This is a chain reaction started by those already settled in Canada, by showing flashy & comfy lifestyle, and hence the punjabi youth develops a fear of missing out (FOMO). Same is the case with kerelas gulf migration. It's all a mindset game. Besides I think in our country respect is considered the highest. Means any youth will do any job in foreign countries but will not do it here. Here he wants a job of respect only. In foreign countries their is no one to watch who is doing what. Here 100 people are watching & judging & gossiping in groups. This actually brings down the morale of a kid or youth.
I live in Pune and even my friends who got 30 LPA package are moving abroad for studies. Maybe the opportunities are less here, I don't know, but personally I believe that the allure of NRI lifestyle is the main reason rather than lack of opportunities.
Bro, I recently got a job at a startup. 2 of my friends who used to live in California, also came back in 2021 to join a startup. Bro i do think that startups can reduce brain drain
The current situation of employment in Punjab is unfortunate but is no different from what's happening in the rest of India. Goverment jobs are minimal, MSME jobs are limited to blue collar skilled/unskilled category, fixed costs to start big businesses are way too high, and not everyone has the access to capital/skills to start small businesses. I graduated from NIT and was fortunate that I had multiple options to start my career. Infact I had cleared the state electricity department exam as well but never bothered to join because of the 'Basic Pay for 3 years' rule. Its not that Youth of Punjab or India has failed us, but the Politicians across aisle are responsible for creating an environment where young minds are not able to see a future for their families and chose the hardship of building a dignified life away from the land of their ancestors.
First thing Punjab should do is the following: 1. make condoms free 2. close all Pregnancy Hospitals and clinic 3. announce to the state that it has decided to reduce population 4. allow people to choose to suicide and start a department for Happy ending suicide and volunteer for organ transplant. 5. Add two more subjects in the education system: A: Aghorism :-) B: Life after death and Hoorism :-)
But it is no more about jobs now. There are many good jobs here. But many don't even think of finding jobs here. It has become a culture to move abroad. Students start to think about moving abroad from childhood itself as they get facinated or influenced by their friends and relatives who are majoritarily staying abroad. So they think it is better to stay abroad near to friends and relatives rather than staying alone in India.
Even most of them don't know why they want to go. They all have fed from their childhood that they will be going to Canada, US ...Their whole aim is to go abroad. One can understand if he/she wants to go abroad to avail the best possible opportunities in their field of interest but their goal is to go abroad that's it . They all have been presented with some fairytales like their life will change drastically when they will live these countries. Also Punjabi music, movie industry have contributed to it to a large extent.
😡get real , no one from Punjab really want to study at all 😡all they want is student visa , which can be illegally used for driving taxis & applying PR , this nonsense is going on since year 2000
I am really happy you have taken up this topic .. state is performing very badly .. i had to leave punjab because of lack of opportunity ... now when i go back i see no one of my circle there... i believe not even 1% of my batchmates are still in punjab ... Hope govt start working towards this issue and brings back industry
See this 1 in 33 people is pegged to the overall population. The way villages are emptying and with mostly the young age group who may go for higher studies, this ratio will come down. Mass exodus of youth and the middle class is not a good sign considering they're the net consumers (paying indirect taxes) and earning taxable incomes (non-farming). Punjab may lose massive revenue earning if its core consumers move away, instead of retaining, they're promising to facilitate!
"Guys please don't mock any state but try to see the real issue of it. The educated middle class is moving out. The professor said the gap between rich and poor will widen with no middle class in it. That's never good for a country, no matter what's your political opinion is. If you care about India; you should worry about this problem."
There will always be a middle class because the number is too high. But the middle class will feel increasingly demoralised, because the poor who resort to crime cant go after the rich so they will come after the middle class. They cannot steal the jewellery of any Bollywood stars daughter. But if your daughter goes out for a morning walk with an earring...
You've made an excellent observation. When the educated class wants to leave, it says something about what is happening in India. It is not a positive thing.
This is just a manipulated brain they think us lifestyle is more happier than here... Just like people are manipulated for nationalism, jihadism, religion its a type of same brain games which is driven by social media.....
@@Jesssco they're recruiting doctors in UK. All I have to do is write the PLAB exam, get registered in the GMC, and then I'll be eligible to work in the UK.
I finished my degree in India and started job in Mumbai in 2010. In 2015 with 5 lakhs I started my own business. My plan is to buy mercedes before 2025. Fingers crossed. I am 36 and keep telling youth that India have same kind of opportunities as west have. My friends in India are drawing salaries of over 1 crore per annum in investment banking. Degree doesn't matter it's your skill which makes you successful.
They are making an attempt to talk in a language that they have not spoken or studied enough, lets be fair here, most people would struggle to talk in a language other than what we studied in or have an exposure to, be kind folks
@@kang2753 so now reference level of punjabi is bihar which have lowest hdi & highest corruption . Dude you must choose some better reference point. Atlest haryana or himachal
These people will learn to speak English very fluently in a matter of few years First thing Punjab should do is the following: 1. make condoms free 2. close all Pregnancy Hospitals and clinic 3. announce to the state that it has decided to reduce population 4. allow people to choose to suicide and start a department for Happy ending suicide and volunteer for organ transplant. 5. Add two more subjects in the education system: A: Aghorism :-) B: Life after death and Hoorism :-)
With the qualifications most of them have, I really doubt how much they can achieve in the first word , not to forget the high cost of living. Maybe lesser competition as compared to India helps👍🏻
@@karthika560 Well , the frustration of the middle class is very evident in your words, but in My state (WB) things are not this bad( Although there's a huge number of poor people, and more than half of them are from Bihar and non Bengali Muslims who live in a very congested and unhygienic places in and around the capital) But for the Middle class Bengalis life isn't that bad, but the trade unions and left front government decimated the industrial belt of Hooghly and Howrah, which made poor people worse of sadly.
@@dwaipayanmoitra4651 dude i think you are from presidency region (south bengal ), the jangalmahal ,central bengal is quite poor , most of bengali migrant worker belong to these region's
Another reason why many students are going abroad to do masters because in India to get into a good iim/iit or any good college or govt job it takes a lot of hardwork but clearing IELTS is relatively easy and the university they get there are good, so rather then studying in a mediocre institution here it is better to go abroad.
This is why we need industrialisation so manufacturing jobs are made. Instead we only care about IT services and propping up unsustainable agriculture due to farmer votebank. We kept buying time in form of free power, cheap fertiliser, irrigation, strict labour laws etc. but time is running out. I predict civil strife in places like Punjab and northern Hindi belt cause unemployment. Not just India but all of South Asia, Africa, middle east, southern Europe and america region.
@@karthika560 i don’t know abt that still long way to go. But certainly some regions in UP industrialised than many states. Noida, Gurguaon, Ghaziabad etc. UP very poor overall but like India should be seen as continent not country, UP should be seen as country not a state. Too much people to categorise generally. More promising than Bihar and other states with impressive expresseay construction and policies. However still very long way to go and legacy problems of education and health. Caste politics and Deobandi islamists.
Frmrs r not getting these facilities..n they r not stopping industrialisation...lolz have some balls to curse gov dude.. Agro farming industries like textile mills are not there in the cotton belts.. Lolz 🤣 talkin is very easy. Will power b hona chahiye
@@OhiSandhu Telengana CM even admits farmer gets free power. Same in Punjab. This comes at cost of manufacturing as industry pays artificially higher tariff to subsidise farmer even though manufacturing more valuable to economy. Even BJP gives rubbish like loan waivers. Yogi talks abour 50% reduced power tariff for farmers. So i am saying BJP part of problem too. They think money comes from trees. We should be spending money on health, education and infrastructure instead of wasteful subsidies.
@@rohanindra6401 telangana state is earning from its sand n other resources..but in punjab all parties leaders stealing the resources..even cntr snatched their water rights which every other state has.. So problems are different.. Industrialists are not getting friendly approach..even neighborhood states giving incentives n less tax..so farmers r not in between all this... N fertilizer u talking about..see latest budget.. Nd even u will know why farming is necessary in upcoming days as mustard import will fail..nd wheat output is also decreasing year by year due to climate change.
Good colleges have limited seats, it's not about better education it's because not everyone can get into IITs and IIMs. In short if you have average talent and skills you are screwed in India.
That's exactly the problem.... An average guy in India is doing wonders in US and Canada.....in western countries mediocrity has a reward unlike India where you have to be made of steel to be successful in India.....
None of these kids have achieved any academic success here and are not willing to work hard & feel that running abroad will just suddenly give them a shortcut to their dreams
I am a proud engineer and have farm land. I am not planning to leave India. I agree with you but That's the problem you have to give success to average students too. Basic need for decent living is required for every one.
@@chandanba4059 I agree but to achieve success some hard work is required and just hoping for short cuts doesn’t help & by success I don’t only mean in terms of academics
@@AB-tx5zm do you agree if you can afford an appartment or a decent home in India with average government salary or private senior salary of 10Lpa in any metro cities. Working till age of 45years people are not able to buy their own home or afford retirement. What we need in India right now is increase in per capita income for average middle class
Only less than 10% of Indians are making 10Lpa for decent living. I am being fair in saying government is failing in providing stable environment for miro economics to grow. For example if you risk taking loan to create your own business you need 100%plus equity to apply for loan. It's egg and chicken problem
@@chandanba4059 sir, I agree with what you are saying yet my point is just that if you are not willing to work hard & gain genuine skills then don’t just blame the system for your own failures!
