Khalistan's old name is Sarkar E Khalsa tell gober bhakts to search Sarkar E Khalsa on google it khalistan been in history 3 times first During Baba Banda Singh Ji Bahadur Ji's time 1709 -1715 second khalistan misl raaj 1762 - 1799 third khalistan 1799 - 1849
The burning question, would the people voting in this referendum, actually go and live in Khalistan if it is ever established? Why make things even more difficult for the people already living there or who plan to stay there, not even counting Sikhs lliving outside Punjab but still in India and our Takhts like Patna Sahib and Nanded Sahib? Our community lost many of its members during the freedom struggle and an organisation like the BJP caanot claim anything on that. We had a realistic chance of Khalistan just before partition but the leadership decided otherwise. The same leadership also discouraged Dr B R Ambedkar from inspiring to convert Dalits to Sikhism, fearing for their own caste hegemony within Sikh society. Nobody wants to say it, but the same caste people (Jatts) are now demanding Khakistan.
1. When hindustan is such a perfect place for u guys why u have to come to western countries? If hinsustan is not our country thats why we have to leave our Punjab. 2. Sikhs never oppose Dr BRAmbedkar saab from converting, he was still weighing options for converting, and it was all about politics for him not just about Spirituality. 3. U dont know shit abt people who r demanding Khalistan. Mostly same people who sacrificed for Indian Union’s freedom, than same people r demanding Khalistan.
@@ss-pm6oj 1. It's not about leaving Punjab, it's about going back to Punjab giving up all Western comforts after becoming used to it. 2. Dr Ambedkar saw that caste was very prevelant in Punjab and that would defeat his purpose. Also, Master Tara Singh, under the influence of Gandhi and Nehru, sat on a fast unto death to prevent Dr Saab from going to Punjab. Similar to what Gandhi had done before Poona Pact. 3. Yes, I don't know shit about people demanding Khalistan, but I do know that Sikhs living outside Punjab, like Delhi and UP, do not want it any cost.
I don't know what these Canadian Sikhs think but how can Punjab, which is such a small state survive on its own as an independent country. Today Sikhs aren't limited to only Punjab you can find many Sikhs even in South India. Have these so-called Canadian Sikhs thought of that? I am a Sikh too and we have businesses expanding beyond Punjab. I would rather strive to protect Sikhi rather than demanding a nonsensical Independent State
Never speak ill of the dead but Nijjar tried to kill a Hindu priest in Jallandhar and was speaking ill of Hindus, he didnt seem like a man that had good judgment
Khalistan, supposedly, to be established in Punjab. But referendum happened in Canada. Citizens who have already left Punjab, renounced Indian citizenship, are voting establish a new sovereign in Punjab, miles away from Punjab. Illogical!! Would they even live there? How will this referendum help you in the cause? Come to Punjab, have a true referendum, convince actual Punjabis, fight for your rights. All this is hokum and reeks of your cowardice!
When we try to fight for rights, we are met with unneeded physical and ideological violence. We just have to strengthen up, and get a good representative and leader for the Qaum, and will get sovereignty; for the time being, we just want more independence in the leadership of Panjab, and the Anandpur Sahib Resolution passed, hope this helped. :)
If u may read the history .. all the freedom referendum movements started. Outside the country … how is it possible to raise your voice in enemy country
@@Sudopia8372 were the kharku singhs in an enemy country? What the history books won't tell you is that, at the peak of the movement, we had our own currency, border etc. during the 80s and 90s
These people are voting to seperate punjab, but they are not even in punjab, and if you go to punjab and ask anyone over there they’ll oppose khalistan, so yeah that’s why khalistan is nothing but waste of time and money
I'm personally not a Khalistani. My only problem with these referendums is that most of the voters are foreign citizens who will keep living there even if khalistan is formed, so the decision does not actually affect them. Does it not make more sense that the people actually living in Punjab do the voting for khalistan, and not foreign citizens? After all, a Canadian citizen cannot vote for PM elections in India. Same thing is in play here. Also, people voting yes are not thinking of other consequences besides religious separation. Punjab's economy will greatly suffer if it is separated. Its GDP is only 1/5th than that of Pakistan. Punjab does not have a big tech sector either, which is very necessary for today's economy. Forget about GDP. Imagine what the map will look like. Two enemy nations, India and Pakistan, with Khalistan sitting exactly in the middle. What happens when they both go on a war? And what about the Sikhs that will be left in India? They will be treated exactly like Muslims are treated there today. All in all, a bad idea in my opinion.
Saw some valid points, thought to add few.. if khalistan get formed still it will be an landlocked place, and have to be heavily dependent on its neighbours.... Secondly what will happen to people who wants to visit Punjab, would they need visa.....
@@goldenmemes51 that's the biggest lie they're telling themselves. They're used to living in luxury. They won't even be able to survive there today, let alone after the partition when the nation will be in shambles.
Bilkul sahi likhia h bro eh bss abroad valiya ne tang kitta hoya khalistan khalistan bolke shuru toh khud tan tuc pr ho bahr saada ki jo punjab ch rhnde ne
Thank you Katapa for making this video, it is a very powerful thing you have done as you have provided your younger Punjabi audience a sight into the real life problems of our people and the world. Not only surrounding issues with Khalistan but the fact that everybody with influence who has spoken out regarding the situation has been silenced. Rest in Peace HS Nijjar. Rest in Peace those who were silenced for using their voice. 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
I don't have a problem if you support Khalistan. Being a resident of Punjab I don't support Khalistan. And the main thing I wanna tell is don't drag Sidhu into this. he never supported Khalistan. in this particular interview that you mentioned he said that he don't like the discrimination to Sikh community. He does not like when people call them terrorists or Khalistani. so please don't drag him into this. because he is not alive to tell his side of story. if he wanted Khalistan then he would not have participated for MLAs elections in Punjab. so please don't twist his words for your favour. yes he respects Jarnail singh bhindrawala. he respects and support other sikh activists that are in prison even they have served their time. Even I support that those sikh prisoners should be free. thats the legal battle. so whatever it is I just want to say that please don't involve Sidhu in all this. HE wanted equality for all the religions casts and creeds. He preffered staying in Punjab even after Being a PR of UK. So if he wanted Khalistan then he would have been in abroad like most of those who support Khalistan. He loved his Punjab. Please Don't Drag him in all this. Its a humble request. #RIPSidhuMOoseWala #JusticeForSidhuMooseWala #295 #Legend #Levels
Iam a sikh from punjab. BRO IMMIGRANTS NE TAH BAHR REHNA ENJOY KRNA TE ASI EVI APNA FINANCIAL AND SOCIAL SYSTEM KHARAB KRNA JA TAH EH JINE V KHALISTAN MANG RHE NE EVI SADE NAL KHALISTAN VICH REHN. We dont want Khalistan you must make in your western countries.🔥🔥🔥🔥
If this guy is from BJP I'm more than happy to support him cause he's the one making sense, and the guy in orange jacket is treating him with disrespect just for having different views, similar behaviour of seeing Hindus as inferior was shown by Muslims during the partition thinking of Hindus and Sikhs as Kafirs, getting the same vibe from this guy towards the blue shirt guy even though he's being totally respectful
Sikhs are chill in India , they are not Ghulam and yeah there are few issues which need to be discussed , raise voice, and have dialogue in an ethical manner , seperate nation Idea is horseshit !!!! Other communities either minors or majors have also dealt with oppression in some sorts !!! This is just going to make things worse for the future
Wake up to reality bro No one is chilling ok they are not ghulam but a lot of issues with modi gov if you try raise your voice you will be dead. Are you mad fam!!!
@@malhi_47 Of course there are issues but the issues are for everyone not just Punjabis and BJP is govt is not great but its still better that Congress any day. Stop day dreaming about Khalistan.
