Two things: 1. I've been watching this program since c.1979 and love everything about it, but no character in that whole time has moved me quite as much as Clara Oswald. There's something about her character, how she grows, how she relates to the Doctors, that is just extraordinarily special. And 2. I love Gran! Thank you for bringing both of those back for me with this video.
Yes, she was the Doctor's best companion by far. Because she was so smart. Especially the best companion for Twelve, who also was the best Doctor of all imho.
That scene that the Doctor was talking to older Clara is proof she had feelings for him in this incarnation too. She fancied/was in love with Eleven and I think her feelings never went away after regeneration but probably thought he'd never see her in that way. Danny Pink was just a rebound; their relationship felt forced imo.
i dont think danny and clara's relationship felt forced , i really enjoyed watching them. but i agree with you, i think it was also obvious that the doctor had feelings for clara too. the doctor was so annoyed by danny because the doctor was kinda selfish. he scared to lose clara since day one & i think this is why it felt forced
I don’t think the older Clara was real though, wasn’t it all a dream? Clara loved the doctor but she loved him like a best friend. I always saw both 11 and 12 as Clara’s closest friend, the only person she could trust and rely on. Old “Clara” even says there was one other man after Danny but it never would’ve worked out. Because though he was a great man, she didn’t love him that way.
@@saltydenny3429 She pretty clearly says it never would've worked out because "he was impossible", not because she didn't have feelings for him. When she says that "there was one other man" that matched up to Danny, the phrase has a romantic subtext. Someone who you don't have feelings for really doesn't count as "matching up" to someone you did. Saying the Doctor is "impossible" is a reference to Clara's pragmatism. The Doctor is a 2000 year old alien that doesn't age, which makes him an "impossible" choice for Clara to be in love with. It doesn't mean she's not. And, yes, it was a dream but, both Clara and the Doctor were in the dream together (that's why Clara immediately asks if she's young when she wakes up). The conversation they had in the dream was very real and they both remember it. That dream is, actually, the deciding factor for why they start traveling together again, because they've now seen what Clara's life would be like without the Doctor and although it turned out fine, they'd both rather spend that life together.
I like how the way you weave the story together it's so easy to accept that 11 and 12 are (is?) the same man. It doesn't matter whether he's wearing Smith's or Capaldi's face, there's just one man in there who cares for Clara.
This cloud sequence is surreal. Knocks and moves are just on time and exactly where we need them And the regeneration scene going into the last Christmas scene, it took my breath away Magnificent as always
-s b- by the way thanks for appreciating the timing on the knocks and moves cause that was definitely deliberate, I had to play with the scene cuts and "speed" of the clips so that the knocks and the way clara instinctionally steps back from the TARDIS matches the music!! You know when you do stuff like this, hardly anyone notices it except smart souls like you, but if I didn't do some scenes on time, the out-of-timeness would be so OBVIOUS!! And it just distracts the viewer. So I have to be careful with these things
JCF Productions well I can see that All the things you do have this amazing quality about them: everything seems to fit in just the right places I go to the gym and I watch/rewatch/re-re-re-rewatch them I am also a big fan of the voice overs, that's just pure magic, the way you understand their relationship and still manage to dig even deeper every time
Dr Who came of age with introduction of Clara. It was no longer a children's story. It became mature and ripened into a full blown love story. The portrayal of the two main characters made you look forward to the next episode. Peter and Jenna made in heaven for this show. Beautiful.
@@JCFProductions thank you for your response. I envisaged spending the rest of my life in a vow of silence after my remarks. Feeling the energy between the two main characters far outweighs any spoken words. Anyway, keep the good work going, look forward to more of your in-depth observations. Regards Tony.
There were a few parts where the scenes melded with the music so beautifully. Just the perfect mix of romantic happiness and tragic sadness. I actually started tearing up a little. Someday, want to feel for someone what Twelve and Clara felt for each other.
