@@igotnojams7865 Yes, BTS has worked so hard in everything they do. They are all so hardworking and people should aspire to be hardworking and kind like them.
I was scared to watch because I'm not ready to cry an ocean again...but it's Bookish theories, so I can't help it. Edit: I legit cried an ocean🥺😭😭😭why are BTS so loving and caring of their fans? Why do they have to be so good? Why can't they be selfish people?? Sometimes I wish they didn't have such genuine personalities, because then it will be a lot easier to love them less, because it hurts my poor heart so much to think that they had to go through such tough times. I'm so so happy for them now💜💜💜
No no it's a misunderstanding. The girl did NOT skip tae. She went back to get her bag or something. Nd also in fan meetings they start from right side to left not the other way around so she had already met tae 😊💜
I lost it when she started talking about RM drowning in his dreams 11:29 and how the purple lights helped him swim to the surface 11:36. I could not collect myself after that and kept reflecting on the lyrics, MV, and analysis of the rest of the video. Thank you for your analysis.
Nooo... I finally stopped crying after countless tears. But you just made me cry again 😭😭😭 Now I don't think I'll be able to stop crying every time I listen to this song 😭😭😭 Oh my poor heart 💔💔💔💔
I am genuinely impressed by the amount of references you use. You literally theorise every bit and explore the connections. I love watching your BTS theories :)
This song is so real and so are BTS! I can't understand why people used to hate this 7 angels! They deserve the world! ARMY please protect BANGTAN! We are they everything! We are the reason they kept going! WE ARE THE REASON THEY ARE SUPERSTARS! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
every artist is immortalized because of the Art, the legacy the leave behind, all Artist bask in the glow of the love fans give them, but only ARMY gets to bask in the glow of BTS's love, only they Immortalize their fans, with such beautiful tribute. proud to be Army. thank you BTS
Thank you, Bookish. 😭 It has been a hard fought and passionate journey, and it definitely continues. Next stop: Grammys. RM is in battle mode. He wants it to happen on their merits. They have earned it, but it will take BTS and ARMY together to influence this. For everything that we did not expect to happen this year, BTS with ARMY has displayed their true relationship and devotion as a force that went unrecognized in the past by the general media. This year has been the greatest exposure for ARMY. We are there for the boys, and their for each other as a global community. BTS is no stranger to racism. They listened to ARMY'S that organized to support and donate. Of course BTS would do this as well because their originated and educated on the origins of hip hop, one of the few artists that vocally recognize it even more than some current western hip hop artists. Proud of you guys. Let's follow BTS and Big Hit's lead to redefine the kpop industry, and the music industry. It is so awesome to see them develop their own path. Full steam ahead. Let's go!! 💜😎🎤💘🎵🎶💪
Thank you for this... I cried... again... already attacked by this MV... now understanding it more makes my hearteu burst with love for the boys... with that feeling of "need to protect"... I came in during their Wings era... missed their hardships during their debut but witnessed their successes through and through... I love these 7 dorks with a love of a mom since I'm a 50 y.o. ARMY... that only means that my love for them is eternal as a mothers love for her children... so, on we go and face the battles hand in hand... because, together we are bulletproof... borahae fambam! 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
I'm a new army, and I'm still getting to know their story and everything they had been through until now, I didn't understand the MV when I watched it for the first time but your analysis was really good (it made me cry - some things on this video I just found out right now)! thank you 💜
It just made it so much deeper than it was before💜. It's so heart breaking bc of all the hate they get. They never did any wrong. Even if the haters call them mean and rude things bts always said love yourself and speak yourself. I wish people would stop being so judgemental and take the time to know and understand bts and their music.
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS.. 🙏🙏 I promised to myself that I won't cry anymore after listening to this song for like the 1000th time😭😭😭.... But I guess that's not possible..I mean its BTS I should have expected it😂😂... Thank you again for your videos I feel like I gain knowledge/ wisdom every time i watch your videos 💜💜💜👍👍
I cried again. I love them I really do. Even if I had to wait, I will always be here waiting for them. no matter how long it takes, I believe in them and will never let them walk alone.
