Garbage were one of my favourite bands in the 90's, I'd almost forgotten about them until I watched this video. I'm not surprised Beth likes Shirley Manson, she is Scottish, an amazing singer and a red head, what's not to like ;-)
If you loved them in the 90’s, well you missed two great albums of theirs, 2005 Bleed Like Me and 2012 Not Your Kind Of People. Believe me, you won’t be disappointed.
I've seen Garbage live 20 years ago as part of a festival. They were due pretty late when everybody was drunk already (including some of the bands that had played that day) and there was a huge crowd. Maybe 1.5 football/soccer fields full of people right in front of the stage and easily as many in the surrounding area - not exactly the best conditions for them, right? Shirley stepped onto the stage and did nothing. She just stood there. She didn't say anything, She just stood there. Alone on the whole wide stage. And in merely seconds the huge drunken crowd calmed down and looked at her. I've never seen anything like it. The way the crowd reacted to Shirley Manson's presence alone was impressive. Thousands of people turned their heads and looked expectantly at her, waiting what she would do. Once that happened the whole band joined her. Needless to say that they stole the show and blew everybody else away, easily. She also was fantastic in The Sarah Connor Chronicles, as a tech company CEO with more than just a few secrets. Enigmatic and hypnotic performance
The first time I saw Shirley Manson step on stage, I finally understood why teenage girls would lose their shit screaming over the Beatles or Elvis. She is luminous, possibly fae.
Great song. 😃 Written by and produced by Garbage. Sample of Don't Worry Baby, written by Brian Wilson and the late Roger Christian. BW was inspired by Be My Baby, sung by The Ronnettes, lead singer was the late Ronnie Spector. Take Me Home Tonight sung by the late Eddie Money has the late Ronnie Spector as a guest. RIP Ronnie Spector, Eddie Money and Roger Christian. Shirley Manson tweeted her eulogy.
I thought I would never see a Garbage reaction. Edit: Also, the Koln 2005 concert is great start to finish, and in my opinion Shirley is better vocally than she was in the 90s.
It has been said that Shirley has a unique and almost rare dynamic vocal range that is based in the contralto range and often slides up higher. When you hear her speak she has that soft
I'm soo glad you reacted to this amazing and underrated band. I'm surprised you hadn't before since she's Scottish! Shirley is a great talent who doesn't get the due she deserves. Always love your reactions and analysis! BTW, I know that you've done 2 songs by Jinjer, but I'd love to see your analysis of Judgement and Punishment (One Take Performance) where the video shows her when she recorded the vocals for the song.
📖 Get your signed copy of my album Fable here: www.bethroars.com/shop ☀ Pre-save my first single "Power Of The Wolf" 🐺 on Spotify (it really helps me out!): distrokid.com/hyperfollow/bethroars/power-of-the-wolf 🥁 Become a Patreon Supporter: www.patreon.com/bethroars
Yup, Butch Vig was involved on many relevant albums from the 90's, from Sonic Youth to Nirvana. He managed to get a cleaner album from Nirvana, Nevermind, an album with a lot of pop hook
The whole band were well known producers, except for Manson. That was the whole premise behind them. Get 3 producers that are fed up with the direction music is going, band them together to show the world and industry how it is supposed to run. Take the mickey out of the irony of the name Garbage and write every song to push all buttons that they can think of. They got lucky in finding Manson. She added to the whole idea and made it one perfect masterpiece.
Someone from Edinburgh watching someone from Edinburgh watching someone from Edinburgh. Edinburgh-ception? I dunno. Still, I'm new to this channel and I've been really enjoying what I've seen. I look forward to watching more!
Saw them live in the early 2000nd's in Köln (Cologne) too. Still remember her saying to the band "Stop, stop, stop..." as her band was going for the next song. She then added, "you guys have to know, we played all the different places all over the world, but I've never seen a waiter going with the tablet of beer through the dancing crowd... This can only happen in germany.... Rock on." Thank you Beth for this reaction and the memories. May I suggest a reaction to Chvrches and "The mother we share" or "clearest blue"?
Was just viewing a clip the algorhythm suggested, Shirley Manson: Quiet everybody; saw this reaction in the selection along side of it and came to see this reaction, one GORGEOUS redhead reacting to another GORGEOUS ginger!
Its about time you checked out my girl. She is so much fun in concert. She is a force all of her own making. A sailor would be proud to swear like Shirley. There were some great vocals back then. I would love for you to do Sinead O'Connor's Fire on Babylon. She has other song that might be better but I think that is her best vocals.
