I was Cancelled for Writing About the DELUSION of MULTICULTURALISM
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 พ.ค. 2024
- On today's #NCFWhittle we speak with Harry Saul Markham, a 24 year old writer who was cancelled by his publisher. Harry's book was deemed to be too controversial as it dealt with issues such as multiculturalism and Islam. Harry joins us to discuss what happened to him as well as the wider subjects his book deals with.
---------------
SUBSCRIBE:
If you are enjoying the show, please subscribe to our channel on TH-cam (click the Subscribe Button underneath the video and then Click on the Bell icon next to it to make sure you Receive All Notifications)
AUDIO:
If you prefer Audio you can subscribe on itunes or Soundcloud.
Soundcloud: / user-923838732
itunes: itunes.apple.com/gb/podcast/s...
SUPPORT/DONATE:
PAYPAL/ CARD PAYMENTS - ONE TIME & MONTHLY:
You can donate in a variety of ways via our website: www.newcultureforum.org.uk/#do...
It is set up to accept one time and monthly donations.
JOIN US ON SOCIAL MEDIA:
Web: www.newcultureforum.org.uk
F: / ncultureforum
Y: / newcultureforum
T: / newcultureforum (@NewCultureForum)
![บุกร้านไอศกรีม VJ วุ้นเส้น !!!! [ดูคลิปเต็มหน้าช่อง] #Short | PANG ORNHIRA](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/g549nEhKZdc/mqdefault.jpg)
If you live in SHEFFIELD (21 May) or LINCOLN (22 May) join us for our upcoming NCF Locals events with Peter Whittle and Dr Philip Kiszely. Email Locals@newcultureforum.org.uk for more details. Cost: Free
Have you already booked the telephone boxes?
Imagine moving to [insert Islamic country] and vocally complaining that there aren’t enough white people in government and on TV.
Troublemakers.
Imagine occupying the lands of the Lakotas, Zulus or Maori and demanding that these nations adopt Western culture or face total extermination.
@@ncheedxx0109 so if it was wrong then why is is all of a sudden right if it’s done now just the other way. What a stupid comment
@@ncheedxx0109 that did not happen... why imagine it?
@@DungeonKeeperLondonDungeonHire Seek and ye shall find. Only that which is neglected escapes discovery.
How can you have multiculturism, where the host culture is put to the bottom of the pile?
one might answer this being Sunday by saying Jesus wanted this sort of behaviour, 'to wash the feet of your oppressor'. I say bollocks, English culture is developing still and its far superior to the barbarians culture which is knocking at the gate to sack and ruin the UK
Incisive.
Well said and completely true
👍👍
Funny how "multiculturalism" always leads to people creating tribes and groups for themselves anyway.
it's absolute madness to believe that all ideas/cultures are of equal value -- this means that there's no such thing as ethics
Culture is downstream from Race.
Moral and cultural relativism is a conclusion of Liberalism. Inevitable
@@evolassunglasses4673well, downstream from genetics
The objective standard for judging the morality of any culture is the principle of individual rights - the principle that recognises the right of every individual to the freedom to act on his or her judgement in order to make his or her life the best that it can be in the full context of his or her particular set of life circumstances, providing that he or she does not violate the same right of others. Individual rights objectively conceived define and sanction a person’s freedom of action in a social setting. The extent to which a culture recognises and upholds individual rights is the extent to which that culture is moral and good.
@@user-xy8wo4zx1x good work.
I think that we could say that the goal is to minimise human suffering and optimise human potential.
The cultures which best approach that goal would then be said to be 'best'.
Fair?
He's a nice kid who seems sincere and earnest but;-
He needs to understand that the anti-semitic attack he experienced only mirrors what has been going on for decades, primarily to the white, Christian-heritage, working class. My people are attacked, raped and even murdered because of our identity and any attempt to frame it as it truly is - an outcome of the failure of mass immigration and multi-culturalism - is dismissed as racism.
His acceptance of, and concern about, what he terms "anti Mus lim hatred' serves none of us. We already know from bitter experience how framing anything as "hatred" works against us and provides ammunition for those who truly hate us- by which I mean not just Is lamists but the hard left and even so-called liberals whose only answer to the issues brought here by Mu lims is that we shut up and try harder to be tolerant.
And frankly, he's too late to the party. His ideas of pushing a new, so called "liberal multi-culturalism" are nothing new. We ordinary people who have been at the shitty end of the stick for decades in this multi-cultural experiment. We have paid for it in more ways than I can list here and received nothing in return but the derision and hatred of the middle class elites.
It has failed. We know it. We had enough of it too long ago. It is time to put an end to this monstrous imposition on us.