Other states too have youths who wish to run abroad but Punjab has the affordability factor working for them. Also, the new generation is reluctant to pursue agriculture.
I agree. Also, a close malayalee friend wanted to open an industrial unit near Cochin. He was so frustrated with the government officials' constant creation of artificial barriers, he ended up opening his factory in UP...yes UP, the place with sub Saharan HDI markers...so it is natural that educated Mallus prefer going to the Gulf!
@@remasteredambience Point is you called UP having sub-Saharan HDI markers which is wrong. I live near Lucknow University Metro Station which is few meters from Daliganj.
The highest immigration in India is being witnessed in Punjab followed by Gujerat and then Kerala. All three states are in much better shape than Jharkhand, UP, Bihar etc., unfortunately our country is third world in every sense; hence education and more importantly the Internet shows the conditions of people around the world. When confronted by that stark reality, Punjabis who have an advantage of already having relatives abroad especially in Canada, USA, UK, Australia and New Zealand tend to be the most successful at immigating. This is the reality of our situation in the country, sad fact is that we have HDI levels at par with Sub Saharan Africa for a majority of the country, and due to extreme hypocrisy we pretend that we are a great world power, this unfortunately is the reality of our nation. Aslo, despite having one of the youngest populations in the world we are obsessed with old men to run our country and the youngsters who enter politics are usually College dropouts.
In my opinion it's a personal choice and everyone is free to do so. India is a big country with 1.4 billion population, majority of which is young. Jobs are not what they used to be 20-30 years back. And India is not a manufacturing powerhouse like China to employ that many people which even today China struggles with. Truth being told automation and manufacturing being taken over by robots will make job requirements higher which most of us don't have the technical know how to do. End mein jisko janai jaye, many of my friends left for Canada, UK while I decided to stay back. It's a choice I made no regrets. And my friends are happy too thou they miss food and family sometimes. Mein toh boltau joh nikal saktai nikal le less competition for us who decided to stay despite having the money to go and chose not to.
Kerala as usual is No1 in this list also. Scientific establishments that can run the economy and see to the welfare mechanisms are missing in India. It's only for rich privileged and select few who make it in India. rest of us have to migrate. not just Punjab , We can create jobs only with innovative new technology. entrepreneurship. Reservations of 60% will ruin the nation.
Punjab used to be one of best prosperous regions of india it has one of most fertile land and healthy economy... It is really sad to see Punjab deterioratig ...
Canada has stated it’s going to take in 1.2 million (12lakhs) immigrants in the next three years. Also Indians have emerged as the highest number of legal immigrants yearly to Canada. One can gauze this from the ubiquity of Indian brands in Canadian stores these days. I think the immigration firms in Punjab sell this “demand “ for Indian immigrants for the Canadian economy.
Not just Punjab. Everyone young person in India wants to move to their former colonial masters countries. Damning verdict on the governance of independent India.
I agree there is unemployment in Punjab but I don't agree there is no opportunity in Punjab my lot of friends are going to Canada they are super rich farmers they have lot of land they are just going there to have fun life without restriction of their parents this is also major factor not everything can be government fault some time media should show this reality also most of people who are going are from rich family of Punjab
That might be what they think their life's going to be when they arrive in the US/Canada, but reality soon hits quite hard. Most of these boys can't string along a viable sentence in English (which in itself is not a shortcoming, but it is a problem when the lingua franca of the host nation is English), they take years, if at all, to shed their retrograde concepts of "izzat", which leads to them labeling every woman in a summer dress as "kudi vadi kaint si". They come in at an age when they're still quite hormonal, and, with absolutely no communication skills combined with their chronic character judgement of women, they end up visiting prostitutes. To deal with boredom, they take to the bottle and given as they're expected to pay off their "donki" agent every month, both the hookers and the booze they indulge in, tends to be the cheapest available option. The end result is they end up doing the exact same jobs, they think are beneath them, back home. For all their success, they tend to do in the US what they expect "bhaiyyas" to do in Punjab. Life abroad is best described by a tiktok/instagram video that went viral in 2015-16, which had a bunch of punjabi guys singing to the effect that "aqal thikane lag jati hey, Amrika aakey".
Fist all thanks for rising important issue of youth of Panjab. My opinion is for solving this issue 1) we should have promot crros order tread with pakistan this will help for local industries and local agriculture . 2) our cotton tread should promote that help for farmer for agriculture diversification so income of farmers also increase . 3) most of industry of Panjab is MSME so govt provide better market access .
@@KamalSingh-qd9jr this biggest problem because a business should pay hight rate tax for country development and should also pay for party fund and also pay local police and administration as bribe . Naturally business not run .
Not sure how these people will fair in Canada. With poor English and far fetched away from reality, it's going to be extremely tough for most. Cheers from Toronto.
One needs a technical/ science based degree to do well.. most of the arts graduates go to make a little money in retail jobs and then come back. Like what the Latin people are doing in America.
Punjab is a Sikh dominated state, and Sikhs have never felt at ease being in India. Controversial statement, yet true. It's sad that Sikhs joined India in 1947.
My friends are also planning to move to Canada because they earn very less in India and they can earn 10 times more in Canada. They also are persuading me to migrate. They believe there is no future in India and they want to make base there in Canada for their childrens also. My friend says that he doing business earning very less and if he does labour job in Canada, he can earn 10 times more in than doing busines in India.
Converting dollar to rupee and then seeing that it's x times of what u earn in India is stupidity. If u earn in dollar u will have to spend in dollar also. I agree there may be less opportunities in India but it's not like u can't make a fortune in India.
@@rahulbansal9834 you are spot on, cinema and music industry glamourizes foreign countries as heaven where everyone has swiming pool at home and drives a bmw. Most migration without demanded skill experience and degrees end up doing menial job at farms, truck drivers cleaners etc however they will never admit it.
@@rohitkhanna4487 but if they sacrifice enough, they can save up to get premium education for their children, which will ensure that their future generations will have good future. Edit: by the way, there is no such caste system in the west (to the extent that we see in India) where service jobs like truck drivers and plumbers are considered "menial". Almost all jobs are seen as honorable as long as you make money. And being a trucker or a plumber will get you a very decent lifestyle in the west.
No it's not true my jijaji is also in canada he told me that expenditure is also very high . Even a one bhk flat cost him 1000$ rents without electricity or water bill included .
Guys you need to study and get a good degree then it would make sense and that is not easy don't just look in terms of conversion to rupee, you need to spend there too to survive, only after going there you will realise it..if you are a software engineer for example you will get paid well in India too but don't just blindly convert it , that amount is not enough out there unless you hold a unique skill or degree and obviously if you are a rich Punjabi with family wealth then that is a different topic.
Govt should do following to retain people in india- 1. Give the tax paying layer (middle class) the much needed medical and education facilties and infra as in canada 2. Give work life balance a thought even in govt jobs there is no work life balance leave alone pvt jobs Many other reasons are there but these two are the main reason NRIs put forth
This shows the poor state of education & employment in Punjab. Also, when all of your friends and relatives start to move there then you see no purpose in staying back in India and this goes on and on result of a chain reaction. Many students even don't try to find jobs here even if there are jobs. Their ultimate goal is to move abroad from childhood itself.
Its not at all about lack of jobs and opportunities or quality of education. If this is their concern then they can move to tier 1 cities like Mumbai, Bangalore, Delhi, etc. But they only have one option that is Canada. The main reason they are lured towards canada is the foriegn lifestyle. Everyone is on insta facebook now a days and these people are easily attracted by such content. They dont even seem to have proper foundation in english language which is must for people going abroad to study. What will happen afterwards is that they will get accepted in extremely low ranked colleges which are just money making universities and after they graduate they will find basic job roles which does not pay good and then they are forced to come back to India. The same is the case with UK. I always suggest people if you want to study abroad choose proper country and good universities and go only for stem courses. We can find a big difference between Indian students in US and in Canada. You will find a large chunk of educated students plus those who can speak good english unlike them. The reason is simple because the US education system requires a lot more than just IELTS. Therefore, these people find it extremely difficult to go to US and then choose Canada and UK which are very easy options available. Also, a big NO for commerce studies in abroad, it will land you nowhere. I hope this helps.
Bhai earlier my perception was only the brightest minds went abroad like IIT, NIT, BITs, IIMs. But now I see every tom dick and Harry going abroad primarily Canada (Kanedda). Matlab joh school mejn 2-3 subjects mein fail hote the voh bhi gaye jinko 2 lines english mein bolne bhi nahi aati properly. My friend who is in UK also told me a lot of Villagers from Punjab, Haryana who are in his class in UK. They cannot even speak English somehow did fraud in Ielts exam and came there under the pretext of education and they don't even attend classes. Side mein ye log illegal cash jobs karte hain. All this Education karnai quality seems BS. Bhai tune commerce kiya hain unless you are enrolling in some cutting edge STEM field what's the point? You can learn majority of stuff on the Internet for free... TH-cam pe. And if you can afford a few thousand rs there are many online courses. Inko bus Abroad janai for enjoyment coz they saw some rapper in Canada, dancing with goris having rented lambos in Punjabj rap songs.
