Andrew Siciliano's Bears Option NOBODY Is Talking About
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.พ. 2024
- Dive into the exclusive insight from #AndrewSiciliano at the #nflcombine as he unveils a Bears option that's flying under the radar: trading @JustinFields AND the number one #NFLDraft pick! 🏈 Join us for an eye-opening breakdown where Siciliano explores this unconventional strategy and its potential implications for the Bears' future. Uncover the strategic insights and considerations that may shape this bold approach to roster management. Don't miss out on this must-watch analysis that delves into the untapped potential of a lesser-discussed option for the team.
For More Bears Content Watch:
The Chicago Bears Podcast : • The Chicago Bears Podcast
Waddle & SIlvy : • Waddle & Silvy
Kap & J Hood : • Kap & J.Hood
Carmen & Jurko : • Carmen & Jurko
Bleck & Abdalla : • Bleck & Abdalla
#chicagobears #Bears #nfl - กีฬา
I can't wait til this is over. I trust Poles to make the right choice.
I don't #Claypool
@@stevethomas5467I do. #DJMoore. #MontezSweat
@@alexamerling79 Touche
@@stevethomas5467 Mack
I don't trust they Bears owners... Ultimately their making the decision!!!
Everyone close your eyes and imagine a trade down with Washington and we get Marvin then with the 9th we get Rome. With these two on the outside and Dj in the slot or moving around. Who would be able to stop 3 1wr. Even if Justin isn't the answer who would turn down the opportunity to work with this crew??? Lt. Center, edge, safety and 3tech. This team wins many superbowl!
I really like this idea. It would be building the way SF did. Then you could plug in a QB in FA or in the draft and be set up for the next 4-5 yrs.
I also agree with this 💯
The same things they are say about Caleb Williams is the same things justin fields his first year starting wit the bears. Holds the ball. Plays hero ball. Bad oline and defense. Fumbling problem. Except he did that in college. Thts crazy
Ur obviously a little slow. Caleb is a much better prospect. Period
Everybody with the pay thing. Bears could simply get ahead of it and sign him now to a three year bear friendly contract.
A lot of teams have been wrong @ #1. Just look at last year and previous years.
So that's a valid reason to not draft no.1 overall and trade the pick? So stupid. Smh
I was thinking about this option today, originally poles said he’d hold onto the pick til April even if he were to trade if. Trade fields, draft night trade with Washington. Caleb goes home and poles walks away with a lot of draft capital, from fields and trading down, & the qb he wanted. Let poles cook
Which qb? Jayden, Drake or JJ?
@@alexamerling79 honestly I don’t watch tape, I don’t have a solid opinion.but I’d prefer maye If we were to take a qb out the class minus Caleb
@@alexamerling79 Daniels. McCarthy is option two if he gets another haul and moves down to as far as 6, taking Nabers or Odunze, then JJ at 9.
I would take JJ and sign Russ to that vet minimum contract if he gets cut by the Broncos for JJ to sit behind
Can we please set the bar for what constitutes 'success' for Caleb? If he doesn't make a ProBowl by year 2, I'll propose that it was a mistake to take him. The opportunity cost of passing on 3 first-round picks is HUGE. If he doesn't live up to the hype by the end of year 2, THAT will be something that will never be lived down. I don't wanna hear 'Nobody knew he wasn't gonna be great', or 'everybody was sure he'd be amazing' to excuse the decision from everyone caping for Caleb. The dude hasn't done a damn thing in the NFL yet, and people are anointing him as 'the next Mahomes.'
Also, stop talking about paying Fields. You'd be getting THREE players at premium positions with contractual control. You're gonna have to spend in FA, and pay a premium on older players if you don't use this pick to acquire additional draft capital. The value to the team vs amount paid for R1 picks is HUGE, and you'd be foregoing the opportunity to do that with THREE players.
He’s going for 4000 and winning ROY
That's just it. If they draft Caleb and trade Justin, Caleb HAS TO be better than Justin by year 2. He can't be the same or worse. If he is the same as Justin, all they did was get an extra year or two of cheaper contract at QB... but they give up the potential of 3-5 first and second round draft picks over the next two years which would save you way more on rookie contracts at multiple positions than just the QB.