Now we are waiting for someone to lead us in the bitter struggle we face for our continued existence in our own land. He can join us if he wants or he can remain an irrelevance..
Yes, I agree. We have to stop immigration and start seriously selecting who can come into our country, we must do this if we want to protect our culture/englishness/way of life. It shouldn't be bloody racist to say that.
100%
1000% ❤
Wow, smack on trevor. You and I are kindred spirits. When you feel inclined mouse my name and read my veterans " THE QUEENS SHILLING" It will eventually get to where it should. Regards
Excellent comment. 🎊 🎉
The room is full of elephants.
Multiculturalism is an oxymoron.
Multiculturalism is unnatural
Sadly they've trampled only the sensible people. The cretins are safe.
I think we’ve found another Carl Marx, only in reverse, he’s a mighty man indeed.
Multiculturalism is a Pachyderm!
Multiculturalism can and never will work, especially when the host country's indigenous citizens have lost all racial consiousness, or have been brow beaten for simply existing.
Quite right Steve, the destruction of national pride has been very successful. Where the flag is only shown on days of the most sanitised and cleansed moments. Even then you'll get the BBC putting on "expert commentary" who will say that the "balcony was very white". Worse yet...get away with it to the sound of applause.
How can being critical of any religion be racist?
It isn't. The lefties just call everyone they don't like racist.
It cannot be. Racist is about race not religion.
If every decison English people make is racist, then the English as a race are finished.
Study the Frankfurt school. All will make sense
@@AT-bq1kg In fact it already looks like my original comment is already gone lol.
The fact that everything is now labelled as ‘racist’ has now completely diminished its impact.
In my entire life I looked for it as a lefty, 35 years later multiple terror attacks and personally being robbed and beat up by Africans, multiple times I think racism is a lie to take away the self-determination of English people. I'm not a leftie anymore, I hate lying and I hate lying to help make our country worse.
indeed
Just seen an Afghan sell his daughter , cause hes skint. No problems with that in Afghanistan. I think Western culture is better and we hold property rights in the highest order
Was that the 9 year old being sold off to that old man
Search, "Bacha Bazi".
It also happens to boys.
Why did the old man buy the little girl?
@@FEiSTYFEVER To be his wife.
I wish Mr. Markham well, but having listened up to him saying (about 4.50) “I’m in favour of maintaining multicultural society”, I left the rest of the video alone.
One could say I ‘cancelled’ him, but the clip is still there; I simply stopped listening to someone whose basic argument diverted my line of thought from curiosity to disinterest.
When one scans the shelves in a well known bookshop, one is able to discern quickly whether or not the book is worthy of reading fully and adorning the shelves at home. I regret that his former intended ‘publisher’ chickened out for reasons I abhor. I’m over three times this young man’s age and still have a functioning brain and, like many near to my age, are tired of the diminishing of patriotism and national identity - and especially the deterioration of our wonderful literature and language - entirely brought about by seedy politicians desire to ‘please all’.
Multiculturalism - NO!! Come to Britain and share OUR culture - YES.
👍🇬🇧👍🇮🇱👍🇬🇧👍🇮🇱👍🇬🇧👍
You should continue on. He's not a complete nutcase. He's just a little confused on what's going on.
Yes!
Maybe you meant 'uninterest' rather than 'disinterest.'....the first means something like, 'I don't care'....but the second means to be impartial (as a mediator or a court judge should be)...very different.... (and one of the many current mistakes being made, even by journalists, authors, politicians - of course!). Blessings!
@@josears3651 👍
All the best from
Across the Norh Sea
I'll be with you.
🇧🇻😎😎🇧🇻
Appalling. Self publish on Amazon and thousands of us will buy it. Take back control.
Speak for yourself.
@@j.harrison6744 He speaks for me as well. So pipe down leftard
I looked for it on Amazon. Could only find one with a similar title written by a Muslim author. Interesting of itself.
It’s complete bollox to differentiate between -lam and -lamism. They are ONE AND THE SAME!
Why did ethno nations emerge hundreds/thousands of years ago? Because different fundamental beliefs simply could not coexist within a workable whole! Multicult has never worked and never will.
It can only be held together through authoritarian rule and that is just not worth it.
In the Roman Empire it worked until Emperors like Diocletian who were not of Roman tradition who had military outlooks.
Anyone who believes we are the same in every way are quite frankly living in a fantasy land of their own making. We wouldn't have such disparity around the World if we were.
indeed
What's happening in the West has got as much or more to do with race as it does with culture. England for the English, Iran for Iranians, Nigeria for Nigerians. That's what works best.
