Yes, you are correct. I misspoke. CPM 3V is not a stainless steel. To be considered stainless a steel must have at least 12% chromium content. CPM 3V has 7.5%. Thanks for commenting.
Great discussion and review. The SRK is a great classic. Midway USA frequently runs sales on the 3V versions. A while back, I picked up a 3V SRK for under $100 from Midway USA. They offer some great deals.
I just picked up two of them (one in Olive Drab, the other in Flat Dark Earth) in 3V from Midway USA for $100 each. Very happy about the price for this 3V knife!
@@MarkYoungBushcraftFrom MidwayUSA's website: "Due to the variety of regulations controlling shipments outside the U.S., MidwayUSA is unable to process international orders." Sorry.😢
It's always a pleasure to see a review of this excellent knife : the SRK. Three letters that impress, more than the steel of its blade. Thanks, have a great holiday season 2024 👍
Appreciate the great review - and the hard work it took to do it! I thought you might end up going through that log, as much as you were working on it!
Midway USA currently has the FDE version of the SK-5 SRK on sale for $37.95 and the CPM-3V version on sale for $99.99. Both are screaming great deals, but I'd definitely be more excited about the 3V version if I didn't already have 3 copies of that excellent knife.
I have an SRK in SK5 and it serves me just fine. The only knife I currently own in 3V is my Boker Bronco and it's quite nice, but very expensive. I think your assessment at the end of the video is spot on; 3V knives are only worth it if you can afford it and know how to sharpen it. 👍 Thanks for sharing, take care and Cheers!
Right on. Super steels are popular right now and great to own but a person can get more knives for the same money. Thanks for commenting Dave. Hope all is well
Thank you, sir. I appreciate you performing this test. I own both steel variants but never took the time to compare them in the field. I do prefer the 3V version over the SK5, but I think that preference comes from the overall fit and finish. The 3V version I purchased came as close to perfect as you could get, I imagine. In either case, the SRK is a great model.
One of my pet peeves is the constant attention needed on carbon steels. 3V has struck that balance for me in toughness, edge retention and it stainless enough that it lasts for most of my adventures with little to no maintenance, until I’m home reprepping gear for next time. Most of the time my 3V blades just need stropped...
Something as extremely effective as EEZOX or Fluid Film can be used or as food safe as Wicked Wax can be used. I have used EEZOX since 1988. It is toxic and you shouldn't eat it, but after you apply it correctly, its very simple to maintain with a VERY light coat. A2 , CARBON V, and 1095 CV might patina if you just ignore it in common sense storage for a year?. 3V would probably laugh the idea of rust off with EEZOX
Thanks for the Comparison. I've owned the Cold Steel Recon Tanto for 30+ years and haven't been easy on it (it used to be my field knife as a Army Combat Engineer). I recently "retired" it to my car BOB in favor of a custom made field knife. Cold Steel makes quality knives, and now I'm intrigued by the new SRK (damn you Mark! lol).
Hi 👋 Mark Im Glad You Enjoyed My Knife & I Was VERY Impressed With The Edge Retention Of The 3V Version !! Yes It Was Very Expensive But I Have Full Faith It Will Outlast Me (Since I Don't Get In Woods As Much As I Want Too) Take Care Mark & Happy Trails.
Hi Mr. Young. I'd just like to point out, that SK5 steel is prone to chipping and/or breaking in cold conditions. That's the only dowside of it, otherwise it's a great budget carbon steel. Still, if I could choose, I'd make the SRK in 80CrV2, and it would still be a budget blade...
I love my knives made in 80-CrV2. So tough. I have a lot of knives in SK85 and have not had any cold weather chipping, yet. I will be watching for that. Thanks for commenting
Good job Mark. No reason to go through all the otherbull crap. I own them both. I still stick with the SRK 5 on the Homestead cutting some rope a little bit of chopping can’t beat it for the price the new version I keep it in a get home bag again great comparison
Great review, Mark. I've always liked the look of the SRK but haven't been able to talk myself into buying one quite yet. Would love to hear your thoughts on how it compares with the Fallkniven F1, A1 or S1 if you've had a chance to use them. 3V is one of my favourite steels for fixed blade knives. It's got excellent toughness and good wear resistance in the common 58-62 HRC range of heat treatments, it's fairly rust resistant for a non-stainless steel, and it doesn't need specialty diamond stones to sharpen like some other super steels do. The higher price is definitely worth it for people who want to push their knives a little harder and can benefit from the added toughness. As you said, the average person who doesn't use their knives very hard or very often would probably be very happy with either knife and wouldn't see much benefit from splurging on the more expensive version. Heck, the different edge geometries likely affect the average user experience more than the higher end steel would. Thanks again Mark.