It's a tradition in states such as Gujarat and Punjab. They go abroad to work in factories and Walmart. Is that the great opportunities they're talking about?
@@kunwarvyapaksingh7562 yes sri ganganagar border of punjab rajasthan..was in punjab state n district Ferozepur in british tym n before too. We all r same ppl. Nd humne achi life jee hai histry me b or ab tak bhi but ab lands b kam hore resources b .rojgar b nhi or desh ki halat khasta hori din ba din jbse ye govt ayi..hatered badra civil war ki or badre..public ki life ki koi security nhi h..koi life standard nhi h..system corruption jadd se chus re.. Log pareshan h akhir kre to kre kya
Attention Dear Students, Nearly 2000 indian students got scammed in Canada last week when 3 Canadian Universities shut down due to bankruptcy. Wish you a very happy journey ahead. Thank you
Yes opportunity in India is less and struggle is more. But still Opportunity is not the real reason but there is a fatuation for Canada and people wanted to be there after listening a lot of success stories but nobody tries to see other side of story. For example, anybody went there for education, they get same job profile in which they studied ? Of course not. Reporting should be done like what reason are being used to to go to Canada and what exactly same people are doing in Canada. There should be a proper plan what study they are intended to do there. Do the training and certification in same skill and try in Canada. So that people can get a good job in Canada instead of doing a petty job.
Don't compare them to Gujratis. Gujjus have ambitions to grow a business, punjabi is happy just being abroad and do anything- taxi, store or housewife.
@Punjab Police PB32 District so are u looking for validation from brits? Gujratis are not trying to impress anyone, so screw what brits think. Meanwhile, punjabis are moving from India to any place to do literally anything,
@@PK-tt5kk But why only Punjab has such an obsession primarily for Canada? Canada has been lenient on immigration policy especially Trudeau's liberal to build a vote bank in Canada. Young Indians from other states primarily go through H1B route which demands high technical skills.
The average Indian earns 1.1-1.2 Lakhs per year and you won't able to live a decent life with that money. Now with that even a basic two wheeler owner will find it hard to make ends meet. Add to it more children in lower income levels. PS: The bs of "people don't pay income tax" is that bs. Average Indian need to earn 3-4 times what they earn now to be able eligible for IT. (Ys it starts at 3 L, but 3-5L gets a lot of rebates)
The fact is elite class and middle class are leavind india in my assumption there will two class will be left in india. One will the super rich and other one will be super poor⚠️
I left punjab in 2019 so now 2022 with my hard work just by doing odd jobs in 2 years i got PR and earned arounf 70-80 lakhs own a car and live good lifestyle i think in todays era we want success and money in less period of time if i would have been in punjab it would have been very slow. i know higher grade scoring students bright student have bright career in india but if we see propotion of average students is more. In canada australia usa even the basic earning guy live good lifestyle stress free
Yah but you have people to support you living aboard . 2 year PR is not possible without investing atleast $500k or Citizen sponsoring you or getting married to a citizen. Odd jobs. Lol. Fuddu kese hoor nu baniye.
The govt earns when you send back money for your parents. ThIs is where the govt and citizen needs align: earning dollars instead of rupee. This is because our Government is TRYING to make India prosperous through exports. So, it values dollar more than rupee. This is disincentivizing solving our own problems by making indigenous solutions low value. Also, phd holders and masters, even in engineering, are neither absorbed easily in indian industries nor are they paid respectably. Engineering(Non-IT) consultation and services are imported from Germany, US, Australia and even China. So, as things stand, I believe emigration is the right move.
@@karthika560 The disdain may be justified. Most of our industries dont work on cutting edge tech and the topic to collaborate on would be too basic to arouse intellectual curiosity. For example, if you specialise in the design of mems and are then being asked to collaborate on farming equipments (which is still awesome in my opinion), how would you be as excited? And I share your pain about publishing papers. 1. Very few respectable journals are indian. 2. They are rarely useful to anyone. 3. Your papers are very respected if you have 7 citations. Really?
@@karthika560 😂 Yes. Their thinking goes something like this : If the paper is too simple in english, someone else will beat you to the next paper which you are writing. But jokes aside, why I think they HAVE to use complex english is because 1. The papers or thesis have a page limit, so we have to compact it. 2. To sound professional, because you are claiming authority on the subject. Example from shark tank: if you are into business you have to speak in terms of Gross profit, net profit, capital etc. You don't have the luxury to not use those terms in front of your investors if you want to be taken seriously. 3. If you are not using accurate english, then you are lying in English. Example, "I just did lunch" means did you make lunch? Or Did you eat lunch?
if all educated working class migrate, then how will the poor and labour get work? This crisis is because of prolonged neglect of Punjab by Akali and Congress for 50 years
The real reason for migration from poor countries to rich countries is raise of social media. It’s a global phenomenon. Massive usage of Facebook, Insta, TikTok is making people aware how bad their quality of life is as compared to those in developed countries.
India need to proactively create a human export ministry and promote moving 1% of its population every year to other places. This is a big potential for india to get rid of its poverty, enrich the world with good talent and rule the world
@@manojgoel3910 dude you don't understand. The Middle class, especially the college educated ones, forms the intelligentsia of any country. That is why whenever an authoritarian govt has taken hold, it is the educated middle class that is killed off first (as evident by what happened in East Pakistan, Cambodia, Germany under Nazi etc). How will you replace the skill that goes away with these people ?
@@riichobamin7612 do you know the population of middle class in India and do you know how many times of middle class india has? FYI india is 90% middle class. I know what I write and what is good for us
@@manojgoel3910 90% middle class ?? What ?? where did u get this stats ?? 26.2% on less than $3.20/day (20/21 est) so atleast 40 % of the country is poor
I am currently doing my Graduate studies in control & robotics here in the US, the fact is that atleast in engineering US has far more opportunities than India, in CS India is great but good CS Jobs are still less than the number of graduates.
Bro which branch of engg you are doing And what university in usa are you enrolled.i am planning to do my mtech in cse and robotics and automation from iisc banglore
Look if they want to leave and go to Canada (Kanedda) they are free to go. Its a personal choice. I am actually happy for them. I wish them all good luck may all of you make it. Everyone keeps saying brain drain brain drain bhai 1.4 billion log hain agar competition kum horahi hain aur abroad jarahi hain toh accha he humare liye who stay here. Also in future when they settle they will send more remittance (Dallar) to India which is good for us. Plus soft power for India abroad as well. Agar Punjab, Kerala mein Industry nahi toh waise bhi ye log kya he karege and even if they get jobs they have to come to Mumbai, Bengaluru so isse accha Kanedda he chale jaye. Udhar jao settle hojao gori se shadiya karo aur citizenship chodo, bus idhar ki zamin hogi voh hume bechdo, hume as in Indian who will live and die here. We will make some productive use of that real estate. Also 1 request to NRI bros, pls bhai log dollar kamake yaha real estate mat lo just for investment, it makes life for us Indians hard as we cannot compete price ke maamle mein. Don't drive us out of real estate market. Peace and good wishes.
Bhai tu Mumbai sai hai idhar punjab mai education tatti hai, ab dekh lai Master kar rahe hai par 4 Basic lines to the point nahi boli ja rahi Akali congress ruined punjab.
I have lived in both Canada n uk and I would say that in my opinion gujrati and tamils are way more desperate to leave india for abroad then punjabis. As a matter of fact every indian is desperate to leave india for the west the only once who say otherwise are the once who are too poor to make the move. In my opinion the biggest reason is that everyone has deep down given up on india as a country so they move out and those who can’t afford to move except their reality and look down upon those who left so they can feel better about not being able to leave. The government should focus on restoring trust in the upper middle class on india.
Bhai meine nahi giveup kiya, meko koi shauk nahi abroad janeka, I don't make much 25-30k month, I am doing OK. End of the day it is personal choice. Also I want to be part of that Generation who can tell their grandkids ke humne iss desh ko 3rd world se 1st world banaya. Free ka kuch nahi milta, and the west will collapse by the end of this century money is moving back to Asia. End mein bus bolunga jinko abroad janai jaye, heck I encourage it more, less competition less population easy for us to find and retain jobs.
I am a indo Canadian but i Came to Canada in the 90s And we're happily welcome any Indian or any Punjabi person then but now living in Canada. I feel like I am in Punjab, not Canada. There are too many people here. Especially immigrants from Punjab in India. But there's absolutely no work availability. Is it's after hitting a market with people and not enough work? So how will these students manage? They take big loans. What about the Canadian citizens that are born in Canada? What will they do? What if everybody from Ontario started moving to Punjab, to take their jobs? Do you think they will be happy? Even the Canadian citizens here cannot find a basic job. Just serving coffee, that is how ridiculous it is here. That shows you that having too many immigrants There's also an issue I understand there is not a lot of work and good jobs, but when you come here now, the employer has a choice and they were undercut so now they will give you pennies for work. That is a difference. I have seen students working 1414 hours just to earn a basic living. Why can't they work that hard in india
Some people don't like to be rude but the problem is not jobs or less employment opportunities The reality is that youth is determined to move out of India anyhow, understand and try to accept the reality
@@nikhilrampal2431 ha 😂🤣 Kerala 20 percent nri remmitence in india and most skilled in Canada. Keralites grow 130 percent in five years in Canada and rest states less than 50 percent. How many world ceos from North India above vindyas ranges??? Central Asian origin rulers kids. How many world ceos from Punjab. Do u know kerala ceos in USA and founders of companies like NetApp oracle Google cloud ceo nowartis ceo FedEx Microsoft global director Padma warrior etc. North Indian are farm labourer and guju pan shop and motels
This is because more and more, Punjabis don't feel a sense of belonging to India which is merely a carry-over from British India empire - an artificial union of different cultures, ethnicities and languages. if Punjab exists as an independent nation, I believe it will progress much better.