@@title4445 and if he doesn't he is a bust...
@@holdwhatdoor7629- He’ll be better Day 1
Spot on
The Bears O-line has been a disaster as well! Andrew just gave 'excuses' about the O-line 10:49 at USC, yet Bears fans don't want to hear about it with JF1. LMAO
Bottom line, the O-line must be fixed REGARDLESS of who's behind center this year.
If Caleb doesn’t work...which i believe it won't. What you guys going to say then???
There going to blame the bears organization
They blame everything else but the quarterback like the fans do.
You're full of it. The QB has always been the scapegoat in Chicago. This is the first time In my lifetime that I've seen the majority of Bears fans support a QB. It's why mental toughness is an Attribute a Chicago QB must have. Honestly, Chicago has a misery fan base
@@sevinbamuels6560 A dissolution fan base
I agree... first overall pick is hardly ever the guy.
Anytime some uses the "Need to reset the rookie salary contract" as principal factor to draft a QB, is a huge waving red flag for their sound decision making. You owe JF 3Mil next year and 23 Mil if you sign his 5th year option add those together and you get 26 Mil for the next two years. If you draft CW or any other QB at 1 you have to pay them 50 Mil /4 years and it you would pay him more than 20 Mil in signing bonus, so how is that cheaper than 26 Mil??? People are throwing out all of these crazy numbers that have ZERO basis. I guess there isn't a whole lot of MATH in broadcasting school. I've check and there is NO team that has ever won a championship using "Resetting the Rookie Salary Clock" as team building technique.
The hear silvy even entertain the idea of drafting Maye number one overall sums up the Bears foolish choices year after year after year!
The only way I would trade Fields to Atlanta is if they give up their 1st round pick this year! If Poles picks CW, it will be his last season with the Bears!
You keep JF and target Boo Nix. If you watched the combine
Chicago media sucks....if i was Justin i would be ready to leave. According to these goofs they want to reset the clock every 3 years.
And notice you never here GM talk about reseting the QB reset. You only need to do that if you're having Issues with cap space.
Great discussion.
Door 3 is the right decision.
Pretty sad also that if Poles makes the wrong move he gets fired. Doesn't matter even if he had good picks last year. Nobody knows now what Caleb will be like in a year or two or if Justin gets better.
I am not Poles’ biggest fan. But I do feel for the guy. This is a make or break decision and it isn’t easy. I like JF and think he can be the guy. But I don’t know what I would do in this situation bcuz there are more questions than answers with Fields. But to be fair, those questions remain bcuz ownership allowed a lame duck GM and HC to pick a QB
Cw has. Never taken a team toi college playoff.. has never never beaten teams in his division who are top tear
He waits for things to come open, doesn’t play in structure, holds the ball, and when asked if generational he makes a grunting shy and starts to make excuses.
That's all bullshit. Can you give me in-game examples to help back up your claims?
CW is far and away much better and already does things that Maye doesn't do. CW does the things you can't really teach. He throws from ridiculous angles like Stafford and mahomes. He extends plays when the pocket collapses from a 4 man rush and yet he still kept his eyes down field... always.. I mean always looking to throw the ball to an open reciever while breaking ankles. And he also has a rocket arm. CW read defenses pretty well already and you see him work through 2-3 progressions in a play during a game. He has a quick release (like rodgers did when throwing to recivers slanting/dragging over the middle). CW is insane. I think that's why others are trying to inflate Mayes draft status. It's the NFL. If you don't think teams will use propaganda on each other and trick each other, then you don't know football.
If you point out CW "bad" games and decide thats the reason you dont want to draft him, then you need to rewatch those games or read from a proper evaluator. His defense was ranked 119/124 in the entire FBS. The are absolutely putrid. His Oline was swiss cheese. Again, he was constanly pressured by 4 man rushes in the blink of an eye (youll understand if you watch the Oregon or ND game again... or pretty mich any game). And his wideouts would constantly drop the ball. Like easy passes that hit them in the hands in the middle of their chest type passes. Its insane that USC had a winning record this year with the talent they had. CW is insane and you should want him for so many damn reasons than what I've already stated.
