When 26/11 happened everyone in developed world said Indian police is old no technology and there is no CCTV surveillance etc now they're questioning this surveillance .
NRIs don’t know that Indian Police in States are Controlled by IPS Cadres who Come Under the Ministry of Personnel of Union Government. But Truth doesn’t matter. 🤭
These DW News guys are so biased and they don't even do basic fact check. For them, India doomed after PM Modi's election in 2014 but the "foolish" Indians are voting for him. The Majority of 1.3 billion people are fools but we, the people of Germany, will tell you the Indians how to live your life. Get a life guys. In next two years, India will be more richer than you. Jealous, right? Please make more such hit pieces.
I am from Northen hilly state of Uttarakhand and the place I grew up in was deep into Himalayas. Earlier to get anything done we had to travel 6 hours in bad hilly roads to the state capital. Now I can access any government services from my smartphone. The pros of digital economy supercede the cons in every manner.
Dw documentary started with a person photograph being taken without permission,if you are afraid of sharing of your photo then surely you are onto something dangerous,thats the least price for digital India.....
@@literarymusings8886 well,there is a difference between personal space and internet privacy ,if you cannot share documents with government then with whom you will..., government is not some private firm that sells data for money ,and by the way Installing cameras on public places is different from installing it in private place..But do not worry because liberals like you will never understand .... rehne do beta tumse na ho payega😁😁😁😁😁😁
As an Indian,who sincerely lives his life peacefully & legally, I want more surveillance so that terrorists/criminals/riots provoking people can be caught quickly! We want good & accurate way for surveillance, and internet is best way!
Same here! I have absolute trust in our government. You can watch porn, download pirated stuff, that's no problem, but follow extremists, promote their ideas and you'll be marked.
India isn't building. India has built world's largest database of citizens with finger print and even retina scan. While this is very efficient in providing services to citizens. Any authoritarian govt can misuse it. Still I am in support of Aadhar but with some restrictions on government. UIDAI should be independent body like election commission.
So much potential from aadhar to unlock example age verification so kid don't buy vape but above 18 can buy made in India vape. imagine how many lives we can save
1. The Indian government already has everyone's photograph(and other biometric details) with them, so the reporting that police are taking photos of individuals from their phones/tablets for DATA COLLECTION is bs. 2. If this report was targeted towards the ruling party, then the reporters should know that police are STATE objects.(Please check the ruling party of Telegana) 3. If a person intends no harm to the society or any individual, it shouldn't concern him if he is being watched or not. And most people fall under this category and nobody should have an issue if we are using the data to capture the few causing nuisance. 4. DW should think about joining some good "Journalism" institutes to at least learn the basics of research in journalism.
Europeans countries themselves doing this The EDRi network has commissioned an independent report from the Edinburgh International Justice Initiative (EIJI) which brings together stark evidence of abusive facial recognition and other forms of biometric surveillance across the European Union (EU). The research shows that harmful biometric mass surveillance practices have become worryingly normalised by law enforcement, other public authorities and private companies in Germany and the Netherlands, with Poland starting to catch up. This new evidence comes hot on the heels of the EU’s two top privacy watchdogs, the European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS) and European Data Protection Board (EDPB), confirming that the EU must ban all automated recognition of human features in publicly accessible spaces, as EDRi has long argued. A chilling set of revelations The report shows that across Germany, Poland and the Netherlands, biometric systems are increasingly required for accessing public services, travel, shopping and other everyday activities. As a result, people are being given the false choice to either submit their sensitive data, or be excluded from society. In one example, the report exposes how Dutch police have allegedly used financial incentives and ‘dark patterns’ to encourage people to share private surveillance footage with police for biometric analysis, as a way to evade current national laws. “The faces of 1 in 12 citizens in the Netherlands are in the massive database of the Dutch police often without any justification. There are multiple cases where, under the guise of experimentation, legal frameworks are pushed aside in order to turn cities into “Living” Laboratories and citizens into guinea pigs. Current regulations are not adequately protecting our rights and freedoms. These toxic and discriminatory biometric mass surveillance practices urgently need to stop!” - explains Lotte Houwing, Policy Advisor at EDRi member Bits of Freedom in the Netherlands In Germany, the report shows that authorities in the city of Cologne have deployed facial recognition systems outside of LGBTQ+ venues, religious venues, doctor’s surgeries and lawyers’ offices without any legitimate justification. The disproportionate deployment of such technologies against certain marginalised groups amplifies structural oppression in society and limits people’s rights to express freely, move without fear and be who they are.
