Thank you so much sir. Now these videos are becoming part of my Good habits which make me realise how "higher pleasure" help us to lead good life with happiness and satisfaction. 😊
35:00 Sir locke's state of nature is pre political. Because in Locke's state of nature society exist, where people were good and living in cooperation guided by natural law (social). But there are concerns of interpretation, implementation and adjudication of laws (Pre political).
@@POLSCHELP then we can say that Lockian State of Nature was pre political but not pre social. While Hobbesian State of Nature was pre social as well pre political.
34:21 - Quite confusing - i have analysed it properly about the state of Nature of 3 contractarians 1. HOBBES - PRE SOCIAL & PRE POLITICAL 2. JOHN LOCKE - SOCIAL & PRE POLITICAL 3. ROUSSEAU - SOCIAL - NOVEL SAVAGE - CAN'T SAY PRE POLITICAL - AS HARMONY WAS THERE BUT CIVIL SOCIETY CREATED INEQUALITY IN SOCIETY AND THUS STATE WAS A HIGH DEMAND FOR PROTECTION OF PRIVATE PROPERTY RIGHTS!!
Dear sir with due respect , Answer to the question "lockes view on human nature " should be pre political and social , but that is not mentioned in any option , hence the answer should be option b I,e prepolitical , Reason : if man in state of nature was both political and social , then what is purpose of social contract for Locke
Oh this question always creates confusion ...main point is that Locke didn't considered 'state of nature' as pre-political and pre-social....it is merely absence of any supreme political authority which may adjudicate among differing people.
@@POLSCHELP don't know how to share a screenshot here but I am copy pasting this from Google ,👉For Locke, by contrast, the state of nature is characterized by the absence of government but not by the absence of mutual obligation. Beyond self-preservation, the law of nature, or reason, also teaches “all mankind, who will but consult it, that being all equal and independent, no one ought to harm another in his life, liberty, or possessions.
sir correct sequence of plato's virtues wisdom, courage ,temperance , justice and sir in 15th question none of option matches the exact answer material, formal,efficient, final john raws book the law of people published in 1993
1:08:30 Sir, here also, I think the correct answer is option C. Simple Technique to understand this is that, Courage comes in between the Wisdom and Temperance as this is related to soldier class. Whereas, Justice is the virtue of the state and not any class of people. According to Plato, if the three virtues - Wisdom, Courage and Temperance are followed by three different classes only then the fourth virtue that is Justice will be generated. That mean the state will be a just state. Please let me know your view on it. I am a big admirer of your class.
ur logic and my explanation both indicate towards C but the official ans was A; anyways not imp to discuss, these r questions for rejection, not selection
Thank you so much sir. Now these videos are becoming part of my Good habits which make me realise how "higher pleasure" help us to lead good life with happiness and satisfaction. 😊
Keep doing sir .Thank you for all your efforts and yes we are waiting for examination guide also.
Sure 👍
Bhut mst sir aapke teaching style ka fan ho gya hy bhut help kr rhi h ye video
good wishes;
Thank you so much sir ❤️🙏
35:00 Sir locke's state of nature is pre political.
Because in Locke's state of nature society exist, where people were good and living in cooperation guided by natural law (social). But there are concerns of interpretation, implementation and adjudication of laws (Pre political).
yes...correct
@@POLSCHELP then we can say that Lockian State of Nature was pre political but not pre social. While Hobbesian State of Nature was pre social as well pre political.
yes...right@@NavneetKumar-vf6gq
1:06:12 Sir, Law of the Peoples Published in 1993, according to Google and from few other sources. Please let me know the correct answer.
Correct sequence of plato four virtue is Wisdom, courage, temperance, justice
#Aap ne galat bataya he sequence ko (1.8min)
34:21 - Quite confusing - i have analysed it properly about the state of Nature of 3 contractarians
1. HOBBES - PRE SOCIAL & PRE POLITICAL
2. JOHN LOCKE - SOCIAL & PRE POLITICAL
3. ROUSSEAU - SOCIAL - NOVEL SAVAGE - CAN'T SAY PRE POLITICAL - AS HARMONY WAS THERE BUT CIVIL SOCIETY CREATED INEQUALITY IN SOCIETY AND THUS STATE WAS A HIGH DEMAND FOR PROTECTION OF PRIVATE PROPERTY RIGHTS!!
Hobbes, Locke's state of nature- correct; but of course Rousseau's was pre-political...savage word itself denotes absence of civil society
At 35:40 I surely think it will be 9(b)
yes, pre-political for Locke, and pre-social for Hobbes
Hy sir, i m back. Thanks for ur due efforts
Welcome back...
Thank you so much sir
Thank you sir
Sir, I found your video contents are very helpful and informative but video clarity is a bit issue.
Sir June 2012 ( 3 ) Q. 9 answer is B ( not D ) according to NET
Dear sir with due respect , Answer to the question "lockes view on human nature " should be pre political and social , but that is not mentioned in any option , hence the answer should be option b I,e prepolitical ,
Reason : if man in state of nature was both political and social , then what is purpose of social contract for Locke
Oh this question always creates confusion ...main point is that Locke didn't considered 'state of nature' as pre-political and pre-social....it is merely absence of any supreme political authority which may adjudicate among differing people.
@@POLSCHELP , sir i reiterate my claim that for Locke man was prepolitical but not pre social ... If needed I can post a screenshot here
@@manzoorsheikh8192 yes u shud...will look into...
@@POLSCHELP don't know how to share a screenshot here but I am copy pasting this from Google ,👉For Locke, by contrast, the state of nature is characterized by the absence of government but not by the absence of mutual obligation. Beyond self-preservation, the law of nature, or reason, also teaches “all mankind, who will but consult it, that being all equal and independent, no one ought to harm another in his life, liberty, or possessions.
@@manzoorsheikh8192 How does these lines different then saying Locke's state of nature is not pre-social?
Sir ... Political Science notes buy karna hai....plzzz help 😭
sir correct sequence of plato's virtues
wisdom, courage ,temperance , justice
and sir in 15th question none of option matches the exact answer
material, formal,efficient, final
john raws book the law of people published in 1993
these r as per the official ques/ ans...
will chk
1:08:30 Sir, here also, I think the correct answer is option C. Simple Technique to understand this is that, Courage comes in between the Wisdom and Temperance as this is related to soldier class. Whereas, Justice is the virtue of the state and not any class of people. According to Plato, if the three virtues - Wisdom, Courage and Temperance are followed by three different classes only then the fourth virtue that is Justice will be generated. That mean the state will be a just state. Please let me know your view on it. I am a big admirer of your class.
ur logic and my explanation both indicate towards C but the official ans was A; anyways not imp to discuss, these r questions for rejection, not selection
Sir 8 Hannah Arden
33:24 can you reconfirm plz . Isn't Locke only Pre-Political ? Ans B
This is what I could understand...u may contend ....
@@POLSCHELP sir what exactly does social and pre-social means?
Sir please unhide that previous yr paper analysis , those are very helpful 🙏
those will be updated, fine tuned and re-uploaded for this year's exam...wait
Sir MA syllabus cover
Get the PYQs and mail at dupolschelp2018@gmail.com
Sir kya apke email id mil sakta hai please ... West Bengal set ke questions send karungi
already got them...looking into...
Thank you sir
Thanks sir