South Cries Foul Over Funds; Game Of Grants Gets Ugly; Federalism Or Favouritism? | Urban Debate
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ม.ค. 2025
- In today's episode of 'Urban Debate', anchor Ritangshu Bhattacharya discusses the fund fight between North and South. Grant distribution sparks controversy as Southern States cry foul over funds". Row erupts as southern states voice dissatisfaction over the allocation of central grants, alleging unfair distribution and neglect of their contributions to the national economy. You can't do injustice just because opposition party is ruling the state: says Congress' Bhavya Narasimhamurthy.
'Bihar, UP, MP are Bimaru states' : Mohan Krishna Ex-Media advisor to ex Karnataka CM Bommai.
#south #karnataka #north #fund #funddistribution #tax #taxdevolution #topnews #latestnews #urbandebate #mirrornow
SUBSCRIBE NOW | bit.ly/Subscri...
For More Updates ► www.mirrornowne...
Like us on Facebook ► / mirrornow
Follow us on Twitter ► / mirrornow
Follow us on Instagram ► / mirrornow_in
Subscribe to our other network channels:
Times Now Navbharat: bit.ly/Subscri...
Zoom: bit.ly/Subscri...
Times Now: bit.ly/Subscri...
ET Now: bit.ly/Subscri...
TN+: bit.ly/Subscri...
South Indians funds is washed away in Ganga river with bridge collapse in Bihar😅😅😅
Do you know freight EQUALISATION POLITY then talk
@CreatorvsDestroyer Andh bhakt....faltu...
@@CreatorvsDestroyer do you know civility don't pollute the environment don't shit on streets especially don't pollute holy ganga river
Converted are crying because government spends money on Hindus and Hindu festivals, while CONgress and other parties spend money on anti nationals, churches and Masjid upkeeping, paying salaries to Mullahs and priests, free electricities for minority institutions. Tax collected goes for Vote catching freebies, not for development.
what about tamilnadu gov who rejects dedicated freight corridor.
Now indian government is treating southern states like Pakistan treated Bangladesh in 1970s like allocating all projects and money for hindhi people development, demographics change, favourism towards hindhi people in all govt jobs, language imposition, we are second class citizens in india
Even wayanad landslide aid still not given by north indian central government.
This feeling of a section of the country being treated as second-class citizens, is dangerous for the nation.
Similar feelings in East Pakistan against West Pakistan was the fuse that ignited the Bangladesh liberation movement by the Mukti Bahini in 1970.
First give your vote to the BJP then expect something, People of Andhra Voted for BJP ally, They are getting the Benefit.
And one more thing, During Congress Tenure :-Do you remember 2G scam?. What did DMK politicians do when they were in Power??
@@thewalker338 then dont collect tax from. Southern states. We will not vote for bjp
@@thewalker338 BJP did more harm than Congress to AP by supporting the state division and denying what is assured. Though AP people voted for BJP twice, it didn't bother to give what is in the bifurcation act even 10 years after the state divided.
North indian news channels never allow southern indians to make the point in any discussions. Especially key points.
This proves how biased this whole country is and always.south india is asked to prove their patriotism by losing in all aspects.
Just see the title itself.they potrayed it like we cries over something unnecessarily .well it's our rights to demand what we need 😑 that we also contributed
When Congress was in power who did the 2G scam?
DMK is responsible for Bankruptcy of BSNL.
@@tamizh2422they put 100 tax on car bike popcorn but looting everything by giving to bihar and UP
We are not south India. Stop calling us south India. We are southern India.
make a sovereign country otherwise these northern gutka people will devour ur progress.
Southern states are discriminated by north sangi government.
Fun fact 😂😂 south states giving more money for north indian states for improvement but north people coming to South states to settle 😂😂
Then they play Hindi victim card in south
😂😂😂they spend money on daily falling brides 😂😂😂
North giving cheap labour for us in South
Pakistan model again
Hindus contribute to the Indian economy while muslims enjoying free schemes.. Governments take income only from temples but not from other religious sites. People with 2 children pay tax and with 10 children enjoying free schemes.. can you speak on this?? Still how many years does the government show partiality??
How many years Bihar and UP will be paid more what is the CAG report
What was the freight equalization policy? Who looted Bihar 40 years?
@@thewalker338why did not protest at that time and keep on begging us for 75 years . How long you want to eat our shit .
