It's one of my favorite movies, I've watched it over twenty times and isn't only a menifest against anti-semitisme but against racism in general. One of the best scenes is at the wedding of the black bride, when Pivert's face is black because of the exhaust pipe and all the wedding guests start to congratulate Pivert because he is the father of (another) bride.
My french teacher took my grade 8 class to see this in the theatre in 1974, and I remember cringing even when I was 13. Time to check it out again, thanks!
I am glad i found your stuff and I am learning a bunch from it, but I guess one thing that would be prominent about this movie to French eyes is that it is a Louis de Funes caper, of which there are nearly too many to count, and there is a sort of pattern to all of them, as there is maybe to Peter Sellars movies (Being There excepted). Funes always plays a sort of absurd scheming idiot but it's not so much the plot that's the centre of the movies but the comic dialogue, timing, slapstick. Only fragments of this can possibly survive translation.
Oh my gosh, this movie opened ten days after I was born! Interesting. I grew up across the street from a synagogue--I believe it's the only synagogue in my small California town. The only time I ever saw the inside of it was when my parents used it as a polling place. They forever had problems with the burglar alarm going off; as a kid, I thought it was a little annoying, but as an adult I realized they had the alarm to deter anti-Semitic vandalism.
@@_yiddishkeit Hillariously showing Piver't bigotry comes from utter ignorance. Imagine being mightly suprised that a man named Solomon Schmoll is Jewish.
I have a suspicion this movie arrived at the cultural moment it did for a reason. Despite France's reputation, especially in America, as the nation of "*La Resistance!*" and "*Vive le Revolution!*," France nevertheless had for a very long time (like, a **millenium**), and to some extent today still has, a deeply culturally conservative streak, which included (at least up to the time of this movie) a fair amount of old catholic antisemitism such as that shown by Pivert. No doubt you are aware of the wrongful trial and conviction of Alfred Dreyfus in the late 19th century. But what is less appreciated in the US is that there are very few nations which offered up their Jews to the Nazis more eagerly than France. The national police agency chasing "Rabbi Jacob" in the film is the very same police agency founded to police Vichy France; the duties of which included identifying and rounding up French Jews to be deported to Germany. The first head of which, Maurice Papon, was a member of the French parliament at the time of the film's release. He was not held responsible for his participation in the Holocaust until the 1980s, and was not imprisoned for it until almost the year 2000. And all of this is to say nothing for the French Government's treatment of Algerian people (most of whom were nominally French citizens) during the 1950s and 60s (thus the shout-out to Islam in the film). Suffice to say, France was working some stuff out during this time period.
Great points! There was a lot of cultural subtext in this film that I didn't appreciate as a kid. Also stay tuned for a movie review about The Dreyfus Affair.
I've never seen this film, but I watched the video since from the title I thought I might it a children's film I saw as a child and remember only vaguely. It had a lot of slapstick comedy including rabbis on roller skates, and the main character was a rabbi (or at least a traditionally dressed Hassidic Jew). Does anyone know what this film is?
@@noelstaar Great question, I actually do know. It's the begining of Parshat Yitro. As I'm writing this I'm thinking it might have something to do since it discusses how Moses' father in law Jethro came to visit the Israelites camp in the desert and he was not part of the nation. But I wouldn't read into that since it is the begining of the Torah portion, while the bar mitzvah boy reads a totally different portion right before.
Yes, but even De Funès is a French stereotype, so I don't see the problem here. It actually helps the purpose of that movie, which is to promote tolerance.
Bro I did not know asking a question as a response to a question was a Jewish thing I thought the dude I was talking too was just old 😂😂😂 i thought he just misheard me or is just old and rambling
It's one of my favorite movies, I've watched it over twenty times and isn't only a menifest against anti-semitisme but against racism in general. One of the best scenes is at the wedding of the black bride, when Pivert's face is black because of the exhaust pipe and all the wedding guests start to congratulate Pivert because he is the father of (another) bride.
A good discussion about a film I've seen many times, and always with pleasure.
An absolutely hillarious classic which deserves far more recognition - IMO one of the greates comedies out there.
My french teacher took my grade 8 class to see this in the theatre in 1974, and I remember cringing even when I was 13. Time to check it out again, thanks!
