at that time, we thought it's a breakup song😅) and it was written by the rap line (they always write their own verses) they always write verses with really deep meaning. Oh and yes you got j-hope and suga right.
I love this song sooooooooo much.
Yay a bts reaction !! 🤩
Yay you’re back on my recommended!
Thank you Scott!!!
Hello nice reaction. Dam it is soooo cool to hear a vocal teacher react to rapper with solid technique. I loved it !
Maybe you ve heard it but they released an Anthology album PROOF before focusing on their solo careers and their personal lives even though they will still have some group activity but less than before.
They performed a mini PROOF concert with a live band and chorus in the middle of Las Vegas desert. They sung 3 songs : Born singers (old song but remixed), Yet to come (new title track) with Anderson Paak at drums and For Youth (New song).
It was fantastic, great vibes.
So if you have some time maybe you could react to it.
Thank You 💜
Sam please please please do BTS- Film out live performance!! You’re my favorite vocal coach reactor and I would love to see your thoughts on that song
Hello i really enjoy how u explain each members' voices it's captivating 🤓
Have u listened to the HUG ME cover with V and J.Hope ?
I noticed that u react to lives. So sad there is no live of Christmas tree and Snow Flower by V. I would have loved hear u dive into those beautiful songs.
Ty for your work i love it 👍💜
i love tear
Tear & Let Go are bittersweet songs. I hope you could react to Let Go too. Thank you.
Always fascinating, man!
Great to hear you review BTS again. This is one of my favourite rap songs. Who would have thought at my age I would come to love rap but as you said the lyrics to me are what make their raps special and worth listening to.The vocals have released some work worth your review lately. V and Jin both released an OST a song that is used in a Korean dram and soon will be released a Jungkook/Suga collaboration of an OST of their new Webtoon. V is a lovely song very modern, very V, blends well with the drama. Jin's is more a dramatic song to match the drama and is my personal favourite. Waiting patiently for Suga/Jungkooks. Would love you to review them. Glad your well. Regards Alwena 😍
Much as I love the vocal analyses, with this song I don’t care! I just want the lyrics read, digested and appreciated! 😭😭😭😅
i hope for another bts reaction👌❤
I recommend for the next video a vocal one: Jin's song - Abyss.
Emotional poetry rap go listen to RM's wildflower and be amazed at the Youjeens vocals
Crystal Snow live with Jin’s triple highnotes
Please react
Time to react to film out next? 🙏🏼
It's not the Wembley one!! It has to be... it's the best one
💜💜💜💜
Good to see you in the bts universe again. There are alot of good live performances with ot7. Maybe try the live from the latest LA concerts (audecity has a dynamite /butter version)
The breath sounds are on purpose you're right
It was so nice to see a return to BTS content. If you're looking for something with more vocals, I suggest "Film Out". It's been so long that I don't really remember which songs you have already reacted to, but I do know you haven't reacted to Jin's recent OST, "Yours" and it's really gorgeous. I'd love to hear your thoughts on it.
Please react to Film Out live performance
Please do video on [2021 FESTA ] BTS ROOM LIVE #2021BTSFESTA 😊😊😊
What about the breath control? I don’t hear a lot of breathing during RM’s long fast raps!
hi sam!!
I'm so surprised you did reaction BTS rap line.
Interesting that you should mention the lyrics...ALL of BTS lyrics are deep..at least all of the songs they write and produce. This one is especially raw because of when and why it was written. BTS is the only rap I like. They've wrecked me for all others.
It’s both. Teer and tare.
💜