"I HOPE YOU MADE A WISH" goodness, you did it again. the song is perfect and clara's nan's voiceover was a great idea. the dialogue scenes you chose were just amazing. you are officially my favorite tribute video youtuber P.S. i didn't need the tears anyway 😭
I never really watched after the Tenant era, so I missed this character. I was never any more than a casual fan and other interests claimed my time and attention. Clara Oswald didn’t exist for me. I went all this time ignorant of the perfect storm of character, writing, and actor. To say that Jenna Coleman has screen presence is a gross understatement. She exudes charm, intelligence, adventurousness, resolve, courage, humour, confidence, vulnerability, curiosity, resilience... hope... I’m reminded of Ingrid Bergman in Casablanca. Come to think of it, Bogie’s Rick does essential same thing as Capaldi’s Doctor. Huh. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Ms. Coleman brought us a character that represents everything each of us wants to be. That’s not hyperbole. Clara’s will is palpable. She wields her dialogue like a magic wand. She can make you laugh one second and break your heart the very next. Clara captures The Doctor’s heart and makes us believe that everyone’s favourite Time Lord has finally met his match. This is what they call acting, fellas. I have a feeling that I have some binge watching in my near future.
One lost Dalek disliked this video. I love Clara. I miss her so much. I miss "Doctor Who" so much. Thank you for making all this waiting way better. This video is simple yet beautiful. It's a bit Christmassy but I don't mind. The melody you chose is so beautiful and emotional. I love how you put all the voiceovers and scenes together. Fantastic work! Thank you!:)
Oldz thank you so much! I miss it too, but at least it gets back on tv this spring right? And yes I agree that the video was a bit christmassy, I even considered uploading it next christmas but then I thought, this is how I feel about them right now and I am mesmerized with this song right now, and I might evolve to editing videos differently, and hopefully better in the upcoming months so I just posted it :D and let's be fair, most of their sincerest interactions happened in Christmas specials, which is why I hold them close to my heart :) thanks for watching and always supporting me!
I hope so because they've made us wait definitely too long. I'm glad you decided not to wait for next Christmas because this video is so beautiful and any day without it would be a waste. Now I can enjoy it every day of my life:). I agree, Christmas specials were a bit different. They were supposed to be more emotional and touching and [SPOILER] I heard that Peter Capaldi is going to leave next Christmas:(. We'll have to deal with it again. [SPOILER] Thanks for sharing your talent and skills with us!:)
"I don't know why, I only know who." That scene with the exquisite piano music you chose is DELIGHTFUL and so moving!! Clara goes, "I don't know why I'm crying," & I was saying the same thing with her...with one exception. I do know what made me cry--it's your amazing editing skills! Thanks endlessly for your contribution to the enjoyment & inspiration of vidders everywhere :) :)
Wow such a beautiful tribute to Clara I still miss her unfortunately I won't be watching this years just my opinion I think it's going downhill which is disappointing as I love doctor who such a shame but I love re watching all the great ones
clara did a lot of amazing things in her time in the box. she literally help save the dr home planet.. she saved the doctor uncountable times when she entered the dr timeline. and that's not to mention a few planets and earth. Id say that's pretty good.
WOW THAT WAS SPECTACULAR. one of the best videos you've ever made. i'm really proud of you,such an amazing work you do everytime. love your work. God bless.
i hate you TT that was the most beautiful video of Clara and the doctors you've made me smile directly and cry at the same moment, it's been a while...
Thank you for making this. It's so wonderful and happy and sad and romantic. And It's brilliant. Absolutely brilliant. I don't know how a person can make such a nice video. Thank you so so much. Love this video
Oh my God I am crying so much, I just cry and cry and cry, My kids are starting to think there is something wrong with me. I have even stopped eating bacon. I cried because I saw a piece of dirt in the road the other day, and I thought how Clara would have looked at that piece of dirt in the road. It was beautiful and I am sure it would have made her cry because she is not the Doctors boyfriend or something. So thank you for making me cry all the time because I have nothing better to do.
Through all the years, all the centuries, all the adventures...he met her. The glimpses he had of himself and the best parts of his kind who were gone. He found her, everything he had aspired to be who stood toe to toe with him. Who's eyes had the same awe and love that were in his when he looked at her, not a part time lord but by God 100% A Doctor!