I was already emotional watching the MV multiple times already. Now you made Namjoon cut more onions and I'm sweating water from my eyes again. 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭💜 Thank you so much for giving us analysis videos like this...it literally gave me more chills watching this. 💜 #ARMYsince2014
😭💜it’s beautiful 🐳you’re explaining this makes it even more clearer n makes me forever thankful for able to exist in this era where bts existed🥺💜 so much things they have taught me😌🤧💜 with this song makes a beautiful new chapter for us all, it’s only ARMYs n BTS now n forever..others none matter anymore💜
Bless whichever ARMY mentioned you in the comments of a different video for sending me to you. Your work is AMAZING. Thank you for the in-depth analysis and information. 💜
6:03 There are so many idols these days.... they'll probably be forgotten too....... . Today the whole world now bts. Oh God seeing all this makes me feel how far these boys have come. 💜💜💜
Are you even human? Your interpretation are always on another level, I'm glad, if I'm able to follow, so I can't imagine how you do these. Oh and I cried, too, this song is just too emotional. 💜
I just wanted to say what I’ve been feeling for a long time. Honestly, I don't know where to begin and there is a lot to say. I am so proud of BTS and all that they have accomplished in the past 7 years. I feel grateful to have known them since debut and to grow up with their music. All the members of BTS, always know how to bring a smile to my face and they make me laugh when I'm feeling terrible. They’ve found a way to make music that speaks to your soul and has done it in a way that is genuine and sincere. For me, those are some of the reasons why that makes them so special. I hope people can actually take the time to get to know them and listen to their music even if it’s not something they like. It won’t hurt to give it a chance. You never know what you will find. Also, I want to say this. I want BTS to know how grateful and proud their (kind, sweet, and true) Army is of them. And we will always be by your side even when we are apart. I want them to know that they’ve come a long way and overcame their bad memories and countless trials. The things that are going on right now are also trials to overcome. Stay strong, things are tough right now, but I hope you know that you can overcome anything together and that everything will turn out okay. We are bulletproof together, right 💜
Thank you. I wish most of the armies be like you and see the love and care of BTS for them, so the members could be spare of all the hate and drama! Some people forgot so easily that through their music, their performances, members offer their Souls to us. And in our blindness, for our petty little moments of malice and even envy, we choose to close our eyes and ears and step on them.
Wow, you said what I've been feeling. I love the way you said it, thank you for talking about it. "Some people forgot so easily that through their music, their performances, the members offer their Souls to us. And in our blindness, for our petty little moments of malice and even envy, we choose to close our eyes and ears and step on them." Musicians and artists are sensitive even if we say "those words" don't affect us. But it really does affect us in a negative way; it slowly builds up and harms us. As an artist, it scares me that some people have to go out of their way to say hurtful things that negatively affect our souls. So people need to be aware that "words" do really hurt if used with malice. We have to remember that BTS is all human too and they need to be treated with kindness.
So excited to see this! Btw did u see TXT's Can't You See Me? pre sequel? What are your thoughts? Wut could it be? I think it's a clue to the the extension element of the +u
If it was +u/tu related in the description there will be tu content verified by BigHit. We'll definitely get an MV for Eternally. That video will be based on tu. The teaser for Can't you see me pre-sequel is what happened between Run Away and Can't you see me. These are my opinions lol. Edit: STREAM CYSM AND PUMA!
@@redrose3576 the pre sequel is what happened between run away and CYSM? But in the pre sequel their clothes are dirty, like they were in the MV when they did the food fight. I think it's related to the +u because the MV for CYSM is related to to +u itself so I was wondering.... If everyone got back to the real world except Soobin, maybe now they are going to save him? Like in their concept pics Taehyun had the caption "We will find a way to get back" 🤔 ANYWAY STREAM CYSM AND PUMA
I think it’s definitely about Eternally, which should come out on the 20th at 00:00 kst 🧐 didn’t they say that something was gonna happen when spring gets warm? Well the 20th is the last day of spring and it’s a magical time because there’s the summer solstice right after. It’s a moment of change so Eternally fits perfectly! If you look at the video when Soobin goes to the window the lighting and the outline of what he sees is very similar to the scene in Magic Island where Yeonjun first gets out of the train. That would fit the idea that we’ll see the prequel of the sequel (so what happens between Run Away and CYSM) but since In the concept photos Taehyun wants to go back it’s also possible that they’ll be introducing time travel :D at that point it’s all over for us all 😂
I always love your analysis. I did already get most of this, but as always you added significant points! I love this song of course and weep regularly. God knows how they manage to sing it!
