Paul's high vocal on this is so bizarre melodically, and it really shifts around the vocal range making it extremely difficult. Incredible chord progression too in this song. Great effort breaking it down!
@@twj2002 They weren't singing the same that's the point of this fantastic video. John was singing a "middle Line" or main line if your will. George was signing a lower harmony. Almost a droning mode - no disparagement in this. Beautiful sensitivity and precision in Georges voice specially in the final part. McCartney was singing the high harmony as was adding beautifully to the melody and again such sensitivity. All three voices combined into something special. I find something magical in McCartney's singing. They were singing different but equally important parts of a whole. Take one of them away and its not the same. I've never understood why this song isn't more highly rated..
The Beatles really knew their music... And so do you! My sister and I have been trying to sing this for a long time and you really helped us. Bravo from Greece!
Your voice is so beautiful, I could listen to you all day long! And here you are singing all my favorite songs and breaking them down by vocal part and harmony which I'm always trying to do myself! I finally have a singing partner for harmonies with your TH-cam videos! Thank you so much, Galeazzo!
not only was paul's voice amazing, but he was a musical genius at coming up with harmonies (most of the harmonies were figured out by paul even if john or george ended up signing the part... he had the natural ability, and it was brilliant!)!
@@hohaia01 it is well documented that John asked George Martin what vocal parts will work for the song. John knew the usually 3rd and 5th harmonies but wanted more complexity, given all the interesting chords the song has. Im sure if you look into this youll find this comment by John. Enjoy
This is fantastic. I've been trying to find how to sing this for a long time. Thank you very much for your videos, they're just great. You're very talented :)
So beautiful. The harmonies in Beatles songs at time are so good it's like one angelic voice. Great breakdown and demonstration as usual my friend God bless.
@sndvl1527 Hey sndvl1527 Galeazzo Frudua here. The bad news first :) it's actually George and Paul singing with John. You can clearly identify George's voice steroed in the LOVE version of Because (check akronos93 video) in the left channel "love is old love is new" verse. The good news now: 1) this was also my doubt for years - 2) After playing these incredible tunes since 30y, everyday, just like you, I'm discovering new things and the last good news are that I hope this will last forever!
Seeing the Frudua’s video I realize how George was important to these vocals. Three geniuses… I don’t think that outside UK could have other group like Beatles ❤ That’s a kind of culture of hundred years.
Because the world is round it turns me on Because the world is round, ah Because the wind is high it blows my mind Because the wind is high, ah Love is old, love is new Love is all, love is you Because the sky is blue, it makes me cry Because the sky is blue, ah Ah, ah, ah, ah
Fantastic job of explaining how it was performed, & then performing it himself. He could have performed this himself and sold it under the table as the Beatles, and I doubt many people would have known the difference (speaking of the final version).
Que armonías !! Siempre me llevo a una especie de medioevo y fantasmal , cuando la escuché por primera vez hace ya muchos muchos años me dije estos tipos son extraterrestres ,,como siempre exelente trabajo de la mejor banda que hubo ni habrá ,,saludos !
This is so cool! I thought.. I'd love to see a video where someone shows me exactly how to sing the harmonies of this song. And here it is! There's literally a video for ANYTHING on TH-cam. :D Thanks so much! :)
Celle que je préfère. ...Et vous la chantez merveilleusement bien. Je me suis toujours essayée en voiture à remettre indéfiniment la même chanson et à en chanter les différents voix...j'adore votre travail...😚❤👌
This is great! I really love your harmonies and how you break everything down- I did this on my channel and Sgt. Peppers- can't thank-you enough! -Phil
Your great! It gives people a deep insight to the crazy amazing melodies they were up to, especially agree with you with Paul, he’s just something else…. But love the way your cat just chills in the back ha, got great music taste!
George Harrison is the key in this, and practically in their 3 piece harmonies. I understand Paul's and John's, but George's are the hardest. Amazing job!
Fantastic. I like all you videos - but this is one of the best Beatles songs. You have a GREAT voice and are obviously very talented. Love the videos. Have you recorded any of your own music? keep up the fantastic work.
This one is so impressive that I've never been tempted to learn it. Your tutorial is perfect, but for such an advanced thing haha Like, "I will demonstrate how to jump over a thirty-story building... Now YOU try!" Hahaha no thanks, mate, "A man's got to know his limitations" haha
Love your tutorials man!!! Would you like to do some tutorial of the Bee Gees? Like How Deep Is Your Love? I love The Beatles, they're my favorite band really :D but I'd like to watch a video of you making a Bee Gees's Tutorial, GREETINGS FROM CHILE!
