I know you said you're not taking requests right now, but I request that you gets lots of restful sleep, good vibes, good energy, eat well, be happy, and stay beautiful. I know that's a lot to ask for but I hope you get to it!
A lot of their early sound was heavily influenced and aided by eSNa who has a degree in jazz vocals from the States! She wrote/helped work on their early stuff and currently is an indie artist herself and still composes/produces & instructs other singers/idols in the recording studio -- she gets called in specifically for aiding with English pronunciation and meanings :) She also has written some top drama OSTs over the years. I'd recommend you give her a listen in the future for that jazz sound.
To provide context to what was all the trend then for girl group releases mid decade 2014-2016: Tall model type sexy kittens emphasis on sexy/suggestive choreo Mamamoo rookie debut gambled and went opposite direction: girl next door type, emphasis on vocals with retro sound, suggestive lyrics instead It was different it got people like me (who didnt give a rats ass about kpop) paying attention and change my view that it may have something for me afterall. Ended up stanning after seeing legendary 6th episode of mamamootv realizing these girls were the real deal. The early retro sound got a very loyal small cult following but not big enough to get music show wins. They only won and broke thru mainstream years after.
Thanks Caitlin for reacting to Mamamoo albums chronologically. This way we can appreciate more their development musicwise. And we can appreciate some of their experimental songs that hide inside an album.
as for wheein I recommend you “goodbye” her vocals here incredible, “easy” because it’s a bop, “water color” her latest comeback, “springtime” she wrote this song for moomoos. thank you.
Such an underestimed mini-album even if it has only 3 songs all of them are masterpieces! This album contains another song called "Love lane", i hope you'll check it even on your own time it's a great song
Dude honestly I can't believe this was their 2nd full MV and they went this hard. I love how it showcases their theatrical ease and vocal talent. Moon will be the death of me always and wheeins runs send me
I'm so excited for the wheein solo! There's so many it's hard to choose from, but I'd say: Easy, Watercolor, Goodbye and Trash performance vid? Ugh I love her
They do another collaboration with Esna, called Ahh Oop. I believe she wrote the song, but the company gradually fazed her out of the stage productions - could be she was busy with other projects and I may be wrong. She is with them in the video and it is quite cute. You are going to enjoy Whee In's solo album Red. She did live videos of all of the songs. Looks like she had a great time promoting.
nope, the company purposefully phased her out after having convinced her to collab with mamamoo for the song (she wrote it intending it to be her debut song). she's very much not happy how they handled things and left the company pretty much immediately after. that said, she still loves mamamoo (and the other rbw artists), just not the agency itself
aaaa yes jazzy era of mamamoo is so iconic and timeless!! they're going to have an online concert this saturday (aug 28) and they're performing their songs thru the years :)) excited to see your wheein solo reaction
they have another song with esna “ahh oop and also hwasa have song with her “love comes” korean and english version. and as far as i know she wrote some songs for mamamoo in beginning of they career. thank you for reaction. can’t wait for wheein. take care of yourself.
WOW! i didn't expect a Mamamoo reaction, thank you so much!! 🥰 Esna it's really such a good artist she was in the same agency of Mamamoo (she not anymore) so you gonna hear her again i agree her voice it's phenomenal, Gentleman it's such a good song and was written by Esna 😂 even don't be happy was written by her i guess she's the reason for Mamamoo to be this retro inspired, Piano men video 🥰 Piano man lyrics 😳 it's a classic
Wheein has so many great songs so I don't know how you will choose but at some point in your journey i highly recommend Butterfly ft Gsoul. Love your reactions!
As always, I loved watching you discovering a new Mamamoo album!!! Your enthusiasm and love keep bringing a smile on my face and I hope you have one on yours right now!!! Thank you and much love to you!!!!
hey, as always i love your reaction to music, you're so passionate 👍 Btw Hwasa and esna did a song together, it's one of my favorite it's : '' love comes ''
Esna was a big part of Mamamoo's music for the first 3 EP's (Hello, Piano Man, and Pink Funky) then she and RBW parted ways (story too long to convey here).
