There was this case where a wife hired a hit man to kill her husband. When asked if she was worried about being caught or suspected, she replied she was tiny woman and no one would think she was capable. Riiiight
Oh I think she did it, but she did it with help. She won't rat out the person that helped her because that means she did it. For all the people who believe she is innocent that would all go away. They would know she was behind his murder.
This. I can't stand it when people say things like "She's too beautiful to have done this" or "She is just a tiny little woman, no way she did this" or other things based off of her looks, gender or charisma. People thought Ted Bundy was an amazing guy too, and look what he did. Women absolutely can and do commit atrocious crimes and many times get away with it because people refuse to see women as "capable" of such things. They absolutely are.
Fear sells just like sex sells it’s sad really how when things like this happens it just gets exploited instead of holding all people accountable clearly jail isn’t working because killers continue to kill. The system is broken. Humans ruin everything
“How can any one think that I did this?” For me, it was the evidence. A person might have had a fight before a spouse disappeared, or just bought a gun, or be having an affair, or been shopping in the area where the body was dumped, or have similar suitcases, or “moved” the husband’s car elsewhere, or have similar blankets to those at the crime scene, or be worried that a toll booth documented your trip despite paying cash, etc. but pretty hard to think “innocent” when all those things and more.
Melanie is a special kind of evil, the kind that fools every one by their fake kindness,smiles & charm. How on flat earth anyone would do a bjob while 8 months pregnant, is beyond me. I am a very fussy eater when I am pregnant.
Stop assuming a nurse couldn’t do this. Have you met any nurses? I’m from a family of them, am one myself, and you’d be surprised how nasty and cold some can be. Do I think she’d murder her patient? No. When she killed her husband, she was a wife killing her husband and her occupation had nothing to do with it.
honestly ppl should look at history theres multiple documented nurse murderers if not serial killers. they are desensitized to inner body stuff and they have access to vulnerable people, so it tracks
He was recording their conversations for the police but he kept having sex with her the whole time. She's guilty but he deserved to be kicked to the curb after that
@@annanimity7085 not really. He is a smart man he used her for sex and nothing more. She is a murderous crazy woman that killed her husband while cheating. The fault is on her not the man.
I’m by no means a criminal profiler. But I’ve watched countless documentaries with or based on killers, this woman appears to me as a salacious, supercilious, perfidious character with a splenetic undertone. Being a female, a nurse and a mother doesn’t camouflage her true sinister or insidious traits as a killer. She’s clearly a Psychopath that can disassociate the evil 👿 within her. Personally I firmly believe the police did a magnificent job in pursuing her and achieving justice for the poor soul she betrayed and brutally executed. She’s in the right place.
Her dead husband was abusing her. He ran away from home at 15 years old because his mom abused him. He became a sadistic woman hater because of it, so they [ stepfather ] murdered him.
@@wtv.no1 who did it then, the doctor? doesn't make any difference. If both of them in prison whose going to help support her children then. if the doctor really did it then they decided one person in prison and the other out here to take care of everything else. it's the best plan for them.
There is no other conclusion. Why would someone kill him and then go through the trouble of dismembering him and putting his body parts in a suitcase? Seems awful personal.
I've watched this documentary twice and can't believe anyone would think she's innocent. Buys a 38 caliber gun ( and same ammo that killed him), out of state and denies theres a weapon in the house when asked by the judge during the restraining order request. When asked if they had luggage she says yes but not a matching set ( kind of an odd thing to say), then changes her mind when they showed her the luggage he was in. Same type of trash bags at the house that he was put into. Tells police to look at the casino for his car (that she put there).Forges a prescription on her bosses prescription pad for a drug she probably used to sedate him before she killed him. Brings her divorce attorney and another lawyer to her interview at the police station. Has him cremated within days and gives his clothes away. How could this beautiful educated nurse ever think she's get away with it is beyond me. All so she could be with her doctor boss. Yea, she's innocent ! I feel so bad for her children. No mother and father now. Only question, where did she dismember him ?
What infuriates me is these so called professionals referring a clear murderer as an innocent who was proved guilty . Like how much more evidence and possible cause you need
When she said she didnt do it? Her eyes squinted n blinked fast and when she said she cant believe people think she did it" her eyes squinted and blinked again like b4. Hmmm
@@leemagrish3432 I watched this trial too while recovering from surgery. She's guilty as hell even tho it's hard to image where she did the slicing 'n dicing. Hell, she sent his wedding ring to his sister! Sad, he sounded/looked like a decent bro w/a good job, sense of humor etc.
Why do they even interview these people? Please. To give them a forum to spew their lies. Basically she's saying that she should be found not guilty because she did a fantastic job cleaning up the crime scene with bleach. She forgot to change her shoes though when she took his car to Atlantic City.
I remember the case, but on this video what really struck me this time is her freaking narcissistic way of speaking in the third person. And I remember she had a camera and she documented or journaled by camera her woes late at night about the case...you know, how put-upon she was by this. Someone below notes how she is like the rest of the sociopaths/narcissistic monsters like Hodi Ariass, Scott Peterson, Casey Anthony, Chriss Watts and that seems true to me!