@@charliemurphy8416 online and defense are both things he cannot control I simply look at the way he decides to play the game. When he has good oline situations he looks for the big play and leaves good pockets. When the Defense makes stops it’s up to him to make the right play. I don’t care if he went 1-11 you can still play within structure and smart but sometimes he doesn’t do either even when the situation is favorable which is concerning.
@andrebarnes3882 His no-pressure passing grade is 93.4, better than any other quarterback in college football. And he is always looking to throw the ball. He always keeps his eyes up when his pocket collapses, which is more often than not. He is a passer first. Like Aaron Rodgers. He has the added ability to escape and produce at a high level in messy pockets, which is what caught the nation's attention. That's where the Mahomes comp keeps coming in.
You are right in that he will sometimes pass on shorter completions on something like a drag or hook route in favor of the big play. That's mostly because his team was always falling behind (due to his awful defense), so he'd play hero ball to keep his team in the game by trying to get first downs to avoid punting the ball. That won't be as much of an issue with the Bears (certainly, if the Bears defense is as good as it was towards season's end). That's easy stuff you can coach out of a kid. But you'd also have to be delicate enough to not completely erase his knack for big plays in those moments.
Again, CW is an absolute stud. You'll be happy with what you're getting.
@@charliemurphy8416 I’m not saying he’s not good and his stats don’t tell the full story simply watch his game. He’s good but I just don’t understand the hype. We can hype up any top prospect but that doesn’t mean it we’ll make their tape better. Also it scares me that he is being overhyped even more because 1st overall picks that are QBs haven’t had much success winning SBs
I just hope the people that want to restart the QB clock are willing to be patient with Mr. Generational. The great MaHomie even had to fall back his rookie season, and learn from a winning QB in Alex Smith. We don't have that on the roster, and if y'all expect Caleb to come in to save the day from game 1 stop smoking that BMF dope. It's not happening, and we'll be fortunate to reach the same record as last year. Maybe if the defense gels we could go 8-9 fighting for a wild card berth.
I certainly am not an expert. But based on the fact that GM Poles keeps saying that the Bears still have several holes to fill on both the defense & offense, I truly believe he will once again trade down for a boatload of draft picks (projected to be 6 to 8 picks... including multiple 1st Rounders) spread over 2024, 2025 & 2026. And the Bears also have a projected $80 Million to spend in free agency!! With this most likely being GM Poles last shot at making such a massive impact on the Bears roster, I don't think he will pass it up.
Poles is a junkie and his drug of choice is “Draft Picks”
Bears want a Surgeon not a artist draft down take Jayden Daniels
Caleb can't pass on time
Why has nobody thrown this scenario in there:
1. Trade Fields
2. Sign Cousins to a 1-yr or 2-yr deal
3. Draft Caleb Williams
To me, that makes the most sense. Kirk can win you a Super Bowl now and Caleb can be your future if he has time to learn.
The painting the finger nails is more of a deeper issue than just wanting them to look nice. Wake up! He’s got deeper issues not physical football ability related. WHO ever picks him is going to have a leadership in the locker room problem with him. He’s no Mahomes, Burrow or even CJ Stroud.
Dude shaking his head but it's not his money......i wondered how he would feel if his bosses didn't give him a raise if outside people told them not to give him a raise, and fire him for someone younger with less experience. Crazy world we live in
I would take Jayden Daniels if the Bears trade Justin Fields
Had a feeling as soon as they took Bryce are pick had potential top 5 pick back.
14:47.....Yal outta pocket! Wtf! 🥲🥲😅
CJ is the reason Justin defenders make no sense. He had a better situation than CJ and blew three double digit fourth quarter leads. Meanwhile, CJ is doing it and won a playoff game with weapons I never heard of. He elevated those around him and Justin apologists are saying he needs a stud at every position on the field to be successful.
