The HT playlist: th-cam.com/play/PLGFQ-qdt_egRGmfch7x9cg2R2H1f-JS4S.html The playlist which covers the Khawarij and the fitna of khuruj during the khilafa and beyond: th-cam.com/play/PLGFQ-qdt_egQ3qYIxoxCGq9wdf9NHWZWU.html Wasim Ismail's Book: False Caliphate: A Critical Analysis of Hizb Ut-Tahrir's Political and Creedal Views": www.amazon.com/False-Caliphate-Critical-Ut-Tahrirs-Political/dp/1989450164
*I messaged and commented on rhyadMuslim's videos about why he never explains aqeedah and tawheed in details! He never replies! He always dodges aqeedah questions that would refute deviant shia sufi sects! He never refutes them and avoids refutations! Naoozubillah!*
*Sa’id ibn Jubayr reported: I asked Ibn Abbas, may Allah be pleased with him:Shall I enjoin good & forbid evil upon the ruler?” Ibn Abbas said:If you fear he will kill you, then no.” Then, I asked him again & he said the same to me. Then, I asked him again & he said the same to me & also said, “If you must do so, then do it between you & him privately✅️Source:AlAmr bilMaruf li Ibn AbiDunya 80✅️Ibn Rajab said:If one fears the rulers will put him to the sword or whip or prison or shackle or banishment or seizure of property or other types of harm like that, then the obligation to enjoin & forbid them is dropped. The Imams were explicit about that, among them Malik, Ahmad, Ishaq & others✅️Source:JamiAlUlum walHikam 2/249*
I’ve been on TikTok for a little while now and I truly believe this is the most dangerous app out there. The amount of ignorance being spread far and wide is terrifying
True and it is. On the other hand one of the best social media platforms i have seen is Twitter, specifically the "Muslim twitter" . You have students of knowledge there spreading knowledge, refuting ignorance with the aqwal of the salaf and generally that is the only app i have felt so ignorant and such a laymen due to so many brothers being so knowledgable. In Tiktok you feel like you are surrounded by people spreading ignorance. Imagine having a naseeha and music playing in the backround or a islamic reminder with beats, that is tiktok. But to be fair, no one is loosing anything if they stay away from these platforms all together. If one decides to use one, one is better than the other for Muslims.
*I messaged and commented on rhyadMuslim's videos about why he never explains aqeedah and tawheed in details! He never replies! He always dodges aqeedah questions that would refute deviant shia sufi sects! He never refutes them and avoids refutations! Naoozubillah!*
@@SaMy.... there's nothing wrong if I call out to my Rabb ... I'm not asking you to do so .... mind your own damn business. You sad individual going around not picking at unnecessary things. Jog on
When you played the first clip I honestly did not notice what was wrong with his because to a layman it makes sense ‘the rule is only for Allah’ but SubhanAllah after you explained it I realised how little knowledge I have about my own religion 😢
I learnt it in kashf Al shubuhat by Muhammad ibn Abd Al Wahhab taughy by AMAUA channels Muhammad Tim Humble. Literally all my life i understood it wrong. It made perfect sense and exposed my ignorance to myself. I once noticed noticed i misspelled the Al tahiyyah in salah, specifically the beginning. This was after learning arabic and gaining some knowledge about the language. Felt so dumb, but it showed me how i must be careful even about the smallest things.
His videos are good and what Saajid portrayed in this video is completely slanderous and assumptive and serves no benefit but to misguide and create fitnah in the Ummah, Be careful of watching and listening to someone whos whole channel is buily on refuting and making other muslims look bad, its a sickness of the heart, and a true person of knowledge does not do these things, and if they were to refute, then they must be qualified and respectfully Saajid is not anywhere near being qualified for that. I recommend you and everyone to stay away from these kind of attacking slanderous videos that are just for views and publicity. Just because someone has a big beard and graduated from madinah does not make them correct or knowledgeable, infact, it is usually those who portray this image that end up being the most harmful to the ummah. Kindness is never added to anything except that it beautifies it, May Allah guide us all and separate truth from falsehood
I hope our brother won’t take this personally when watching this video, it is done to correct him and keep Muslims away from deviation. May Allah bless you for this video.
I don't see anything wrong with anything the bro said. It is the most overlooked part of the kalimah. If the Khawarij misapplied takfir doesn't negate the correctness of the fact that Allah is the only Sovereign or Authority. 2nd there is something as general takfir and specific takfir. It is generally Kufr to rule by other than Shariah. But to make specific takfir is something else. 3rd Khilfah is the same things as the Imamah. The hadith is in respect to Khulafah rashidun. Khilafah is generally any imam that has authority of the Muslims and rules by the Shariah. 4th To establish Shariah is one the greatest duties of the Muslims. Yet somehow Sajid made it an act of deviency. Ajeeb
BarakAllahfeek Akhi Saajid these lessons are so important for those who don't really know about these misguided sects may Allah Azawajal protect you and us from misguidance
Brother Saajid, I understand and appreciate the points you’re trying to make but i think it’s a stretch when applying to this brother. You may have misunderstood him and are making assumptions. After watching some of his videos I feel like his heart is in the right place. In this case you should have messaged him before putting him on blast.
This is true. I stopped watching him for a long time bcz he with all due respect had became the controversy king of the Dawah scene. Came back after a long time & saw this😂
@@anonymousnoticer congratulations on giving him good deeds, I’m sure Allah will appreciate your backbiting, Gheeba is one of the punishments of the graves
My brother, we can say 1 is almost equal to 2 when compared with 10,000. But in reality, we will never count to 10,000 properly if we don't know the difference between 1 and 2. What that tiktok dude is doing is very subtle...
@@raider7790 this is unfounded paranoia, he didn't say a single damning thing "ان بعض الظن إثم" what sajid did is textbook example of jumping into conclusions and slandering another person without proof.
I have always said that despite well-intentioned young brothers, i see a major fitnah brewing from social media da'aees. Whilst on the one hand it's commendable that these young brothers are keen to spread Islam, it is unfortunate that they do so whilst lacking fundamental knowledge and aqeedah. I have come across so many social media channels that are spreading categorically false concepts to their ever-increasing fan-base; and i fear this is just the very beginning. May Allah guide us all.
Many of these Tiktok Daees have a slightly above average Islamic knowledge among the ignorant Muslim youths. Their way of preaching and the platform attracts youth. I have benefitted a lot but after a certain point and most probably due to the audience's pressure, they speak on topics on which they have little to no knowledge off. They did not learn under a scholar so they themselves try to use logic or take knowledge of deviant groups that sound appealing and parrot it to the audience.
@@sadiqrahman2961 yes, I believe you are correct. I think it's very likely that is the way they go astray. May Allah keep them steadfast upon the faith and help these young brothers to gain more knowledge. Ameen
His videos are good and what Saajid portrayed in this video is completely slanderous and assumptive and serves no benefit but to misguide and create fitnah in the Ummah, Be careful of watching and listening to someone whos whole channel is buily on refuting and making other muslims look bad, its a sickness of the heart, and a true person of knowledge does not do these things, and if they were to refute, then they must be qualified and respectfully Saajid is not anywhere near being qualified for that. I recommend you and everyone to stay away from these kind of attacking slanderous videos that are just for views and publicity. Just because someone has a big beard and graduated from madinah does not make them correct or knowledgeable, infact, it is usually those who portray this image that end up being the most harmful to the ummah. Kindness is never added to anything except that it beautifies it, May Allah guide us all and separate truth from falsehood
@@sageezbaid If someone spreads misinformation in public, the scholars said to correct them publicly. You don't understand the danger of what this guy is preaching.
SubhanAllah I myself would not be able to catch that. Jazakullahair for clearing this all up! This is why it is important to know who you are taking your knowledge from!
Asalam alaikum waramahtullah wa barakatu brother Saajid While I understand snd can appreciate why you made this video Just so this doesn't turn into a youtube back and fourth, would you be willing to Sit down with brother Rhyad and speak about this over zoom or similar apps and discuss this and clear up any confusion? I'm willing to mediate this discussion as a neutral party since I've had dealings with you both Let me know insh'allah
I have reached out to some of the da'wah people on tiktok and I was told that this was a private conversation between the parties involved and other da'wah tiktokers and brother Saajid chose to take it publicly. Although I understand brother Saajid from his pov he needs to ''warn" people about certain rhetoric but I feel this is going to make another Ali Dawah situation.
