@@andrefilipe6910 i just want her to do whats most comfortable to her. if she doesnt wanna lip she should sing live. if she doesnt wanna sing live she shouldnt (even tho she sounds amazing)
The usual track does start after this clip BUT this is still so such a breath of fresh air my god. I need to know if she sang anything else tonight, what if she changed stuff too in silent night or wcc or miss you most😭😭
@@b.k.471the track starts after the video cuts ACTUALLY. Just because she sounds good people think it’s not live🥱 she clearly listened to reviews about lipsync because she has been incorporating even more live vocals and most recently always be my baby is FULLY LIVE she finally removed the lipped F5 she has done her ENTIRE CAREER after 1996😉
If she would lower her songs to her her comfortable tessitura now (and probably dodge some lows which would probably be in the mid to lower 2nd octave after lowering the key of her songs) she would sing most of her discography with relative ease.
What I don't understand is Mariah is often critisized for not using her voive wisely in her "prime" (tried to sing mostly live even the hardest parts where other singers might let back vocals or even play back take over) yet in the current condition of her voice she is trying to preserve it and gets crucified on the internet by her own fans. If her fans dont point out these stuff no one will come for her ! This is not a hate comment towards any youtuber nor this account btw... Just be patient for the next project and let her rock especially during Xmas :))
I see both sides of the criticism while she definitely should preserve her voice and take the rest she needs for it and maybe she is preparing for a new album rollout, but on the flip side I don’t think the a year of vocal rest is the answer 😭 obviously know you’re limits but preserving you’re voice is about how you warm it up and exercise it to keep it in shape not really just not using it, using humidifiers and then hoping for the best when you use it again when she drops new music to promote, which is her usual technique lol. But the point is I think there is some truth to both arguments and I don’t necessarily blame Mariah because it’s her voice, just confused where she got this rhetoric from about how to preserve her voice
I might upload a pic or video for tomorrow. I don’t usually record shows but I’m finally seeing my most favorite person. I wonder if she will sing live on her first AZ show since angels advocate tour.
I actually wonder what made her decide to do it live… like I’m not complaining, but ngl I’m kinda shocked 😅, definitely was not expecting this but hey, it’s a good change 🥹
This is interesting! I guess she’s experimenting to see what lipping formula should work for her long term without tiring her out. Idk why, but the back of my mind is telling me that the playback failed😭.
This is going to bother some people but it's okay because it is my opinion. I wholeheartedly believe that there were serious vocal issues arising in 2022 & 2023. Not that it's our business but I think she may have some surgery (yes, I can be wrong). I think she may also have some physical limitations (age, medicine, injury...again, speculating here). What if something happened to where her condition improved significantly? Maybe her muscle memory is used to breaking up certain syllables and relying on playback for certain sections of songs. Perhaps now she can approach words and phrases differently, with clarity in confidence. Essentially she would have to relearn her songs, adjusting what gets sung live and what should be given to playback. She's been through a lot these past few years and time will tell. This is certainly a step in the right direction. I'm more tuned in to watching her smile more and observing that she's enjoying performing more. I know she sometimes reads comments on multiple platforms and those can get her down. I hope she knows how adored she is by so many people, how we are rooting for her, and how we wish her love and light.
as disappointed as I am in her for getting to this point where we're celebrating crumbs of live vocals, she's mother for this. queen even. she really said fuck these homosexuals
@@mrmelaninmagic Aww thanks so much!! I definitely want to upload this holiday season I’ve just been sooooo busy at college. But thank you for saying this it gives me more motivation to finish some videos I have in the works!
She's old but she sings better than any other singer out there. To give you an idea, Mariah Carey sings in 5 octaves, something that no other singer today can do, which is why she and Whitney are unique.
@ i’m so happy, unfortunately when singing Christmas Time is in the air (live) she screwed up a lil bit I Hope she doesn’t lose her confidence and keep singing !