To give a different take on the question of whether or not the price difference is worth it. I like to compare each knife as though it was my one and only "survival knife". Being that 3V is no doubt a famously toughter and less likely to snap steel, and can hold a long edge, the answer is already there - yes. Yes it is worth the 3 times price difference. I use the same thinking with led flashlights, in that, the flashlight with the greater ability to utilize super-low lumens settings will always win over the higher lumen light (all other metrics being equal). Why? Conservation of energy is akin to prolonged usage/usefulness. Given there is no way to charge them at the time of usage. Great review, thank you.
Good argument. It did get me thinking about the value of buying three SK5 versions of the SRK as opposed to one 3V version. Personally, I prefer the 3V version. Thanks for commenting
I agree about the hollow grind. I have seen videos where the tip broke off too easily. I don't want to push mine to see if it will happen. Thanks for commenting
G'day Mark, iconic design and there's been quite a few iterations over the years. There was an uproar over too long a ricasso a while back, but looks like thats been sorted. Whilst 3V is not technically a stainless, it is certainly stain ........ less, and yep it's never been a lower budget steel in any brand/design to my knowledge ; ) I've nearly pulled the trigger a few times, though I kinda lost interest after I missed out on a VG-1, or 10, (cant remember), version @ a compelling price point and secondly I have several others of similar design already. However, must say, if I was starting out all over again, it would be one of the first I'd go to. Thanks for your efforts mate, yes a last resort type of application, but that is a capability I'd I expect out of a 5-6 in "secondary" blade out in the sticks ..... regardless of steel, ....mind you, as you so rightly mentioned, an easier honing/maintenance strategy is a very significant consideration, compared to a harder nut to crack out in the field. Cheers Duke. P.S. since I didnt have the foresight to keep an old telephone book or two, next best thing, if you're really fussy about fine paper cut tests, are those (bloody annoying IMO), brochures/catalogues that turn up in ones letter box ........ there is still some justice to be had in the world ; ) ....... I have even more fun with political propaganda, hehehe. Composting or recycling afterwards, of course. .... depending on the ink content. Btw; I believe "newspaper" print, (obviously another good fine paper option), has been rid of the real ink nasties, (lead, arsenic and such), for some years now, .... here anyway, .... though personally I'm not pay'n a coupla knicker everyday ...... just for the crossword, blade testing and compost material ; )
Hi Duke. I think most people do not often think about knife maintenance in the field. I know I am guilty of not packing a stone or even a strop at times. You found a great way to recycle the otherwise useless stuff. Thanks for commenting
I don't understand why anyone would be using their knife as a prying tool? it's for cutting, chopping splitting, but I would never use any knife to do any serious prying. I'd rather have the hollow grind for better cutting.
Really cool🙂 I don’t have an SRK but I have a master hunter in san mai. It works pretty well. I have had amazing 3V knives and crappy 3V knives. I had an adventure sworn mountaineer in 3V. Holy cow it was extreme. I beat on it all day and it was like I never touched it. Freaky sharp. I still have nightmares of selling that knife😬 I’ve also had a benchmade in 3V and it was very disappointing. I think maybe it comes to the heat treatment? I think I would go with the SK5 because it works well enough and I am a weekend warrior lol. Thanks for sharing 😀👍🏻
I got a CPM-3V version and put a new edge on it with the WS Professional Precision Adjust sharpener and it cuts amazing. This steel has surpassed my expectations and I personally think it is worth the extra money. I have thrown the knife also into oak without any problems with tip damage. It is one of my last knives I would expect tip damage with. The way the clip point is cut makes it like a diamond shape and very strong. I may pick up one of the old SK5 models for practicing throwing. Then if I break it or damage the handle it's only about $35.
How about this for a SCREAMING deal: Midway USA has the SK-5 version of the SRK and the Trail Boss axe for $44.99! When you consider the SRK alone is at least $37.95, that means you're getting a really great Cold Steel axe for $7. That is incredible. I don't need another SRK or another axe, and it's such a great deal I'm getting one anyway.