This is such an incredibly important message to all, nothing is more important than the foundation of one’s beliefs, only then, when that belief is there can the people receive laws and legislation with an open heart, without feeling oppressed. May God bless richly the work of your hands. Not only in teaching but in filling the role given to you to help clean up online Dawah in these end times so the new believers receive guidance to build that very foundation you speak of
Brother Sajid, i have seen some of this guy’s videos, i don’t want to jump to the conclusion on this brother, Allah knows the best, may Allah guide us all on the right path
Assalam Au Alykum bro. Be careful to group everyone on a certain social media platform as khwarij, this creates more damage than good. It's like suggesting TH-cam is led by non-believers so we should shut down the media. This is a fatwa and largely impractical. You should try to seek out knowledge and that is focused on building a healthy Aqeedah as that is the knowledge foundation for our beliefs but that does not ally itself to any state today because as you've seen with Sudhi Arubia and other states, the nation-state concept is very limiting belief-wise, psychologically, socially, and even ethically.
How many times have Muslims become prisoners in their own state for advocating for Islamic independence, try reading one book: Caliphate: The History of an Idea. It is by a non-Muslim historian but the author tries to study the development of the Caliphate-term and how it has led to its use today where the term has been hijacked to identify Muslims who threaten Western superpowers. Chapter 11 specifically if you ever get a chance
Subhannallahe; May Allah grants us knowledge; honestly if not for your clarification I would not have noticed any issues with this video; Jazakhallahou khayr brother for clarifying
_"Let there be a group among you who call ˹others˺ to goodness, encourage what is good, and forbid what is evil-it is they who will be successful."_ _Quran (3: 104)_ May Allah ﷻ bless you with happiness and health, Ustadh Sajid. Ameen!
Quran 24 : 55. Allah has promised those among you who believe and do righteous good deeds, that He will certainly grant them succession to (the present rulers) in the land, as He granted it to those before them, and that He will grant them the authority to practise their religion which He has chosen for them (i.e. Islam). And He will surely give them in exchange a safe security after their fear (provided) they (believers) worship Me and do not associate anything (in worship) with Me. But whoever disbelieves after this, they are the Fasiqun (rebellious, disobedient to Allah).
Quran 3 : 103. And hold fast, all of you together, to the Rope of Allah (i.e. this Qur'an), and be not divided among yourselves , and remember Allah's Favour on you, for you were enemies one to another but He joined your hearts together, so that, by His Grace, you became brethren (in Islamic Faith), and you were on the brink of a pit of Nar, and He saved you from it. Thus Allah makes His Ayat (proofs, evidence, verses, lessons, signs, revelations, etc.,) clear to you, that you may be guided.
Subhanallah I was just questioning when I came across this brother’s video earlier today. May Allah guide us and keep us steadfast to his straight path.
There is nothing wrong with what the brother said. You are clearly exaggerating the message he is trying to convey. These views are very common amongst other very respected scholars. I respect you brother Saajid, but this video shows the influence of your educational background and the Saudi system where you just leave the so called "leader" do whatever without pointing to his mistakes because it is khurooj. Since you like to educate Muslims about the current issues they are facing, how about you make a video about Mohammed Ibn Salman in Saudi Arabia and the damage he is causing to Muslims and scholars there? Don't worry, it is ok. You are American and it won't be considered as Khurooj !
its khurooj today, but apparently wasn't khurooj when Al-Saud did the same to the Ottoman turks during WW1 and helped the Entente kill Muslims RE Lawrence of Arabia
Correct.Agree w u vehemently.Yes Sajjid u got yr Islamic credibility from Medina..yes do try after all u are American no one can put you down. What Ryand Islam Tik Tok is generally correct why not Islamic state as well as educating Muslims to be taqwa same time..like what the Prophet did...all of us are educating and shld have Caliphate to enforce things..Right??!! How u accuse easily everyone as Kwarij..check yr facts.
Brother with proper respect, If you are against establishing Khilafa (not Islamic govt.), I disagree with you. It should be a dream for Muslims to have an established Islamic ruling system. Look at the chaos around the world, they throw bomb, call you terrorist, insult our prophet(PBUH), disrespect our practicing sisters and so on You can never stop these issues until you have the power to talk back and for that power you must need a Islamic ruling system or Khilafa.
@@rusi6219 I do not know why the scholars who have degree from Saudi like Medina University or others, they always try to hide the battle stuff (Jihad) from ummah. It seems like they feel embarrassed to fight and talk against kufr. Unfortunately these type of scholars are widely seen in my country (Bangladesh).
Just because someone believes establishment of khalifa is not obligatory, it doesn’t mean they completely oppose it. The salafi position is that it is preferable but not obligatory.
@@pushtotalk7007 How did the prophet upon whom be peace and his companions politically establish deen when there was no caliphate? Why did the prophet upon whom be peace reject political power when offered by one of pagan Quraish and continue giving dawah and cultivating?
This is quite a serious accusation with a very weak proof. U could have just informed the audience how the khawarij mindset is instead of making him an example. What if u r wrong ? Can u open his heart and know his true intentions?
there hasn't been one after the 30 years of the Prophetic Khilafah that was fully implemented. Even the last Ottoman Khalifah had numerous flaws such as the Sultans with the title of Caliphs killing their brothers, allowing music and sufi ways of worship, etc, however, Allah ordered us to be dutiful to the authority. Nevertheless, we are obliged to respect the authority a blanket statement of "there is no Islamic country" is dangerous and leads to Kharijism. I was born in UAE and refuse to speak ill of the Muslim authority even though there is discrimination against South Asian Muslims, it is a test from Allah and patience is rewardful. As Muslims our primary focus should be perfecting our Tawheed and strive for Jannah
Do you even know what is an Islamic country. It means majority is Muslims and Muslims are protected by Muslim government Stop making ignorant statements no Muslim country exist
I used to have this same misconception, but it's not true that a country has to implement 100% of the Islamic laws in order to be an Islamic country. I'm not excusing them of course, and they are answerable to Allah, but that doesn't mean it's not an Islamic country.
بارك الله فيك شيخ ساجد. Its great that you share your thoughts, you’ve been down the road while most of us haven’t, allowing us a quicker way to understand theses things instead of falling down a pit and needing to climb out afterwards because of our ignorance. الله يجزيك الخير
JazakumAllaahu khayran brother and team for your video and share the knowledge and bring awareness to those seeking the truth based on al-Qur'aan and the authentic ahadeeth. Keep up the great work and your reward is from Allaah alone.
Beautiful explanation by brother Saajid. May Allah reward him immensely. However only few people whom Allah has guided will understand and accept. Unfortunately majority of todays Muslims follow emotions and whims and desires instead of correct knowledge….
@@soulcandy5758 that there's no Islamic country in today's world? That's a very abrupt statement - are you suggesting that Qatar, Kuwait, Saudi, Pakistan etc are all disbelievers.. I'm don't think you know the true weight of some of the things the TikTok guy has said
@@khaliduae-qv5ni so you think there is a real Muslim country which is completely based on Islam today? I think it's you who needs to be more mentally strong and embrace the truth. We can close our eyes and think everything is fine but it won't change anything. This video tries to even take away the desire to establish an Islamic system from the heart of the audience portraying that all is well. Also he is right about modern borders being drawn by western powers. I always support brother Sajid and will too but i think he was completely wrong on this one
I just went to TikTok and found that I was following him. i would never have cached on that if it weren't for this video. Thank you so much brother sajiid, may Allah bless you
You clearly didn't understand the points he made and I advise you to watch the video again and also educate yourself on the Khwarij and their ideology so you have a better understanding.
Dear Shaykh Lots of love for you It is clear to see that the brother suffers from groupthink. With utmost love and respect, it appears that your thoughts are not free of this either. I hope one day you are able to see that. If not, and in any case, may Allah (swt) reward your good intentions.
@@akramnimer6755 We are speaking of two extremes ahki. One camp makes governance a priority with little regard for aqeedah. The other prioritizes aqeedah with little regard for true Islamic governance. The latter gives way to it's own set of problematic issues.
