MACHU PICCHU "A stone masons commentary" (MIke Haduck)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 พ.ค. 2024
- I visit Machu Picchu, Peru. I show the Inca ruins and give opinions on how they were built.
• MACHU PICCHU, How we g... (Machu picchu - How we got there)
• Stone cutting, laying ... (stone cutting ,laying with jeff haduck)
• OLLANTAYAMBO (A stone ... (Ollayantambo) - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
![เปิดบ้าน เปิด Supercar อั๋นโอกิ เคยเอา rolls Royce เเลกพระ องค์ละ 100 ล้าน l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FeGwJwXauZ0/mqdefault.jpg)
Several methods of fabrication of the polygonal masonry using clay/gypsum replicas, a topography translator, and reduced clay models of the stone blocks along with a 3D-pantograph are described in the article “Fabrication methods of the polygonal masonry of large tightly-fitted stone blocks with curved surface interfaces in megalithic structures of Peru” (DOI: 10.20944/preprints202108.0087.v7). TH-cam does not allow a direct link. Search by the article title.
Hi Rostislav, it's only stone, not a big deal, just make your patterns and match it up, thanks Mike
Yeah clay is same as granite
I did a video called " carving stones with ancient technology? Not a big deal, just time ,money and labor, thanks Mike
@@scotch_onrocks1876 Did you read the article? Search for the 7th edition (7th version) of the article at Preprints website by title or by DOI 10.20944/preprints202108.0087.v7.
The 8th article edition (DOI: 10.20944/preprints202108.0087.v8) is posted at Preprints. Search the article by DOI or by title.
On my family's farm there is a road about 1/4 mile long raised several feet above the wet meadow. My grandfather and his brother built that with shovels and a wheelbarrow because their father told them to. Now that's simple compared to massive stonework, but already it seems impossible to do without an excavator and dump-truck. There was a tool in our toolbox for most of human history that is no longer there. And that is the tool of TIME.
Thanks Jim, very well said, mike
I was 26 before i ever RAN a mile... A single mile felt like an eternity and was daunting. It's really no big deal, one foot in front of the other and a little time and you've covered your ground. Do it again and you've covered 2x you ground... And it took less than 16 minutes. Not forever, just get working and you'll accomplish something.
No truer words have ever been said " Find the laziest guy and he will show you the most efficient way of doing any job". I've been preaching this at my work for decades. Love your stuff Mike keep up the good work.
Hi John, very true, lol, Mike
My 20/20 HIND sight says the samething.
My grandfather used to say that same thing and I would have to agree.
@@MikeHaduck we used to always say .. work smart NOT hard lol
The lazy guy would say, let's not use granite but one of the softer stones that are easy to work.
Says "This place is not that big of a deal as they claim", then proceeds to pan around showing 1000's of linear feet of walls built on the side of a mountain. We'll have to disagree on what a "big deal is" :). That's impressive even if done today. Thanks for sharing.
Thanks Greg, mike
Not a big deal??..With all the " theories" out there you'd think with the 9 billion people on planet earth there would be one that would want to PROVE his , hers or their favourite academia's perspective; that today's man could accomplish such an easy feat. They have to go out, find a bare side of a mountain, and with a thousand volunteers, and no infrastructure support for medical, grocery stores, daycare etc, etc, live off the land, transport a billion tons of massive boulders, with no tools to speak of, and no machinery..from a remote location. And then with bare hands hue the stones in perfect alinement. Until that someone can step up to the plate, I'll go with super intellect humans that could altar the kinetic energy of frequencies. K I'm done here; Scottie beam me up!
I think he's saying that it's humanly possible and doesn't need to involve Aliens or magic to explain how this got there. It's incredible work, but not supernatural.
Greg9504
Seriously. No one or group on the earth today could make and place 20 of those megalithic stones let alone the huge walls that exist all around the earth. No big deal though. Childish attitude really.
@@kimsand53 I'd like him to visit the stones that are perfectly flat to within 2 ten-thousandths of an inch, something we can't even do today with our most advanced MODERN technology, and they had around a DOZEN of them that were entirely massive in size to boot.
"Hi Mike, how did they build machu pichu?"
"well ghryst, they found a lazy guy"
"oh thanks mike, that clears that one up, lets go look at the pyramids next"
Hi Ghryst, I also did videos on conwy castle, cathedral of St. John divine and coral castle and as a stone mason they were far more impressive than anything I seen at Machu Picchu, was st the pyramids also, Thanks, mike
@@MikeHaduck impressiveness is not the issue.
no one can replicate this with period tools.
ppl havent even tried, cos logic. these ppl supposedly only had copper tools at best
@@Ghryst The technocratic elite maintain power over the world by gatekeeping the advanced technology of the ancients.