India is under constant threat because of Terrorism and Poor Managament in roads. No one use helmet or Rash driving in roads So we need this to safe guard people. Its very important for us!!
He is an activist and didn't knew that instead of asking WHY WHY WHY, He should have said a clear NO for taking his picture, if you said no, then any govt. body can't take any photo of you without any clear allegations
@@rishabhchaudhary3918 Bhai Indian police wale apni galati ko bhi nahi mantee... saloo ko lagta hai ki jaise unhonee ne hee azadi dilwaii hai India koo ..😂😂😂😂
To be Frank enough,I actually felt impressed that India is ahead of even European countries in the race of data usage I believe India will use it to make it more efficient I also read about India's aadhar system It's actually cool ,Go India 👍
Yes India is using data efficiently....in the last 5-6 years our govt makes sure to store indians data in India whether one using any foreign app that's why many US origin techno giants are building data centre in India....and we have two hostile neighbour Pakistan and China that's why it is necessary to track our misguided citizens and also terrorist organisations which work for Pakistan
Unlike in the West, India has been affected hugely by terrorism. So surveillance isn't a luxury. It's a necessity. Plus it helps combat trafficking of all types.
As an Indian I just want to say that this channel reports our country in negative light always and tries to build a perception maybe the people that rule over Germany or the ones who control this channel want the current govt to change
You are being overly sensitive. They report on bad things the USA and Russia and China and lots of others do, too. India is not perfect, just like everyone else.
These guys are worse than TRT, BBC and France 24. Those channels have made it clear that they are anti-India, but these DW guys pretend that they are neutral but always intend to create a negative image.
Lol you Indians hate the west so much but realize you have no other allies. China is currently stealing your land as I write this and Russia has no more military equipment to send you. It’s just you and North Korea sitting there now like what next. Orange flags will be only the beginning of the end of your country, just wait for the red ones
When a foreign state funded broadcaster is asking questions, you should know they have an agenda. Don't forget east India company and British rule, they were able to rule us for 200 years because of our internal differences. They were just 100000 British when India got independence, but there were 300 million Indians.
Hey hey in India Law and Order is State matter and the whole sample space you took of just 4 people don't come under governance of BJP which don't know why somehow popped up that brings me to question, Are you really publishing honest reports or are selectively cherry-picking
Governments and companies like Google and Facebook already have all the personal data, so there is no such thing as privacy. Just do no wrong and there is nothing to worry about.
Who will decide what is wrong ? what seems right for today's government will be wrong for other , google and facebook don't hold the same power as governments . Although data with both of them is a coz of concern .
@@SaraswatMajumder Google and Facebook have more power then a govt they so biased that they block people opinion on online not come under any govt laws
Silicon valley based big-tech companies is not accountable to Indian laws or its people. Having its own capacity in tech that impacts billions of Indians and their data is important and as you suggest having its own network like China is not a bad idea.
@@avishakdebroy937 Bro Americans do not have protection from our own companies, so it's not like our companies are picking on Indians. Laws are good but this is not some kind of data colonialism - they take advantage of Americans the most.
@@avishakdebroy937 And just steal all of the good ideas from the American companies like Indian and Chinese "entrepreneurs" are already doing, and then put a new name on it. Easy. "Fixed" with new problems.
This channel is becoming progressively more unhinged with its narrative about India and news related to India. The only real value this channel has for the news of Indian subcontinent is comical one.
Since the Germans, or the EU, couldn't get Modi closer to the West and NATO to be against Russia after inviting him at the G7 and did a European leaders tour, they decided to do an internal regime change to coup Modi out by spreading their propa to vilify anything Modi and India. Just like how they actively did to Russia a few months back.
One simple thing I learnt with respect to the global south, if you are annoying the west, you're on the right track. If you're making Bill Gates happy, time to rethink your whole life.
@@krishnkant9477 ROFL! Sure a Modi spam team´s "proof". Evenmoreso as Petersburg newzcasaters happily jump on any bandwagon to spread their online gibberish.
@@Randy778 they have summarized and hypothesized by cherrypicking cases. Sorry not even cases but a single case. They have based an entire 20 min documentary on 1 paranoid individual in 1 city of india and they are trying to generalize for over 1 billion people. Instead of quoting biased individuals they should quote actual studies.