@@thewalker338who looted? And when was this policy abolished? What did you do after that till now?
Hindus contribute to the Indian economy while muslims enjoying free schemes.. Governments take income only from temples but not from other religious sites. People with 2 children pay tax and with 10 children enjoying free schemes.. can you speak on this?? How many years does the government show partiality to them??
@@LahariMathyala So there are no Hindus in South 😅😅
Karnataka and kerala are the only major states in india which still dont have AIIMS. madurai AIIMS IN TN still not operational. Centre asked tamilnadu to take loan to build madurai AIIMS.
Meanwhile centre fully funded all AIIMS in northern states. Many northern states LIKE UP have 2 AIIMS. THEY ARE ALL OPERATIONAL. UP is waiting for their 3rd AIIMS ☺️.
Jammu hp all got
Center not even help southern states during grave natural calamities. They spend crores to Gujrat for flood, but when an entire area was washed away in Wayand, still not a penny is paid, worse they want state to pay for rescue operations of army. There is no new infrastructure project in Kerala in last 10 years. A mere 10 km road and railway connectivity from a major port in Kerala is still not started even after port is operational.
@@coconutpunch123 all money goes to freebies, and other vote gathering projects
@@sujithkumar2041 💯
No development in UP , but still union Government allocated more fund just to use only for temple....
Temple is constructed with donations from Hindu society, Government contributions is just 1 rupee.
In fact government spends money for HAJ .
@@NidhiBobba😂😂😂daily falling brides 😂😂😂
Temple was built with the money donated by the Hindus. You are living in an Hindu country. Respect the host religion in which you are currently residing in. Our money, our land our nation our wish.
You want UP to be filled with Gundas? Prior to BJP, that is the situation in UP. Development cannot happen in the middle of violence.
@@NidhiBobbaModi, Amit Shah and many MPs & MLAs used Ram temple for election. Just study the amount of money spent on PM clothes. And then study about amount of money spent on PM and Cabinet Ministers security. That money got washed away because of Ram temple.
The choice of words.. 🙄 south is not crying. It's DEMANDING. There's a hell lot of difference. Typical north media.
Why should southern states pay for the Bhimaru states?
Let the Bhimaru states take loans from Bhimaru states & pay interest to the donor states.
How will center ensure development of southern states are not hampered due to low funds allocation to the southern states?
BJP is acting like a communist party, take from rich and disturb to the poor.
BJP & Modi government will slowdown the economic development of India by their stupid logic & policies
just like northern state paid when south was bimaru.
The real aspect is that the bimaru aattes doesn't want to work on their population index, no proper education, no proper infrastructure in rural areas.
After all the funds, UP is still the crime and hate capital of India.
@@mkbioscope8253 when was the north rich enough to feed the southern states? Can you please give data?
Dude can you just think about the country look at your language people like u are the real bhimaru of this country...
@@mkbioscope8253 lol when was it ?
Giving money to North india is not problem, but funds are used for religious fight instead of growth
Cut the crap. UP has been growing at 7 percent on avg.
Which is decent for state with 25 Cr population.
Everytime these guys make cry about money to hide their own failures and corruption.
We are ok with the nations border areas develops as going now in Kashmir arunachal but spending tax money for religious events like kumbmela ,5500 crore is unacceptable, even union govt money also not spending in south like land purchased for AIIMS in south but no construction started....we love nation but but...need to talk and solve before this is spiral out ....
And huge corruption and mismanagement. Most of these funds goes to the pockets of politicians and beuareocrats
How come it is not a problem. Are you a debt free state? It is a problem for most of the poor South Indians.
@@Samsungbrowsractually according toi news paper front page report rs.9000 crores is the budget for kumb mela
Rs.7.5 k up govt & rs.1.5 k union central govt.
The news appeared on front page few days back.
The costs may differ reported by media but spending so much is not necessary as UP lacks good primary and high schools and hospitals for massive population of the state.
So much publicity and huge cutouts of modi and yogi spread across from Delhi onwards to up
These two big leaders could have adviced their party subordinates not to spend so much on their self glorification.
If it continues southern bharat will separate and form different country
Do you want UAPA😂
That's better than eating cow dung and being quite.
@@rajaindraverma1880 blackmailing?? Are you not ashamed of eating out of someone else's money, without working on your own?
Andha bhakt.