🎯
Culture is downstream from Race
Yes, yes yes.
They always talk about culture as if it is separate from race. Culture comes from a people and that people's innate ways of being.
English are not a race!
Dismantle the NGO intimidation system.
Hope not Hate for example should not exist.
hope not hate are probably the far left who want open borders
Why should anyone respect an ideology which does not respect them, why should they accept them into their society.
Liberalism is destroying the West.
All our problems are just symptoms of that
Fright’s you it frightens the life out of me for the future of my family
Trying to say we are all equal and the same. This is crazy and unachievable. Your right we should have freedom to challenge multiculturalism. We see it isn't working. It also seems that the whole burden is on the shoulders of the British. Because we have no integration . We are going down a dangerous road. I sense an under-laying anger. We are sick and tired of being tolerant to the intolerant incomers .
not just the British, Canada the USA and other Western countries. the question must be why, and who profits because multiculturalism is for profit.
@@clachan24Australia too. Look at the international agreements they make with the UN etc
Centrisim and grotesque amounts of multiculturalism are whats put us where we are. I must disagree strongly with this stage actor.
What is far right to this individual? And what if someone does think someone is an abomination but you have the right to be and say what you want and I don’t want to physically hurt you but I do want some separation by not inviting you in my home or being forced to learn about your religion or sexual views in school.
He is Liberal containment, no solutions
then you are unjustifiably called far right or intolerant or a bigot
Even this lad is not centrist because he believes in multiculturalism.
"Multicoloured, but not multicultural"....that is the only realistic hope for the UK
Have you heard what second, third, even fourth generation British born black people and Indians say about reparations and decolonisation? Ask them where their loyalties would lie should conflict break out between England and their supposed ethnic homeland.
We need to stop immigration. Why do we need immigration, really? I don't believe their answers to this question anymore.
@@kn3448 the ones I know are educated and speak English like I do and have no grievance. I admit they are a tiny fraction of all those with recent migration history...but some did assimilate successfully. If what you say is the truth, then you are talking about mass ethnic cleansing which is never going to happen. Why hope for something that will never happen?
What I propose is enabling those who are unable to assimilate should find that their lives are better outside the UK. Most non-whites will just get on with life, especially if schools and universities did a decent job.
Who are those who are least likely to assimilate? Those who practice Islam seem least likely to accept the supremacy of western social democracy.
Can I envisage passing some laws which would make that happen without ethnic cleansing that you propose? Yes, I can.
British culture is the outflow of British people. You can’t have one without the other. Political leanings are inherited. Personality is inherited. We are not blank slates. The new comers, even if they were all the offspring of Albert Einstein and mother Teresa. Are still not British. They will produce their own culture.
@@scottwhat3362 if you believe that, what is your solution? Is it workable?
His book is no loss. NCF would better spend it's time supporting people who support it rather than those who oppose it.
Ive heard many rabbis say that promoting multi-culturalism is vital to make sure that the 'Far Right' dont repeat history. They would rather be in a a society of many muslims who actively despise them. Does not make sense
That is what they want for us not necessarily for themselves
It is rather vague now, as to what is 'far right'! Some bitter people, just try to smear other's whom they disagree with, with that silly label!
In fact we are witnessing fascist and depraved behavior, from the so called left, so the labels are wrong!
This guy appears a little deluded!
They are anti White before everything else.
@@grannyannie2948 If we copied their country and had an 'expired male's button' pointing at them and their houses of worship throughout the world, perhaps they'd wise up.
Tough luck. Israel is surrounded by Muslims.
This island should only have the cultures of the indigenous(of this land since the earliest of times) people. We certainly do not require any weirdo cults or religions not of this land.
My definition of populism, its another word for "the will of the people" or "democratic rule".
At 4.50 Markham says "I'm in favour of maintaining multicultural society". How is that compatible with the concept of The New Culture Forum and the very existence of British society as people of my advanced age know it? Several years ago purely by chance I spoke face to face with Peter Whittle whom I have always had the greatest respect for but quite frankly I am appalled that he wasted even two minutes talking to this clown.
This guy is drenched in arrogance. Non friend.
... and you appear to be drenched in bigotry and stupidity.
The way he arrogantly pontificates, like he's some sort of sage.
Don’t you dare pontificate! 😂
Wet behind the ears entitled derp!
I think he makes a fair point regarding centrists.
They have enabled this current status, whilst leftists have jumped in the bandwagon in support.
But he wants to prop up the post 1945 Liberal paradigm
I agree with others…..cannot listen to this man. Too full of his own ‘importance’ for a start.