If someone else killed him how did he end up in the suitcase from their own house? You're not going to live a life with someone anymore yet buying a house with the person!? There's different ways to handle money to prevent it from being gambled. 🤔🤨
The suitcases, the blanket with her clinics logo, the prescription pad, she forged her lovers name to get that killer drug, the gun her trip to Atlantic City leaving his car there. She told on herself lol
Oh but there is great explanation she says "he packed his things while I was hiding in the bathroom" so she wants us to believe he took 3 suitcases of stuff to Atlantic city to gamble and said a canned line like out of sopranos "you can explain to the kids why they dont have a father" or something like that. For some reason when she talks I'm distracted by her own self's over importance w every word her ego grows.
@Ben Hur agreed those cop checked everything everything line to her she moved out the house the had cleaned gave he's clothes then stated he packed he's clothes cone one her signature on prescription come on the gun she bought come Guilty then she said he had a gamble ing problem but he was wining it how he bought the house she sound so stupid
I am convinced Melonie didnt kill him by herself, But she was involved...I have a weird feeling her lover was strong enough to do what happened to Bill though.
I have always wondered about her getting help from someone like her step father. The prosecutor said years ago they weren’t out ruling she could of gotten help.
Two things not sitting right with me: this woman is 5'3 and weighed no more than 115 lbs when Bill died. I do not believe she dismembered him, nor do I believe she drove 300 miles with a dismembered body in the car. Each suitcase weighed between 65 and 80 lbs of dead weight. I don't believe she threw them off the bridge. Second, I do not believe that Bill was dismembered in their apartment. That would be noisy, messy, and require a lot of physical strength. Not a trace of blood or tissue was found in that apartment. Nobody cleans THAT well. It's easy to say "oh, she had help" but that's a mere assumption. No offer of proof was made, and there was no evidence against the one person who most likely would have been an accomplice. That notwithstanding, there is something about her that makes me believe she knows more than she's telling. She may or may not have been the shooter, but I'm not convinced she doesn't know what happened to him.
Sure she could . She put him in 3 luggege and took each luggage,one at a time ,she didn't even had to lift it, could have pushed or slide/roll it to her car and then lift each luggage for few seconds to put in trunk . People can lift very heavy things for short periods of time,it's not like she had to carry the luggage with two hands and walk long distance. The same when she got to the bridge ,she lift each luggage one at a time and throw it to the water All it takes is few seconds. Before she cut him she put in his wine the drug to make him sleepy / uncounsious and rolled /pushed/ dragged his body to the shower where she cut him all the blood is drained the running water makes it easy to clean the messs. The noise of a saw cutting the body blend with background noises of tv or music combined with noises of running water, air-condition on ... I doubt someone from outside can know what's going on in an inside room of apt with close windows. There was no mess because she covered the floor with plastic bags nylon/ tarp or whatever material before she shoot him and dragged the body on the floor. She had the whole night and whole day to clean the mess. Only the fact the apt was left so clean is clearly showing she did it. She is an obsessive compulsive psychopath , she was in a trance cleaning and scrubbing the apt for hours. What normal person leaves an apt in such spotless condition like no one ever lived there?! A witness said when she came inside the apt she was taken by the strong smell of the cleaning products, she couldn't breath .It felt like a smell of a mourge. Any place were two small children lived in can't be so clean . It's not normal. Creepy how she has an answer for everything. A pathological liar . Scarry how her eyes move to the sides when she talk. She was not found guilty based on opinions or assumptions but based on evidence and facts. This is the reason the lawyer her family paid lot of money to hire and was one of the best in town ...he couldn't acquit her because all facts and evidence point to her. Last thing, after she used all appeals and when she knew she is not going anywhere, she is in prison until her death , only then she admitted to her children that she did participate in the murder.
@@tedybear7314 ok, I know for a fact that last statement is untrue. She has had zero contact with either child since her incarceration. The apartment was spotless because she moved out and wanted her security deposit back. Like I said, she may have shot him, but he wasn't dismembered there. Nope, nope, nope. Sorry. Didn't happen.
@@annanimity7085 Someone who has inside information said it. Even if Melanie doesn't have contact with her children and they don't visit her , she still can call them from prison and she did. It was in a phone conversation when she called her children and she admitted she was present at the time of the murder. A detective who worked on this case said it. Not me !!! About the apt. Melanie Mcguire could easily clean the apt by herself. She was alone , no one to interrupted her. She didn't sleep , she was cleaning the apt all night and all day. How can it be that in a house where 4 people lived for a long period of time, there was not even one fingerprint. Not even one DNA Who cares to clean a house so thoroughly when you know you are not going to continue to live there ? This is very unnormal. Another point I want to mention : Most people when they find out their ex husband/wife was dismembered and put in suitcase , regardless of how the relationship between them , they will have some empathy and compassion no matter how bad things between them When Melanie Mcguire talks about Bill you can see the hate in her eyes In all her interviews she makes it look like he is the bad guy ...how mean he was ... he hit her...he abused her ... The man died a horrible death , the least you can do is not to talk bad about him. She is a dangerous woman. She is where she needs to be and she will be there until she dies. A side note When a tenant leave an apt even if the apt is dirty as long as there is no damage and nothing was destroyed, he will get the security deposit back
@@tedybear7314 "Someone who has inside information" = hearsay. If someone who treated me poorly ended up getting murdered, I wouldn't put on a big show of grieving either. Maybe she just didn't care; that doesn't mean she killed him. If I remember correctly, there were people living in the apartment after she vacated and the state had to put them up in a hotel so the forensics team could come in. Your "not so much as a fingerprint" statement doesn't ring true. They examined the pipes, the drains, the traps (which people are not physically able to access to clean) and they found nothing to bolster their case. Nada, zip, zilch. It didn't happen there. As for Bill, Melanie is not the only person who said he could be an a$$hole. He had a gambling problem and a knack for pissing people off. He didn't die a "horrible death"; he was shot twice. The dismemberment came afterward. I think as far as abuse she probably gave as good as she got. She may have shot him, she may have been there when it happened, or she may have had it done, but I am not buying that she cut him up a) in that apartment and b) without help. But I do believe she was in on it and that she parked Bill's car in AC to make it look like he went on a bender. Someone else was there, either in her car or their own, and brought her back to Woodbridge. Her biggest lie was about those cab rides: someone was with her, and that's her accomplice. It makes way more sense than the alternative. And sorry, but I'm not believing she admitted any involvement to Jack and Jason without some kind of proof.
