Get busy living or get busy dying (do your part to save the scene and stop going to shows) I’ve got a dark alley and a bad idea that says you should shut your mouth (summer song) I love telling people the full titles of them because they’re like “wtf” its my favorite thing.
Yeah the transition between But It's Better if You Do and I write Sins Not Tragedies didn't work because of Spotify. Every other time I've listened to it it flowed perfectly
Lottie yo i love this music but i appreciate his honesty. i’m sick of the reviewers that are just the cookie cutter “i enjoyed this. don’t kill me.” i’m glad that he is truthful.
i personally really like this type of music, so im interested in hearing what others think of it. i admit i do actually like a few of the songs he trashed, but i try my beat to respect others opinions. and honestly, i can see why he didnt like them.
This is one of my favorite albums...with that said I do also get a lot of his criticism too concerning some of the production choices, and lyrically there's a lot to parse through, and without those two things? Yeah it'd kinda just be by the numbers mid-2000s pop punk (that Auto tune bit during 'Nails' was great bee tee dubs)
@Wydoz Yee it was made to hurt tho. this album did not take itself seriously at all. and the first 2 songs let the listener know, and then nails and tacks makes sure everyone knows that he doesnt care at all
@@ThaDarkSavior There is a certain point in which just making something awful for the sake of making it awful in the middle of the album isn't acceptable. We listen to albums to feel emotion, not to feel sick.
“But It’s Better If You Do” DOES transition perfectly into “I Write Sins Not Tragedies” Spotify just has an issue with the transition depending on your sound system
I appreciate these reactions so much, even if they're negative. I'm glad you don't pander to the emos and that your reactions are genuine. This is one of my favorite music channels now because our tastes are pretty wildly different and it's really interesting to watch an "outsider" listen to music from my early childhood.
Yeah he's improved a lot over the years. One thing I will say is it may have just been the singing on this album (which I don't think is terrible just average), because he sounded pretty great on Live in Denver in my opinion.
Clifford LeDuc Vaillancourt well clifford, when i listen to it on apple music, there is a perfect transition unless there is an internet issue, then it lags slightly, it usually blends perfectly
Brendon Urie did not write this album, you were misinformed by someone idfk but he wasn't writing yet at this point lmao. You can thank the 2 boys who quit Panic! for this record. Who left due to creative differences funny enough
Actually it's just Ryan Ross. Jon Walker wasn’t in the band until about a year after this album. And if you’re referring to Brent Wilson, he was kicked out and he didn’t have any creative power.
I'm pretty sure that for this album they had literally no money for this album and that they had kids to do some instruments because they couldn't get professionals.
Basically the album is split in two halves with the First Half being Dance/Electronic/Pop-Punk and the Second Half being Theatrical/Vaudeville/Pop-Punk. I much prefer the second half and wish the whole album was like this tbh
I mean like, certain people that I’ve seen are like “this album didn’t give me as much passion and explosiveness as the black parade.” And I’m like yeah, that’s because it’s not going for the same thing, not every album needs to sound like mcr.
smellykid83 He’s probably going to listen to them all sooner or later. He did it with twenty one pilots and he hated a good chunk of that. He wants to get caught up with Panic! before the new album drops
Try the second album (Pretty Odd.) if you’re sick with the thin & annoying electronic sound + repetitive patterns of AFYCSO. Tbh AFYCSO is more like a hit or miss album. In my opinion, PO has the diversity, better sound, and lyrics overall. It has this 60s The Beatles vibes to it. Some people like it some don’t. I do like it tho. I think it’s their best album yet Maybe give it a shot?
Lemoboi Memes agreed, they were extremely influenced by the Beatles at the time, especially Ryan I suppose. That’s why I said PO has the Beatles vibe lol But I still love that album, while it’s not the most original but imo it’s the most fun album they have ever made. Plus the writings are great, i love the mood & the atmosphere. Definitely has better production overall, the sound is amazing, i love all the different instruments they used on that album. Also there are some “little” songs (I have friends in holy spaces, etc) in between “major” fast paced songs like Nine in the Afternoon, The Green Gentlemen, Mad as Rabbit. But yeah it’s my opinion
I actually heard some Kinks and Zombies as well. Also, the piano at the beginning at "Nine In The Afternoon" reminded me of ELO, particularly the intro to "Mr. Blue Sky".
@@jabe3167 i know! man I love it beginning to end. I've never found it to be bad in any way, tbh the autotune has never leaped out as being horrible because it's just how the track is unashamedly constructed. Just gives me complete joy and a vibe of being a carefree teenager and falling in love with this album.
I’m so confused. Haven’t watched the video yet, just reading the comments rn.. I thought everyone loved this album? Fever’s still a masterpiece and fantastic debut imo.
This album is my favorite album. I love all it's flaws,the rawness in it, the edge, the weirdness whatever you call it. I frickin love how Ryan Ross pour all his favorite books and his personal problems in it. That thing is really speacial for me.