For when you do the solo round for Moonbyul, here are some suggestions: Eclipse (badass Moonbyul) Absence (vocalist and dancer Moonbyul) Trying to say goodbye (main vocalist on a ballad Moonbyul) th-cam.com/video/ZjhctbeifW0/w-d-xo.html Moon Movie (hype live performer Moonbyul) th-cam.com/video/JaCvxkIplQQ/w-d-xo.html Looking forward to it 😍🙏🏼
Hai Caitlin! I love your opening and closing song so much ^^ and I realize that you have great taste in music. If you don't mind can you share your English songs playlist with us, please :)
oh man, esna... there's so much about her, a lot good, some not so good (the way she was treated by the company) she's an american singer-songwriter who got started in south korea, being picked up by wa entertainment, the brand new agency that was about to debut their first girl group, mamamoo. (they later became known as rainbow bridge world). she actually was involved in quite a number of mamamoo's early songs, either co-composing or co-writing them. several of the songs they performed were actually originally things she wrote for herself but was convinced to give to mamamoo to perform (i believe the pre-debut "don't be happy" was one of those) you'll see her again singing "ahh oop" with the girls, which is a bittersweet moment... the song is amazing, but esna's treatment reached a head here and she left the agency because of it, came back to live in the states again). "ahh oop" was a song she wrote intending to be her debut song, but she was convinced to share it with mamamoo. the stylist apparently purposefully made her look quite old for the mv (she's only a few years older than solar but looks... a lot older in that mv) and she got crapped on by knetz for being 'too old' and 'not pretty enough' ...you know, typical fare from those asshats... but the agency used that as an excuse to pull esna off of promotions...for her own song... and left it with just mamamoo... she still absolutely adores the girls, though, and any time they're in the states for any reason she tries to be there, typically as host and/or translator for their shows
Aw yay I'm so happy you're alternating between solo stuff and albums, and I'm SOOO happy you reacted to Gentleman, LOVE that jam. Wheein is going to knock your socks off, so prepare yourself. EDIT: (Caitlyn only read this if you haven't already filmed the "Wheein reaction.") So I was ruminating over what would make a really unique "WHEEIN" reaction and I think I've got a few that will create a really well-rounded first impression. 1. Watercolor - it's the title track on her most recent album (Redd), and it seems like a really personal composition. (honestly the whole album is an absolute masterpiece) 2. TRASH ft. PH-1 (Redd)(performance video) - I think more people need to recognize a) her excellent taste in music (leans R&B) b) her EXTREMELY underrated dancing ability, she's so good. 3. Anymore (with Jung Key) Live on Yu Huiyeol's Sketchbook or 1theK live - It's not a proper Wheein impression if you haven't heard her live. This one's a ballad and it made me forget how to breathe. 4. Easy ft. Sik-k - It's such an excellent track, so well-written and produced.
your reactions to Mamamoo are my fav' reactions, and as someone who ONLY listens to Mamamoo and Mamamoo related stuff, IT MEANS THE WORLD. Love from Chile, South America, QUEEN! Let's be friends! haha!
i love your mamamoo album reaction, bc i,m a bad fan and didn't take the time to listen to their b-sides and wow theyre so NICE plus it's like i'm watching it with a friend haha
Your reactions always make so happy! Im not sure how to explain it, but you have a very positive vibe around you, and you always come across as a very genuine person. Thanks for taking the time to explore their older discography🥰 Also very excited to hear that you’ll be checking out Wheein’s solos next! My personal suggestions would be her 3 title tracks and one performance video that she released this year with her mini album Redd Easy: th-cam.com/video/U_tQ-GIC0O8/w-d-xo.html Goodbye (Ballad) : th-cam.com/video/U_dpIqCDcZk/w-d-xo.html Watercolor (TT for Redd, released this year): th-cam.com/video/ShFKF2YN7H0/w-d-xo.html Trash (performance vid, no subs): th-cam.com/video/cnnaBrj_Ses/w-d-xo.html I’ve seen in the comments ppl recommending some of her bsides from Redd. She released live clips for all of them (with eng subs), some songs sound slightly different from the album version since they're live Live Clips: Trash: th-cam.com/video/oCSadXDV2Yg/w-d-xo.html Ohoo: th-cam.com/video/Uns545_GEzk/w-d-xo.html Butterfly: th-cam.com/video/jHTXC_FdVis/w-d-xo.html Springtime (song for moomoos): th-cam.com/video/vgQSKH365Xs/w-d-xo.html No Thanks: th-cam.com/video/4dJSqNvK3Vo/w-d-xo.html As I saw someone mention, she did a cover of baekhyun's candy (sadly didn't include her dancing): th-cam.com/video/toMi0n2pFo0/w-d-xo.html All members have some covers though, that could be for another time in the future There's also the song 25, but although it is a "solo" it is included in the mamamoo discography, since it was for their four seasons project, so again I’d think that could be for later th-cam.com/video/6l4divMKp4E/w-d-xo.html
3:35 same girl... 😁 I wonder who's your bias? You always share love to these girls equally which i really love it. But i dont know why your reaction to moonstar always hit different and relatable (moonstar is my bias tho😍). Btw, can't wait to wheein solo marathon. My fav wheein solo are EASY, GOODBYE, WATERCOLOR, TRASH.