Just ordered the CPM3V version (olive drab handle) from Midway for $100 (that's including shipping and taxes!). Just sold off my older OKC RAT-7, so this will replace that knife. Never liked the RAT-7 micarta handles and it felt heavy and unwieldy. Got the SRK-C last week and love its "goldilocks" size and profile.
3v is my favourite steel for a fix blade . It is not stainless but like d2 it's close . Cold steel are not the best heat treat on 3v . But the steel is still good . 3v is worth every cent you pay . I have broken up 3 red deer with only a few stops to strop .
Yes, I misspoke about 3V being stainless. I pinned a correction comment on the video. I agree, great steel for anyone who will put the time into maintaining it. Thanks for commenting
That would be nice. I may be wrong but I thought CS made the SRK in AUS8 at one time. Not the best steel but not bad. Very tough. Thanks for commenting
If you've need something that will last longer between needing to be sharpened (because you're not able to do so), value the time saving of less overall sharpening (even if a single session takes longer) and don't mind the extra cost the 3v makes sense. If you need something that will work well and don't mind regular touch ups/maintenance, something that has to work well enough for one circumstance, or are going to use it as a tool that could very likely see hard use than the regular might suit you better. I haven't got a need currently that the regular won't fit the bill for, and for far fewer bills out of my wallet. I've also never been a fan of shiny blades on knives, I leave that aesthetic for actual swords.
Hmmmm, the age old question of diminishing returns on more expensive stuff. Always a tough one. Especially with a knife that may take forever to repair damage….or will it not get damaged, etc…. I leather strop my straight razor, but I feel like there isn’t much point with a knife. The edge is so fine and delicate, and knife use can be pretty rough, so that a few uses and it’s back past that point, but there is a great satisfaction in the first few cuts. Hey, I got a question. I know you’ve done at least one video on ferro rods, so do you have a suggestion or two for a good large size one?
How would it (3V) compare to Demko Freereign? Here in the US the prices on Amazon are $127 and $150 respectively. SRK has a full inch blade length advantage, better steel, and no strange pseudo jumping at the top of the blade. Saber grind of Demko is a better geometry for strong tip than clip point, but then again, the SRK is made of a stronger steel. Realistically, you are not going to break either tip unless you do something really stupid. Demko has a better sheath... Anything else?
Coincidently, I have a video coming out soon doing the same test (same day actually) comparing the FreeReign in AUS10A against the FreeReign in Magnacut. I have not yet compared the Magnacut against the 3V. I would have to borrow (or buy) the SRK again. I do a bit of a comparison of design in my FreeReign video. I personally prefer the FreeReign to the SRK. Thanks for commenting
@@MarkYoungBushcraft Thank you, that would be interesting. A fairer comparison would be SRK in 3V VS Demko in AUS10, as even in AUS10 version Demko is the more expensive knife of the two. Magnacut version is unavailable for purchase at this time, and when it becomes available it will be more expensive still.
@@MarkYoungBushcraftJust out of curiosity... is there anything in particular that leads you to prefer the freereign in Magnacut to the SRK in 3V? TIA.
@@cjmutschler Mostly a personal decision. I feel the FreeReign in AUS10A is a stronger design than the SRK in SK5; However, the gap is closer for the knives with the upgrade in steel. For me, I prefer the grip design of the FreeReign and I like that the Magnacut is a stainless steel. Having said that, I would be perfectly happy to own a SRK in 3V
@@MarkYoungBushcraft Thank you for your reply. I had been weighing the purchase of the 3V SRK vs the Magnacut Freereign and whether the Freereign was worth the extra money. Then I found a really good deal on the SRK so it became a less competitive decision.
I'll make it simple for you all. If you want a solid throw away knife, the SK-5 is better. If you want something to pass on to your kids, something that will last and that you can trust, get the 3V.
So, if I send you one of my knives to test, does that mean you’ll eventually own it?…..🤓 On which steal is the best to get, it really depends on how much you really use the knife. If you don’t have or plan on buying a lot of knives, and you don’t mind a spending little more money, then having that one blade that can handle most of the tasks you need can be beneficial. I personally prefer knives that are easier to sharpen in the field. ✌️🇺🇸🇨🇦✌️
You could try sending me one and see what happens😉 I agree, 3V or other "super steels" are worth it if you are willing to maintain them. Thanks for commenting
Either one of them is not worth it in the sense that there are lower (much) priced knives than DO the same job and there are a couple of REAL cheap ones. Maybe my opinion comes from my 89 yr. age. Heck a good axe can do the same(cheap one mind)
Mate I'm 65 and I can see the advantages of good steels against lesser quality. But heat treat also is important. If the heat treat is off , the blade will be poor . My experience is that a better quality steel gets a better heat treat . Otherwise we would learn about it fast and no one would buy it .
