The way he says: "I've always worked" and the depth of humanity, perseverance, and dedication he conveys in that single quietly stated phrase has inspired me to work hard.
Working hard? No, one day automation and/or AI will replace thousands, if not millions, of hard workers. For example, the cotton combined harvester eliminated manual labor in the cotton field. We must work intelligently, not hard.
@@charlescurran1289 Freeattle/Peeattle, more like it. It's an embarrassment and a tragedy that it is allowed to be such a major force affecting the lives of us who live near it, but thankfully, not in it.
I wish they showed this movie in schools. My mom showed it to me when I was around 18. I was reading Marxist literature and just getting weird about things. The film changed my perspective. Read the book years later. It was a rough read but people could learn a lot. Pasternack was in a Russian prison for 3 years for just his writings. He lived this and I cannot believe people are pushing this now. Very sad. 😓
It's amazing how relevant this film is today. Look up the scene "The private life is dead" and then examine what the far-left want today. Guilty of "wrong-think". They want the private life to be dead, to control and censor everyone they disagree with through technology, social media, and education. All the while they brand anyone who is critical of them as fascists or "fashies", a cheap tactic to silence opposition. Honestly it makes me want to slap some people.
@@timpatrick_ you realize that boris pasternack the writer was in a russian prison for 3 years for his writings which were considered dissention. Maybe youre the one who needs to read up on some history before you syart bashing people on here. This is very typical of today and I should guess you're young. They don't teach about The Bolshevik revolution in schools I'm sure and if they do I'm sure it's in a good light.
@@larissamaddas9361 not sure if they read anything except CNN, msn huff post articles. And I'm not being insulting just certain they don't have exposure like we probably have. Thinking different generation or really sheltered.
@@levvy3006 did you know this was written by Boris Pasternack who spent time in a Russian prison during this time for his writings??? They felt they were dissenting. Did you know that?? This is written by a REAL person who Suffered under this. How can you defend it?? More people died than in the Holocaust. Both are horrible but somehow people ignore this part of history lately. Smh
This scene shows the leftist utopia as it really was...where the rubber meets the road. Zhivago tries to shake the man's hand and is immediately rebuffed because there is no longer a place for familiarity. Later on Zhivago's brother shows up and snaps his fingers. In an instant, all of the peons (formerly peasants, but still on the lowest rung of the ladder) scurry like mice as he exerts his authority as a member of the Soviet secret police. The leftist utopia crushed the spirit of the individual and expected extreme obedience to the state. Never again.
Thanks Eric Schele for the post. "Dr. Zhivago" - what a marvelous film! A romance, a love-triangle. At the same time, the heart of the Russian Revolution, a struggle for freedom that went horribly awry. Truly memorable characters in every role, no matter how small. And the soundtrack: Lara's Theme, Yuri's Theme, Revolution, Varykino, The scenery, the seasons changing, the motif of falling leaves. Seen it so many times I can practically quote the whole film and can't wait for a chance to see it again.
Dear Pie.. I will ruin it for you now. Next time you see the movie, look at how the focus is on the actor's eyes. Look at how Laura's eyes spring open when she realizes she's going to be raped by Komarovsky in the dress shop. Look how she looks into the camera after the rape and you know she has made a decision to shoot him. Look at how Zhivago's teary eyes look at Lara when he makes a pass at her when she is ironing. Look at Laura's eyes when she sees Zhivago in the library.
+obsolete professor How could the focus on eyes ruin the film? Julie Christie (Lara) isn't pretty; her expressive blue eyes make her absolutely beautiful. Yuri's serious brown eyes enhance Omar Sharif's role as well.
Dear Pie.. I've invited people to watch this movie with me a hundred times. Many younger people have never heard of this movie. I guess I ruin it for them when I tell them to watch the eyes and the highlighting the director puts on the faces. They wind up focusing too much on the eyes. Laura's face is artificially light up in the library when she looks at Zhivago.. she seems simultaneously glow with joy and sadness. On a side.. When Tonya stands at the porch and sees Zhivago in the street coming towards the house.. she swings the glass door open. If you advance frame by frame, you will see that the director and crew is obscured by the reflection as she opens the door.. I am obsessed with this movie.
Ah.. another thing. When Laura brings her fiance to meet Komarovsky at the bistro (where he says it reminds him of his youth).. When they are discussing "experience", look how both Komarovsky and Laura lower their heads (in shame) when her fiance says that Laura is 17.. "and that speaks for itself (for the lack of "experience").
