I edit a lot of sound too and this is 100% accurate. The sound can't get into the editor timeline unless you added it there. The action of adding the file there means you need a source file and have to spend time acquiring the source file.
@@ellenrittgers990 Not only are Yankee Democrats and their Canadian cousins IGNORING the lesson of the recent election - they are now crafting INSULTING EXCUSES to explain why they lost!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Cdn LIE-berals and Yankee Democrats INSULT THE INTELLIGENCE of the general public!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Consider that Cdn LIE-beral strategist Warren Kinsella - who has worked on campaigns for BOTH Cdn and Yankee LIE-berals - has just published an opinion piece in Cdn media claiming that the "number one reason Kamal lost is because she is a woman"!!!!!!!!!!! HYPOCRITE LIE-beral Kinsella IGNORES the facts: that Kamal is a SOCIALIST STOOGE with poisonous Woke leanings!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Biden was shunted aside for the simple reason that he was NOT doing any better in winning over the public with his Socialist and Woke garbage - so always ARROGANT LIE-berals started over with a new candidate -that the general public recognized as being just as Socialist and Woke as the other DIM WIT!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Kinsella THINKS SO LITTLE of the general public that he does not believe that Harris is being judged on her idiot word salad responses to any questions about the economy, crime or immigration!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Kinsella is SO CONTEMPTUOUS of the general public that he lists the economy and inflation as NUMBER FIVE on his list of foolish reasons why Kamal LOST!!!!!!!!!!!!
I am an American living in the U. S. and I must turn to Sky News Australia for credible news coverage. Thanks for your coverage of the American news scene.
@@SusanPearce_H Yep. Sounds of gunshots don't just appear in video editing. You have to be specifically adding in sound effects to the sound tracks of the project files.
Thanks for trying to do the right thing with your service sir ! Im sure you were asking yourself why a few times. However i believe you are a patriotic American and i salute you for serving .
Maybe they just had a few extra gunshots lying around in the edit room that’s why they call it the ‘edit’ room. - As to “finding no evidence”, what was he expecting to find a smoking gun?
The same way someone accidentally cheats on their spouse with a coworker for 3 years and commits paternity fraud so you raise a child thinking he is your own. "Just an accident"
Legacy media has lost all trust from the public, it's never coming back. I used to be skeptical of legacy media, today I just discount their propaganda disguised as reporting outright. They've earned that level of contempt.
Reporter and producer at the very least. Outright lies were told and embarrassing a LOT of service people. Several others at the ABC should also be sacked.
@@SusanPearce_H Even with a Liberal government, they'd need the will and grit to put together an Eliot Ness team to go in and root out the Abject Leftism.
How do you inadvertently add gun shots. That is a complete and deliberate act. Absolutely disgraceful. The independent investigation what a joke. Sky have summed this up perfectly however heads need to role
it was on purpose. therefore it was NOT a waste. it just seems that way to you because their goal was to broadcast lies, and you think their goal was to broadcast truth
@@silverbackag9790 Trump is referring to all Mainstream/ Legacy Media as they are all owned either by the leftwing givernments or leftwing billionaires. All fake news like Orwell's 1984, to indoctrinate the gullible and lazy audience.
@@silverbackag9790you raised an excellent point (this is not the same network that doctored the K interview on 60 minutes) but as already stated, Trump doesn’t differentiate between stations but is calling attention to an industry that is more propaganda and marketing than news and journalism.
_"Take their license ban them from TV."_ Unfortunately it was Obama that ended the Smith Mundt act of 1951 in 2012 that prohibited news agencies from broadcasting government propaganda to the American citizens. So, thanks to Obama that made it perfectly legal.
Disney owns ABC. Disney co-chairman Dana Walden is a close friend of Kamala Harris and Doug Emhoff. Walden arranged the Trump-Harris debate, and will likely be named CEO of Disney Entertainment in 2026, when Bob Iger is finally kicked out of Disney. Let that sink in for a moment. The Leftists are EVERYWHERE in US media.