@@desktorp mmm!
buzzword salad for lunch
@@Ghryst you explain it then, fuckhead
“Strange sheep they got here”. Ha! I am so glad you, as a real stone mason, did these videos. Thanks for taking the time.
Thank you, Mike
Those are called "kissing sheep" b/c they love when you get face to face with them ;-)
I have been at the edge of my seat since the how we got there video. So wonderful to see the stonework and have a person that works within the art form speak. Better than tv because the company don’t control the words. It gets exponentially better because their is trust. Show us the good stuff. Grimé.
Thanks, mike
How truly good it is to have somebody that knows his stone
to make a presentation based on real experience.
Thanks ARailway, I appreciate it , mike
Love your videos. thanks for making them.
Thanks jaboy, mike
“Yes I am a veteran and have been to college.” I just about pissed my pants! Thanks for your service and I really enjoy your channel!
Thanks Bofa, mike
i love all of your videos mike. once again im going to express my appreciation for them! thanks!
Thanks Georgia, I appreciate it, mike
Wow when interests combine. Didn’t expect something like this on your channel. Love it
Thanks Idaho, Mike
So how do you figure they rubbed and banged together 20-60 tonne granite rocks with less than millimeter precision?
They didn't, he explained how they did it by hand with a small stone that was harder than the stone they used for the walls. They chip, chip, chipped away over days to sculpture one large stone to fit another. Lots of trial & error tilting the stone back & forth until they fitted nicely.
Duh! They used lazy guys
Hi J , just use your patterns and keep rubbing till they fit, thanks, mike
@@MikeHaduck I guess in the minds eye of unicorns and pink fairies I could rub and bang out a 60 ton granite rock to sub-milimeter precision in about what ,10,000 years ? if I can live that long in this make believe world. And that would be a single rock! how many did you imagine were in matchu pichu? maths don't quiet add up let alone these primitive people supposedly didn't have Einstein IQ's. I think your assumption may be alittle wishful. but I'm just a simple mechanical engineer, and have no real knowledge on much of anything.
@@j.sagiechode Your whole statement reeks of false statements. There is NO sub millimeter precision....first of all. Second of all you're not banging out 60 tons of rock on a 60 tone stone. Only the outer later which may be 10's of pounds since they used stones that already had close to the proper fit in the first place, or that were cut together at the quarry so they were almost a perfect match before work even began. It doesn't take 10, 000 years......it just takes hours of hard work. Not just one man.......thousands of people working at any one time. The IQ of the people working there is equal to the IQ of people living today, however their work ethic was tenfold what we have today. Being an engineer obviously hasn't taught you to be critical thinker.....get off your desk and your computer, and go build something. You'll see it actually can be done. The fact that it was done almost everywhere on the planet is pretty compelling proof. There's no mystery. Stone shapes stone. Harder stone shapes softer stone quicker. Charcoal can be used to draw on stone. The rest is just general labour. It doesn't get any simpler. People still do this type of work today, they just use better tools so the work progresses faster. Just like Engineers used to use pencils and rulers before computer modelling.
Very interesting Mike. when I look at this ancient masonry, I always think of - Labor, Time, and Material. Truly a masterpiece!
Hi, your right, it's just time effort and material, thanks Mike
Yeah seems quick and easy right? Get the thousand pound rocks from the other mountains and just bring em on over, cut here, cut there, nothing to it
Amazing Mike! Thanks for sharing your adventures.
Thanks hey starfish I appreciate it, mike
Thank you for traveling and taking the time to explain the fine details of stone building.
Thanks JAMAEl, I appreciate it, mike
Some people are so dumb that they will never believe that humans have done amazing things with little more than rocks, dirt, grass, and some logs. Anyone who has ever worked with their hands and learned some simple mechanics realizes that if you get enough people together they can do some impressive stuff without any space aliens needed.
Hi deezynar, very well said, thanks, mike
Great, let's see a pic of a tiny 12'X12' wall in your back yard with that size stone and precision. Just grab a few neighbors and stack'em up. Shouldn't be hard.
@@seriousguitarinstructionbo6690 Of course we could. The question is not actually about methods, it is one of motives. If me and my neighbors were actually motivated, we could do that.
"Steps aren't code." I like your sense of humor, Mike. Big fan from TN.
Thanks fan, I appreciate it, nice to hear from Tennessee , mike
Gallatin TN here
Fan of your Channel
Maybe they had one leg longer than the other.