@@infoage265 I fail to see the extremisim of brother Sajid. His nuanced criticism does not deny islamic governance but rather insists on the proper definition of the concept of tawhid without the dilution and oversimplification expressed by the tiktok brother. Such well-intentioned errors can corrupt muslims' understanding of what Islam is really about.
its the description that changes it. its the rehortic that you can't be muslim unless you live in complete sovereignty to allah. meaning that you have to be in fully islamic country or rule to be a muslim. it's problematic cause it isn't true. which is why the prophets saw companions eliminated their other companions who believed in that because it breeds bad conflict that has been throught all of history. turning islams FUNDAMENTALS into a religion that soley values governance of its people is VERY dangerous. you get crusaders 2.0
I think you misinterpreted his intent. He does not mean that countries that do not implement Sharia law are non-Muslim citizens. But he said that the current form of law in every country is not 100% Shariah Islam.
@@LearnFromTheLight why? Cos Sajjid ddnt add humping sounds and background instrumentals? You can’t learn about Islam through short clips, knowledge isnt based of yes and no answers its far deeper than that. The context is more important than just an answer. Everyone and anyone gets a platfrom these days, start making over exaggerated videos and start giving out ‘Islamic knowledge’ from google. These people dont possess any Islamic credentials and everyone suddenly runs to go to listen to them. Why are people watching them? Cos they make their videos all fun, exciting… whilst you and others sit there taking knowledge from these social media celebrities how can you be sure that what they’re teaching is correct? Don’t take knowledge from these people rather go take courses, online seminars with students of knowledge etc anyways Allah know’s best
@@LearnFromTheLight learn islam and practice it thats what gonna get you closer to Allah. Not some kid who needs dawah himself in a short clip. What he is saying is not right he is implying that if Iran where to adopt sharia fully and still have their beliefs they would be the only muslim country. They start like that and then they tell you its ok to wage war against the muslims because they are not ruling by sharia. Saajid clarified with hadith how wrong he is but if you want to be misguided only Allah can save you.
BarskAllahu Feekum. Just watched a single video of his right now, the brother seems genuine, perhaps ignorant - May Allah Guide Us All. Jazakumullahu Khairan 😁 Respect to what you're doing brother!
I am happy that you made this video. I saw his videos popping up in my feed and I thought this is absurd what he's saying about Muslim countries and about the khilafa. Barak Allahu feeka for critiquing his videos.
Yes, because a country doesn’t have to 100% rule by the shariah to be considered Islamic just like how you don’t have to 100% adhere to Islamic laws to be Muslim, otherwise an individual who drinks alcohol would be considered an apostate.
I think brother Sajid has some serious comprehension issues, when brother Rhyad said there isn't a single Islamic country in today's world he didn't mean what you thought he meant. imo this refutation was so unnecessary.
@@AANaeemDoesMore Brother Do you know during debates with non muslims sometimes they say "Hey you know in Pakistan or Iran or Turkey they did this & this to women or non muslims" then we say so what they are not representatives of Islam, if you wanna judge Islam judge it by it's book Quran. And that's what Brother Rhyad meant that there isn't any country rn that represents Islam bc they don't follow Islamic law completely and he's absolutely right.
While you're debunking him, u felt into the other side, khawarjqawaed. I'm sure you're not, I hope you correct yourself, you'll stand alone in front of Allah and he's asking u about everything you say
Jazzakh Allah khairun brother Sajid you have really broken down and addressed this very important in fact incredibly important issue in a very easy to understand manner. May Allah SWT bless the Ummah with khair in duniya and akhira and reunite us all in Jannah Al Firdose Ameen Ya Rabb
His videos are good and what Saajid portrayed in this video is completely slanderous and assumptive and serves no benefit but to misguide and create fitnah in the Ummah, Be careful of watching and listening to someone whos whole channel is buily on refuting and making other muslims look bad, its a sickness of the heart, and a true person of knowledge does not do these things, and if they were to refute, then they must be qualified and respectfully Saajid is not anywhere near being qualified for that. I recommend you and everyone to stay away from these kind of attacking slanderous videos that are just for views and publicity. Just because someone has a big beard and graduated from madinah does not make them correct or knowledgeable, infact, it is usually those who portray this image that end up being the most harmful to the ummah. Kindness is never added to anything except that it beautifies it, May Allah guide us all and separate truth from falsehood
Nah man he is somewhat right about one flag one ummah. There is no nationalism in Islam. West divided Muslim nations. An Islamic state should have Islamic/Sharia law/legislation
Interesting discussion. Just a quick question, would you say that Saudi Arabia government are Muslim when they implemented a ruling directly opposing Islam, usury (riba)? Putting aside this tiktok video and the incident with Ali (ra). I am wondering where you draw the line on what does and does not take one out of the fold of Islam.
Why single Saajid out? MH and AD have did their fair share of criticizing other dahees.. why do they get a free pass? I love all of the brothers for their dawah content, i just think all of the back and forth as a whole is unnecessary. Though, in regards to Ali Dawah, the brother had it coming for his not so great "discussion" he did with apuss lol.
Lol, have you seen how many people Hijab and Ali have gone after? They even have a channel dedicated to it. I don't see anything wrong with correcting someone if they're wrong and Ali was definitely wrong and the way he acted afterwards was childish. His discussion with Apuss was embarassing, and this guy is apparently the face of Islamic Dawah on youtube. Is that who you want representing your faith to non muslims? For me, no.
yeah bro i want to help in establishing a country where the people are not judged by their nationalties but by onky their religion and where the laws of Allah flourish without the laws of man i truly hope and pray to Allah that we can do something for our ummah.
4:40 khawarij 6:10 rule completely according to islamic law (legilation) 🕵🏻♀️ 8:25 Hizbut tahrir. . 12:10 13:22 QS 12 : 40 ▪️Deviated ideology 🕵🏻♀️ 13:59 🕵🏻♀️14:22 foundation of religion from the right people ✅n
Damn! How does any Muslim without knowledge see the problems in that TikTok? This is alarming. I wouldn't have flagged it as problematic had I not watch this video to understand exactly what the tiktoker was talking about. May Allah protect our seen from those who will lead us astray. Jazaakallahu Khairan brother Saajid.
Jazak Allah Khair brother Saajid for defending the deen and La Ilaha Illallah. The 3 Muslims were out of order for responding to your video the way they did and for including Ali Dawah in their video. No scholar in history has given that definition. Even non Muslims understand the definition. Outrageous, most people on the comments on the 3 Muslims Chanel were furious with Rami, we should speak the truth and never side with people when we know they are wrong just because we may have a relationship with them.
Iranians don't worship the 12 imams. They love them as best servants of Allah swt, and teachers of religion. They don't do takfeer of sahaba. They same some of them deviated from the command of the prophet on the day of Qadeer. And they do not believe Quran is incomplete. They have the same Quran as every other muslim. They just believe the rules of Quran weren't followed.
You don’t have to believe in them as gods to worship them. If you take away Allah’s rights and give them to his creation then this is worshipping them.
@@MohammedAlSharif2002 Allah is the one, the creator, the nurturer, the lord, the one who gives life and takes it away, the powerful, and the knower. There is no comparison between Him swt and His creation. Everyone is His weak servant, even our beloved prophet who is the best of creation. Our prophet and Imams of ahlulbait are guides to Allah swt and teachers of His religion and examples of how to live that religion. They have nothing except it's given by Allah and can be taken away by Allah swt.
Br. Sajad...While I acknowledge some inaccuracies that you pointed out, I don't understand why you think his message is so dangerous and deviant. Essentially he is calling for Muslims to live under one khalifah who implements Islam as a ruling system over them. Is that so horrible? Didn't Rasoolullah (s) order us to be united under one Imam/sultan who rules by the Haq? I would think that our kids becoming kuffar due to the spread of atheism and liberalism is far more urgent than what's going on here.
You are clearly misrepresenting the guy in the video. He didn't say that the definition that he mentioned is "the only meaning". It really seems like a reach tbh
I appreciate you both. Hope brother Riyadh doesn't take it personally, as he seems like a kind and sincere person. May Allah guide us all to the straight path.