Let's see...Independent Punjab: A landlocked country atleast 950 km away from the nearest ocean. Culturally fraught relations with the largest religio ethnic group to their west. Dependence on rivers that neither originate nor drain out in the state. Internal sectarian friction (viz-a-viz Jatts, Ravidasias and other groups). A large religious minority (Hindus) that is likely to be pro India. Lacking in a strong Industrial/manufactring base on which to build on. Low standards of technical education. Fuedal culture. Yes, I'm also convinced that "if Punjab exists as an independent nation, I believe it will progress much better"...hahahahahahahahaha...on an entirley separate note, PTI Tiger Force zindabad! hahahahahahahahaha...
@Kabir Bal, I believe you'd be able to see that my comment is a response to someone elses. Since, you're clearly able to read and write, atleast peruse the comment I've responded to for context, before shooting off the hip. Thank you!
Present employment opportunities in india is worst. I am very frustrated on my govt and country. India is failed to create jobs. India is only famous for politics, CORRUPTION 1ST PLACE, MOVIES, CAST, RELIGIOUS.
Trust me, Kerala students numbers going abroad and total number of Keralites in Canada would outdo the number of people from Punjab. The competition in the future would be between Kerala & Punjab. The looser would be India in this battle.
@@raisarwanath4484 grow up man. Go and search. Keralites 130 percent population growth in Canada and rest states less than 50 percent. Gulf more rich than india
@@raisarwanath4484 do u know famous keralites like Google cloud ceo and oracle founder, Microsoft global director Padma warrior, FedEx ceo, nowartis ceo, NetApp founder and owner etc in USA???
How is India the loser, if people from Punjab and Kerela want to go abroad its a personal choice. Plus its good for us we will have less competition for jobs. They will send remittance as well which is good for the country. Ye sab Brain Drain brain drain karte ho , yaha rehke kya he ukhad lege ye log, atleast bahar se dollar toh bhejte hain. Mein toh boltau sab jao bahar waise bhi India mein 1.4 billion population hogaya hain, thoda kum hojaye toh accha he hain.
They better don`t say that they do not want to come back to India and let the Canadian Government hear about it - the Immigration authorities will look for them
This situation is more or less seen throughout the country. I think It's due to less job opportunities+useless 💩 degree from faltu college+lower standard of living here Because most of these people go there and happily work in grocery shops, restaurants, as a driver, etc.
The thing is people are paid what they deserve over there where as in india they work their entire lives to achieve nothing. A watch man in Mumbai earns 10thousand rupees a month where a watch man in Canada earn 4 to 5 thousand dollars a week. The amount they make in Mumbai is barley enough to survive in that city, but the amount made in Toronto is enough to live with dignity and a lot more comfort. 5 thousand dollars are about 2.5 lakh in india
@@harvinsingh9347 4 to 5 thousand dollars a week. So about 20 thousand dollars a month and around 240k in a year. That's almost 5 times their average national income?🙂
Merely cracking IELTS is not enough to study for a degree in a reasonable university in Canada because you need to have high standards in your 10+2. If you have good standards, it may be better to do a degree in India (there are many private Engg. colleges in the South) by spending a few lakhs rather than spending tens of lakhs for a degree in a small college in Canada.
Nothing wrong, to get better pay and better quality life going abroad. Indians like white skin, like western dress, society feels great about you when you act like whiteman, use his language.
Sorry but that first girl had no idea why she wanted to study abroad or what she wanted to study. Commerce is a very broad subject and all she could say was study commerce and be a businessman. That’s not a plan that’s a vague idea.
The kids don’t realize that the exchange rate yes is different but u have expenses in canada. Just bc u are making dollars doesn’t mean your expenses are in rupees.
This is a chain reaction started by those already settled in Canada, by showing flashy & comfy lifestyle, and hence the punjabi youth develops a fear of missing out (FOMO).
Same is the case with kerelas gulf migration.
It's all a mindset game.
Besides I think in our country respect is considered the highest. Means any youth will do any job in foreign countries but will not do it here. Here he wants a job of respect only.
In foreign countries their is no one to watch who is doing what. Here 100 people are watching & judging & gossiping in groups. This actually brings down the morale of a kid or youth.
I live in Pune and even my friends who got 30 LPA package are moving abroad for studies. Maybe the opportunities are less here, I don't know, but personally I believe that the allure of NRI lifestyle is the main reason rather than lack of opportunities.
Bro, I recently got a job at a startup. 2 of my friends who used to live in California, also came back in 2021 to join a startup. Bro i do think that startups can reduce brain drain
What do you think bruh, can startups reduce brain drain?
@@raghav7202 80 percent of startups fail as per stats. Most of these returnees would have to head back at some point.
@@cb9461 But bro the number is still very high, I mean about 10 unicorns were created in January alone
@@cb9461 Bro I am not sure but I think that this is a old data. I mean I am not sure
Excellent reporting by Nikhil Rampal. An eye opening as well as worrying situation in Punjab. Good job The Print.
Thank you :)
The current situation of employment in Punjab is unfortunate but is no different from what's happening in the rest of India. Goverment jobs are minimal, MSME jobs are limited to blue collar skilled/unskilled category, fixed costs to start big businesses are way too high, and not everyone has the access to capital/skills to start small businesses.
I graduated from NIT and was fortunate that I had multiple options to start my career. Infact I had cleared the state electricity department exam as well but never bothered to join because of the 'Basic Pay for 3 years' rule.
Its not that Youth of Punjab or India has failed us, but the Politicians across aisle are responsible for creating an environment where young minds are not able to see a future for their families and chose the hardship of building a dignified life away from the land of their ancestors.
Very well phrased Jagpreet
First thing Punjab should do is the following:
1. make condoms free
2. close all Pregnancy Hospitals and clinic
3. announce to the state that it has decided to reduce population
4. allow people to choose to suicide and start a department for Happy ending suicide and volunteer for organ transplant.
5. Add two more subjects in the education system: A: Aghorism :-) B: Life after death and Hoorism :-)
😥😥😥
But it is no more about jobs now. There are many good jobs here. But many don't even think of finding jobs here. It has become a culture to move abroad. Students start to think about moving abroad from childhood itself as they get facinated or influenced by their friends and relatives who are majoritarily staying abroad. So they think it is better to stay abroad near to friends and relatives rather than staying alone in India.
@@siddxk kerala 130 percent population growth in Canada and rest states all below 50.
Thanks such a wonderful documentry nd reporting 💕💕
Dear friend,
Thank you for supporting our journalism..
Thank you so much for supporting
Even most of them don't know why they want to go. They all have fed from their childhood that they will be going to Canada, US ...Their whole aim is to go abroad. One can understand if he/she wants to go abroad to avail the best possible opportunities in their field of interest but their goal is to go abroad that's it . They all have been presented with some fairytales like their life will change drastically when they will live these countries. Also Punjabi music, movie industry have contributed to it to a large extent.
Being a graduate from a top notch university in India would also put you in a competition for small number of good paying jobs.
@@haphazardblizzard799 abey dalley Kitne paise miley hain comments karne ke...Her jagah arugement kare jaa rha hai
@@madetolaugh3476 Argument nahi tum jaisey Godsey ki aulaad ko sheesha mein shakkal dikhaa raha hao.
😡get real , no one from Punjab really want to study at all 😡all they want is student visa , which can be illegally used for driving taxis & applying PR , this nonsense is going on since year 2000
So is it a crime to go to Canada?? I believe every indian should move to Canada USA Australia Britain
the expression of Rampal while in IELTS classroom is priceless
I am really happy you have taken up this topic .. state is performing very badly .. i had to leave punjab because of lack of opportunity ... now when i go back i see no one of my circle there... i believe not even 1% of my batchmates are still in punjab ... Hope govt start working towards this issue and brings back industry
See this 1 in 33 people is pegged to the overall population. The way villages are emptying and with mostly the young age group who may go for higher studies, this ratio will come down. Mass exodus of youth and the middle class is not a good sign considering they're the net consumers (paying indirect taxes) and earning taxable incomes (non-farming). Punjab may lose massive revenue earning if its core consumers move away, instead of retaining, they're promising to facilitate!
"Guys please don't mock any state but try to see the real issue of it. The educated middle class is moving out. The professor said the gap between rich and poor will widen with no middle class in it. That's never good for a country, no matter what's your political opinion is. If you care about India; you should worry about this problem."
There will always be a middle class because the number is too high. But the middle class will feel increasingly demoralised, because the poor who resort to crime cant go after the rich so they will come after the middle class. They cannot steal the jewellery of any Bollywood stars daughter. But if your daughter goes out for a morning walk with an earring...