That is what they want actually, I perceive, but one must not fall pray. Our founding fathers envisioned a greater and more united India than what these hate mongers contemplate.
Southern states should stand unite and fight against this discrimination and north indian domination
South India needs self-rule.
I agree with you.Its long overdue
Seperate south India is the only solution.
A small disaster and the states ask central gov for funds -This is the reality no one wants to see -
I will full support to South India
Their stepmotherly attitude forces us to thing like that...but future will decide everything.
Or South India need South Indian prime minister, South Indian supreme Court, South Indian reserve Bank,,, etc
I have watched the news yesterday night on tv .
Whatever people have different opinions like political parties n its leaders.
One thing is fact , south states collected tax due should be given back to states for the benefit and growth of the people.
The anchor has mentioned three states up mp bihar which are collecting more tax money
The govt led by modi and these states mps and mls should develop these states with all infrastructure, bonding all people and setup make in india factories for people to work.
UP people shld start working 90 hours per week to support India's gdp since they swallow most of the India's GDP
😂
they already work that much, most of labours across India come from there😅
@@AbhinavChauhan-nc8hj As labours! It's not a proud statement. UP govt shld be ashamed that it's people are working as labours all across India..with so much money getting allocated each n every time, the govt could have easy deposited 10lakh in each household account by now for free!!!
UP & Bihar people already start working 90 hours per week for increase population🤣
It is simply shocking to not have expressways between cities like Hyderabad, chennai and Bengaluru, but expressways have been set up to connect two tier 2 cities in UP.
Well Said Brother...
There is a expressway already built between Chennai and bangalore and a expressway built between Bangalore and mysore also...
This is why South asks for autonomy. Whereas North says one india one nation
Step motherly treatment😢😢😢
UP Bihar has been used to this stepmotherly behaviour for 4 decade
He is 2 rupee beggar paid tax 🤣🤣🤣
@natarajank6565Now people start to shout freebies/revdi culture. Bullshit!!!because of that freebies (mid day meal, bicycle, laptop and first graduate subsidy), I become a 30% tax payer. And there is no 100% efficient in any schemes. If you keep on look at the wastage there is no development in the country. A wise man said there is no poor states in india, it's because of mismanagement and lack of futuristic vision.
@ lol
Yes. Fight against this discrimination
God's sake split the country, let South unite and make a country
Go out of india.
Then tamil nadu will take most of the money and leave other states with nothing.
Why do you think andhra split from tamil nadu
@@karthika560 mannnn we need a independent financial model, autonomy and de centralization. Else this robbery won't end.
@@karthika560nope they won't when their revenue isn't as good as Karnataka's
For gods sake we don't want a separate country. I am a South Indian and don't want a separate country.
South will separate from rest of India
It's not going to happen>..
@@executorben9800Otherwise North would become poor and under developed
The United States of South India should be formed as a country as soon as possible
*Dravida Nadu*
I think we should seperate for our good future.. Words from ex patriot😢
@@rajavishnuvardhana6830 if Modi wins next election, it's the only solution.....
GST should be abolished. It is a centralised crime.
It's not about the population. Its about the number of seats for election matters. It really hurts
Number of seats is decided by population only
@@karthika560is this the punishment that we deserve for implemented the two child policy
Next delimitation is dangerous for southern states
@@karthika560so southern states who controlled population are losers
But the population and election seats are always consuming tax money instead of generating.. while south states are always generating more Tax in return gets peanuts..
South is reprimanded always in every way since independence.
Tamilnadu needs political autonomy like Madras presidency in british era. so pls reunification to united kingdom. we are not beggers to begging money from some other power center we are autonomus from 5000 years of sangam age. we built temples and forts all over southeast asia vietnam ,campodia, malasia,bali,illankai, singapore,thailand and so many countries. so we are country within country.
The Tamildoms are sovereign Independent empires for past 5000 years , why it should be under rhe rule of moguls slaves for the past 75 years
This is day light robbery
Southern states should jointly fight against this. Be careful of delimitation, which is due shortly. More damage is expected for southern states.
Yes we earn for the north India to live on our money 🤦🏻♂️ shameless government snd shame less people
This is a classical example of how the north feels proud and they are better than the south...... how genuine is their pride.
they are beggers
They don't have a shame culture even proud of wrong doing if it brings material benefit perfect social incubator for sociopaths
Thanks to the union for punishing us for the developments, population control and top of everything for gdp contribution too.