This reporter and the rest involved must be held accountable . THIS IS A CRIMINAL ACT that nearly destroyed an innocent person. THE ABC CRIMINALS MUST BE CHARGED. We need justice for the man they set out to frame and destroy.
@mackheadrum1295 kinda irrelevant to the point that I'm making that there's no such thing as "inadvertently adding" things like this. It was deliberate and they knew exactly what they were doing otherwise they wouldn't have done it.
@@Steve_P_B yes but like the person at ABC is saying ow ya we added the 5 extra gun shots on accident as an audio error. As well as having a video multiple video errors that all happend to slip past everyone. How many times can you fuck up for it to be intentional.
@@mackheadrum1295or, more to the point, these are supposed to be professional editors, how many times can someone fuck up before it's clear that it's deliberate?
0:55 How do you inadvertently introduce gunshots into a video without doing it on purpose? It can't happen! They're still lying even when they're trying to convince us they're telling the truth.
They paid $400k because they looked about someone but refused to apologize? I would have told them they could pay me $800k with no apology or $400k with an apology. It would have been interesting to see what they chose.
The ABC is constitutionally incapable of reporting truthfully. Every stage of production from staff hiring to editing is run through a left wing filter that ensures a left wing bias hardwired into the content.
@@NoWindNoSunNoPower Media as usual, To inflate nothing into a breaking story, But more likely the editing was done before the Edited Footage was sold to the Media for a large amount of Money.
We don't want their apologies, we want their resignations. They have tried to tell us it was an accident? So that means their incompetent, so get rid of them. We don't need to spend 1.2 billion on incompetent either!
"They have tried to tell us it was an accident? So that means their incompetent" anyone that ever edited videos can tell you that there is no way to "accidentally" add gunshots, cut from the end and paste to the start of the video and so on. it HAS to be deliberate they lied back when they broadcasted this. they are lying now
TV station editors are experts in fake news and removing context to make things more sensational. The ABCs Media Watch likes to pretend the ABC is above such things
What any extraordinary disgrace. It is impossible it was accidental - how does an editor “accidentally” add in gunshots to paint a picture of guilt. Leadership is rotten from the top. Turn them off.
What action is being taken against the people involved in this fiasco? These weren't mistakes, this was a deliberate planned action to shame and discredit Australian soldiers. I am an ex digger and I cant imagine how our soldiers must feel when an Australian government department is conspiring to undermine their morale and give comfort and support to our enemies. Did someone say treason?
Sound Engineer here. Those are not errors. Someone put them there on purpose. Sounds don't just show up for no reason, while editing.
Everything goes one way as well. No gunshots were deleted.
I edit a lot of sound too and this is 100% accurate. The sound can't get into the editor timeline unless you added it there. The action of adding the file there means you need a source file and have to spend time acquiring the source file.
@@JonnoPlays Exactly
How is it added “Inadvertently”?
Exactly
Not only should they all be sacked, they should be arrested. Fabricating evidence to try and incriminate somebody is a crime.
AGREED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Main stream Democrat and LIE-beral Woke media is DESTROYING ITSELF with these constant LIES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Someone should tell the US democrats that!
@@ellenrittgers990 Not only are Yankee Democrats and their Canadian cousins IGNORING the lesson of the recent election - they are now crafting INSULTING EXCUSES to explain why they lost!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Cdn LIE-berals and Yankee Democrats INSULT THE INTELLIGENCE of the general public!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Consider that Cdn LIE-beral strategist Warren Kinsella - who has worked on campaigns for BOTH Cdn and Yankee LIE-berals - has just published an opinion piece in Cdn media claiming that the "number one reason Kamal lost is because she is a woman"!!!!!!!!!!!
HYPOCRITE LIE-beral Kinsella IGNORES the facts: that Kamal is a SOCIALIST STOOGE with poisonous Woke leanings!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Biden was shunted aside for the simple reason that he was NOT doing any better in winning over the public with his Socialist and Woke garbage - so always ARROGANT LIE-berals started over with a new candidate -that the general public recognized as being just as Socialist and Woke as the other DIM WIT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Kinsella THINKS SO LITTLE of the general public that he does not believe that Harris is being judged on her idiot word salad responses to any questions about the economy, crime or immigration!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Kinsella is SO CONTEMPTUOUS of the general public that he lists the economy and inflation as NUMBER FIVE on his list of foolish reasons why Kamal LOST!!!!!!!!!!!!