I sing with you !!!!!! :) In your video , I realize Im singing John's part, though, I go high in some places to Paul's part, becauses it's pretty :) lol... ( although, if I was singing my own part in a ensemble, I would stick to the notation, of course :) ) LOVE and THANKS : !!!!
I'm recreating this myself right now and although Paul's is the most challenging due to the range, George's is definitely the strangest most unnatural part to sing.
Chapeaux!!!!!!! Gale, sarà che amo questa canzone, ma questo è uno dei video più belli che abbia mai visto su TH-cam!!!! Dovrebbe avere miliardi di views :) Me lo sto riguardando-riascoltando mentre scrivo questo commento, bravissimo! Credo che non potrei mai ricordarmi nemmeno una di quelle parti così complesse. PS: che applicazione hai usato per fare il video a riquadri?
Ah! Thanks! I see now how they swap up-note-and down-note phrasing. This is what gives that unusual and unexpected twist in harmony; J and P are swapping roles back and forth while G plays it straight. Kewl!
THESE BEATLES LESSONS MAY END! PLEASE DONATE TO KEEP THEM ALIVE!: ➡ goo.gl/ldPTmk -- WATCH HOW I RECORD MY VOCALS! ➡ bit.ly/2B7kgZU
Paul's high vocal on this is so bizarre melodically, and it really shifts around the vocal range making it extremely difficult. Incredible chord progression too in this song. Great effort breaking it down!
All three were singing the same melody how can you possibly focus on McCartney not not see the greatness of the totality?
@@twj2002 They weren't singing the same that's the point of this fantastic video. John was singing a "middle Line" or main line if your will. George was signing a lower harmony. Almost a droning mode - no disparagement in this. Beautiful sensitivity and precision in Georges voice specially in the final part. McCartney was singing the high harmony as was adding beautifully to the melody and again such sensitivity. All three voices combined into something special. I find something magical in McCartney's singing. They were singing different but equally important parts of a whole. Take one of them away and its not the same. I've never understood why this song isn't more highly rated..
@@olavthyvold2288 you are correct! I think that person might be tone deaf!
This makes me regret all them years I smoked. I used to be able to reach Paul's range. Now, I can reach about 2/3.
Children, don't smoke.
Paul smoked too, but his voice is still good for his age.
Imagine where his voice would be if he didn't.
Victor England - sorry Vic, peer group rules, then its addiction.
Simone Gabellini yeah but he didn’t smoke *that* much.
AmberTheBeatles FanaticLol26 Havs you seen photos or footage of him? He and the rest of them smoked like chimneys. Paul started smoking around 13 too
Alguien más se enamoró del gatito? que cute! Hermoso y excelente trabajo, gracias por tus videos!
The Beatles really knew their music... And so do you! My sister and I have been trying to sing this for a long time and you really helped us. Bravo from Greece!
Dang! I didn’t know Paul could sing that high! He really has a wide vocal range!
HIs usable vocal range was and is among the widest in the industry. The same could be said of Linda Ronstadt.
@@VideoNOLA what about Freddie Mercury?
What we’re discovering is that Galeazzo Frudua’s range is equally amazing. Bravo.
The Man of thousand voices...
@@Lucille_McCartney73Paul’s vocal range was even wider than Freddie Mercury’s
Your voice is so beautiful, I could listen to you all day long! And here you are singing all my favorite songs and breaking them down by vocal part and harmony which I'm always trying to do myself! I finally have a singing partner for harmonies with your TH-cam videos! Thank you so much, Galeazzo!
not only was paul's voice amazing, but he was a musical genius at coming up with harmonies (most of the harmonies were figured out by paul even if john or george ended up signing the part... he had the natural ability, and it was brilliant!)!
You don't know that. You're just guessing. John must have had some idea of harmony. He did write the song after all.
@@hohaia01 george martin gave everyone their parts
@@bobbyjewel you were there then, were you?
@@hohaia01 it is well documented that John asked George Martin what vocal parts will work for the song. John knew the usually 3rd and 5th harmonies but wanted more complexity, given all the interesting chords the song has. Im sure if you look into this youll find this comment by John. Enjoy
George Martin arranged these harmonies.
Such love, care and attention to details.... I'm 35 years on singing and playing, and I CAN say: Way to go!!!!! 🙌🏻
This is fantastic. I've been trying to find how to sing this for a long time. Thank you very much for your videos, they're just great. You're very talented :)
Loved the song, but seeing how they were put together makes it even more amazing. Thanks for sharing
Te lo he dicho muchas veces y no me canso...Qué buen trabajo!, con él aprecio mucho más lo buenos que eran mis ídolos...gracias Frudua!