Seen a few of ur other videos and at every single one I'm astounded by the quality and hard work you must go through to make these videos keep up the good work
Theirs was a platonic love, a bond so strong that neither of them could support it. May we see them together again one day somehow before Clara must meet her fate. They we were meant to be together, too bad it couldn't last.
I just now realized in watching this the whole thing about them helping each other with the Christmas cracker. Oh and yeah, I always believed they were in love. What was the music used in the video?
![ตีสิบเดย์ [FULL] | เปิดใจ "อาจารย์ เบียร์ ฅนตื่นธรรม" นักสนทนาธรรมสายดุดัน!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vqaBI_mnoDk/mqdefault.jpg)
Two things: 1. I've been watching this program since c.1979 and love everything about it, but no character in that whole time has moved me quite as much as Clara Oswald. There's something about her character, how she grows, how she relates to the Doctors, that is just extraordinarily special.
And 2. I love Gran!
Thank you for bringing both of those back for me with this video.
pleonic completely agree! Thank you
same here
Because she's a brilliant actor and can convey so much emotion without even speaking.
@@agentcmac yes
Yes, she was the Doctor's best companion by far. Because she was so smart. Especially the best companion for Twelve, who also was the best Doctor of all imho.
That scene that the Doctor was talking to older Clara is proof she had feelings for him in this incarnation too. She fancied/was in love with Eleven and I think her feelings never went away after regeneration but probably thought he'd never see her in that way. Danny Pink was just a rebound; their relationship felt forced imo.
Abit yeah
i dont think danny and clara's relationship felt forced , i really enjoyed watching them. but i agree with you, i think it was also obvious that the doctor had feelings for clara too. the doctor was so annoyed by danny because the doctor was kinda selfish. he scared to lose clara since day one & i think this is why it felt forced
In Listen, she straight up says that his accent is a turn-on🤗
I don’t think the older Clara was real though, wasn’t it all a dream? Clara loved the doctor but she loved him like a best friend. I always saw both 11 and 12 as Clara’s closest friend, the only person she could trust and rely on. Old “Clara” even says there was one other man after Danny but it never would’ve worked out. Because though he was a great man, she didn’t love him that way.
@@saltydenny3429 She pretty clearly says it never would've worked out because "he was impossible", not because she didn't have feelings for him. When she says that "there was one other man" that matched up to Danny, the phrase has a romantic subtext. Someone who you don't have feelings for really doesn't count as "matching up" to someone you did. Saying the Doctor is "impossible" is a reference to Clara's pragmatism. The Doctor is a 2000 year old alien that doesn't age, which makes him an "impossible" choice for Clara to be in love with. It doesn't mean she's not. And, yes, it was a dream but, both Clara and the Doctor were in the dream together (that's why Clara immediately asks if she's young when she wakes up). The conversation they had in the dream was very real and they both remember it. That dream is, actually, the deciding factor for why they start traveling together again, because they've now seen what Clara's life would be like without the Doctor and although it turned out fine, they'd both rather spend that life together.
I like how the way you weave the story together it's so easy to accept that 11 and 12 are (is?) the same man. It doesn't matter whether he's wearing Smith's or Capaldi's face, there's just one man in there who cares for Clara.
"how about we just...don't"? That breaks my heart
This cloud sequence is surreal. Knocks and moves are just on time and exactly where we need them
And the regeneration scene going into the last Christmas scene, it took my breath away
Magnificent as always
-s b- thank you so much! I find the staircase sequence so ethereal and magical and just amazing!! It is easily one of my favorite scenes in doctor who
-s b- by the way thanks for appreciating the timing on the knocks and moves cause that was definitely deliberate, I had to play with the scene cuts and "speed" of the clips so that the knocks and the way clara instinctionally steps back from the TARDIS matches the music!! You know when you do stuff like this, hardly anyone notices it except smart souls like you, but if I didn't do some scenes on time, the out-of-timeness would be so OBVIOUS!! And it just distracts the viewer. So I have to be careful with these things
JCF Productions well I can see that
All the things you do have this amazing quality about them: everything seems to fit in just the right places
I go to the gym and I watch/rewatch/re-re-re-rewatch them
I am also a big fan of the voice overs, that's just pure magic, the way you understand their relationship and still manage to dig even deeper every time
-s b- thank you so much :')
Couldn't agree more... Every video of yours has a detail that touches my soul like anything else... Tks for the most fantastic and brilliant videos!!
simplicity at its best. incredible work. But now my heart hurts. I don't think I'll ever get over this ship. Clara will always be my favourite.