Do you dislike this scene? Expressing emotion without dialogue is good cinematic technique Komarovsky? A shameless egotist. He controls Lara and torments her because she feels shame. "Good man to shoot at."
By 1921 over half of original idealistic Bolsheviks were gone, mostly killed in the civil war. The party had expanded in numbers and the new members included many opportunists, careerists and gangsters. Also the educational level of party members fell dramatically as it became proletarian.
Lenin was a criminal. Stalin was a maniac. Trotsky was a butcher. Marx never worked a day in his life, impregnated his housekeeper and made his own son use the servants entrance. Communism collect scum like a grease trap.
@@brettonwoods9856 that is a retarded comment... like this is a good thing? You want to live like that? 20 million people died as a result of the Bolshevik revolution much of it due to starvation and freezing in the winter bc they didnt have food and firewood! Yeah communism is great! Read an actual freakin history book written by people who have lived it not one written by a retarded woke hipster millennial in black glasses who works for NYT... Boris Pastwenak the man who wrote this novel was sentenced to a prison camp(gulag) for just being critical of communism . If you're for that then I cant wait for you to get what's coming to you when it happens here. Because they will turn on you. They always do... they turned on the Kulaks- the farmers only bc they saw they were middle class and felt offended and jealous by that. At first they were all for farmers and then they became jealous bc they're spoiled ignorant children and started killing and locking them up... just bc they had a little land! You're a fool if you think this is a good thing.
@@dystopian2153 I have to say I did not expect a miniature essay. Many people have died in circumstances that could be cast as unjust all throughout history. Old people die in England today because they cannot afford their energy bills. What do we do about that? No-one really cares. Ho- hum. Sometimes change has to occur and there is a price to be paid. Politics is an amoral sphere. If you try to apply the good/ bad dichotomy you would send yourself mad; that dichotomy is up for manipulation by rhetoricians and propagandists.
@@dystopian2153 You should just shut your mouth. Boris Pasternak never went to prison in Russia or the Soviet Union. Many Russiand died in the civil war because of foreign countries who supported the Whites who were known for their cruelty towards peasants and workers.
@@brettonwoods9856 You realize that the tsar was thrown out in the february revolution right? And the Bolsheviks took over in the october revolution, when they overthrew democracy. People voted in an election, and did not pick the Bolshies.
Comrade Kaprugina! What a mean ole biddy she is. Nothing gets by her - a BIG frog in a very small pond - head of the Resident's Committee. Anyone know who played that part? Not on IMDB's full cast list. Thought I spotted her in a 1962 British movie ("I Thank a Fool"), playing a sweet sympathetic nurse. Obviously not Brenda de Banzie, Nurse Drew in that film. Who played Comrade K???
“Dr. Z, you didn’t build that!” We watched this movie in high school geography class. Because of this particular scene, I despise all leftists to this date.
@@pipn9090 I'm 27 twit. Go back to your basement and play on your Xbox. Ask your mommy if she'll make you a grilled cheese sandwich cut in squares, just the way you like them.
"Good, it needed reforming." This scene is funny! Its cool that Omar Sharif gets to do a bit of comedy in this scene with none other than Geraldine Chaplin!
Just read that the City of Los Angeles is considering a law to tax "unoccupied/under occupied" homes. If "they" decide you have more space in your home than you need, you are taxed. It's ostensibly to solve the homeless problem in LA.
I mean, the homeless could try to find employment. If they can’t find any, go elsewhere and try again. Everyone has the power and ability to work in one way, shape, or form.
This perspective is oversimplified and misleading. While some unemployed people may be just one handshake away from meaningful and adequately compensated work, many others have multiple, significant barriers to earning a living wage such as former stay-at-home moms with a barren resume, or anyone without access to basic facilities who is significantly disadvantaged at interviews by arriving unclean and unrested. Until someone has enough essential life elements in place (secure and reliable shelter, secure storage of personal effects, consistent and convenient access to facilities for food preparation preparation and maintenance of personal hygiene, protection from threats of violence, transportation modes sufficient to reach necessary services within a manageable radius of living quarters, somewhere to receive correspondence and a mode of outward communication, access to healthcare and to information resources, enough financial flexibility to meet unplanned obligations or shortfalls without incurring further penalties, a minimally employable skillset and an established social network to provide references and to exchange support with) they simply cannot participate in society nor be productive enough to contribute. It is too easy for those of us who are already living manageable lives to overlook the enormous challenge and necessity of having the barest of resources in place before being able to start caring for oneself.
@@oilersridersbluejays And yeah, that is another issue. Many jobs pay so little you can't even afford to get to them. I have had this personally happen to me, and have seen others with that issue.