Us canadians, may not be, as technologically advanced, but, in canada, cutting a fresh 6" oak, is best left to the chain saw. A real knife test, would be fighting off a po'd 500 lb black bear. Skinning this bear, is also a good test. Perhaps, another test, if you could find a cooperative bruin?
I wish you could see what ive done to my srk Lol. I bought it specifically for a shit knife and it has held up great. Or at least it hasn't broken yet. I use it for just fun brutal dangerous things like stabbing barrels and chopping rocks. Good secondary pack knife for hard tasks so i can spare my decent blades the abuse.
CPM-3V isn’t a stainless steel.
Yes, you are correct. I misspoke. CPM 3V is not a stainless steel. To be considered stainless a steel must have at least 12% chromium content. CPM 3V has 7.5%. Thanks for commenting.
Its close enough.
@@Steve_G88close enough to bust a nut 😮
For all intent and purposes it can be considered a stainless variant. It will take some serious neglect and abuse to genuinely rust it up.
Great discussion and review. The SRK is a great classic. Midway USA frequently runs sales on the 3V versions. A while back, I picked up a 3V SRK for under $100 from Midway USA. They offer some great deals.
Great deal. Not sure if buying from Midway will work for us in Canada but I will check. Thanks for commenting
I just picked up two of them (one in Olive Drab, the other in Flat Dark Earth) in 3V from Midway USA for $100 each. Very happy about the price for this 3V knife!
@@MarkYoungBushcraftFrom MidwayUSA's website: "Due to the variety of regulations controlling shipments outside the U.S., MidwayUSA is unable to process international orders." Sorry.😢
@@charlesp9681same
It's always a pleasure to see a review of this excellent knife : the SRK. Three letters that impress, more than the steel of its blade.
Thanks, have a great holiday season 2024 👍
Thank you and Merry Christmas to you as well
@MarkYoungBushcraft , 🙏🙂
Thanks Mark, another thoughtful, intelligent, inspired review!
Thank you for your kind words
Appreciate the great review - and the hard work it took to do it! I thought you might end up going through that log, as much as you were working on it!
Thank you for your kind words
Midway USA currently has the FDE version of the SK-5 SRK on sale for $37.95 and the CPM-3V version on sale for $99.99. Both are screaming great deals, but I'd definitely be more excited about the 3V version if I didn't already have 3 copies of that excellent knife.
Great idea. I did try parchment in a few versions. Did not use a tube but should have as it tended to break up some. Thanks for commenting
I have an SRK in SK5 and it serves me just fine. The only knife I currently own in 3V is my Boker Bronco and it's quite nice, but very expensive. I think your assessment at the end of the video is spot on; 3V knives are only worth it if you can afford it and know how to sharpen it. 👍 Thanks for sharing, take care and Cheers!
Right on. Super steels are popular right now and great to own but a person can get more knives for the same money. Thanks for commenting Dave. Hope all is well
Thank you, sir. I appreciate you performing this test. I own both steel variants but never took the time to compare them in the field. I do prefer the 3V version over the SK5, but I think that preference comes from the overall fit and finish. The 3V version I purchased came as close to perfect as you could get, I imagine. In either case, the SRK is a great model.
I was very impressed with the 3V version in comparison to the SK5 version. Thanks for commenting
One of my pet peeves is the constant attention needed on carbon steels. 3V has struck that balance for me in toughness, edge retention and it stainless enough that it lasts for most of my adventures with little to no maintenance, until I’m home reprepping gear for next time. Most of the time my 3V blades just need stropped...
I agree. I found the 3V easy to maintain but then again, I have not chipped it. That may take a bit more work. Thanks for commenting
Something as extremely effective as EEZOX or Fluid Film can be used or as food safe as Wicked Wax can be used. I have used EEZOX since 1988. It is toxic and you shouldn't eat it, but after you apply it correctly, its very simple to maintain with a VERY light coat. A2 , CARBON V, and 1095 CV might patina if you just ignore it in common sense storage for a year?. 3V would probably laugh the idea of rust off with EEZOX
3v isnt that rusty tbh
Thanks for the Comparison. I've owned the Cold Steel Recon Tanto for 30+ years and haven't been easy on it (it used to be my field knife as a Army Combat Engineer). I recently "retired" it to my car BOB in favor of a custom made field knife. Cold Steel makes quality knives, and now I'm intrigued by the new SRK (damn you Mark! lol).