It goes with being "Chosen".
I found his flirtations with Peter somewhat nauseating.
Sorry, this guy lost me when he admitted to supporting multiculturalism. How any rational individual can believe that cultures, which are often widely dissimilar, can exist happily together is beyond me. And surely we have learnt this lesson only too well here in Britain. Our country is now filled with millions who not only do not share our culture and values, but, I am afraid, actually despise them and us. This has led to an increasing breakdown in social cohesion. Of course, we, meaning our politicians, are to blame. For years, they have celebrated the great myth of some sort of multi culti Utopia, failing to admit that the reality has been rather different, and in fact a disaster. Almost inevitable when they did not ensure that those who chose to come and live in our country were not made to understand that certain aspects of their own culture were neither welcome or acceptable here in Britain. Thus, we have often ignored or tolerated the intolerable. Misogyny, homophobia, forced marriages, and even such truly disgusting practices as FGM. Oh, and religious bigotry and extremism have grown along with the numbers arriving. The simple truth is that social cohesion is mostly founded on a shared culture, history, and values, they being the glue which helps hold us all together. When you have competing cultures, especially those semingly intent on recreating their own societies here in our country, then that is a hell in the making.
I get your point, multiple different cultures cannot exist together to any constructive degree. The best to hope for is for them to co-exist peacefully side by side, but not together - completely separately without overlapping. That's modern Canada for you, at least Ontario, Quebec and British Columbia (the most populous provinces). You still have one cohesive society on the level of laws, education etc, but not in the cultural sense, the real everyday life is organized around ethnic/religious closed communities that keep to themselves, their beliefs, vibe, and socially accepted behaviours, and accept no outsiders. As an immigrant myself, I came here with an extremely open mind and a naive belief i would be joining an incredible multicultural society and make a ton of friends with origins from the whole world. I ended up entirely alone (with my immediate family), as we were not accepted by other communities, and we didn't want to stick to just our own, that's almost as exclusive as any other.
But I imagine it's different in the UK, and not even this kind of separate co-existence in peace is feasible.
@dvanaestcestica1135 Very different here in the UK. First , Britain is a tiny country, absolutely dwarfed by the size of Canada. The massive growth in population is therefore more apparent, people living separate and often conflicting lifestyles almost side by side cannot help but lead to resentment and conflict. But also, Britain is an ancient country, one with a long and proud history. A nation which, despite its size, has had an enormous impact worldwide. Yes, with mistakes made, as with all great Empires, but i would say, more good than bad has come out of this Island. Beginning with the Industrial Revolution, it was Britain which practically invented the modern age. Further, it was England from where parliamentary democracy, the rule of law, Habeas Corpus, Trial by jury, and the very notion of human rights were coined. All these, of course, now spread to many different countries. To have our history, culture, and traditions undermined by incomers, people who choose to come here for a better life, yet often seem intent on imposing their own culture and norms onto us, is unacceptable. This is now even impacting on our cherished and long fought for laws, even those which demands everyone be treated equally, now under threat. The reintroduction of blasphemy laws, specifically intended to appease one particular religious group, being almost inevitable. Yes, cultures which have nothing in common are not good bedfellows. We see the inevitable result, a breakdown in social cohesion, with violence increasingly possible. A global world, leading to a global meltdown.
@@christinerussell113 Yes, I'm aware, I have a degree in European languages/culture, and besides, I'm European too, from Eastern Europe. While Western Europe was accepting in a largely uncontrolled way immigrants from oversees from vastly different cultures since the 90s, their door was firmly closed for the fellow Europeans from the East - that's how I, and my husband with a MS degree, ended up in Canada, instead in the UK, Sweden, Germany or Spain, for example. If they needed more labour force, they surely did have options with way better chances of integration than, in their majority, low skilled, and in many cases, practically illiterate refugees from warzones in the Middle East and Africa, who had never learned any foreign language in their lives, and with zero willingness to accept and adapt to the host country's culture. My heart breaks for Western Europe, but also for myself and my family, who could've made good citizens of any of the WE countries, law-abiding and well integrated, with the knowledge and respect of their second culture. Well...
@dvanaestcestica1135 I hate to break it to you, but Eastern European countries will soon be experiencing the 'benefits' of multiculturalism. That is if the EU get their way. Said EU being enthusiastic about the globalist agenda, which is for the abolition of the nation state, and open borders. So far, a number of East European nations have rejected immigration from outside of Europe, but having pressure applied, including threats of huge fines, along with the withdrawal of EU subsidies, they are, or probably will, soon cave in. The only way to save Europe is to work together to deny any further immigration from outside, and protect all of our borders. However, that is almost impossible, while an organisation like the European Union remains firmly in charge. We in Britain may technically be out of the EU, but due to that free movement so beloved by the Brussels bureaucrats, all those who enter Europe are free to travel around and across borders at will. With many then crossing from France to Britain. The French of course being glad to get rid of some of their unwanted guests, indeed the French Navy are actually seen escorting the boats filled with immigrants into English waters.