The male commie tried to shake Zhivago's hand until he saw the lady commie show up. Interesting little moment in this scene. I would like to think in some way this man knows he (and the ideology of marxism) is wrong but is powerless. Women cling to this type of ideology since they need men. In this case the man is replaced by the state. So when the woman who shows up, obviously old and childless (like feminist today) he cowers. He knows her ideology is unshakeable since without the state (bolsheviks) she is nothing.
@@romangeneral23 the feminist archetype is percieved this way hy many including me. Bugger off you book burning leftofascists statist. Cultural Marxism will be relegated to bottom of the lake of fire to burn for eternity.
This is a must see for all those spoiled, self-entitled basement dwellers who do nothing but whine about this country. Keep complaining about all you have, continue to show ingratitude and no humility and one day you will get what you unknowingly cry for. This scene.
like the squatters in DETROIT OR WA DC don't move to those cities if you are the property owner the government force you to live with non rent paying squatters and pay for them .
Though her character Tonya has adjusted to the circumstances,when they are finally alone you can see she wants to break out in laughter,showing she has a sense of humor,Geraldine Chaplin was a lovely young woman with her father's smile and mothers delicate looks.
Comrade Yelkin and Comrade Kaprugina are strangely reminiscent of Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren respectively. Every young person who is embracing socialism as a way to create a more "just" society should see this movie.
I just love this movie! Just as timely and appropriate today as it was 55+ years ago. All of the Millenials should be forced to watch it. I say forced because I doubt their short attention spans would draw them to it voluntarily.
Your own generation should have paid a lot closer attention to it. The fact that you'd make such a hypocritical statement by implying forced indoctrination to something that aligns with your worldview shows how much of a hypocrite you are.
@@therevolvingmonk whatever dude. I wasn't implying anything about anyone. I stated plainly that Millenials have short attention spans and probably wouldn't be drawn to a 3-hour movie made 55 years ago. NO more. No less.
@@WAHJRYou must not have a very good attention span either. Go watch the scene when Yevgraf arrives at the dam and is talking to the guy about the workers. There's an interaction about the younger generation that you need to think on, if you're capable of it.
I wish someone who knows how -would make a clip of the "Your attitude hass been noticed!" and "Vher are your pap pers! Vee must see your pap pers!!" scenes?
The rich have always tormented the poor with living space, but for poor people to look down on someone as humble as this man is confronting, its evil how bad people can hide in the poor rages of a town and take advantage of what the actual poor should have.
and yet at these outdoor rock concerts we have millionaire artists whining to snot knows frat kids who can afford 250 quid tickets about how capitalism has failed them
It’s a pity imperial Germany failed to see where the real enemy was. They could’ve whipped out Russia and bolsheviks from the face of earth but they choose to fought a hopeless war in the west, where they could never emerge victorious. Twenty years later the price for this mistake was paid, by them and many other nations.
The stifled handshake is understandable.. Russian men shake hands on greeting almost as a reflex.. For the party to discourage handshakes as being too ‘personal’, and as a precaution against spreading disease, is logical..
Sen Chris Murphy of CT introduced a bill called The National Strategy for Social Connection Act just recently. It aims to do something very similar. Look it up.
The Surgeon General recently declared an epidemic of loneliness and isolation in the United States, noting that social isolation and loneliness pose a significant risk to individual health and longevity, create economic cost for individuals and communities, and decrease community resilience, safety, and economic prosperity. The National Strategy for Social Connection Act is a simple roadmap to begin addressing this epidemic by naming the problem, developing solutions, educating the public about best practices, and improving data about the scope of the problem. Create an Office of Social Connection Policy to advise the President on loneliness and isolation and how these issues relate to the economy, public health, national security, the environment, and civic and community engagement. Form an Advisory Council within the Office to convene stakeholders and work across federal departments and agencies to develop effective strategies to improve social infrastructure, quality of life, and community engagement in the United States. The Office would develop a government-wide strategy to integrate social connection policy across federal departments and agencies, such as transportation, housing, health, education, and labor, to promote connection and strengthen communities. Similar to existing national guidelines on nutrition, sleep, and physical activity, the Office would issue research-based best practices on how to better engage and connect within our local communities. Provide consistent, sustainable funding to support the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s research on social connection, loneliness, and social infrastructure.
Everyone is commenting on how terrible this regime was, and that's true. But don't forget that it only came about because people had been pushed too far by ultra-conservative forces. It was because many countries adopted elements of socialism that they managed to avoid communism. Russia did not follow the same path, and many people paid the price. Maybe something to think about when you're trying to compare this to the relatively moderate policies of people like Obama and Biden.