THEIR BEST ALBUM IS PRETTY ODD and it’s weird but it makes me cry Ryan Ross is a beautiful writer and that’s why I love panic 😭😭😭😭 This album wasn’t made by Brendon it was mostly composed by Ryan and he used to be an edgy boi lol but after this album they made a kind of baroque album and I cried every time But Ryan left now so rip
Tbh I love Pretty. Odd. but I feel like Brad is gonna hate it. Also in my opinion V&V is their best album but I still love P. O. with all my heart. Also Ryan Ross one of the best writers don't @ me
Introduction - 2:24 The Only Difference Between Martyrdom And Suicide Is Press Coverage - 3:02 London Beckoned Songs About Money Written By Machines - 6:51 Nails For Breakfast, Tacks For Snacks - 11:45 Camisado - 14:18 Time To Dance - 17:15 Lying Is The Most Fun A Girl Can Have Without Taking Her Clothes Off - 20:43 Intermission - 24:33 But It’s Better If You Do - 25:30 I Write Sins, Not Tragedies - 28:00 I Constantly Thank God For Esteban - 28:46 There’s A Reason These Tables Are Numbered Honey, You Just Haven’t Thought Of It Yet - 31:31 Build God, Then We’ll Talk - 32:21
Oh my god, thank you for this, Brad! I get that you're totally pandering to us, but this was fantastic. I haven't even finished watching, but you just brought out the Eminem cover and I can't stop laughing. Even with the minimal edits, it doesn't feel like a compromise in quality analytical review + entertainment. And Nails for Breakfast is a song I really like...this autotune _does_ make it nails on chalkboard, but the lyrics are literally about the lyricist's alcoholic father. Anyway, I love that you immediately picked on the theater vibe and your rating signs. Your breakdowns are interesting to hear as always. Now let me get back to you roasting my musical taste.
yea i loved this video but the only thing i hated was that the songs he liked were the songs with the most obvious lyrics. to understand these songs you cant just say "what is he talking about this is bad" i get why he thinks the electronics sound bad but ryan has some incredible lyrics in both pretty odd and afycso and im sitting there watching this like stopppppp read the lyrics you cant just hear them and understand it.
I can't understand why Tøp, Fob, and panic are more popular than MCR when the quality of MCR's music is a different level than the rest of the "emo" bands it honestly pisses me off
It’s alright you didn’t like the album. Either you love or hate this album. There really isn’t a middle ground. I acknowledge that the album is a total mess and there’s a few bad songs (Nails for breakfast). But I really do think it has it’s charm. The anxious, chaotic and sarcastic feel of the album really reflect my teenage years, and this album is exactly that. It’s a rollercoaster with fun choruses, dark guitar solos, a theatric/shallow look and critical lyrics. It perfectly portraits a certain feel and emotion. If you don’t get that, I can see how the album would be pretty pretentious. For me the album is therefore a solid 8 out of 10. I enjoyed the video as always and look forward to hearing more from you. Btw. my favorite P!ATD album is “Pretty. Odd.”. It’s a total change of pace, and I would recommend it.
Unfortunately this has less to do with your comment and more with a personal taste of mine. I actually really like Nails for Breakfast. The autotune is very purposefully overdone to instill a sort of weird and disgusted feeling in the listener. This makes sense, as the song is about taking pills
Yeah. Ryan is an amazing songwriter, but Brendon's vocals on afycso didn't do them all justice. He's got better over time. His voice was already so much better on Pretty.Odd.
i knew he'd have that exact reaction with nails for breakfast tacks for snacks, i had the same reaction the first time too, i was like 'what in the tarnation is this garbage?', but after listening to the album for the next 13 years of my life i hardly notice the autotune
That song, I really wished they didn’t use it. If they use it for just, “speech is slurred” or something for affect not appeal. I agree, Brendons voice is somewhat annoying in some songs and obviously he was young when they recorded this and he is definitely a respectable singer now, his live vocals now are ridiculous and he can hit insane notes. There’s only like 2 songs I don’t really like on this album but overall it’s a pretty good album. If they (😬) re-recorded this album now, it would be really good. Same with MCR’s bullets album.
OP Gaming Yeah, same (Vices in my fav) but it was funny watching his reaction bra use my friends have the same reaction But I really don't care, I still really like this album (Vices and Pretty. Odd. are better tho)
I've never commented before, but I have to express how much I appreciate the depth of your analyses. I subscribed when you released your "The Black Parade" review and, since then, have really enjoyed the videos you make--especially when they include so-called "emo" bands. The time and effort that you put into your videos are obvious, especially in the edits, and it really means a lot. It's very difficult to find somebody that will delve so deeply into the lyrics and instrumentals of a specific album. I understand that you didn't do that as much for this video, and I completely understand. I don't particularly care for this album myself, although I recognize that, in time, Panic! has greatly improved. I know that you're into explosive music, and I feel like you would genuinely enjoy Black Veil Brides. I know that it takes lots of time and energy to review an entire album, so I would recommend listening to "The Last One" and either "Wake Up" or "The Outsider". These are off their newest album Vale, and all of them contain awesome instrumental solos. I honestly think you would love them, and keep up the amazing work! You are the best reviewer that I have seen, and I hope you continue the awesome analysis and edits. Thanks for yet another great video!
jusosa Everybody has their own opinion. Personally, I view Andy's voice as very good--it has a surprisingly deep, rough tone, which one wouldn't expect from first looking at him. But, that's my personal opinion, and you aren't required to agree with that.
Idk what happened to the translation with but it’s better if you do and I write sins but it should of been a smooth transition I mean it’s always been that way when I’ve listened to the album
I’m real nervous because this is my favorite album of all time 😤 edit: nails for breakfast is my favorite song 😂 nails, camisado, and time to dance are my three favorites I’m and I think it’s better to watch live in denver
I am beginning to understand how the Twenty One Pilots fans felt. But hey at least you liked Build God, Then We’ll Talk which is my favorite song on the album. I will say that some of the production and vocals on this album aren’t the best, but I’m more of a lyric oriented listener so I can look past that type of thing. I’d say Too Weird To Live, Too Rare To Die, does the electronic sound much better, and you might actually enjoy that album. Well, agree to disagree, still respect your opinion and hey on the bright side you might like the new album cause I’m pretty sure it’s going to be nothing like this😂
We guys getting bullied or hated because of the music we like for years and are you taking the same fucking attitude towards something you barely know? Seriously? That's fucking bullshit right there. Educate yourself please man. The thing you called "kpoop" kpop is a genre which amazing people put so much effort, emotion and their blood, sweat and tears to give something amazing. It's okay if you don't like it. It's okay if you don't want him to react that. But don't phrase that in that manner. They don't deserve that. Don't spread hate towards something you just basically didn't like.