I would love to see that old Egypt video; going to see if it’s on your channel right now. Thank you sir for taking the time, I’ve been looking everywhere for a stonemason’s take on all these ancient sites
Thanks victor, mike
Love it! Looking forward to the next videos!
Thanks Alhambra, I appreciate it, mike
Machu picchu is an example of an ancient public works project.
Hi Mr Krasker, I would believe that, thanks mike
Yeah, using lots of slaves as always.
Finally a pragmatic approach that isn't laced with ancient astronaut theories.
Always thought their stonework was well done for the tools that were available. If there were power tools available 10k years ago then it would have been much more symmetrical - IMO. The fit always amazed me. It was only the facing and the sides; not the back part that was fitted was a keen observation. As far as lifting the stones just watch how they leverage up a house using blocking. Simple and effective.
There are still some mysteries yet to be discovered about ancient times beyond our current understanding of the methods used to construct large works.
Well done sir, i appreciate your perspective.
Thanks S. Truth, I appreciate it, mike
They weren't going for symmetry, because asymmetrical keystone-cut masonry is much more resistant to earthquake damage. You know absolutely nothing about megalithic monuments.
@@slappy8941 Settle down Napoleon.
@heygeno1951 King tuts sword is made of iron that is thought to have originated from a meteorite. The ancients very well could have used iron meteorite tools to do some of stone work. They could have also made pure sand from specific types of minerals like diamonds, ruby's, hematite, iron meteorite, etc. Simply crush hematite or a meteroite and you have an abrasive much more efficient than your common desert sand. The fact is there are hundreds of ways it could be done without electricity or modern tools. Water and wind carved out the Grand Canyon, it didn't take diamonds raining down or Paul Bunnen dragging his axe. Lol, just a whole lot of time.
I really appreciate your can do attitude towards getting these projects done. I'm a big fan.
Thanks Jeff, mike
Wow!! what amazing scenery and everything you've shown so far!! looks like a pretty interesting trip!!
Thanks Sue, Mike
Spanish never made it there.. It was undiscovered..
Hi Oscar, I don’t know, mike
The local people always knew about it. What I think he means is that, after the Spanish came over here and the local people learned about cement, the local people then used the cement to repair walls of structures that they were still using or living in up on Machu Pichu. Its my understanding that the abandonment of Machu Pichu was a gradual process driven largely by the difficulty with getting resources up there. Old stone masonry villages continue to be slowly abandoned in the modern era driven largely by similar issues.
@@MikeHaduck Before making comments that are lies, You should talk to authentic Peruvian archaeologist; most of them speak English. They will tell you that Spanish Conquers never found or knew about this place, only and some local aborigen knew it. Actually this place was considered a Sacred Place or Temple for the INCAS only and its close relatives or descendants.
NO one else in PERU during the conquer and its independence did not know this place exist. It was until July 14th of 1902 a local Peruvian-citizen called Agustín Lizárraga discover this site. He tried to obtain financial aids from the Peruvian government and was denied; then one guy from USA called Hiram Bingham, sponsored by Yale University took credit for it.
Know a days is when they star using some cements for small repairs in Machu-Pichu.
Hi, I call it as I see it, sorry if I offended you, mike
Oh thank you, anything to do with Manchu Picchu on TH-cam usually leads to UFO's & giants. So nice to hear someone sane actually explaining this sort of thing.
Liked & Subscribed.
I must have missed that bit.?
@IRHanley He was commenting on some religious peoples ideas that giants built these megalithic structures and proceeded to disagree with it when he stated his hypothesis that they were indeed built by ancient humans. And that's not a "conspiracy" theory. Lol. Look up the definition of conspiracy. That's just a theory. I guess we could more accurately call that a biblical theory or mythological theory? I can't see how it could be a conspiracy.
"usuall leads to UFO' and aliens " AND big foot ,lol
Awesome MIKE!!! I’d love to go there. Thanks for all of your videos!
Thanks Chad, mike
I must have seen 100 Machu Picchu videos etc - you have shown quite a few things I haven't seen before - well done!
Thanks Trail, Mike
Great video, thank you! Same as with pyramids and all other ancient structures, it's not half as ideal, as many people want to believe.
Respect to mason from an architect, cheers:)
Thank you Eau, I appreciate hearing that from a architect, I agree, mike
Thanks Mike - great to hear some sanity on this subject!
I agree about Egypt - there you have only 2 short work-seasons - plant and harvest with crops yielding so much that they made a lot of it into beer. ..