This scene was an ideological piece, strategically placed in a film that was released at the height of the Cold War. It created hysteria all over the world, the middle class all over the world when they hear about socialism they start to fear that a group of people coming from the streets will come to live in their huts! 😆😆
Michael Malice has documented the history of the Soviet Union in his newest book. I think this is a pretty generous treatment compared to some of what was going on.
@@paulfroelich1024 I understand, but that's not what I meant, I said that this movie was made during the cold war and served to frighten those who watched it... like a scarecrow.
this movie serves as a warning, to those societies that fall into oligarchy, the end stage of pure capitalism. Either progress to something better, or face communism. Your choice.
The way he says: "I've always worked" and the depth of humanity, perseverance, and dedication he conveys in that single quietly stated phrase has inspired me to work hard.
Agree. The film taught me a lot too. Thanks to my mom showing it to me for educational purposes.
Working hard? No, one day automation and/or AI will replace thousands, if not millions, of hard workers. For example, the cotton combined harvester eliminated manual labor in the cotton field. We must work intelligently, not hard.
@@infonomics We not all meant to be Tech Bros.
"The food on your plate
Now belongs to the State,
A collective regime of Peace And Love!"
Is that anything like the summer of love in Seattle?
@@charlescurran1289 Freeattle/Peeattle, more like it. It's an embarrassment and a tragedy that it is allowed to be such a major force affecting the lives of us who live near it, but thankfully, not in it.
where everything is free except the people
“There was living space for thirteen families in this one house.” -- The voice of communism. You can still hear it’s echo today.
@Jacques Cardinal Only a few. Those can easily be identified as those who refuse to wear the mask.
@Jacques Cardinal "Vher are your pap pers! Vee must see your pap pers!!"
Just wait till next year now that Harris er I mean Biden is the new president.
The $hitheads are bringing it to our nation now...
It’s all of Western Society now.
I wish they showed this movie in schools. My mom showed it to me when I was around 18. I was reading Marxist literature and just getting weird about things. The film changed my perspective. Read the book years later. It was a rough read but people could learn a lot. Pasternack was in a Russian prison for 3 years for just his writings. He lived this and I cannot believe people are pushing this now. Very sad. 😓
@Aaron Burr I did not know that. Thanks for sharing. 😉
Aaron Burr Marx rejected the label, but he never renounced his beliefs in revolutionary communism.
It's amazing how relevant this film is today. Look up the scene "The private life is dead" and then examine what the far-left want today. Guilty of "wrong-think". They want the private life to be dead, to control and censor everyone they disagree with through technology, social media, and education. All the while they brand anyone who is critical of them as fascists or "fashies", a cheap tactic to silence opposition. Honestly it makes me want to slap some people.
@@AngryToasterOven i agree with everything you say. Its so frustrating to just watch the ignorance
@@Evil0tto thank you for sharing this piece of info. Interesting..
Imagine showing this masterpiece in schools, nowadays. The majority will lack the ability to understand it.
They’d just focus on the infidelity, call him a cheater, and agree with the communists.
This scene scared the daylights out of me when I saw it on the big screen in 1966, but I never thought it would come to pass. Yet here we are.
Scary, really scary. We can't let the Democrats destroy our country.
Your comment is 100% accurate.
@@cliffordkinnear9705 Open your eyes. You are upside down. Trump and Putin are a nuclear threat to the world.
@@Operafreak9 They're to blind to take notice of it. Damn fools.
U all so fricking paranoid xD stfu u ignorant US-americans
Love this scene. Condenses communism to its essence.
Yea, an entire socioeconomic system can be condensed to a bullshit western Hollywood scene. You're just full of intellectual analysis.
This was real life in communist Russia, written by a Russian who experienced this. Go read the book.
@@timpatrick_ you realize that boris pasternack the writer was in a russian prison for 3 years for his writings which were considered dissention. Maybe youre the one who needs to read up on some history before you syart bashing people on here. This is very typical of today and I should guess you're young. They don't teach about The Bolshevik revolution in schools I'm sure and if they do I'm sure it's in a good light.
@@larissamaddas9361 not sure if they read anything except CNN, msn huff post articles. And I'm not being insulting just certain they don't have exposure like we probably have. Thinking different generation or really sheltered.
@@levvy3006 did you know this was written by Boris Pasternack who spent time in a Russian prison during this time for his writings??? They felt they were dissenting. Did you know that?? This is written by a REAL person who Suffered under this. How can you defend it?? More people died than in the Holocaust. Both are horrible but somehow people ignore this part of history lately. Smh
I like how the brother then comes in and everyone leaves very obsequiously.