Truth
India is a federal state is there no constitutional protection for states if centre goes rogue?
@@ajaxajax2379 They're changing Constitution bro!! What are you talking about??
Actually Mrs Indira Gandhi abolished cession laws and historically speaking India is not formed due to agreement between the center and states as in USA , It is Indian presidency with princely states , I was shocked by this legal deadlock that forms when states demand federal structure and also Mr BR Ambedkar made centre more powerful than states..... speaking of population I think in this delimitation debacle , if we compare states like odisha, TN, karnataka etc their votes value is more than UP people's vote value since in their constituency more people reside than the states I mentioned above. If a structure is not fair cession is not the solution brother because from the time of independence we do not follow equality , we follow social justice that's the whole point of reservation also . I think politicians must tone down their cessionist rhetoric and should demand the center govt that how much real development happens per rupees invested in BIMARU states and should force the center to enact anti corruption measures so that these states stand on their own feet. Lastly I hate politicians who act as they care about us but politicians from their own party will go to these BIMARU states and beg for votes in name of caste and religion........ peace brother
Very rarely a news channel puts the facts. Thanks
The anchor does not want to hear the grievances of the South., He keeps interrupting.
What? I thought he should have interrupted more. They were going on an on and not talking quickly. Everything was emotional instead of factual.
@@itsover9008 what was not factual? please point out those nonfactual things you found in the video
@@stalinsampras First let's start with facts. Govt exists to take care of certain requirements of the people. Defense, energy, space, welfare, and infrastructure. Within a state, a govt will use taxes it gets from say Chennai, to develop Madurai, or Salem. There might be other regions which are poorer. It doesn't take taxes from Chennai to provide services only to Chennai because they are the only productive city in TN. It has to be assumed that TN will make bridges in Kanyakumari despite that region not making as much money.
@@stalinsampras Another fact:
Based on population and the state of population and HDI values, govts target individuals who are lower in hdi and provides them infrastructure, housing, food, free education etc. Southern states receive a relatively fair amount based on the state of all states of India. Based on the population and progress UP has seen, it deserves more. Bihar is wasting money, so I can understand if people are frustrated with Bihar. Karnataka and Tamil Nadu also waste a lot of money on freebies. If we talk about merit based tax sharing, we should also prevent all states from giving freebies. AAP and TN parties started the freebie nonsense. It will make all states bankrupt.
Why can’t the gov pay by performance of each state? I see year on year south India end in paying high tax and north leveraging south money. If UP is not performing don’t give them. Every year Gov is paying more to them
Govt job is to uplift people. It doesn’t care if you live in a Andaman or Andhra.
Each citizen of country have equal right to lead a life with dignity.
States are just for administrative convenience
@@karthika560uplift people by degrading others? Even a family doesn't support their own member who wastes money & does nothing
Yes. 18% of fund for UP alone. For tamilnadu only 4.5%. Karnataka only 3.6%. Telanagana 2%, kerala 1.9% only
@@karthika560states are not slaves of union government.
Cannot continue this loot anymore
UPLIFT UP and bihar not by looting southern states and punishing them
Central govt spending more than Rs.12000 crores for Maha kumb mela in 2025
The Central govt don't have projects in Southern India , they neglected the Chennai metro project too , same neglect for rest of the Southern States 😢
As for Mr Anurag's statement that migrant labour was responsible for growth of Hyderabad and Bangalore. Sorry this is not right. They came in search of jobs and in any way thet are not responsible for the city growth.
Its not fedaralism but favoritism
Guys we don't want separate southern country but we want better allocation of funds to our states. Let us take some steps where center doesn't have any option but to give us more allocation. Remember united we stand divided we fall.
this is the best chance you people have got 😅, try to make the best of it, don't fall for nationalism; it doesn't feed
Ok good boy now go work for North indian he is demanding his Money $làve
Options like what they're even changing the law in their favour.
South should fight for right,
For Delhi, South India is a worst enemy than Pakistan or Bangladesh.
@@shankargovindarajan7975 not only for Delhi, whole North India.
What their crime,that they contribute most tax so you can make cow piss factories?