@@christinerussell113 While I agree on your points, and your general opinion on the subject, I don't appreciate your tone. Normally, I would have stopped reading your comment after you opened it with a standard sarcastic "I hate to break it to you...", but I read it through, and I understand and support your stance. For a better communication in general, especially with people who express themselves civilly and even agree with you, I'd suggest you dropped the confrontational internet comment attitude (and the condescending attitude in your previous comment, where you took for granted that I was semi-literate and in need of a history lesson on YT) - more communication and exchange of knowledge and ideas, better chances we might salvage something in this world, I'd reckon, but you're free to decide for yourself! :) Cheers!
No, sorry, can't take this guy anymore. 16 minutes in and I'm stopping. Sorry Peter, first time I've been unable to watch a Sunday chat.
Summarise why please. I suspect it has nothing to with his haircut but what do I know?
@@orsoncart802 that was my follow-up comment to one in which I outlined my reasons. I persevered for a couple of minutes more before enough was enough.
@@stevenkeith5784 OK. Thanks.
Me too.
Same
All social classes are not of equal value either.
Nobody knows that better than the British.
Democracy got us into this mess.
Liberalism got us into this mess, not democracy.
What you mean the democracy that was adhered to after brexit ?
@@JP-vz1xs Liberal Democracy is just rule by international finance capitalism and the Merchant class.
All Liberal Democracies are heading in the same direction on all the big issues particularly with mass replacement migration.
@@kn3448 Democracy is just rule by international finance capitalism and the Merchant class.
All Western Democracies are heading in the same direction on all the big issues particularly with mass immigration.
Globalisation destroyed the nation state democracy decades ago.
@@kn3448 Democracy was a coup by Liberal forces.
it's insane how a perfectly sensible discourse like this is now labelled as "far-right". it's not even a right-wing point of view. it's progressive, if anything.
Yes. So nice to see others expressing this. Thanks
It's the Tower of Babel.
Gosh - his grandfather was a black taxi driver; one would never think he had a black grandfather.
Sorry. But seriously, if someone as indulgent, some might say over-indulgent, of the Islamic communities etc., as this chap clearly is, finds that even he is under censure for expressing these relatively mild views, it just shows how rabidly and unreasoningly intolerant are those who constitute many of the ethnic and religious minorities in our society. If publishers are so fearful of the backlash, it is a measure of what they understand the nature of these groups to be: fanatical, vengeful and violent towards any who do not fully accept their view of the world. We must resist this censorship and curtailment of freedom; our future as a meaningfully free country depends on these forces being defeated as surely as it did in 1940 against another tyrannical and ideologically intransigent enemy.
Curiously, as bright and articulate and enthusiastic and reasonable and insightful and broadly correct as he seems to be, I didn't hear anything new. However, it's good to see the finer principles being defended by youth.
He proudly comes from a tribe that gave us multiculturalism. The Frankfurt School.
@@thelostboy9884 I think you may have lost the plot. But honestly, are you not the one being "tribal" and "othering" here?
Good god. Why is it always about _them_ ?
Liberal containment
His little book wasn’t published, so suddenly there’s a problem. Didn’t give a sh1t about mudslide grape gangs, just his little book and his little hand gestures.
@@thehammer9599 Them being unable to make money is more of a crime than white girls getting "groomed" on an industrial scale.
Shame not all comments are accepted
Sometimes you can see them by clicking 'newest first'.
Glad to see that there are still some students who can think for themselves!
Why do we give away Rights, that took us Centuries to achieve - why do we give them to people who've only lived here a few years? The Right to Vote, Right to run for Public Office, Right to demonstrate on our streets for ex. You know when you give something so valuable away so easily its not likely to be appreciated. Worse still they use those Rights against you.
This young man fills me with hope and enthusiasm.
Maybe it would be a good idea to self publish, I know its not as prestigious as being published by a big company, but it could be one way of getting the book out there.
the Persians had a multicultural society dominated by the ruling culture, but in the end were they not defeated by the Maccidonian culture and Alaxander the Great. Rome had a multicultural setup too, but Roman culture had to dominate for it to survive and ended with the barbarian culture sacking Rome. One could also say the Ottaman culture ad to dominate Turkey and the rest of the Calaphate and when it was desolved, the Calaphate died too.
