It is. Because of was trained with 2 instruments being played at once, but with no distinction between them, it's output was 2 instruments being played at once.
Man your videos are getting even better. And holy crap, that Jazz was actually really convincing! I'm so curious to hear it done with the drums taken out fully
In jazz like in any other genre, there are chords, rythms and time structures(repetitions, long notes and short notes, regular pauses), melodies(relationship between notes in sequence), .... That's what we want the AI to learn.
@@schok51 You're vastly underestimating the human element of music, especially jazz which doesn't tend to follow logical structures and rules of popular music. Very complicated for humans to even understand jazz, let alone an ai.
"Wow wow, there's three options. Gosh darn it, sounds just like another boring old goldilocks story huh? Too big, too small, just right! Too hot, too cold, _just right!_ Too time based, not time based enough, *JUST RIGHT!* " EDIT: Thanks for the 100+ likes. :)
Max Fuller unfortunately there's something called "Law of diminishing returns" which pretty much means, at a certain point if you keep training the NN for longer it wont get much better or even get worse.
Imagine if every planet on the universe is a computer program designed to produce the best music that they possibly can, so some supreme 5th dimensional race can filter through each of the quintillions of planets to find the single most ultimate piece of music in the universe.
It sounds like your neural net is good at picking out hallmark features of jazz music, but doesnt understand melody. What you might think about doing is showing it the differences between baroque and jazz as well as the similarities, then have it come up with something that is similar to baroque but is jazzy
The jazz scale is the shortest scale. It can be played in any order, and it will always sound "like jazz" because its just a scale. Thats why "noodling" up and down the scale sounds bad to most people, because it's just scale memorization done fast. The type of music the algorithm listened to is irrelevant, lol. The timing between the notes and how long they're played for is important. That's why the outputs sounded awkward until the end. Partially, at least.
Do a strength and balance evolution simulator where two creatures are joined by a rope and the one to pull it back the least is killed, the one that pulled it the most has offspring (evolutionary tug of war)
Isaac Y. I thought of the same thing It looks really interesting to me but I don't think I have a good enough computer to make an AI, but I would love to make an AI that composes metal
Hi Cary, Im not sure if this is a stupid idea, but I was wondering what's the 'ultimate word'? So maybe you could put all existing English words together and by the number of all the letters maybe you could form an ultimate word. Like 'dog'+'cat'+'rat'= *at* because there are 2 a's and t's I think I'm talking nonsense right now bye
You wouldn't be able to go just on spelling though because words may have similar spelling but not sound even slightly similar. (weight and wait for example)
PixelCNN sounds like two people playing on the same piano. One who is really good than one that just smashes keys every once and a while.
Andrew Parker and each time the bad ones plays the good one gets offbeat and panic a little trying to be right
It is. Because of was trained with 2 instruments being played at once, but with no distinction between them, it's output was 2 instruments being played at once.
That's what jazz is
Needs two different midi instruments
that’s me and my brother for you!
As in me being the one smashing the keys..
12:51 I'd recognize that sound anywhere!! This is _exactly_ what it sounds like when you play a percussion track as MIDI piano.
MrCheeze when you accidentally drag your drum clip over to the wrong track
It sounds pretty cool too
Why do I hear boss music?
It really sounds like Chick Corea honestly
LMAO this is actually relatable
Man your videos are getting even better. And holy crap, that Jazz was actually really convincing! I'm so curious to hear it done with the drums taken out fully
SENPAIIII!!!!!
(/●O●)/
Boyinaband omg
boyinaband ft pixelcnn now
#CheckmarkSuperior
We can teach ai how to play music but we can't teach children how to pay tax?!?
12:50
Cary: I want Jazz music!
PixelCNN: No, you actually want final boss music.
garykh
æiou
ah yes. gary
That's what I thought too!
hmmm... gary....
12:50 Boss Stage Time
That one was certainly interesting. Ha ha ha!
ikr
RosenBosen Michael Rosen is cancer
michael rosen is awesome
yeah i kinda sounds like something from a pixley video game
The mouth animation was clearly the best part of this
You have bee in your name. I bet you can guess why I pointed this out.
Because the face is black and yellow?
I loved it
JaytleBee von Miraus
Fuck vice lords
I agree
12:54 woah! That’s some boss battle music!