You've made an excellent observation. When the educated class wants to leave, it says something about what is happening in India. It is not a positive thing.
@@jmudikun it's most qualified migrating. Kerala 130 percent growth in Canada. Rest all states below 50. Usa Telugu highest now.
@@jmudikun Reservations
Story of Gujarat too my friend Not just Punjab...
Especially in North Gujarat there is an unprecedented craze for US. Recently a family was found frozen to death at US Canadian border
This is just a manipulated brain they think us lifestyle is more happier than here...
Just like people are manipulated for nationalism, jihadism, religion its a type of same brain games which is driven by social media.....
@@parvadhami980 but USA don't give pr
@@parvadhami980 kerala 130 percent population growth in Canada and rest states less than 50. Usa Telugu highest nri now overtook gujus.
Same situation in kerala. Candidates are keen to migrate to UK nowadays
@TrueAryans Lol .😁😁
Same situation in uttarakhand
Me too. I'm planning to write PLAB and move to UK from Kerala.
@@Ahmed-ef6ss is is is not recruiting in UK, go to saudi
@@Jesssco they're recruiting doctors in UK. All I have to do is write the PLAB exam, get registered in the GMC, and then I'll be eligible to work in the UK.
I finished my degree in India and started job in Mumbai in 2010. In 2015 with 5 lakhs I started my own business. My plan is to buy mercedes before 2025. Fingers crossed. I am 36 and keep telling youth that India have same kind of opportunities as west have. My friends in India are drawing salaries of over 1 crore per annum in investment banking. Degree doesn't matter it's your skill which makes you successful.
Well good for you don't speak for rest
All the best
May I know which business u started
India job failed nation and usd 80 now
@@M----S he's is speaking for himself, you comment has no validity.
You took her ielts exam interview already 😆😆😆
More learning required for them to clear it
atleast they speak better in comparison to toppers of Bihar board.
They are making an attempt to talk in a language that they have not spoken or studied enough, lets be fair here, most people would struggle to talk in a language other than what we studied in or have an exposure to, be kind folks
@@kang2753 so now reference level of punjabi is bihar which have lowest hdi & highest corruption .
Dude you must choose some better reference point.
Atlest haryana or himachal
These people will learn to speak English very fluently in a matter of few years
First thing Punjab should do is the following:
1. make condoms free
2. close all Pregnancy Hospitals and clinic
3. announce to the state that it has decided to reduce population
4. allow people to choose to suicide and start a department for Happy ending suicide and volunteer for organ transplant.
5. Add two more subjects in the education system: A: Aghorism :-) B: Life after death and Hoorism :-)
With the qualifications most of them have, I really doubt how much they can achieve in the first word , not to forget the high cost of living. Maybe lesser competition as compared to India helps👍🏻
Truck driving doesn't require phd i guess... most of them intend to leave for good...ilets is just for entry
@@MrRakaraka1111 Anything Western is good, that's the mindset
@@karthika560 Well , the frustration of the middle class is very evident in your words, but in My state (WB) things are not this bad( Although there's a huge number of poor people, and more than half of them are from Bihar and non Bengali Muslims who live in a very congested and unhygienic places in and around the capital) But for the Middle class Bengalis life isn't that bad, but the trade unions and left front government decimated the industrial belt of Hooghly and Howrah, which made poor people worse of sadly.
@@dwaipayanmoitra4651 dude i think you are from presidency region (south bengal ), the jangalmahal ,central bengal is quite poor , most of bengali migrant worker belong to these region's
@@metatron-scribeofgod6572 You're right 👍🏻 also North Bengal gets neglected by whoever comes at the government in Kolkata.
Another reason why many students are going abroad to do masters because in India to get into a good iim/iit or any good college or govt job it takes a lot of hardwork but clearing IELTS is relatively easy and the university they get there are good, so rather then studying in a mediocre institution here it is better to go abroad.
Reservations
This is a very superficial and generic reason, which should apply to whole India agnostically, not specifically to Punjab.
This is why we need industrialisation so manufacturing jobs are made. Instead we only care about IT services and propping up unsustainable agriculture due to farmer votebank. We kept buying time in form of free power, cheap fertiliser, irrigation, strict labour laws etc. but time is running out. I predict civil strife in places like Punjab and northern Hindi belt cause unemployment. Not just India but all of South Asia, Africa, middle east, southern Europe and america region.
@@karthika560 i don’t know abt that still long way to go. But certainly some regions in UP industrialised than many states. Noida, Gurguaon, Ghaziabad etc. UP very poor overall but like India should be seen as continent not country, UP should be seen as country not a state. Too much people to categorise generally. More promising than Bihar and other states with impressive expresseay construction and policies. However still very long way to go and legacy problems of education and health. Caste politics and Deobandi islamists.
Correction: Gurguaon in Haryana
Frmrs r not getting these facilities..n they r not stopping industrialisation...lolz have some balls to curse gov dude..
Agro farming industries like textile mills are not there in the cotton belts..
Lolz 🤣 talkin is very easy.
Will power b hona chahiye
@@OhiSandhu Telengana CM even admits farmer gets free power. Same in Punjab. This comes at cost of manufacturing as industry pays artificially higher tariff to subsidise farmer even though manufacturing more valuable to economy. Even BJP gives rubbish like loan waivers. Yogi talks abour 50% reduced power tariff for farmers. So i am saying BJP part of problem too. They think money comes from trees. We should be spending money on health, education and infrastructure instead of wasteful subsidies.
@@rohanindra6401 telangana state is earning from its sand n other resources..but in punjab all parties leaders stealing the resources..even cntr snatched their water rights which every other state has..
So problems are different..
Industrialists are not getting friendly approach..even neighborhood states giving incentives n less tax..so farmers r not in between all this...
N fertilizer u talking about..see latest budget..
Nd even u will know why farming is necessary in upcoming days as mustard import will fail..nd wheat output is also decreasing year by year due to climate change.
Good colleges have limited seats, it's not about better education it's because not everyone can get into IITs and IIMs. In short if you have average talent and skills you are screwed in India.
That's exactly the problem....
An average guy in India is doing wonders in US and Canada.....in western countries mediocrity has a reward unlike India where you have to be made of steel to be successful in India.....
Thank you for your excellent and in depth report on a timely and worrisome issue 🙏🏾
None of these kids have achieved any academic success here and are not willing to work hard & feel that running abroad will just suddenly give them a shortcut to their dreams
I am a proud engineer and have farm land. I am not planning to leave India. I agree with you but That's the problem you have to give success to average students too. Basic need for decent living is required for every one.
@@chandanba4059 I agree but to achieve success some hard work is required and just hoping for short cuts doesn’t help & by success I don’t only mean in terms of academics
@@AB-tx5zm do you agree if you can afford an appartment or a decent home in India with average government salary or private senior salary of 10Lpa in any metro cities. Working till age of 45years people are not able to buy their own home or afford retirement. What we need in India right now is increase in per capita income for average middle class
Only less than 10% of Indians are making 10Lpa for decent living. I am being fair in saying government is failing in providing stable environment for miro economics to grow. For example if you risk taking loan to create your own business you need 100%plus equity to apply for loan. It's egg and chicken problem
@@chandanba4059 sir, I agree with what you are saying yet my point is just that if you are not willing to work hard & gain genuine skills then don’t just blame the system for your own failures!
Other states too have youths who wish to run abroad but Punjab has the affordability factor working for them. Also, the new generation is reluctant to pursue agriculture.
Kerala population growth 130 percent in Canada and rest less than 50. Telugu top in usa now
Why does no media cover this issue?
Students wearing Burberry and Champion cloths !!
Same situation in Kerala too people are preferring foreign studies if they can afford the financial burden.
Returns are better
I agree. Also, a close malayalee friend wanted to open an industrial unit near Cochin. He was so frustrated with the government officials' constant creation of artificial barriers, he ended up opening his factory in UP...yes UP, the place with sub Saharan HDI markers...so it is natural that educated Mallus prefer going to the Gulf!
@@remasteredambience Have you ever been to UP? Come to Lucknow and NOIDA you will forget your Kerala
@@Achintyanath I'm from UP. Lived in Gomti Nagar and Daliganj in Lucknow and Sector 51 in Noida. What's your point?
@@remasteredambience Point is you called UP having sub-Saharan HDI markers which is wrong. I live near Lucknow University Metro Station which is few meters from Daliganj.
All the very best to the kids on the block...it's going to be equally tough, if not tougher, life is not easy anywhere and there are few shortcuts
The highest immigration in India is being witnessed in Punjab followed by Gujerat and then Kerala. All three states are in much better shape than Jharkhand, UP, Bihar etc., unfortunately our country is third world in every sense; hence education and more importantly the Internet shows the conditions of people around the world. When confronted by that stark reality, Punjabis who have an advantage of already having relatives abroad especially in Canada, USA, UK, Australia and New Zealand tend to be the most successful at immigating. This is the reality of our situation in the country, sad fact is that we have HDI levels at par with Sub Saharan Africa for a majority of the country, and due to extreme hypocrisy we pretend that we are a great world power, this unfortunately is the reality of our nation.
Aslo, despite having one of the youngest populations in the world we are obsessed with old men to run our country and the youngsters who enter politics are usually College dropouts.