Maybe its time Europe grows over the mindset that the world cannot govern itself and hence its Europe's moral responsibility to lecture everyone how a country should be run.
Read a few dozen books about historical wars and how they occur and then you might understand why so many countries worry about stability in other countries. It is not because they want you to be perfect, or because they think you are worthless...it is because the world could burn the next time we hit a big period of world unrest.
@@hanmantpatil5721 Germans are still living in 20th century, I was dumbfounded when I was in Berlin that people are so less digitally uneducated in a first world country lik Germany 😐
Wow DW documentry is on next level, he has done great job, i can't stop me for laughing he has done great research 😂😂😂 His background space and music is very funny like ghost story
@@jirachi-wishmaker9242 so if someone uses the wrong map the indian gov should ban all of the content on TH-cam? You guys need to chill, New Zealand gets left out of world maps and the just sigh and move on. Grow a bit tougher skin dude
@@nenasiek Indians are one of the most sensitive about being criticized, I'm not sure why. I think it is probably not even the normal people, but instead poorly managed psychological operations units.
@@ems7623 Western media will not tell lies because western media is free and fair, only Russian and Chinese media will tell lies, when western media criticize India, India should reflect on itself
Of course India is doing that and most Indians support it. No matter how much hogwash you spread here about it, you can't delude Indians. We are strongly standing with our government.
Why do so many Indians online take offense at any international media interest in their nation? This is very peculiar behavior and not a good sign of what might be occurring culturally inside India in recent years. Not everything is an attack on India. The world is interested in India because it's a massive democracy and an ancient civilization. Calm down.
Western media will not tell lies because western media is free and fair, only Russian and Chinese media will tell lies, when western media criticize India, India should reflect on itself
@@Shadowless_Kick You are right. More surveillancing has reduced crime rates, and places are much more safer than earlier. I have been to the capital city of my state and saw the drastic positive effects that a strong surveillancing system along with well trained cyber police has bought. Most parts of the city are now perfectly safe to even visit at midnight without any fear. People has also became more sincere and are following rules and laws too.
US, UK are leading along with Germany in the top 5 to 6… The documentary is talking about other countries only.. 🧐 agree that there is need to strengthen data protection laws, security and measures
I was working in gulf countries one my friend car got accident . when my friend gone to police station the police already took the video footage of the incident and said it is not his mistake but other vehicle violated the rule . When he came to know that that route was important for transporting cash to the city ATM machines police started 24/7 surveillance of that particular road helps fetch the video footage of accident . But this channel chooses india for their propoganda. We indians I think should be serious to deal with these westeners.
These Westerner divided our country, our people in the name of religion and language. They looted all the wealth and left behind broken system so India can never rise.
Personal data collection has been going on from even before WWII. Good to know, people globally have become conscious about their personal data. Too late though.
sure, if you are a citizen abiding the CURRENT rules you might have nothing to be afraid of. what if the rules change however? what if in the future the political climate in the country changes and a government comes to power with more radical views, views that you might not agree with. and what if that government then starts to persecute its political opponents? Suddenly this massive amount of surveillance data can be used to oppress minorities and people with differing political ideas, like you. you don't even have to think of that drastic of a scenario. you might someday be judged for your past archived actions, which at the time were considered fine, but now are against the law or are deemed unacceptable based on new rules that you might not agree with. not even speaking about how a system like this prohibits societal change and creates a climate of fear because everyone speaking out against the status quo does so with much greater risk to themself. large scale surveillance is prone to be abused and must be kept in check and under regulations.
I am happy I still have some kind of privacy in the Netherlands. I am no criminal but that doesn’t mean I would like to be videotapes all time. It’s sad that they need those methods to keep power
before the spread of victim cards by minorities telangana/hyderabad is ruled by non BJP non MODI govt who have alliance with hate monger aimim, so they are doing this for own safety and ignore these paid ngos spreading lies of privacy bogey
Yes there are face recognition camera in city ...am from Hyderabad and there are so many cameras around...this is good and for safety for us and for country safety and security...
when your enemies has data of his 1.42 billion people you are bound to increase surveillance and ...remember a great man said ...............'Privacy is Just a Joke ' If jeff bezos phone can be hacked than anyone's can be 😂😂
@@coraltown1 this is necessary to learn the use of artificial intelligence for future warfare which will be based on cyber,space and artificial intelligence
India is a democracy in progress. New technologies keep pushing the boundaries of what's possible. Observing citizens is not a concern as long as the citizen is allowed to know what's known about him like we are informed who accessed our AADHAR info.