If the Bears keep JF1, why do they need to pay him 40M/yr now? For "good faith", pick up the 5th year. If he plays like an average starter and the Bears have winning season and make the playoffs, he's worth the 20M in year 5. If he plays better, then renegotiate towards making him the franchise QB. Keeping JF1 means trading down for multiple first and second round picks in the next couple years, making it much easier to be a perennial playoff team for years to come, allow older players to hit free agency, with high draft picks taking over at the right time. A couple of those extra ones or twos could be once again turned into more future picks, or allowing the Bears to trade up to draft a QB in '25 or '26 if they don't want to pay JF1 after year 4 or 5. The best move for the Bears is to keep JF1 and trade back. The best move for Poles is to have a crystal ball and know definitively that CW (or other '24 QB) is a future HoF QB and draft that person at #1.
Draft Caleb, draft down from 9 get 2nd rounder back. Draft left tackle, edge , wr
This is ABC preschool talking - tooo many have went into deep depth about each of these subjects and here their just regurgitating what was talked about 3 months ago. This is PG talk - surface talk. Nothing to hear here that hasn’t been deeply taken apart by many of late already.
You can't trade down without Justin because the value will go down, keep Justin and trade him in preseason for 2025 picks and we'll get more
CW using stats only should be like the third from bottom QB
I KNEW Bryce Young was a ridiculous pick,..
Just his size alone was the biggest Red Flag in history~
I wouldn't have picked him at #5
The bears need an OT, DE, and 2 DBs more than a Qb get Penix in the 4th round!
I’m getting worried that Poles hasn’t been able to trade Justin by now. I don’t think we’re getting a 2nd round pick.
Is he generational?
Well….(every excuse and hypothetical, but no yes, he is generational)
He’s really good.
This is exactly what I've been saying. Trade Fields to Atlanta and get at least a 2nd. Trade down to Washington and get some more picks and draft Maye and hopefully Nabers or Odunze at 9.
I think Kayla Williams would get crushed by the Chicago media
Thanks Michelle…
And he wouldn't be able to handle it. There is Red Flags about him I don't like. Let him go to Washington where he is from. He went to the combine, but didn't participate, why go?.....His ego is Too big for a draft pick who hasn't proved himself at College to be a big time winner!
CW13 and Mahomes are around the same size, same screen and scramble offense, arm talent, and arm arrogance. That is the comp, doesn't mean they are going to be the same just that they compare coming out of college.
Pat is 3 inches taller and the most determined guy I’ve ever seen. Caleb ain’t 1/10 of Mahomes. He can’t handle adversity!
It's not that hard. Every year two or three teams are wrong about the top quarterbacks. If you like two or three of them this year, let other teams pay you to guess which one will be best.
We don’t need to pay Justin. He’s owed 6M this year. There’s no fire.
I love to watch Justin run. I love watching him escape the pocket. He does things with his athleticism that are jaw dropping. But in three years he has not developed as a passer. At all. You CANNOT pay him Franchise Quarterback money. It’s time to move on. Caleb is the best talent available.
3 year extension
Will the chiefs trade Mahomes to ‘reset the contract’?
I'm a USC fan and a bears fan. He's going to Chicago. No weapons no offensive line. So... what's he going to do. Since he can't beat a top 25 team. Now he's jumping to a new level where everybody is a top 25 college team. Lol
How many times do I have to school your ass? You're not a Bears fan or a USC fan cause I'd think if you were, then you understand wtf is going on. You fall for the propaganda of other NFL teams/media that is coming up with stupid excuses to try and drop CW draft status. Think about it. Peter King, Colin Cowherd, Hasselbeck. Non are Chicago fans. And none had actual evidence to back up their claims. Yet idiots like yourself fall for all of their stories.
CW is far and away much better and already does things that Maye doesn't do. CW does the things you can't really teach. He throws from ridiculous angles like Stafford and mahomes. He extends plays when the pocket collapses from a 4 man rush and yet he still kept his eyes down field... always.. I mean always looking to throw the ball to an open reciever while breaking ankles. And he also has a rocket arm. CW read defenses pretty well already and you see him work through 2-3 progressions in a play during a game. He has a quick release (like rodgers did when throwing to recivers slanting/dragging over the middle). CW is insane. I think that's why others are trying to inflate Mayes draft status. It's the NFL. If you don't think teams will use propaganda on each other and trick each other, then you don't know football.