Kerala population growth 130 percent in Canada and rest less than 50
In my opinion it's a personal choice and everyone is free to do so. India is a big country with 1.4 billion population, majority of which is young. Jobs are not what they used to be 20-30 years back. And India is not a manufacturing powerhouse like China to employ that many people which even today China struggles with. Truth being told automation and manufacturing being taken over by robots will make job requirements higher which most of us don't have the technical know how to do.
End mein jisko janai jaye, many of my friends left for Canada, UK while I decided to stay back.
It's a choice I made no regrets.
And my friends are happy too thou they miss food and family sometimes.
Mein toh boltau joh nikal saktai nikal le less competition for us who decided to stay despite having the money to go and chose not to.
Just like UK closed its immigration, Canada will do so in couple years. I wonder what country will open up next?
The Western countries will always need immigration due to increase in old age people and to modernise their infrastructure.
HOLLAND will be new canada for punjabis..........very soon...
just wait and watch
Canada will not close it's doors. U got it all wrong my friend. Canada needs more and more immigrants as population growth is very low.
@@joysingh1929 Ireland too is taking a lot of Indians due to the demand in IT sector and Pharma
@@haphazardblizzard799 it's now a story of past bcuz now most jobs will get automated.
Kerala as usual is No1 in this list also. Scientific establishments that can run the economy and see to the welfare mechanisms are missing in India. It's only for rich privileged and select few who make it in India. rest of us have to migrate. not just Punjab , We can create jobs only with innovative new technology. entrepreneurship. Reservations of 60% will ruin the nation.
Punjab used to be one of best prosperous regions of india it has one of most fertile land and healthy economy... It is really sad to see Punjab deterioratig ...
Canada has stated it’s going to take in 1.2 million (12lakhs) immigrants in the next three years. Also Indians have emerged as the highest number of legal immigrants yearly to Canada. One can gauze this from the ubiquity of Indian brands in Canadian stores these days. I think the immigration firms in Punjab sell this “demand “ for Indian immigrants for the Canadian economy.
Keralites 130 percent population growth in Canada and rest below 50
Not just Punjab. Everyone young person in India wants to move to their former colonial masters countries. Damning verdict on the governance of independent India.
Not like the way the punjabi does in a big margin.
@@aakash26159 keralites 130 percent population growth in Canada and rest states less than 50 percent. So
🙏🏼👍🏼👍🏼 The Print bringing important issues forward
*print
@@parvadhami980 Oh sorry
12:10..Absolutely right "Dignified" is the right word.
I agree there is unemployment in Punjab but I don't agree there is no opportunity in Punjab my lot of friends are going to Canada they are super rich farmers they have lot of land they are just going there to have fun life without restriction of their parents this is also major factor not everything can be government fault some time media should show this reality also most of people who are going are from rich family of Punjab
It had become a part of mindset, that your life is destroyed if you don't move to foreign,
That might be what they think their life's going to be when they arrive in the US/Canada, but reality soon hits quite hard. Most of these boys can't string along a viable sentence in English (which in itself is not a shortcoming, but it is a problem when the lingua franca of the host nation is English), they take years, if at all, to shed their retrograde concepts of "izzat", which leads to them labeling every woman in a summer dress as "kudi vadi kaint si". They come in at an age when they're still quite hormonal, and, with absolutely no communication skills combined with their chronic character judgement of women, they end up visiting prostitutes. To deal with boredom, they take to the bottle and given as they're expected to pay off their "donki" agent every month, both the hookers and the booze they indulge in, tends to be the cheapest available option. The end result is they end up doing the exact same jobs, they think are beneath them, back home. For all their success, they tend to do in the US what they expect "bhaiyyas" to do in Punjab. Life abroad is best described by a tiktok/instagram video that went viral in 2015-16, which had a bunch of punjabi guys singing to the effect that "aqal thikane lag jati hey, Amrika aakey".
@@remasteredambience best reply bro ….
Fist all thanks for rising important issue of youth of Panjab.
My opinion is for solving this issue
1) we should have promot crros order tread with pakistan this will help for local industries and local agriculture .
2) our cotton tread should promote that help for farmer for agriculture diversification so income of farmers also increase .
3) most of industry of Panjab is MSME so govt provide better market access .
Are govt he industry walo se he hissa mang leti hai..... Jalandhar haveli ke bare mein research kro jo business chal jata hai usko yeh choddte nai
@@KamalSingh-qd9jr sir, dont know because I form rajasthan please send link
@@paramjeetsingh8793 bhai kisi ka business he leh lia gundagardi se unka link thodi na hota hi
@@KamalSingh-qd9jr this biggest problem because a business should pay hight rate tax for country development and should also pay for party fund and also pay local police and administration as bribe .
Naturally business not run .
Most people miss the point that the living expenses are higher as similar to the wages you earn out of India .
Life style and quality of life are best
But the lifestyle you get for the money you spend is worth it.
Not sure how these people will fair in Canada. With poor English and far fetched away from reality, it's going to be extremely tough for most. Cheers from Toronto.
Absolutely true. No wonder they don’t have jobs in india. They will end up working in retail in Canada. It’s about lack of skills
One needs a technical/ science based degree to do well.. most of the arts graduates go to make a little money in retail jobs and then come back. Like what the Latin people are doing in America.
Why aren't they being asked about not choosing bigger Indian cities like Mumbai, Delhi, Bangalore, Pune?
We don't have same culture we don't want to live in different states of India
@@Harry2002-z9q lol.. nice one
They feel Canadians are hand in gloves with them,similar culture!
@@Harry2002-z9q but abroad the culture is even more differentt?! So your answer makes no sense.
Punjab is a Sikh dominated state, and Sikhs have never felt at ease being in India. Controversial statement, yet true. It's sad that Sikhs joined India in 1947.
Sikhism is only limited to jatt sikhs .
There are many lower caste converting to christianity.
My friends are also planning to move to Canada because they earn very less in India and they can earn 10 times more in Canada. They also are persuading me to migrate. They believe there is no future in India and they want to make base there in Canada for their childrens also. My friend says that he doing business earning very less and if he does labour job in Canada, he can earn 10 times more in than doing busines in India.
Converting dollar to rupee and then seeing that it's x times of what u earn in India is stupidity. If u earn in dollar u will have to spend in dollar also. I agree there may be less opportunities in India but it's not like u can't make a fortune in India.
@@rahulbansal9834 you are spot on, cinema and music industry glamourizes foreign countries as heaven where everyone has swiming pool at home and drives a bmw. Most migration without demanded skill experience and degrees end up doing menial job at farms, truck drivers cleaners etc however they will never admit it.
@@rohitkhanna4487 but if they sacrifice enough, they can save up to get premium education for their children, which will ensure that their future generations will have good future.
Edit: by the way, there is no such caste system in the west (to the extent that we see in India) where service jobs like truck drivers and plumbers are considered "menial". Almost all jobs are seen as honorable as long as you make money. And being a trucker or a plumber will get you a very decent lifestyle in the west.
No it's not true my jijaji is also in canada he told me that expenditure is also very high . Even a one bhk flat cost him 1000$ rents without electricity or water bill included .
Guys you need to study and get a good degree then it would make sense and that is not easy don't just look in terms of conversion to rupee, you need to spend there too to survive, only after going there you will realise it..if you are a software engineer for example you will get paid well in India too but don't just blindly convert it , that amount is not enough out there unless you hold a unique skill or degree and obviously if you are a rich Punjabi with family wealth then that is a different topic.
Govt should do following to retain people in india-
1. Give the tax paying layer (middle class) the much needed medical and education facilties and infra as in canada
2. Give work life balance a thought even in govt jobs there is no work life balance leave alone pvt jobs
Many other reasons are there but these two are the main reason NRIs put forth
People from western countries come to India because of cheap medical care
This shows the poor state of education & employment in Punjab.
Also, when all of your friends and relatives start to move there then you see no purpose in staying back in India and this goes on and on result of a chain reaction. Many students even don't try to find jobs here even if there are jobs. Their ultimate goal is to move abroad from childhood itself.
Its not at all about lack of jobs and opportunities or quality of education. If this is their concern then they can move to tier 1 cities like Mumbai, Bangalore, Delhi, etc. But they only have one option that is Canada. The main reason they are lured towards canada is the foriegn lifestyle. Everyone is on insta facebook now a days and these people are easily attracted by such content. They dont even seem to have proper foundation in english language which is must for people going abroad to study. What will happen afterwards is that they will get accepted in extremely low ranked colleges which are just money making universities and after they graduate they will find basic job roles which does not pay good and then they are forced to come back to India. The same is the case with UK. I always suggest people if you want to study abroad choose proper country and good universities and go only for stem courses. We can find a big difference between Indian students in US and in Canada. You will find a large chunk of educated students plus those who can speak good english unlike them. The reason is simple because the US education system requires a lot more than just IELTS. Therefore, these people find it extremely difficult to go to US and then choose Canada and UK which are very easy options available. Also, a big NO for commerce studies in abroad, it will land you nowhere. I hope this helps.
Bhai earlier my perception was only the brightest minds went abroad like IIT, NIT, BITs, IIMs. But now I see every tom dick and Harry going abroad primarily Canada (Kanedda). Matlab joh school mejn 2-3 subjects mein fail hote the voh bhi gaye jinko 2 lines english mein bolne bhi nahi aati properly.