So for the other half of the year, you have essentially nomadic tribes all crammed together - well fed and drunk causing mayhem - specially the young men.
So you give them something to do:
"Hey let's make a giant pyramid by banging rocks together!"
The Pharos were geniuses.
And in between banging rocks together, you could get them to kill the surrounding tribes.
Things haven't changed much - and the lazy man still rules technology .. and media .. etc ;)
Thanks ozwhistles, very well said, thanks, mike
@@MikeHaduck Mind you Mike - I am attracted to the "stone-softening" techniques some talk about .. the lower parts of the big stones are more shaped than the upper-parts .. that sounds suitably lazy to me?
And what I can't get good pictures of is the back sides of the big stones .. I saw one where I think it looks like it was ground-in for the front with the back looking more like a scoop than a cut.
Certainly not well crafted.
Have you seen such?
Hi oz, I got to say when I was looking at the pyramids and the temples in Egypt and Greece , they were not perfect, lots of imperfections ( I wish I had the cameras I got now), but I seen greater works in the cathedrals and castles of Europe, my opinion, just me, I appreciate it, mike
@@MikeHaduck Have you seen the 12 angle stone in Cusco? What in those cathedrals or castles matches the perfection of that inca stone?
@@ozwhistles Stone softening granite? Why does science and engineering know nothing about this if this ever was a thing? It sounds utterly preposterous to me.
Hey Mike, really appreciate your videos. I live in Montana and I’m wondering about adding a modified Thinset to my mortar mix for use on some exterior flagstone steps? Is that necessary or is a basic type S mortar mix sufficient? Thanks-Nate
Hi Nate, on anything laying outside flat I only use Portland and sand, s mortar don’ Hold up in these parts, I hope it helps, thanks,, Mike
Thanks so much for replying Mike, must be something with the added moisture laying flat and the lime that’s in S mortar?
This is brilliant and thank you, its makes sense to me now. Expect this video to go massive.
Thanks again, Mike
As soon as you started speaking I knew you were from PA....like myself! Nice video!
Thanks D, yep we got our own language in these parts, lol, mike
Mike many to day have little clue as to the effectiveness of the the simple machines.
The lever the roller and inclined plane. I have done some millwrighting, moving and setting heavy machinery.
I know first hand that one person can move and set something that weighs many ton with nothing more than a lever rollers and cribbing. But I will leave the cutting and shaping of stone to someone like you ; )
Thanks CD S, I believe you, And I seen some heavy things lifted by the old timers, thanks for a truthfull comment, mike
How exactly do you move a boulder weighing a hundred tons plus, lift it and set it perfectly in place only with stone and maybe some bronze tools? Add in a steep mountainside slope... modern engineers would love to hear the answer to this.
just watched this again and it's almost like you made all the walls to prove the points you have been repeating from PA. love sharing your vids from your channels with friends and family. thanks again Mike
Thanks Thor, mike
I can't find the video of Ed building the Coral can you tell me how to find Video? Thanks for your time RCW
Hi Robert, my video is " coral castle visit" Mike Haduck and the video where he was filmed doing it is " coral castle , mystery solved" thanks mike
You know that there are another sites with megalithic wall, right?
Why you don't post videos from these sites:
Sacsayhuamán,
Look at coricancha , stones are smooth on all sides.
Diorite cusco wall
ollantaytambo ruins, stones also smooth on all sides
Sun temple pisac Peru, stones also smooth on all sides
And maybe many more..
Machu piccu maybe "not that big deal", but combine all those sites, then it is big deal.
Hi Tape, I got the footage but am 20 videos behind with my regular masonry, but I will get there, thanks, mike
I beg to differ Mike. They found the loudest wife!
Thanks aloh, probably so,lol, mike
😬😬😂😂😂😂😂😂
How would you describe the building style where some stones interlock with the ones below & above them? The last only similar modern style I’m aware of is in light house construction.
Hi Alex, I don’t see anything that is special down there, back on the 60s I was working with the old timers that was doing all the railroad and wpa work, and it was basically the same, thanks Mike
Love your vids Mike. I'm from PA and have been just accepted in CTC for masonry. Your videos are a great help and very fascinating. Thanks Mike !
Thanks Jimmy, mike
Brilliant Mike, I used to wonder why there were no cutting tools found, now I know, the masons took them home with them. 😎👍🏻
Hi Robert, yep I seen that at the flee markets, lol, mike
I will be curious to see them flip flop the big huge megalithic stone to found the best one to fit together...lol.
Try again.
Thanks Daa3, mike
Hi Mike, I really enjoyed this and look forward to learning more from your videos. Subcribed!..from London UK.