Government gives more only to those states which are ruled by BJP. TN is largest contributor of GST and soon be a one Trillion Economy but gest only a small fraction of its GST. This is why Modiji is so worshipped in North India. North does not contribute to India's growth story. North is 50 years behind South😂😂😂😂😂
Correct Nanba but those illiterate vadakans deliberately criticize us as separates if we say the truth.
@@mrparamasivanvellala1875 THATS MODIS DOUBLE ENGINE SARKAR POLICY. LOOTING SOUTH INDIA
@@mrparamasivanvellala1875 how humiliating is that we have to beg to these north indians for funds to run our states
People from Bihar , UP, are working in southern states and take of other part of southern state s money.
what working in construction ??? bro please stay in your state dont come here
@mynameis7964 I am not interested to come to ur state and don't need. Until there is a southern prime minister
Yes, this is unfair. Let the southern states jointly fight it out. Lets look for other options...
We South Indians have only our selves to blame for this kind of pillaging of our hard earned money...People of UP, Bihar and Madhya Pradesh must laughing back at us for not standing up to our rights and the moral, cultural and linguistic obligation we have for our children. On one hand the hindi belt states never meet any of the developmental parameters and keep adding more population to push India to the unenviable rank of being the most populous nation on earth while year after year more money is pillaged from our Southern states and given to them even without formality of even asking what was the development achieved with last year's money. Now we are saddled with the next task of creating millions of employment opportunities to the uneducated, unskilled, semi-skilled, skilled people from the North at the cost of pushing our own people even out of low end jobs...create chaos on cities, use up natural resources like water and land to create even more facilities to host these people. Our children struggle to get into Schools, colleges which we had built through decades of hard work and frugal money left over after bulk of it surrendered to the North while they claim seats in our states through domicile while no South India even dream or want to settle in the hindi belt leave alone raise a family there. We under delusion of nationhood while our condition much worse than under the British...The sad part is why do we let ourselves to be ruled by uneducated, uncouth vandals from North?
This government will try to get tax money from beggar as well
The topic itself portrays south as some one a crybaby for silly things. Thats how north thinks so High of themselves..
South India is not getting fund ok.
Knowing very well about BJP's 10 years rule, Why these foolish people of Karnataka & Telangana voted for BJP in 2024.
Both states contributed 28 MPs to BJP tally.
If Karnataka & Telangana avoided voting for BJP,
Modi - Amit Shah would have been out of power.
Who the hell is MirrorNow to show bad gesture abt south indian.
South should black list MirrorNow
Truth say kal gai na Teri!
@Abhishek-wh6nn truth is... South paying more tax... Modi giving all funds to his friends and north.
Wt development is he doing in south??
For the tax we pay?
@@SanthoshKumar-gq2km yes that's what I am saying south 5 states alone is paying 48% of total India's revenue while remaining are 52% by 24 states. Your comment feels like your on north side. Supporting North am i misunderstood?
I’m from south india
We need our own country
I don’t need this central govt with ego and drama
We neeed to be separated from India
All north India people don’t come to south india
U need job ask to ur bjp govt
Don’t come to Bangalore or tamilnadu or any south states
Go back from south states North Indian people
Go back to ur state
Ask ur govt for all u needs
We just need to increase transparency in both north and south states on how the money is spend and the current financial commission allocate funds based on income distance(45%), population(15%), area(15%), forest and ecology(10%), demographic performance(12.5%), tax and fiscal efforts(2.5%) . This fundamentally rewards states with higher population and lower economic development so to make this system fairer we need to 1. Reduce weight of population and increase on economic performance and fiscal discipline 2. Increase reward for demographic control 3. Refine income distance formula with metrics like gdp per capita and HDI 4. Introduce fiscal need metrics to reward better governance and revenue 5. Revise area factor to focus on regional inequality instead of size 6. Incorporate a multi dimensional poverty index to consider factor like health and education.
We don't need have this separate south state country mindset. we fight for our freedom together and we will face the challenges together, we will grow together👫 .
We want seperate Budget for South India
Bihari peoples are escaping from state in search of job. If a state is giving big amount of tax that means the state have enough industry in Bihar. But still what development they have. Why their peoples are fleeing from there state. It's 100%Correct that the support of Central Government is not there for Southern States. But the North and east Indian people want to work and settle down in Southern states. 100% partiality is there. No doubt at all
Now to all the people who are saying there is no north south divide and no north Bias, just tell what UP government has achieved with all the tax money. Drinking Gau Muthra won't solve the state's problems. Education, better health care, better infrastructure and more jobs will be better for the citizens. But who cares. The UP Citizens are so embroiled in Hindu-Muslim agenda, caste system and all the things bad that they fail to ask their politicians good questions. No one wants develop. I am all on the side of giving north states more money. But only if they are developing.