@@ayblablabla Aybala Tuana Uslu Hey it's been over a year and I probably wouldn't make that joke again (mostly bc in retrospect its not that funny) but also like. Kpop isn't the only genre I (or others) make fun of so I don't quite understand why it's alright to make lighthearted jokes about hating country, dubstep, ect but me making fun of kpop somehow crosses a line. I dislike the industry and I really don't vibe with most popular groups but I respect the artists for what they do and I think they're all very talented people. Sorry if it came off as overly malicious but like. it was a poop joke? On the internet? No one's gonna see my comment and start a kpop hate blog.
@@henryk539 good point. People are ok with absolutely shitting on dubstep and country (mostly country) and no one bats an eye despite there being plenty of great artists in the genres. But as soon as someone even dares to criticize let alone make fun of kpop all the sudden God has come down to smite thy ass because your not allowed to make fun of kpop.. I get that kpop fans don’t like being made fun of but they do seem very comfortable making fun of other genres as well. Kpop much like country and dubstep also has some generic aspects to it which should not be free from criticism. Kpop is just like every other genre of music and if people are too sensitive that just making fun of it requires a apology, then it adds an even worse assumption about kpop fans then before (since kpop stans don’t have a great track record of being generally liked on the internet)
Hey Brad! Thank you for the honest review. I enjoyed your take on it and you made very valid points. I love this album, but I understand some aspects of it are very niche. I was one of the people who suggested it, sorry about that lol. Still, it made for really good entertainment.
I also wanted to add, this was made when the members were all still in high school, and Ryan Ross wrote most of the lyrics and composed most of the album. The reason you like the new stuff more, is probably because you prefer Brendon Urie's writing to Ryan's. Ryan left the band after the second album, Pretty. Odd. Their second album is entirely different from anything they've ever done. If you intend to check out their whole discography, wipe away everything you know about the band. Whether or not that's a good thing? That's entirely up to you.
This is my favorite Panic! at the Disco album. I like a lot of their music (not including the last two albums). It’s interesting to see how much opinions on music can vary. Everything is subjective and that’s really cool.
You're either gonna find Pretty Odd to be a beautiful return to form or it'll bore the shit outta ya It is their best album and doesn't do all theae attempts at flashy
Have you considered the bad auto tune was on purpose? And that like the previous song it was making a really obvious statement about the state of pop music around the time it was released? Just an idea.
i feel like they could do this but still execute it better. like, they could do autotune for a bit and then stop for the rest of the song. its a statement but the message gets convoluted because jesus fucking CHRIST its sonically unbearable
Istg I used to be the biggest fucking fan of patd and even then I didn’t stand nails for breakfast, tacks for snacks. I never understood why that song even existed
Time To Dance is actually a song about a Chuck Palahniuk book called Invisible Monsters. This album also isn't for everyone. It has a theatrical baroque pop/cabaret feel to it.
I wish you took a proper break after Nails. You can see your frustrations bled through the following tracks. Should've just left it for a couple days and come back to it
it's so funny to me how he calls the lyrics 'pretentious' and says he didn't hear that in the newer stuff bc this is all ryan ross' stuff, it was his band, his idea, hell, brendon wasn't even supposed to sing, and everyone constantly says that panic! went to shit when ryan and jon left, i like to differ but people always attack me for it
I've just discovered you today, so I'm late. But as a huge Panic! fan I appreciate your honesty. A lot of other review channels sugarcoat their reviews on popular things but you don't and I love it. It annoys me that a lot of people in the fandom try to defend every single thing that Brendon creates. Even he himself knows his first album was unprofessional sounding. They were just starting out and didn't really know what they were doing. I like to just pick out the songs in the album I like and skip out on the others entirely. I love listening to him sing his older songs live because he has developed his vocals enough to give the lyrics the recognition they deserve.
You think those song titles are long? Have you seen pre hiatus Fall Out Boy?
Ryan Ross not yet he didn't
Hahahahaha, imagine him seeing Under The Cork Tree
Ryan Ross no but I got cheez whiz
Get busy living or get busy dying (do your part to save the scene and stop going to shows)
I’ve got a dark alley and a bad idea that says you should shut your mouth (summer song)
I love telling people the full titles of them because they’re like “wtf” its my favorite thing.
he needs to react to some pre hiatus fall out boy
Yeah the transition between But It's Better if You Do and I write Sins Not Tragedies didn't work because of Spotify. Every other time I've listened to it it flowed perfectly
Wist yea
idk if it's a new setting or something but now you can choose the transition to be smoother
Build god is the most underrated panic song
Why is it underrated? I mean, I thought it was at the same level than I Write Sins Not Tragedies, since it also has a music video.