Thanks Coney, good to hear from London, mike
Hey Mike, another question if you don’t mind? I’m building a brick mailbox, about 28”x28” and 5’ tall. Should it have a cinder block core that is anchored to my concrete pad or are just the bricks enough? I was also wondering if weep holes are necessary? Thanks so much-Nate
Hi Nate, I guess that would depend on the size of the brick, but all the old chimneys were hollow, thanks, mike
Wow! Amazing you follow Brien Froester. I’ve watch you both separately thinking about stone work! Make sure you check in on ‘Ancient Architects’ he’s got a video about the puma punku stones possibly being a geopolymer matrix mixed with organic material so it’s like very hard rock concrete. The stones you are looking at may have been sculpted with a acid slurry from acid lakes near by. Still very mysterious and amazing!
thanks James, mike
Not as impressive as everyone says. Lost me with that.
Hi Brad, I don,t know how to answer that, Thanks, mike
@@MikeHaduck I think I get what you're saying. It's not something that requires a paranormal explanation to exist.
@@rockinbobokkin7831 If alien (or paranormal) theorists are described as "everyone" you're in a dodgy social situation or click the wrong videos on TH-cam.
Let's hope that's not what he meant...
To a dull mind a telescope is just a stick.
Brad Butcher
You mean Brad The Butch.
Mike, thank you for sharing what you know. Your videos are awesome.
Thanks Vespa, I appreciate it, mike
@@MikeHaduck Me again : ) Thank you again for taking the time to do all these wonderful videos, which I am telling friends and family about and reposting on FB & Twttr (because wonderful things and PEOPLE should always be shared!) and for answering my question re stone foundation - I will get it done. No big deal : ) I pray and hope that you or whoever you're with at the VA will be well. God bless you again : )th-cam.com/video/PJg_n9BGck0/w-d-xo.html
Enjoyed watching, Thks for posting.
Thanks Sean, mike
You had me at laziest guy.
Thanks, Mike
Yeah, just keep pounding on that stone. You'll get there in about 13 million years.
Hi Kim, if you worked with stone for any length of time you would think different, thanks, mike
Mike Haduck Masonry
No one today can build some of the megalithic stone walls found all around the face of the earth. No one can place together stones of that size in interlocking fashion having all four sides matching without any deviation whatsoever that is displayed in some of those walls. Your right about some of the newer works, I'm talking about the ancient stone structure. Sorry, you may think you can, but you cannot, not you or anyone else in today's world and you are perpetuating a false narrative by saying that you can with a little bit of experience. You cannot. There was a technology used in ancient times that has been lost and is now being intentionally suppressed by a power that none of us fully understand. All the kings men and all the kings horses could not even begin to build those walls and neither could you. Go read Genesis 6, maybe you can gain some understanding.
How do you explain all the ancient carvings, they are a lot more intricate than any big megalithic stone that everyone is making such a big deal about, and the ones making the big deal are not carvers, stonemasons, quarry men or movers, ???? With respect, mike
Not impossible, hard work and a long period of time will get some results. Having a thousand people working on it helps too.
A million years? You must be lazy.
I love this video, Mike. Thanks for posting. Regarding retaining walls, in addition to letting the grass grow over the top of it, would it help to build them at an angle as opposed to plumb?
Hi Brian, yes I always pitch them in and they did too, thanks, mike
Great video, Mike it's great to see you in Peru. I watched a lot of your other videos on stone wall building, brickwork, how to mix concrete, etc. I always found your videos very interesting. It's nice to hear a experienced, expert stone mason giving his two cents on "how could they have possibly done it". Lets face it, we don't have all the answers and probably never will. But Peru sure is an interesting place. Lets see more videos and don't forget Bolivia. They have some very interesting stone structures there, too.
Thanks John, I appreciate that, mike
Not as big a deal as they claim?? I've been there and i tend to disagree with you mate.
Hi Aussie, I did videos on conwy castle, the cathedral of St. John nyc, coral castle, etc etc, and as a stone mason I was far more impressed with these, than anything I seen at Machu Picchu, Thanks, mike
@@MikeHaduck What is megalithic, mortar-less, anti seismic, ancient in any of those place? Anything like the temple of the sun at Machu Picchu?
You just explained how you would exploit the seams in the rock. Thats how you would do it. Obviously not how they did it. Next.
That’s was a pretty cool n chill video. Thanks.
Thanks John, mike
"This place is not that big of a deal as they claim" what an obtuse appreciation on such an architectural wonder..