If you want multicultures to work you must have a dominant culture to dominate and rule over the rest and prevent harmful diversity. That is what Parliment lacks. The ability to rule with its culture rather than be ruled by the loudest mob with a opposing culture.
Quite impressive for a 24yo. Agree with Mr Markham that liberals need to get real and call out leftist-marxist-progressive nonsense and admit that not all cultures are of equal value. We must have a dominant culture, and that dominant culture must be British and respected by minorities.
Would not add 'progressive' to leftist Marxist! Degeneracy and destructive are more suitable terms!
I hope Harry manages to publish his book as I would very much like to read it.
Diversity is different than inclusion. In that , diversity is just a bunch of different cultures living together but not being inclusive to one another. Ie, Little Italy, China Town, Greek Town , etc .. I work with a fellow who's Indian, great we're diverse. But we don't socialize at work he prefers to have lunch with other Indians and we don't meet up after work. So my opinion is that "diversity" is one of those buzz words that's ment to make everyone feel good but is a bunch of crap.
What about the they/them community?
He looks like he’s been strapped into his chair with an airline seatbelt. And speaks with an animation that suggests it’s needed.
And I agree with everything he says
We need a fearless "Margaret Thatcher" thinker to call out the dangers of importing Islamists: So well clarified by Harry who is also fearless. The Silent Majority think like you, and we stand with you.
The problem is the financial and banking system that loves millions and millions of cheap workers and future consumers.
18:21 Agree. Our grandparents fought for freedoms we're giving away. Tolerating fascism in another guise. 😢
Liberalism destroyed the West not Fascism.
Culture is downstream from Race.
Yes, and we see the backwards cultures of Africa and the Middle East 😂
As an Indian , I would say if incoming people are not ready to accept and respect the culture of host countries just kick them out.
I do disagree and feel bad about how developed countries have reached to this level of prosperity(colonization, slavery and loot), but still I admire the advancements scientific and others, they have brought in Human civilization.
Wonderful. Harry is very engaging. Maybe some clarification of terms is needed. Harry says he supports multiculturalism, yet says we need to get past the idea that all cultures are of equal value. That is the core of multiculturalism. It is emphatically NOT a national culture made up of different influences. It is different cultures sharing space, but remaining separate. It says newcomers don't need to "fit in" with the national culture because all cultures are of equal value.
Different cultures in there own environment , is what makes life interesting and the world go round Period!!!
Key statement = "in their own environment". Nationalists support that all cultures in their environments have the right to conduct their own affairs - without imposing on other countries/cultures.
So well said. Your guest grasped it very well
We've had censorship in this country for donkey's years. On the campuses, on the beaches. It stinks but it's there. Say the wrong thing about the right people and that's you for the chop. Done for, the mortgage doesn't get paid, the divorce papers arrive and we end up in dimly lit rented digs trying to keep body and soul together, if we're fortunate that is. So we all live lives of synthetic agreement, conforming to whatever species of absurdity the regime requires of us in the given moment. At some point, we get past actually caring about it.
@@shabbos-goy9407 Well the privileged groups may change but the regime remains. Back in the 50s, there was censorship of another sort. We've come full circle in a strange sort of way.
It's hard enough getting a photo published now. So many hurdles to jump, I just tell them to feck off.
28:39 - "Criticizing ideas is not the same as being a racist".
I fully agree with this statement. I would be interested to know how strongly he holds this principle. For example if one were to criticize Zionism then would he call such people anti-Semites (racists)? If one claimed the number who died as a result of Typhoid in certain camps were higher than the number of people gassed and so shouldn't be counted in the extermination totals, would he call that person some other names?
I bet he would.
Bingo.
Is this man saying that his kind of white culture needs protecting but that the other white culture , anglo saxon/celtic culture still needs working on , and that all the other cultures are still welcome here as long as they lay off of his kind of white culture ?
Question: One has to wonder, when all the very contiverial books of their time, were actually being sought after by publishers, sadly it would seem that the publishers of to-day have actually cow-towed to the more ever vociferous, all be it smaller groups with their own agendas.
I enjoyed listening to Harry. Came to the problems of multiculturalism and Islam from angles that are not that common
I think he is very interesting. Don't give up on him!
Would there were more students like him, but I think he's still - like many soi-disant centrists - struggling with the problem that 'liberalism' per se cannot draw bright shining lines whilst simultaneously promoting the idea that it is intrinsically good to 'disrupt orthodoxies.'
Love Peter Whittle over here. And yes, because I’m seeing you his show I’ll be buying your book.