Question: Are these people actually ready to leave for New country??? They all got citizenships from USA, Uk & Canada but they’re saying that they need freedom
I love my india I love my motherland I love my punjab.. i don't need any khalistan Maa baap kuch naa maane toh unse alag nhi hote..india hamara ma bhi baap bhi.. how can we seprate from our motherland.. koi dhakka nhi ho reha punjab vich... Sab normal hai yahan Pls dnt apread any hatred things for god sake.. let us spread peace brother..
Bro as an Indian I could say that growing up in state of Uttarakhand you don’t see many sikhs out here but all I know within our hindu community the love / respect for sikhs is immense even my hindu friends visit gurudwara frequently idk why you guys want a separate nation anyways love your content 🇮🇳
Brother these are not sikhs. they are madarchods. I as a citizen of India am proud of my motherland. These people just want to create nuisance and don't want social harmony.
im not trying to hate or anything but its a genuine question. supposing khalistan is formed are all you willing to leave the country ya'll are currently living in (canada , uk , us , australia) and start living a new life in khalistan ?
it’s not just about living there once it’s made. It’s also about not having the fear of getting falsely arrested just because you support a Sikh homeland. Why should I fear for my safety whenever I go back to Panjab. I shouldn’t have to think twice about going back to Panjab because of the corrupt government that puts our brothers and sisters in jails and tortures, rapes, and murders them .
@@puffmuff586once come and seen how India has changed into a peaceful society (for sikhs )and see how people are living peacefully Hindus and sikhs like friends and brothers(but Muslim hate is still high).
@@gillx84 I understand but the protests all of you are taking part in overseas are impacting the lives of sikhs in India. I dont think ya’ll are realising this but when you guys fight for your rights abroad its the sikhs in India who suffer because of all of you. Try to understand
Most of the people asking for Khalistan live outside of India, not in Punjab. They’ll never go back to Punjab. Ehi gall hundi tan punjab chadd k bahar wal nu na bhajjde. Also fer Ardas hoyegi “Sri Nankana Sahib, Sri Huzur Sahib, Sri Hemkund Sahib, Sri Patna Sahib, Sri Manikaran Sahib, Sri Paonta Sahib ate hor gurdwareyan ton jinha ton panth nu vichodeya gya hai…” Har gurudwara sahib di bedbi da kasoorwar sikh hi hon ge, koi hor nahi! Stop demanding Khalistan. Punjab nu flourish krao, sikhi naal judo, dharam de naam te eh wand krni band kro. Saade kise guru sahib ne kade separate country di koi demand ni c kiti. Sikhi ikk jeen da tareeka aa, us tareeke nu apnaao.
Sikhi is not a jeen da tarekka cmon brother what are you even saying? If sikhi was like you’re saying, it would be classified as a philosophy not as a religion. And who told you the people abroad won’t go back in the new born Khalistan? I can’t wait to have my own hymn, my own flag and my own land where I can be proud of. Sikhs are born to conquer, but not as an aggressive way, but to implement a peaceful society where no one is discriminated, no one is converted forcefully etc. People that have a mindset like you are the reason our kaum is soft. Go look Muslims, and ffs even Jews. They are hated but they have their own land, they are recognized as a different community. What are we Sikhs? Do you realize Hindus classify us as a sector of their religion, even after all the sacrifices we made for eliminating the caste system etc?
I like ❤Khalistan but 😢 when they said to separate the Punjab and that’s totally wrong and why they are making protests in other countries and disturbing the country people and that’s why it’s totally wrong 😑 _____________________________________ HINDU/ MUSLIM/ SIKH /isai sare Han bhai bhai 🙏🏻
It’s because they live in fear of being killed or kidnapped In India. The government has too much power and can make people who raise awareness to such issues as Khalistan can be easily killed.
Most sikhs that come to these countries always become Khalistanis after realizing how shit india is as a country. Sikhs living there don't know they are gulaam. You have no idea how many sikhs living in punjab support khalistan. U r not a sikh so u don't know.
And what will happen then?? Deep sidhu, sant bhindranwale and 400+ singhs have been in india and fought for their rights. What happened?? What happened to amritpal? Why did they arrest jaggi johal as he went to india? Really defines your low iq
Veer as sikh I don't support khalistan cuz the people living in Canada don't know about the exact situation in india. Our punjab is enough for us we don't want to be separated bro. In India's point of view canada is supporting terrorism. Bro khalistan is not even a good word for punjab. Please i request the people of Canada to change the name of your event cuz khalistan is not a good word to keep. That day is not too far when all sikhs will be considered as terrorists. I don't wanna spread any kind of hate. Sorry if i said something wrong but its the truth 🙏 Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh ! 🙏
@@ShotPRO139he is true punjabi , coz he is living in punjab , not like you guys who leave their motherland and now trying to divide their own motherland
It shows support from across the globe for something. All the nations will then turn to India Khalistan is no bad thing, not sure why its made to be seen as a radicalisation. We just want the power to stop drugs and other injustices.
@@georgehearn2024khalisatan is a bad thing my friend it will have no sea in it zero trade and yk about the agriculture and hospitality in punjab economy kidan chalu punjab di india trade ni kruga it is going to be next pakistan jeh bn gea khalistan and what are the ods that pakistan or china doesn't attack it what about military...
India will remain United these folks need to think logically if they want Punjab to become independent, punjab is a bankrupt state with no money if they really want to do something for punjab set up industry and invest here please🙏🙏🙏
Punjab will bankrupt, oh really tell me how? India taan kudh bankrupt aaa unemployment vekhi aaa tatuu. 140 crore di population aaa te GDP 3 trillion only.
@@Er.HarjotSingh-xz6myIndia is the fastest growing economy, plus looking at the trends of unemployment rate , it is receding significantly. Tell us Indians your plan on building an economy for khalistan. Where is the capital? What is the source of it? Describe the prudential reasons, and also what type of government would be in it? For I can see that there’s a high possibility of militant rule.
Sikh community always stand for OPRESSION , what are ur thoughts on Hindu rastar ? What do u think Hindu raster being promoted in national media and Sikh farmers also being called as khalistani , what do u think ABOUT HINDU RASTAR BACCHE . Are they any different from Khalistan ?
No hate to you kattapa but my view is I am a happily teenager Indian Sikh. I don't want khalistan in India. India will remain the same from all the directions. First khalistani should try to get Punjab from Pakistan. They are already going to collapse. You should try to get Punjab Pakistan. I also believe Sikh who want khalistan are forgetting what really Sikh are. Again if someone hurt my country 🇮🇳 or my people never forget we have brave regiment army specially Sikh regiment and don't forget submarine, rocket, nuclear bomb, tank. And you have nothing's just like Pakistan If Pakistan comes in way, they always lose ( all war they lost since independence 😂) . Waheguru ji ka Khalsa waheguru ji ki Fateh Bhart mata ki Jai
Uncle in blue shirt was right, If Khalistan is to make in India then this referendum should happen in India, but ig i won't be possible there because 99% of Punjabis are against Khalistan in India
Khalistan is Punjabi chauvinism and it has nothing to do with Sikhism or Khalsa. Punjabi Sikhs instead of spreading the message of Sikhism to other people are excluding them to be a Sikh by restricting the message of Guru Nanak, Guru Gobind Singh ji and Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji. They want Sikhism to be exclusively remain among Punjabis. Whole of India can become Khalistan if message of our Gurus disseminates in a proper way (Gurbani in their own native languages). Khalistan is harming Sikhism. We should not ally with Islamic terrorists who really are following their desert cult.
75% of Sikhs live in Panjab. Majority of Sikhs living in foreign countries are the ones who fled from Panjab in order to survive. So they definitely have the right to vote for this. As for foreign-born Panjabis, they also have the right to vote for the freedom of their rightful homeland, do they not? Otherwise why do people do protests for Israel or Ukraine in the UK or USA; if they're not citizens of those countries then - with your logic - they don't have a say right?
Well, It is technically right as long as India allows voting for referendum in India. Right now, Indian government isn't holding any voting for referendum and they are aganist it and they crack down on every one who supports it. So these votings has to held somewhere else. And if we talk about sikhs and punjabis who left India, they did it in order to survive and escape the genocide and oppression their community is going through. So, they have a right to vote as well.