He just snaps his fingers...the terror.
This scene shows the leftist utopia as it really was...where the rubber meets the road. Zhivago tries to shake the man's hand and is immediately rebuffed because there is no longer a place for familiarity. Later on Zhivago's brother shows up and snaps his fingers. In an instant, all of the peons (formerly peasants, but still on the lowest rung of the ladder) scurry like mice as he exerts his authority as a member of the Soviet secret police. The leftist utopia crushed the spirit of the individual and expected extreme obedience to the state. Never again.
If you think this propaganda film is fact you have low IQ. But then again all rightists have low IQ.
Well said.
@@levvy3006 It's based on fact, and only subhuman leftist filth deny it.
Sorry, but this is one of thousands of accounts of what it was like. I'm certain they all didn't lie about it.
@@bb5242 why would we have to rely of those accounts? Don;'t we have N Korea, Cuba, Russia, China, today? Look at what is happening in Hong Kong.
Thanks Eric Schele for the post. "Dr. Zhivago" - what a marvelous film! A romance, a love-triangle. At the same time, the heart of the Russian Revolution, a struggle for freedom that went horribly awry. Truly memorable characters in every role, no matter how small. And the soundtrack: Lara's Theme, Yuri's Theme, Revolution, Varykino, The scenery, the seasons changing, the motif of falling leaves. Seen it so many times I can practically quote the whole film and can't wait for a chance to see it again.
Dear Pie.. I will ruin it for you now. Next time you see the movie, look at how the focus is on the actor's eyes. Look at how Laura's eyes spring open when she realizes she's going to be raped by Komarovsky in the dress shop. Look how she looks into the camera after the rape and you know she has made a decision to shoot him. Look at how Zhivago's teary eyes look at Lara when he makes a pass at her when she is ironing. Look at Laura's eyes when she sees Zhivago in the library.
+obsolete professor How could the focus on eyes ruin the film? Julie Christie (Lara) isn't pretty; her expressive blue eyes make her absolutely beautiful. Yuri's serious brown eyes enhance Omar Sharif's role as well.
Dear Pie.. I've invited people to watch this movie with me a hundred times. Many younger people have never heard of this movie. I guess I ruin it for them when I tell them to watch the eyes and the highlighting the director puts on the faces. They wind up focusing too much on the eyes. Laura's face is artificially light up in the library when she looks at Zhivago.. she seems simultaneously glow with joy and sadness. On a side.. When Tonya stands at the porch and sees Zhivago in the street coming towards the house.. she swings the glass door open. If you advance frame by frame, you will see that the director and crew is obscured by the reflection as she opens the door.. I am obsessed with this movie.
Ah.. another thing. When Laura brings her fiance to meet Komarovsky at the bistro (where he says it reminds him of his youth).. When they are discussing "experience", look how both Komarovsky and Laura lower their heads (in shame) when her fiance says that Laura is 17.. "and that speaks for itself (for the lack of "experience").
Do you dislike this scene? Expressing emotion without dialogue is good cinematic technique Komarovsky? A shameless egotist. He controls Lara and torments her because she feels shame. "Good man to shoot at."
Contrast the taking of a private house with the taking of private property under the eviction moratorium. Be careful what you wish for.
Portland.
"There was living space for thirteen families in this one house."
- Eric Adams, NYC Mayor, probably.
Exactly.
And AOC.
00:56 - When China reports abnormally low Covid-19 numbers...
By 1921 over half of original idealistic Bolsheviks were gone, mostly killed in the civil war. The party had expanded in numbers and the new members included many opportunists, careerists and gangsters. Also the educational level of party members fell dramatically as it became proletarian.
Lenin was a criminal. Stalin was a maniac. Trotsky was a butcher. Marx never worked a day in his life, impregnated his housekeeper and made his own son use the servants entrance.
Communism collect scum like a grease trap.
Cope.
This is why my parents and I left Yugoslavia many years ago. This sums up Communism and the utter destruction of Russia.
Would you prefer to be the serf of some robber baron, who employs a religious leader to tell you that God ordained it so?
@@brettonwoods9856 that is a retarded comment... like this is a good thing? You want to live like that? 20 million people died as a result of the Bolshevik revolution much of it due to starvation and freezing in the winter bc they didnt have food and firewood!
Yeah communism is great! Read an actual freakin history book written by people who have lived it not one written by a retarded woke hipster millennial in black glasses who works for NYT...