If she had a believable defense, she should have taken the stand at trial. Who wouldn’t want to speak on their behalf if they were facing years in prison for a murder they didn’t commit? She chose not to speak because of the avalanche of evidence against her. Patricia Prezioso did a brilliant job prosecuting McGuire, and would have torn her, and her baloney stories to shreds. McGuire is guilty as hell, and she’s exactly where she needs to be. The only way she’s leaving prison is in a box. They should do it Melanie McGuire-style...take her out in three boxes.
It's literally common practice for the accused to be advised, by their own attorneys, *not* to take the stand. Things can be twisted to mean something very different than intended and people can get flustered, even when they're telling the truth. Being in a witness box in front of cameras and a jury is very nerve-racking. Juries aren't really about getting messy, grey-area details. They want cut-and-dry, black & white, very obvious believable **stories**, not necessarily the facts as they are, which are never straightforward in real life. Innocent people get convicted of crimes they didn't commit on bullshit evidence that can be/has been refuted at a later stage. There's a lot she did that makes her look questionable, but none of it actually points to or means she murdered her husband.
Those two podcasters should be ashamed , this woman is guilty, there is TONS OF EVIDENCE, think about Bill and his family and friends when you are defending her , she is where she belongs !!!
It's nice these criminologists have looked into this case. Unfortunately, there's a mountain of circumstantial evidence and they don't present anything to contradict it. She'll never get out. This program presents nothing of value. I can't help but wonder if it's simply that she doesn't "seem" like the average sociopath that some people keep focusing on it. If she has something more to present then do it.
Nobody on the planet thinks this woman is innocent except someone looking to gain publicity or financially covering this high profile case. Which is so disrespectful to the victim's loved ones. Thanks ABC for making us aware of these cases. However the 2 women claiming she is innocent should be ashamed.
I was thinking the same unless somebody trying to frame her. If she was framed, they gotta be big and powerful. Something like her work place, in my opinion
No I do not feel bad for her she absolutely did it and tried to cover it up. I hope she sits in that cell and regrets it everyday there’s a special place for truly evil individuals she’ll see sooner than later.
She did it cause the fact that every single evidence points to her, the trash bag he was found in to the ones she gave her cousin his cloths in and the suitcase he was found in to the suitcase they owned she also purchased a gun and he was killed with a gun, she's a manipulater that killed her husband because she wanted to be with the guy she was cheating on him with.
Melanie also changed her story about their "fight" several times. *She originally said they fought in the early evening. After they celebrated their house closing. Then she said they woke up in the middle of the night and fought around 1:00 a.m. Then Melanie told someone that they argued in the morning. She also changed her story about what Bill said when he left. She said he told her you're the reason the boys will never see me again. Then she said he told her, you'll never see the kids again. She is one evil broad.
@@nettejohnson7492 yeah my mom said she was really sweet and they worked well together. they used to talk all the time. she saw her on the news when it happened and was shocked
Check out the quick half smile at 3:26. And she's still worried most about what other's think of her vs. the fact that she's erroneously serving a life sentence?? Give me a break. There was a mountain of evidence against her.
How bad can you be ? Cheater Psycho Murderer Keep the body in suitcases (And worse of all she was a mother while/after she did it) And still get life sentences and still be so delusional that you're innocent even after 13 years imprisonment.
Yeah I don't know. Involving someone else is a huge risk. How many people are willing to help you dispose of a body? Maybe, her stepfather. That's the only guy I can think would help her. Dr. Miller (the guy she was having the affair with)? No way.
What does her being a so called “beautiful girl “ have to do with it? If she was ugly would that make a difference? She did it,she’s just trying to get off now because prison life just isn’t for her.
An embarrassing liar, a pathetic cheater, a manipulative loathsome individual, who thought, she would be able to get away with murder. She's exactly, where she belongs. Everything, from the motif to the MO points at her., and everyone who has even a single doubt about her guilt, has never seen or heard about this case, entirely.
You guys pay attention to how she flutters her eyes when she answers questions. I went prison and I really did meet people just like this. You could have all the evidence in the world and as calm as day they'd swear they didn't do it but yet would be in their obsessed with talking about the crimes.🙄🤦🤣🤣
I’m not saying she didn’t do it but why didn’t they question the guy she was having an affair with? The same guy whose car she took to drive in Virginia. It’s a bit weird. I think she had help.