Source about Gau mutra?
We South Indians should vote for a South Indian candidate to be the next PM👑👑👑
Correct we South peoples want south. PM that too from SC. ST OBC not Ariya like. Nirmala of Tamil Nadu
And we we north Indians thought you don't do caste politics in the south @@ganapathisamykrish5633
@@ganapathisamykrish5633 yes
Yes that's where south failed, and that's why North loots them. If the south people had given interest in centre/parliament matters and India as a whole, this wouldn't have happened. They were mostly busy with themselves.
Southern states have too many commitments, the cost of living is huge in South India, but the center is paying unfair business.
We r in bangalore, there are no proper roads, no water supply, no free garbage collection, no free street light, and we r in a bda layout 😢 and we r paying 30 pc of taxes
Tax Going to BIMARU states
@@Footballcraze1000 Select a Government for freebies, you not get a Govt capable of cleaning Garbage from the road. Jai Sidramullah.
Not federalism Central govt playing only favourlism
Next prime minister should be south Indian and finance minister should be south Indian
As an Southerner I am appalled by how the south is being discriminated against.
The person from AP had a straight face when talking of the special package to AP! Must have been very tough.
Yes this North Indian Hindi states doesn't have a big impact in boosting india economy
But still they take the big slice of cake
Our state West Bengal is also facing a similar kind of problem which the southern states are facing .
SOUTH INDIA & SOUTH INDIAN TAXES EARNINGS REVENUES WEALTH ASSETS etc.etc etc.etc etc.etc.etc etc.etc.etc etc.etc.etc etc.etc.etc etc.etc.etc are heavily generously and lavishly Looted by hindi states gujarat and some north indian states.
bharath mata ki jai
gujarat mata ki jai
hindi mata ki jai
bharath mata ki jai
EVERY STATE SHOULD GET ATLEAST 50 % OF WHAT THEY CONTRIBUTE TO THE CENTRE ....
BJP GOVERNMENTS IS SPLITTING NATION IN EVERY MANNERS , DIVIDE ANS RULE IS BJP MOTO......A PM WITH NO BACK BONE IS THE MAIN REASON .....SHAMELESS PM OF THIS CENTURY...... NO WORDS IS ENOUGH TO EXPLAIN HIS BHAKTHS TOO.....
A study must be done right from 1947 as to how much % of fund has been allocated to all the states . This must also include the discriminatory policy of Freight Equalisation and its effect on BIMARU state like Bihar+Jharkhand combined . Also the agricultural produce miney like MSP that goes to states and the Central Government funds being given for opening PSUs and other central allocation to Southern states . Probably then we can have a greater picture .
The Power and Freedom moved from different Nations of the Sub-continent to London and then moved back to New Delhi. But it never reached the place it started. Stop fighting for petty things fight to get your Power and Freedom back.
Tax collected in the state 90% to be spent in same state and only 10% to be remitted to central
The main crux is this money to each South Indian states has been lesser and lesser in each financial commissions after modi took over.
Where can I find historical data of funds allocation for all states since independence ?
I don't know why Govt is sponsoring Kumbh mela on such level. And why do govt not sponsoring the cleaning of ganga. Its just utter wastage of money.
GANGA IS IMPORTANT
Because Kumbh will being in a lot more money.
@@itsover9008 no, Kumbh will bring lots of votes.
Because of this kind of approach separate South india demand may arises
Who told you man no one don nothing we developed our own by our education and skill we bulid our own from 1995
Obviously an ugliest game by the Union Government..what’s the kind of formula for this sharing matrix?? Same as GDP statistics!!!!
Purley it's Discrimination
Bhakts - master stroke
It is not centrel government of india...its north indian government of india😢
Kudos for mirror now to bring this matter up !!!!!!
British janata party, still ruling by 'divide and rule policy' of the British
Even after pumping so much tax funds into UP, MP n Bihar, still there's no development, no industrial output, illiteracy is rampant, communal sentiments at its peak, unhygienic filthy places, no appropriate transportation cum city infrastructure.....there should be a detailed report on how these funds have been used for the past 10 years....and Modi, Shah, Nirmala. Yogi, Nitish n MP CM should be answerable to the people.