That was my favorite one lol
10/10 would put in my bootleg gameboy RPG
I know right
With refining, and I mean like a lot of refining, it could actually work
@@lukasnovella9001 the tune's there.
12:50 Lol this sounds somehow like boss battle music
sounds almost like you read gen tanaya's comment from 10 months ago and re-wrote it.
@@Bunny_515_64 I didn't read the comments, it was just my genuine reaction xD. Oh and btw, ow the edge.
Mambomen jaws
@Honudes Gai wow so good at roasting a 2 month old comment. Thats a lot of time to think.
@Honudes Gai as well as you my not so much friend
12:50 actually sounded like good intense music...
Droid 0.1 Alpha Like a scary boss battle from a Zelda game.
This could be used as metal tablature I guess, and it would sound like a song from System of a Down
This one stuck with me too. This probably will be the last song we will hear when AI turns against us. :P
Droid 0.1 Alpha literally the battle with red in pokemon
Droid 0.1 Alpha yes
The chord progression at 11:04 is very nice!
Henley Smith it is quiet beatifull
sounds like it learnt from Chick Corea's Spain
as well as 11:30
What chords are they? I don't know enough music theory
Joel Huang THATS WHAT I WAS THINKING
I think 481 (12:50) was my favorite. It definitely caught my attention.
Totally agree, it has this rite of spring vibe in it.
Bowser's Castle
Volvocloud Agreed
Definitely same. It's not exactly great jazz, but it's definitely got a unique sound and some kind of real rhythm to it.
rite of spring 💗
6:27 is honestly the best result. its an absolute masterpiece, better than anything us humans could create
*THAT*
*WAS*
*NAUSEATING*
*I HOPE I NEVER CROSSPATH YOU FOR THE REST OF MY LIFE*
*LEAVE IMMEDIATELY*
*bing*
@@Joseph-ru8de is better than google
@@asheep7797I mean it can teach you how to rob a bank
HyperGAN: *cries* continue chain :/ 👇
"The main downsides are-" *Advertisement plays*
right?
The main downsides are congestion and the lack of sex drive. Contact your doctor for more information.
The main downsides are apparently razors.
That didn’t happen to me, because I now have TH-cam Red Membership!
The Main Downside is the 2019 Honda Odyssey
6:34 'leave imMIDIately'
Haha... Geddit
Haha
yes
Bob Bobson Cool mid pun!
Bob Bobson AAAYYYYY😂😂😂
Geddit? Get reddit?
Is it possible to make it evolve to the point where it starts to play "the lick"
And once it starts to play the lick, it never stops.
Well yes because it has evolved to perfection why mess with perfection
ITS NECESSARY
DUH DUH DUH DUH DA DU DA
that would be overfitting
12:20 is actually really incredible!!
gets worse over time though
I like it
PixelCNN 481 was an absolute banger.
I want that as boss music.
Me too! Haha!
the violent smashing and baby noises are actually kinda terrifying
Squii y e a h
your photo too
edit:your face(book) too
Ya
I sure found it quite (smashing) I'm not sorry
It almost makes me sad to hear them suffering 😢
The first two didn't produce bad jazz. It was obviously just super progressive jazz and you iq isn't high enough to appreciate it. *Tips fedora*
. . .
LOL
guess he doesn't watch rick and morty
Do you have enough iq to understand rick and morty
Jonny Jackson, I think it’s actually maybe something that could be in “Trout Mask Replica” look it up and you’ll understand what I’m talking about.
So, in a few years Hatsune Miku will write her own songs?
This comment made me sad
@@thes.wilsonchannel203 why?
the vocaloid fandom will rise once more
@@TigirlakaLaserwolf6 hell naw let it die
Oh shit
4:20 I thought that was the song the program has created I was like "damn! that shit good!" until I heard the drums, I know it wasn't the program
Same
Jake The Raven the song and visualization were damn a e s t h e t i c too
The first two robots are me trying to play piano ._.
TheMCcreeper71 xD
TheMCcreeper71 Don't worry you're the next Thelonious Monk
TheMCcreeper71 also similar to Conlon Nancarrow
Prepare for brutal death :D
A.I
Me: Hey bro pass the aux cord!