Hi Mainor, I did videos on conwy castle, the cathedral of St. John ,the Great Wall of China, coral castle, etc etc and as a stone mason they were far more impressive 5han anything I seen at Machu Picchu, Thanks, mike
@@MikeHaduck why do you leave the same comment on every post ? you're not answering any of the questions
Because I am trying to make the point that Machu Picchu is a nice post card and of course interesting but compared to real stone masonry it is nothing, thanks, mike
@@MikeHaduck well we disagree Mike.. you're a great mason though i learn a lot from you... Definitely would like to see you reproduce this with the period tools .. thanks
My brother who is in the stone business also is going to drop some granite off today, no big deal, Machu Picchu is Disney world compared to other sites, the Great Wall of China is 13000 miles long, thanks, Mike
I'll just wait until you build a megalithic wall with the techniques you claim the ancients used, because others have tried, and all failed.
the only reason people don't is A. they aren't skilled with the equipment and B. it would take several days per stone
Hi Slappy, I did some videos on conwy castle, cathedral of St. John And the coral castle and as a stone mason they were far more impressive to me than anything I seen a Machu Picchu, thanks, mike
Slappy: I'm with you. That's the scientific method at it's core. Can it be duplicated?
Surely you aren't expecting a single person or even a group to replicate something that literally thousands of people built? The moving and shaping of stone using tools and resources available to the time and area has been demonstrated enough that proof of concept has been established. It's a simple extrapolation from that point that more hands make for light work, so to speak. It's okay to be skeptical but cynicism is no one's friend.
th-cam.com/video/HtNLEYQnFRs/w-d-xo.html
Dolerite pounders to create pefect joints in 40 ton stones and 90 degree internal angles? i don't think so.I'd like to see a modern stone mason create just one of those perfect large granite stones using stone hammers and copper.They would never be able to do it.
Hi Nicholas, I am about 20 videos behind but when I get to the rest of Peru I will do a demonstration, but I agree with forester about the saw marks, thanks, mike
Very intersting video, thanks for taking the time to show this... i was always curious if the "razor thin" seams were were all the way through the walls or if it was almost a facade and as you stated a way to seat the stone and "good enough" so to speak... interesting to see the transitions between building periods as well... glad you had such a clear sky and long views day, i think you got lucky... also thanks for the tutorial at the end
Thanks mdh6977, I appreciate it, mike
You are the coolest!!! Love you Mike. Wish you the best. I always learn something from you. Thanks!
Thanks Austin, mike
Wasn’t impressive because it’s not European
Enjoyed this video very much. Look forward to your thoughts about the knobs and protrusions visible on some stones. If they were used for placement why not break them off afterwards? It appears original builders had an eye for aesthetics would have done so.
Hi Farzad, I feel that way, and I think for the most part they did, but they left some on in case, maybe, I was not there long enough for any final thoughts, thanks, mike
Mike do you have any theories about the saw marks or tube drill holes in egypt? Did the ancients have metal machines?
Hi marshal, I know that had diamonds and the wheel, so that’s the beginning of a modern day saw, thanks mike
Finally a video like this. A lot of authors have opinions on how these are built, but rarely actual experts.
Thanks Waffles, mike
I find all this highly compelling. Thanks
Thanks, Mike
curiouser and curiouser! I just had a thought watching your excellent video. I have messed with rock walls in CT but nothing like this, and even that was hard work! So when i see how close they fit, I wonder how to do that with out having to lift and chisel out, lift and refit...so hard to do that with 50 ton rocks....soooo???WTF! but if they carved out the bottom rock, then did a plaster (mud?) cast of the top, then they could use that as a template to shape the next block? Or one of those nifty rigs with lots of spokes that shape to things ...you said find the laziest person, and I am always trying to find the easiest way to do things. But how they lifted them I have no clue! and thanks for the grass-over-the-top of the retaining wall, makes sense!
Thanks moo moo, I appreciate it, mike
Hey Mike thank you for this video and God bless you bro and thanks for your time
thanks Leo, I appreciate that, God bless also, mike
How cool, I really enjoyed this one Mike
Thanks Craig, mike
Beautiful Mike thanks for your knowledge sir keep up the great work
Thanks Mickey, mike
Such a great video- food for thought
Thanks Franca, Mike
I remember seeing a program on British TV at least two decades (maybe more) ago. It demonstrated (not just talked about) how using very simple techniques that whomever built these structures slid huge stones into place. I have looked and cannot find it but it is out there somewhere. Like your work Mike, thank you.
Thanks Bill, Mike
Great video and I loved your music in it! Do you have a link to the music?