Lautaro Bosques definitely more complex than every song on this album
Lautaro Bosques I think it’s a little deeper (lol sounds pretentious)
I love the opening verse, it sounds amazing
Fujihara San uh, no, basically any song from Pretty. Odd. is underrated
People constantly beg for these emo album reactions but whine about it when you actually make them and give your honest opinions? You cant win
Lottie yo i love this music but i appreciate his honesty. i’m sick of the reviewers that are just the cookie cutter “i enjoyed this. don’t kill me.” i’m glad that he is truthful.
i personally really like this type of music, so im interested in hearing what others think of it. i admit i do actually like a few of the songs he trashed, but i try my beat to respect others opinions. and honestly, i can see why he didnt like them.
This is one of my favorite albums...with that said I do also get a lot of his criticism too concerning some of the production choices, and lyrically there's a lot to parse through, and without those two things? Yeah it'd kinda just be by the numbers mid-2000s pop punk (that Auto tune bit during 'Nails' was great bee tee dubs)
Fr I love this album but I like his honesty
I love hearing him get upset at this shit. Its hilarious to me
I know it's not an excuse, but they were 17 when they made this album
Mr. Sax-O-Beat Actually they were almost 20 yo. Wtf
Not an excuse
no. they were 16 when they made the album
lorde was 16 when she wrote and released pure heroine and it won two grammys
Mardy bum really?? Didn't know that. I only listened to Melodrama, but I might listen to it
I love how actually pissed and disgusted he got at nails for breakfast
@Wydoz Yee it was made to hurt tho. this album did not take itself seriously at all. and the first 2 songs let the listener know, and then nails and tacks makes sure everyone knows that he doesnt care at all
god fever is my favorite album but nails is my absolute most HATED song from Panic!. it is atrocious. an absolute m e s s
syd I love that song very underrated
the autotune is so screwed up because its supposed to represent the terrible sound of nails or some shit
@@ThaDarkSavior There is a certain point in which just making something awful for the sake of making it awful in the middle of the album isn't acceptable. We listen to albums to feel emotion, not to feel sick.
“But It’s Better If You Do” DOES transition perfectly into “I Write Sins Not Tragedies” Spotify just has an issue with the transition depending on your sound system
I appreciate these reactions so much, even if they're negative. I'm glad you don't pander to the emos and that your reactions are genuine. This is one of my favorite music channels now because our tastes are pretty wildly different and it's really interesting to watch an "outsider" listen to music from my early childhood.
Evan Brown I laughed so hard and I think the album is fun and quirky
yea even brendon thinks his singing on this album was trash. he went from noob to pro level in like 8 years
PartyPotPie kinky boots helped him too
Isah Lol no WAYYY before Kinky Boots
Clifford LeDuc Vaillancourt ik but kinky boots def helped him
Yeah he's improved a lot over the years. One thing I will say is it may have just been the singing on this album (which I don't think is terrible just average), because he sounded pretty great on Live in Denver in my opinion.
PLAY OF THE GAME: Brendon as NOT COMPLETE TRASH
THISSSS IMPOSSIBLLLE YEARRRRRRRRRRRRRR
IDK ON WHAT U LISTENED THIS BUT IT USUALLY BLENDS PERFECTLY BETWEEN BUT ITS BETTER IF YOU DO AND SINS
ikr!
No. There is a pause between the two songs! Blending is when it's a perfect transition
Clifford LeDuc Vaillancourt on the cd its a seamless transition i have this album on cd.
djk6516 Ok but Brad listened to it on Spotify so no, the transition isn’t perfect.
Clifford LeDuc Vaillancourt well clifford, when i listen to it on apple music, there is a perfect transition unless there is an internet issue, then it lags slightly, it usually blends perfectly
Brendon Urie did not write this album, you were misinformed by someone idfk but he wasn't writing yet at this point lmao. You can thank the 2 boys who quit Panic! for this record. Who left due to creative differences funny enough
Yeah I don't think Brendon started really writing them til Vices & Virtues right?
Actually it's just Ryan Ross. Jon Walker wasn’t in the band until about a year after this album. And if you’re referring to Brent Wilson, he was kicked out and he didn’t have any creative power.
Beshkno M. wow so you're just shitting on Ross
Tayo Odebunmi th-cam.com/video/MUdvybUPJ4w/w-d-xo.html
Best thing he's ever done but hasn't released it so he's still the worst smh
Beshkno M. I was just saying what you said you didn't want people to say 😂 I'm not being serious
I'm pretty sure that for this album they had literally no money for this album and that they had kids to do some instruments because they couldn't get professionals.
Kieron Kipling Yup, that DID happen
Basically the album is split in two halves with the First Half being Dance/Electronic/Pop-Punk and the Second Half being Theatrical/Vaudeville/Pop-Punk. I much prefer the second half and wish the whole album was like this tbh
It sucks that people compare this to MCR
Yeah, other albums don’t sound like the black Parade because ITS NOT THE BLACK PARADE
x.on.the.calender Bullets is better than TBP tho
No, you just like it more.
AM Trash not to hate on Bullets but you could not be more wrong
I mean like, certain people that I’ve seen are like “this album didn’t give me as much passion and explosiveness as the black parade.” And I’m like yeah, that’s because it’s not going for the same thing, not every album needs to sound like mcr.
you hear that? that the sound of jon from artv crying
I guess Brad’s personal hell is tacks for snacks on repeat
From your tweets, and due to the fact that I’ve listened to the album already, I am SO ready for these comments 😁😂
The Tune Up ayyyy Love your channel bro
D3ATH R0W99 much love!! 😊❤️🙏🏾
Dude your channel is amazing
First Name Last Name too kind! 😭❤️🙏🏾 thank you!!