Does a murderer look a certain way? There are so many murderers over the years that should really inform us, murderers are committed by a wide range of people. We should be wiser than looking at appearances and status
![กิโลเมตรที่ 0 เดินทางรอบโลกไม่ใช้เครื่องบิน [Around The World Ep. 1]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/toJG9oofLFY/mqdefault.jpg)
“She doesn’t fit the profile of a murderer “ the most stupid utterance I’ve heard!
ikr😑
And repeated remarks on her appearance as if attractiveness is a factor in murder capability!
There was this case where a wife hired a hit man to kill her husband. When asked if she was worried about being caught or suspected, she replied she was tiny woman and no one would think she was capable. Riiiight
A.K.A she’s not a tall big black man 😂
Black Widow
I feel bad for the boy who opened the suitcase .. horrific image can't be deleted ..
Abeer Azzyadi they missed school for those fresh legs
was my first thought, poor boy wow what image..
not till death do as part but in death dump your parts.
Same and for the victim who lost the legs the young lad saw
@@foff2246 ppp
Everybody is capable of evil. I hate how people are so disbelieving that she could have done this. Evil has no specific shape, gender, or age.
Oh I think she did it, but she did it with help. She won't rat out the person that helped her because that means she did it. For all the people who believe she is innocent that would all go away. They would know she was behind his murder.
This. I can't stand it when people say things like "She's too beautiful to have done this" or "She is just a tiny little woman, no way she did this" or other things based off of her looks, gender or charisma. People thought Ted Bundy was an amazing guy too, and look what he did.
Women absolutely can and do commit atrocious crimes and many times get away with it because people refuse to see women as "capable" of such things. They absolutely are.
Not any one especially empath's
Progressives never hate. They are the embodiment of love.
@@ApplePie-ro9lc I agree
It takes a special kind of monster to cut someone up. She would know how because she's a nurse...she'd know where to cut
Just because you're a nurse doesn't mean you know where to cut
@@tloveit7910 well it would help I'm sure
I don’t think being a nurse would teach you any special dismemberment skills .
@@pwallace5359 she would know where the joints meet and muscles are etc. My mother was an r.n.
if you murdered someone and had a saw would you have literally no idea how to cut them up? you literal just cut where you want the cut to be
Her life was a act just like chris watts Jodi, Casey Anthony , Scott Peterson
This comment ^^^
My mom actually had Melanie as a nurse back in 2002. She loved her as well as Dr. Miller and was shocked when this all came about.
@Angel idaf if u care or not
@Angel I do actually
@Angel why ur so mad? Tf
Does anyone know what happened to Dr. Miller? Did he lose his license?
wtf
Why are we so fascinated with psychopaths?
Coz we can't relate ! Unbelievable as well and shocking. Just a guess
I originally saw this years ago and snapped of course it was only an hour long so they cut out a lot
Because secretly, at some point, we've all been at that cliff....we want to understand why some jump and some walk away...
@silverbud you'll get there
Fear sells just like sex sells it’s sad really how when things like this happens it just gets exploited instead of holding all people accountable clearly jail isn’t working because killers continue to kill. The system is broken. Humans ruin everything
That poor little boy was probably traumatized from opening that bag and seeing legs!
This is going to sound weird, but doesn't she look like Corey Feldman.
Sure does look like him! Thought the same thing! Lol
@LG When she's not in the mood, she makes herr voice really deep and starts quoting Corey Feldman's lines from The Lost Boys just to turn you off. LOL
Yes yes. I was gonna say she isn’t beautiful like they keep saying.
I thought, did corey Feldman transition?
Sort of
She talks about herself third person. That is scary.
yeah...shes dissasociating/distancing herself from a direct question about her guilt. very fishy to me
If you listen, the interviewer asks her a question that you have to respond to in 3rd person
The evidence at trial was absolutely OVERWHELMING. She totally did it, no question.
They should just do a lie detector
@@emmanuel3566 in cases like this lie detectors are rarely used to prove innocence. They can be easily deceived so they aren’t accurate
@@fiamojo1 true but still why not just do if just to see
If all it took was a lie detector (an investigative tool), Ted Bundy would still be on the loose!
I am from NJ, but am unfamiliar with this case...what was the evidence?
“How can any one think that I did this?” For me, it was the evidence. A person might have had a fight before a spouse disappeared, or just bought a gun, or be having an affair, or been shopping in the area where the body was dumped, or have similar suitcases, or “moved” the husband’s car elsewhere, or have similar blankets to those at the crime scene, or be worried that a toll booth documented your trip despite paying cash, etc. but pretty hard to think “innocent” when all those things and more.
Melanie is a special kind of evil, the kind that fools every one by their fake kindness,smiles & charm. How on flat earth anyone would do a bjob while 8 months pregnant, is beyond me. I am a very fussy eater when I am pregnant.
Stop assuming a nurse couldn’t do this. Have you met any nurses? I’m from a family of them, am one myself, and you’d be surprised how nasty and cold some can be. Do I think she’d murder her patient? No. When she killed her husband, she was a wife killing her husband and her occupation had nothing to do with it.
honestly ppl should look at history theres multiple documented nurse murderers if not serial killers. they are desensitized to inner body stuff and they have access to vulnerable people, so it tracks
I believe when ppl reference her being a nurse, it's because of her knowledge of the body, say for the purposes of making perfect cuts to dismember.
Yep. True. That’s like saying no doctors or dentists could kill. All types can kill. Lawyers judges millionaires.
NOBODY INNOCENT WOULD CALMLY AND PEACEFULLY CRY OUT INJUSTICE..