Same here. The SRK in 3V was a borrow. Now I am considering buying one. Thanks for commenting
With the sharp 90 degree spine on the 3v in 3/16" you also get a stand alone feather sticker as well as a great scraper. I like it.
Oh yes, much better scrapper for sure. Thanks for commenting
Hadn't thought about that until you said it. Good idea.
One of the cheapest 3V knives you can get, especially at that length and thickness. A fantastic value when I found one for $105 on sale.
Would love to see on for that price in Canada. Thanks for commenting
The "Originals" were in Carbon V, and after that in Aus8. Neither in hollow grind. Both were more "bushcrafty" due to a bigger size ricasso.
Right on. Thanks for commenting
Thanks for your dedication 😊 I hope your joints aren't sore for too long
My shoulders paid for that workout for a few days😅 Thanks for commenting
These SRK and SRK compact were on sale awhile back in 3V for around $70. The carbon versons were much less. Picked up both and a compact 3V version.
Nice find. Have not seen them that cheap here in Canada. Thanks for commenting
Where did you buy them?
Hey Mark, great content! You sold me on the SRK 3V I’ll be ordering mine 😂
Great choice. Thanks for commenting
Midway USA frequently has the 3V version on sale for $100. Totally worth it for the price.
That’s a great deal for the 3V steel. Unfortunately, Midway does not ship to Canada. Thanks for commenting
Hi 👋 Mark
Im Glad You Enjoyed My Knife & I Was VERY Impressed With The Edge Retention Of The 3V Version !!
Yes It Was Very Expensive But I Have Full Faith It Will Outlast Me (Since I Don't Get In Woods As Much As I Want Too)
Take Care Mark & Happy Trails.
It is a very nice knife for sure. Thanks for commenting Derek
You picked a test that would particularly showcase both the steel and the grind, the hollow SK5 can't possibly compete
True, but hopefully a "real world" test and something closer to what a person would actually use their "survival" knife for. Thanks for commenting
Is see House of Knives can’t keep the SK-5 models in stock. I wonder where else I can find the SRK in Canada.
Amazon maybe? Thanks for commenting
Talk about a rigorous test. Thanks for sharing Mark.
Quite a workout. Thanks for commenting Steve
I'm a fan of the CS SRK for sure, i have the older AUS8A version, VG10, and the CPM3V. All Great knives.
Right on. Thanks for commenting
Hi Mr. Young. I'd just like to point out, that SK5 steel is prone to chipping and/or breaking in cold conditions. That's the only dowside of it, otherwise it's a great budget carbon steel. Still, if I could choose, I'd make the SRK in 80CrV2, and it would still be a budget blade...
I love my knives made in 80-CrV2. So tough. I have a lot of knives in SK85 and have not had any cold weather chipping, yet. I will be watching for that. Thanks for commenting
Good job Mark. No reason to go through all the otherbull crap. I own them both. I still stick with the SRK 5 on the Homestead cutting some rope a little bit of chopping can’t beat it for the price the new version I keep it in a get home bag again great comparison
The original is tried and true for sure. Thanks for commenting
@ new subscriber here. I like your style. Man I have a lot of catching up to do on your videos.
Great review, Mark. I've always liked the look of the SRK but haven't been able to talk myself into buying one quite yet. Would love to hear your thoughts on how it compares with the Fallkniven F1, A1 or S1 if you've had a chance to use them.
3V is one of my favourite steels for fixed blade knives. It's got excellent toughness and good wear resistance in the common 58-62 HRC range of heat treatments, it's fairly rust resistant for a non-stainless steel, and it doesn't need specialty diamond stones to sharpen like some other super steels do. The higher price is definitely worth it for people who want to push their knives a little harder and can benefit from the added toughness.
As you said, the average person who doesn't use their knives very hard or very often would probably be very happy with either knife and wouldn't see much benefit from splurging on the more expensive version. Heck, the different edge geometries likely affect the average user experience more than the higher end steel would.
Thanks again Mark.