Most of those who went out to fight without the permission of the government and blew themselves up were sincere !! Sincerity without knowledge has dire consequences
@@khaliduae-qv5ni ok, keep taking permission of the govts who rule by taghut laws, Allah has given permission to the believers alhamdulilah , May allah accept those who left their homes for Allah 🤲
@@khaliduae-qv5ni Al-Hajj 22:58 And those who emigrated for the cause of Allah and then were k!lləd or d!ed - Allah will surely provide for them a good provision. And indeed, it is Allah who is the best of providers. Al-Baqarah 2:216 Fiğht!ng is ordained for you, though you dislike it. You may dislike something although it is good for you, or like something although it is bad for you: God knows and you do not.’
There's no question that Hizb-ut-Tahrir and Da'esh have deviated greatly from correct creed and I applaud you for pointing that out and warning against them. That said, we have to agree that 1) change from the top is a very valid method for affecting societal change and has many current and historical precedents (Ibn Katheer mentions several such instances) and most Muslim counties would be much better off without their current ruling classes, 2) the Saudi model is clearly not the best we should aspire to, and therefore 3) we should work toward a better model that is more congruent with Shari'ah. This work (that we must do) starts by setting the standard of what we look to ultimately achieve. Any da'ee who criticizes HUT or Da'esh without calling for the ideal vision of Islamic governance risks appearing like a Saudi shill, perhaps rightfully so.
@@SoMonstersDoExist Correct. I didn't study their ideologies but my understanding is that they share the tactic of "change from the top", each in their own deviant way.
@@contemplatively How can you make a statement about someone or something without knowing their creed or intentions? Even if you disagree with something, doesn't Islam tell us to be truthful and just? IS was created as a resistance against the US invasion of Iraq. Which deviant way would that be? I'm interested to know.
@@contemplatively "I didn't study their ideology..." and you proceeded to make bold statements about them lumping them together without certain knowledge. When you are questioned on the day of judgment about this statement do you think it will be sufficient to say that's what I heard?
this video greatly changed my mindset i thought the west are all to blame for the problems we have today thanks saajid may allah reward you jannat al firdaws
Don’t say InshAllah after dua habibi: Anas bin Malik narrated, “The Messenger of Allah said, ‘When one of you makes dua, he should be firm in his supplication and should not say, “O Allah, if You wish then grant me (my request),” for indeed, there is none who can compel Him.’” (Sahih Muslim) JazakAllah Khairan
Hoping for a real Muslim country is NOT a sin my brother.. He is right, there is no a single country today that we can say it applies Islam & Quran .. Although, we don't say that the people are not Muslims.. NO , Allah's forbid.. we just saying that we hope and wish and pray to our Lord to give all Muslims the opportunity to apply our marvellous religion in our lives, so we can live happily and we can help non Muslims and guide them..
we have to be fair and charitable to the truth brother. the young tiktoker didn't say "we hope for a real Muslim country" he said "there are no Islamic countries today". this is a dangerous mindset. Syria/Iraq/Libya/Egypt/Tunis were all destroyed by the Arab-Spring few years ago all because the people were ignorant and they didn't realize the prophet (pbuh) forbade rebellion against the ruler (even if he takes your wealth and whips your back). if they actually followed Quran and Sunnah these countries would not be in the situation they are today. words cannot be ignored. it is important for us to share the truth and guide others for the sake of Allah
Jazakallah - I find that I need to study a lot more. It took me until point 2 or 3 to realize the falsehood It’s dangerous rhetoric Thank you for the references
So true mentions of half and half knowledge by Muslims themselves had grown confusion and conflict among believers and mockery ground or targets for disbelievers...
I was very worried about this kind of ideology spreading to the muslims of west and sadly it’s happening. I’m very appreciative that you are doing your best to not allow this to spread any further may Allah bless you my brother.
The literal translation is There’s no God but Allah. Nothing about laws and worship, though that is implied. Y’all fighting and nitpicking drama. He means well and isn’t confusing anyone with anything. Mate, you’re overthinking.
The HT playlist:
th-cam.com/play/PLGFQ-qdt_egRGmfch7x9cg2R2H1f-JS4S.html
The playlist which covers the Khawarij and the fitna of khuruj during the khilafa and beyond:
th-cam.com/play/PLGFQ-qdt_egQ3qYIxoxCGq9wdf9NHWZWU.html
Wasim Ismail's Book:
False Caliphate: A Critical Analysis of Hizb Ut-Tahrir's Political and Creedal Views": www.amazon.com/False-Caliphate-Critical-Ut-Tahrirs-Political/dp/1989450164
جزاك الله خيراً
*I messaged and commented on rhyadMuslim's videos about why he never explains aqeedah and tawheed in details! He never replies! He always dodges aqeedah questions that would refute deviant shia sufi sects! He never refutes them and avoids refutations! Naoozubillah!*
Assalaamu alaikum Saajid, is there a way I can get in contact with you privately about this video's subject matter?
Assalamu alaikum
Brother , expecting a detailed series about ‘modern time khawarij’
*Sa’id ibn Jubayr reported: I asked Ibn Abbas, may Allah be pleased with him:Shall I enjoin good & forbid evil upon the ruler?” Ibn Abbas said:If you fear he will kill you, then no.” Then, I asked him again & he said the same to me. Then, I asked him again & he said the same to me & also said, “If you must do so, then do it between you & him privately✅️Source:AlAmr bilMaruf li Ibn AbiDunya 80✅️Ibn Rajab said:If one fears the rulers will put him to the sword or whip or prison or shackle or banishment or seizure of property or other types of harm like that, then the obligation to enjoin & forbid them is dropped. The Imams were explicit about that, among them Malik, Ahmad, Ishaq & others✅️Source:JamiAlUlum walHikam 2/249*
I’ve been on TikTok for a little while now and I truly believe this is the most dangerous app out there. The amount of ignorance being spread far and wide is terrifying
True and it is. On the other hand one of the best social media platforms i have seen is Twitter, specifically the "Muslim twitter" . You have students of knowledge there spreading knowledge, refuting ignorance with the aqwal of the salaf and generally that is the only app i have felt so ignorant and such a laymen due to so many brothers being so knowledgable. In Tiktok you feel like you are surrounded by people spreading ignorance. Imagine having a naseeha and music playing in the backround or a islamic reminder with beats, that is tiktok.
But to be fair, no one is loosing anything if they stay away from these platforms all together. If one decides to use one, one is better than the other for Muslims.
@@mohamudahmed6554 Give your life to Jesus.
@@truthangel5314 I rather worship the one who created Jesus.
@@nomore3346 facts
@@truthangel5314 I will give my life to the One Jesus ﷺ himself worshipped and called "The only true God" . Stop worshipping a Prophet, a man.
I’m glad I deleted TikTok a long time ago
I'm glad I never created an account
Never installed it, never will inshaAllah
*I messaged and commented on rhyadMuslim's videos about why he never explains aqeedah and tawheed in details! He never replies! He always dodges aqeedah questions that would refute deviant shia sufi sects! He never refutes them and avoids refutations! Naoozubillah!*
never had to delete
Alhamdulillah I never had tiktok.
That app is one of the worst things to happen to this generation. May Allah destroy that app.
Aameen.
Ameen
😂🤣😂😂
😂
Ya Allah forgive us and guide our children all
Ameen Ya Rabb
Ameen.
آمين
@@SRNK...2127
ياء حرف نداء
ورب العالمين لايحتاج نداء
@@SaMy.... there's nothing wrong if I call out to my Rabb ... I'm not asking you to do so .... mind your own damn business. You sad individual going around not picking at unnecessary things. Jog on
When you played the first clip I honestly did not notice what was wrong with his because to a layman it makes sense ‘the rule is only for Allah’ but SubhanAllah after you explained it I realised how little knowledge I have about my own religion 😢
one of the fundamentals of coming to learn knowledge, is realising you dont know and need to learn. dont be disheartened. its a good sign
@@imaadmalik7336 Jazakallahu khayr brother
I learnt it in kashf Al shubuhat by Muhammad ibn Abd Al Wahhab taughy by AMAUA channels Muhammad Tim Humble. Literally all my life i understood it wrong. It made perfect sense and exposed my ignorance to myself.
I once noticed noticed i misspelled the Al tahiyyah in salah, specifically the beginning. This was after learning arabic and gaining some knowledge about the language. Felt so dumb, but it showed me how i must be careful even about the smallest things.