Friend: Ok, but don't play trash
Me: *PixelCNN*
justagiraffe and not a single trash was played that day
justagiraffe Actually Coblstm was better
🅱️ro
god why agghh
11:01 *M I N E C R A F T*
Edit : HOLY CRAP THANKS FOR 200 LIKES! :o
my god your right
wet hands
W.ww wow you remembered the music really well congratz
I like that intro to a Minecraft aong
@@silvervens OMG
10:27 love the little blue fart
Charlie Ropesocks .
Flamingfox 29 .
Edit:oh dog josh what have we started
dead meme .
Charlie Ropesocks .
@@jef_f8751 .
12:50 Sounds like a boss theme from a retro game, like Megaman or something
Aidan Croft agreed
that's exactly what I was gonna comment
Aidan Croft
Later in the video, he reveals it had to do with the drums.
Sounds a bit like Stravinsky's Rite of Spring to me
Natsume Wu that's exactly what I thought of too!!!
now time to see if it can generate black metal
Lillian Constanzeeeee :P
There might be too fucking much drums in it
Got any black metal MIDI files lying around?
There is no such thing as too much drums in black metal
Lillian they would need to learn the concept of «kvlt» first
10:23 it plays a II-VI and then leaves out the resolution :(
That was unsatisfying
James Heffernan it’s JAAAAZZZZZ
It kinda resolves in the next one
The name of that song is "How to Keep a Music Theorist in Suspense"
James Heffernan The next chord has a 1maj7 sound
4:22 I thought this was the actual song that "HyperGAN" made
open.spotify.com/album/3bNZR6g7xsBYg78Tl5Mdz8?si=1usXtzDWT3m1O8sSbLuCaw
me too
Same
No thats the music Mark Rober uses...
Same
6:27
AND THE GRAN FINALE!
*ding*
My favorite song
Its called "One Note"
Jayden_Jade not only is it blue, it is alone. MY CONCLUSION: it has depression.
13:18 :O
Best song. 10/10
@@ahmetcangokceer it's an homage
"That... was... nauseating. I hope I never cross paths with you for the rest of my life."
well that went dark quick
I feel like these programs could actually make decent music if you didn’t give them one of the hardest genres to play
Also one of the hardest to understand and compose
In jazz like in any other genre, there are chords, rythms and time structures(repetitions, long notes and short notes, regular pauses), melodies(relationship between notes in sequence), .... That's what we want the AI to learn.
@@schok51 The point is that these are a lot more sophisticated and complicated in jazz than in, say, pop music
@@schok51 You're vastly underestimating the human element of music, especially jazz which doesn't tend to follow logical structures and rules of popular music. Very complicated for humans to even understand jazz, let alone an ai.
12:51 Final boss music!
You've pretty much nailed your comedic timing.
Asdayasman really? his humor isn't my cup of tea.
Lol ya at 1:07 seeing hi face slowly turn into a frown was gold ( ੭ ˙ᗜ˙ )੭
11:05 actually that's not bad.
Hey, thats pretty gud
Isabella Pantaleao
Nice chords but too short ;D
iDubzzz
The masterpiece at 5:54 had me in tears of joy
"Wow wow, there's three options. Gosh darn it, sounds just like another boring old goldilocks story huh? Too big, too small, just right! Too hot, too cold, _just right!_ Too time based, not time based enough, *JUST RIGHT!* "
EDIT: Thanks for the 100+ likes. :)
What about too left, too right, just right?
"Dad listen to me play the drums!"
(starts hitting the piano)
His name? John cage
Leave PixelCNN running for a year!
Max Fuller PixelCNN now performs at a fancy restaurant, and is on his way to the top of the Jazz ladder.
Max Fuller unfortunately there's something called "Law of diminishing returns" which pretty much means, at a certain point if you keep training the NN for longer it wont get much better or even get worse.
3.1415926535 8979 "Yay I can become SkyNet!"
Max Fuller fake news
Let PixelCNN make fake news for 4 years
10:36 this is... actually pretty good!
Yes. I think so
True, but it doesn’t sound jazzy enough.
Same
ya like jazz?
That was BEE-utiful music keemSTAR
Do you particularly enjoy jazz music?
😐😐
You stole my profile hooligan
u like 🅱️azz?
