Cross Stitch Laying Tool vs Railroading for Neater Stitches

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 พ.ย. 2024

ความคิดเห็น • 67

  • @Frogglin
    @Frogglin 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +20

    I tend to only railroad the top of my cross stitches, the bottom stitches can do what they like it's none of my business.

  • @maryannjohnson5410
    @maryannjohnson5410 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +11

    Didn't know what a laying tool was until you explained it. I finally learned what railroading was a few months ago. I usually don't bother with it unless my stitches are really not looking right, and then I do the top leg. I've found that if I let the floss spin once in awhile it lays nicer and my worst stitches seem to be at the end of my thread.

  • @sherryzimmerman9220
    @sherryzimmerman9220 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +12

    Well as a Happy 73 Year Old Ager You Both have taught me some great Visual images with sound reasoning,,,,Who says You can’t teach this old Mare some new tricks?…..loved “Crack On”…..do I understand it to me “carry on”?

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      @@sherryzimmerman9220 Haha, yes correct. Bit of a British slang moment there! 😅

    • @annlittle6193
      @annlittle6193 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@TheGiddyStitcherLove British slang 😄

  • @suncoastcrafting6362
    @suncoastcrafting6362 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    Thank you for showing these techniques. I use both (although sometimes my laying tool is just another needle) and also the frog stitch. Sometimes I have to 'rip out' stitches and try again. Usually just one or two. Drop the thread. Railroad for a bit. And there should be an improvement. This happens mostly when I'm trying to use that last bit of floss. It's too short and getting twisted. I know that I shouldn't force 'just one more stitch.' It helps to end that thread and start with a new piece of floss.

  • @TheQcaller
    @TheQcaller 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

    Fantastic video - very informative. I've always wanted more details about this very topic. Thank you!

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      You're very welcome! Some great tips in the other comments too, but if there's anything else you'd like to know do feel free to ask 🥰

  • @metal-lace
    @metal-lace วันที่ผ่านมา

    I always used a thin knitting needle as a laying tool long before i even knew that was a thing. I find it really makes a difference when your working mutliple colors in a stitch and when its a half stitch. My current project is on dark fabric ith 4 strand in a half stitch and i have to use my knitting needle to get all the threads to work they way io need them too.

  • @retrocraftdreams
    @retrocraftdreams 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +6

    I won't live without a laying tool. I love it. Though, I will say I ALWAYS use it in needlepoint, and only sometimes for cross stitch. It makes a HUGE difference in the thicker threads and yarn used in needlepoint. Here are my tips:
    1. Try keeping the laying tool as flat as possible against the fabric. This will help keep those threads in position as you do the following.
    2. Instead of inserting it into the loop after placing your needle, pull the needle/thread in the opposite direction of the hole and use the laying tool to stroke the threads into position, holding them in place against the fabric as you insert the needle and pull the thread through. Makes for a much smoother motion. (LMK if you'd like me to point you to a quick demo I have.)
    Also, I prefer the handled version, but can only use it when using a stand. So I use the trolley needle when I'm holding my frame. I go between wearing it on my index finger or thumb, depending on where I'm holding the frame or what area I'm stitching. I do sometimes need to hold my work upside down to reach a given area.
    While tricky to hold on to, you can also try out the technique with a tapestry needle. Some trolley needles are literally just tapestry needles attached to thimbles.
    My results with railroading are always unsatisfactory. Sometimes it works, but my threads often still twist regardless, so I rarely bother.

    • @stitch2659
      @stitch2659 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      I find the same with railroading, where the floss can have a tendency to twist or tangle. So, I actually use my Trolley Needle to help me control my thread better. If I see a knot starting, I'll pull back on the Trolley Needle to make the thread more taut and I'll pull my thread through more slowly. Most of the time, this helps prevent the twisting and tangling. But if it just tightens the knot, it also makes it easier to catch faster so it doesn't get so tight that you simply CAN'T untie it. I usually railroad and use the Trolley Needle together on quarter, three quarter and top stitches, and only feel comfortable wearing it on my pointer finger of my left hand as I stitch with my right. It's a lot more convenient for me to do it that way because I typically only stitch in-hand, so holding a laying tool separately doesn't seem to be very comfortable.