100 % she did it, the prescription pad is some damning evidence. If someone else did it, they wouldnt have access to that doctors prescription pad.
this
When she says " How can somebody think that I did that?" she smirks. That's cold.
She has the tells of someone not being honest..
That’s what I thought. She doesn’t seem genuine or sincere.
3:06 that blinking when asked if she’s wrongfully convicted.. she’s totally lying 😂
I know right its just how she acted was not right. 😂
Alot of blinking more then usual can indicate lying. I agree with your comment. I thought I was the only one that noticed her incessive blinking.
I literally thought that was Corey Feldman dressed as a woman in the thumbnail.
Me too!!!
Lol omg
Omg me too
🤣
I was looking for this, I thought the same. 😂
Notice how she disgaurded her boyfriend after he took the stand and told his truth...I find it amazing she thinks we would find her innocent !!!
Agreed
He was recording their conversations for the police but he kept having sex with her the whole time. She's guilty but he deserved to be kicked to the curb after that
@@annanimity7085 🤣🤣 y'all crazy
@@annanimity7085 not really. He is a smart man he used her for sex and nothing more. She is a murderous crazy woman that killed her husband while cheating. The fault is on her not the man.
@@annanimity7085 I think he was doing that so she wouldn't grow suspicious tf
I’m by no means a criminal profiler. But I’ve watched countless documentaries with or based on killers, this woman appears to me as a salacious, supercilious, perfidious character with a splenetic undertone. Being a female, a nurse and a mother doesn’t camouflage her true sinister or insidious traits as a killer. She’s clearly a Psychopath that can disassociate the evil 👿 within her. Personally I firmly believe the police did a magnificent job in pursuing her and achieving justice for the poor soul she betrayed and brutally executed. She’s in the right place.
i feel like a lot of folks from that part of the world are pretty splenetic but facts
Right on Beast Hunter! Couldn’t have summed it up any better. You write so well‼️
Sounds like your describing a seriously complex wine.
Poison ivy wine in an attractive bottle.
What a load of crap
Her dead husband was abusing her. He ran away from home at 15 years old because his mom abused him. He became a sadistic woman hater because of it, so they [ stepfather ] murdered him.
She got that Carol baskin look in her eyes.
Yes! Totally...
Loving the guy's wholesome reaction to finding human body parts in a suitcase "Oh my gracious" bless him.
LOL
shes such a horrible person. her thinking that she shouldn't be guilty makes me sick. we all know that she did all this.
I 👍 she's guilty!
Corby Dinzen no but she didn't murder her husband and cut him up!!
She actually didn’t do it.
@@wtv.no1 who did it then, the doctor? doesn't make any difference. If both of them in prison whose going to help support her children then. if the doctor really did it then they decided one person in prison and the other out here to take care of everything else. it's the best plan for them.
There is no other conclusion. Why would someone kill him and then go through the trouble of dismembering him and putting his body parts in a suitcase? Seems awful personal.
I've watched this documentary twice and can't believe anyone would think she's innocent. Buys a 38 caliber gun ( and same ammo that killed him), out of state and denies theres a weapon in the house when asked by the judge during the restraining order request. When asked if they had luggage she says yes but not a matching set ( kind of an odd thing to say), then changes her mind when they showed her the luggage he was in. Same type of trash bags at the house that he was put into. Tells police to look at the casino for his car (that she put there).Forges a prescription on her bosses prescription pad for a drug she probably used to sedate him before she killed him. Brings her divorce attorney and another lawyer to her interview at the police station. Has him cremated within days and gives his clothes away. How could this beautiful educated nurse ever think she's get away with it is beyond me. All so she could be with her doctor boss. Yea, she's innocent ! I feel so bad for her children. No mother and father now. Only question, where did she dismember him ?
She looks better than most of us would, after 13 years in prison.
She does not deserves more time in jail .
@@attilafry I also think she isn’t guilty
@@d.k6096 Maybe you are righ... She needs mercy and much love .
She was ugly even before prison. 😂😂😂
@@attilafryshe does need mercy. We all do. I pray for her soul.
What infuriates me is these so called professionals referring a clear murderer as an innocent who was proved guilty .
Like how much more evidence and possible cause you need
Other people just get a Divorce. Period.
they always overstate beauty in these murder documentaries
When she said she didnt do it? Her eyes squinted n blinked fast and when she said she cant believe people think she did it" her eyes squinted and blinked again like b4. Hmmm
I noticed that!
You people are fucking stupid
PupinTheTurd III exactlyy
@@pupintheturdiii so you know something that we don't?
Do you suspect she has some sort of psychological disorder?
She didn't believe she would be convicted but I believe she is guilty and is right where she needs to be.
Right? Like even her attitude throughout the whole trial
I remember this case. I was a sophomore in college watching the trial on MSNBC.
Whoa, she's aged.
Maybe she should have stayed with the hubs.
@@leemagrish3432 I watched this trial too while recovering from surgery. She's guilty as hell even tho it's hard to image where she did the slicing 'n dicing. Hell, she sent his wedding ring to his sister! Sad, he sounded/looked like a decent bro w/a good job, sense of humor etc.
She sounds convincing that she's innocent. However, some people can lie so calmly and convincingly
Sociopath
It's pretty easy to lie. I used to do it all the time to my Mom and Dad when I was younger. Were you drinking? I just had a couple...... of 6 packs. 😂
At 3:26 the scariest duper's delight I've ever seen
Why do they even interview these people? Please. To give them a forum to spew their lies. Basically she's saying that she should be found not guilty because she did a fantastic job cleaning up the crime scene with bleach. She forgot to change her shoes though when she took his car to Atlantic City.