Great to hear from a younger intellectual.
What was the name of the publisher, didnt catch it ?
like the student said to Owen Jones, diversity in itself is neither good nor bad, its just a thing. . Being nonjudgemental is the number one virtue. We make judgements all the time. People who scold for being judgemental are the most controlling and judgmental of them all. THis guy is out on a limb. We have gone too far down the road we are on to being stating that cultures arent equal. He is right but that counts for nothing. Its all about power. The power to cancel., force publishing houses to your whim.
Of course, didn't you that tribal drums are way ahead of European Renaissance.
Excellent interview.
"The pressure is such that they will inevitably cave"
And this attitude is why you fail. You need more of Martin Luther's approach -- "Here I stand, I can do no other, God help me, amen!"
Self-publishing a possibility???
it's a pity he didn't name the publisher so that we can see them as they are, even cancel them, if we wish.
Preferred the round the sofa style of the older NCf videos. This is quite clinical
The cowardice of publishers. Ugh.
I have nothing to say on the subject. TH-cam insists.
"The act of speaking the truth has BEEN CRIMINALIZED...RIGHT BEFORE OUR EYES!"...
JUST BACK ON YT AFTER MY 48 HOURS BAN!?.I'M OLD,Poor health & passed careing🎉😂😂have a grand day & be on guard 🎉😂❤
We should UNITE THE RIGHT!
I t has always been common sense to me that mixing up cultures is a recipe for an inedible stew of humanity, were the most primitive and violent will take over.
Thanks , People should not be censored for having different opinions in England. In Scotland it appears to be too late. ( U S influence ?)
One of the problems with Multiculturalism, is that a lot of people confuse it with Multi cuisine, but it doesn't value the host Culture, One Country, One Culture, and One Flag...!!
There’s a reason why zoos keep different animals separated.
We need to assert our own values and our own culture while being open to new ideas and new people that are compatible with it. No beliefs and practices that are incompatible with it - let alone those that are illegal- should be accepted and privileged simply because they're part of a religion. I sometimes wonder what we'd do if a group arrived whose religion practised human sacrifice. When are we finally going to say NO you can't do that here ?
My opinion of multiculturalism is Huitzilopochtli
Theres no such thing as cancelling. Graham Norton explained this to Graham Linehan when the later lost everything, including his marriage
Get this guy together with Douglas Murray
It's too late
Spain lived under Islamic rule for centuries and still turned it around
Spain lived under Islamic rule for centuries and still turned it around
Freedom is in peril defend it with all our might.. 🏴🌹🇬🇧🏴🌹🇬🇧
There can only be one Islam: The Quran is the Final Word of Allah given to Muhammad over 22 years by Gabriel.
Not one word or Phrase can be altered as this is a "Perfect Book" that can only have been given to the Most Perfect Man in the history of Humanity.
Those that may choose to change any of the texts will befall the ultimate punishment (Left Blank) The same punishment that befell William Tyndale ( 1st English Translation of the Bible after Martin Luther 1517 Luther - 1522)
Those claiming that ‘anything goes’ are clearly on board with themselves and others being murdered, physically attacked, racially discriminated against, raped, tortured etc; also they are clearly on board with the existence of folk who act against persons perpetrating such behaviour. If they get *selective* about it, then they are affirming some hierarchy of values (whether supporting attachment to, or indulgence in, greed/lust, hate/enmity (including self-directed), self-deception/-dulling, narcissistic pride, aggressive rivalry, prejudice, or intending to lead away from such attachment/indulgence, or a mix); if additionally they do not admit this, they are deluded/blind.
Fear of ‘Popper’s paradox’ may be fear for self-image, of loss of face (narcissistic pride), and of taking responsibility for ones volition and choices, combined with genuine perplexity. Taking responsibility for ones own volition ‘takes back’ ones power/energy (that would else remain fragmented in a face-saving mist of seeking ‘self-justification’); and one can see the responsibility of others for theirs.
You don’t have to care about anyone or anything but your own bloodline
Says who?
This guy has an intellwctual naivety that is staggering - no society can survive a multitude of ideas based within a structure of equality - jùst think about it for a moment - without restrictive boundaries, dominance seeking ideas will prevail and destroy the very concept of multi idealism
18:40....reminds me of the way many thought in 1930's Germany...
I do wonder if certain ideologies are narcissistic. Isn’t anyone brought up as Muslim taught that non-Muslims are “less than”? And even those that become Muslim later in life are thought of as less than those born into it. I read that somewhere and that was what woke me up to the dangers of becoming a majority Muslim country. It was also what makes me think it’s cult like. Please tell me if I’m wrong.