Yes! One of my favourite bands ever, introduced to me by a friend right after the first album release. I have only heard them live once, on the night in 2016 when someone we won't mention entered office. Let's just say that you could slice Shirley's anger that night with a knife :D But they put on one hell of a performance for me and the 900 other people at the venue.
Just recently got into listening to Garbage. Amazing band. You should look into Matt Andersen. Especially his version of 'Ain't no Sunshine'. Incredible!
Great video! I just discovered your channel so I'm catching up on your wonderful vast knowledge. Shirley is one of my top favorite artist.But I listen to every genre of music.In 1995 · I guess I was 35 when I bought their debut album and had just moved from Memphis TN. to the Ozark Mountains of Arkansas. "Vow" of course which hit big in other states got absolutely no radio play what so ever in that Bible Belt neck of the woods.If people only knew the song was written in reference to domestic abuse.That type of censorship is far more damaging in my opinion.Anyways ,when the lock downs started.I re- listened to every album,read and watched everything every interview concert or podcast Shirley Manson and Garbage I could find. Not only a fantastic artist in every sense of the word.But genually a very unique compassionate inspiring person.. Just all around good folk.. I just watched your video on Fleetwood Mac andAmy Lee. I so agree with you on her abilities. "My Immortal" has brought me to tears on several occasions.Incredible talent.
Butch Vig is from there and had his studio there. Duke and Steve were also producers and worked with Butch for a very long time. I believe they had been friends from early on in their careers. The three guys wanted to form a band that they did more than produce with. One night, while looking for a singer, Steve heard Shirley on a video for her old band Anglefish on MTV. They approached her without knowing much about her other than how they liked her voice. Her other band was following apart and so they all meet up, and they eventually asked her to come record with them. Interestingly enough, the first day they met was the day Kurt Cobain died. Butch of course produced Nirvana’s Nevermind album. Really it’s one of those crazy stories that someone worked out in the end. They just released their seventh album this year!
I'd looooooove for you to hear Tami Neilson - You Were Mine (Live at Round Head Studio). I promise she will blow you away. Also, Shirley Manson is my #1 crush for life and one of my favorite voices in music.
Garbage is my favorite band! I would love if you did a video reacting to The Distillers (to be precise, the performance of the song The Hunger on Reading Festival)
I remember reading some critic somewhere who talked about Shirley Manson's breathing in her singing, and being a huge fan of Garbage, I always remembered it: "Manson breathes into the mic as if she were recording mid coitus."
Paulina from the Mexican band The warning has perfect control and pitch while she plays the drums. She's a genius but even more at writing music. Go check her out
Great video. I love every album they have made. OK cd, whatever.😊 if you haven’t already, listen to the song Empty from 2016’s Strange Little Birds. Just the album title shows that they still have an attitude. Their output may be less but only by choice not by quality.
_Even Though Your Love is Doomed_ was so brilliant. Shirley did a very emotional version at Summerfest 2016. The crowd was hot and it was very moving :3
2 things before I listen to your commentary here...1) this performance is from 1998, 2) Garbage had a 7 yr hiatus, but in 2012, came together and actively created new music and released new music..., their latest album came out in 2022....Check it out...Godhead! ...I have seen your voice teacher videos on youtube before, but haven't listened to one yet. So be nice!!! Lol. I am totally biased, so I'm super skeptical now,
The day you react to The warning you will be amazed by their talent. They make better music than full bands, and there're only 3 sisters, very young but kicking ass
Love Garbage. Shirley Manson was totally my 90's crush.
Hell yeah, brother!
Yes !!
Her voice is so damn sexy
Me too... Ultra orange!!
❤You
I truly believe every line is delivered with conviction, that’s what I love about Shirley Manson
Garbage were one of my favourite bands in the 90's, I'd almost forgotten about them until I watched this video. I'm not surprised Beth likes Shirley Manson, she is Scottish, an amazing singer and a red head, what's not to like ;-)
If you loved them in the 90’s, well you missed two great albums of theirs, 2005 Bleed Like Me and 2012 Not Your Kind Of People. Believe me, you won’t be disappointed.
@@FunEcar dont forget strange little birds that was a great album too
She is one of the best singers ever
Shirley, my instant all time favourite crush.
#1 Crush?
Shirley was the reason I dyed my hair ginger (still do) when I was 16 and only started listening to Garbage
Mine too 💯💯💯
Haha me 2 15 and fallen in love
Still is.
She's a great singer, but she also gave a chilling performance in the Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles TV series.