i cryed so mush watching this video... it`s my fav song from last album. i have really bad times mentaly right now, so MV and your video cheers my up a little bit, but i`m still fighting with my life
You are amazing and the way you demonstrate the love we have for BTS and the love BTS has for us is brilliant. Thank you for this sweet video!!! 🌷🌺 BTS + ARMY 💜 FOREVER
Me: it’s impossible to cry more because of this song than what I already had. Bookish Theories: Hold my Books. But for real, this made me cry all over again and also remember why I love them so much. Because of all of the pain, troubles and tribulations they had to go through, but also the journey to love themselves and yet, despite all the negatives, they persevered, they stayed true to themselves and then they found ARMY, who loved them no matter what, but not only they felt saved by ARMY but they also saved us. I always loose it when I see the whale of whalien 52. They were the whales, but so is ARMY, but they’re no longer just 7 and we are no longer alone 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
I love how all their songs can be interpreted in different ways. Personally when I first heard this song it felt like they were saying that as long as bts and army have eachother we are untouchable and nothing can stop us
I'd just like to add as well. 1) The part where Yoongi was being attacked by shards, it was so quick but you can see how he was clutching his left arm. That was a reference to Yoongi's accident in their earlier years that hindered him from performing complicated moves because the injury, although healed, limited his arm movements(since, you know, your arm popping out of your socket doesn't heal overnight)but of course, the injury happened in his pre debut days. The era represented by the clothes he was wearing was an era where they were slowly transitioning to intense choreos and Yoongi always felt bad that he couldn't perform his best because of the ghost pains from his injury. 2) The image of the boys sitting on top of the whale represents BTS's WINGS Final Concert, (where JK cried saying he was so happy😭) this was during the ARMY Sing moment... And BTS watched Army as if taking a photograph of the moment, with tears in their eyes 😭😭 they sat on the stage as if Army were the idols and they were our fans 😭😭😭😭😭 Oh my god, who's cutting the onions! 😭😭😭😭💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
I knew that they were already in the dark and the shadows were around them since the beginning, it's why I mentioned it in one of your theory videos. Now they've grown to overcome and accept it. I think their name Bulletproof Boyscouts is great and I thought it really fit with the times since it's so scary/violent now and back when they first started. I have always loved Taehyung's voice; it's so beautiful and unique only to him. I know even with all that hurt, they stayed true to themselves and to each other. BTS never needed to prove themselves to those haters and they still don't need to acknowledge the haters. Those haters weren’t open-minded enough to get to know BTS as a group or as individuals, so those hater's words should and will always mean nothing. The haters just decided to ignore and ridiculed them. You know those lights when Namjoon was drowning in the mv, they were blurry because of the water which made the lights look kind of like hearts. Also, the waters surface and where Namjoon and Yoongi are standing looks like the photo for their 2020 concert picture and one of the photos from the 2020 BTS Festa photo collection 19/20. It’s the one with them all standing on the water's surface; the violet sky with clouds and the other with the violet water and stars/galaxy. Since you’ve mentioned about Boy with Luv and it’s also in the mv. I wanted to share this before, but I think now is a good time. “Real love is selfless and free from fear. It pours itself out upon the object of its affection, without demanding any return. Its joy is in the joy of giving. Pure, unselfish love draws to itself its own; it does not need to seek or demand.” This is a passage from a book called “The Game of Life & How to Play it” by Florence Scovel Shinn. So the love that you give is the love that you receive. The love that Army gives to BTS is the love that BTS gives us. You’ve explained that really well. This mv made me tear up, but I didn’t cry probably because I heard the song a few times now. It does give me chills every time though. The mv just made me feel nostalgic and proud that BTS overcame their struggles. I love the whole animation it's adorable. I love the rap sections of the song too. Hoseok, Yoongi, and Namjoon’s sections of the song really got me. I love the part with the lonely whale and the part of the song with Jimin and Jungkook during the Spring Day scene of the animation. That's one of my favorite parts of the song. (“We won’t ever stop.” “We’re together here.”) Jin and Taehyung’s voices sound so good. (“Tell me your every story.” “Tell me why you don’t stop this.” “Tell me why you still walkin', walkin’ with us.”) Just everything about this song sounds beautiful; the melody, the lyrics, and the transitions in the animation 💜
@@zizziepisano1021 Honestly, I didn't know if anyone was reading my comments besides Bookish Theories and a few other people. I was feeling so nervous about commenting when I first found Bookish Theories' videos. Now, I just feel comfortable enough to leave comments on her videos. So thank you for taking the time to read my comments, I appreciate it. (I also wrote another comment on this video.) Thank you, so much :) It's been a while; I came up with this username years ago for most of my social media. I just thought of words that might work well together lol The word decadence means the process of decline or decay in society’s morals. For me, it actually means to wake up the good morality that was declining or something like that. (The good morality most people don't care about anymore.) You're welcome 😊 As for the book, it was one of the books my father owned when he was alive. It's a book I own now, it's pretty old but I think it's a good one. It's written by an artist, so that's one of the reasons why I like the book.
I’m crying 😭 they are incredible! I personally didn’t discover them while passing hard times, I’m not one of those armys that they helped overcome anxiety and depression.. they actually got to me in a phase of my life when I was very happy 😊 but I connected with them because they hard work and success inspired me! Now that the pandemic is here and I’ve felt a little bit lost their music have helped me to keep smiling, it has allow me to cry, to dance, to let all this feelings out! I can’t wait for whats to come! This boys (now men really hahah) are legends and I feel honored to be living their era!!!
Thank you Bookish Theories, once again, for the awesome reflection of the meaning of this song and the MV. It reinforces my own thoughts and reminds me of my love for all the members of BTS and my vow to always be here for them.
💜💜. Dear BT, I really love ur explanation videos especially bcos u centre it around their artistry and the connections in the universe they created for us and the overall message of their music. Since the animated MV dropped I literally can't listen to this song without weeping which is funny coz I was already crying like a baby whenever I listened to it but it's more intense now.
"Even if winter returns..." When COVID caused them to lose all the concerts they'd planned for 2020, that was a winter no one could have predicted. Now no people were against them, but was ARMY still for them? ARMY's love shined brighter in the darkness. When BTS returned their love and support through songs in English, ARMY responded and BTS hit #1 on Billboard.