Indian Govt need not spy on People on CCTV Cameras, They already have a Big Database of Records of almost every Indian - Its called "Aadhar Biometric Database" which contains Personal Information like Photo, Thumb Print, Blood Type, Age, Name, Sex, Religion, Location and Educational Qualifications of every Indian to issue "Social Security" Cards called "Aadhar Cards".
I think dw should know that is police is a state subject and under control of state government. There is no role of central government.india faced so many terrorist attack and Hyderabad is one of top popular city of india so its become very important to secure its security
Hyderabad isn't even ruled by bjp, i am sorry for pointing out the mistake of video don't want to sound very argumentative, but this sound like a propoganda video.
The EDRi network has commissioned an independent report from the Edinburgh International Justice Initiative (EIJI) which brings together stark evidence of abusive facial recognition and other forms of biometric surveillance across the European Union (EU). The research shows that harmful biometric mass surveillance practices have become worryingly normalised by law enforcement, other public authorities and private companies in Germany and the Netherlands, with Poland starting to catch up. This new evidence comes hot on the heels of the EU’s two top privacy watchdogs, the European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS) and European Data Protection Board (EDPB), confirming that the EU must ban all automated recognition of human features in publicly accessible spaces, as EDRi has long argued. A chilling set of revelations The report shows that across Germany, Poland and the Netherlands, biometric systems are increasingly required for accessing public services, travel, shopping and other everyday activities. As a result, people are being given the false choice to either submit their sensitive data, or be excluded from society. In one example, the report exposes how Dutch police have allegedly used financial incentives and ‘dark patterns’ to encourage people to share private surveillance footage with police for biometric analysis, as a way to evade current national laws. “The faces of 1 in 12 citizens in the Netherlands are in the massive database of the Dutch police often without any justification. There are multiple cases where, under the guise of experimentation, legal frameworks are pushed aside in order to turn cities into “Living” Laboratories and citizens into guinea pigs. Current regulations are not adequately protecting our rights and freedoms. These toxic and discriminatory biometric mass surveillance practices urgently need to stop!” - explains Lotte Houwing, Policy Advisor at EDRi member Bits of Freedom in the Netherlands In Germany, the report shows that authorities in the city of Cologne have deployed facial recognition systems outside of LGBTQ+ venues, religious venues, doctor’s surgeries and lawyers’ offices without any legitimate justification. The disproportionate deployment of such technologies against certain marginalised groups amplifies structural oppression in society and limits people’s rights to express freely, move without fear and be who they are.
@@jirachi-wishmaker9242 they aren't pointing out they are doing this preplanned agenda to spoil the Indian image infront of world Why the heck they are talking about india if their country does the same thing. it's good thing Indian sided with russia, Russian media don't do this type of things that why indians love russia and most importantly they aren't shamless hypocrite like western countries
@@jirachi-wishmaker9242 yeah, but that's why we should be doubly angry about our government doing it with our people! Even with all the concrete transparent framework there has been abuse of surveillance powers, how can we trust our government? In a population as sensitive as India?! How do we know they wouldn't use it to influence elections?!
Public Surveillance is fine as long as their are data protection laws in place and a system to ensure no misuse happens. Those wishing otherwise are naive and will suffer the consequences
Surveillance is absolute necessary in country like India where there are lot of people. Without surveillance there can't be any law enforcement and ultimately citizens will blame government if any anti social activity happens. It is the duty of government and police to track down anti social elements, solve crime as soon as possible. Don't try to make horror video on this. This is happening in India for a long time time. And this is why we are safe here.
Masood posts pics and videos on facebook, twitter, whatsapp.... But a click by police is directly hitting and killing democracy.....hipocracy Ki bhi koi sima hoti h
Germany, USA,Uk etc are too doing these kind of stuff.... Make video about them aswell Or in this video you could have atleast add those countries name while you are mentioning democratic countries
1. Police is under control of the state government and not centre 2. Hydrabad is not ruled by BJP but a local party 3. Government already has Photo and biomatric data of people, including location phone numbers etc 4. A country that is divided and fragmented and crimes that go unsolved most of the time, we Indians welcome this 5. Unlike west we have to worry about terrorist activities 6. DW just hates BJP or its trying to push India bad agenda, its not hidden unlike the past people have internet and a good echosysem has formed proving baised reporting with proof 7. BJP won because people voted them and showed support in BJP's vision, next election in 2024 they will win again for 3rd time, are they perfect? no they are far from it, but BJP is solving some of the biggest issue India is facing, like building bathrooms, building roads and railways, providing electricity and water to every home, cheap internet, inclusion of poor people into digital economy, most of the indians dint even had bank accounts before, solving issue of massive curroption 8. And because of biased news like this is why alot of youth are starting to resent west
First of alI, I wonder, does Germany asks personal information for VISA or not? Second, Europe will never understand India, they look from their own templates on all matters, and think they are template for democracy as well. India is different country and people have different priorities and sensitivities.