Lenka Jeleňová I know right, this ship is everything! Thank you so much for the kind words x
What a beautiful comment!❤
Dr Who came of age with introduction of Clara. It was no longer a children's story. It became mature and ripened into a full blown love story. The portrayal of the two main characters made you look forward to the next episode. Peter and Jenna made in heaven for this show. Beautiful.
I absolutely agree ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
@@JCFProductions thank you for your response. I envisaged spending the rest of my life in a vow of silence after my remarks. Feeling the energy between the two main characters far outweighs any spoken words. Anyway, keep the good work going, look forward to more of your in-depth observations. Regards Tony.
There were a few parts where the scenes melded with the music so beautifully. Just the perfect mix of romantic happiness and tragic sadness. I actually started tearing up a little. Someday, want to feel for someone what Twelve and Clara felt for each other.
Kevin Carroll I feel the same, their love will always remain a perfect example of selflessness for me :)
THAT WAS JUST....
omg i'm crying
Sharon Studio
"I HOPE YOU MADE A WISH"
goodness, you did it again. the song is perfect and clara's nan's voiceover was a great idea.
the dialogue scenes you chose were just amazing.
you are officially my favorite tribute video youtuber
P.S. i didn't need the tears anyway 😭
Filipe Marques aww, I'm so honored. Thank you!
Love it. Love the song. Love every single thing. Absolutely Fantastic.
Marina Ladomorzi thank you so much
I never really watched after the Tenant era, so I missed this character. I was never any more than a casual fan and other interests claimed my time and attention. Clara Oswald didn’t exist for me. I went all this time ignorant of the perfect storm of character, writing, and actor.
To say that Jenna Coleman has screen presence is a gross understatement. She exudes charm, intelligence, adventurousness, resolve, courage, humour, confidence, vulnerability, curiosity, resilience... hope... I’m reminded of Ingrid Bergman in Casablanca. Come to think of it, Bogie’s Rick does essential same thing as Capaldi’s Doctor. Huh. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Ms. Coleman brought us a character that represents everything each of us wants to be. That’s not hyperbole. Clara’s will is palpable. She wields her dialogue like a magic wand. She can make you laugh one second and break your heart the very next. Clara captures The Doctor’s heart and makes us believe that everyone’s favourite Time Lord has finally met his match. This is what they call acting, fellas.
I have a feeling that I have some binge watching in my near future.
I can’t understand how anyone could hate Clara after seeing this. They just don’t have a heart.
One lost Dalek disliked this video.
I love Clara. I miss her so much. I miss "Doctor Who" so much. Thank you for making all this waiting way better.
This video is simple yet beautiful. It's a bit Christmassy but I don't mind. The melody you chose is so beautiful and emotional. I love how you put all the voiceovers and scenes together. Fantastic work! Thank you!:)
Oldz thank you so much! I miss it too, but at least it gets back on tv this spring right? And yes I agree that the video was a bit christmassy, I even considered uploading it next christmas but then I thought, this is how I feel about them right now and I am mesmerized with this song right now, and I might evolve to editing videos differently, and hopefully better in the upcoming months so I just posted it :D and let's be fair, most of their sincerest interactions happened in Christmas specials, which is why I hold them close to my heart :) thanks for watching and always supporting me!
I hope so because they've made us wait definitely too long. I'm glad you decided not to wait for next Christmas because this video is so beautiful and any day without it would be a waste. Now I can enjoy it every day of my life:). I agree, Christmas specials were a bit different. They were supposed to be more emotional and touching and [SPOILER] I heard that Peter Capaldi is going to leave next Christmas:(. We'll have to deal with it again. [SPOILER] Thanks for sharing your talent and skills with us!:)
Oldz aww, you're super nice :) and yes that spoiler is very sad, he is my fav doctor.