Hey Caitlin I know this isn’t a TXT video but I don’t know if you heard TXT Sriracha it is an amazing song and I would love to see you react to it And I feel like you would love it because it is an amazing song by the way I really love watching your videos you inspire me a lot you’re so confident and strong and you encourage me a lot I don’t know if you’re gonna see this but if you do thank you for all you do
![MAMAMOO: Piano Man MV/Live Reaction! [+ Gentleman Lyrics!]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DzUAVv7ToAI/mqdefault.jpg)
![กิโลเมตรที่ 0 เดินทางรอบโลกไม่ใช้เครื่องบิน [Around The World Ep. 1]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/toJG9oofLFY/mqdefault.jpg)
I know you said you're not taking requests right now, but I request that you gets lots of restful sleep, good vibes, good energy, eat well, be happy, and stay beautiful. I know that's a lot to ask for but I hope you get to it!
preach sister
YESSS
yes YES YESSSSS
This is so wholesome. Caitlin and everyone who reads this, hope the same for you too!
Yes
That era they won best rookie of the year award..and thank you for the reaction!!!.. continue loving them!!!
A lot of their early sound was heavily influenced and aided by eSNa who has a degree in jazz vocals from the States! She wrote/helped work on their early stuff and currently is an indie artist herself and still composes/produces & instructs other singers/idols in the recording studio -- she gets called in specifically for aiding with English pronunciation and meanings :) She also has written some top drama OSTs over the years. I'd recommend you give her a listen in the future for that jazz sound.
the dots are connecting as to why her english sounds so good and her phrasing/cadence/articulation sound very jazz. gonna have to look into her
To provide context to what was all the trend then for girl group releases mid decade 2014-2016:
Tall model type sexy kittens emphasis on sexy/suggestive choreo
Mamamoo rookie debut gambled and went opposite direction: girl next door type, emphasis on vocals with retro sound, suggestive lyrics instead
It was different it got people like me (who didnt give a rats ass about kpop) paying attention and change my view that it may have something for me afterall. Ended up stanning after seeing legendary 6th episode of mamamootv realizing these girls were the real deal.
The early retro sound got a very loyal small cult following but not big enough to get music show wins. They only won and broke thru mainstream years after.
They won with Youre the Best which it's still retro sounding but still amazing
Thanks Caitlin for reacting to Mamamoo albums chronologically. This way we can appreciate more their development musicwise. And we can appreciate some of their experimental songs that hide inside an album.
as for wheein I recommend you “goodbye” her vocals here incredible, “easy” because it’s a bop, “water color” her latest comeback, “springtime” she wrote this song for moomoos. thank you.
Ohoo and trash mvs !