I've seen Garbage live 20 years ago as part of a festival. They were due pretty late when everybody was drunk already (including some of the bands that had played that day) and there was a huge crowd. Maybe 1.5 football/soccer fields full of people right in front of the stage and easily as many in the surrounding area - not exactly the best conditions for them, right? Shirley stepped onto the stage and did nothing. She just stood there. She didn't say anything, She just stood there. Alone on the whole wide stage. And in merely seconds the huge drunken crowd calmed down and looked at her. I've never seen anything like it. The way the crowd reacted to Shirley Manson's presence alone was impressive. Thousands of people turned their heads and looked expectantly at her, waiting what she would do. Once that happened the whole band joined her. Needless to say that they stole the show and blew everybody else away, easily.
She also was fantastic in The Sarah Connor Chronicles, as a tech company CEO with more than just a few secrets. Enigmatic and hypnotic performance
You don't mess with Shirley Manson 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻💯💯💯😂😂😂🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻
The first time I saw Shirley Manson step on stage, I finally understood why teenage girls would lose their shit screaming over the Beatles or Elvis. She is luminous, possibly fae.
Garbage has a new album
coming out soon--their 7th
(not including their best of,
bonus tracks, etc.).
I never thought I’d see Beth react to the sensual and striking, Shirley Manson.
🙌🏻❤️❤️❤️
It's like some vortex of attractive Scottish women. Get Karen Gillan in there and everything would collapse into a beautiful singularity.
Great song. 😃
Written by and produced by Garbage.
Sample of Don't Worry Baby, written by Brian Wilson and the late Roger Christian. BW was inspired by Be My Baby, sung by The Ronnettes, lead singer was the late Ronnie Spector.
Take Me Home Tonight sung by the late Eddie Money has the late Ronnie Spector as a guest.
RIP Ronnie Spector, Eddie Money and Roger Christian.
Shirley Manson tweeted her eulogy.
I will SIMP for Shirley Manson any day of the week. She actually deserves it
😂
I thought I would never see a Garbage reaction.
Edit: Also, the Koln 2005 concert is great start to finish, and in my opinion Shirley is better vocally than she was in the 90s.
I know, right. Almost like Beth has something against Scottish redheads...
That is their best concert, on TH-cam anyway.
Same I found this vid because i youtubed kurt older shirley mansion since no one has yet to upload garbage interview with kurt.
Loved garbage in the 90s, still love them now!
It has been said that Shirley has a unique and almost rare dynamic vocal range that is based in the contralto range and often slides up higher. When you hear her speak she has that soft
Butch Vig is a genius.
Totally!
I saw them four times live. Great show EVERY time!!!!!!!!!!
I'm soo glad you reacted to this amazing and underrated band. I'm surprised you hadn't before since she's Scottish! Shirley is a great talent who doesn't get the due she deserves. Always love your reactions and analysis! BTW, I know that you've done 2 songs by Jinjer, but I'd love to see your analysis of Judgement and Punishment (One Take Performance) where the video shows her when she recorded the vocals for the song.
I love this so much! You are the *o n l y* vocal coach to react to Shirley Manson. She's so underrated and neglected! Instant subscribe!
📖 Get your signed copy of my album Fable here: www.bethroars.com/shop
☀ Pre-save my first single "Power Of The Wolf" 🐺 on Spotify (it really helps me out!): distrokid.com/hyperfollow/bethroars/power-of-the-wolf
🥁 Become a Patreon Supporter: www.patreon.com/bethroars
I was in love with Shirley!!! So many memories from my youth... thanks Beth 🤟🏻
Fun facts, Metallica covered their song ''I'm only happy when it rains''. The drummer also produced Nirvana's Nevermind album.
Butch did the original mix.
Andy Wallace did "post production" and turned it radio friendly
Yup, Butch Vig was involved on many relevant albums from the 90's, from Sonic Youth to Nirvana. He managed to get a cleaner album from Nirvana, Nevermind, an album with a lot of pop hook
The whole band were well known producers, except for Manson. That was the whole premise behind them. Get 3 producers that are fed up with the direction music is going, band them together to show the world and industry how it is supposed to run. Take the mickey out of the irony of the name Garbage and write every song to push all buttons that they can think of. They got lucky in finding Manson. She added to the whole idea and made it one perfect masterpiece.
Ah she's so great. A wonderful human being with buckets of talent
The breath thing is same with Matt Bellamy, it just becomes part of the song
Nice! A Garbage reaction... There is a first for everything. Lol. Shirley Manson, I just love what she can bring, as well as the band.