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      Oh Lindsay you have me so excited with this comment, because I recently invested in my first needlepoint supplies (I think, anyway...long story) and am just trying to find time to give it a whirl. Will make sure the laying tool is handy when I do! Thanks for the tips 😄

    • @retrocraftdreams
      @retrocraftdreams 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      @@TheGiddyStitcher Yay! I really think you're going to like it! It's a great middle ground between cross stitch and embroidery. It's one of my low-key missions to get more people to try it. If you've already got your supplies, you probably don't need this, but I put up a video a few weeks ago going through a lot of that stuff. You might find a few more tips there, including (I think) a couple that can help you be frugal with it 😉. Can't wait to hear how it goes!

  • @ericathefae
    @ericathefae 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

    My main problem with these methods is their fiddlyness - I do the "hold the project in your left hand kinda draped between you fingers and stitch like you're sewing" method of cross stitching (although to me this is simply known as cross stitch - the internet's fascination with hoops and frames is baffling to me). What I love about cross stitch is the flow of it, how casual and easy it is. Adding this level of carefulness to each and every stitch sounds like a nightmare - granted, I haven't tried them, but they just look like they'd suck the joy out of the craft for me.
    As for coverage I tend to favour working with three strands on most fabric - not only is there less need for any careful stitches, but you can also get more subtle colour changes (especially useful since I'm using second hand floss instead of buying the "proper" colours). I've also found that just adding a single strand to the top stitch is a great way to shift a colour after the fact without adding any noticeable bulk.

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Definitely fair! I don't enjoy railroading exactly because it's so fiddly, so will only do it if I know it matters (going to have extreme close up photos or - one day eventually - get entered into a craft show or something where these things matter. Otherwise it's the messy life for me!
      I found the laying tools actually really fun in a satisfying sort of way, there's just something about the feeling of the threads gliding over it? Idk how to describe it! But yeah if you're not enjoying, there's no point. Do what brings you joy, that's my motto.

  • @marie-low-stresslife7374
    @marie-low-stresslife7374 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

    I learned a lot in this video! I even think I'll try railroading to see if my stitches can look better this way or if I am doomed 🤭 Thank you Michelle! 🥰

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@marie-low-stresslife7374 I believe in you! 👏

  • @staciehrvy2565
    @staciehrvy2565 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I like to use my trolley needle on my left thumb flat side down. It’s so helpful I need to tame a wavy stitch. It also helps when I’m using a 26 needle, the fat needle eye helps the thread line flat. Great info.

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      I've not really been able to get the hang of it on my thumb yet but have been wearing it on my ring finger a lot! Seems to vary from person to person, but whatever works for us right? :D

  • @vallprout
    @vallprout 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Have you done a video on tension?
    I just discovered if I stitch with a hoop and railroad, my stitches are almost perfect. No hoop and stitching in hand, the first stitch is looser, then the top stitch is tighter and it all tends to look messier, even with railroading the top stitch.
    Thanks for this video.

  • @RG.9970
    @RG.9970 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I did not realize I was doing this techniques, just didn’t know the names. I am still new to the hobby, but become extremely frustrated with the floss not laying flat. I cannot do the Parking method because the back is too messy. So I even keep the backs as neat as I can for mind to not panic. Takes me forever to do anything, but this is a hobby that helps with stress and my ADHD. :)

  • @ElizabethBertheaud
    @ElizabethBertheaud 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Just discovered your videos. Love them! I do sometimes railroad my stitches. And - I’ve wondered how a laying tool works and now I know. Thanks!,

  • @sharilamey
    @sharilamey 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Hi from the US. I have been wanting to comment on a knitting video but they aren’t very recent. The next time you get the urge to knit, try the Entrelac style. It’s not for the faint of heart. But once you get you get it.

  • @samvanderkooy7314
    @samvanderkooy7314 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    This was a great refresher on railroading, which I definitely needed as I'm about to start a project for my soon-to-be nibbling and I have not stitched in months. Thanks. :D

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      At your service! *takes a long, dramatic, bow*

  • @sharondeverslobaton3511
    @sharondeverslobaton3511 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Great video! I recently started using a laying tool and a trolley needle. Haven’t decided which one I like best, but I do like using them. I only use these tools one the top leg of the stitches. Where these tools seem to help, is when your thread is getting shorter and twisting more. I also found if I rub the thread too much, it starts to get curly.

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Yes I've found that the twisting can still be a pretty big problem even when railroading, so the old "let the needle hang and untwist itself" trick is definitely still a go-to. For whatever reason I haven't found the threads to twist as much when I'm using the laying tool but that might be more because I'm stitching two handed. So many variables to rule out, so little time!