Would gladly buy an album by you! Great voice.
2:55 george
El gran Ichigoblack por aquí, que gusto que tengamos más de un interés común.
¡Qué vivan Los Beatles!
Que demonios ases aki Fred??
Most complex one for sure
Great harmonies on this beautiful song! You are an amazing talent!
Wow...your voice just works so well "With the Beatles" lol nice play on words... but for real your voice is perfect for the Beatles!!!!
Brilliant !!!! It's such a difficult song to Harmonize but you did an excellent job. Well done !!!
So beautiful. The harmonies in Beatles songs at time are so good it's like one angelic voice. Great breakdown and demonstration as usual my friend God bless.
Awesome! You really demonstrate the magic of the Beatles harmonies. Thanks so much!
This is such a good video, my god! The part with all the voices out together was so satisfying.
@sndvl1527 Hey sndvl1527 Galeazzo Frudua here. The bad news first :) it's actually George and Paul singing with John. You can clearly identify George's voice steroed in the LOVE version of Because (check akronos93 video) in the left channel "love is old love is new" verse. The good news now: 1) this was also my doubt for years - 2) After playing these incredible tunes since 30y, everyday, just like you, I'm discovering new things and the last good news are that I hope this will last forever!
Thanks guys it great to know you like and you are getting what you need!
Seeing the Frudua’s video I realize how George was important to these vocals. Three geniuses…
I don’t think that outside UK could have other group like Beatles ❤
That’s a kind of culture of hundred years.
Awesome ! Really shows the Beatles genius yet again!
borrowed genius..mozart's moonlight sonata chords in reverse
@@ultrakoolehhhh, that’s what john said but i dont really hear it
Because the world is round it turns me on
Because the world is round, ah
Because the wind is high it blows my mind
Because the wind is high, ah
Love is old, love is new
Love is all, love is you
Because the sky is blue, it makes me cry
Because the sky is blue, ah
Ah, ah, ah, ah
Fantastic job of explaining how it was performed, & then performing it himself. He could have performed this himself and sold it under the table as the Beatles, and I doubt many people would have known the difference (speaking of the final version).
Que armonías !! Siempre me llevo a una especie de medioevo y fantasmal , cuando la escuché por primera vez hace ya muchos muchos años me dije estos tipos son extraterrestres ,,como siempre exelente trabajo de la mejor banda que hubo ni habrá ,,saludos !
This is so cool! I thought.. I'd love to see a video where someone shows me exactly how to sing the harmonies of this song. And here it is! There's literally a video for ANYTHING on TH-cam. :D Thanks so much! :)
Your video really helped me with my "because" cover. Thank you!!
Thank you so much for these vocal harmony videos! They really help me for my abbey road performance where I have to sing quite a few of the harmonies.
Celle que je préfère. ...Et vous la chantez merveilleusement bien. Je me suis toujours essayée en voiture à remettre indéfiniment la même chanson et à en chanter les différents voix...j'adore votre travail...😚❤👌
This is great! I really love your harmonies and how you break everything down- I did this on my channel and Sgt. Peppers- can't thank-you enough! -Phil
I
George clearly had the most difficult harmony to be in between. He was the balancer between a melody and harmony. Very underrated.
Thank you for this beautiful explanation about “Because”
3:25 There is a cat behind him.
😂
Magnificent musician
Very beautiful, love this grey cat in the back!!!
Incredible
Spectacular
What other words can describe ?❣️
Thank you, the great Beatles Song. Lg from Germany, Ellen ✌❤
Johns voice is very audible in this song. Georges too
That’s because he sings the melody 😁
So simple, yet so amazing! Thank you for putting this up.
Show de bola, parabéns Frudua.
Eyes turning into hearts this is so good! Am trying it out today! :D thanks galeazzo for this work :)
@vince1985yes Thanks ! You need some ear and some experience. I have also been listening to the Baatles since years.
Your great! It gives people a deep insight to the crazy amazing melodies they were up to, especially agree with you with Paul, he’s just something else….
But love the way your cat just chills in the back ha, got great music taste!
George Harrison is the key in this, and practically in their 3 piece harmonies. I understand Paul's and John's, but George's are the hardest. Amazing job!
It's Studio Project B3 condenser mike. I find it to be pretty nice quality for the price!