I would love to try out a Fallkniven but don't own one, yet. Thanks for commenting
To give a different take on the question of whether or not the price difference is worth it. I like to compare each knife as though it was my one and only "survival knife". Being that 3V is no doubt a famously toughter and less likely to snap steel, and can hold a long edge, the answer is already there - yes. Yes it is worth the 3 times price difference. I use the same thinking with led flashlights, in that, the flashlight with the greater ability to utilize super-low lumens settings will always win over the higher lumen light (all other metrics being equal). Why? Conservation of energy is akin to prolonged usage/usefulness. Given there is no way to charge them at the time of usage. Great review, thank you.
Good argument. It did get me thinking about the value of buying three SK5 versions of the SRK as opposed to one 3V version. Personally, I prefer the 3V version. Thanks for commenting
I own the 3v version, I thought about the sk5 version but at the time the hollow grind was a dealbreaker for me.
I agree about the hollow grind. I have seen videos where the tip broke off too easily. I don't want to push mine to see if it will happen. Thanks for commenting
G'day Mark, iconic design and there's been quite a few iterations over the years. There was an uproar over too long a ricasso a while back, but looks like thats been sorted. Whilst 3V is not technically a stainless, it is certainly stain ........ less, and yep it's never been a lower budget steel in any brand/design to my knowledge ; )
I've nearly pulled the trigger a few times, though I kinda lost interest after I missed out on a VG-1, or 10, (cant remember), version @ a compelling price point and secondly I have several others of similar design already. However, must say, if I was starting out all over again, it would be one of the first I'd go to.
Thanks for your efforts mate, yes a last resort type of application, but that is a capability I'd I expect out of a 5-6 in "secondary" blade out in the sticks ..... regardless of steel, ....mind you, as you so rightly mentioned, an easier honing/maintenance strategy is a very significant consideration, compared to a harder nut to crack out in the field.
Cheers Duke.
P.S. since I didnt have the foresight to keep an old telephone book or two, next best thing, if you're really fussy about fine paper cut tests, are those (bloody annoying IMO), brochures/catalogues that turn up in ones letter box ........ there is still some justice to be had in the world ; ) ....... I have even more fun with political propaganda, hehehe.
Composting or recycling afterwards, of course. .... depending on the ink content.
Btw; I believe "newspaper" print, (obviously another good fine paper option), has been rid of the real ink nasties, (lead, arsenic and such), for some years now, .... here anyway, .... though personally I'm not pay'n a coupla knicker everyday ...... just for the crossword, blade testing and compost material ; )
Hi Duke. I think most people do not often think about knife maintenance in the field. I know I am guilty of not packing a stone or even a strop at times. You found a great way to recycle the otherwise useless stuff. Thanks for commenting
Great Side By Side Test Thanks For This & Your Thoughts Mark ! ATB T God Bless
Thanks 👍
I just received my 3V SRK from Midway. I chose the Olive Green and now I gotta get some time off work to go use it.
Midway offers some great deals. Unfortunately, they do not ship to Canada. Thanks for commenting
I don't understand why anyone would be using their knife as a prying tool? it's for cutting, chopping splitting, but I would never use any knife to do any serious prying. I'd rather have the hollow grind for better cutting.
Prying does not make sense to me either unless it is a purpose built survival knife. Even then, I don't think I would. Thanks for commenting
Really cool🙂 I don’t have an SRK but I have a master hunter in san mai. It works pretty well. I have had amazing 3V knives and crappy 3V knives. I had an adventure sworn mountaineer in 3V. Holy cow it was extreme. I beat on it all day and it was like I never touched it. Freaky sharp. I still have nightmares of selling that knife😬 I’ve also had a benchmade in 3V and it was very disappointing. I think maybe it comes to the heat treatment? I think I would go with the SK5 because it works well enough and I am a weekend warrior lol. Thanks for sharing 😀👍🏻
I have heard that about 3V heat treats. Must look at the Adventure Sworn. Thanks for commenting
I got a CPM-3V version and put a new edge on it with the WS Professional Precision Adjust sharpener and it cuts amazing. This steel has surpassed my expectations and I personally think it is worth the extra money. I have thrown the knife also into oak without any problems with tip damage. It is one of my last knives I would expect tip damage with. The way the clip point is cut makes it like a diamond shape and very strong. I may pick up one of the old SK5 models for practicing throwing. Then if I break it or damage the handle it's only about $35.
I am considering buying a 3V version myself. Thanks for commenting
@MarkYoungBushcraft If you can order from Midway where your at they always have a orange handle one on sale for $90.