That British guy was way too excited about that kid finding those legs.
He wrote a book about this case.
I remember the case, but on this video what really struck me this time is her freaking narcissistic way of speaking in the third person. And I remember she had a camera and she documented or journaled by camera her woes late at night about the case...you know, how put-upon she was by this. Someone below notes how she is like the rest of the sociopaths/narcissistic monsters like Hodi Ariass, Scott Peterson, Casey Anthony, Chriss Watts and that seems true to me!
I think Brian koburger can be added to the list now 🤔...
If someone else killed him how did he end up in the suitcase from their own house? You're not going to live a life with someone anymore yet buying a house with the person!? There's different ways to handle money to prevent it from being gambled. 🤔🤨
The suitcases, the blanket with her clinics logo, the prescription pad, she forged her lovers name to get that killer drug, the gun her trip to Atlantic City leaving his car there. She told on herself lol
@@donnab7666 Indeed she did!
Oh but there is great explanation she says "he packed his things while I was hiding in the bathroom" so she wants us to believe he took 3 suitcases of stuff to Atlantic city to gamble and said a canned line like out of sopranos "you can explain to the kids why they dont have a father" or something like that. For some reason when she talks I'm distracted by her own self's over importance w every word her ego grows.
@Ben Hur agreed those cop checked everything everything line to her she moved out the house the had cleaned gave he's clothes then stated he packed he's clothes cone one her signature on prescription come on the gun she bought come Guilty then she said he had a gamble ing problem but he was wining it how he bought the house she sound so stupid
Why do people keep saying she’s beautiful? She’s not even remotely beautiful.
She" a sensual woman .
I am convinced Melonie didnt kill him by herself, But she was involved...I have a weird feeling her lover was strong enough to do what happened to Bill though.
Who's here because of tiktok?
I have always wondered about her getting help from someone like her step father. The prosecutor said years ago they weren’t out ruling she could of gotten help.
Two things not sitting right with me: this woman is 5'3 and weighed no more than 115 lbs when Bill died. I do not believe she dismembered him, nor do I believe she drove 300 miles with a dismembered body in the car. Each suitcase weighed between 65 and 80 lbs of dead weight. I don't believe she threw them off the bridge. Second, I do not believe that Bill was dismembered in their apartment. That would be noisy, messy, and require a lot of physical strength. Not a trace of blood or tissue was found in that apartment. Nobody cleans THAT well. It's easy to say "oh, she had help" but that's a mere assumption. No offer of proof was made, and there was no evidence against the one person who most likely would have been an accomplice.
That notwithstanding, there is something about her that makes me believe she knows more than she's telling. She may or may not have been the shooter, but I'm not convinced she doesn't know what happened to him.
Ahh omg, yess you’re right! Finally someone who understands!!
Sure she could .
She put him in 3 luggege and took each luggage,one at a time ,she didn't even had to lift it, could have pushed or slide/roll it to her car and then lift each luggage for few seconds to put in trunk .
People can lift very heavy things for short periods of time,it's not like she had to carry the luggage with two hands and walk long distance.
The same when she got to the bridge ,she lift each luggage one at a time and throw it to the water
All it takes is few seconds.
Before she cut him she put in his wine the drug to make him
sleepy / uncounsious
and rolled /pushed/ dragged his body to the shower where she cut him all the blood is drained
the running water makes it easy to clean the messs.
The noise of a saw cutting the body blend with background noises of tv or music combined with noises of running water, air-condition on ...
I doubt someone from outside can know what's going on in an inside room of apt with close windows.
There was no mess because she covered the floor with plastic bags nylon/ tarp or whatever material before she shoot him and dragged the body on the floor.
She had the whole night and whole day to clean the mess.
Only the fact the apt was left so clean is clearly showing she did it. She is an obsessive compulsive psychopath , she was in a trance cleaning and scrubbing the apt for hours.
What normal person leaves an apt in such spotless condition like no one ever lived there?!
A witness said when she came inside the apt she was taken by the strong smell of the cleaning products, she couldn't breath .It felt like a smell of a mourge.
Any place were two small children lived in can't be so clean .
It's not normal.
Creepy how she has an answer for everything. A pathological liar . Scarry how her eyes move to the sides when she talk.
She was not found guilty based on opinions or assumptions but based on evidence and facts.
This is the reason the lawyer her family paid lot of money to hire and was one of the best in town ...he couldn't acquit her because all facts and evidence point to her.
Last thing, after she used all appeals and when she knew she is not going anywhere, she is in prison until her death , only then she admitted to her children that she did participate in the murder.
@@tedybear7314 ok, I know for a fact that last statement is untrue. She has had zero contact with either child since her incarceration. The apartment was spotless because she moved out and wanted her security deposit back. Like I said, she may have shot him, but he wasn't dismembered there. Nope, nope, nope. Sorry. Didn't happen.
@@annanimity7085
Someone who has inside information said it.
Even if Melanie doesn't have contact with her children and they don't visit her , she still can call them from prison and she did.
It was in a phone conversation when she called her children and she admitted she was present at the time of the murder.
A detective who worked on this case said it. Not me !!!
About the apt.
Melanie Mcguire could easily clean the apt by herself.