Oh my stars I miss Clara so much. I loved the relationship between her and the Doctor. It was so beautiful and heartbreaking
Awesome video
The scenes where there's older Clara and then young adult Clara made me realize just how similar Clara and the Doctor's story is to Howl and Sophie
"I don't know why, I only know who." That scene with the exquisite piano music you chose is DELIGHTFUL and so moving!! Clara goes, "I don't know why I'm crying," & I was saying the same thing with her...with one exception. I do know what made me cry--it's your amazing editing skills! Thanks endlessly for your contribution to the enjoyment & inspiration of vidders everywhere :) :)
Wow such a beautiful tribute to Clara I still miss her unfortunately I won't be watching this years just my opinion I think it's going downhill which is disappointing as I love doctor who such a shame but I love re watching all the great ones
Lydia Oswald Winchester I miss her too. Did you like the last season?
clara did a lot of amazing things in her time in the box. she literally help save the dr home planet.. she saved the doctor uncountable times when she entered the dr timeline.
and that's not to mention a few planets and earth.
Id say that's pretty good.
This is brillant, so much feels, I miss them together so much!
Cleclemy thank you!
That was so beautifully edited. Love the transition with 12/Clara at 03:36. My heart!
Great video! Love Clara!
Ok I commented while I was watching...
Now I finished, WELL DONE!! This is the best one yet!!!!
Chandler Sun thank you so much!!
this is so beautiful
EleventhEra thank you!
This is just unbelievable. I can not describe in words how powerful and heartbreaking it is. 💙
THIS. IS. BLOODY. MAGICAL.
This video is so beautiful I cried remembering she was captured by the Daleks and made into a Dalek. Run you clever boy and remember.
WOW THAT WAS SPECTACULAR. one of the best videos you've ever made. i'm really proud of you,such an amazing work you do everytime. love your work. God bless.
Selena Lifesaver thank you so much! I hope I won't let you down x
So simple yet so beautiful!
Punydoctor thank you!!
This has hurt me sooo much. And love it sooo much. How I miss all those days, just The Doctor and Clara Oswald in the TARDIS! What a beautiful video ❤
Lining up her three knocks and the piano notes was genius. You're a genius. This edit is amazing.
This is simply beautiful
aubreylurvsharrypotter thank you!
He was magical.
WOW! Just wow! Utterly incredible! You have such great editing with such wonderful pacing. Plus perfect song and great emotional feel
CloseUpBeauty thank you so much!
As alway, truly amazing. Your videos always make me grin and smile without even knowing it!
Agnes Brown so glad to make you smile! Thank you
Favorite Doctor: David Tennant
Favourite Companion: Clara Oswald (Jenna Coleman)
What is life?
The impossible girl!
Greatest story of the modern Dr Who series.
You made me cry. Literally
this video is perfect in every way
This is magical
This is such a stunning edit. The piano music and the scenes are beautifully matched ❤
Great video *sniffle* so beautiful.....*sniff*
Victor Peterson aww, don't cry :'( x thank you
Is so beautiful. I'm crying, sure!
i hate you TT that was the most beautiful video of Clara and the doctors you've made me smile directly and cry at the same moment, it's been a while...
That's is amazing idea around just one phrase. Always loved Clara's Gran. Great video, thank you.
Jenna is just amazing !
Thank you for making this. It's so wonderful and happy and sad and romantic. And It's brilliant. Absolutely brilliant. I don't know how a person can make such a nice video. Thank you so so much. Love this video
Biggest Whovian you’re lovely.. thank you :)
JCF Productions You're welcome. It's really a fantastic, amazing, wonderful video. And I LOVE it. Clara+11 and Clara+12 are so sweet together.
This is beautiful OMG😍😍
Omg it's too beautiful it breaks my heart ♥
This is probably one of my favourite videos of yours. I love it so much, well done!❤
fairylightobsession thank you, you're amazing!
The music fits perfect. Memorys come up 😍 wonderful edit 💙
This is beautiful. Truly, well done.
This video is actually amazing. I kinda love where you have got the bittersweet music from the piano and put it into this episode
I love this edit,thank you.