3V is one of the best steels for a fixed blade, I have a lot of knives with it.
Great steel for sure. Thanks for commenting
How about this for a SCREAMING deal: Midway USA has the SK-5 version of the SRK and the Trail Boss axe for $44.99! When you consider the SRK alone is at least $37.95, that means you're getting a really great Cold Steel axe for $7. That is incredible. I don't need another SRK or another axe, and it's such a great deal I'm getting one anyway.
Nice but they don't ship to Canada. I just tried. Thanks for commenting
I know, about vicious beaver. Was married to one, for 3 years!
😣😅
The top edge if sharpen, gives you a better and stronger edge to remove small limbs. However, it is a negative for batoning. 👍
Ture, a sharp spine is hard on batons and on thumbs when carving. Easy enough to round of a portion of it. Thanks for commenting
Just ordered the CPM3V version (olive drab handle) from Midway for $100 (that's including shipping and taxes!). Just sold off my older OKC RAT-7, so this will replace that knife. Never liked the RAT-7 micarta handles and it felt heavy and unwieldy. Got the SRK-C last week and love its "goldilocks" size and profile.
I just tried to buy this knife from Midway but they don't ship to Canada. Thanks for commenting
My 3v SRK-C is noticeably thicker than my SK5 version at both the spine and tip, is there a difference in the full sized SRK's?
Yes, The SRK in 3V is a tiny bit thicker than the SK5 version. Thanks for commenting
3v is my favourite steel for a fix blade . It is not stainless but like d2 it's close . Cold steel are not the best heat treat on 3v . But the steel is still good . 3v is worth every cent you pay . I have broken up 3 red deer with only a few stops to strop .
Thanks for the review and testing
As much as I like sk5 a hollow grind isn’t my first choice for a survival knife
Yes, I misspoke about 3V being stainless. I pinned a correction comment on the video. I agree, great steel for anyone who will put the time into maintaining it. Thanks for commenting
I wish CS would make the cheaper srk in 14c28n super stainless and almost as tough as 3v.
That would be nice. I may be wrong but I thought CS made the SRK in AUS8 at one time. Not the best steel but not bad. Very tough. Thanks for commenting
If you've need something that will last longer between needing to be sharpened (because you're not able to do so), value the time saving of less overall sharpening (even if a single session takes longer) and don't mind the extra cost the 3v makes sense.
If you need something that will work well and don't mind regular touch ups/maintenance, something that has to work well enough for one circumstance, or are going to use it as a tool that could very likely see hard use than the regular might suit you better.
I haven't got a need currently that the regular won't fit the bill for, and for far fewer bills out of my wallet. I've also never been a fan of shiny blades on knives, I leave that aesthetic for actual swords.
Thanks for commenting
Hmmmm, the age old question of diminishing returns on more expensive stuff. Always a tough one. Especially with a knife that may take forever to repair damage….or will it not get damaged, etc….
I leather strop my straight razor, but I feel like there isn’t much point with a knife. The edge is so fine and delicate, and knife use can be pretty rough, so that a few uses and it’s back past that point, but there is a great satisfaction in the first few cuts.
Hey, I got a question. I know you’ve done at least one video on ferro rods, so do you have a suggestion or two for a good large size one?
As for large ferro rods, the best I have tested so far are the Uberleben. I have yet to test the FireSteel brand ones. Thanks for commenting Jim
Which Tilley hat is that?
My Outback. Thanks for commenting
@@MarkYoungBushcraft Thanks
What's everyone's favorite edc fixed knife under 4 inch blade in cpm3v?
I would be interested in hearing this as well
How would it (3V) compare to Demko Freereign? Here in the US the prices on Amazon are $127 and $150 respectively. SRK has a full inch blade length advantage, better steel, and no strange pseudo jumping at the top of the blade. Saber grind of Demko is a better geometry for strong tip than clip point, but then again, the SRK is made of a stronger steel. Realistically, you are not going to break either tip unless you do something really stupid. Demko has a better sheath... Anything else?
Coincidently, I have a video coming out soon doing the same test (same day actually) comparing the FreeReign in AUS10A against the FreeReign in Magnacut. I have not yet compared the Magnacut against the 3V. I would have to borrow (or buy) the SRK again. I do a bit of a comparison of design in my FreeReign video. I personally prefer the FreeReign to the SRK. Thanks for commenting
@@MarkYoungBushcraft Thank you, that would be interesting. A fairer comparison would be SRK in 3V VS Demko in AUS10, as even in AUS10 version Demko is the more expensive knife of the two. Magnacut version is unavailable for purchase at this time, and when it becomes available it will be more expensive still.