If you point out CW "bad" games and decide thats the reason you dont want to draft him, then you need to rewatch those games or read from a proper evaluator. His defense was ranked 119/124 in the entire FBS. The are absolutely putrid. His Oline was swiss cheese. Again, he was constanly pressured by 4 man rushes in the blink of an eye (youll understand if you watch the Oregon or ND game again... or pretty mich any game). And his wideouts would constantly drop the ball. Like easy passes that hit them in the hands in the middle of their chest type passes. Its insane that USC had a winning record this year with the talent they had. CW is insane and you should want him for so many damn reasons than what I've already stated.
If Tyson Bagent can win games so can Caleb
What happened to the defensive recruiting last year...
He would be 1 st pick in the last 2 and the next 2 still. So ...
@ddm62571 The Bears won In spite of Bagent .. He's not very good.
You guys are miserable in these comments, you believe your guy ( Fields or Williams) is the only answer and nothing else would ever work. Let the GM cook, if it doesn't work either then stop supporting the product. I'm a fan no matter who they pick, I'm gonna be watching whether it's a playoff run or a train wreck, I'm here for it
Whoops. Bo
⭐⭐⭐ I'm not the smartest person in the world..but if the bears LOOKING 👀 for a haul for the first pick....does that mean they're possibly trying to stick with justin? Poles will not let others make his decision..if the 1 was a number 3 pick.. he wouldn't move up for Williams. So don't let Williams change your plans!!!
You. Trade back
You pic Roma wr
You either Trade up or trade back pic. No Nix
Unfortunately you don’t win games by handling the media🤷🏻
Caleb is NOT generational!!!! He'll be Johnny Manziel 2.0
Like how Fields was Trubisky 2.0
No point in talking other options...Bears are taking Caleb Williams
JF gets 8mil 2025
The big pay-off is not til 2026 and the Bears can Franchise tag. This is false miss information
They can keep JF and structure his contract like the Packers did with Love. A 2yr deal worth about 35m per year and give him time. And draft a QB and sit him behind JF
Man Caleb Williams another Justin fields he not gonna come in and change the franchise smh trade pick one for more picks
Bo Nix
Hope he pans out. They take trubisky and williams instead of mahommes and stroud. Typical bears.
CW is a bust. Rosen was probably better. Take Daniels
You all know nothing. Justin stays. Poles trades the pick.
You all are clueless. Ryan trades the pick.
This is aging well 😂😂😂
Sick of hearing it. Figure it out already…
He mentally couldn't handle the media in Chicago like Justin Fields has.
You're brain is mush
Whatever. Justin just proved he can’t handle it, duh.
You guys are clinging to the most ridiculous things with Justin.
Not to mention the Chicago media is one of the weakest in the league at holding guys accountable.
Half the reason is they’re all dorks that don’t know the game to know how to question them. The rest of them are too scared to get their credentials taken if they do hold people accountable.
You have the owners who are too scared to even give the media a mic so we can hear what they ask just in case they would step out of line.
Can’t handle the Chicago media. Funny.
@@NickkaDUBJustin played 3yrs with us.. never once blame other ppl for the failures, never through a temper, never asked for a trade, whole locker room wants him including the last home game when fans was changing his name.. never seen that with a losing team
He spent a couple years in LA, he can handle the media.
Trade Justin and the pick.
All of this is hyperbole
All total nonsense.
IF POLES TAKES CALEB AT #1 AND HE IS A BUST OR JUST AVERAGE HE WOULD LOSE HIS JOB...... IF HE KEEPS JUSTIN AND CALEB TURNS OUT TO BE WHAT HE IS ADVERTISED TO BE HE STILL LOSES HIS JOB HE IS BETWEEN A ROCK AND A HARD PLACE.////IT IS SAD TO SAY BECAUSE I WANT TO KEEP JUSTIN AND USE THE HAUL WE GET TO FILL LOT OF HOLES BUT IT ALWAYS COMES DOWN TO THE MONEY WHEN EVERYTHING IS SAID AND DONE THAT IS WHY THEY TRADE HIM.......THE MONEY COMMITMENT!!!