Boris Pastwenak the man who wrote this novel was sentenced to a prison camp(gulag) for just being critical of communism . If you're for that then I cant wait for you to get what's coming to you when it happens here. Because they will turn on you. They always do... they turned on the Kulaks- the farmers only bc they saw they were middle class and felt offended and jealous by that. At first they were all for farmers and then they became jealous bc they're spoiled ignorant children and started killing and locking them up... just bc they had a little land!
You're a fool if you think this is a good thing.
@@dystopian2153 I have to say I did not expect a miniature essay. Many people have died in circumstances that could be cast as unjust all throughout history. Old people die in England today because they cannot afford their energy bills. What do we do about that? No-one really cares. Ho- hum. Sometimes change has to occur and there is a price to be paid. Politics is an amoral sphere. If you try to apply the good/ bad dichotomy you would send yourself mad; that dichotomy is up for manipulation by rhetoricians and propagandists.
@@dystopian2153 You should just shut your mouth. Boris Pasternak never went to prison in Russia or the Soviet Union. Many Russiand died in the civil war because of foreign countries who supported the Whites who were known for their cruelty towards peasants and workers.
@@brettonwoods9856 You realize that the tsar was thrown out in the february revolution right? And the Bolsheviks took over in the october revolution, when they overthrew democracy. People voted in an election, and did not pick the Bolshies.
This movie pulls so many punches and it STILL makes Communism look like the worst idea any human being has ever had.
if you sick sociopath then it does
Great quote! I'll use this one myself.
Comrade Kaprugina! What a mean ole biddy she is. Nothing gets by her - a BIG frog in a very small pond - head of the Resident's Committee. Anyone know who played that part? Not on IMDB's full cast list. Thought I spotted her in a 1962 British movie ("I Thank a Fool"), playing a sweet sympathetic nurse. Obviously not Brenda de Banzie, Nurse Drew in that film. Who played Comrade K???
She lives today, in US Condo association boards!
If Bernie was elected.
Or if Biden is elected...wake up America!
This is already happening with Biden!
This scene was filmed in Berlin 2017.
RAPEfugiess welcome!! xDD
Love this scene. I think there is a line missing from one of the peasants as he ascends the stairs.
“Dr. Z, you didn’t build that!”
We watched this movie in high school geography class. Because of this particular scene, I despise all leftists to this date.
MARTHA'S VINEYARD Comrades.
th-cam.com/video/mq__Z-Z_Ofs/w-d-xo.html
They say they fought for the workers but it was nothing but smoke and mirrors.
It's just another version of Feudalism.
If they were remake this movie, Chelsea Handler would make a perfect Comrade Kapugina.
Wake up America. This is exactly what's happening right now in the US. Keep voting Democrat if this is acceptable.
boomer moment
@@pipn9090 I'm 27 twit. Go back to your basement and play on your Xbox. Ask your mommy if she'll make you a grilled cheese sandwich cut in squares, just the way you like them.
@luna66 Uh, no. I was born in 1994. Shows what a twit you are. LOL!!!
@@pipn9090 dumb moment
@@Arlo360-Official 🤣🤣👏👏👏
Poor old Zhivago. He's so unenlightened. (sarcasm)
A scene into the future of Comrade Corbyn's Britain
Join the fightback.
populistpartyuk.blogspot.com/
"Good, it needed reforming."
This scene is funny! Its cool that Omar Sharif gets to do a bit of comedy in this scene with none other than Geraldine Chaplin!
Boy, Comrade Karen is a real sweetie isn't she. Coming soon to the US.
But Dr. Z, you didn’t build that. And at some point you’ve made enough money.
Just read that the City of Los Angeles is considering a law to tax "unoccupied/under occupied" homes. If "they" decide you have more space in your home than you need, you are taxed. It's ostensibly to solve the homeless problem in LA.
I mean, the homeless could try to find employment. If they can’t find any, go elsewhere and try again. Everyone has the power and ability to work in one way, shape, or form.
This perspective is oversimplified and misleading. While some unemployed people may be just one handshake away from meaningful and adequately compensated work, many others have multiple, significant barriers to earning a living wage such as former stay-at-home moms with a barren resume, or anyone without access to basic facilities who is significantly disadvantaged at interviews by arriving unclean and unrested. Until someone has enough essential life elements in place (secure and reliable shelter, secure storage of personal effects, consistent and convenient access to facilities for food preparation preparation and maintenance of personal hygiene, protection from threats of violence, transportation modes sufficient to reach necessary services within a manageable radius of living quarters, somewhere to receive correspondence and a mode of outward communication, access to healthcare and to information resources, enough financial flexibility to meet unplanned obligations or shortfalls without incurring further penalties, a minimally employable skillset and an established social network to provide references and to exchange support with) they simply cannot participate in society nor be productive enough to contribute. It is too easy for those of us who are already living manageable lives to overlook the enormous challenge and necessity of having the barest of resources in place before being able to start caring for oneself.