Very good sides of the story , jokes apart - katapa from hamdard tv surely did a better job at most of the people covering the event. I am a Sikh and love India, I do not feel Khalistan is a viable fix to what is wrong in our state, our culture is broken which needs a fix and harmony amongst all not only brown people is critical for the world to move forward. Religions are Faith are meant to do as their name suggests. Killing, Separation and Anger shouldn’t be a part of it as they dilute what we all stand for. I respect everyone and their opinion but most of the people won’t go back IF khalistan was made a separate state. No one would like to live in a landlocked country surrounded by enemies
First time in years, Katapa really did a great interview and made a eye opening video for the community. Keep it up brother and do these kind of videos more often along with other funny ones. Stay blessed
This is pure foolishness, Punjab need education ,employment and people who can live there .Villages are empty for Canada dreams people are mad for leaving Punjab .Marrying there sister so they can reach Canada .Living outside India and shouting we want Khalistan is only harming our comunity ,so stop this bullshit .
the biggest threat to our community is the people from our community itself. All the past events were Sikhs experienced injustice did involve the people from our community itself. So, if Khalistan happens, which is being demanded by people who're living outside India, they will continue living there and the people who didn't want Khalistan will be forced to live in Khalistan. It'll give a free hand to the rulers who can now impose anything on the people. Trust me referendum is happening for this decision. Later, for any policy implementation in Khalistan, will not have democratic way of deciding policies. They'll be directly imposed (most likely in a dictatorship environment). We will not be able to ask help in that situation, as everyone else (states, countries etc.) will say, you chose this.
@@thesingh588 that's wrong Sikhs are just 53% according to the last census(wikipedia) .now even less . In just 10 years we won't be the majority in punjab
@@politiussnewsnetwork9863 we live in the 21st century mate. Plus the Sikhs are who fought these wars and currently make up the majority of the indian army. I believe the Khalistan movement has come to abolish the use of drugs and beadbi in panjab. Politicians feed off the drug money and there is high rates of poverty for a state which exports so much produce. My comment to katapa was to do more civilised interviews and not comedy. I think you presumed I meant interview more on Khalistan. Peace and Love
@@politiussnewsnetwork9863One could argue that naming a country after a Subcontinent even though that country doesn't occupy the whole subcontinent is ridiculous.
@@georgehearn2024 tu c saare ghoose ghate o 2 number ch gye hoye. Those maa pyo v do number ch gaye aa. Bina data to e kahi jana sikhs make majority of army.
Because legally, Sikhs/hindus no longer have a claim on those lands - they were given away to the Islamic republic of Pakistan by Pandit Negru. We can only include what we currently have. I agree, the maps are outrageous - by including random districts into khalistan, and whoever designs them is a fuddu. But don’t worry, if we do get independence, Lahore will be the first regional city to fall, followed by Delhi⚔️
@@puffmuff586 look man I have no hatred against any people but I don’t think anyone in these times can change borders forcefully of any country whichever it is. Only thing you or me can do is work hard or smart and make our parents and us comfortable. and I watch this coz is funny. now you guys can says you are all powerful etc etc its funny at the end
Nope..we dont want any khalisatn.. instead of fighting govt u guys are fighting with nation..come here in india..be in politics..and establish khalsa raaj..not khalisatn
im in canada now im not canadain or indian im punajbi farmer nd khalistan when farmers protest is going on i been there but i see there is no violence or anything farmers want justice indian government is doing dictatorship then i see indian national media saying everyone is khalistani then i release that yes we are if your saying its true indian government is doing bad with sikh since we lost our kingdom
Brooo why not they come to india and ask for the rights. Because they know what will happened to them.and yeah the indian sikh soldiers,players, like this nothing happened mark my words about this
Dude I have nothing against Khalistan but I just want to say that although you guys want Khalistan you still don’t know the whole roots of it and what it will cause. If Khalistan is created then the Sikhs of Punjab india will go after the Punjab of Pakistan and cause war. Even if not Pakistan they will go after Haryana or Himachal. I personally believe that the trust between the india government and Sikhs is so broken after 1984 that the Indian government is afraid to give Sikhs any sort of relief.
It is very difficult to be done in India as the government tortures the freedom fighters and goes upto the cruel deed of giving shock to genitalia. Thus so. I hope your question is answered.
@@g.a.m.b.i Everyone is living peacefully and getting employment under the Indian government irrespective of any religion. There are some problems in every country whether it is usa canada India. The current condition of punjab is bad because punjabi youth are going abroad.
@@g.a.m.b.i if you think of natural disasters being caused by some government body i cant change your mind. It is the same as the AAP blaming the BJP for floods in delhi. Every year the north east faces floods but the Indian government doesn't blame china for that.
@lakshchanan4690 nope the water was getting under controlled when the government decided to release the damm water again. I don't trust the Indian Government dude, and the rest if the world if seeing the cracks in indias so called democracy. Don't worry about Khalistan bro worry about Manipur and such events
Brother I respectfully disagree with the idea of Khalistan. And I love the Sikh religion more than my own Hindu religion. My family is Hindu Punjabi from Tarn Tarn area, during the 80s my family was heavily persecuted for being Hindu Punjabi. My father had to leave India. Half of his friends were killed for being Hindu. One prime example is deepak dawan. My mother’s side was saved by Baba Manochahal. As my grandfather was the only math teacher in the villages and baba Manochahal was his student and loved my grandfather. He told my grandfather that kadkus were going to come to your house to kill you and told him to hide somewhere else. My mother her four sisters one brother and grandparents all hid in a Sikh families house. When they came to their house the next day their furniture was destroyed.
It definitely has a strong root on why its needed. The injustice and mistrestment of punjab. Drug culture promotion, the issue with SYL. If this doesnt show how they want to subdue our people i dont know what will. The only concern i have is the management of this new nation, if we get good leaders then it will prosper beyond imagination. We dont need puppets of the indian government puppeteering punjab.
Day before he died he was talking about khalistan on an interview with another journalist. He had members of shiromani akali dal amritsar which supports khalistan at his house too and then the next day he died. Was it a coincidence or was it because the government knew he had so much support from all across the world he could gain so much support and change peoples minds about it?
Haven't finished watching yet, but I think a lot of people, including myself, tend to forget that many of our parents were in their teens. The families I talked to about 1984 were split. Some want to be free of oppression, and others think the creation of Kahlistan will divide us further. The assassination definitely shook up the community. Shocking this can happen so close to many of us at a sacred place. Although you may be profane, you still keep it rock hard for the community
I think its important to discuss the good things and the bad things associated with this movement. There are plenty of people who represent that group poorly. For starters the referdom needs to happen in India. Why escape all those problems in India just to vote on Indian problems seems backwards af. Secondly the air Canada bombing no one seems to be talking about, this group has so many radicals that have absolutely guttered the khalistani movement. In the end I would like to say that I can very much sympathize with the movement but I just generally cannot agree with the premise and the current approach. A good solution would be to internally clean up the movement by disposing of the violent terrorist's and radicals and removing any association with them, and secondly to have this vote in the nation of India. Protest on ground zero, as difficult as that may be if you are really passionate about the movement and the message it needs to be on ground zero. I normally do not comment on videos but felt this needed some discussion. Jai Hind and Whaeguru ji da Khalsa Wheguru Ji di phate. let us unite and take a proper and civil approach to this very serious topic.
Is that the case? If so why is government opposed to referendum in Punjab? If that's truly the case, it would be a done deal within a matter of days. But we both know that's not the truth.
Sangrur voted for Khalistani MP Simranjit Singh Mann last year. How many people took part in Khalsa Vaheer? How many people show up to Sri Akal Takht Sahib on June 6? Go to Punjab and ask.