It sounds so clean, she said oh hell they coming for me let me sing this first few lines.
i hope she keeps this up, and i also hope she doesnt feel forced to sing live but then again if shes too lazy to sing live she shouldnt perform
ITS NOT LAZYNES, SHE DOES'T FELL SO CONFIDENT TO SING LIVE, look at ALL the critics she has been trough...@@butterflyera
@@andrefilipe6910 i just want her to do whats most comfortable to her. if she doesnt wanna lip she should sing live. if she doesnt wanna sing live she shouldnt (even tho she sounds amazing)
@@butterflyerapreach ! I don’t uds why people can ask her to lip sync when her expression clearly says: I can’t
She sounds so fucking beautiful omg
The usual track does start after this clip BUT this is still so such a breath of fresh air my god. I need to know if she sang anything else tonight, what if she changed stuff too in silent night or wcc or miss you most😭😭
@@VMariah omg if she serve Miss you most then I’m up for Christmas this year ! 😃
Yup@@rogl3W
honestly, give me Christmas Time is in the Air Again from Rockafeller 2012
@ for real …
ITS SO EASY FOR HER EVEN BETTER THAN LAST YEAR
OMG she sounds so good! And her face doesn’t show struggle! It just looks like she’s concentrated lol
It is lipped 🙄
@@b.k.471the track starts after the video cuts ACTUALLY. Just because she sounds good people think it’s not live🥱 she clearly listened to reviews about lipsync because she has been incorporating even more live vocals and most recently always be my baby is FULLY LIVE she finally removed the lipped F5 she has done her ENTIRE CAREER after 1996😉
Thats the botox lol
YESSS OMG SHES ENTERING HER VILLAIN ERA
help I was so excited I accidentally uploaded this as a short lol
I keep coming back to this it was just so effortless for her😩
it’s time for her to embrace her new voice! go mother!
That delusion 😂 it is lipped and it's embaressing !
YES QUEEN, WE ALL HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS MOMENT 😭😭😭🙏🙏🙏🙏💯💯💯💯💯.
DUDE IMAGINE SHE DOES THIS IN VEGAS 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT I'VE BEEN HOPING FOR like just make the intro maybe 30 seconds of each song live😍😍
Everything here sounds soo clean.. see why I love this women?
I am so glad to see her finally singing live!!! Mother heard our prayers and answered💅
Omg the intro is live and she sounds so nice.
OH MY GOD SHE SOUNDS AMAZING
Period Mariah👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
If she would lower her songs to her her comfortable tessitura now (and probably dodge some lows which would probably be in the mid to lower 2nd octave after lowering the key of her songs) she would sing most of her discography with relative ease.
she also sang a snippet of AIWFCIY sounded so nice
she is so back omg
@@VMariahyou better make a live vocals video from this date
we're tryna see if there's more
@@westanmariah ik I'm waiting for all the clips😭 it's already well over two minutes this feels surreal
Wait she sang part of the intro too?
She's absolutely amazing
Wow she looks beautiful ❤
THANK YOU LORD THANK YOU LORD THANK YOU LORD
OMG I’M CRYINGGGGG
She’s baaaaack 😭😭❤️
LOVE LOVE LOVE THIS!! So happy
WE WONNNN
@@ramirodineroronan I wouldn’t say we won but at least SHE HEARD US ! And she still care for us 😄
OMGGG I was so looking forward to Hark The Herald and this white ensemble is eatingggg
if she keeps this up im reconsidering going to her concert near me
Finally something live😊
omg is this live? I can't turn on my volume😢 i cant hear her singgg
I mean why did she? I’m so glad she did this for the REAL LAMBS 😇😇😇 and thanks for sharing you’re the best lamb and real lamb
th-cam.com/video/UAzGxVld78A/w-d-xo.htmlsi=Eo7gFGHaOam6hD59
The lipped one is so pale in comparison some one please notice.
YES QUEEN!
OMG YESSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!
!!see if she wanted to she could, and she wanted to yesterday 😻
She really sounds like a totally different person. If this were on the radio, I would not have recognized her as Mariah Carey the ultimate songbird.
Thank you LORD....AM STILL WITH ANRHONY@ THE BAR
THANK YOU JESUS
I told yall she’s slowly going back to the 2023 formula
she literally surpassed 2023 in one night with fully live Christmas Time is Here tbh
YESSSSSSSS MOTHER
What I don't understand is Mariah is often critisized for not using her voive wisely in her "prime" (tried to sing mostly live even the hardest parts where other singers might let back vocals or even play back take over) yet in the current condition of her voice she is trying to preserve it and gets crucified on the internet by her own fans. If her fans dont point out these stuff no one will come for her ! This is not a hate comment towards any youtuber nor this account btw... Just be patient for the next project and let her rock especially during Xmas :))
I see both sides of the criticism while she definitely should preserve her voice and take the rest she needs for it and maybe she is preparing for a new album rollout, but on the flip side I don’t think the a year of vocal rest is the answer 😭 obviously know you’re limits but preserving you’re voice is about how you warm it up and exercise it to keep it in shape not really just not using it, using humidifiers and then hoping for the best when you use it again when she drops new music to promote, which is her usual technique lol. But the point is I think there is some truth to both arguments and I don’t necessarily blame Mariah because it’s her voice, just confused where she got this rhetoric from about how to preserve her voice
Mariah's middle register has always sounded amazing.