@@Ichiko980 I-….I don’t know if she’s ready for the trash performance video 😭😭😭 I’m still shook and panic when I see Wheein there 💀
Such an underestimed mini-album even if it has only 3 songs all of them are masterpieces! This album contains another song called "Love lane", i hope you'll check it even on your own time it's a great song
esna has a literal degree in jazz vocals :D
If you liked the jazzy mamamoo u should listen to MELTING!! i’m sure u will die for it ahhh I love your reaction a lot Thanks for the reactionss
Dude honestly I can't believe this was their 2nd full MV and they went this hard. I love how it showcases their theatrical ease and vocal talent. Moon will be the death of me always and wheeins runs send me
Yes Amy Winehouse! Also, Solar loves Amy Winehouse she did a whole photoshoot inspired by Amy. 🖤
I'm so excited for the wheein solo! There's so many it's hard to choose from, but I'd say: Easy, Watercolor, Goodbye and Trash performance vid? Ugh I love her
They do another collaboration with Esna, called Ahh Oop. I believe she wrote the song, but the company gradually fazed her out of the stage productions - could be she was busy with other projects and I may be wrong. She is with them in the video and it is quite cute.
You are going to enjoy Whee In's solo album Red. She did live videos of all of the songs. Looks like she had a great time promoting.
nope, the company purposefully phased her out after having convinced her to collab with mamamoo for the song (she wrote it intending it to be her debut song). she's very much not happy how they handled things and left the company pretty much immediately after. that said, she still loves mamamoo (and the other rbw artists), just not the agency itself
Currently binging your videos. I love your reactions. I am currently going down a Mamamoo rabbit hole so these reactions will be fun for me.
The guy from the Piano Man MV is from B1A4 His name is Gongchan he was my bias before. LOL. but seriously, piano man album is a booommmmbbb~~!!
GIRL THERE IS A MAMAMOO ONLINE CONCERT TOMORROW
Come waaaaaaatch withhhhh!
aaaa yes jazzy era of mamamoo is so iconic and timeless!! they're going to have an online concert this saturday (aug 28) and they're performing their songs thru the years :)) excited to see your wheein solo reaction
they have another song with esna “ahh oop and also hwasa have song with her “love comes” korean and english version. and as far as i know she wrote some songs for mamamoo in beginning of they career. thank you for reaction. can’t wait for wheein. take care of yourself.
btw the reaction was🔥🔥,I love mamamoo so much,and they won rookie of the year with this album
i love to rewatch all of these and watch you on all these journeys! you are so authentic and lovely ✨
WOW! i didn't expect a Mamamoo reaction, thank you so much!! 🥰 Esna it's really such a good artist she was in the same agency of Mamamoo (she not anymore) so you gonna hear her again i agree her voice it's phenomenal, Gentleman it's such a good song and was written by Esna 😂 even don't be happy was written by her i guess she's the reason for Mamamoo to be this retro inspired, Piano men video 🥰 Piano man lyrics 😳 it's a classic
Yeeeesss thank you Caitlin
I’m so excited for your reaction to melting album if you like this sound!!! Love your reactions
Wheein has so many great songs so I don't know how you will choose but at some point in your journey i highly recommend Butterfly ft Gsoul. Love your reactions!
We love the mamamoo reactions
Yeees, cant wait for Wheein. She has so many gems, Anymore live is such a masterpiece.
I feel like gentleman should be listened in a café in paris with a glass of wine haha
im so glad you released another mamamoo reaction, thank you caitlin!!
As always, I loved watching you discovering a new Mamamoo album!!!
Your enthusiasm and love keep bringing a smile on my face and I hope you have one on yours right now!!!
Thank you and much love to you!!!!
Moonbyul in this era had me in a chokehold.
hey, as always i love your reaction to music, you're so passionate 👍
Btw Hwasa and esna did a song together, it's one of my favorite it's : '' love comes ''
You're reactions are very reminiscent of my first time watching Mamamoo's content 😂 I go crazy all the time watching your reaction videos!
Wow! Girl, ur reaction to Piano Man was a roller coaster ride.. I dont blame you cuz that's also what I've felt 1st time watching the MV..
Esna was a big part of Mamamoo's music for the first 3 EP's (Hello, Piano Man, and Pink Funky) then she and RBW parted ways (story too long to convey here).
Gentleman is SO underrated! eSNa and Mamamoo voices together are perfect! Thanks for reacting to this
For when you do the solo round for Moonbyul, here are some suggestions:
Eclipse (badass Moonbyul)
Absence (vocalist and dancer Moonbyul)
Trying to say goodbye (main vocalist on a ballad Moonbyul) th-cam.com/video/ZjhctbeifW0/w-d-xo.html
Moon Movie (hype live performer Moonbyul) th-cam.com/video/JaCvxkIplQQ/w-d-xo.html
Looking forward to it 😍🙏🏼
Reviewing all mamamoo's reacts with the hope that you will react to their albums again. Melting would be next and my favorite. 🥰
I really love you reacting to mamamoo's video!