@@GuptSingh1469i m from sangrur . People just voted for simrnjit singh mann just because of deep sidhu . Do u know how many times he lost before nd even people not liking him now . He will lose again next time nd brother that is truth no body cares in punjab . Maybe 1 percent no more. Nobody is talking about amritpal singh anymore thts shows how much people care
@@AmritpalSingh-hl8tm Indeed, These NRI Sikhs are fucking up our reputation back in our country, thanks to you fuckers we need to go deal with bad comments. JUST BECAUSE YOU WANT KHALISTAN and WE DONT
Sat shree akal saare prava nu. Apa sare pra va. Na koi Khalistan na koi India we all are brother and I agree with referendum but we all want peace and harmony. But there are some naughty 😈 elements they are just spreading hate and have support of Pakistan 😂. But then doesn’t matter at all. But we all need to get together and establish brotherhood between our communities ❤️.@katapatv
most Sikhs in India don't want Khalistan. Majority of the support comes from Sikhs living abroad. Khalistan makes zero sense, because India would not exist without the help of Sikhs. We play such a crucial role in the development of India in every aspect. All these supporters living abroad would not give up their lives to go and develop Khalistan. Not to mention, how would we train Sikhs with high skills that are required to start and maintain a country. Western Sikhs are that are skilled are not going to fly to Khalistan to educate the population with the needed skills. Khalistan would be as impoverished as Pakistan, if not worse. I understand why we want our own nation, but logistically, it makes zero sense. The quest for Khalistan is another take at the "foul's gold."
people keep saying that the people who voting here have no rights to ask for a separate state. But, they have to understand that these are the people that have been displaced from India/Punjab during the genocide. It was because of the circumstances during the genocide that made them refugees and not by choice. Thereby, due to self education of the new generation, and with a connection to ancestors and religious backgrounds, they have a right to demand a State that is safe to practise their beliefs. Mind you, I don't agree to it, but, it is their rights. I just hope and pray, it doesn't turn into a overly religious State like the Taliban.
Make sure to check out the new collection www.khichke.com and support the channel ❤️
Khalistan's old name is Sarkar E Khalsa tell gober bhakts to search Sarkar E Khalsa on google it
khalistan been in history 3 times
first During Baba Banda Singh Ji Bahadur Ji's time
1709 -1715
second khalistan misl raaj
1762 - 1799
third khalistan
1799 - 1849
You should stick to ur 🤡 ing
khalistan zindabaad
please cover topics like this
lots of love
plz try to make it watch in family
its very impoetant best of luck
kich keee
khalistan zindabaad
@@moosehoodofficial impotent🤣🤣🤣
Great to see katapa using his platform to inform
The burning question, would the people voting in this referendum, actually go and live in Khalistan if it is ever established? Why make things even more difficult for the people already living there or who plan to stay there, not even counting Sikhs lliving outside Punjab but still in India and our Takhts like Patna Sahib and Nanded Sahib? Our community lost many of its members during the freedom struggle and an organisation like the BJP caanot claim anything on that. We had a realistic chance of Khalistan just before partition but the leadership decided otherwise. The same leadership also discouraged Dr B R Ambedkar from inspiring to convert Dalits to Sikhism, fearing for their own caste hegemony within Sikh society. Nobody wants to say it, but the same caste people (Jatts) are now demanding Khakistan.
Finally a logical comment
Swear this whole own country idea is fudu of them
1. When hindustan is such a perfect place for u guys why u have to come to western countries? If hinsustan is not our country thats why we have to leave our Punjab.
2. Sikhs never oppose Dr BRAmbedkar saab from converting, he was still weighing options for converting, and it was all about politics for him not just about Spirituality.
3. U dont know shit abt people who r demanding Khalistan. Mostly same people who sacrificed for Indian Union’s freedom, than same people r demanding Khalistan.
@@ss-pm6oj 1. It's not about leaving Punjab, it's about going back to Punjab giving up all Western comforts after becoming used to it.
2. Dr Ambedkar saw that caste was very prevelant in Punjab and that would defeat his purpose. Also, Master Tara Singh, under the influence of Gandhi and Nehru, sat on a fast unto death to prevent Dr Saab from going to Punjab. Similar to what Gandhi had done before Poona Pact.
3. Yes, I don't know shit about people demanding Khalistan, but I do know that Sikhs living outside Punjab, like Delhi and UP, do not want it any cost.
True , what about sis ganj sahib , bangla sahib ? Already have leaved gurdwara in pakistan . Cant lose more
I don't know what these Canadian Sikhs think but how can Punjab, which is such a small state survive on its own as an independent country. Today Sikhs aren't limited to only Punjab you can find many Sikhs even in South India. Have these so-called Canadian Sikhs thought of that? I am a Sikh too and we have businesses expanding beyond Punjab. I would rather strive to protect Sikhi rather than demanding a nonsensical Independent State
Agreed!
Respect you brother!!
so true, i was actually worried seeing this growing demand of seperate nation, but comments like this really give releif.
Never speak ill of the dead but Nijjar tried to kill a Hindu priest in Jallandhar and was speaking ill of Hindus, he didnt seem like a man that had good judgment
Source
??? I live in Punjab … nothing happened like that …
Khalistan, supposedly, to be established in Punjab. But referendum happened in Canada. Citizens who have already left Punjab, renounced Indian citizenship, are voting establish a new sovereign in Punjab, miles away from Punjab. Illogical!!
Would they even live there? How will this referendum help you in the cause?
Come to Punjab, have a true referendum, convince actual Punjabis, fight for your rights. All this is hokum and reeks of your cowardice!
fudu
When we try to fight for rights, we are met with unneeded physical and ideological violence. We just have to strengthen up, and get a good representative and leader for the Qaum, and will get sovereignty; for the time being, we just want more independence in the leadership of Panjab, and the Anandpur Sahib Resolution passed, hope this helped. :)
If u may read the history .. all the freedom referendum movements started. Outside the country … how is it possible to raise your voice in enemy country
@@Sudopia8372 were the kharku singhs in an enemy country? What the history books won't tell you is that, at the peak of the movement, we had our own currency, border etc. during the 80s and 90s
@@CS-rw4es chundi lassi
These people are voting to seperate punjab, but they are not even in punjab, and if you go to punjab and ask anyone over there they’ll oppose khalistan, so yeah that’s why khalistan is nothing but waste of time and money
I'm personally not a Khalistani. My only problem with these referendums is that most of the voters are foreign citizens who will keep living there even if khalistan is formed, so the decision does not actually affect them.
Does it not make more sense that the people actually living in Punjab do the voting for khalistan, and not foreign citizens? After all, a Canadian citizen cannot vote for PM elections in India. Same thing is in play here.
Also, people voting yes are not thinking of other consequences besides religious separation. Punjab's economy will greatly suffer if it is separated. Its GDP is only 1/5th than that of Pakistan. Punjab does not have a big tech sector either, which is very necessary for today's economy.
Forget about GDP. Imagine what the map will look like. Two enemy nations, India and Pakistan, with Khalistan sitting exactly in the middle. What happens when they both go on a war?
And what about the Sikhs that will be left in India? They will be treated exactly like Muslims are treated there today.
All in all, a bad idea in my opinion.
Saw some valid points, thought to add few..
if khalistan get formed still it will be an landlocked place, and have to be heavily dependent on its neighbours....
Secondly what will happen to people who wants to visit Punjab, would they need visa.....
I totally agree with you ❤
No I know alot of Americans Canadian englandis who would return and help develop the independent nation
@@goldenmemes51 that's the biggest lie they're telling themselves. They're used to living in luxury. They won't even be able to survive there today, let alone after the partition when the nation will be in shambles.
Bilkul sahi likhia h bro eh bss abroad valiya ne tang kitta hoya khalistan khalistan bolke shuru toh khud tan tuc pr ho bahr saada ki jo punjab ch rhnde ne
Thank you Katapa for making this video, it is a very powerful thing you have done as you have provided your younger Punjabi audience a sight into the real life problems of our people and the world. Not only surrounding issues with Khalistan but the fact that everybody with influence who has spoken out regarding the situation has been silenced.
Rest in Peace HS Nijjar. Rest in Peace those who were silenced for using their voice.
🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
I don't have a problem if you support Khalistan. Being a resident of Punjab I don't support Khalistan. And the main thing I wanna tell is don't drag Sidhu into this. he never supported Khalistan. in this particular interview that you mentioned he said that he don't like the discrimination to Sikh community. He does not like when people call them terrorists or Khalistani. so please don't drag him into this. because he is not alive to tell his side of story. if he wanted Khalistan then he would not have participated for MLAs elections in Punjab. so please don't twist his words for your favour. yes he respects Jarnail singh bhindrawala. he respects and support other sikh activists that are in prison even they have served their time. Even I support that those sikh prisoners should be free. thats the legal battle. so whatever it is I just want to say that please don't involve Sidhu in all this. HE wanted equality for all the religions casts and creeds. He preffered staying in Punjab even after Being a PR of UK. So if he wanted Khalistan then he would have been in abroad like most of those who support Khalistan. He loved his Punjab. Please Don't Drag him in all this. Its a humble request. #RIPSidhuMOoseWala #JusticeForSidhuMooseWala #295 #Legend #Levels
Iam a sikh from punjab.
BRO IMMIGRANTS NE TAH BAHR REHNA ENJOY KRNA TE ASI EVI APNA FINANCIAL AND SOCIAL SYSTEM KHARAB KRNA JA TAH EH JINE V KHALISTAN MANG RHE NE EVI SADE NAL KHALISTAN VICH REHN.
We dont want Khalistan you must make in your western countries.🔥🔥🔥🔥
Sahi comment kita tusi.
Same here love india❤ i dont want khalistan.
@@one5608ur Hindu das why
I'm in Jalandhar and I want khalistan
@ionkno8986 I’m Sikh and I don’t want Khalistan.
It’s always a good day when Katapa uploads
11:12 he might be from the bjp just because he had an opposing view?! shallow mindset
If this guy is from BJP I'm more than happy to support him cause he's the one making sense, and the guy in orange jacket is treating him with disrespect just for having different views, similar behaviour of seeing Hindus as inferior was shown by Muslims during the partition thinking of Hindus and Sikhs as Kafirs, getting the same vibe from this guy towards the blue shirt guy even though he's being totally respectful
Sikhs are chill in India , they are not Ghulam and yeah there are few issues which need to be discussed , raise voice, and have dialogue in an ethical manner , seperate nation Idea is horseshit !!!!
Other communities either minors or majors have also dealt with oppression in some sorts !!!
This is just going to make things worse for the future
You don’t know any history or facts .
Indian state killed 200k Sikhs from 1984-1995
Just let UN to conduct refrendum in panjab
Wake up to reality bro
No one is chilling ok they are not ghulam but a lot of issues with modi gov if you try raise your voice you will be dead.
Are you mad fam!!!
@@malhi_47 Of course there are issues but the issues are for everyone not just Punjabis and BJP is govt is not great but its still better that Congress any day. Stop day dreaming about Khalistan.
@@imaandeepsinghdhillon no
Bro no hate ....I love u. .. katapà......I'm also sikh but i proud to an Indian.... people here don't get confuse Sikhs with khalistani.....
I agree with you.❤
Fake id ,,,
I m from Amritsar Panjab Sikh !!!
I support khalistan,,,
Who tf are u??
@@gurbanigursikhi7377khalistan is nothing but dirty politics. Don't fall for it .
There are so many problems in Punjab don't create more.
Question: Are these people actually ready to leave for New country??? They all got citizenships from USA, Uk & Canada but they’re saying that they need freedom
I love my india
I love my motherland
I love my punjab.. i don't need any khalistan
Maa baap kuch naa maane toh unse alag nhi hote..india hamara ma bhi baap bhi.. how can we seprate from our motherland.. koi dhakka nhi ho reha punjab vich... Sab normal hai yahan
Pls dnt apread any hatred things for god sake.. let us spread peace brother..
My parents were in Delhi during the riots I don’t even wish that on my worst enemies
That was a Genocide!!!
@@H1262.0You are right.
But Why You Dont Talk About Kharku Waad Before 1984 that killed thousands people
@@RYFMuzic some hundred of ppl were killed pre blue star. Numbers were less than that shithole called UP.
@@RYFMuzickharku Kills only corrupt people or the people Who help to take genocide in 1984
This guy never disappoint us ... Because he never uploads
AHAHA
Well done katapia. Presenting education in your own comedic way. Shaabash mundiya
🙌🏻
Bro as an Indian I could say that growing up in state of Uttarakhand you don’t see many sikhs out here but all I know within our hindu community the love / respect for sikhs is immense even my hindu friends visit gurudwara frequently idk why you guys want a separate nation anyways love your content 🇮🇳
Brother these are not sikhs. they are madarchods. I as a citizen of India am proud of my motherland. These people just want to create nuisance and don't want social harmony.
Punjab will always be the part of india. love to all my sikh brothers out there ❤
im not trying to hate or anything but its a genuine question.
supposing khalistan is formed are all you willing to leave the country ya'll are currently living in (canada , uk , us , australia) and start living a new life in khalistan ?
Why
it’s not just about living there once it’s made. It’s also about not having the fear of getting falsely arrested just because you support a Sikh homeland. Why should I fear for my safety whenever I go back to Panjab. I shouldn’t have to think twice about going back to Panjab because of the corrupt government that puts our brothers and sisters in jails and tortures, rapes, and murders them .
yes. we will. many of us are planing to move back, khalistan or not.
@@puffmuff586once come and seen how India has changed into a peaceful society (for sikhs )and see how people are living peacefully Hindus and sikhs like friends and brothers(but Muslim hate is still high).
@@gillx84 I understand but the protests all of you are taking part in overseas are impacting the lives of sikhs in India.
I dont think ya’ll are realising this but when you guys fight for your rights abroad its the sikhs in India who suffer because of all of you. Try to understand
Guys all us brown people should be united regardless of which region we come from!
exactly you should support Khalistan
Just not the Hindus
How
You are correct so support us? We aren’t asking for anything untoward. Just our freedom
Agreed
Most of the people asking for Khalistan live outside of India, not in Punjab. They’ll never go back to Punjab. Ehi gall hundi tan punjab chadd k bahar wal nu na bhajjde.
Also fer Ardas hoyegi “Sri Nankana Sahib, Sri Huzur Sahib, Sri Hemkund Sahib, Sri Patna Sahib, Sri Manikaran Sahib, Sri Paonta Sahib ate hor gurdwareyan ton jinha ton panth nu vichodeya gya hai…”
Har gurudwara sahib di bedbi da kasoorwar sikh hi hon ge, koi hor nahi!
Stop demanding Khalistan. Punjab nu flourish krao, sikhi naal judo, dharam de naam te eh wand krni band kro.
Saade kise guru sahib ne kade separate country di koi demand ni c kiti. Sikhi ikk jeen da tareeka aa, us tareeke nu apnaao.
Sikhi is not a jeen da tarekka cmon brother what are you even saying? If sikhi was like you’re saying, it would be classified as a philosophy not as a religion. And who told you the people abroad won’t go back in the new born Khalistan? I can’t wait to have my own hymn, my own flag and my own land where I can be proud of. Sikhs are born to conquer, but not as an aggressive way, but to implement a peaceful society where no one is discriminated, no one is converted forcefully etc. People that have a mindset like you are the reason our kaum is soft. Go look Muslims, and ffs even Jews. They are hated but they have their own land, they are recognized as a different community. What are we Sikhs? Do you realize Hindus classify us as a sector of their religion, even after all the sacrifices we made for eliminating the caste system etc?
@@gupsdhamraitisn't cast system in Sikhism too😂😂😂
hardeep singh nijjar was killed beacause he was a terrorist he was involved in the bomb plantation in air india plane
Ja na tuu
For ur kind information proofs published globally that air india bombing was done by india itself jut to blame sikhs and if u need proofs just tell me
Tu Ki lana
He was 8 years old when that happened
I like ❤Khalistan but 😢 when they said to separate the Punjab and that’s totally wrong and why they are making protests in other countries and disturbing the country people and that’s why it’s totally wrong 😑
_____________________________________
HINDU/ MUSLIM/ SIKH /isai sare Han bhai bhai 🙏🏻
13:40 "let the Indian people decide" that uncle was right and we people love our India .....