I love this movie, but then again, I love all Louis de Funes movies
I am glad i found your stuff and I am learning a bunch from it, but I guess one thing that would be prominent about this movie to French eyes is that it is a Louis de Funes caper, of which there are nearly too many to count, and there is a sort of pattern to all of them, as there is maybe to Peter Sellars movies (Being There excepted). Funes always plays a sort of absurd scheming idiot but it's not so much the plot that's the centre of the movies but the comic dialogue, timing, slapstick. Only fragments of this can possibly survive translation.
Oh my gosh, this movie opened ten days after I was born! Interesting.
I grew up across the street from a synagogue--I believe it's the only synagogue in my small California town. The only time I ever saw the inside of it was when my parents used it as a polling place. They forever had problems with the burglar alarm going off; as a kid, I thought it was a little annoying, but as an adult I realized they had the alarm to deter anti-Semitic vandalism.
I love the soundtrack of Rabbi Jacob.
This movie has so many quotable lines, if you speak any French.
Agreed! Mine is "Solomon Juif"
@@_yiddishkeit Hillariously showing Piver't bigotry comes from utter ignorance. Imagine being mightly suprised that a man named Solomon Schmoll is Jewish.
LOVE THIS MOVIE !!!
Interesting video
I have a suspicion this movie arrived at the cultural moment it did for a reason.
Despite France's reputation, especially in America, as the nation of "*La Resistance!*" and "*Vive le Revolution!*," France nevertheless had for a very long time (like, a **millenium**), and to some extent today still has, a deeply culturally conservative streak, which included (at least up to the time of this movie) a fair amount of old catholic antisemitism such as that shown by Pivert. No doubt you are aware of the wrongful trial and conviction of Alfred Dreyfus in the late 19th century. But what is less appreciated in the US is that there are very few nations which offered up their Jews to the Nazis more eagerly than France. The national police agency chasing "Rabbi Jacob" in the film is the very same police agency founded to police Vichy France; the duties of which included identifying and rounding up French Jews to be deported to Germany. The first head of which, Maurice Papon, was a member of the French parliament at the time of the film's release. He was not held responsible for his participation in the Holocaust until the 1980s, and was not imprisoned for it until almost the year 2000. And all of this is to say nothing for the French Government's treatment of Algerian people (most of whom were nominally French citizens) during the 1950s and 60s (thus the shout-out to Islam in the film).
Suffice to say, France was working some stuff out during this time period.
Great points! There was a lot of cultural subtext in this film that I didn't appreciate as a kid. Also stay tuned for a movie review about The Dreyfus Affair.
This reminds me of a variation of "Some like it hot"
"Or Yental."
Or "undercover brother."
Or one of many other "Fish out. Of water"movies where people pretend to be. Something that they are not.
I've never seen this film, but I watched the video since from the title I thought I might it a children's film I saw as a child and remember only vaguely. It had a lot of slapstick comedy including rabbis on roller skates, and the main character was a rabbi (or at least a traditionally dressed Hassidic Jew). Does anyone know what this film is?
The name of the film is in the title of the video, and you can watch it by clicking the link in description.
I watched this movie back in 1989 dubbed in Russian. Funny to see this review now...
I need stereotypes to play my records on.
Excellent 😮
Thank you 💛
Still want to watch this movie. This movie was used in a meme too
Curious which moment... Was it the dance?
@@_yiddishkeit yes the dance
@@_yiddishkeit do you know what part of the Torah they were reading in the movie? Is it relevant / connected to the story?
@@noelstaar Great question, I actually do know. It's the begining of Parshat Yitro. As I'm writing this I'm thinking it might have something to do since it discusses how Moses' father in law Jethro came to visit the Israelites camp in the desert and he was not part of the nation. But I wouldn't read into that since it is the begining of the Torah portion, while the bar mitzvah boy reads a totally different portion right before.
😊❤
❤❤❤
I detest this film because of its oh so funny stereotypes. Typically French,-even today!
Yes, but even De Funès is a French stereotype, so I don't see the problem here. It actually helps the purpose of that movie, which is to promote tolerance.
Bro I did not know asking a question as a response to a question was a Jewish thing I thought the dude I was talking too was just old 😂😂😂 i thought he just misheard me or is just old and rambling
OJM is a real thing 😂
(Old Jewish Men on Instagram)
I really must try that.