@@oilersridersbluejays And yeah, that is another issue. Many jobs pay so little you can't even afford to get to them. I have had this personally happen to me, and have seen others with that issue.
Like the hotels in West LA
The male commie tried to shake Zhivago's hand until he saw the lady commie show up. Interesting little moment in this scene. I would like to think in some way this man knows he (and the ideology of marxism) is wrong but is powerless. Women cling to this type of ideology since they need men. In this case the man is replaced by the state. So when the woman who shows up, obviously old and childless (like feminist today) he cowers. He knows her ideology is unshakeable since without the state (bolsheviks) she is nothing.
You don't know what Marxism is. Also this is a propaganda film. Not based on facts.
so all feminist are old and childless ?
Shut the fuck up alt-right troll
@@romangeneral23 the feminist archetype is percieved this way hy many including me. Bugger off you book burning leftofascists statist. Cultural Marxism will be relegated to bottom of the lake of fire to burn for eternity.
@@romangeneral23 Some are young and childless
@@levvy3006 Sorry Comrade. The source material was written by a guy who experienced this. YOU are the one stating things not based on facts.
This is a must see for all those spoiled, self-entitled basement dwellers who do nothing but whine about this country. Keep complaining about all you have, continue to show ingratitude and no humility and one day you will get what you unknowingly cry for. This scene.
Dios Sea Contigo U mean Antifa protesters.
very well said, Dios
Communism, what fun.
"There is no typhus in our city."
like the squatters in DETROIT OR WA DC don't move to those cities if you are the property owner the government force you to live with non rent paying squatters and pay for them
.
Geraldine Chaplin and her father have the same smile. Splitting image.
Though her character Tonya has adjusted to the circumstances,when they are finally alone you can see she wants to break out in laughter,showing she has a sense of humor,Geraldine Chaplin was a lovely young woman with her father's smile and mothers delicate looks.
Who's the actor playing George Monbiot?
Comrade Yelkin and Comrade Kaprugina are strangely reminiscent of Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren respectively. Every young person who is embracing socialism as a way to create a more "just" society should see this movie.
Good thing Dr. Zhivago didn’t over “estimate the value”of his property.
America 2020
We are rapidly approaching this. Get ready.
Bullshit. It's a damned MOVIE!!
America 20 years from now ?
th-cam.com/video/mq__Z-Z_Ofs/w-d-xo.html
I just love this movie! Just as timely and appropriate today as it was 55+ years ago. All of the Millenials should be forced to watch it. I say forced because I doubt their short attention spans would draw them to it voluntarily.
Yup!
Your own generation should have paid a lot closer attention to it. The fact that you'd make such a hypocritical statement by implying forced indoctrination to something that aligns with your worldview shows how much of a hypocrite you are.
@@therevolvingmonk whatever dude. I wasn't implying anything about anyone. I stated plainly that Millenials have short attention spans and probably wouldn't be drawn to a 3-hour movie made 55 years ago. NO more. No less.
@@WAHJRYou must not have a very good attention span either. Go watch the scene when Yevgraf arrives at the dam and is talking to the guy about the workers. There's an interaction about the younger generation that you need to think on, if you're capable of it.
So you would force a movie on ppl who DO NOT WANT THIS LIFE??! How Soviet of you!
Every Democrat voter needs to see the future they are voting for
well said Mr Baxi
MAGA is a cult!
I wish someone who knows how -would make a clip of the "Your attitude hass been noticed!" and "Vher are your pap pers! Vee must see your pap pers!!" scenes?
Definitely America 2021
6/7/2023
New York City took notes.
😡😡😡🤡
Doctor Zhivago is my second favorite movie. It shows what will be, which is in complete opposition to what should be...
... #1 It's A Wonderful Life.
The rich have always tormented the poor with living space, but for poor people to look down on someone as humble as this man is confronting, its evil how bad people can hide in the poor rages of a town and take advantage of what the actual poor should have.
Huh?
@@dystopian2153 I will second dystopian 21's comment. In other words, WTF is Errolea Brown saying ?
and yet at these outdoor rock concerts we have millionaire artists whining to snot knows frat kids who can afford 250 quid tickets about how capitalism has failed them
This is what's going to happen if Bernie get elected.