Bingo!
@@ellenrittgers990 Sorry, for these people news that are not favorable to them are fake, misinformation, or worse, conspiracy. They are hopeless.
"Tell a lie often enough, it becomes journalism."
ABC's Mantra
its also what Gohring said... you know the NAZI from WW2.
That should be a t-shirt and a bumper sticker!
Love it
They've been copying the BBC...they've been a waste of space for the last couple.of decades.
Both Australian and American ABCs - plus CBS, CNN and PMSNBC (the latter per the late Rush Limbaugh)
I am an American living in the U. S. and I must turn to Sky News Australia for credible news coverage. Thanks for your coverage of the American news scene.
msnbc is reliable 😂
@@christopherdailey 🙂😊😃😄😆😂🤣
@@christopherdailey Yes, reliably wrong.
@@christopherdailey you've seriously got to be kidding!!!
@@christopherdailey MSNBC is a total horse shit network.
They should NOT be subsidized by taxpayers' money.
Its basically impossible for this to be accidental. It was clearly doctored on purpose
twice
As a professional audio/video editor, I concur.
It could only be consciously deliberate. On both occasions.
The only inadvertent thing was getting caught
@@SusanPearce_H As a recreational vid graphic's creator and editor I agree 100%
@@SusanPearce_H Yep. Sounds of gunshots don't just appear in video editing. You have to be specifically adding in sound effects to the sound tracks of the project files.
As an ex soldier I’m disgusted… not that these woke fools would care.
Your sacrifice was for their right to behave like assholes. They’ll never understand.
Thanks for trying to do the right thing with your service sir ! Im sure you were asking yourself why a few times. However i believe you are a patriotic American and i salute you for serving .
Defund them.
Should be defunded and shutdown because this broadcaster has been destroying the Australian soldiers lives.
Defund?? Arrest them all for 8 billion counts of fraud. They're lying to the entire planet.
Bring it on!
That wont happen because they are woke.
pull their broadcast license. Give the frequency to Mother Earth News or something.
The MSM does this garbage daily
The sad thing is it is perfectly legal to do it in the USA thanks to Obama.
They are LIARS! You have to go OUT OF YOUR WAY to edit those extra gunshots into a report!
There should be criminal charges and long prison sentences over this - they lied to try to put an innocent man in prison for life.
💯..absolutely
They were actually hoping he would un alive himself
And slandered and smeared the entire ADF
@@Lemmetellyousomethin Very good point you have there
ive been advocating for a "reverse uno" law where the accuser gets the punishment the accused would have gotten had the lie been true
This ABC ‘incident’ is an exemplary example of left wing journalism at its deceitful finest.
💯
This you, bro? 👴
ABC cheer squad eh. Do you want the ABC to edit it for you?@jackrainbow560
@NoWindNoSunNoPower Looks like I'm not allowed to comment! This is my third try and the "algorithms" keep knocking me back
Wow! Claiming to make truth more truthful. This is old style Soviet additions to exaggerate and distort for propaganda purposes.
How would one “accidentally” ADD gunshots to a footage?
Did he just trip and they fell in there?
Absolute joke ABC
A trip and fall was probably how that guy was accidentally made.😂
Maybe they just had a few extra gunshots lying around in the edit room that’s why they call it the ‘edit’ room. - As to “finding no evidence”, what was he expecting to find a smoking gun?
The same way someone accidentally cheats on their spouse with a coworker for 3 years and commits paternity fraud so you raise a child thinking he is your own. "Just an accident"
It’s not your ABC, it their ABC - the radical left - you just fund it for them.
Take away their broadcast licence! We don't need them!
AMEN to that!
As a taxpayer,,I would appreciate some accountability immediately
The ABC "sincerely regret and apologise" for being caught.
Precisely.
The taxpayer regrets and apologises funding a leftist biased media sham.