Those first two Garbage albums were pure magic.
Very glad you did this one! This is my favorite Garbage song of all time!
Garbage, favorite band in my high school years... and Shirley was definitely my celebrity crush.
Thanks!
Thanks Mike!
Someone from Edinburgh watching someone from Edinburgh watching someone from Edinburgh. Edinburgh-ception? I dunno.
Still, I'm new to this channel and I've been really enjoying what I've seen. I look forward to watching more!
Saw them live in the early 2000nd's in Köln (Cologne) too. Still remember her saying to the band "Stop, stop, stop..." as her band was going for the next song. She then added, "you guys have to know, we played all the different places all over the world, but I've never seen a waiter going with the tablet of beer through the dancing crowd... This can only happen in germany.... Rock on." Thank you Beth for this reaction and the memories. May I suggest a reaction to Chvrches and "The mother we share" or "clearest blue"?
God I love Shirley Manson!
Was just viewing a clip the algorhythm suggested, Shirley Manson: Quiet everybody; saw this reaction in the selection along side of it and came to see this reaction, one GORGEOUS redhead reacting to another GORGEOUS ginger!
Its about time you checked out my girl. She is so much fun in concert. She is a force all of her own making. A sailor would be proud to swear like Shirley. There were some great vocals back then.
I would love for you to do Sinead O'Connor's Fire on Babylon. She has other song that might be better but I think that is her best vocals.
I love garbage. One of my favorite bands 😭😭
My first live concert was Garbage, I started at the back, second song I was in the front rows jumping like a maniac, happy memories
Should an eco-warrior be attending gigs? 😁
@@jaynbob42😄
What ever Shirley does is perfect in the moment (imo)
This sparks joy 😊
Yes! One of my favourite bands ever, introduced to me by a friend right after the first album release. I have only heard them live once, on the night in 2016 when someone we won't mention entered office. Let's just say that you could slice Shirley's anger that night with a knife :D But they put on one hell of a performance for me and the 900 other people at the venue.
One of the best female vocalists out there.
This is top 20 for me of greatest live performances on TV.
My number 3 favourite band of all time. I was listening through their albums yesterday.
Who are your first two?
@@jtarantula3390 The Tea Party and The Tragically Hip
@@canuckled need to check them out
She first came to my attention in "Goodbye Mr McKenzie". The talent was obvious.
Love Garbage and this lady's analytical videos.
Shirley is an absolute goddess
Just recently got into listening to Garbage. Amazing band.
You should look into Matt Andersen. Especially his version of 'Ain't no Sunshine'. Incredible!
this video made me appreciate her vocals.
Seen them 3 times live awesome show
Shirley Manson, a graceful zombie with a beautiful voice
Goes without saying that Shirley is also the best rock frontwoman since Chrissy Hynde.
Great video! I just discovered your channel so I'm catching up on your wonderful vast knowledge. Shirley is one of my top favorite artist.But I listen to every genre of music.In 1995 · I guess I was 35 when I bought their debut album and had just moved from Memphis TN. to the Ozark Mountains of Arkansas. "Vow" of course which hit big in other states got absolutely no radio play what so ever in that Bible Belt neck of the woods.If people only knew the song was written in reference to domestic abuse.That type of censorship is far more damaging in my opinion.Anyways ,when the lock downs started.I re- listened to every album,read and watched everything every interview concert or podcast Shirley Manson and Garbage I could find. Not only a fantastic artist in every sense of the word.But genually a very unique compassionate inspiring person.. Just all around good folk.. I just watched your video on Fleetwood Mac andAmy Lee. I so agree with you on her abilities. "My Immortal" has brought me to tears on several occasions.Incredible talent.
Such an interesting band to come out of Madison, WI. I wonder how they all met & why they were all in Wisconsin of all places.
Butch Vig is from there and had his studio there. Duke and Steve were also producers and worked with Butch for a very long time. I believe they had been friends from early on in their careers. The three guys wanted to form a band that they did more than produce with. One night, while looking for a singer, Steve heard Shirley on a video for her old band Anglefish on MTV. They approached her without knowing much about her other than how they liked her voice. Her other band was following apart and so they all meet up, and they eventually asked her to come record with them. Interestingly enough, the first day they met was the day Kurt Cobain died. Butch of course produced Nirvana’s Nevermind album. Really it’s one of those crazy stories that someone worked out in the end. They just released their seventh album this year!
Could you review "The World is Not Enough" she does an amazing job on that one.