So we have to have the correct meaning ? Km confused . Was he adding extra stuff to the kalima?
His videos are good and what Saajid portrayed in this video is completely slanderous and assumptive and serves no benefit but to misguide and create fitnah in the Ummah, Be careful of watching and listening to someone whos whole channel is buily on refuting and making other muslims look bad, its a sickness of the heart, and a true person of knowledge does not do these things, and if they were to refute, then they must be qualified and respectfully Saajid is not anywhere near being qualified for that. I recommend you and everyone to stay away from these kind of attacking slanderous videos that are just for views and publicity. Just because someone has a big beard and graduated from madinah does not make them correct or knowledgeable, infact, it is usually those who portray this image that end up being the most harmful to the ummah. Kindness is never added to anything except that it beautifies it, May Allah guide us all and separate truth from falsehood
Remember to mention Allah and don’t miss your daily prayers ❤ may your day be blessed
Simple rule when online. If you don't know who the person is, don't know their teachers, don't take knowledge from them.
I hope our brother won’t take this personally when watching this video, it is done to correct him and keep Muslims away from deviation. May Allah bless you for this video.
i hope things dont end up like the ali dawah situation
@@mizoo1954 me too, that’s why I said this lol.
خله يجلده
يقول مافيه ولا دوله اسلاميه
وين راحت السعوديه !!!
مخلفات الاستعمار مالهم الا الجلد
@@SaMy....
نعم كلامه خطأ لأن السعودية دولة اسلامية سلفية على منهج النبوة، ولو كان فيها بعض الاخطاء. اسال الله ان يهديه.
I don't see anything wrong with anything the bro said. It is the most overlooked part of the kalimah. If the Khawarij misapplied takfir doesn't negate the correctness of the fact that Allah is the only Sovereign or Authority.
2nd there is something as general takfir and specific takfir. It is generally Kufr to rule by other than Shariah. But to make specific takfir is something else.
3rd Khilfah is the same things as the Imamah. The hadith is in respect to Khulafah rashidun. Khilafah is generally any imam that has authority of the Muslims and rules by the Shariah.
4th To establish Shariah is one the greatest duties of the Muslims. Yet somehow Sajid made it an act of deviency. Ajeeb
BarakAllahfeek Akhi Saajid these lessons are so important for those who don't really know about these misguided sects may Allah Azawajal protect you and us from misguidance
Brother Saajid, I understand and appreciate the points you’re trying to make but i think it’s a stretch when applying to this brother. You may have misunderstood him and are making assumptions. After watching some of his videos I feel like his heart is in the right place. In this case you should have messaged him before putting him on blast.
He just pointed out the true dawah against ignorance about dawah he did not need to message him
Sajid is a Saudi American puppet
This is true. I stopped watching him for a long time bcz he with all due respect had became the controversy king of the Dawah scene. Came back after a long time & saw this😂
Is that the right thing to do Islamically, or are you simply assuming that. I don't know your level of knowledge so, just asking genuinely.
He didn't need to message him because he made these mistakes publicly so they need to be refuted publicly so people know the correct understanding.
Allah Bless you Saajid! Ameen
I do believe our Brother Rhyad is generally a force of good. May Allah keep us all on the straight path.
A force of good is when One renforces Allah Said.... His prophet (sa.w). said... tawheed. How many young muslim died with this retorik Khalifat
@@anonymousnoticer I hope our brother can patch the holes.
@@anonymousnoticer congratulations on giving him good deeds, I’m sure Allah will appreciate your backbiting, Gheeba is one of the punishments of the graves
@@samiharb1684 brother, it is not backbiting of it is in public and openly
@@samiharb1684 that’s an L bro
This is why ppl should never take dawah from TikTok
Instead youtube is the go to place for dawah
or from any random on the internet be it TH-cam, Facebook or something else. Always refer back to trustworthy scholars.
Thank you very much for the reminders,alot will benefit from this video.
You're reaching waaay beyond what he said, you got all this from these short clips. A great example of jumping into conclusions
My brother, we can say 1 is almost equal to 2 when compared with 10,000. But in reality, we will never count to 10,000 properly if we don't know the difference between 1 and 2. What that tiktok dude is doing is very subtle...
@@raider7790 this is unfounded paranoia, he didn't say a single damning thing "ان بعض الظن إثم" what sajid did is textbook example of jumping into conclusions and slandering another person without proof.
@@raider7790 watch his response
@@hafedbougraine945 my fellow muslim brother try digesting sajids words
Totally agree with you brother
I have always said that despite well-intentioned young brothers, i see a major fitnah brewing from social media da'aees. Whilst on the one hand it's commendable that these young brothers are keen to spread Islam, it is unfortunate that they do so whilst lacking fundamental knowledge and aqeedah. I have come across so many social media channels that are spreading categorically false concepts to their ever-increasing fan-base; and i fear this is just the very beginning. May Allah guide us all.
Many of these Tiktok Daees have a slightly above average Islamic knowledge among the ignorant Muslim youths. Their way of preaching and the platform attracts youth. I have benefitted a lot but after a certain point and most probably due to the audience's pressure, they speak on topics on which they have little to no knowledge off. They did not learn under a scholar so they themselves try to use logic or take knowledge of deviant groups that sound appealing and parrot it to the audience.
Yes. 👆🏻This exactly.
@@sadiqrahman2961 yes, I believe you are correct. I think it's very likely that is the way they go astray. May Allah keep them steadfast upon the faith and help these young brothers to gain more knowledge. Ameen
His videos are good and what Saajid portrayed in this video is completely slanderous and assumptive and serves no benefit but to misguide and create fitnah in the Ummah, Be careful of watching and listening to someone whos whole channel is buily on refuting and making other muslims look bad, its a sickness of the heart, and a true person of knowledge does not do these things, and if they were to refute, then they must be qualified and respectfully Saajid is not anywhere near being qualified for that. I recommend you and everyone to stay away from these kind of attacking slanderous videos that are just for views and publicity. Just because someone has a big beard and graduated from madinah does not make them correct or knowledgeable, infact, it is usually those who portray this image that end up being the most harmful to the ummah. Kindness is never added to anything except that it beautifies it, May Allah guide us all and separate truth from falsehood
@@sageezbaid If someone spreads misinformation in public, the scholars said to correct them publicly. You don't understand the danger of what this guy is preaching.
SubhanAllah I myself would not be able to catch that. Jazakullahair for clearing this all up! This is why it is important to know who you are taking your knowledge from!
This is a great video and hats of for tackling this topic and breaking it down
Asalam alaikum waramahtullah wa barakatu brother Saajid
While I understand snd can appreciate why you made this video
Just so this doesn't turn into a youtube back and fourth, would you be willing to Sit down with brother Rhyad and speak about this over zoom or similar apps and discuss this and clear up any confusion?
I'm willing to mediate this discussion as a neutral party since I've had dealings with you both
Let me know insh'allah
orite geez
@@imaadmalik7336 hello old chap
Great idea
I have reached out to some of the da'wah people on tiktok and I was told that this was a private conversation between the parties involved and other da'wah tiktokers and brother Saajid chose to take it publicly. Although I understand brother Saajid from his pov he needs to ''warn" people about certain rhetoric but I feel this is going to make another Ali Dawah situation.
Please use a capital a when writing or typing the name Allah.
This is such an incredibly important message to all, nothing is more important than the foundation of one’s beliefs, only then, when that belief is there can the people receive laws and legislation with an open heart, without feeling oppressed. May God bless richly the work of your hands. Not only in teaching but in filling the role given to you to help clean up online Dawah in these end times so the new believers receive guidance to build that very foundation you speak of
this is dumb lol
It's not dumb what she said is true.
Well said, thank you 👏
Kimberly Lipham? Is that a relation?
Any relation?
Brother Sajid, i have seen some of this guy’s videos, i don’t want to jump to the conclusion on this brother, Allah knows the best, may Allah guide us all on the right path
Thank you, brother. You really make us think deep.
Ali dawah recent video brought me here and I listened to your points and actually agree with you. New subscriber, thank you.
Thanks brother for informing me I am 17 years old. And was starting to get brainwashed by these types of TikTok’s.