Legacy media has lost all trust from the public, it's never coming back. I used to be skeptical of legacy media, today I just discount their propaganda disguised as reporting outright. They've earned that level of contempt.
💯
Exactly..
Why is the taxpayer still funding the ABC in 2024?
Good point.
State-owned and -sponsored media outlets
- The Beeb, ABC(Australia), CBC(Canada) et al -
passed sell-by quite a long while ago.
RINO's
and for some reason they are upset Russia funds the news here. I guess they have a problem with Putin not lying.
@@robertsmith2956not sure what a nickname for an American politician has to do with an Australian broadcasting company but go off
@@N1korasu State bad actors. Double agents for foreign governments.
It was just easier to type the synonym.
I trust this reporter is being charged - everyone should be DEMANDING this
@modifeyedgas1chain of command
Reporter and producer at the very least. Outright lies were told and embarrassing a LOT of service people. Several others at the ABC should also be sacked.
That's not edited by a reporter, but a political activist.
Give their broadcast license to Joe Rogan.
I would like to see a lot more than a VERBAL APOLOGY ✝️🇺🇸😠😠😠😠😠
I'm a news video editor, there is NO WAY you can mistakenly ADD more shots to a video clip unless you were doing it purposely.
not an 'error' - a manipulation of facts
Correction: - a deliberate manipulation of facts
Aka a lie
Why aren't heads rolling, defund this horrible abc
Labour government.
if your a communist its ok , thats what i have noticed.
@@SusanPearce_H Even with a Liberal government, they'd need the will and grit to put together an Eliot Ness team to go in and root out the Abject Leftism.
How do you inadvertently add gun shots. That is a complete and deliberate act. Absolutely disgraceful. The independent investigation what a joke. Sky have summed this up perfectly however heads need to role
Thank you Sky News Australia 👏👏👏
All I hear is "next time we will do better to fake the footage".
As an American I know exactly what you guys are going through. It's just immoral
That's nothing, tried the UK lately, bloody communists!?!
Utter waste of taxpayer funding.
Wrongthink! You're supposed to enjoy and trust your tax-payer funded propaganda.
it was on purpose.
therefore it was NOT a waste.
it just seems that way to you because their goal was to broadcast lies, and you think their goal was to broadcast truth
NOT ENOUGH!!!!! Remove their license!!!!!!!!!
Somebody drag the producer to court & get him to disgorge all the money usurped over the years.... and fire him!
And they wonder why Trump calls them fake
He calls the Australian Broadcast Company fake? I mean they are, like the American one, but two different organizations.
@@silverbackag9790He lumps them all together. He doesn’t go after one network. The industry is fake.
@@silverbackag9790 Trump is referring to all Mainstream/ Legacy Media as they are all owned either by the leftwing givernments or leftwing billionaires. All fake news like Orwell's 1984, to indoctrinate the gullible and lazy audience.
Not the same! They are better than American Lamestream media! During the co¹⁹ the only people who spoke more truths!
@@silverbackag9790you raised an excellent point (this is not the same network that doctored the K interview on 60 minutes) but as already stated, Trump doesn’t differentiate between stations but is calling attention to an industry that is more propaganda and marketing than news and journalism.
Take their license ban them from TV. Remember No One’s Above The Law?
That includes Trump, correct? If only.
There is no reason that the FCC couldn’t pull their broadcast license. That is exactly what the FCC was established to do.
@@NC-Mama-Bear tds still lol!
@@NC-Mama-Bear _"That includes Trump, correct? If only."_ And the people like Jack Smith that is now fleeing the country correct? If only.
_"Take their license ban them from TV."_ Unfortunately it was Obama that ended the Smith Mundt act of 1951 in 2012 that prohibited news agencies from broadcasting government propaganda to the American citizens. So, thanks to Obama that made it perfectly legal.
Inadvertently? That’s a crock of bs.
So glad to see them exposed!!
Compounding the ‘error’ with grotesque dishonesty.
Evil ABC - defund these sickos!
ABC = Always Broadcasts Crap!
Bring it on!