Wow. That was AMAZING.
I'm crying
It's so beautiful
Aaaaa
Dark Side aww, thank you!
This is fantastic. Love it 💛 thankyou for making it.
greysfan thanks for watching!! :)
I'm not crying, you're crying......
absolutely beautiful
Ashleigh Bailey thank you so much, glad you enjoyed it
Oh my God I am crying so much, I just cry and cry and cry, My kids are starting to think there is something wrong with me. I have even stopped eating bacon. I cried because I saw a piece of dirt in the road the other day, and I thought how Clara would have looked at that piece of dirt in the road. It was beautiful and I am sure it would have made her cry because she is not the Doctors boyfriend or something. So thank you for making me cry all the time because I have nothing better to do.
oh my! such a beautiful vid! lovely editing, very poetic!
Clara....Clara Oswald.... magic moments!!
This is beautiful! Really, really beautiful!
Awh, that is just brilliant. Really nicely edited and with lovely music.
OJWH thank you so much for the kind words x
oh jesus christ how do you keep getting better????? ITS AMAZING. this may be my favorite yet. just wow
I think it is the best..
Jasper production thank you!
This videos is so so amazing. I can't wait for the next series to come out. I love Clara and I love this so much. Keep up the amazing work
Also this has been the best video you've done so far. I mean I loved the others this one is really amazing
Muneeb Ahmed thank you Muneeb! Take care x
Through all the years, all the centuries, all the adventures...he met her. The glimpses he had of himself and the best parts of his kind who were gone. He found her, everything he had aspired to be who stood toe to toe with him. Who's eyes had the same awe and love that were in his when he looked at her, not a part time lord but by God 100% A Doctor!
amazing as always!!!!! lovely video
The Whoniverse thank you!
JCF Productions absolutely love the beutiful piano piece i had heard it before but never fully definetely going to be downloading it
The Whoniverse I know right, it's so amazing! Gives me all the feels about my own personal life as well as doctor who.
Perfect!
Tim Brodersen thanks a lot!
and some say they were platonic........i think i'll have to save link for this video to send to them.
great video. thanks for this piece of art
I love your videos so much 😍😍
oh my God she is her own grandmother WOW holy crap i love it !!!! thanks
Why am i crying, it's been years
Ohmygod, my most favorite song, the most sad song and so f*ucking sad video. I love you, but I hate you, but I love you, gaaaah.
The Artemis Hunter I love you too! And this is one of my fav songs as well.
Nikdo Nikdo have a real suggestion can all fans ask that they get Captain Jack to show up just to use the line you were sexy before but now wow
the most beautiful video.
Jenna Coleman est sublime!!!!!!!!
Nathan Berbach oui!!
You had me crying on heaven sent one. It hurts. I love it
a geez, you are magnificent
0:45 I just love how he says *Clara*
I still believe in a Doctor Who heaven where Ten ended with Rose, Eleven with River, Amy and Rory together forever and... Twelve and Clara XD
i love it!
Sofie Bojková thank you!
you are really brilliant! keep going!
God! That just made me cry!
I'm crying. Your work is so beautiful as always, and everything is so on point. I can't wait for the next video!
great scene and music selections! Clara is the only companion I ever see eye-to-eye with, thank you for the beautiful tribute :')
such a beautiful video :)
oswld thank you so much!
I love clara and docteur
Great video)
la chanson est sublime
Very good
Seen a few of ur other videos and at every single one I'm astounded by the quality and hard work you must go through to make these videos keep up the good work
I'm in tears
Watching this video after a long day is self care.
I’m not crying
Theirs was a platonic love, a bond so strong that neither of them could support it. May we see them together again one day somehow before Clara must meet her fate. They we were meant to be together, too bad it couldn't last.
Great)
Anna Viol thank you so much!
Clara Oswald is still inside my head.
I just now realized in watching this the whole thing about them helping each other with the Christmas cracker.
Oh and yeah, I always believed they were in love.
What was the music used in the video?
Brilliant
This is possably the best version of this song I have heard.
Where did you get it? Because this is not the same as the version I have.
Clara was amazing..too good for me
omg this song sounds exactly like clara's being