Hate, is not limited to political adherence; and hatred is endemic in the Islamic mind set. 'I hate therefore i am'.
I don't think the issue is one of British identity, let's stop blaming ourselves. Immigrants coming in much more limited numbers would automatically swim in and absorb British culture. A country without a dominant stable culture will not succeed. The problem is numbers of immigrants and the enabling of those who want to dominate and impose their own foreign culture and are in fact anti British and unashamedly. The bravery and backbone to call out such people is what is lacking to identify these particular groups and actively restrict them in the first place is what is needed.
Talking about NATIONAL IDENTITY at 5.30 in.
I shall tell you, what informs NATIONAL IDENTITY = Those of us who are White and who have hundreds (and in many cases, thousands), of years of Ancestry here.
We are the TRULY BRITISH people.
My understanding is that Britain is an Island with 3 Nations ,England, Scotland, Wales each Nation with its own distinct culture. Together with Northern Ireland which comprises of 6 counties in the North East of the island of Ireland they constitute the State of the United Kingdom.
@@michaelogrady1002 ... But what I said, needs to be said. ... And no disrespect to any fine and beautiful immigrants, who are law abiding and hard working here, but obtaining a British passport and being granted British citizenship, does not make one truly British. And being granted a passport and citizenship, is something that I feel aught to be granted on a 10 year non permanent, but renewable basis (to those who have proven themselves good immigrants). ... Whoever the hell decided that a non indigenous person can become someone British overnight, by granting them a passport and citizenship, was truly a traitor to our people.
If I was born in China, would that make me Chinese? Of course it wouldn't. And any of China's rich cultural heritage, would have absolutely nothing to do with me.
I am talking common sense things here, although I am well aware that many Leftists and Marxists will want to accuse me of racism.
@@scorpiorob7986How would you define British ,is it white English,Scottish, Welsh or Northern Irish. Would you exclude from the term British for example prople of Asian,African ,those of West Caribbean ethnicity or the 550,000 in Northern Ireland who hold Irish passports and identity as Irish.Would you describe members of Parliament,athletes, those working in the media who are of colour as British.
@@michaelogrady1002 ... No one who is not of white Celtic or Saxon or Viking descent, and who has no true Ancestry here, can be accurately described as being British.
Simple as that.
Honory British perhaps, yes.
Again, if I was born in China, would that make me Chinese?
If I was born in Nigeria, would that make me Yoruba or Ebo?
If I was born in Ghana would that make me Ashanti?
If I was born in America, would that make me Apache or Commanche or Navaho or anyone indigenous?
If I was born in Australia, would that make me Aboriginal?
Yes, I am a Nationalist (of sorts), without a political home.
However, I believe a new type of Nationalism based upon the kind of administration that Tibet had prior to the Chinese invasion, and that current day Bhutan has, is the type of Nationalism the whole world needs.
There is nothing wrong or racist about any people wanting to preserve their own culture and heritage, in their own Ancestral homeland.
Fantastic channel
Thanks 🙏 from Expat
This wasn't the most interesting interview and I'm not clear his book would have had anything to say which many of us already think. There are no new ideas and he offers no new evidence. And to be honest, I'd check the authenticity of the cancellation. I can't put my finger on it, but something doesn't feel right.
I respect Israel's right to defend themselves against terrorism. But in this context, Israel isn't a shining example of free speech. They are more democratic than many Middle Eastern countries, yes, but by European standards, not only do their senior ministers routinely stir up violence and hate speech, but at the same time, they arresting poets in Palestine and routinely murder journalists. I'm not saying Egypt or Iran are any better. I just think we should tread carefully when we make friends. The politics of the Middle East isn't a question of working out who the "good guys" are. None of those countries can hold a candle to our standards. None of them even aspire to.
I also think that, inasmuch as the left has allowed Islamists to infect the Pro-Palestine protests (which has definitely happened,)
some on the right have likewise smeared perfectly legitimate pro-Palestinian free speech as "anti-Semitism" or "support for terrorism".
There is a need to distinguish free speech from hate speech on both sides.
The discussion which is wanting is an even-handed audit of the brutal over-generalizations conducted both sides.
Very well said....and for being circumspect about the interviewee.
@@reliableandrew It wasn't long ago, (a year?) when a professor was fired for "antisemitism" from Bristol University, in exactly the same manner Kathleen Stock was chased out of Brighton University for "transphobia". It isn't an issue of being "centrist, the way he emphasizes. It's an issue of not allying ourselves with those who may not share the values you're campaigning for.
This isn't a romance. It's a Faustian bargain.