  • @Ohnonotthatguy
    @Ohnonotthatguy 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Thank you so much for the video! I’m possibly the world’s slowest stitcher due to some hand shenanigans, but this makes me think maybe using either of these techniques might make my floss chicken a little neater, instead of the stringy mess it usually becomes 😂

  • @mcavolt
    @mcavolt 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    I use a seam ripper if I have some stitches or hat don't want to lay right.

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Oh that's living on the edge, I try and keep the seam ripper as far away from my cross stitch as possible out of general fear of my own clumsiness! But whatever works 😅

  • @barbarawest1205
    @barbarawest1205 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Thank you for the very clear demo and explanation! I prefer stitching in hand and have been blaming that for less than ideal stitches when railroading. But I think it may be because I'm placing the needle too far from the fabric! Going to try getting closer over the next few days to see if I notice improvement.

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      Looking at my three blocks side by side I was genuinely surprised by how messy the railroaded one still is compared to the one with the laying tool. Only when you stare obsessively at it up close, of course, but there is definitely a difference. So I wonder if railroading is just inherently not as effective, although maybe it's just that we both need to practise more. My point is you're not alone, haha 😂

    • @barbarawest1205
      @barbarawest1205 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@TheGiddyStitcher Your demo of laying tools was clearer than lots of others I've seen, too! But I'm not ready to move to hoops or Q-Snaps. Yet.

  • @Cali_Jeni
    @Cali_Jeni 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Interesting, I will have to check that out!

  • @ShaunaMckiernan
    @ShaunaMckiernan 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Thank you for sharing this. 😊

  • @LindasheesStitches
    @LindasheesStitches 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I've started railroading since you're "how to stitch faster video" (ironic I know 😂) and it does seem more consistent but on lazier days I still manage to have wonkey stitches here and there. The laying tool is intriguing though, it does seem to look much neater strangely enough. I do wonder how much is down to which is your favorite side of the fabric (left-handed/right-handed) and frames sometimes work against me. I did enjoy the demonstration of all three methods and will be checking if I have any crochet hooks or something that can lend itself as a laying tool!

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Haha, well you know what they say, it takes all sorts! I found with the laying tool (probably should've said this in the video but I always forget *something*), it's a bit like the sewing method in that I find it really easy and intuitive in one direction, but a bit more awkward in the other. So there's a certain amount of adjusting grip or even turning the q-snap round if I'm holding it in-hand.
      But the specifics of that will be different for everyone so like I said, just a case of experimenting to see what sticks.
      p.s. I'd dug out an old wooden shawl pin of an appropriate shape to give that a try, before remembering the stitch correctors. And someone else has already commented suggesting a biggish tapestry needle. I'm sure there'll be something suitable lying around most of our houses! 😄

  • @lindalindstrom860
    @lindalindstrom860 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Great video. Can I use railroading if I stitch with 3 treads? Or 5?

  • @hezvandermeij
    @hezvandermeij 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I only rail-road my half stitches per personal preference & full black stich on white fabric for the coverage

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Yeah I think a lot of people do. Sometimes I'll do both legs if I'm stitching white on black or something, but generally I'll try and get away with the barest minimum extra effort that looks ok and I am not ashamed of that :D

  • @Cindy112Manami
    @Cindy112Manami 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I use a different method.i pull my needle close to the canvas till there is only a smal part of thread left between the hole and the needle. After i rotate my needle 90 degress, i hold my finger on the top of the needle (not the tip, but the part next to the hole thats facing the roof now) i hold the thread in my other hand and pull my needle till nearly the end of the thread. Since the needle is not sharp inside the hole it wont fray. But all the threads laying now next to each other. So i dont need anything else. It wont take long and last for many stitches. Its hard to explain but i tried my best 😂 hope you could understand😅

  • @leavingitblank9363
    @leavingitblank9363 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

    The laying tool created stitches that appeared squared off, almost like tiny bricks, whereas your hand stitches looked more elliptical shaped-- a bit pointed on the ends. The brick-like stitches did look very neat, but the more I looked at the samples, the more I think I like the hand stitching better. It just looks more like hand work and less like machine work. (I didn't think the railroading sample had enough of an improvement in neatness to make it worth the effort.)