Let the minorities that are being oppressed decide? India will allow referendum voting? Eda de uncle Hindu community wich boht aa 😂
people are arrested for even keeping literature about stuff like khalistan and khalsa raj
@@isingh90richest community in India talking about oppression. It's a joke.
@@bg6358richest are Jains and Parsis
Sikhs are not rich at all
Uncle came there to spy n to stop that event...
Great video broski. Keep this kinds stuff around. Really happy to see you supporting
People in India doesn't want Khalistan. Canadian only want it
Who said have you ever gone Punjab
Yes, I have been there. They like India
@@amar5318I live in India and i want khalistan
I dont want khalistan i love india and i m sikh.
@@one5608 visit Delhi vidwa house colony of Sikh women's if you are real Sikh will not say again want india
well said that guy "let the Indian ppl decide". And tbh Sikhs living in India are in less favour of khalistan than the sikhs living outside of India.
It’s because they live in fear of being killed or kidnapped In India. The government has too much power and can make people who raise awareness to such issues as Khalistan can be easily killed.
Most sikhs that come to these countries always become Khalistanis after realizing how shit india is as a country. Sikhs living there don't know they are gulaam. You have no idea how many sikhs living in punjab support khalistan. U r not a sikh so u don't know.
It's better to fight by being here in 🇮🇳 so that defines the unity of khalistanni then. 🙏🏽
And what will happen then?? Deep sidhu, sant bhindranwale and 400+ singhs have been in india and fought for their rights. What happened?? What happened to amritpal? Why did they arrest jaggi johal as he went to india? Really defines your low iq
Dal khalsa and shromni akali dal(A) are here in panjab
And Amritpal singh fighted here see now he is in jail illegally
“Edumacaiton” GOT ME CRYIN💀
Veer as sikh I don't support khalistan cuz the people living in Canada don't know about the exact situation in india. Our punjab is enough for us we don't want to be separated bro. In India's point of view canada is supporting terrorism. Bro khalistan is not even a good word for punjab. Please i request the people of Canada to change the name of your event cuz khalistan is not a good word to keep. That day is not too far when all sikhs will be considered as terrorists. I don't wanna spread any kind of hate. Sorry if i said something wrong but its the truth 🙏 Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh ! 🙏
Why is Khalistan bad ?
You cant be panjabi
@@ShotPRO139he is true punjabi , coz he is living in punjab , not like you guys who leave their motherland and now trying to divide their own motherland
Finally i hv found a logical comment
Not a logical comment, its just a one side thinking specially delhi de bhappeya wale soch aa ena di te teri jankari lyi dss dva mai punjab ch rehna
i don't get it, how is a referendum in Brampton supposed to apply to India? 13:14 this dude said it
It shows support from across the globe for something. All the nations will then turn to India
Khalistan is no bad thing, not sure why its made to be seen as a radicalisation. We just want the power to stop drugs and other injustices.
@@georgehearn2024khalisatan is a bad thing my friend it will have no sea in it zero trade and yk about the agriculture and hospitality in punjab economy kidan chalu punjab di india trade ni kruga it is going to be next pakistan jeh bn gea khalistan and what are the ods that pakistan or china doesn't attack it what about military...
@@Deepak-kl1lhKhalsa Raj was and will be again the greatest empire in the world.
Maybe cause in India you will be jailed, arrested, tortured, your family harassed, and your human rights stripped if you talk
@@waterbottlekid1121 Then how is Dal Khalsa is able to operate in India and how is simranjit singh mann able to contest and win election ?
India will remain United these folks need to think logically if they want Punjab to become independent, punjab is a bankrupt state with no money if they really want to do something for punjab set up industry and invest here please🙏🙏🙏
Punjab will bankrupt, oh really tell me how?
India taan kudh bankrupt aaa unemployment vekhi aaa tatuu. 140 crore di population aaa te GDP 3 trillion only.
@@Er.HarjotSingh-xz6mya landlocked country 😂😂😂lun te vajju khalistan
Singh hta le naam picho
@@Er.HarjotSingh-xz6myIndia is the fastest growing economy, plus looking at the trends of unemployment rate , it is receding significantly.
Tell us Indians your plan on building an economy for khalistan. Where is the capital? What is the source of it? Describe the prudential reasons, and also what type of government would be in it? For I can see that there’s a high possibility of militant rule.
@@mrweed9178 Lunn te vaje fer mere hindu rashtra te lindustan smjeya
Kudos to your efforts the whole panth needs videos like these.
Does he have a valid point? The man in the blue
People do not want khalistan. But truck and taxi drivers need refugee so they do this cheep politics
Khotestan 😅
Lindustani😂
This is a joke. Ask the people if ever Khalistan exists would they ever consider going to khalistan and live there with there families?
Sikh community always stand for OPRESSION , what are ur thoughts on Hindu rastar ? What do u think Hindu raster being promoted in national media and Sikh farmers also being called as khalistani , what do u think ABOUT HINDU RASTAR BACCHE . Are they any different from Khalistan ?
No hate to you kattapa but my view is I am a happily teenager Indian Sikh. I don't want khalistan in India. India will remain the same from all the directions. First khalistani should try to get Punjab from Pakistan. They are already going to collapse. You should try to get Punjab Pakistan. I also believe Sikh who want khalistan are forgetting what really Sikh are. Again if someone hurt my country 🇮🇳 or my people never forget we have brave regiment army specially Sikh regiment and don't forget submarine, rocket, nuclear bomb, tank. And you have nothing's just like Pakistan If Pakistan comes in way, they always lose ( all war they lost since independence 😂) .
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa waheguru ji ki Fateh
Bhart mata ki Jai
you're not a sikh lmao. hindus love larping istg.
Well said
Uncle in blue shirt was right, If Khalistan is to make in India then this referendum should happen in India, but ig i won't be possible there because 99% of Punjabis are against Khalistan in India
Kohn keha thonu? mere vallo saare Sikhaan nu Azadi chahida, Khalistan Zindawad, sovereignty is the only solution
Hindu is sightless
Khalistan is Punjabi chauvinism and it has nothing to do with Sikhism or Khalsa. Punjabi Sikhs instead of spreading the message of Sikhism to other people are excluding them to be a Sikh by restricting the message of Guru Nanak, Guru Gobind Singh ji and Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji. They want Sikhism to be exclusively remain among Punjabis. Whole of India can become Khalistan if message of our Gurus disseminates in a proper way (Gurbani in their own native languages). Khalistan is harming Sikhism. We should not ally with Islamic terrorists who really are following their desert cult.
Thank you for making this ❤️
Lots of respect bro, really nice video
the concept of khalistan is pretty ridiculous... just imagine a small country sandwiched between two big nuclear armed nations... lol 😂 😂
They'd fall into a civil war the moment they'd come into existence. There would be people quite angry with the partition.
not really
Badaaaal😊
Look now boy 😅😅
Lol canada has no nukes yet its surrounded by nukes
next week never came!
Fr
This line was right 👍
Only Indian Punjabi citizens have right to vote for referendum not Canadian or foreigners.
They went there from punjab only lol. And if punjabis have right why is refrendom banned in punjab
@@mTrader1 should I call them Punjabi or Canadians ??
75% of Sikhs live in Panjab. Majority of Sikhs living in foreign countries are the ones who fled from Panjab in order to survive. So they definitely have the right to vote for this. As for foreign-born Panjabis, they also have the right to vote for the freedom of their rightful homeland, do they not? Otherwise why do people do protests for Israel or Ukraine in the UK or USA; if they're not citizens of those countries then - with your logic - they don't have a say right?
@@paramrajsingh8585 khari gall
Well, It is technically right as long as India allows voting for referendum in India. Right now, Indian government isn't holding any voting for referendum and they are aganist it and they crack down on every one who supports it. So these votings has to held somewhere else. And if we talk about sikhs and punjabis who left India, they did it in order to survive and escape the genocide and oppression their community is going through. So, they have a right to vote as well.