She was alone , no one to interrupted her. She didn't sleep , she was cleaning the apt all night and all day.
How can it be that in a house where 4 people lived for a long period of time,
there was not even one fingerprint. Not even one DNA
Who cares to clean a house so thoroughly when you know you are not going to continue to live there ?
This is very unnormal.
Another point I want to mention :
Most people when they find out their ex husband/wife was dismembered and put in suitcase , regardless of how the relationship between them , they will have some empathy and compassion no matter how bad things between them
When Melanie Mcguire talks about Bill you can see the hate in her eyes
In all her interviews she makes it look like he is the bad guy ...how mean he was ... he hit her...he abused her ...
The man died a horrible death ,
the least you can do is not to talk bad about him.
She is a dangerous woman. She is where she needs to be and she will be there until she dies.
A side note
When a tenant leave an apt even if the apt is dirty as long as there is no damage and nothing was destroyed,
he will get the security deposit back
@@tedybear7314 "Someone who has inside information" = hearsay. If someone who treated me poorly ended up getting murdered, I wouldn't put on a big show of grieving either. Maybe she just didn't care; that doesn't mean she killed him. If I remember correctly, there were people living in the apartment after she vacated and the state had to put them up in a hotel so the forensics team could come in. Your "not so much as a fingerprint" statement doesn't ring true. They examined the pipes, the drains, the traps (which people are not physically able to access to clean) and they found nothing to bolster their case. Nada, zip, zilch. It didn't happen there. As for Bill, Melanie is not the only person who said he could be an a$$hole. He had a gambling problem and a knack for pissing people off. He didn't die a "horrible death"; he was shot twice. The dismemberment came afterward. I think as far as abuse she probably gave as good as she got. She may have shot him, she may have been there when it happened, or she may have had it done, but I am not buying that she cut him up a) in that apartment and b) without help. But I do believe she was in on it and that she parked Bill's car in AC to make it look like he went on a bender. Someone else was there, either in her car or their own, and brought her back to Woodbridge. Her biggest lie was about those cab rides: someone was with her, and that's her accomplice. It makes way more sense than the alternative. And sorry, but I'm not believing she admitted any involvement to Jack and Jason without some kind of proof.
If she had a believable defense, she should have taken the stand at trial. Who wouldn’t want to speak on their behalf if they were facing years in prison for a murder they didn’t commit? She chose not to speak because of the avalanche of evidence against her. Patricia Prezioso did a brilliant job prosecuting McGuire, and would have torn her, and her baloney stories to shreds. McGuire is guilty as hell, and she’s exactly where she needs to be. The only way she’s leaving prison is in a box. They should do it Melanie McGuire-style...take her out in three boxes.
It's literally common practice for the accused to be advised, by their own attorneys, *not* to take the stand. Things can be twisted to mean something very different than intended and people can get flustered, even when they're telling the truth. Being in a witness box in front of cameras and a jury is very nerve-racking. Juries aren't really about getting messy, grey-area details. They want cut-and-dry, black & white, very obvious believable **stories**, not necessarily the facts as they are, which are never straightforward in real life.
Innocent people get convicted of crimes they didn't commit on bullshit evidence that can be/has been refuted at a later stage.
There's a lot she did that makes her look questionable, but none of it actually points to or means she murdered her husband.
Those two podcasters should be ashamed , this woman is guilty, there is TONS OF EVIDENCE, think about Bill and his family and friends when you are defending her , she is where she belongs !!!
I agree! These “so called” criminologists are a joke.
Agree. I watched a snap episode about her. It was season 5 episode 13. It was clear she murdered her husband.
It's nice these criminologists have looked into this case. Unfortunately, there's a mountain of circumstantial evidence and they don't present anything to contradict it. She'll never get out. This program presents nothing of value. I can't help but wonder if it's simply that she doesn't "seem" like the average sociopath that some people keep focusing on it. If she has something more to present then do it.
She certainly lives up to her prominent widow's peak!
Well technically she is a widow.
6:08. He said oh my gracious?
I’m thinking I would of say a lot of other stuff. Smh
Nobody on the planet thinks this woman is innocent except someone looking to gain publicity or financially covering this high profile case. Which is so disrespectful to the victim's loved ones. Thanks ABC for making us aware of these cases. However the 2 women claiming she is innocent should be ashamed.
you did it. I remember when the fisherman found the suit case.
“how could somebody think i did that” “i did that” she’s guilty y’all she just said “i did that”
How I can be criminologist and detective at the same time HELP
Bricks are cheap and rocks are free . Just saying.
Lol....
Wow
I was thinking the same unless somebody trying to frame her. If she was framed, they gotta be big and powerful. Something like her work place, in my opinion
i feel so sorry for her parents, how could they imagine raising a killer
In french
I think her Father was in on it.
@@TK-ro5nn It was her stepfather. He real Dad was dead at the time.
Of course she’s guilty. She’s self centred and arrogant!
"You're sitting here, a wrongfully convicted person?" .. "yes, absolutely" **blink, blink ,blink
Reminds me of the movie The Shawshank Redemption. "Yeah we're all innocent here."
Melanie looks like Cory Feldman. 🤣
Sociopaths will never admit the truth.
No I do not feel bad for her she absolutely did it and tried to cover it up. I hope she sits in that cell and regrets it everyday there’s a special place for truly evil individuals she’ll see sooner than later.