Good
More like what will happen when Biden/Kamala do.
that's 'Comrade Bernie' to you .... peasant!
Bernie Sanders and Nancy Pelosi.
"Most of history has been a dystopian future." - Goat
If an actual 🐐 stated that, I would believe it. Goats know what's up.
I rejected socialism at a very young age because of this scene.
It’s a pity imperial Germany failed to see where the real enemy was. They could’ve whipped out Russia and bolsheviks from the face of earth but they choose to fought a hopeless war in the west, where they could never emerge victorious. Twenty years later the price for this mistake was paid, by them and many other nations.
The stifled handshake is understandable.. Russian men shake hands on greeting almost as a reflex.. For the party to discourage handshakes as being too ‘personal’, and as a precaution against spreading disease, is logical..
Mon amor....Il encor n' est pas encuntree🐘♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Sen Chris Murphy of CT introduced a bill called The National Strategy for Social Connection Act just recently. It aims to do something very similar. Look it up.
The Surgeon General recently declared an epidemic of loneliness and isolation in the United States, noting that social isolation and loneliness pose a significant risk to individual health and longevity, create economic cost for individuals and communities, and decrease community resilience, safety, and economic prosperity. The National Strategy for Social Connection Act is a simple roadmap to begin addressing this epidemic by naming the problem, developing solutions, educating the public about best practices, and improving data about the scope of the problem. Create an Office of Social Connection Policy to advise the President on loneliness and isolation and how these issues relate to the economy, public health, national security, the environment, and civic and community engagement. Form an Advisory Council within the Office to convene stakeholders and work across federal departments and agencies to develop effective strategies to improve social infrastructure, quality of life, and community engagement in the United States. The Office would develop a government-wide strategy to integrate social connection policy across federal departments and agencies, such as transportation, housing, health, education, and labor, to promote connection and strengthen communities. Similar to existing national guidelines on nutrition, sleep, and physical activity, the Office would issue research-based best practices on how to better engage and connect within our local communities. Provide consistent, sustainable funding to support the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s research on social connection, loneliness, and social infrastructure.
Coming soon to US , so make sure your vaccinated. Wouldn't want covid in those tight quarters.
this could happen in Keir Stalin's britain
Everyone is commenting on how terrible this regime was, and that's true. But don't forget that it only came about because people had been pushed too far by ultra-conservative forces. It was because many countries adopted elements of socialism that they managed to avoid communism. Russia did not follow the same path, and many people paid the price.
Maybe something to think about when you're trying to compare this to the relatively moderate policies of people like Obama and Biden.
Ludicrous. Russians merely replaced one police state with another that was infinitely worse.
Bull f***ing sh**. The Russians merely exchanged an oppressive monarchy for oppressive collectivism.
It's more an expression of Bolshevism (Leninism) instead of Marx's view.
Obama and Biden's America right here
Je ne connaitre pas💙💙💙💙
экая эталонная клюква этот ваш "доктор")
Ho shit man
MR HERRON IS BAE
Español completa
American politics in 2022 is full of these angry, humorless marxists.
This scene was an ideological piece, strategically placed in a film that was released at the height of the Cold War. It created hysteria all over the world, the middle class all over the world when they hear about socialism they start to fear that a group of people coming from the streets will come to live in their huts! 😆😆
Michael Malice has documented the history of the Soviet Union in his newest book. I think this is a pretty generous treatment compared to some of what was going on.
@@paulfroelich1024 I understand, but that's not what I meant, I said that this movie was made during the cold war and served to frighten those who watched it... like a scarecrow.
@@krullntherakrore742 word.
This is a real life account brought to life.
this movie serves as a warning, to those societies that fall into oligarchy, the end stage of pure capitalism. Either progress to something better, or face communism. Your choice.
Two questions for Mr Anthony; what is that "something better", and which side will you be on ?
@@NahmakantaCamps Notice he doesn't have a snappy reply to your question.
This in Commiefornia?
KAMALA HARRIS 2020
I've been a Bolshevik since 1970. I LOVE this movie.
Then you understand that Bolshevik idea are nonsese and you're not ready to admit you got lied to.
Bravo to you for being able to admit your stupidity.
Today it would be: "Comrade! Men can give birth! Death of a fetus is life! Flog your gas stove to save the planet!"
coming to Joe Biden's Amerika.
LONG LIVE OUR CAPITALIST INSECURITY!
Simply reduce the number of people....geez
you first .... k?
The Soviets did that. They let millions starve.