Very good sides of the story , jokes apart - katapa from hamdard tv surely did a better job at most of the people covering the event.
I am a Sikh and love India, I do not feel Khalistan is a viable fix to what is wrong in our state, our culture is broken which needs a fix and harmony amongst all not only brown people is critical for the world to move forward.
Religions are Faith are meant to do as their name suggests. Killing, Separation and Anger shouldn’t be a part of it as they dilute what we all stand for.
I respect everyone and their opinion but most of the people won’t go back IF khalistan was made a separate state. No one would like to live in a landlocked country surrounded by enemies
Nothing in the comment that I can't agree to💯
India is making it worse by not freeing the bandi singhs. We literally live surrounded by enemy - india
I used to support khalistan but now I don't cus if we cant all be khalsa, we cant all keep our kesh how will we maintains a whole country
Do more info videos on sikh history or khalisthan …Informatic and always support my broh❤️🔥❤️🔥
We can't even run a gurdwara let alone anything else
First time in years, Katapa really did a great interview and made a eye opening video for the community. Keep it up brother and do these kind of videos more often along with other funny ones. Stay blessed
Eye opening video ta oho honi aa jado punjab diya kudiya di asliyata canada vich apne channel te vekhaunga
Khalistan map does not include Lahore, the capital of Maharaja Ranjit Singh Empire. Hmmm
This is pure foolishness, Punjab need education ,employment and people who can live there .Villages are empty for Canada dreams people are mad for leaving Punjab .Marrying there sister so they can reach Canada .Living outside India and shouting we want Khalistan is only harming our comunity ,so stop this bullshit .
the biggest threat to our community is the people from our community itself. All the past events were Sikhs experienced injustice did involve the people from our community itself. So, if Khalistan happens, which is being demanded by people who're living outside India, they will continue living there and the people who didn't want Khalistan will be forced to live in Khalistan. It'll give a free hand to the rulers who can now impose anything on the people. Trust me referendum is happening for this decision. Later, for any policy implementation in Khalistan, will not have democratic way of deciding policies. They'll be directly imposed (most likely in a dictatorship environment). We will not be able to ask help in that situation, as everyone else (states, countries etc.) will say, you chose this.
Bro half of the indian sikh population lives outside punjab n they have good business where they will go
75 percent of sikhs live in Punjab where did you get half from😂
@@thesingh588 that's wrong Sikhs are just 53% according to the last census(wikipedia) .now even less . In just 10 years we won't be the majority in punjab
They will get babaji ka thullu...... from Indian Govt.....😂😂
Love it veereh! Good interview style, do more of these
the concept of khalistan is pretty ridiculous... just imagine a small country sandwiched between two big nuclear armed nations... lol 😂 😂
@@politiussnewsnetwork9863 we live in the 21st century mate. Plus the Sikhs are who fought these wars and currently make up the majority of the indian army. I believe the Khalistan movement has come to abolish the use of drugs and beadbi in panjab. Politicians feed off the drug money and there is high rates of poverty for a state which exports so much produce.
My comment to katapa was to do more civilised interviews and not comedy. I think you presumed I meant interview more on Khalistan.
Peace and Love
@@politiussnewsnetwork9863Such a country exists. Switzerland, Netherlands, Bolivia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, Georgia, Bulgaria, Libya, Algeria, Bhutan, Laos, Siberia, etc so many. Doesn't matter they're nuclear powers, nobody is willing to engage in nuclear warfare.
@@politiussnewsnetwork9863One could argue that naming a country after a Subcontinent even though that country doesn't occupy the whole subcontinent is ridiculous.
@@georgehearn2024 tu c saare ghoose ghate o 2 number ch gye hoye. Those maa pyo v do number ch gaye aa. Bina data to e kahi jana sikhs make majority of army.
Just one question for these people why they don’t include Pakistan part of Punjab in their Khalistan
These terrorist are funded by Pakistan. That's why.
Because legally, Sikhs/hindus no longer have a claim on those lands - they were given away to the Islamic republic of Pakistan by Pandit Negru. We can only include what we currently have. I agree, the maps are outrageous - by including random districts into khalistan, and whoever designs them is a fuddu. But don’t worry, if we do get independence, Lahore will be the first regional city to fall, followed by Delhi⚔️
Come back to reality and In this modern era No one can do shit
@@AmitYadav-ki7zq Khalsa can do anything. But the referendum is obviously not realistic. we're going to have to fight for our land.
@@puffmuff586 look man I have no hatred against any people but I don’t think anyone in these times can change borders forcefully of any country whichever it is. Only thing you or me can do is work hard or smart and make our parents and us comfortable. and I watch this coz is funny. now you guys can says you are all powerful etc etc its funny at the end
Respect to Katapa for this video, shed some light on why Khalistan is so important for Sikhs. Hopefully the younger generation can carry on the fight
Nope..we dont want any khalisatn.. instead of fighting govt u guys are fighting with nation..come here in india..be in politics..and establish khalsa raaj..not khalisatn
@Yaar.13_Lit many Sikhs have been murdered doing this. They are not listening.
@@Yaar.13_Litand india is gonna let u do that come out of the bubble of fake pseudo democracy
@@Yaar.13_Lit Khalistan is Khalsa raaj
@@Yaar.13_Litshut it you India bot
But why don't they protest in india and why didn't they mention the Pakistani punjab because it have most of our history
nice video - finally understood everything about the topic ❤
Love ur energy bro!!! Keep rocking
Raj Bina Nai Dharam Chale Hai, Dharam Bina Sab Dalle Malle Hai, Raj Karega Khalsa
Waiting for instagram fake followers part 2 like it who want part 2
we are not those support khalistan by land .. we are those who support khalistan by thinking .. that we can’t tolerate the crisis
Say no to khalistan.only Hindustan. Jai Hind.🙏
Yes to khalistan. Waheguru ji ka Khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
im in canada now im not canadain or indian im punajbi farmer nd khalistan when farmers protest is going on i been there but i see there is no violence or anything farmers want justice indian government is doing dictatorship then i see indian national media saying everyone is khalistani then i release that yes we are if your saying its true indian government is doing bad with sikh since we lost our kingdom
Im not clear why people outside india are voting on referendum...surely this is a internal matter for the people who actually live in punjab?
Mate did u not listen to what he said 😂
Brooo why not they come to india and ask for the rights. Because they know what will happened to them.and yeah the indian sikh soldiers,players, like this nothing happened mark my words about this
Dude I have nothing against Khalistan but I just want to say that although you guys want Khalistan you still don’t know the whole roots of it and what it will cause. If Khalistan is created then the Sikhs of Punjab india will go after the Punjab of Pakistan and cause war. Even if not Pakistan they will go after Haryana or Himachal. I personally believe that the trust between the india government and Sikhs is so broken after 1984 that the Indian government is afraid to give Sikhs any sort of relief.
Akahand Bharat 🇮🇳🪷
hindu rashtra + khalistan 😍
@@japsingh8497 kala khalistan bai ... aaa akhand pakhand hi aa
They should hold a referendum at the guy in the blues shirt since hes got a problem with it being held on city property
We are from the humdard tv😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂 protesting for Punjab in Canada!??? I mean it's like looking for clothes in kitchen.😂😂
Meanwhile in India...no body cares😂
Try doing it in India, you'll die or be jailed lol.
It is very difficult to be done in India as the government tortures the freedom fighters and goes upto the cruel deed of giving shock to genitalia. Thus so. I hope your question is answered.