Hai Caitlin! I love your opening and closing song so much ^^ and I realize that you have great taste in music. If you don't mind can you share your English songs playlist with us, please :)
Their older MV is so entertaining to watch. It's like watching movie 😂😂😂😂
oh man, esna... there's so much about her, a lot good, some not so good (the way she was treated by the company)
she's an american singer-songwriter who got started in south korea, being picked up by wa entertainment, the brand new agency that was about to debut their first girl group, mamamoo. (they later became known as rainbow bridge world). she actually was involved in quite a number of mamamoo's early songs, either co-composing or co-writing them. several of the songs they performed were actually originally things she wrote for herself but was convinced to give to mamamoo to perform (i believe the pre-debut "don't be happy" was one of those)
you'll see her again singing "ahh oop" with the girls, which is a bittersweet moment... the song is amazing, but esna's treatment reached a head here and she left the agency because of it, came back to live in the states again). "ahh oop" was a song she wrote intending to be her debut song, but she was convinced to share it with mamamoo. the stylist apparently purposefully made her look quite old for the mv (she's only a few years older than solar but looks... a lot older in that mv) and she got crapped on by knetz for being 'too old' and 'not pretty enough' ...you know, typical fare from those asshats... but the agency used that as an excuse to pull esna off of promotions...for her own song... and left it with just mamamoo...
she still absolutely adores the girls, though, and any time they're in the states for any reason she tries to be there, typically as host and/or translator for their shows
Aw yay I'm so happy you're alternating between solo stuff and albums, and I'm SOOO happy you reacted to Gentleman, LOVE that jam. Wheein is going to knock your socks off, so prepare yourself.
EDIT: (Caitlyn only read this if you haven't already filmed the "Wheein reaction.") So I was ruminating over what would make a really unique "WHEEIN" reaction and I think I've got a few that will create a really well-rounded first impression.
1. Watercolor - it's the title track on her most recent album (Redd), and it seems like a really personal composition. (honestly the whole album is an absolute masterpiece)
2. TRASH ft. PH-1 (Redd)(performance video) - I think more people need to recognize a) her excellent taste in music (leans R&B) b) her EXTREMELY underrated dancing ability, she's so good.
3. Anymore (with Jung Key) Live on Yu Huiyeol's Sketchbook or 1theK live - It's not a proper Wheein impression if you haven't heard her live. This one's a ballad and it made me forget how to breathe.
4. Easy ft. Sik-k - It's such an excellent track, so well-written and produced.
Seni çok seviorum yaa Mamamoonun da ayrı aşığıyım✨🤍
I feel you gurl! I love mamamoo sm!
your reactions to Mamamoo are my fav' reactions, and as someone who ONLY listens to Mamamoo and Mamamoo related stuff, IT MEANS THE WORLD.
Love from Chile, South America, QUEEN! Let's be friends! haha!
I cant wait for AHH OOP! It’s one of my favorite tracks from them and there’s barely any reactions to it.