The Tune Up Never visited your channel, is it worth popping over?
he emo now, there's no way he can go back
*chanting*:
pREtty oDD PretTy oDD preTTTY OdD
You know he's gonna hate Pretty Odd just like the Tune Up did. He's gonna call it 'trying too hard to be the Beatles'
smellykid83 He’s probably going to listen to them all sooner or later. He did it with twenty one pilots and he hated a good chunk of that. He wants to get caught up with Panic! before the new album drops
he's gonna hate it lol
Yuck delete your profile pic we don’t want him here
Virginia J. Same lol 😂😂😂
London beckoned song about money writ-write-wri-
wHy?
Try the second album (Pretty Odd.) if you’re sick with the thin & annoying electronic sound + repetitive patterns of AFYCSO. Tbh AFYCSO is more like a hit or miss album.
In my opinion, PO has the diversity, better sound, and lyrics overall. It has this 60s The Beatles vibes to it. Some people like it some don’t. I do like it tho. I think it’s their best album yet
Maybe give it a shot?
Satrio Barselino Beatles “vibe”? I love that album and I’m not even a panic fan, but Brendon himself has said they ripped off the Beatles.
Lemoboi Memes agreed, they were extremely influenced by the Beatles at the time, especially Ryan I suppose. That’s why I said PO has the Beatles vibe lol
But I still love that album, while it’s not the most original but imo it’s the most fun album they have ever made. Plus the writings are great, i love the mood & the atmosphere. Definitely has better production overall, the sound is amazing, i love all the different instruments they used on that album. Also there are some “little” songs (I have friends in holy spaces, etc) in between “major” fast paced songs like Nine in the Afternoon, The Green Gentlemen, Mad as Rabbit.
But yeah it’s my opinion
He hated PO too
...my favourite album is fever... but then again p.o is hell underrated
I actually heard some Kinks and Zombies as well. Also, the piano at the beginning at "Nine In The Afternoon" reminded me of ELO, particularly the intro to "Mr. Blue Sky".
didn’t expect you to like Tacks For Snacks!
. Why
He has brad taste in music that's why
am I the only one who actually likes the autotune in it and the whole song?
@@jabe3167 i know! man I love it beginning to end. I've never found it to be bad in any way, tbh the autotune has never leaped out as being horrible because it's just how the track is unashamedly constructed. Just gives me complete joy and a vibe of being a carefree teenager and falling in love with this album.
I’m so confused. Haven’t watched the video yet, just reading the comments rn.. I thought everyone loved this album? Fever’s still a masterpiece and fantastic debut imo.
Brittany Butler yeah
i feel the same... kinda feeling betrayed because i never knew so many people don't like afycso haha
Fr why does everyone hate it
Lol no
I think afycso is only hated by newer fans *cough* pftw fans *cough* (sorry for my bad english(?)
This album is my favorite album. I love all it's flaws,the rawness in it, the edge, the weirdness whatever you call it. I frickin love how Ryan Ross pour all his favorite books and his personal problems in it. That thing is really speacial for me.
I agree
THEIR BEST ALBUM IS PRETTY ODD and it’s weird but it makes me cry
Ryan Ross is a beautiful writer and that’s why I love panic 😭😭😭😭
This album wasn’t made by Brendon it was mostly composed by Ryan and he used to be an edgy boi lol but after this album they made a kind of baroque album and I cried every time
But Ryan left now so rip
Ryan Ross vices and virtues
boreddonut LMAOOOO all the weed taken in pretty odd era I’m-
Tbh I love Pretty. Odd. but I feel like Brad is gonna hate it. Also in my opinion V&V is their best album but I still love P. O. with all my heart. Also Ryan Ross one of the best writers don't @ me
Nah Too Weird to Live, Too Rare to Die is their best one.
sopranoshelley You know that's not true no one likes Too Weird To Live it's a shitty fucking album. On Pretty. Odd. ALL the songs are good
Introduction - 2:24
The Only Difference Between Martyrdom And Suicide Is Press Coverage - 3:02
London Beckoned Songs About Money Written By Machines - 6:51
Nails For Breakfast, Tacks For Snacks - 11:45
Camisado - 14:18
Time To Dance - 17:15
Lying Is The Most Fun A Girl Can Have Without Taking Her Clothes Off - 20:43
Intermission - 24:33
But It’s Better If You Do - 25:30
I Write Sins, Not Tragedies - 28:00
I Constantly Thank God For Esteban - 28:46
There’s A Reason These Tables Are Numbered Honey, You Just Haven’t Thought Of It Yet - 31:31
Build God, Then We’ll Talk - 32:21
Thanks
Legend
''Now I'm of consenting age''
''Congrats''
Always get me
Most vocal coaches did not think Panic would not get very far.
Oh my god, thank you for this, Brad! I get that you're totally pandering to us, but this was fantastic. I haven't even finished watching, but you just brought out the Eminem cover and I can't stop laughing.
Even with the minimal edits, it doesn't feel like a compromise in quality analytical review + entertainment.
And Nails for Breakfast is a song I really like...this autotune _does_ make it nails on chalkboard, but the lyrics are literally about the lyricist's alcoholic father.
Anyway, I love that you immediately picked on the theater vibe and your rating signs. Your breakdowns are interesting to hear as always. Now let me get back to you roasting my musical taste.