Wow it’s almost like protestors get arrested by Indian govt when they do it over there
ਠਾਕਰ ਆ ਤੂੰ ਤਾਂ ਸੜਨਾ ਈ ਆ ਸਿੱਖਾਂ ਤੋ 🖕🏻🖕🏻🖕🏻ਪਹਿਲਾ ਹਸੀਨਾ ਏ ਹਿੰਦ ਚੇ ਕੀ ਹੋਇਆ ਸੀ ਇਹ ਪੜ ਫੇ ਗੱਲ ਕਰੀ ਅੱਗੇ
"Freedom Fighters" 💀
Bro u make me cry when interviewed jathedar saab🙏
How many punjabi hindus are there for voting by the way in Indian punjab there are 39% hindus 😂😂
Smart punjabi Hindus will vote for as they know what's best for their children. Living under Indian government their chances are slim
@@g.a.m.b.i Everyone is living peacefully and getting employment under the Indian government irrespective of any religion. There are some problems in every country whether it is usa canada India. The current condition of punjab is bad because punjabi youth are going abroad.
@lakshchanan4690 brother me and you are living different realities. Who caused the flooding in punjab just recently? I rest my case
@@g.a.m.b.i if you think of natural disasters being caused by some government body i cant change your mind. It is the same as the AAP blaming the BJP for floods in delhi. Every year the north east faces floods but the Indian government doesn't blame china for that.
@lakshchanan4690 nope the water was getting under controlled when the government decided to release the damm water again. I don't trust the Indian Government dude, and the rest if the world if seeing the cracks in indias so called democracy. Don't worry about Khalistan bro worry about Manipur and such events
When will you be making another video ?😊
Brother I respectfully disagree with the idea of Khalistan. And I love the Sikh religion more than my own Hindu religion. My family is Hindu Punjabi from Tarn Tarn area, during the 80s my family was heavily persecuted for being Hindu Punjabi. My father had to leave India. Half of his friends were killed for being Hindu. One prime example is deepak dawan. My mother’s side was saved by Baba Manochahal. As my grandfather was the only math teacher in the villages and baba Manochahal was his student and loved my grandfather. He told my grandfather that kadkus were going to come to your house to kill you and told him to hide somewhere else. My mother her four sisters one brother and grandparents all hid in a Sikh families house. When they came to their house the next day their furniture was destroyed.
bullshit
facts
Cap
If u love it so much convert
Most likely never happened. Free Khalistan.
One of your best video . Keep it up with clean videos
It definitely has a strong root on why its needed. The injustice and mistrestment of punjab. Drug culture promotion, the issue with SYL. If this doesnt show how they want to subdue our people i dont know what will. The only concern i have is the management of this new nation, if we get good leaders then it will prosper beyond imagination. We dont need puppets of the indian government puppeteering punjab.
Where did you find this blue shirt fudu from India.
But bro bigger Punjab still stays in Pakistan why don't we ask them also😂
is it me or does he look pretty big with that vest on😭😭
The killing of moose wala was gang related not because he spoke about Khalistan.
yeah he is just manipulating facts.
Exactly
No it was planned by government as no proof has been found my anyone to back that he had any connections with gang people. Source Indian government.
Day before he died he was talking about khalistan on an interview with another journalist. He had members of shiromani akali dal amritsar which supports khalistan at his house too and then the next day he died. Was it a coincidence or was it because the government knew he had so much support from all across the world he could gain so much support and change peoples minds about it?
@@r17380 ok
Sidhu moosewala has never talked about khalisthan as he was living peacefully in indiaa
bhai g nashe me ho jag jao .
@@rubinsingh9383 he never support khalistan he only wants nation like ranjit singh time
@@KohliGamingOfficial bai udi gala nu ek bare ferto go through karke aa
@@rubinsingh9383 tusi dsdo ode as it is word nale ohh video dssdo
Bro history speaks itself..
singgga nal vair naa payyyi 🪯
Don't mix khalistan with Sikhism 🙏
Rip hardeep singh ji 🤍⚔️🙏
Haven't finished watching yet, but I think a lot of people, including myself, tend to forget that many of our parents were in their teens.
The families I talked to about 1984 were split. Some want to be free of oppression, and others think the creation of Kahlistan will divide us further.
The assassination definitely shook up the community. Shocking this can happen so close to many of us at a sacred place.
Although you may be profane, you still keep it rock hard for the community
I think its important to discuss the good things and the bad things associated with this movement. There are plenty of people who represent that group poorly. For starters the referdom needs to happen in India. Why escape all those problems in India just to vote on Indian problems seems backwards af. Secondly the air Canada bombing no one seems to be talking about, this group has so many radicals that have absolutely guttered the khalistani movement. In the end I would like to say that I can very much sympathize with the movement but I just generally cannot agree with the premise and the current approach. A good solution would be to internally clean up the movement by disposing of the violent terrorist's and radicals and removing any association with them, and secondly to have this vote in the nation of India. Protest on ground zero, as difficult as that may be if you are really passionate about the movement and the message it needs to be on ground zero. I normally do not comment on videos but felt this needed some discussion. Jai Hind and Whaeguru ji da Khalsa Wheguru Ji di phate. let us unite and take a proper and civil approach to this very serious topic.
its weird that NRI sikhs want khalistan but the actual sikh community living in punjab, don't want khalistan lmao.
Is that the case? If so why is government opposed to referendum in Punjab? If that's truly the case, it would be a done deal within a matter of days. But we both know that's not the truth.
Sangrur voted for Khalistani MP Simranjit Singh Mann last year. How many people took part in Khalsa Vaheer? How many people show up to Sri Akal Takht Sahib on June 6? Go to Punjab and ask.
@@GuptSingh1469i m from sangrur . People just voted for simrnjit singh mann just because of deep sidhu . Do u know how many times he lost before nd even people not liking him now . He will lose again next time nd brother that is truth no body cares in punjab . Maybe 1 percent no more. Nobody is talking about amritpal singh anymore thts shows how much people care
@@AmritpalSingh-hl8tm Indeed, These NRI Sikhs are fucking up our reputation back in our country, thanks to you fuckers we need to go deal with bad comments. JUST BECAUSE YOU WANT KHALISTAN and WE DONT
Lmao search up 1984 rally in Punjab every year theres lakhs of people quit this bs gandu hindu propaganda that nobody asks for it
Cousin Vicky lmao
Sat shree akal saare prava nu. Apa sare pra va. Na koi Khalistan na koi India we all are brother and I agree with referendum but we all want peace and harmony. But there are some naughty 😈 elements they are just spreading hate and have support of Pakistan 😂. But then doesn’t matter at all. But we all need to get together and establish brotherhood between our communities ❤️.@katapatv
Veere koi proof haini ke amritpal, nijjar hori Pakistani ton tankha lainde si
Your best video. RIP Hardeep Singh Nijjar
CANADA CH AH GHOOSIYA BHORKE NI BANN NA KHALSTAN.. ETHE AAKE SYNGH SAJJO PANJAB CH RHO KATH KRO FER GAL BANN NI.. BAHRLIYA COUNTRIES CH LANGAR LAAKE KUSHH NI HONA SYNGHO
most Sikhs in India don't want Khalistan. Majority of the support comes from Sikhs living abroad. Khalistan makes zero sense, because India would not exist without the help of Sikhs. We play such a crucial role in the development of India in every aspect. All these supporters living abroad would not give up their lives to go and develop Khalistan. Not to mention, how would we train Sikhs with high skills that are required to start and maintain a country. Western Sikhs are that are skilled are not going to fly to Khalistan to educate the population with the needed skills. Khalistan would be as impoverished as Pakistan, if not worse. I understand why we want our own nation, but logistically, it makes zero sense. The quest for Khalistan is another take at the "foul's gold."
@@xG5S LMFAOOOO I'm a Jatt, who was born in Jalandar and moved to the states when I was 7, but aight cope more.
Proud of you katapa veer
people keep saying that the people who voting here have no rights to ask for a separate state. But, they have to understand that these are the people that have been displaced from India/Punjab during the genocide. It was because of the circumstances during the genocide that made them refugees and not by choice. Thereby, due to self education of the new generation, and with a connection to ancestors and religious backgrounds, they have a right to demand a State that is safe to practise their beliefs. Mind you, I don't agree to it, but, it is their rights. I just hope and pray, it doesn't turn into a overly religious State like the Taliban.