Hmm, I do see lack of perspective in your strong opinion. Personal information for VISA? How else are they gonna identify you as a indian national in other coutry? Bdw did you ever fill bank loan application ? or installed corona tracking app on your mobile?
Dw India is emerging super power accept it and my advice to you dont be at bad side of indian viewers, cause when we start covering and exposing every domestic issues of Germany you cant bear it.
Hyderabad is the same city where first hindu massacres started. Hindus were openly raped and Hyderabad is fairly radicalised. I see no problem. Btw Hyderabad not under BJP
@@Randy778 I know right.....let me help you out... through so you are saying.....none of the Indian women have access to healthcare ...like noone...... Go figure....Maybe U need special care....
Stayed 3 years in UK, each and every home and street, each public bus and train, has a camera. So @DW you have anything to sensationalise and complain ???????????????
I doubt India showed Germany anything other than the horrible pollution levels in India! Germany = an ordered disciplined society which is clean, developed, and technologically advanced. India = an disorganised chaotic anarchic society where people are undisciplined and isn't developed enough.
Law&order and Police is under state list ( For DW knowledge, India is a federal country), and thus the Telegana Government is empowered by constitution of India to make laws on police and order. And BJP is not the ruling party of Telegana 😅 thus the thumbnail proves the preconceived bias & blindness labelling of DW
Because Germany does not agree with India's contested territories, and "Donbas & Crimea" will never be shown as Russian as it does not serve the narrative of Germany, by extension NATO.
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 87 วันนี้!! คู่เอก "ก้องชัย vs โชคปรีชา"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YN6e7HVnekw/mqdefault.jpg)
A Bus with a seating capacity of 35 in london had 16 cameras . Imagine those angles.
When 26/11 happened everyone in developed world said Indian police is old no technology and there is no CCTV surveillance etc now they're questioning this surveillance .
Hahaha true clowns of the first order.
Absolute hypocrites
There is such a thing as too much surveillance. Government spying on its people...dont tell be that came out of 26/11.
@@codewalters looks like u watched some documentaries here .Good for you
The problem has to do with what china has done..and witht he fact that they are introducing social crrdit system. I would feel threatened
Weird thing is that BJP isn't even in power in Hyderabad and police is controlled by the state government.
NRIs don’t know that Indian Police in States are Controlled by IPS Cadres who Come Under the Ministry of Personnel of Union Government. But Truth doesn’t matter. 🤭
Because these dumb fs blame every bad thing (even good things they portray as bad) to BJP
haha 🤣 true dw has no logical news.
These DW News guys are so biased and they don't even do basic fact check. For them, India doomed after PM Modi's election in 2014 but the "foolish" Indians are voting for him. The Majority of 1.3 billion people are fools but we, the people of Germany, will tell you the Indians how to live your life. Get a life guys. In next two years, India will be more richer than you. Jealous, right? Please make more such hit pieces.
The state govt is a puppet in the hands of Central.
I am from Northen hilly state of Uttarakhand and the place I grew up in was deep into Himalayas.
Earlier to get anything done we had to travel 6 hours in bad hilly roads to the state capital.
Now I can access any government services from my smartphone.
The pros of digital economy supercede the cons in every manner.
Anti national , Pakistanis , and urban naxals like you help this channel by commenting and viewing it
Dw documentary started with a person photograph being taken without permission,if you are afraid of sharing of your photo then surely you are onto something dangerous,thats the least price for digital India.....
@@rahulmani2886 yes , soo true , please install cameras in your bedroom and give it to Yugpurush , Shri . Modiji
@@literarymusings8886 well,there is a difference between personal space and internet privacy ,if you cannot share documents with government then with whom you will..., government is not some private firm that sells data for money ,and by the way Installing cameras on public places is different from installing it in private place..But do not worry because liberals like you will never understand .... rehne do beta tumse na ho payega😁😁😁😁😁😁
@@rahulmani2886 They're not a private company selling your data for money, it's much worse.