Disney owns ABC. Disney co-chairman Dana Walden is a close friend of Kamala Harris and Doug Emhoff. Walden arranged the Trump-Harris debate, and will likely be named CEO of Disney Entertainment in 2026, when Bob Iger is finally kicked out of Disney. Let that sink in for a moment. The Leftists are EVERYWHERE in US media.
An error I think NOT, bring charges against those responsible and defund the ABC.
Good point.
State-owned and -sponsored media outlets
- The Beeb, ABC(Australia), CBC(Canada) et al -
passed sell-by quite a long while ago.
The entire Management of ABC needs to be removed, any reporter that has had dodgy reports needs to go as well.
The ABC needs to go….
When it comes to the ABC, the tail wags the dog.
@@510gt1 Yes, we don't need them. Waste of taxpayers' money funding a propaganda news outlet who even try to indoctrinate children into leftist views.
@@510gt1 Good point.
State-owned and -sponsored media outlets
- The Beeb, ABC(Australia), CBC(Canada) et al -
passed sell-by quite a long while ago.
Guess that means gut ABC and close it down since from top to bottom all are involved in lies and criminal activity
Cut off all public funding and revoke press credentials.
They have become paid activists.
This reporter and the rest involved must be held accountable . THIS IS A CRIMINAL ACT that nearly destroyed an innocent person. THE ABC CRIMINALS MUST BE CHARGED. We need justice for the man they set out to frame and destroy.
Deliberately done. We all know that. SHAME
There's no such thing as "inadvertently" adding additional gunshot noises.
Wasn't just noises they also added more shell caseings being ejected from the gun.
@mackheadrum1295 kinda irrelevant to the point that I'm making that there's no such thing as "inadvertently adding" things like this. It was deliberate and they knew exactly what they were doing otherwise they wouldn't have done it.
@@Steve_P_B yes but like the person at ABC is saying ow ya we added the 5 extra gun shots on accident as an audio error. As well as having a video multiple video errors that all happend to slip past everyone. How many times can you fuck up for it to be intentional.
@@mackheadrum1295or, more to the point, these are supposed to be professional editors, how many times can someone fuck up before it's clear that it's deliberate?
@@Steve_P_B i think were talking past each other. i also think they did this intentionally
SHUT DOWN THE ABC NOW !!!!
"Inadvertently"... Really?
"Our" ABC's utter contempt for those who pay for it is on full display here.
What else have the ABC “Accidentally” misled Australia on other events?
@@IanDaniel-DataAnalytics They've misled Australia by saying they are journalists
If the ABC reported that WA was towards the west I'd pull up a map to check.
What else? Everything.
Cough cough cough cough
It needs to be said, most Australians absolutely *loathe* the ABC.
Hear! Hear!
Americans do as well.
Most Canadians loathe the CBC...Canadian Broadcasting Corporation.
Not bloody good enough. And no consequences yet again. Defund this abomination NOW
0:55 How do you inadvertently introduce gunshots into a video without doing it on purpose? It can't happen! They're still lying even when they're trying to convince us they're telling the truth.
Shut them down
I refuse to even look at the ABC. What a disgrace. Good to see our taxes hard at work. So WOKE.
Defund.
Bring it on!
@@richardsaunders3743Sure thing
Nothing they report can ever be trusted again.
They paid $400k because they looked about someone but refused to apologize? I would have told them they could pay me $800k with no apology or $400k with an apology. It would have been interesting to see what they chose.
We have extensively investigated ourselves, and found ourselves blameless.
How many other times have they done this, but haven't been caught?
Plenty no doubt!!!
The ABC is constitutionally incapable of reporting truthfully. Every stage of production from staff hiring to editing is run through a left wing filter that ensures a left wing bias hardwired into the content.
If Dutton promises to put the ABC on a subscriber only basis, he won't lose one
Green or Labor vote.
He will gain Conservative votes.
The bias consistently shown by a PUBLICLY FUNDED broadcaster is disgusting.
A Royal Commission needs to be held to investigate that lot.
Who is behind it all?
@@NoWindNoSunNoPowerNot my fault.
@@NoWindNoSunNoPowerwho is just one of them.