Oh my heart ive seen this video and the song a million times n cry everytime this makes it so hard to stan another group i love bts to much. That it hurts and i cant let go im 30 years old n i will never let you guys go
Yes, it appears on Heartbeat MV, but also on Idol MV. And there is also that hoodie with a wale which Jin seems to like very much. And of course, we have Whalien 52. I feel like Kore is a sort of motif all through BTS' history.
bruh my eyes kept sweating 😖, no but the fact that people in their earlier years had the audacity to be biased & hateful towards these boys & call themselves fans irks me, sum of those ppl still try to call themselves fans like they deserve it😑 if you ain’t ready to love them as humans you ain’t ready to be apart of the army simple. we’re here to protect & strive with them, not bring them down
I cried soo much because of the song,the visuals and the journey itself... But after listening to this... I genuinely cried even more... You pointed out each and every minute aspect...making it even more beautiful... Thank you for this... Wow... Even the explanation is emotional 😭 We were lucky enough to born and met them.. In this lifetime... And I wish and hope to stay in this safe heaven that they have created forever... 💜
I just want to point out that some other ARMY said Suga was holding his shoulder in the animation (from his accident). And also I think the first set of falling leaves are (Autumn Leaves /dead leaves song) They are so many layers!
Oh my gosh. My heart broke when I saw the video of that girl passing Taehyung. I feel so sad... I hope that girl regrets it every day of her life... but I also hope that Taehyung forgave her.
I just discovered Bookish theories today. And this is only my 3rd video. But We Are Bulletproof: The Eternal is my all time favorite BTS song, so seeing the explanation for it was super emotional. I knew they went thru a lot to get where they are, but I didn't know all of it. It was so sad to hear and watch this video.
![[2020 FESTA] BTS (방탄소년단) 'We are Bulletproof : the Eternal' MV #2020BTSFESTA](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/7UWBYJjuIL0/mqdefault.jpg)
![[2020 FESTA] BTS (방탄소년단) 'We are Bulletproof : the Eternal' MV #2020BTSFESTA](/img/tr.png)
![⭐ฮิตในTikTok!! ( มะมะมะหมูเด้ง MooDeng ) Ver. แดนซ์ ReMix BY [ ดีเจกิต รีมิกซ์ ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4noyAoMa7bQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Oh my god... My heart literally broke when I saw the hate comments and the pictures of the black ocean. Well look who's laughing now lol
Exactly! The black ocean I can't believe people can be so cruel 😭
Agreed :(
BTS shouldn't be hated on.
I know right?! They are soooo cruel! They should support people who give their music and creations all they’ve got and being so hard working!
@@igotnojams7865 Yes, BTS has worked so hard in everything they do. They are all so hardworking and people should aspire to be hardworking and kind like them.
😭😭😭😭I can't stop crying
I was scared to watch because I'm not ready to cry an ocean again...but it's Bookish theories, so I can't help it.
Edit: I legit cried an ocean🥺😭😭😭why are BTS so loving and caring of their fans? Why do they have to be so good? Why can't they be selfish people?? Sometimes I wish they didn't have such genuine personalities, because then it will be a lot easier to love them less, because it hurts my poor heart so much to think that they had to go through such tough times. I'm so so happy for them now💜💜💜
I relate to ur comment 100%
Yes me too. Crying!
*That girl who passed by V, girl... how's life looking at V now? *devil laugh**
but the face that V was so sad. I can't get over it🥺🥺
No no it's a misunderstanding. The girl did NOT skip tae. She went back to get her bag or something. Nd also in fan meetings they start from right side to left not the other way around so she had already met tae
😊💜
@@muzainas8664 ah ok 😅💜
@@muzainas8664 yes
They have explained this many times, i dont understand why everyone still brings it up. The girl didnt skip Taehyung.
I lost it when she started talking about RM drowning in his dreams 11:29 and how the purple lights helped him swim to the surface 11:36. I could not collect myself after that and kept reflecting on the lyrics, MV, and analysis of the rest of the video. Thank you for your analysis.
Nooo... I finally stopped crying after countless tears. But you just made me cry again 😭😭😭
Now I don't think I'll be able to stop crying every time I listen to this song 😭😭😭
Oh my poor heart 💔💔💔💔
same im crying rn
Same
Same im crying now
I am genuinely impressed by the amount of references you use. You literally theorise every bit and explore the connections. I love watching your BTS theories :)
How could you crack all of these mvs and their meanings and theories asdfghjkl
A question I always ask myself with no answer
I shed so much tears watching this MV. It's wonderful. Your analysis makes it even better.
Your analysis makes this MV even more meaningful.
Thank you so much
This song is so real and so are BTS! I can't understand why people used to hate this 7 angels! They deserve the world! ARMY please protect BANGTAN! We are they everything! We are the reason they kept going! WE ARE THE REASON THEY ARE SUPERSTARS! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Is this going to make me cry... probably
Am I still going to watch it...ABSOLUTELY ITS BOOKISH THEORIES!
Just when I thought this song couldn’t make me any more emo 🥺
Army would surely get choked up while watching this.
When I say, I CRIED RIVERS!!!!