Thanks James, just search " cadtle" Mike haduck, My music is on my other channel, thanks Mike
@@MikeHaduck thanks! Subscribed to both and am enjoying your music, my wife too. I many times spend huge amounts of time thinking how the walls in South America were built. I'd love to go there sometime.
great channel mike i've been a bricklayer in the u k nearly 40 years and i love the old school old buildings old wall bonds sites today are about laying as many as you can with low grade materials when i get the chance to build something i know is going to be there a 100 years im off with me tools because i know i will enjoy every brick,keep the videos coming
Thanks yam, I appreciate hearing that from a professional, thanks, Mike
Another interesting video. Well done
Thanks Steve, mike
Thank you for your presentation Mike. I also watched the "How we got there" video. I think you did good.
Thanks Keny, I appreciate it, mike
s'cuse me...at 16:28 I don't understand what you're saying...are you cutting or colouring the stone with torches?
Hi Prios, yes, today it's called thermal facing, I have a few examples on my videos " stone cutting and making patterns mike haduck and stone work ( part 2) mike haduck, but the hotter you get the stone the easier it is to face it, thanks Mike
@@MikeHaduck Hi Mike, sorry, but english is not my native tongue...what exactly means facing? Same topic, different question: would it be possible to weaken a stone locally with high heat and then shock cool it to take out material i.e. shape it?
"Funny looking sheep!" Ha! You have the best sense of humor... I thought about that the next day at work, and was laughing out loud. The guy working next to me and looked at me like I was crazy. I didn't care because I was so amused... Thank you for taking us along, and for all of your teaching.
Excellent video Mike. I'm sure you enjoyed yourself there.
Hi Tim, yes, I had to go, mike
Thank you, Mike. I learned more from this than a guided tour
Thanks Meyer, Mike
Thanks for the lesson at the end!
Thanks Mona, Mike
Let the lazy man figure it out.
As a man that worked commercial roofing for over 30 years. That statement is a fact.
For anyone that thumbs down that statement. You think to much. Just do it don’t over think it.
I needed to move a round bail of hay. It weighs 1700 lbs No big tractor.
I back up a trailer to the bail and unhook it. I shove a long bar into the bail. I hook a chain to the bail and to truck.
When I pull forward it flips bail onto the trailer. Hook up to trailer and away I go
A winch would be faster. But mine was broken. I used what was available at the time.
Don’t overthink.
God bless you drmachinewerke, I can tell a man with experience, I appreciate it, mike
Wouldn't the lazy guy choose to not use granite?
@@thomastmc then he wouldn't be the laziest, keep lookin
@@roberttaylor5668 Well, the lazier man would've also cut the stones from up to 60 tons down to smaller pieces that are easy to carry. The laziest man wouldn't have done it at all. This lazy man reasoning sure makes sense...
What make tractor do you suppose they used?
Hey Mike I love your videos and my uncle was from Pottstown Pa. once while visiting, he took us to Ringing Rocks.
Thanks David, mike
Mike thank you so much for showing us all the places you go and the mason aspect of it. I love to travel and dream of all the places you go. Thank you
Thanks Playgirl, Mike
Great review video of this site.
Thanks Linda, mike
Hi Mike firstly thanks for taking the time to make your videos. Can you or have you done a video on you making a couple of these granite stones fit together like they do, (good size ones) and move them around to see what will fit best together. i mean no disrespect i would just like to see someone recreate one of these walls so i can stop wondering how they did it! you say its very easy but i need better than you rubbing a couple stones together for 5 seconds! thanks
Hi Glo, I have a few more videos to do on Peru, I would like to when I get the time, thanks, mike
@@MikeHaduck That would be great if you could. until then ill keep wondering as no-one seems to have a video of them just doing a couple of stones (sad face)
Mike I love your presentation style!
Thanks doc, I appreciate that, mike
Anyway to get the song? I love it!
Hi Dick, I just did a background thing, I guess you can just download it off the video, thanks, mike
wow great music!! oh, and thanks for the tour.
Thanks she’s, I appreciate it, mike
Wow mike what a trip so glad you did this video people underestimate how smart we are and how smart people where even back then with hard work and knowledge much can be achieved
Thanks Mac, I agree, mike
Me gusto muchisimo !! 💖 Gracias 👏 Bendiciones
Graciaas, Ana, mike
Love your travel vids mike. Cheers
Thanks Joseph, Cheers also, mike
It's great that someone with the skill set actually went to these locations and explained how it was done,rather than an armchair expert looking at images and saying "no way we couldn't have built that."