Not gonna lie i thought this was going to be about the suitcase from tiktok with the two dead bodies in other suitcases as well.
flxwercxrpse no this was years ago
firedrago0115 Yeah...i see that lol thats why i said, “i thought”
Girl Bye, you did it
Wow she has a tell 3:26
All you need to know. Our expressions give away the lies our mouth speaks.
I’m not sure she did it by herself. The fisherman even said it was heavy and he had to help them pick it up
It was water logged .
How bad can you be ?
Cheater
Psycho Murderer
Keep the body in suitcases
And still get life sentences
she low key looks like a female Corey Feldman
I totally see it! 😂
Nailed it🎯
She did it cause the fact that every single evidence points to her, the trash bag he was found in to the ones she gave her cousin his cloths in and the suitcase he was found in to the suitcase they owned she also purchased a gun and he was killed with a gun, she's a manipulater that killed her husband because she wanted to be with the guy she was cheating on him with.
yeah. how convenient the bit about being framed only came out after her conviction 🤔
Melanie also changed her story about their "fight" several times.
*She originally said
they fought in the early evening. After they celebrated their house closing. Then she said they woke up in the middle of the night and fought around 1:00 a.m.
Then Melanie told someone that they argued in the morning. She also changed her story about what Bill said when he left. She said he told her you're the reason the boys will never see me again. Then she said he told her, you'll never see the kids again. She is one evil broad.
And of course as always the gun mysteriously disappears. What horrible luck. If she had not lost that gun, it could have proven her innocence. 😂😂
this lady was my mom's nurse when she was pregnant
Was she a good nurse?
@@nettejohnson7492 yeah my mom said she was really sweet and they worked well together. they used to talk all the time. she saw her on the news when it happened and was shocked
@@beccaesten7709 She's a sweet little lady .
Copied Comment
@@tentsee8312 it's definitely not lol
Believe me, u wont find the last part...not the body part, the video part that abc post for free...
I posted the remaining parts in another comment under this video
Josie P Clever post
Let he out. She’s innocent
Does the detective look exactly like Bill McGuire -
as she adds, sweetly, “ and I just burst into tears “ any moron can see her guilt
Check out the quick half smile at 3:26. And she's still worried most about what other's think of her vs. the fact that she's erroneously serving a life sentence?? Give me a break. There was a mountain of evidence against her.
DOESNT SHE LOOK CARING ?
She did it...period.
How bad can you be ?
Cheater
Psycho Murderer
Keep the body in suitcases
(And worse of all she was a mother while/after she did it)
And still get life sentences and still be so delusional that you're innocent even after 13 years imprisonment.
This woman is very very very guilty. She can lie all she wants she wanted him gone she should have just divorced him without killing him.
3:25 she says how could someone think 3:26 that i could do that. The dupers delight in 3:26 was chilling
Why are they giving these convicted criminals air time? After what she did, she should be locked up forever in solitary.....
This lady does not deserves more suffering .
Yeah but we’re watching it 🤷🏻♀️
@@SalveRegina8 She suffered enough time .
She can barely contain her contempt and hatred when speaking of her husband.
Why didn't they ask his ex-wife to testify about his character? It seemed important to me.
There was no pattern or they would have
I want to watch this but its an incomplete ABC series
Look at the face when she says how shes inocent
Her eyes are all over the place. There's virtually no eye contact. It looks like she's lying all throughout.
Some people are great manipulators..
Fresh legs, the Chesapeake Bay's known for its seafood.
Candlestick holder in library by ??? .
So many other cases deserve attention where there is likely an innocent person in jail. This is NOT one of those cases.
There's no way she pulled it off alone.
Yeah I don't know. Involving someone else is a huge risk. How many people are willing to help you dispose of a body? Maybe, her stepfather. That's the only guy I can think would help her. Dr. Miller (the guy she was having the affair with)? No way.
Innocent and behind bars for life... smh
😂😂🤣 If she’s innocent, I’m the next (and first female) pope
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
What does her being a so called “beautiful girl “ have to do with it? If she was ugly would that make a difference? She did it,she’s just trying to get off now because prison life just isn’t for her.
Attractive people, especially women, tend to get less time than others. Not in this case though.
5:29 Couldn't help laughing at that😂😂😂
Gurl u did it 😒
Guilty guilty
Datang kesini karena kak Nessie wkwk
Divorce is better than murder. So sad.
Her husband looked so sweet man
An embarrassing liar, a pathetic cheater, a manipulative loathsome individual, who thought, she would be able to get away with murder. She's exactly, where she belongs. Everything, from the motif to the MO points at her., and everyone who has even a single doubt about her guilt, has never seen or heard about this case, entirely.
You guys pay attention to how she flutters her eyes when she answers questions. I went prison and I really did meet people just like this. You could have all the evidence in the world and as calm as day they'd swear they didn't do it but yet would be in their obsessed with talking about the crimes.🙄🤦🤣🤣
Who’s here from the Behavior Panel 🙋🏻♀️🤙🏽
I’m not saying she didn’t do it but why didn’t they question the guy she was having an affair with? The same guy whose car she took to drive in Virginia. It’s a bit weird. I think she had help.
Does a murderer look a certain way? There are so many murderers over the years that should really inform us, murderers are committed by a wide range of people. We should be wiser than looking at appearances and status
Who was watching the child? Her parents someone covered for her watching that newborn baby or was she still pregnant they kind of skip over that