I MEAN IT!!!
every artist is immortalized because of the Art, the legacy the leave behind, all Artist bask in the glow of the love fans give them, but only ARMY gets to bask in the glow of BTS's love, only they Immortalize their fans, with such beautiful tribute. proud to be Army. thank you BTS
“The price of greatness is responsibility” (Winston Churchill). it`s what BTS going through
This song is very touchy and with the theories, it's just amazing.
I almost cry 😭
Yep. Made me cry! Again! I didn't even know I still had tears left after Festa 2020!
Thank you, Bookish. 😭 It has been a hard fought and passionate journey, and it definitely continues. Next stop: Grammys. RM is in battle mode. He wants it to happen on their merits. They have earned it, but it will take BTS and ARMY together to influence this. For everything that we did not expect to happen this year, BTS with ARMY has displayed their true relationship and devotion as a force that went unrecognized in the past by the general media. This year has been the greatest exposure for ARMY. We are there for the boys, and their for each other as a global community. BTS is no stranger to racism. They listened to ARMY'S that organized to support and donate. Of course BTS would do this as well because their originated and educated on the origins of hip hop, one of the few artists that vocally recognize it even more than some current western hip hop artists. Proud of you guys. Let's follow BTS and Big Hit's lead to redefine the kpop industry, and the music industry. It is so awesome to see them develop their own path. Full steam ahead. Let's go!! 💜😎🎤💘🎵🎶💪
Thank you for this explain. My heart goes out to BTS. Glad they’re happy now.
What is your IQ level again?
148IQ
Namjoon: I am proud.😢
Thank you for this... I cried... again... already attacked by this MV... now understanding it more makes my hearteu burst with love for the boys... with that feeling of "need to protect"... I came in during their Wings era... missed their hardships during their debut but witnessed their successes through and through... I love these 7 dorks with a love of a mom since I'm a 50 y.o. ARMY... that only means that my love for them is eternal as a mothers love for her children... so, on we go and face the battles hand in hand... because, together we are bulletproof... borahae fambam! 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
I cried. Like I cried when I first saw the MV in my own understanding but now, I cried so hard by seeing how they loved us, Armys, truly 💜
It's the time that tears run through my eyes while watching an analysis video..
I'm a new army, and I'm still getting to know their story and everything they had been through until now, I didn't understand the MV when I watched it for the first time but your analysis was really good (it made me cry - some things on this video I just found out right now)! thank you 💜
You should watch "Nobodies to legend 2019" by Xcelest and "Who is BTS?" as a starter to BTS.
@@btsforever5187 thank you sm! I will 💕
I love South Korea but I will always hold a sore spot in my heart towards them for how they treated BTS. 💯
It just made it so much deeper than it was before💜. It's so heart breaking bc of all the hate they get. They never did any wrong. Even if the haters call them mean and rude things bts always said love yourself and speak yourself. I wish people would stop being so judgemental and take the time to know and understand bts and their music.
Wow. "Wow" is all I can say! You always blow me away! Thank you for all your hard work!!
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS.. 🙏🙏 I promised to myself that I won't cry anymore after listening to this song for like the 1000th time😭😭😭....
But I guess that's not possible..I mean its BTS I should have expected it😂😂...
Thank you again for your videos I feel like I gain knowledge/ wisdom every time i watch your videos 💜💜💜👍👍
Every Since the Beginning of the video I was Crying like Hard...I'm so PROUD TO BE AN ARMY💜
BOOKISH THEORIES JUST MADE THE SONG MORE SPECIAL FOR ME
I cried again. I love them I really do. Even if I had to wait, I will always be here waiting for them. no matter how long it takes, I believe in them and will never let them walk alone.
I was already emotional watching the MV multiple times already. Now you made Namjoon cut more onions and I'm sweating water from my eyes again. 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭💜
Thank you so much for giving us analysis videos like this...it literally gave me more chills watching this. 💜
#ARMYsince2014
😭💜it’s beautiful 🐳you’re explaining this makes it even more clearer n makes me forever thankful for able to exist in this era where bts existed🥺💜 so much things they have taught me😌🤧💜 with this song makes a beautiful new chapter for us all, it’s only ARMYs n BTS now n forever..others none matter anymore💜
Bless whichever ARMY mentioned you in the comments of a different video for sending me to you. Your work is AMAZING. Thank you for the in-depth analysis and information. 💜
I love your comment and hope she reads it. I'm one person mentioning her channel everywhere. She deserves more subs 💜
6:03 There are so many idols these days.... they'll probably be forgotten too....... . Today the whole world now bts. Oh God seeing all this makes me feel how far these boys have come. 💜💜💜
This is very informative to all Baby Armys out there. Thank you for this and I really love your analysis. Bookish Theories you Rock!
Are you even human? Your interpretation are always on another level, I'm glad, if I'm able to follow, so I can't imagine how you do these. Oh and I cried, too, this song is just too emotional. 💜
I just wanted to say what I’ve been feeling for a long time.