PIANO MAN LIVE PERFORMANCE IS GOLD
i love your mamamoo album reaction, bc i,m a bad fan and didn't take the time to listen to their b-sides and wow theyre so NICE plus it's like i'm watching it with a friend haha
Yeaaah please moooore about MAMAMOO 😍
i might play gentleman on my wedding too, i mean to dance and sway slowly under the moonlight while this song is playing damnnn 🤩😫❤️
Amazing as always (talking about you and Mamamoo)
You will need a lightstick of MAMAMOO
Your reactions always make so happy! Im not sure how to explain it, but you have a very positive vibe around you, and you always come across as a very genuine person. Thanks for taking the time to explore their older discography🥰
Also very excited to hear that you’ll be checking out Wheein’s solos next! My personal suggestions would be her 3 title tracks and one performance video that she released this year with her mini album Redd
Easy: th-cam.com/video/U_tQ-GIC0O8/w-d-xo.html
Goodbye (Ballad) : th-cam.com/video/U_dpIqCDcZk/w-d-xo.html
Watercolor (TT for Redd, released this year): th-cam.com/video/ShFKF2YN7H0/w-d-xo.html
Trash (performance vid, no subs): th-cam.com/video/cnnaBrj_Ses/w-d-xo.html
I’ve seen in the comments ppl recommending some of her bsides from Redd. She released live clips for all of them (with eng subs), some songs sound slightly different from the album version since they're live
Live Clips:
Trash: th-cam.com/video/oCSadXDV2Yg/w-d-xo.html
Ohoo: th-cam.com/video/Uns545_GEzk/w-d-xo.html
Butterfly: th-cam.com/video/jHTXC_FdVis/w-d-xo.html
Springtime (song for moomoos): th-cam.com/video/vgQSKH365Xs/w-d-xo.html
No Thanks: th-cam.com/video/4dJSqNvK3Vo/w-d-xo.html
As I saw someone mention, she did a cover of baekhyun's candy (sadly didn't include her dancing): th-cam.com/video/toMi0n2pFo0/w-d-xo.html
All members have some covers though, that could be for another time in the future
There's also the song 25, but although it is a "solo" it is included in the mamamoo discography, since it was for their four seasons project, so again I’d think that could be for later th-cam.com/video/6l4divMKp4E/w-d-xo.html
Yeeeey excited for your WheeIn reaction
Thank you for this reaction…
Piano man its just 🔥 and Gentleman omg, a dream ♥️
"I'm in heaven" me every time I listening to mamamoo's
Hwasa with 19 🥺 our baby..
I really love their sound on their rookie days the only thing that i dont really like about is byul not having much lines.
3:35 same girl... 😁 I wonder who's your bias? You always share love to these girls equally which i really love it. But i dont know why your reaction to moonstar always hit different and relatable (moonstar is my bias tho😍).
Btw, can't wait to wheein solo marathon. My fav wheein solo are EASY, GOODBYE, WATERCOLOR, TRASH.
Thank you for this
More Mamamoo Albums please
I'm sure people told you, but once you Whee-in, you cannot Whee-out. i warned you.
oh my god wheein solo reaction?????? BOY... I'm gonna have to pull out a glass of wine for that one
The man in piano man is gongchan from b1a4
Also you should react to their queendom performances, they're DA SHIT!
if you like esna and hwasa’s voice check out love comes :) it’s a collab and it’s so gorgeous
MAMAMOO is a name of queen group
I literally screamed!♡(> ਊ
Hey Caitlin I know this isn’t a TXT video but I don’t know if you heard TXT Sriracha it is an amazing song and I would love to see you react to it And I feel like you would love it because it is an amazing song by the way I really love watching your videos you inspire me a lot you’re so confident and strong and you encourage me a lot I don’t know if you’re gonna see this but if you do thank you for all you do
Moonbyul in piano man 😳🔥
MOONBYUL SOLO IM WAITING FOR THIS 😩❤️
Hwasa and Esna made a song together called 'Love Comes' and it's perfection!! Check it out~
mama mama mooooooo (I'm practicing to get it right one day)
Want Whee In Reaction. 🥺❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Hope you could listen to Hwasa and Esna's Love is coming.. they have korean and english version ❤️🥰🥰🥰👌👌
Mamamoo concert on aug 28
Don’t forget Jungkey feat. Wheein - ANYMORE.
u look so beautiful 😍 💗
I’ve never been so early in my life.
When are you going to react to wheein solo songs?
Gleam is a good one, you might be interested in.
Hiiiiii!
Check their delilah cover please
the way piano man is about fingering😭😭😭
1:39 HAHAHA
does the queen respond?
6:12. fifth member of mamamoo ?
Hey whats the outro song called
Check out her description, she has rhe songs there.
@@dafnid7294 thanks 😊
Cait, react to action figure pleaaaaase😭😭😭😭🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼❤❤❤❤❤
Plzz react to seventeen songs 💗
If u are a momoo,,,, where there aren't any photo of MAMAMOO'S girl🤔😒
React to spicy by cl
reaction DROP THAT(EXO) please