Fantastic. I like all you videos - but this is one of the best Beatles songs. You have a GREAT voice and are obviously very talented. Love the videos. Have you recorded any of your own music? keep up the fantastic work.
That cat wants to sing! 0:27
@chdodd01 Thanks! You're correct. I remembred they were 4 overdubs but indeed they were 3 so it's surely 9 oparts harmony!
So great! Besides Paul, John and George...You are the Man!
This is difficult...
Sounds like you have had a lot of experience singing in choral groups, in church? Very nice...
@ciclosonico MItico Ciclo! Grazie sono contento che ti piacciano ho usato FInal Cut.
fortissimo!!!! Bravo. Una delle mie canzoni preferite... anticipa il medley... cercherò se l'hai registrato. Grazie! TBC, Elisabetta
Thanks for the tutorials, i accidentally broke my own voice only in 1 day cause of Paul's voice, thanks a lot Paul
i have no idea how i ended up here, but that was brilliant!!!
Thank you.
Simplesmente maravilhoso!!! Obrigada
@BaCkDoOrKaiN It's a Studio Projet B3
This one is so impressive that I've never been tempted to learn it. Your tutorial is perfect, but for such an advanced thing haha
Like, "I will demonstrate how to jump over a thirty-story building... Now YOU try!" Hahaha no thanks, mate, "A man's got to know his limitations" haha
Love your tutorials man!!! Would you like to do some tutorial of the Bee Gees? Like How Deep Is Your Love? I love The Beatles, they're my favorite band really :D but I'd like to watch a video of you making a Bee Gees's Tutorial, GREETINGS FROM CHILE!
Really well done❤
@matco24 yes it si a Yamaha 12 strings
Im GONNA GET THIS!! Thanks so much man
You Are an incredible talent
Thank you.
I sing with you !!!!!! :) In your video , I realize Im singing John's part, though, I go high in some places to Paul's part, becauses it's pretty :) lol... ( although, if I was singing my own part in a ensemble, I would stick to the notation, of course :) ) LOVE and THANKS : !!!!
hey Guy. thank you so much for prepairing the voices of that wonderful songs.what's about SEE THE CHANGES from CROSBY STILLS AND NASH?
Amazing!!!! and just interesting for warior Ukraine!!!Many thanks for yuor greatest lessons!
Thank’s this is exactely what i wish to know.
You're amazing! Thank you so much for your tutorials :)
Sure I will cover them all.
George hacía lo más difícil siempre!
Thank you so much, it help us on smule singer, on make group compile..
Amazing stuff. Always accurate and just like the record.
3:09 the cat likes what it hears. As did I. Great job
LOVE !!!!!!!!!!!!
your voice is so sweet
awesome the beatles and you for showin up this to us, thanks mate
George parts is difficult... tnx for your tutorial ...also love the cat in your table sir
Thanks a lot, very helpfull ! Francine.
Thanks a lot, very good work.....We'll do it with my friends. Thanks so much!!!
the cat! THE CAT! I WANT THE CAT!!!
Good Job!!!! Beatiful cat behind you.rsrs
I'm recreating this myself right now and although Paul's is the most challenging due to the range, George's is definitely the strangest most unnatural part to sing.
amazing master frudua!
just amazing. loved it
MERAVIGLIOSO GALEAZZO !!
Good god that is amazing.
@lgamietea Cool! Glad being of help! Sure will do give me a few time though!
Stunning demonstration... superb for anyone or group wishing to learn this amazing song... love the pussy cat too, cats love quality music!
Have you ever play The Beatles Rock Band on harmonies?
Very cool! And your kitty is so cute
this is amazing. can you do this with Fleetwood Mac songs?
I like when your cat appears! I was surprised it was during the "George" vocal, because my cats always show up during falsetto singing.
Great job, please more tutorials cant wait!!!!!
Chapeaux!!!!!!!
Gale, sarà che amo questa canzone, ma questo è uno dei video più belli che abbia mai visto su TH-cam!!!! Dovrebbe avere miliardi di views :)
Me lo sto riguardando-riascoltando mentre scrivo questo commento, bravissimo!
Credo che non potrei mai ricordarmi nemmeno una di quelle parti così complesse.
PS: che applicazione hai usato per fare il video a riquadri?
EXCELENT VOCAL WORK.
You r the man !!!!
Ah! Thanks! I see now how they swap up-note-and down-note phrasing. This is what gives that unusual and unexpected twist in harmony; J and P are swapping roles back and forth while G plays it straight. Kewl!
quite a good job, but you shifted a bit of john's line into george's: the last note of "it blows my MIND"