Honestly, I don't know where to begin and there is a lot to say. I am so proud of BTS and all that they have accomplished in the past 7 years. I feel grateful to have known them since debut and to grow up with their music. All the members of BTS, always know how to bring a smile to my face and they make me laugh when I'm feeling terrible. They’ve found a way to make music that speaks to your soul and has done it in a way that is genuine and sincere. For me, those are some of the reasons why that makes them so special. I hope people can actually take the time to get to know them and listen to their music even if it’s not something they like. It won’t hurt to give it a chance. You never know what you will find.
Also, I want to say this. I want BTS to know how grateful and proud their (kind, sweet, and true) Army is of them. And we will always be by your side even when we are apart. I want them to know that they’ve come a long way and overcame their bad memories and countless trials. The things that are going on right now are also trials to overcome. Stay strong, things are tough right now, but I hope you know that you can overcome anything together and that everything will turn out okay. We are bulletproof together, right 💜
I listened to the song again and I remembered that I really love the way they say the word "Bulletproof." It sounds nice :)
I'm very very early yaay!! Thank you so much for the video... This made me cry more... 😭
PS I love all your theory/exp videos!
I'm crying also for this video😭
You have such a beautiful way of explaining their stories and messages I cried this while video . Thank you!
Man i was crying through the whole video 😭 i love them so much!
I experienced so many conflicting emotions while watching this analysis. Beautiful explanation. Please keep up the good work.
Thank you. I wish most of the armies be like you and see the love and care of BTS for them, so the members could be spare of all the hate and drama! Some people forgot so easily that through their music, their performances, members offer their Souls to us. And in our blindness, for our petty little moments of malice and even envy, we choose to close our eyes and ears and step on them.
Wow, you said what I've been feeling. I love the way you said it, thank you for talking about it. "Some people forgot so easily that through their music, their performances, the members offer their Souls to us. And in our blindness, for our petty little moments of malice and even envy, we choose to close our eyes and ears and step on them."
Musicians and artists are sensitive even if we say "those words" don't affect us. But it really does affect us in a negative way; it slowly builds up and harms us. As an artist, it scares me that some people have to go out of their way to say hurtful things that negatively affect our souls.
So people need to be aware that "words" do really hurt if used with malice. We have to remember that BTS is all human too and they need to be treated with kindness.
Thank you for making these videos. They are really helpful 🤓
Wow! Another channel I'm subscribed to right here! 😄
So excited to see this! Btw did u see TXT's Can't You See Me? pre sequel? What are your thoughts? Wut could it be? I think it's a clue to the the extension element of the +u
If it was +u/tu related in the description there will be tu content verified by BigHit. We'll definitely get an MV for Eternally. That video will be based on tu. The teaser for Can't you see me pre-sequel is what happened between Run Away and Can't you see me. These are my opinions lol.
Edit: STREAM CYSM AND PUMA!
@@redrose3576 the pre sequel is what happened between run away and CYSM? But in the pre sequel their clothes are dirty, like they were in the MV when they did the food fight. I think it's related to the +u because the MV for CYSM is related to to +u itself so I was wondering.... If everyone got back to the real world except Soobin, maybe now they are going to save him? Like in their concept pics Taehyun had the caption "We will find a way to get back" 🤔
ANYWAY STREAM CYSM AND PUMA
I think it’s definitely about Eternally, which should come out on the 20th at 00:00 kst 🧐 didn’t they say that something was gonna happen when spring gets warm? Well the 20th is the last day of spring and it’s a magical time because there’s the summer solstice right after. It’s a moment of change so Eternally fits perfectly! If you look at the video when Soobin goes to the window the lighting and the outline of what he sees is very similar to the scene in Magic Island where Yeonjun first gets out of the train. That would fit the idea that we’ll see the prequel of the sequel (so what happens between Run Away and CYSM) but since In the concept photos Taehyun wants to go back it’s also possible that they’ll be introducing time travel :D at that point it’s all over for us all 😂
@@bookishtheories OMG this makes sense! I can't wait for the MV! Thank you so much for your detailed explanation! 💞
@@user-tl4mk4en7n Your user name fits perfectly for me rn. I'm soo Yeonfused XD
I thought that I already understood everything about the mv, but as always you gave me so much more!!! Thank you💜
Yeah, me too.
Knew some still learning 👍This clears up a whole lot🤔 Awesomeness 💕 Thanks again 🤗💜 Keep Safe 😷♥️
I keep saying you deserve more subs. Thanks for another amazing video. How you analize and put things together is just perfect 💜
Your videos are very done and bring so much clarity and understanding. Thank you.
Thank you for this perfect explanation!
I've never been clicked so fast until right now love your videos as always💜💜💜
I always love your analysis. I did already get most of this, but as always you added significant points! I love this song of course and weep regularly. God knows how they manage to sing it!
i cryed so mush watching this video... it`s my fav song from last album. i have really bad times mentaly right now, so MV and your video cheers my up a little bit, but i`m still fighting with my life
Wish you well.... you are not alone. As Koreans say: "Fighting!"
i always watch your theories because they are closer to what bts thinks and are really informative and helpful.... thank you always...