Only giving money is not producing any results
Educate them
Change your hindutva politics there
Even after giving so much money, the politicians from those BIMARU states put in their pockets. So what is the use ?
Biased news... Without listening voice of south... Nortn Indian media
Govt should stop allocating based on population...
First read freight EQUALISATION policy and impact on Bihar which made bihar to pakistan , congress took all industry to south india, still got thullu in 1991 😢😢😢
Its been 35 years😂 still u guys didnt develop😂
@monishasekar4716 ya, it takes 1 day to built industry, 2 day to flourish, 3 day to develop, 4 day to become superpower, everything got uprooted systematically, then govt got less income , so less investment with landlocked condition , made it 'NARAK' , only one it got money from govt , u got pain in a**
Whenever south makes point don't try to disconnect
One more important factor the political circles are ignoring is the GST vis a vis earlier sales tax. While sales tax is collected based on production, GST is totally consumption basis and by which the developed states have already lost significant shares of taxes. Also the centre appropriated entire portion of taxes on petroleum products by levying cess in place of excise duty, denying the states their due share by playing with numbers like higher devolution percentage of centre tax collections. One would have seen the infra expenditure in north and south in recent years. Most of the metros in north are funded by centre, whereas the south CMs are begging for support for their metros without much success.
Clearly discrimination against South is shown by the Central Govt. South is been specifically isolated because it is not favouring or voting the present Govt. based on the new wave Hindutva agenda which is dominated by the Hindi people which is the vote bank of parties and because of this, simply North gets more favourism than South. Its simply not just about supporting a family member who is in bad shape. Its getting a fair deal to continue the efforts and prosperity and growth of Southern states too, while Centre focusses on upliftment of other economically poor states. And the story of support has been going on since long long time, and South has always been supportive of upliftment and development of poor states. But inspite of that South has always been kept isolated by the Govt. But still the poor states do not seem to be turning around. And afterall South also needs to grow and develop for which they need funds and Centre support. South is always getting stepmotherly treatment and while world over, good performance is awarded, here in India the Govt. taxes South because of their good development and growth. But however hard the Govt. tries to show favouritism or try to isolate South, people of South will ensure their states develop by their hard work.
What about Gujarat and Maharashtra???
North states not improving inpite of allocating more funds...they have become no 1 in population...families on south are dividing as they end up overworking
SHAMELESS NORTH STATES- The moment we South states ask for rights. The talk about about unity and patriotism. South Indian states states keeps quite then North States Force HINDI on South States. When some people From South states tried Learning HINDI, North Indians Make FUN, sterotype of South Indian Hindia accent as if HINDI is a some superior Language and all South indians are dying to learn it.
REMEMBER- SOUTH INDIA FEEEDS North INDIANS states , BIMARU states. North Indian states should start showing some gratitude to south Indian states.
If this continues ,I doubt if south states will be part of India in Future.
Should raise our voice ...
By former FM Chidambaram's estimate If South India was separate Dravidian country during partition now it would have been a middle income country like Malaysia instead has to feed ungrateful people who hate you
They never treat the southerners like their own people and then call them antinationaIs
All the southern people's taxes is being painted by panmasala all over North India...😂😂
Why every investment going to 6 metros when Tire 2 cities are not growing.
Look the Scoundrel North Indian Godimedia even not giving enough time to south people to speak
Debt not reduced, subsides lifted, Crude price came down, Excise duty on oil products increased ,no price cut down on Petrol , Diesel, LPG. Oil bonds not repaid, Cheap Crude from Russia, Debt from IMO increased, 3.5 Lakh Cr taken out from RBI reserves, collection from GST with 5 slabs increasing year by year. Tax on LTCG and STCG increased....Still struggling to maintain economy and Rupee value . This Govt Run by Propaganda and Media.. no real economists in cabinet. One man show. Where is all this money being pumped out? No one dare to ask. Our bad fate. 😢 we dont know when we get rid of 😢😢
Why she is funding more to UP and other states compared to South India... more migrants from north to south only. She should consider local state govt managing migrants as well.
The government should see the remarks made by the people.....
North states like bihar, Up etc not improving because centre invests in them...southern states people work hard and northern states eat all the money..shame on people..if population is the problem try to control it