@@NoWindNoSunNoPower Media as usual, To inflate nothing into a breaking story, But more likely the editing was done before the Edited Footage was sold to the Media for a large amount of Money.
We have exactly the same kind of thing here in the UK with the BBC, which is also publicly funded.
Close them down.
they finally haven't fooled enough people, enough of the time
Inadvertently my rear. It was intentionally added.
Absolutely disgraceful, they need their broadcasting license revoked.
People should go to prison for this kind of disgraceful fraud.
Ok so they added gunshots twice Inadvertently…yeah nah. Defund now. Let’s take it as a referendum to the next election. It would be a resounding YES.
Corporate media sucks.😢
American here. This is horrible and should never happen but this wouldn’t even register on the fake news meter over here.
Take them to Court, and hold the Criminal Liable.
Why are we still funding this garbage?
We don't want their apologies, we want their resignations. They have tried to tell us it was an accident? So that means their incompetent, so get rid of them. We don't need to spend 1.2 billion on incompetent either!
Makes them extremely qualified to be unionised government employees. Liars and incompetent.
"They have tried to tell us it was an accident? So that means their incompetent"
anyone that ever edited videos can tell you that there is no way to "accidentally" add gunshots, cut from the end and paste to the start of the video and so on. it HAS to be deliberate
they lied back when they broadcasted this. they are lying now
@@bluefmiabsolutely!
Exactly how would it be done 'inadvertently'? How?
Long gone are the days of accuracy in journalism.
Lies upon lies, the use of the word "inadvertently" twice, only used to diminish the severity of what they've done.
How can it be accurate when they make additions ? The reporter tried to create a FALSE ACCOUNT and imply a situation that wasn’t accurate !
Surely this is an actual crime? ...which is a jailable offence.
sacked him now
Love your sky News hi Rita❤❤❤❤❤
Defund now
BRING IT ON!
Fine them, jail them , Or Defund them. Get rid of the corrupt ABC.
Hear! Hear!
They should do all of the above!
All of the above!
*_inadvertently?_*
Give me a break.
😆😆😆😆😆
TV station editors are experts in fake news and removing context to make things more sensational. The ABCs Media Watch likes to pretend the ABC is above such things
You know, this is like such a petty thing to what really goes on in media, EVERY DAY.
What any extraordinary disgrace. It is impossible it was accidental - how does an editor “accidentally” add in gunshots to paint a picture of guilt. Leadership is rotten from the top. Turn them off.
Defund them
Yes. Defund them
Unfortunately most people will never hear this
Note , we are not seeing this on American news. They will not broadcast this story because it is proof they are manipulating not reporting.
Remove their broadcast license and defund them.
That’s criminal.
How is this not criminal
Now I fully understand the term "urnalism". Stop pissing on my boots while telling me it's raining.
DEFUND THE PRICKS
Bring it on!
This is horrific but the saddest part for me is that I’m not at all surprised.
I stopped watching corporate-owned news years ago.
HOLD THEM ACCOUNTABLE. NOW!
They should close that news station 🚉
What action is being taken against the people involved in this fiasco? These weren't mistakes, this was a deliberate planned action to shame and discredit Australian soldiers. I am an ex digger and I cant imagine how our soldiers must feel when an Australian government department is conspiring to undermine their morale and give comfort and support to our enemies.
Did someone say treason?
Hear! Hear!
How tf is it we have to pay for that garbage organisation. Fucking sick of paying so much tax in this country to have it used against us.
Bring on the lawsuits!!!!!!!!
pro tip: if you DO NOT edit raw footage....you never have to worry about being caught doing anything "accidental".
Jail for lying to congress.
@@teling2134 "You can't touch us, we are to big to go to jail, Hah,hah-haa!"
If it wasn't intentional, explain how it happend.
Twice..
They did, they said "Whoops!" That should do it....right?
@toter-drache Disney....😵💫
Inadvertently and accidentally 😂😂😂 Oh please
Inadvertently ??? I wouldn't even be able to do it advertently
Tip of the iceberg…
Inadvertently? Bull shit!