My thoughts exactly.
yea i loved this video but the only thing i hated was that the songs he liked were the songs with the most obvious lyrics. to understand these songs you cant just say "what is he talking about this is bad" i get why he thinks the electronics sound bad but ryan has some incredible lyrics in both pretty odd and afycso and im sitting there watching this like stopppppp read the lyrics you cant just hear them and understand it.
i love afycso and this is exactly how i feel haha
ikr
@@maxduvall9055 yess
You can't be an edgy 14 year old listening to panic at the disco without reminding everyone you have social anxiety at least 3 times a day
Comment sponsored by: Twitter
I can't understand why Tøp, Fob, and panic are more popular than MCR when the quality of MCR's music is a different level than the rest of the "emo" bands it honestly pisses me off
Ray Summers main reason is cause those three actually still make music
In a way, it's better that way. At least that's what I think. 😊
Well you know, those other three bands are still making music so.😂
YES, THANK YOU
Mcr is just another level it can’t be compared, not that I don’t like panic or fob but mcr is just beauty
It’s alright you didn’t like the album. Either you love or hate this album. There really isn’t a middle ground. I acknowledge that the album is a total mess and there’s a few bad songs (Nails for breakfast). But I really do think it has it’s charm. The anxious, chaotic and sarcastic feel of the album really reflect my teenage years, and this album is exactly that. It’s a rollercoaster with fun choruses, dark guitar solos, a theatric/shallow look and critical lyrics. It perfectly portraits a certain feel and emotion. If you don’t get that, I can see how the album would be pretty pretentious.
For me the album is therefore a solid 8 out of 10. I enjoyed the video as always and look forward to hearing more from you.
Btw. my favorite P!ATD album is “Pretty. Odd.”. It’s a total change of pace, and I would recommend it.
Unfortunately this has less to do with your comment and more with a personal taste of mine. I actually really like Nails for Breakfast. The autotune is very purposefully overdone to instill a sort of weird and disgusted feeling in the listener. This makes sense, as the song is about taking pills
I don't get why everybody hate ls Nails for Breakfast so much... It's supposed to be overdone. Personally, I love it.
He hated PO
Just Your Friendly Neighborhood Fan exactly. the over-autotune is done on purpose to amplify the message of the song
This comment.
you should definitely reach to folie a deux by fall out boy
Y e s thats my favorite fob album lol
Reptile kid same
Best album FOB has made.
PLEASE please!!!
Stop saying Brendon. Stop saying Brendon. Stop saying Brendon. He did not write any of this.
Yeah. Ryan is an amazing songwriter, but Brendon's vocals on afycso didn't do them all justice. He's got better over time. His voice was already so much better on Pretty.Odd.
it doesn't matter who wrote it, what matters is the quality
plus he didn't know too much going into this
Brendon was 17. Brendon was 17. Brendon was 17. Brendon was 17.
@@crispysalads you can't take other people's opinions. his age doesn't make the music any better.
PhantomKing88 repeating something several times doesn’t make it any more correct
i knew he'd have that exact reaction with nails for breakfast tacks for snacks, i had the same reaction the first time too, i was like 'what in the tarnation is this garbage?', but after listening to the album for the next 13 years of my life i hardly notice the autotune
Andrea Marcano same lol
That song, I really wished they didn’t use it. If they use it for just, “speech is slurred” or something for affect not appeal. I agree, Brendons voice is somewhat annoying in some songs and obviously he was young when they recorded this and he is definitely a respectable singer now, his live vocals now are ridiculous and he can hit insane notes. There’s only like 2 songs I don’t really like on this album but overall it’s a pretty good album. If they (😬) re-recorded this album now, it would be really good. Same with MCR’s bullets album.
Ok so all you need is 13 years, not bad
have you heard of the medical phenomenon known as Stockholm syndrome.
It's funny because I actually love this album 🤷🏽♀️
OP Gaming Yeah, same (Vices in my fav) but it was funny watching his reaction bra use my friends have the same reaction
But I really don't care, I still really like this album (Vices and Pretty. Odd. are better tho)
OP Gaming Finally found someone
I just realized I made so many mistakes I'm so sorry dafqu I'm usually on people's back for grammar and spelling but I fucked up so much here. Damn
This is my favorite panic! album... I don't know why, I guess it's just a classic.
Me too
Sooo... are you ever gonna review From Under The Cork Tree...?
I've never commented before, but I have to express how much I appreciate the depth of your analyses. I subscribed when you released your "The Black Parade" review and, since then, have really enjoyed the videos you make--especially when they include so-called "emo" bands. The time and effort that you put into your videos are obvious, especially in the edits, and it really means a lot. It's very difficult to find somebody that will delve so deeply into the lyrics and instrumentals of a specific album. I understand that you didn't do that as much for this video, and I completely understand. I don't particularly care for this album myself, although I recognize that, in time, Panic! has greatly improved. I know that you're into explosive music, and I feel like you would genuinely enjoy Black Veil Brides. I know that it takes lots of time and energy to review an entire album, so I would recommend listening to "The Last One" and either "Wake Up" or "The Outsider". These are off their newest album Vale, and all of them contain awesome instrumental solos. I honestly think you would love them, and keep up the amazing work! You are the best reviewer that I have seen, and I hope you continue the awesome analysis and edits. Thanks for yet another great video!
I can't wait till he shits on BVD's obvious auto tune, instrumentally they are good but the vocalist sucks
jusosa
Everybody has their own opinion. Personally, I view Andy's voice as very good--it has a surprisingly deep, rough tone, which one wouldn't expect from first looking at him. But, that's my personal opinion, and you aren't required to agree with that.
jusosa Yeah, autotune ruins that band.
He definitely won’t like BVB.