"SHOW ME WHAT YOU GOT"
Darkstar vs Superstar uhhhh a candy bar......and a book in my backpack
Darkstar vs Superstar DISQUALIFIED
Imagine if every planet on the universe is a computer program designed to produce the best music that they possibly can, so some supreme 5th dimensional race can filter through each of the quintillions of planets to find the single most ultimate piece of music in the universe.
then they listen to it for a couple of days and it gets boring :P
s3e1 todayyyyyyy
#481 at 12:52 sounds a LOT like incidental music heard in plays.
That one is actually one of my favorites
@@vastowen4562 same
10:35 when my GF left me
Noriel Sylvire To me that sounds like Let it go.
@@loganiushere more like river flows in you
13:06 had a good start
12:50 holy fuck that intensity
6:33 When my friend makes an awful pun.
Me: go commit d i e
worst pun ever
"leave immediately"
(activates death machine)
@@sciblastofficial9833 [Insert abused baby cries followed by banging lmfao]
I HOPE I NEVER CROSS PATHS WITH YOU
14:46 well, Michael Jacksons Bad was actually really good
PixelCNN actually sounds like something.
AI evolves to compose 3 hours of dubstep.
JustAGamer you'd need some serious Wub generators
JustAGamer jazz is way more complex than dubstep
i am MAD No Dubsetp Is The Most Highest Art Form
butt_woman u trollin'?
:( i am a dubstep major...
"hey he's listening to baroque music" proceeds end cary's suffering with badminton clubs
this is so funny
A Lemon Citrus , I think they're squash bats...
beethoven wasnt even a baroque composer lmao
My mistake, they're badminton clubs.
A Lemon Citrus are you deaf? how did you get beethoven out of baroque?
The 7 of 8 from hypergan was actually pretty cool sounding and you could hear that it was trying to make jazz.
It sounds like your neural net is good at picking out hallmark features of jazz music, but doesnt understand melody. What you might think about doing is showing it the differences between baroque and jazz as well as the similarities, then have it come up with something that is similar to baroque but is jazzy
🔵👀...
🙆🔢🎶‼
So...it needs to be baroque to fix it? I'm not sorry...
weird flexible but ok
The jazz scale is the shortest scale. It can be played in any order, and it will always sound "like jazz" because its just a scale. Thats why "noodling" up and down the scale sounds bad to most people, because it's just scale memorization done fast. The type of music the algorithm listened to is irrelevant, lol. The timing between the notes and how long they're played for is important. That's why the outputs sounded awkward until the end. Partially, at least.
r/wooosh@@dennisthemenace3695
Got a little carried away with those gradual mouth transitions, huh? Lol
I bet it could make some pretty sick dubstep.
1:26 is my reaction when I find out pet fish can’t do tricks
6:35 that... was... nauseating, i hope we never cross paths
carykh: the main downsides are-
*ad plays*
Ad: "I've never been to novascocia"
me: ._.
6:16 the start's actually pretty good
9:01 the whole extrait is kinda nice too
12:52 That part is surprisingly good in my opinion.
This is actually incredible, it sounds like actual jazz music! It has standard licks and stuff, and even chord changes!
Yeah I loved it :)
Just need to be able to get the length of the notes length extended from time to time
video: cary gets beat up
subtitles: *top 10 saddest anime deaths*
CANCEROUS, BAD, OLD, AND DEAD MEME
@@diosatapatia speak for yourself, hun
6:33
the song at 12:50 is actually kinda good!
drums
1:07 lol Sticky’s face gradually goes from smile to frown
EDIT: “the stick figure’s” -> “Sticky’s”
that feeling when computer makes better music than you .......... .
Morc I just thought I could comment that right before I read that... damn computers
Don't feel bad bud, Computers can do most things better than you, or even me. Except sex, we've still got that going for us meatbags.
not for long haha
+tybo199 vibrators?
It can be used to help some composers, just make your computer generate a rythm for you, so you can make a better song from it.
S H O W M E W H A T Y O U G O T
I W A N T T O S E E W H A T Y O U G O T
W H Y A R E Y O U T A L K I N G L I K E T H I S
1:27 Why do I like this part so much. especially since Cary is just smiling about it.
Them: What do you listen to?
Me:
Lemonbreadd hhuh
Do a strength and balance evolution simulator where two creatures are joined by a rope and the one to pull it back the least is killed, the one that pulled it the most has offspring (evolutionary tug of war)
Peter, the offspring would just fight a random creature of the other 999 I guess
the other offspring
I cried at 10:27 the music... Its just.. So powerful...😆
LOL!