@@MarkYoungBushcraftJust out of curiosity... is there anything in particular that leads you to prefer the freereign in Magnacut to the SRK in 3V? TIA.
@@cjmutschler Mostly a personal decision. I feel the FreeReign in AUS10A is a stronger design than the SRK in SK5; However, the gap is closer for the knives with the upgrade in steel. For me, I prefer the grip design of the FreeReign and I like that the Magnacut is a stainless steel. Having said that, I would be perfectly happy to own a SRK in 3V
@@MarkYoungBushcraft Thank you for your reply. I had been weighing the purchase of the 3V SRK vs the Magnacut Freereign and whether the Freereign was worth the extra money. Then I found a really good deal on the SRK so it became a less competitive decision.
I'll make it simple for you all. If you want a solid throw away knife, the SK-5 is better. If you want something to pass on to your kids, something that will last and that you can trust, get the 3V.
Thanks for commenting
@@MarkYoungBushcraft thx for the content.
If a blade is required why choose a knife....instead of a machete???
Machete is a good choice for the proper setting. Thanks for commenting
A knife can't do everything a machete can do and a machete can't do everything a knife can do
Well done. Thanks for the info.
Glad it was helpful! Thanks for commenting
3v made from Taiwan, but the price need 7200 NTD, why!??
I have no idea how the prices are arrived at. Thanks for commenting
I can only afford the sk5 and it’s good enough for what I’m gonna use it for And easy to sharpen
Thanks for commenting
I went through 2 of these OCONUS. They both snapped blade @ the hilt. Obviously not full tang. Never brought another Cold Steel product. Damn shame.
Unfortunate for sure. Thanks for commenting
I have the 3v version. Its my go-to knife
Right on. Thanks for commenting
So, if I send you one of my knives to test, does that mean you’ll eventually own it?…..🤓 On which steal is the best to get, it really depends on how much you really use the knife. If you don’t have or plan on buying a lot of knives, and you don’t mind a spending little more money, then having that one blade that can handle most of the tasks you need can be beneficial. I personally prefer knives that are easier to sharpen in the field. ✌️🇺🇸🇨🇦✌️
You could try sending me one and see what happens😉 I agree, 3V or other "super steels" are worth it if you are willing to maintain them. Thanks for commenting
Search and rescue knife. It is not survival!
Thanks for commenting
Sk5😂. Man .... I barely touched my finger. I mean BARELY touched it and I had a cut of 2 inches...unreal
Sharp knife. Thanks for commenting
Either one of them is not worth it in the sense that there are lower (much) priced knives than DO the same job and there are a couple of REAL cheap ones. Maybe my opinion comes from my 89 yr. age. Heck a good axe can do the same(cheap one mind)
Mate I'm 65 and I can see the advantages of good steels against lesser quality. But heat treat also is important. If the heat treat is off , the blade will be poor . My experience is that a better quality steel gets a better heat treat . Otherwise we would learn about it fast and no one would buy it .
I am okay with less expensive steels but I am also willing to do the required maintenance that many don't. Thanks for commenting
Uh the original SRK from the 90s was a different blade profile and finish. It was very plain Jane. Strong knife but basic. Sheath was crap.
Yes, I recall that design. I mentioned it in my first review of this knife. Thanks for commenting
Just fyi. The original srk was in carbon v steel.
Yes, that is true. Mentioned it in my original SRK video. Thanks for commenting
Us canadians, may not be, as technologically advanced, but, in canada, cutting a fresh 6" oak, is best left to the chain saw. A real knife test, would be fighting off a po'd 500 lb black bear. Skinning this bear, is also a good test. Perhaps, another test, if you could find a cooperative bruin?
The black bear in Nova Scotia are like pussy cats. The beaver on the other hand are vicious. Thanks for commenting
I wish you could see what ive done to my srk Lol. I bought it specifically for a shit knife and it has held up great. Or at least it hasn't broken yet.
I use it for just fun brutal dangerous things like stabbing barrels and chopping rocks. Good secondary pack knife for hard tasks so i can spare my decent blades the abuse.
I would feel safe about using a SRK 3V that way but not so much the new SK5 versions with hollow grind. Thanks for commenting