We are so back😍😍😍
Periodt💅. Hopefully she starts singing live during the vegas show as well
She saw those comments I’m glad.
FINALLY!!!!!🎉🎉🎉🎉
The low tone is so yummy omg.
OMG
Thanks for tagging her out dear lamb I SEE YOU UP THERE
Ugh that’s my girl
OMGOMG
YAAASSS
Oh she changed her outfit for all i want too
I might upload a pic or video for tomorrow. I don’t usually record shows but I’m finally seeing my most favorite person. I wonder if she will sing live on her first AZ show since angels advocate tour.
Have fun!
WHATTTTTTT NO I AOMOST FEEL OF THE BED I'M SO HAPPY
I actually wonder what made her decide to do it live… like I’m not complaining, but ngl I’m kinda shocked 😅, definitely was not expecting this but hey, it’s a good change 🥹
Girl Christmas Time Is Here is live too omgggggg
you're kidding me
NO WAY DID SHE DO THIS WITH EVERY SONG OR SOMETHING
@@jacksonsunwoo I'm being soo serious omg
She didn't even sing that live last year omgggg
@@VMariah so refreshing to see her not looking down at the screen all the time 😭
WE ARE SO BACK
This is interesting!
I guess she’s experimenting to see what lipping formula should work for her long term without tiring her out.
Idk why, but the back of my mind is telling me that the playback failed😭.
It looks like the stage design also changed a bit so I think they rearranged some stuff during the three-day break, and the track was one of them.
DO NOT JINX IT PLEASE
This is going to bother some people but it's okay because it is my opinion.
I wholeheartedly believe that there were serious vocal issues arising in 2022 & 2023. Not that it's our business but I think she may have some surgery (yes, I can be wrong). I think she may also have some physical limitations (age, medicine, injury...again, speculating here).
What if something happened to where her condition improved significantly? Maybe her muscle memory is used to breaking up certain syllables and relying on playback for certain sections of songs. Perhaps now she can approach words and phrases differently, with clarity in confidence. Essentially she would have to relearn her songs, adjusting what gets sung live and what should be given to playback.
She's been through a lot these past few years and time will tell. This is certainly a step in the right direction. I'm more tuned in to watching her smile more and observing that she's enjoying performing more. I know she sometimes reads comments on multiple platforms and those can get her down. I hope she knows how adored she is by so many people, how we are rooting for her, and how we wish her love and light.
as disappointed as I am in her for getting to this point where we're celebrating crumbs of live vocals, she's mother for this. queen even. she really said fuck these homosexuals
IS THIS LIVE?? IM CRYING YALL IT CANT BE LIVE
What city was this?
Palm springs
K now I’m mad bc I feel robbed of incredible vocals if she would sing live more 😅
@@TheEmancipationOfMC that’s the whole point of hating on her lip sync 🙃
We miss your videos, will you be uploading any more of them soon
@@mrmelaninmagic Aww thanks so much!! I definitely want to upload this holiday season I’ve just been sooooo busy at college. But thank you for saying this it gives me more motivation to finish some videos I have in the works!
WAIT IS THIS LIVE??????
YES FISH SHE SANG CHARLIE BROWN CHRISTMAS (CHRISTMAS TIME IS HERE) FULLY LIVE TOO IT'S TWO WHOLE MINUTES OF PURE VOCALSSSS
@@VMariah I SAW
@@VMariah I swear if she starts lipping next show again I'm gonna cry😭
@@Fishriah_Ari no no don't even think it😭
So was it live?
yes the whole clip is live!!
@@VMariah YES AND WE REAL LAMB KNOWS which exact part she sing live !!!
She's old but she sings better than any other singer out there. To give you an idea, Mariah Carey sings in 5 octaves, something that no other singer today can do, which is why she and Whitney are unique.
IS THIS LIVE ???
YES SHE CUT THE TRACK FOR THIS PART TONIGHT. The track starts after "reconciled" now
@ i’m so happy, unfortunately when singing Christmas Time is in the air (live) she screwed up a lil bit I Hope she doesn’t lose her confidence and keep singing !
She started lipping towards the end right?
yeah after 0:55
ok so I trimmed that part out so it's more clear
SHE DEFO SAW THE HATE TWEETS
Exactly no hate but we doing everything for the live vocals 😂
@@rogl3W😂