Assalam Au Alykum bro. Be careful to group everyone on a certain social media platform as khwarij, this creates more damage than good. It's like suggesting TH-cam is led by non-believers so we should shut down the media. This is a fatwa and largely impractical. You should try to seek out knowledge and that is focused on building a healthy Aqeedah as that is the knowledge foundation for our beliefs but that does not ally itself to any state today because as you've seen with Sudhi Arubia and other states, the nation-state concept is very limiting belief-wise, psychologically, socially, and even ethically.
How many times have Muslims become prisoners in their own state for advocating for Islamic independence, try reading one book: Caliphate: The History of an Idea. It is by a non-Muslim historian but the author tries to study the development of the Caliphate-term and how it has led to its use today where the term has been hijacked to identify Muslims who threaten Western superpowers. Chapter 11 specifically if you ever get a chance
@Borsalino Kizaru Why? Interesting thought
Subhannallahe; May Allah grants us knowledge; honestly if not for your clarification I would not have noticed any issues with this video; Jazakhallahou khayr brother for clarifying
_"Let there be a group among you who call ˹others˺ to goodness, encourage what is good, and forbid what is evil-it is they who will be successful."_
_Quran (3: 104)_
May Allah ﷻ bless you with happiness and health, Ustadh Sajid. Ameen!
Ameen
Quran 24 : 55. Allah has promised those among you who believe and do righteous good deeds, that He will certainly grant them succession to (the present rulers) in the land, as He granted it to those before them, and that He will grant them the authority to practise their religion which He has chosen for them (i.e. Islam). And He will surely give them in exchange a safe security after their fear (provided) they (believers) worship Me and do not associate anything (in worship) with Me. But whoever disbelieves after this, they are the Fasiqun (rebellious, disobedient to Allah).
Quran 3 : 103. And hold fast, all of you together, to the Rope of Allah (i.e. this Qur'an), and be not divided among yourselves , and remember Allah's Favour on you, for you were enemies one to another but He joined your hearts together, so that, by His Grace, you became brethren (in Islamic Faith), and you were on the brink of a pit of Nar, and He saved you from it. Thus Allah makes His Ayat (proofs, evidence, verses, lessons, signs, revelations, etc.,) clear to you, that you may be guided.
Ameen 🤲🏽🤲🏽
Subhanallah I was just questioning when I came across this brother’s video earlier today. May Allah guide us and keep us steadfast to his straight path.
There is nothing wrong with what the brother said. You are clearly exaggerating the message he is trying to convey. These views are very common amongst other very respected scholars.
I respect you brother Saajid, but this video shows the influence of your educational background and the Saudi system where you just leave the so called "leader" do whatever without pointing to his mistakes because it is khurooj.
Since you like to educate Muslims about the current issues they are facing, how about you make a video about Mohammed Ibn Salman in Saudi Arabia and the damage he is causing to Muslims and scholars there?
Don't worry, it is ok. You are American and it won't be considered as Khurooj !
Exactly.
its khurooj today, but apparently wasn't khurooj when Al-Saud did the same to the Ottoman turks during WW1 and helped the Entente kill Muslims RE Lawrence of Arabia
@@flansable exactly what I think and here's where their hypocrisy lies. What a extreme kind of hypocrisy that is
Is The Killing of Ali RA is exaggeration? Fear Allah.
Correct.Agree w u vehemently.Yes Sajjid u got yr Islamic credibility from Medina..yes do try after all u are American no one can put you down.
What Ryand Islam Tik Tok is generally correct why not Islamic state as well as educating Muslims to be taqwa same time..like what the Prophet did...all of us are educating and shld have Caliphate to enforce things..Right??!! How u accuse easily everyone as Kwarij..check yr facts.
Brother with proper respect,
If you are against establishing Khilafa (not Islamic govt.), I disagree with you.
It should be a dream for Muslims to have an established Islamic ruling system.
Look at the chaos around the world,
they throw bomb, call you terrorist, insult our prophet(PBUH), disrespect our practicing sisters and so on
You can never stop these issues until you have the power to talk back and for that power you must need a Islamic ruling system or Khilafa.
Yes they do all those things then Sajid runs to their defense and joins them in attacking you for merely being upon tawhid.
@@rusi6219 I do not know why the scholars who have degree from Saudi like Medina University or others, they always try to hide the battle stuff (Jihad) from ummah.
It seems like they feel embarrassed to fight and talk against kufr. Unfortunately these type of scholars are widely seen in my country (Bangladesh).
Just because someone believes establishment of khalifa is not obligatory, it doesn’t mean they completely oppose it. The salafi position is that it is preferable but not obligatory.
@@aaliyah3037 how do you establish deen politically without khilafa?
@@pushtotalk7007 How did the prophet upon whom be peace and his companions politically establish deen when there was no caliphate? Why did the prophet upon whom be peace reject political power when offered by one of pagan Quraish and continue giving dawah and cultivating?
This is quite a serious accusation with a very weak proof. U could have just informed the audience how the khawarij mindset is instead of making him an example. What if u r wrong ? Can u open his heart and know his true intentions?
So when he says there's no Islamic countries, that's not a takfiri manhaj?
Dude the part about no Islamic country is literally true, there isn’t a single country which fully implements islamic law
there hasn't been one after the 30 years of the Prophetic Khilafah that was fully implemented. Even the last Ottoman Khalifah had numerous flaws such as the Sultans with the title of Caliphs killing their brothers, allowing music and sufi ways of worship, etc, however, Allah ordered us to be dutiful to the authority. Nevertheless, we are obliged to respect the authority a blanket statement of "there is no Islamic country" is dangerous and leads to Kharijism. I was born in UAE and refuse to speak ill of the Muslim authority even though there is discrimination against South Asian Muslims, it is a test from Allah and patience is rewardful. As Muslims our primary focus should be perfecting our Tawheed and strive for Jannah
Absolutely
Do you even know what is an Islamic country. It means majority is Muslims and Muslims are protected by Muslim government
Stop making ignorant statements no Muslim country exist
I used to have this same misconception, but it's not true that a country has to implement 100% of the Islamic laws in order to be an Islamic country. I'm not excusing them of course, and they are answerable to Allah, but that doesn't mean it's not an Islamic country.
@@231doughboy yes jazzak allah khayr may Allah guide us
بارك الله فيك شيخ ساجد.
Its great that you share your thoughts, you’ve been down the road while most of us haven’t, allowing us a quicker way to understand theses things instead of falling down a pit and needing to climb out afterwards because of our ignorance.
الله يجزيك الخير
JazakumAllaahu khayran brother and team for your video and share the knowledge and bring awareness to those seeking the truth based on al-Qur'aan and the authentic ahadeeth. Keep up the great work and your reward is from Allaah alone.
Brother saajid, jazaka llahu khairan for your efforts and hard work and all the years you spent seeking knowledge.
Ali dawah running to tweet "opportunistic backstabber"
You should've privately messaged him about this!!
is the tik tok video was privet and who told you it should be privately
Beautiful explanation by brother Saajid. May Allah reward him immensely. However only few people whom Allah has guided will understand and accept. Unfortunately majority of todays Muslims follow emotions and whims and desires instead of correct knowledge….
Thank you very much for putting this out there and warning the people my allah reward you for your efforts
I don't think there is much wrong with what he said
That's scary
@@AANaeemDoesMore actually i quite agree with all that the tiktok guy said
@@soulcandy5758 that there's no Islamic country in today's world?
That's a very abrupt statement - are you suggesting that Qatar, Kuwait, Saudi, Pakistan etc are all disbelievers..
I'm don't think you know the true weight of some of the things the TikTok guy has said
@@soulcandy5758 You need to re-study Islam from Authentic sources.
@@khaliduae-qv5ni so you think there is a real Muslim country which is completely based on Islam today? I think it's you who needs to be more mentally strong and embrace the truth. We can close our eyes and think everything is fine but it won't change anything. This video tries to even take away the desire to establish an Islamic system from the heart of the audience portraying that all is well. Also he is right about modern borders being drawn by western powers. I always support brother Sajid and will too but i think he was completely wrong on this one
I just went to TikTok and found that I was following him. i would never have cached on that if it weren't for this video. Thank you so much brother sajiid, may Allah bless you
Disappointed with you Saajid. The brother didn't mention anything about being Khawaarj, you taking what he said out of context.
You clearly didn't understand the points he made and I advise you to watch the video again and also educate yourself on the Khwarij and their ideology so you have a better understanding.