First time I heard them was the chilled out version of The World Is Not Enough which is such good version of the song.
They made a great surrealistic rock video for this song well worth checking out here on TH-cam!
Have you ever done a video for Michael Hutchence of INXS. He was a terrific singer and frontman
Shirley Manson is eternally hot and timelessly cool.
I was lucky enough to see them opening for The Smashing Pumpkins on the Mellon collie and the infinite sadness tour in 96
I would love to see you interview Shirley Manson!
Will always love Shirley. I could just be a sucker for Scottish ginger singers though. :)
Watching this and can't help but notice you and Shirley look quite similar.
Two amazing redheads. :)
You are so kind
@@BethRoars Very welcome :)
Woohoo Shirley Manson!
i love her and them as a whole!
If you haven’t done anything on Spirit Box yet..”Holy Roller” and “Constance” preferably back-to-back to show the amazing abilities of the group!
Love ❤️ Shirley Mason! Played Garage 2.0 CD to death.
Girls Talk, Garbage ft Brody dalle, it's amazing
Bien Beth me. gustó 👏👏🍀🍀
I'd looooooove for you to hear Tami Neilson - You Were Mine (Live at Round Head Studio). I promise she will blow you away. Also, Shirley Manson is my #1 crush for life and one of my favorite voices in music.
Garbage is my favorite band! I would love if you did a video reacting to The Distillers (to be precise, the performance of the song The Hunger on Reading Festival)
The Trick is to keep breathing...
Beth. You roar. Thank you.
This brings to light how important dynamics play a part in a vocal performance. Loved it. Thank you Beth.
Audio quality on the track is like an AM radio.
The song itself is heavily processed.
My fav Garbage song.
I remember reading some critic somewhere who talked about Shirley Manson's breathing in her singing, and being a huge fan of Garbage, I always remembered it: "Manson breathes into the mic as if she were recording mid coitus."
Paulina from the Mexican band The warning has perfect control and pitch while she plays the drums. She's a genius but even more at writing music. Go check her out
@Living In Spain - The S Is Silent no problem they have a lot of addictive music. You can start here (: th-cam.com/video/FK7pLOWEYJU/w-d-xo.html
Watch her on Craig Ferguson. Adorable!
Love your top Beth!
Love this!
Yay I'm early, and I've never heard Beth swear before :O
Do you mean her saying, Hell?
the best commentary!!!
She and this song kick ass.
Great video. I love every album they have made. OK cd, whatever.😊 if you haven’t already, listen to the song Empty from 2016’s Strange Little Birds. Just the album title shows that they still have an attitude. Their output may be less but only by choice not by quality.
_Even Though Your Love is Doomed_ was so brilliant. Shirley did a very emotional version at Summerfest 2016. The crowd was hot and it was very moving :3
Man I had the biggest celeb crush on S.M. growing up. Of course now its ZZ Ward, Lindsey Stirling, Amy lee and of course Beth's smile
New camera gear? 4k and looks great!
Love Garbage!
2 things before I listen to your commentary here...1) this performance is from 1998, 2) Garbage had a 7 yr hiatus, but in 2012, came together and actively created new music and released new music..., their latest album came out in 2022....Check it out...Godhead!
...I have seen your voice teacher videos on youtube before, but haven't listened to one yet. So be nice!!! Lol.
I am totally biased, so I'm super skeptical now,
Checkout one mile high push it performance from 2012.
Shirley, she's attractive but I'd be terrified to be in a relationship with her.
The guitar tiki tikitikitikitiki🎶🎶🎶👏👏
Love garbage!
shes my crush go baby go,go😍and i love her american accent in terminator
Could you look at bumblefoot dont know who to pray to anymore? He is actually a guitarist not a singer but he is still awesome at singing
Shirley😍
Ah, I'm on a Garbage kick right now. Thanks for covering Shirley! In the vein of the 1990s/2000s rock goddesses, could you react to some Gwen Stefani?
Highschool crush... love garbage
Caramba sua aparência está melhor. A mudança está fazendo efeito Boa sorte para você.
Hey Bethy, you should react to Dan Vasc doing a cover of Toss a Coin to Your Witcher. You'd love it, I think.
The day you react to The warning you will be amazed by their talent. They make better music than full bands, and there're only 3 sisters, very young but kicking ass
you should react again with PJ Harvey, and analizing her sing with her song "I Think I'm A Mother", curious singing, please do that reaction.
😍😍😍😍😍 Beth
👏👏👏👏👏