I'd be interested to see him react to BVB
Hm, I love this album but you did not. And I can see where you're coming from. I feel like you'd like Too Weird to Live Too Rare to Die more
First Name Last Name no he won't hah
He didn't like it
Hated it.
Your honesty is so damn refreshing. We need more people like you in the world.
We've awakened his regressed emo. O H N O
Your Mom But he hated the record
Could you react to the trilogy music videos of P!ATD?
Order: 1. Say Amen (Saturday Night)
2. This is Gospel
3. Emperor's new clothes
Watching this while sitting under my huge ass poster of the album cover.. oops
bruh same
goals
Literally same
Same
ryan ross is a musical genius 🗣️🗣️
SO TRUE
SAY IY LOUDER 🔊🔊
I CANT STOP LAUGHING TO HIS REACTION TO NAILS FOR BREAKFAST TACKS FOR SNACKS I CANT BREATHE HAHAHAHAHAHA
Sitting here waiting for the bus and then u upload
If I miss my bus it’s your fault
Toxic May that’s not how busses work.
autotuned brad sounds like blink-182
SHIT FOR BREAKFAST 12:49 - TIME TO DIE 19:06
Idk what happened to the translation with but it’s better if you do and I write sins but it should of been a smooth transition I mean it’s always been that way when I’ve listened to the album
RyanPlzComeBack WhyAmIHereAgain he listens on spotify which doesn't have simless transitions
TheSroolik Weird, it transitions well for me.
it depends on your settings
I’m real nervous because this is my favorite album of all time 😤 edit: nails for breakfast is my favorite song 😂 nails, camisado, and time to dance are my three favorites I’m and I think it’s better to watch live in denver
Evans weefee he hates it lol
Evans weefee I actually love nails for breakfast
syd me too, and the auto tune was a creative choice for the song. It wasn't in demo which is my favorite version of the song.
Camisado, lying, and there's a good reason are my favorites
Evans weefee Ur 14 right? or 13
I am beginning to understand how the Twenty One Pilots fans felt. But hey at least you liked Build God, Then We’ll Talk which is my favorite song on the album. I will say that some of the production and vocals on this album aren’t the best, but I’m more of a lyric oriented listener so I can look past that type of thing. I’d say Too Weird To Live, Too Rare To Die, does the electronic sound much better, and you might actually enjoy that album. Well, agree to disagree, still respect your opinion and hey on the bright side you might like the new album cause I’m pretty sure it’s going to be nothing like this😂
Please don't start doing kpoop reactions. I'm begging.
me too jesus christ I don't want to see that
kpoop lmaooooo and i agree🙌
We guys getting bullied or hated because of the music we like for years and are you taking the same fucking attitude towards something you barely know? Seriously? That's fucking bullshit right there. Educate yourself please man. The thing you called "kpoop" kpop is a genre which amazing people put so much effort, emotion and their blood, sweat and tears to give something amazing. It's okay if you don't like it. It's okay if you don't want him to react that. But don't phrase that in that manner. They don't deserve that. Don't spread hate towards something you just basically didn't like.
@@ayblablabla Aybala Tuana Uslu Hey it's been over a year and I probably wouldn't make that joke again (mostly bc in retrospect its not that funny) but also like. Kpop isn't the only genre I (or others) make fun of so I don't quite understand why it's alright to make lighthearted jokes about hating country, dubstep, ect but me making fun of kpop somehow crosses a line. I dislike the industry and I really don't vibe with most popular groups but I respect the artists for what they do and I think they're all very talented people. Sorry if it came off as overly malicious but like. it was a poop joke? On the internet? No one's gonna see my comment and start a kpop hate blog.
@@henryk539 good point. People are ok with absolutely shitting on dubstep and country (mostly country) and no one bats an eye despite there being plenty of great artists in the genres. But as soon as someone even dares to criticize let alone make fun of kpop all the sudden God has come down to smite thy ass because your not allowed to make fun of kpop.. I get that kpop fans don’t like being made fun of but they do seem very comfortable making fun of other genres as well. Kpop much like country and dubstep also has some generic aspects to it which should not be free from criticism. Kpop is just like every other genre of music and if people are too sensitive that just making fun of it requires a apology, then it adds an even worse assumption about kpop fans then before (since kpop stans don’t have a great track record of being generally liked on the internet)
I Brought You Bullets, You Brought Me Your Love please, Brad. Love your videos 👍🏻
Alex Taylor oh no...
Yeeeeesssssss
Alex Taylor *I brought you my bullets you brought me your love but yes he needs to do it
oh god he's going to tear that album apart
Cwemmles _ I'm honestly just curious what he is going to say about it, because it is so raw
I JUST WANT TO YELL AT HIM TO LOOK AT THE LYRICS
ok but dallon weekes same especially for lying is the most fun xD
lyrics don't matter if the song sounds like trash.
huh that's interesting. though i think aiden and the differing variants on it are somewhat popular.
Brad Taste in Music i don't blame you, and i'm a huge fan of panic!
Seriously I don't get why people like this shit.
"I Didn't Even Know It Was Possible to Fit This Many Words Onto a Single Song Name" by Fall Out Boy
I love this album but I'm self aware that it's a total hot mess. I'll never stop listening to it though.
Hey Brad! Thank you for the honest review. I enjoyed your take on it and you made very valid points. I love this album, but I understand some aspects of it are very niche. I was one of the people who suggested it, sorry about that lol. Still, it made for really good entertainment.
I also wanted to add, this was made when the members were all still in high school, and Ryan Ross wrote most of the lyrics and composed most of the album. The reason you like the new stuff more, is probably because you prefer Brendon Urie's writing to Ryan's. Ryan left the band after the second album, Pretty. Odd.