Jzk brother. That was really helpful.
Dear Shaykh
Lots of love for you
It is clear to see that the brother suffers from groupthink. With utmost love and respect, it appears that your thoughts are not free of this either.
I hope one day you are able to see that.
If not, and in any case, may Allah (swt) reward your good intentions.
Brother Sajid warned us of the danger of spreading aqeedah falsehoods. What is wrong with his ideas or approach? May Allah guide us all.
@@akramnimer6755 We are speaking of two extremes ahki. One camp makes governance a priority with little regard for aqeedah. The other prioritizes aqeedah with little regard for true Islamic governance. The latter gives way to it's own set of problematic issues.
@@infoage265 I fail to see the extremisim of brother Sajid. His nuanced criticism does not deny islamic governance but rather insists on the proper definition of the concept of tawhid without the dilution and oversimplification expressed by the tiktok brother. Such well-intentioned errors can corrupt muslims' understanding of what Islam is really about.
Thanks for bringing this topic.
What's wrong with wanting Allah's laws in all our affairs?
its the description that changes it. its the rehortic that you can't be muslim unless you live in complete sovereignty to allah. meaning that you have to be in fully islamic country or rule to be a muslim. it's problematic cause it isn't true. which is why the prophets saw companions eliminated their other companions who believed in that because it breeds bad conflict that has been throught all of history.
turning islams FUNDAMENTALS into a religion that soley values governance of its people is VERY dangerous. you get crusaders 2.0
I think you misinterpreted his intent. He does not mean that countries that do not implement Sharia law are non-Muslim citizens. But he said that the current form of law in every country is not 100% Shariah Islam.
And that's the issue 🤯
I used to watch his videos before I deleted tik tok. I had no idea how dangerous this ideology is. SubhanAllah May Allah protect us
Amin
@@LearnFromTheLight why? Cos Sajjid ddnt add humping sounds and background instrumentals? You can’t learn about Islam through short clips, knowledge isnt based of yes and no answers its far deeper than that. The context is more important than just an answer. Everyone and anyone gets a platfrom these days, start making over exaggerated videos and start giving out ‘Islamic knowledge’ from google. These people dont possess any Islamic credentials and everyone suddenly runs to go to listen to them. Why are people watching them? Cos they make their videos all fun, exciting… whilst you and others sit there taking knowledge from these social media celebrities how can you be sure that what they’re teaching is correct? Don’t take knowledge from these people rather go take courses, online seminars with students of knowledge etc anyways Allah know’s best
@@LearnFromTheLight you are right brother barak allahu fek
@@LearnFromTheLight learn islam and practice it thats what gonna get you closer to Allah. Not some kid who needs dawah himself in a short clip. What he is saying is not right he is implying that if Iran where to adopt sharia fully and still have their beliefs they would be the only muslim country. They start like that and then they tell you its ok to wage war against the muslims because they are not ruling by sharia.
Saajid clarified with hadith how wrong he is but if you want to be misguided only Allah can save you.
@@shakirch8192 the tiktoker brother didn't do anything wrong but this brother is actually listening something else....
Thanks, I was thinking like him before watching your video
BarskAllahu Feekum. Just watched a single video of his right now, the brother seems genuine, perhaps ignorant - May Allah Guide Us All. Jazakumullahu Khairan 😁 Respect to what you're doing brother!
May Allah bless you and continue to protect you and aid you as you use your platform to help us all amin
May Allah ﷻ reward you for your efforts, Ustadh Sajid. Ameen!
I am happy that you made this video. I saw his videos popping up in my feed and I thought this is absurd what he's saying about Muslim countries and about the khilafa.
Barak Allahu feeka for critiquing his videos.
You should have personally messaged him with these. This is not good to do like this in public place I guess
Brother Saajid, may Allah bless you for your work. Indeed, Allah has replaced the worst of us with best ones. Best regards to you from Uzbekistan!
He is right, there is no country that has applied 100% shariah.
Yes, because a country doesn’t have to 100% rule by the shariah to be considered Islamic just like how you don’t have to 100% adhere to Islamic laws to be Muslim, otherwise an individual who drinks alcohol would be considered an apostate.
Your right this is one of your most important videos. If your aqeedah isn’t correct then all your walls of your castle will fall down.
To be able to give dawah you must be filled with true knowledge nowdays many don't take this to consideration.
Barakallahu fee for bringing our attention to this brother.
I think brother Sajid has some serious comprehension issues, when brother Rhyad said there isn't a single Islamic country in today's world he didn't mean what you thought he meant. imo this refutation was so unnecessary.
But that's such a dangerous statement
@@AANaeemDoesMore Brother Do you know during debates with non muslims sometimes they say "Hey you know in Pakistan or Iran or Turkey they did this & this to women or non muslims" then we say so what they are not representatives of Islam, if you wanna judge Islam judge it by it's book Quran. And that's what Brother Rhyad meant that there isn't any country rn that represents Islam bc they don't follow Islamic law completely and he's absolutely right.
Прекрасное напоминание, пусть Аллах сделает тебя одним из обитателей Фирдауса!
While you're debunking him, u felt into the other side, khawarjqawaed. I'm sure you're not, I hope you correct yourself, you'll stand alone in front of Allah and he's asking u about everything you say
Jazzakh Allah khairun brother Sajid you have really broken down and addressed this very important in fact incredibly important issue in a very easy to understand manner.
May Allah SWT bless the Ummah with khair in duniya and akhira and reunite us all in Jannah Al Firdose Ameen Ya Rabb
His videos are good and what Saajid portrayed in this video is completely slanderous and assumptive and serves no benefit but to misguide and create fitnah in the Ummah, Be careful of watching and listening to someone whos whole channel is buily on refuting and making other muslims look bad, its a sickness of the heart, and a true person of knowledge does not do these things, and if they were to refute, then they must be qualified and respectfully Saajid is not anywhere near being qualified for that. I recommend you and everyone to stay away from these kind of attacking slanderous videos that are just for views and publicity. Just because someone has a big beard and graduated from madinah does not make them correct or knowledgeable, infact, it is usually those who portray this image that end up being the most harmful to the ummah. Kindness is never added to anything except that it beautifies it, May Allah guide us all and separate truth from falsehood
Nah man he is somewhat right about one flag one ummah. There is no nationalism in Islam. West divided Muslim nations. An Islamic state should have Islamic/Sharia law/legislation
Interesting discussion. Just a quick question, would you say that Saudi Arabia government are Muslim when they implemented a ruling directly opposing Islam, usury (riba)?
Putting aside this tiktok video and the incident with Ali (ra). I am wondering where you draw the line on what does and does not take one out of the fold of Islam.
First it was Mohamed Hijab, then it was Ali dawah, now it's ryhad. I'm seeing a pattern unfortunately.
Why single Saajid out? MH and AD have did their fair share of criticizing other dahees.. why do they get a free pass? I love all of the brothers for their dawah content, i just think all of the back and forth as a whole is unnecessary. Though, in regards to Ali Dawah, the brother had it coming for his not so great "discussion" he did with apuss lol.
Lol, have you seen how many people Hijab and Ali have gone after? They even have a channel dedicated to it. I don't see anything wrong with correcting someone if they're wrong and Ali was definitely wrong and the way he acted afterwards was childish.
His discussion with Apuss was embarassing, and this guy is apparently the face of Islamic Dawah on youtube. Is that who you want representing your faith to non muslims? For me, no.
May Almighty Allah rewards you sheikh for help us from these people. Ameen
To establish a Islamic county, shouldn't we work? If anyone wants it then he becomes khawarej. Why you people don't try to establish Islamic law?
yeah bro i want to help in establishing a country where the people are not judged by their nationalties but by onky their religion and where the laws of Allah flourish without the laws of man i truly hope and pray to Allah that we can do something for our ummah.
@@user-ue4fh5mv9s insaallah
4:40 khawarij
6:10 rule completely according to islamic law (legilation) 🕵🏻♀️
8:25 Hizbut tahrir. .
12:10
13:22 QS 12 : 40
▪️Deviated ideology
🕵🏻♀️ 13:59
🕵🏻♀️14:22 foundation of religion from the right people
✅n
Damn! How does any Muslim without knowledge see the problems in that TikTok? This is alarming. I wouldn't have flagged it as problematic had I not watch this video to understand exactly what the tiktoker was talking about. May Allah protect our seen from those who will lead us astray.