You are amazing and the way you demonstrate the love we have for BTS and the love BTS has for us is brilliant. Thank you for this sweet video!!! 🌷🌺
BTS + ARMY 💜 FOREVER
Me: it’s impossible to cry more because of this song than what I already had.
Bookish Theories: Hold my Books.
But for real, this made me cry all over again and also remember why I love them so much. Because of all of the pain, troubles and tribulations they had to go through, but also the journey to love themselves and yet, despite all the negatives, they persevered, they stayed true to themselves and then they found ARMY, who loved them no matter what, but not only they felt saved by ARMY but they also saved us. I always loose it when I see the whale of whalien 52. They were the whales, but so is ARMY, but they’re no longer just 7 and we are no longer alone 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Now I'm crying again.
Thank you so much for all of your hard work making these videos! 💜
Thank you always for your amazing work. I already prepared my tissues in advance before watching.
I love how all their songs can be interpreted in different ways. Personally when I first heard this song it felt like they were saying that as long as bts and army have eachother we are untouchable and nothing can stop us
I'd just like to add as well.
1)
The part where Yoongi was being attacked by shards, it was so quick but you can see how he was clutching his left arm.
That was a reference to Yoongi's accident in their earlier years that hindered him from performing complicated moves because the injury, although healed, limited his arm movements(since, you know, your arm popping out of your socket doesn't heal overnight)but of course, the injury happened in his pre debut days. The era represented by the clothes he was wearing was an era where they were slowly transitioning to intense choreos and Yoongi always felt bad that he couldn't perform his best because of the ghost pains from his injury.
2)
The image of the boys sitting on top of the whale represents BTS's WINGS Final Concert, (where JK cried saying he was so happy😭) this was during the ARMY Sing moment... And BTS watched Army as if taking a photograph of the moment, with tears in their eyes 😭😭 they sat on the stage as if Army were the idols and they were our fans 😭😭😭😭😭
Oh my god, who's cutting the onions! 😭😭😭😭💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
At 10:00 you see Suga holding his arm and that could be a reference to when he hurt his arm in the motorcycle accident before debut 😭
Thank you so much for all the time and effort you put into these videos. You are amazing!!
I knew that they were already in the dark and the shadows were around them since the beginning, it's why I mentioned it in one of your theory videos. Now they've grown to overcome and accept it. I think their name Bulletproof Boyscouts is great and I thought it really fit with the times since it's so scary/violent now and back when they first started. I have always loved Taehyung's voice; it's so beautiful and unique only to him. I know even with all that hurt, they stayed true to themselves and to each other. BTS never needed to prove themselves to those haters and they still don't need to acknowledge the haters. Those haters weren’t open-minded enough to get to know BTS as a group or as individuals, so those hater's words should and will always mean nothing. The haters just decided to ignore and ridiculed them. You know those lights when Namjoon was drowning in the mv, they were blurry because of the water which made the lights look kind of like hearts. Also, the waters surface and where Namjoon and Yoongi are standing looks like the photo for their 2020 concert picture and one of the photos from the 2020 BTS Festa photo collection 19/20. It’s the one with them all standing on the water's surface; the violet sky with clouds and the other with the violet water and stars/galaxy.
Since you’ve mentioned about Boy with Luv and it’s also in the mv. I wanted to share this before, but I think now is a good time. “Real love is selfless and free from fear. It pours itself out upon the object of its affection, without demanding any return. Its joy is in the joy of giving. Pure, unselfish love draws to itself its own; it does not need to seek or demand.” This is a passage from a book called “The Game of Life & How to Play it” by Florence Scovel Shinn. So the love that you give is the love that you receive. The love that Army gives to BTS is the love that BTS gives us. You’ve explained that really well.
This mv made me tear up, but I didn’t cry probably because I heard the song a few times now. It does give me chills every time though. The mv just made me feel nostalgic and proud that BTS overcame their struggles. I love the whole animation it's adorable. I love the rap sections of the song too. Hoseok, Yoongi, and Namjoon’s sections of the song really got me. I love the part with the lonely whale and the part of the song with Jimin and Jungkook during the Spring Day scene of the animation. That's one of my favorite parts of the song. (“We won’t ever stop.” “We’re together here.”) Jin and Taehyung’s voices sound so good. (“Tell me your every story.” “Tell me why you don’t stop this.” “Tell me why you still walkin', walkin’ with us.”) Just everything about this song sounds beautiful; the melody, the lyrics, and the transitions in the animation 💜
Awakening Decadence, I am in awe of your "name/title) and your personal thoughts. Thank you for the quote and the book, too.
@@zizziepisano1021 Honestly, I didn't know if anyone was reading my comments besides Bookish Theories and a few other people. I was feeling so nervous about commenting when I first found Bookish Theories' videos. Now, I just feel comfortable enough to leave comments on her videos. So thank you for taking the time to read my comments, I appreciate it. (I also wrote another comment on this video.)
Thank you, so much :) It's been a while; I came up with this username years ago for most of my social media. I just thought of words that might work well together lol The word decadence means the process of decline or decay in society’s morals. For me, it actually means to wake up the good morality that was declining or something like that. (The good morality most people don't care about anymore.)