My friend who is in UK also told me a lot of Villagers from Punjab, Haryana who are in his class in UK.
They cannot even speak English somehow did fraud in Ielts exam and came there under the pretext of education and they don't even attend classes. Side mein ye log illegal cash jobs karte hain. All this Education karnai quality seems BS.
Bhai tune commerce kiya hain unless you are enrolling in some cutting edge STEM field what's the point?
You can learn majority of stuff on the Internet for free... TH-cam pe. And if you can afford a few thousand rs there are many online courses.
Inko bus Abroad janai for enjoyment coz they saw some rapper in Canada, dancing with goris having rented lambos in Punjabj rap songs.
Ielts is just emptying the homes 🏡 of Punjab badly.
It's a tradition in states such as Gujarat and Punjab. They go abroad to work in factories and Walmart. Is that the great opportunities they're talking about?
Kerala population growth in Canada 130 and rest states less than 50
To be true it's the Canadian and American Dream, that is inspired by people who are already settled abroad.
who don't want to face the problem simply run away.
Now ppl of haryana also starting migrating.
Both states hv similar issues.
So u must visit their also once.
If u r not on any special agenda.
@@kunwarvyapaksingh7562 yes sri ganganagar border of punjab rajasthan..was in punjab state n district Ferozepur in british tym n before too.
We all r same ppl.
Nd humne achi life jee hai histry me b or ab tak bhi but ab lands b kam hore resources b .rojgar b nhi or desh ki halat khasta hori din ba din jbse ye govt ayi..hatered badra civil war ki or badre..public ki life ki koi security nhi h..koi life standard nhi h..system corruption jadd se chus re..
Log pareshan h akhir kre to kre kya
Attention Dear Students,
Nearly 2000 indian students got scammed in Canada last week when 3 Canadian Universities shut down due to bankruptcy.
Wish you a very happy journey ahead.
Thank you
😅
Yes opportunity in India is less and struggle is more.
But still Opportunity is not the real reason but there is a fatuation for Canada and people wanted to be there after listening a lot of success stories but nobody tries to see other side of story.
For example, anybody went there for education, they get same job profile in which they studied ? Of course not.
Reporting should be done like what reason are being used to to go to Canada and what exactly same people are doing in Canada.
There should be a proper plan what study they are intended to do there. Do the training and certification in same skill and try in Canada. So that people can get a good job in Canada instead of doing a petty job.
She is still is in IELTS mode she is speaking like she giving ielts speaking exam😂
Don't compare them to Gujratis. Gujjus have ambitions to grow a business, punjabi is happy just being abroad and do anything- taxi, store or housewife.
@Punjab Police PB32 District so are u looking for validation from brits? Gujratis are not trying to impress anyone, so screw what brits think. Meanwhile, punjabis are moving from India to any place to do literally anything,
@@piyushsopory5817 guju failed in usa. Not rich just motel and pan shop.
This is not about opportunities it's just abut Punjabis obsession with living in western country.
Kerala highest migration to North America and Europe now
Wtf, bring employment and enforce rule of law. Stop with this crap.
Either Punjab's economy and job sector is really messed up or there is an intense obsession in migrating abroad. Maybe both !
both .
Its not only Punjab but the entire country barring IT, if it was only punjab than we would seen people leave punjab for other states not abroad.
@@PK-tt5kk But why only Punjab has such an obsession primarily for Canada? Canada has been lenient on immigration policy especially Trudeau's liberal to build a vote bank in Canada. Young Indians from other states primarily go through H1B route which demands high technical skills.
Ek baar visa mil jaye fir koi nahi aa raha wapas 😅
The average Indian earns 1.1-1.2 Lakhs per year and you won't able to live a decent life with that money. Now with that even a basic two wheeler owner will find it hard to make ends meet. Add to it more children in lower income levels.
PS: The bs of "people don't pay income tax" is that bs. Average Indian need to earn 3-4 times what they earn now to be able eligible for IT. (Ys it starts at 3 L, but 3-5L gets a lot of rebates)
Dude the per capita is 2100+usd it's more than 1.8Lakh. i think that's very low but not as low what u are writing
If you are earning 1-2lac per year then you wont be better off in Canada. Salary is high for those job which pays well here also.
Give people jobs and more opportunity/funds to start business in Punjab.
Kerala population growth 130 in Canada rest states less than 50
The fact is elite class and middle class are leavind india in my assumption there will two class will be left in india. One will the super rich and other one will be super poor⚠️
I left punjab in 2019 so now 2022 with my hard work just by doing odd jobs in 2 years i got PR and earned arounf 70-80 lakhs own a car and live good lifestyle i think in todays era we want success and money in less period of time if i would have been in punjab it would have been very slow. i know higher grade scoring students bright student have bright career in india but if we see propotion of average students is more. In canada australia usa even the basic earning guy live good lifestyle stress free
Hello bro how much money we need to settle there...?
Bhai sunke accha laga, khush raho aur aise he tarakki karte raho.
Yah but you have people to support you living aboard . 2 year PR is not possible without investing atleast $500k or Citizen sponsoring you or getting married to a citizen.
Odd jobs. Lol. Fuddu kese hoor nu baniye.
@@Pyasa.shaitan ek kam kr tu fudu banke betha reh new brunswick chlja 2 saal ch pr hojange jine hina study krke
Someone get this lady ''best oppurtunities''.
Udta punjab literally..
Everyone is flying here in Gujarat also. All people are talking about canada or uk
@@DhruvPatel-zg1zs Kerala population growth in Canada 130 percent in 5 years and rest states less than 50 percent.
Remind me why we took independence from the British ? Oh right….
The govt earns when you send back money for your parents. ThIs is where the govt and citizen needs align: earning dollars instead of rupee. This is because our Government is TRYING to make India prosperous through exports. So, it values dollar more than rupee. This is disincentivizing solving our own problems by making indigenous solutions low value.
Also, phd holders and masters, even in engineering, are neither absorbed easily in indian industries nor are they paid respectably. Engineering(Non-IT) consultation and services are imported from Germany, US, Australia and even China.
So, as things stand, I believe emigration is the right move.
@@karthika560 The disdain may be justified. Most of our industries dont work on cutting edge tech and the topic to collaborate on would be too basic to arouse intellectual curiosity. For example, if you specialise in the design of mems and are then being asked to collaborate on farming equipments (which is still awesome in my opinion), how would you be as excited?
And I share your pain about publishing papers.
1. Very few respectable journals are indian.
2. They are rarely useful to anyone.
3. Your papers are very respected if you have 7 citations. Really?
@@karthika560 😂 Yes. Their thinking goes something like this : If the paper is too simple in english, someone else will beat you to the next paper which you are writing. But jokes aside, why I think they HAVE to use complex english is because
1. The papers or thesis have a page limit, so we have to compact it.
2. To sound professional, because you are claiming authority on the subject. Example from shark tank: if you are into business you have to speak in terms of Gross profit, net profit, capital etc. You don't have the luxury to not use those terms in front of your investors if you want to be taken seriously.
3. If you are not using accurate english, then you are lying in English. Example, "I just did lunch" means did you make lunch? Or Did you eat lunch?
if all educated working class migrate, then how will the poor and labour get work? This crisis is because of prolonged neglect of Punjab by Akali and Congress for 50 years
The real reason for migration from poor countries to rich countries is raise of social media. It’s a global phenomenon. Massive usage of Facebook, Insta, TikTok is making people aware how bad their quality of life is as compared to those in developed countries.
India need to proactively create a human export ministry and promote moving 1% of its population every year to other places. This is a big potential for india to get rid of its poverty, enrich the world with good talent and rule the world
Most of the "poor" will stay here, the middle class would flee
That is ok, it will still create more opportunity for poor with less competition from middle class
@@manojgoel3910 dude you don't understand. The Middle class, especially the college educated ones, forms the intelligentsia of any country. That is why whenever an authoritarian govt has taken hold, it is the educated middle class that is killed off first (as evident by what happened in East Pakistan, Cambodia, Germany under Nazi etc).
How will you replace the skill that goes away with these people ?
@@riichobamin7612 do you know the population of middle class in India and do you know how many times of middle class india has? FYI india is 90% middle class. I know what I write and what is good for us
@@manojgoel3910 90% middle class ?? What ?? where did u get this stats ?? 26.2% on less than $3.20/day (20/21 est) so atleast 40 % of the country is poor
I am currently doing my Graduate studies in control & robotics here in the US, the fact is that atleast in engineering US has far more opportunities than India, in CS India is great but good CS Jobs are still less than the number of graduates.
Bro which branch of engg you are doing
And what university in usa are you enrolled.i am planning to do my mtech in cse and robotics and automation from iisc banglore
@@manoshinandy5180 electrical & computer at Purdue
@@PK-tt5kk sahi hain
Did he really need to ask which country?😅
Look if they want to leave and go to Canada (Kanedda) they are free to go. Its a personal choice. I am actually happy for them. I wish them all good luck may all of you make it.
Everyone keeps saying brain drain brain drain bhai 1.4 billion log hain agar competition kum horahi hain aur abroad jarahi hain toh accha he humare liye who stay here.