Their second album is entirely different from anything they've ever done. If you intend to check out their whole discography, wipe away everything you know about the band. Whether or not that's a good thing? That's entirely up to you.
You should react to too weird to live, to rare to die
BlurredAl it’s pretty much a slightly more interesting Death of a Bachelor
GamermanRPGKing
so accurate
GamermanRPGKing It really is, it has good influences aswell
I feel like he would too...
This is my favorite Panic! at the Disco album. I like a lot of their music (not including the last two albums). It’s interesting to see how much opinions on music can vary. Everything is subjective and that’s really cool.
ur so real
i think the reason it didn’t blend is because of the slight pause spotify has, the actual blend is super smooth
Your disgust for this album is CRACKING me up
I think pop punk trying to be Bjork is the perfect explanation for why Time To Dance is my favorite song they ever made
when i say shotgun you say wedding is a certified hood classic moment
love that u say this w a travis scott pfp tbh
I like how he said he needed to "sit back" while listening to Camisado before even hearing the lyric with those words.
You're either gonna find Pretty Odd to be a beautiful return to form or it'll bore the shit outta ya
It is their best album and doesn't do all theae attempts at flashy
*these
Raven Hutt Yeah, like there's no in between with Pretty. Odd.
He hated it 😂
I know you had suffer through this album
But you got to give Pretty.Odd. a chance
BenGminT35 he hated it 😂
Have you considered the bad auto tune was on purpose? And that like the previous song it was making a really obvious statement about the state of pop music around the time it was released? Just an idea.
ThatGuy Joey have you considered maybe it just sounded like shit regardless?
Ice cream Guru 😂
Darla Sullivan that’s more likely than them using auto tune that shit and having no idea
Ice cream Guru Yes I don’t enjoy listening to that song, but that wasn’t my point.
i feel like they could do this but still execute it better. like, they could do autotune for a bit and then stop for the rest of the song. its a statement but the message gets convoluted because jesus fucking CHRIST its sonically unbearable
Spotify ruined the transition lmao, last time I pirated the album that is ripped from a CD still have perfect transitions.
Please do the paramore self titled
Or Riot
Paramore self titled is pretty fucking good!
i actually choked when i saw this in my feed
Istg I used to be the biggest fucking fan of patd and even then I didn’t stand nails for breakfast, tacks for snacks. I never understood why that song even existed
the transition to i write sins works perfectly in every form i listen to. thats fked up
i'm d e a d
edit: well this is my second favourite panic! album so i'm kind of afraid of asking for pretty. odd.
Brad reviewing Pretty. Odd. Is all i'm looking forward to in my life right now.
This isn't an excuse nor explanation, but a fact....they were 17-18 during this album.
There have been many bands who started out younger than this and released good music
arctic monkeys were the same age but made a mindblowing debut
Riot! by Paramore exists
I LMAO with the Nails for breakfast review hahaha!
“So this was back when he actually had a band backing him”
*Damn* you weren’t shy about that at all 😭
Time To Dance is actually a song about a Chuck Palahniuk book called Invisible Monsters. This album also isn't for everyone. It has a theatrical baroque pop/cabaret feel to it.
"Now I'm of consenting age..."
"congrats."
React to I Brought You My Bullets, You Brought me Your Love by MCR!!!!!!! There are a lot of explosions, I promise!!!!!!
Danger days plz
I wish you took a proper break after Nails. You can see your frustrations bled through the following tracks. Should've just left it for a couple days and come back to it
I very much enjoy all your videos and I’m sad you got pulled into the ‘emo’ reaction content (despite it being exactly what I want)
The blend between but its better if you do and i write sins not tragedies is actually perfect, idk what u listened the album on...
I went into this thinking "he's gonna hate track 4..."
When brad says he needs to sit back during camisado
Brad: *hears random high note*
Brad: (╯°□°）╯︵ ┻━┻
it's so funny to me how he calls the lyrics 'pretentious' and says he didn't hear that in the newer stuff bc this is all ryan ross' stuff, it was his band, his idea, hell, brendon wasn't even supposed to sing, and everyone constantly says that panic! went to shit when ryan and jon left, i like to differ but people always attack me for it
"No wonder they call this guy pretentious, Jesus Christ" 😂
PERFECT TIMING
I’m offended
Dude I know every single word of every song on this album and I agree with you about it all wholeheartedly.
28:52 "these don't work" how on earth do they not work?
You could say nails for breakfast, tacks for snacks feels like eating nails for breakfast and tacks for snacks…
I’m totally not sitting in front of an AFYCSO poster rn while watching this
I disagree with a lot of this but god you are undeniably hilarious. Rest In Peace brads hand
Pretty Odd and Vices & Virtues are probably more enjoyable for you.
Personally I love this album
I beg of you, please review their single "It's almost Halloween"
Bernadette Davis omfg he's going to either HATE IT AND SACRIFICE IT TO SATAN or he's going laugh at the obvious irony and hilariousness of music vid
I've just discovered you today, so I'm late. But as a huge Panic! fan I appreciate your honesty. A lot of other review channels sugarcoat their reviews on popular things but you don't and I love it. It annoys me that a lot of people in the fandom try to defend every single thing that Brendon creates. Even he himself knows his first album was unprofessional sounding. They were just starting out and didn't really know what they were doing. I like to just pick out the songs in the album I like and skip out on the others entirely. I love listening to him sing his older songs live because he has developed his vocals enough to give the lyrics the recognition they deserve.