You're welcome 😊 As for the book, it was one of the books my father owned when he was alive. It's a book I own now, it's pretty old but I think it's a good one. It's written by an artist, so that's one of the reasons why I like the book.
I love these series! I'm your fan! thanks for the hardwork!
I'm ugly crying.😭😭😭😭😭😭 I love BTS so much. Thank you for making this very touchy video!💜💜
I have been waiting for this!!!! :D
Bookish Theories, you certainly deliver! Sincerely grateful for all your hard work.
BTSFOREVER! ❤🧡💛💚💙💜
you are the Royal AMRY!!! thanks!!! (감사합니다.)
I’m crying 😭 they are incredible! I personally didn’t discover them while passing hard times, I’m not one of those armys that they helped overcome anxiety and depression.. they actually got to me in a phase of my life when I was very happy 😊 but I connected with them because they hard work and success inspired me! Now that the pandemic is here and I’ve felt a little bit lost their music have helped me to keep smiling, it has allow me to cry, to dance, to let all this feelings out! I can’t wait for whats to come! This boys (now men really hahah) are legends and I feel honored to be living their era!!!
Lady, you finally did it to me. I'm in tears from this analysis. 😭😭😭😭💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
What a pleasant thing to hear your voice again!
Did I tell you lately that I love you- Lolz! Thank you so much 💜💜💜💜😀
I'm literally getting goosebumps, it so deep and emotional🥺💜
Thank you Bookish Theories, once again, for the awesome reflection of the meaning of this song and the MV. It reinforces my own thoughts and reminds me of my love for all the members of BTS and my vow to always be here for them.
My live for bts is eternal i started the journey with then in 2013 i been her for it all and i will be here forever
💜💜.
Dear BT, I really love ur explanation videos especially bcos u centre it around their artistry and the connections in the universe they created for us and the overall message of their music.
Since the animated MV dropped I literally can't listen to this song without weeping which is funny coz I was already crying like a baby whenever I listened to it but it's more intense now.
Thanks for one more exiting video, do you accept my tears as a payment for this happiness? T-T
Gathered all my tissues to watch this and yeap by the time you reached the whale theory am crying. Thanks for the wonderful video
Words aren't enough to express how much i love your videos💜💜💜💜
Borahae😭😭😭
"Even if winter returns..." When COVID caused them to lose all the concerts they'd planned for 2020, that was a winter no one could have predicted. Now no people were against them, but was ARMY still for them? ARMY's love shined brighter in the darkness. When BTS returned their love and support through songs in English, ARMY responded and BTS hit #1 on Billboard.
Oh my heart ive seen this video and the song a million times n cry everytime this makes it so hard to stan another group i love bts to much. That it hurts and i cant let go im 30 years old n i will never let you guys go
Oh boy... Why are my emotions all over the place after watching this? 😭😭😭😭💜
I thought the whale was from the MV heartbeat
Yes, it appears on Heartbeat MV, but also on Idol MV. And there is also that hoodie with a wale which Jin seems to like very much. And of course, we have Whalien 52. I feel like Kore is a sort of motif all through BTS' history.
bruh my eyes kept sweating 😖, no but the fact that people in their earlier years had the audacity to be biased & hateful towards these boys & call themselves fans irks me, sum of those ppl still try to call themselves fans like they deserve it😑 if you ain’t ready to love them as humans you ain’t ready to be apart of the army simple. we’re here to protect & strive with them, not bring them down
While im watching this im crying 😭 thank you for this video .💕💕
Thanks for making me cry again. 😭 You seriously deserve more subs.
Thank you Bookish. 💜💯
I cried soo much because of the song,the visuals and the journey itself... But after listening to this... I genuinely cried even more... You pointed out each and every minute aspect...making it even more beautiful... Thank you for this... Wow... Even the explanation is emotional 😭
We were lucky enough to born and met them.. In this lifetime... And I wish and hope to stay in this safe heaven that they have created forever... 💜
ETERNAL is a huge concept with BTS and TXT.
Argh I understand the roll reversal with the whale now! Makes so much sense. Thank you!
i'm crying.
thank you so much for the video!!
I cried again.. Thank u for the explaination💜
I just want to point out that some other ARMY said Suga was holding his shoulder in the animation (from his accident). And also I think the first set of falling leaves are (Autumn Leaves /dead leaves song)
They are so many layers!
Oh my gosh. My heart broke when I saw the video of that girl passing Taehyung. I feel so sad... I hope that girl regrets it every day of her life... but I also hope that Taehyung forgave her.
Thank you so much for this it was amazing
thank you so much for this! now i'm going to cry more when watching this video....
I'm crying again... 😭😭😭
I just discovered Bookish theories today. And this is only my 3rd video. But We Are Bulletproof: The Eternal is my all time favorite BTS song, so seeing the explanation for it was super emotional. I knew they went thru a lot to get where they are, but I didn't know all of it. It was so sad to hear and watch this video.