Also in future when they settle they will send more remittance (Dallar) to India which is good for us.
Plus soft power for India abroad as well.
Agar Punjab, Kerala mein Industry nahi toh waise bhi ye log kya he karege and even if they get jobs they have to come to Mumbai, Bengaluru so isse accha Kanedda he chale jaye.
Udhar jao settle hojao gori se shadiya karo aur citizenship chodo, bus idhar ki zamin hogi voh hume bechdo, hume as in Indian who will live and die here. We will make some productive use of that real estate.
Also 1 request to NRI bros, pls bhai log dollar kamake yaha real estate mat lo just for investment, it makes life for us Indians hard as we cannot compete price ke maamle mein. Don't drive us out of real estate market.
Peace and good wishes.
Its the shosha of being an nri
ek bhi student muze talented nahi laga is video me!
Bhai tu Mumbai sai hai idhar punjab mai education tatti hai, ab dekh lai Master kar rahe hai par 4 Basic lines to the point nahi boli ja rahi Akali congress ruined punjab.
@@advaita6523 Toh tum Mumbai aur dusre states main kyu nahi aate?
No one is stopping you.
Badal's have screwed Punjab.... Prakash singh Badal
I have lived in both Canada n uk and I would say that in my opinion gujrati and tamils are way more desperate to leave india for abroad then punjabis. As a matter of fact every indian is desperate to leave india for the west the only once who say otherwise are the once who are too poor to make the move. In my opinion the biggest reason is that everyone has deep down given up on india as a country so they move out and those who can’t afford to move except their reality and look down upon those who left so they can feel better about not being able to leave. The government should focus on restoring trust in the upper middle class on india.
Majority of them are taking a huge risk while going there to study. Almost everyone has a huge loan, only a few are rich enough to afford it.
Kerala population growth 130 percent in Canada and rest states less than 50 percent
Bhai meine nahi giveup kiya, meko koi shauk nahi abroad janeka, I don't make much 25-30k month, I am doing OK.
End of the day it is personal choice. Also I want to be part of that Generation who can tell their grandkids ke humne iss desh ko 3rd world se 1st world banaya.
Free ka kuch nahi milta, and the west will collapse by the end of this century money is moving back to Asia.
End mein bus bolunga jinko abroad janai jaye, heck I encourage it more, less competition less population easy for us to find and retain jobs.
I am a indo Canadian but i Came to Canada in the 90s And we're happily welcome any Indian or any Punjabi person then but now living in Canada. I feel like I am in Punjab, not Canada.
There are too many people here. Especially immigrants from Punjab in India. But there's absolutely no work availability.
Is it's after hitting a market with people and not enough work? So how will these students manage? They take big loans. What about the Canadian citizens that are born in Canada? What will they do? What if everybody from Ontario started moving to Punjab, to take their jobs? Do you think they will be happy? Even the Canadian citizens here cannot find a basic job. Just serving coffee, that is how ridiculous it is here. That shows you that having too many immigrants
There's also an issue I understand there is not a lot of work and good jobs, but when you come here now, the employer has a choice and they were undercut so now they will give you pennies for work. That is a difference. I have seen students working 1414 hours just to earn a basic living. Why can't they work that hard in india
i always think what if western country stop or restrict immigration
Nah atleast in canada tho there's alot of labour shortage
Some people don't like to be rude but the problem is not jobs or less employment opportunities
The reality is that youth is determined to move out of India anyhow, understand and try to accept the reality
Yes i have feeling of left behind
Australia need nurses , Plumber and electrician they get 35$ per hour . study Medical and technical study .
With that English these students will face a lot of problems in Canada.
4:03 almost ALL 6 % of Keralites who emigrated, are workers
The proportion is half for Punjab and Delhi
Right, about 94-95% Keralites go as workers
@@nikhilrampal2431 ha 😂🤣 Kerala 20 percent nri remmitence in india and most skilled in Canada. Keralites grow 130 percent in five years in Canada and rest states less than 50 percent. How many world ceos from North India above vindyas ranges??? Central Asian origin rulers kids. How many world ceos from Punjab. Do u know kerala ceos in USA and founders of companies like NetApp oracle Google cloud ceo nowartis ceo FedEx Microsoft global director Padma warrior etc. North Indian are farm labourer and guju pan shop and motels
This is because more and more, Punjabis don't feel a sense of belonging to India which is merely a carry-over from British India empire - an artificial union of different cultures, ethnicities and languages. if Punjab exists as an independent nation, I believe it will progress much better.
Let's see...Independent Punjab: A landlocked country atleast 950 km away from the nearest ocean. Culturally fraught relations with the largest religio ethnic group to their west. Dependence on rivers that neither originate nor drain out in the state. Internal sectarian friction (viz-a-viz Jatts, Ravidasias and other groups). A large religious minority (Hindus) that is likely to be pro India. Lacking in a strong Industrial/manufactring base on which to build on. Low standards of technical education. Fuedal culture.
Yes, I'm also convinced that "if Punjab exists as an independent nation, I believe it will progress much better"...hahahahahahahahaha...on an entirley separate note, PTI Tiger Force zindabad! hahahahahahahahaha...
@Kabir Bal, I believe you'd be able to see that my comment is a response to someone elses. Since, you're clearly able to read and write, atleast peruse the comment I've responded to for context, before shooting off the hip. Thank you!
I think this is the same problem in north east were language and culture of north India is being imposed
@@moirangthemvishalsingh even most south indian ministers Maharashtra etc asking autonomy even freedom
By your logic every state is different nation
Not only Punjab 😁😁😁😁😁😁
Might be worth interviewing them after they've reached the promised lands.
Australia also need Cook , lab tech and Truck Driver
Dangling wire from the mic.... why?
Lot of Jobs in Australia . Fertility rate is 1 7% which means less kids in future and more immigration . Join Bro
Present employment opportunities in india is worst.
I am very frustrated on my govt and country.
India is failed to create jobs.
India is only famous for politics, CORRUPTION 1ST PLACE, MOVIES, CAST, RELIGIOUS.
Trust me, Kerala students numbers going abroad and total number of Keralites in Canada would outdo the number of people from Punjab. The competition in the future would be between Kerala & Punjab. The looser would be India in this battle.
Never Kerala migration is only limited to gulf I was in Singapore. Malayalis don't have enough money to move to develop countries.
@@raisarwanath4484 grow up man. Go and search. Keralites 130 percent population growth in Canada and rest states less than 50 percent. Gulf more rich than india
@@raisarwanath4484 do u know famous keralites like Google cloud ceo and oracle founder, Microsoft global director Padma warrior, FedEx ceo, nowartis ceo, NetApp founder and owner etc in USA???
How is India the loser, if people from Punjab and Kerela want to go abroad its a personal choice. Plus its good for us we will have less competition for jobs. They will send remittance as well which is good for the country. Ye sab Brain Drain brain drain karte ho , yaha rehke kya he ukhad lege ye log, atleast bahar se dollar toh bhejte hain.
Mein toh boltau sab jao bahar waise bhi India mein 1.4 billion population hogaya hain, thoda kum hojaye toh accha he hain.
What did you study in Punjab?
8’s
They better don`t say that they do not want to come back to India and let the Canadian Government hear about it - the Immigration authorities will look for them
This situation is more or less seen throughout the country. I think It's due to less job opportunities+useless 💩 degree from faltu college+lower standard of living here Because most of these people go there and happily work in grocery shops, restaurants, as a driver, etc.
The thing is people are paid what they deserve over there where as in india they work their entire lives to achieve nothing. A watch man in Mumbai earns 10thousand rupees a month where a watch man in Canada earn 4 to 5 thousand dollars a week. The amount they make in Mumbai is barley enough to survive in that city, but the amount made in Toronto is enough to live with dignity and a lot more comfort. 5 thousand dollars are about 2.5 lakh in india
@@harvinsingh9347 4 to 5 thousand dollars a week. So about 20 thousand dollars a month and around 240k in a year. That's almost 5 times their average national income?🙂
@@ashirwadmishra3536 my bad I meant a month but still better then what they make in india
@@harvinsingh9347 bro do you live in Canada?
Merely cracking IELTS is not enough to study for a degree in a reasonable university in Canada because you need to have high standards in your 10+2. If you have good standards, it may be better to do a degree in India (there are many private Engg. colleges in the South) by spending a few lakhs rather than spending tens of lakhs for a degree in a small college in Canada.
the money they spent on going if used in brains in india they can make a living in india as well
People are leaving because of reservations policy and social distributions.
Fact is Punjab completes labour shortage for Canada
No way 😭
Nothing wrong, to get better pay and better quality life going abroad.
Indians like white skin, like western dress, society feels great about you when you act like whiteman, use his language.
It's not about white skin and acting like the white man. It's about being able to enjoy a much greater quality of life for less hard work.
Sorry but that first girl had no idea why she wanted to study abroad or what she wanted to study. Commerce is a very broad subject and all she could say was study commerce and be a businessman. That’s not a plan that’s a vague idea.
Ans: SAD+CONG
I think it is only bhed chaal not for better higher education and job opportunities in Canada
The kids don’t realize that the exchange rate yes is different but u have expenses in canada. Just bc u are making dollars doesn’t mean your expenses are in rupees.
Life is hard in those countries for students if they have to support themselves