  • @conniegarvie
    @conniegarvie 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I just ordered a vintage trolley needle from Etsy. I'm waiting for it to arrive. In reviews of the trolley needle you used in this video, several people said you're needle was painful to wear more than a few minutes due to the needle being a standard tapestry needle welded onto the part that hugs your finger. Apparently the eye of the needle can push into the skin, causing pain.
    Have you experienced this?

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      I haven't so far, it did feel a little odd at first because of exactly that, but not painful just sort of noticeable, if that makes sense? I quickly got used to it and it's been fine, but of course everyone's different and maybe with more time it would become an issue. I'll have to do an update video if that ever happens!

  • @rachelierston9373
    @rachelierston9373 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Try putting the trolley needle the on the other side of your little finger. I find this much easier. 😊

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@rachelierston9373 Little finger is one I've never seen anyone do, will definitely have to give it a try and see 😄

  • @jylromain6439
    @jylromain6439 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I'm too slow to add these although the laying tool does a nice job. But if I was wearing it I'd poke my eye out for sure.

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      It's definitely only a matter of time before I'm putting out a PSA video of my own about the safety goggles...

  • @kimstolworthy3606
    @kimstolworthy3606 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Thank you so very much. New subscriber & love your channel!

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Woop! Welcome and make yourself at home :D

  • @LDecker-g8y
    @LDecker-g8y 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    What is that holding your qsnap? Can't find anything that fits thicker than a hoop.

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      I have a Lowery workstand and just use the default side clamp. It's not designed to hold a q-snap but I found that as long as there's a grippy fabric between the clamp and the q-snap (a bit of felt, a grime guard etc) it actually works fine. That said, a lot of people have commented saying the Lowery corner clamp works much better for them, so I'll hopefully get to try that one day.
      Hope that's helpful, but if you have other questions about the workstand they might be answered in this video I made! th-cam.com/video/kuq6WdhTczo/w-d-xo.html

    • @LDecker-g8y
      @LDecker-g8y 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@TheGiddyStitcher Thank you!

  • @belwynne1386
    @belwynne1386 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I find that a laying tool is particularly helpful in needlepoint.

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Ok you're the second person who's told me this and now I'm very excited, as I'm literally looking at the small pile of my first ever needlepoint supplies while writing this reply and really looking forward to giving it a try :D

  • @angim8984
    @angim8984 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I'm new to your channel. Do you have any advice for people who stitch with 3 strands?

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      With a laying tool, your method is the same although it may take a bit more wiggling on occasion. As long as the three strands are lying parallel across the top of the tool, you're all good.
      With railroading it's a bit less exact. Some people split the strands 2 on one side of the needle, 1 on the other and find that looks tidy enough for them. I know some people prefer to sort of hold the floss flat in the direction it's about to be stitched, make sure it's laying as they want, and then put the needle down (sort of like I did at 02:25, it's hard to explain in words!)
      Not a black and white answer and unfortunately another case of "experimentation required". Hopefully it helped a little bit.
      p.s. welcome to the channel! :D

    • @angim8984
      @angim8984 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@TheGiddyStitcher Awesome. I'll try a laying tool.

  • @PhantomOfMemories
    @PhantomOfMemories 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    The laying method is very interesting, but to me the puffiness of the stitches gives the piece more texture and more life in my eyes. I feel having the laying tool would make the piece look too flat. It was interesting to learn, but I will stitck to not using the laying method.

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      That's absolutely fair, honestly. For me I like to know about the options and can then pick and choose. But sometimes you want things to be extra textured too, like I remember stitching one pattern that called for a blend for the hair, and instructed you to let the strands twist and cross as much as they liked to give it a more realistic texture.
      All just depends on what you're going for, ultimately, there's no right and wrong!

  • @papermoon50
    @papermoon50 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Ive already had eye surgery because of a freak accident. I wont be using this fabulous tool. 😮

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Eep! Might be wise. So far I'm happy to report no accidents, but I do have to be careful to pack it away after use otherwise I'll end up sitting on it or something 😅

  • @Joyce-bv2tg
    @Joyce-bv2tg 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Only railroad white stiches

    • @TheGiddyStitcher
      @TheGiddyStitcher  4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Definitely a good rule to live by :D

  • @beejayem42
    @beejayem42 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    🐨👍

  • @FrostyXStitch
    @FrostyXStitch 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    🪡🧵🥰