Boy shut yo sensitive ass up
Nvm I just cried
I clicked the timelink, as soon as I did that, an ad played for karaoke
10:28 that lil blue doot⏹
CBLSTM: Robot flower standing on minecraft cobblestone
Hypergan: weird speakerbox thingy
PixelCNN: Roboty
12:50 go pikachu!
Why's the character frowning on some of the ones that actually sounded quite decent? Like 11:11 is actually pretty good.
Name Name its to make a loop
A looping animation*
It slowly gets happier as good ones play
He frowns on 9:57.
DUDE THAT’S ONE OF THE BEST SAMPLES
When you said "avoid piece 610" I didn't listen and skipped straight to it. Now I'm deaf.
CBLSTM and HyperGan: “exist”
PixelCNN: imma bout to end this mans whole career.
I just wanted to hear jazz made by a computer, I can't be the only one.
11:06 why you frowning! If figured out min7s!
It's a looping animation.
Acutally it is a minor 9th
@@sealplaysguitar damn
11:16 its this part what made him frown
Sorry when im late
yeaa it's good and all, but does it DJENT?
Joel Peot I guess it doesn't, but it could
12:50
Also hello fellow Rob Scallon fan. Let's try and make the comment section less stagnant by keeping fanbases to their channels, though
13:36 Bill Wurtz has joined the chat.
W o w
"We get these dope ass looking french flags"
I loved the 481st song of PixelCNN (at 12:50).
Why did you draw that long face?
YoomarTuNoOmar probably cause it wasnt jazz
Assumably, because of the "drums". He explained that later.
YoomarTuNoOmar When that played his face started going back to happy
Its supposed to be Jazz.
YoomarTuNoOmar It wasn't jazz. It's amazing that it did something other than jazz when only given jazz.
this made me really want to listen to Thelonius Monk
Zack Barbieri I think it sounds more like Ryo Fukui but Monk aswell yeah!
I was reminded more of the Dave Brubeck Quartet, personally, though I suspect using more instruments than just piano would have affected that.
i love the cary switching from smile to frown and back to smile when AI is playing music
I love how hypergan's final song was just 1 note
You do realize that you just sent everyone to piece #610?
Who?
minshwan tang 16:20
Its funny because this was still the best AI midi generator until like a year ago 💀
9:05 that was pretty good
7:39 I thought I had seen it all but I never thought I would see a truly cute stick figure
Would probably work much better if you transposed the training data into the same key before feeding it to the AI.
Kind of hard if we're talking about jazz
Jazz said screw key signatures
Yeah and time signatures
for sure it wouldve sounded better
Damn this channel looks cool
you should watch it.
Can you make an AI djent??
Isaac Y. I thought of the same thing
It looks really interesting to me but I don't think I have a good enough computer to make an AI, but I would love to make an AI that composes metal
Dadabot
12:50 what is this some boss fight intro music
I was just on your channel, and I go off for one minute, and you post.
I actually enjoyed a lot of the ones PixelCNN made that you didn't like.
1:27 Ah, yes. My favourite kind of music. Baby crying and smashin- Nope. Nothing happened
12:41 - 12:45 Dat circle of dominants tho
IKR! From a jazz theory perspective, it's kind of crazy how good this is. It was the #9b13 chord at 12:25 that got me lmao
I'd love to see something like this, but trained only one one chord progression in one key (like rhythm changes)
12:50 trains jazz, ended up getting contemporary classical music.
drums
Hi Cary,
Im not sure if this is a stupid idea, but I was wondering what's the 'ultimate word'?
So maybe you could put all existing English words together and by the number of all the letters maybe you could form an ultimate word.
Like 'dog'+'cat'+'rat'= *at*
because there are 2 a's and t's
I think I'm talking nonsense right now bye
Bensuuu that's a good question
Bensuuu that's cool imo
You wouldn't be able to go just on spelling though because words may have similar spelling but not sound even slightly similar. (weight and wait for example)
If you do that with all of the words in the english language you'll probably get something with "e"
fourtytwo
i love how you can see the smile on cary's face turn into a frown
Hahah. The music gets really damn dramatic at 12:50.
I think it sounds pretty neat.