Thanks Clive, I appreciate that, mike
No, what's sadder is an "expert" goes to MP and has no clue what he yammers on about.
@@ArthurDentZaphodBeeb Ok. What's your theory then?
@@tollundman7524 probably aliens again lol
If it was aliens l would have expected them to do a better job. What's wrong with nice square blocks? Lol .
As a granite worker, you are crazy if you think pounding stones together turns out things like these or granite is softer underground lmao
Hi America, I will be putting a video out next week about ollayantambo where I do a small demonstration, thanks, mike
@@MikeHaduck take 2 slabs of granite 2x2 from quarry cut to perfectly flat and seamed together within microns with only stone and copper tools and then I might put thought into saying you're right. This is still a challenge with modern tooling. I also think people were to worried about eating and raising livestock to spend copious amounts of time a day slamming rocks together
Mike, will you maybe please soon upload a video where you are blowing up a wall with a dynamte to create a window opening?
Hi Dino, I do that on my “breaking out of prison for beginners “video, lol. Thanks, mike
Very beautiful, you are certainly getting around the globe. Cheers from S.W, Ontario.
Thanks Hopper, cheers also, mike
That tip on retaining walls earned my subscription. I’ve never heard anyone mention that.
Also, hello from Zelienople lol
Thanks, nice to hear from Zelienople, Mike
fellow pennsylvanian. ever hear about ancients using sound/frequency to cut and melt stone? like a giant tuning fork? fascinating stuff. i worked at a plantation that had a spring fed troth craved out of a single stone in 1700's was larger than a bath tub. had stone mortarless walls for fences. was an awesome place.🍻
Thanks, mike
Love your videos as always!
So i understand how they could sand, chip sand, chip, sand, etc but how do you think they lifted those huge rocks?
Hi simclar, Only the laziest guys know that, lol, Mike
@@MikeHaduck lol
@@MikeHaduck a great non answer, thanks
So many bedroom researchers making wild claims who do not understand stone. The Egyptian's used bow saws with flat blades introducing powdered sinta lubricated with water, the Inca worked stone as you demonstrated but I suspect they may have used French drags to feather in the edges or as you show granite rubbing blocks. As a Mason you know it's relatively simple to move very large blocks of stone with the use of a single pebble, and I'm sure you know the trick using sugar cubes, shame the Inca didn't have cubes it would have made life easier.....those bedroom researchers will be scratching their heads at that one! Interesting vlogg.
Hi Nick , I am not a mover but I see a lot moved in the past by different means, I agree, thanks, mike
A stone mason coming up with these conclusions make sense to me. The most logical, following his understanding of the world and make it fit.
The question on how this was build becomes interesting when you look at known history. Humans make beautiful works of art on a smaller scale, something that is within the limits of the technique they are using. Nowhere were insane megalithic building created. Big walls yes, but always within their capabilities.
Why carry the stones that far? Most sane people would kindly object if anyone would ask them to do this for no other reason than "entertainment". Even when they are bored haha! Maybe that reasoning works for 2 days but when breaking your back on stones you'll soon dream about being bored again. Moving a 50 ton block for months is not a solution to overcome boredom. But I can totally see how a stone mason would come to that conclusion. Mike comes from 1 point of view and that's an interesting and informative one. In a bigger context the value is little. I assume we all realise it could have been done by simple beating. Question is: Is that a realistic proposal?
I think "no". Although new theories could change that. If that whole civilization had some kind of psychological disorder and found peace of mind while working on those stones it could make sense. But then again, is that a realistic proposal? I think "no". Even in this video you'll have to move the stone tens (hundreds?) of time to make them fit. It's more than simple beating. Aside from that there's a lot of evidence of a developed civilization. That doesn't fit the picture of "sitting around being bored". That's a tat ignorant honoustly... "Ah, that civilization back then, yeh, they were just bored, didn't know shit".
Bit disappointed with the technique used at the end. For slabs the marking technique was interesting but I miss a technique like that in the solid rock in the end, the only one relevant. All I learned there is that stone breaks if you hit it. Question remains: How do you make them fit? Is there a similar technique there without changing the questions to flat, basically 2D surfaces?
Mike, how about finishing that rock you started at the end? Keep track of time (and the amount of times you tried the fit by moving the rocks together), make a rough estimation of the amount of work done in Machu Picchu. Very rough. My guess would be that you'll find out there's not enough time in conventional history to account for that. Now that's a video I would like to see. Skip the lifting and carrying part, just the finishing...
Thanks valkenburgert, I will det to it, thanks, mike