Jazaakallahu Khairan brother Saajid.
Same
It shows we need to study our Deen more (going in depth)
بارك الله فيك أخي ساجد، ونفع بك الإسلام والمسلمين
Jazak Allah Khair brother Saajid for defending the deen and La Ilaha Illallah. The 3 Muslims were out of order for responding to your video the way they did and for including Ali Dawah in their video. No scholar in history has given that definition. Even non Muslims understand the definition. Outrageous, most people on the comments on the 3 Muslims Chanel were furious with Rami, we should speak the truth and never side with people when we know they are wrong just because we may have a relationship with them.
I began this and thought it was criticizing minutiae but my goodness, this was absolutely necessary. This is essentially the path to extremism.
Iranians don't worship the 12 imams. They love them as best servants of Allah swt, and teachers of religion.
They don't do takfeer of sahaba. They same some of them deviated from the command of the prophet on the day of Qadeer.
And they do not believe Quran is incomplete. They have the same Quran as every other muslim. They just believe the rules of Quran weren't followed.
You don’t have to believe in them as gods to worship them. If you take away Allah’s rights and give them to his creation then this is worshipping them.
@@MohammedAlSharif2002 Allah is the one, the creator, the nurturer, the lord, the one who gives life and takes it away, the powerful, and the knower. There is no comparison between Him swt and His creation. Everyone is His weak servant, even our beloved prophet who is the best of creation.
Our prophet and Imams of ahlulbait are guides to Allah swt and teachers of His religion and examples of how to live that religion. They have nothing except it's given by Allah and can be taken away by Allah swt.
making comments about other muslims to gain views instead of actually speaking to them directly live to help them if you truely think you are correct.
May Allah bless you Brother Saajid!
It’s so, so important to properly learn the deen.
May Allah bless and protect us all.
Ameen
I watched that video long time ago but i saw video of someone talking wrong like this guy so i came back for reminder ty sajid
Br. Sajad...While I acknowledge some inaccuracies that you pointed out, I don't understand why you think his message is so dangerous and deviant. Essentially he is calling for Muslims to live under one khalifah who implements Islam as a ruling system over them. Is that so horrible? Didn't Rasoolullah (s) order us to be united under one Imam/sultan who rules by the Haq? I would think that our kids becoming kuffar due to the spread of atheism and liberalism is far more urgent than what's going on here.
You are clearly misrepresenting the guy in the video. He didn't say that the definition that he mentioned is "the only meaning". It really seems like a reach tbh
I appreciate you both. Hope brother Riyadh doesn't take it personally, as he seems like a kind and sincere person.
May Allah guide us all to the straight path.
Ameen
Most of those who went out to fight without the permission of the government and blew themselves up were sincere !! Sincerity without knowledge has dire consequences
@@khaliduae-qv5ni ok, keep taking permission of the govts who rule by taghut laws, Allah has given permission to the believers alhamdulilah , May allah accept those who left their homes for Allah 🤲
@@eddyyusuf7034 Show me the evidence that Allah has given permission. Do you have a verse from the Quran or hadith?
@@khaliduae-qv5ni Al-Hajj 22:58
And those who emigrated for the cause of Allah and then were k!lləd or d!ed - Allah will surely provide for them a good provision. And indeed, it is Allah who is the best of providers.
Al-Baqarah 2:216
Fiğht!ng is ordained for you, though you dislike it. You may dislike something although it is good for you, or like something although it is bad for you: God knows and you do not.’
Alhamdulillah, thank you brother.
There's no question that Hizb-ut-Tahrir and Da'esh have deviated greatly from correct creed and I applaud you for pointing that out and warning against them. That said, we have to agree that 1) change from the top is a very valid method for affecting societal change and has many current and historical precedents (Ibn Katheer mentions several such instances) and most Muslim counties would be much better off without their current ruling classes, 2) the Saudi model is clearly not the best we should aspire to, and therefore 3) we should work toward a better model that is more congruent with Shari'ah. This work (that we must do) starts by setting the standard of what we look to ultimately achieve. Any da'ee who criticizes HUT or Da'esh without calling for the ideal vision of Islamic governance risks appearing like a Saudi shill, perhaps rightfully so.
As far as I know, IS doesn't follow the same creed as Hizb-ut-Tahrir. Can you elaborate on that?
@@SoMonstersDoExist Correct. I didn't study their ideologies but my understanding is that they share the tactic of "change from the top", each in their own deviant way.
@@contemplatively How can you make a statement about someone or something without knowing their creed or intentions? Even if you disagree with something, doesn't Islam tell us to be truthful and just? IS was created as a resistance against the US invasion of Iraq. Which deviant way would that be? I'm interested to know.
@@contemplatively "I didn't study their ideology..." and you proceeded to make bold statements about them lumping them together without certain knowledge. When you are questioned on the day of judgment about this statement do you think it will be sufficient to say that's what I heard?
TikTok is cancer.
Amazing as Muslims we are so proud of such great scholars like you ❤️
May Allah bless you
он не учёный
Scholar 😂?
Jazzakaa'Allahu Khairan, Today very first time I understand about the concept of Hizbul tahrir, Indeed you explained it rightly.
this video greatly changed my mindset i thought the west are all to blame for the problems we have today thanks saajid may allah reward you jannat al firdaws
Don’t say InshAllah after dua habibi:
Anas bin Malik narrated, “The Messenger of Allah said, ‘When one of you makes dua, he should be firm in his supplication and should not say, “O Allah, if You wish then grant me (my request),” for indeed, there is none who can compel Him.’”
(Sahih Muslim)
JazakAllah Khairan
@@mahmoudismail7761 ok akhi I didn’t know and may allah reward you too
@@Damnahh may Allah bless for accepting the truth maybe Edit the first comment as well brother
@@Nima-ec4tr ok brother
BarakkAllah fik brother..
Tiktokers spreading Khawarij ideology.
Astagfirullah
There’s so many of them and other ahlul bidah spreading their ideology there, its crazy
Tiktok is full of 14 year old takfiris or sufi influenced liberals
after few minutes your video started making sense Good job
Hoping for a real Muslim country is NOT a sin my brother.. He is right, there is no a single country today that we can say it applies Islam & Quran .. Although, we don't say that the people are not Muslims.. NO , Allah's forbid.. we just saying that we hope and wish and pray to our Lord to give all Muslims the opportunity to apply our marvellous religion in our lives, so we can live happily and we can help non Muslims and guide them..
we have to be fair and charitable to the truth brother. the young tiktoker didn't say "we hope for a real Muslim country" he said "there are no Islamic countries today". this is a dangerous mindset.
Syria/Iraq/Libya/Egypt/Tunis were all destroyed by the Arab-Spring few years ago all because the people were ignorant and they didn't realize the prophet (pbuh) forbade rebellion against the ruler (even if he takes your wealth and whips your back). if they actually followed Quran and Sunnah these countries would not be in the situation they are today.
words cannot be ignored. it is important for us to share the truth and guide others for the sake of Allah
Jazakallah -
I find that I need to study a lot more.
It took me until point 2 or 3 to realize the falsehood
It’s dangerous rhetoric
Thank you for the references
So true mentions of half and half knowledge by Muslims themselves had grown confusion and conflict among believers and mockery ground or targets for disbelievers...
The last Islamic country that existed was the Ottoman empire until they introduced monarchies. And Saudi Iran are misguided
Thank you for sharing. May Allah Subhanatala guide us all to the straight path.
I was very worried about this kind of ideology spreading to the muslims of west and sadly it’s happening.
I’m very appreciative that you are doing your best to not allow this to spread any further may Allah bless you my brother.
Jazak Allahu khayran
(May Allah reward you with goodness)
For educating us
May Allah protect us from deviation and keep us steadfast upon the Straight Path
O the I didn't even know, jazakallah bro
I can't say he is perfectly right but I don't see anything to be pointed as dangerous or misleading in what he says
The literal translation is There’s no God but Allah. Nothing about laws and worship, though that is implied. Y’all fighting and nitpicking drama. He means well and isn’t confusing anyone with anything. Mate, you’re overthinking.