As an Indian,who sincerely lives his life peacefully & legally, I want more surveillance so that terrorists/criminals/riots provoking people can be caught quickly! We want good & accurate way for surveillance, and internet is best way!
You lack vision. Such tools end up being used for evil, especially by nationalists.
Same here! I have absolute trust in our government. You can watch porn, download pirated stuff, that's no problem, but follow extremists, promote their ideas and you'll be marked.
Go to China
Yup,
More Spying on Our Daughters and
Sisters too. 😁👍 National Security
@@ratnamani8228 Definitely on sisters and daughters like Ayisha, Fathima, Mariyam, Raffeala. 😂👌
Privacy My Foot
I already have my neighbours spying on me.
😂😂
That's actually good for you. Getting robbed by someone from outside with many eyes watching definitely works. 😁😁
There are large radical elements in Hyderabad. So surveillance was just increased to better security of all people security.
Excatly. This channel is trying to brainwash us towards the current government.
Did they consult with you?
@@pranky28 yes they did.
@@bowwow255 Pretty sure this masood guy is connected to those radical elements, that's why he wants to stop the surveillance system.
India isn't building. India has built world's largest database of citizens with finger print and even retina scan. While this is very efficient in providing services to citizens. Any authoritarian govt can misuse it. Still I am in support of Aadhar but with some restrictions on government. UIDAI should be independent body like election commission.
But the illegal people and sleeper cells didn’t opted for it and that’s the real issue.
BS. China clearly has the world’s largest database of citizens. In India, at least data collection is privatized to a degree.
Your suggestion is like
Let's put the car speed meter in back of seats
@@MrPokemonCheatandTech your suggestion is like "lets have someone else watch the car metre cause we trust him"
So much potential from aadhar to unlock example age verification so kid don't buy vape but above 18 can buy made in India vape. imagine how many lives we can save
1. The Indian government already has everyone's photograph(and other biometric details) with them, so the reporting that police are taking photos of individuals from their phones/tablets for DATA COLLECTION is bs.
2. If this report was targeted towards the ruling party, then the reporters should know that police are STATE objects.(Please check the ruling party of Telegana)
3. If a person intends no harm to the society or any individual, it shouldn't concern him if he is being watched or not. And most people fall under this category and nobody should have an issue if we are using the data to capture the few causing nuisance.
4. DW should think about joining some good "Journalism" institutes to at least learn the basics of research in journalism.
Was when American
Government see American people privacy that is no dictarship but India use their technology for their interest this problem for you
Europeans countries themselves doing this
The EDRi network has commissioned an independent report from the Edinburgh International Justice Initiative (EIJI) which brings together stark evidence of abusive facial recognition and other forms of biometric surveillance across the European Union (EU). The research shows that harmful biometric mass surveillance practices have become worryingly normalised by law enforcement, other public authorities and private companies in Germany and the Netherlands, with Poland starting to catch up.
This new evidence comes hot on the heels of the EU’s two top privacy watchdogs, the European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS) and European Data Protection Board (EDPB), confirming that the EU must ban all automated recognition of human features in publicly accessible spaces, as EDRi has long argued.
A chilling set of revelations
The report shows that across Germany, Poland and the Netherlands, biometric systems are increasingly required for accessing public services, travel, shopping and other everyday activities. As a result, people are being given the false choice to either submit their sensitive data, or be excluded from society.
In one example, the report exposes how Dutch police have allegedly used financial incentives and ‘dark patterns’ to encourage people to share private surveillance footage with police for biometric analysis, as a way to evade current national laws.
“The faces of 1 in 12 citizens in the Netherlands are in the massive database of the Dutch police often without any justification. There are multiple cases where, under the guise of experimentation, legal frameworks are pushed aside in order to turn cities into “Living” Laboratories and citizens into guinea pigs. Current regulations are not adequately protecting our rights and freedoms. These toxic and discriminatory biometric mass surveillance practices urgently need to stop!” - explains Lotte Houwing, Policy Advisor at EDRi member Bits of Freedom in the Netherlands
In Germany, the report shows that authorities in the city of Cologne have deployed facial recognition systems outside of LGBTQ+ venues, religious venues, doctor’s surgeries and lawyers’ offices without any legitimate justification. The disproportionate deployment of such technologies against certain marginalised groups amplifies structural oppression in society and limits people’s rights to express freely, move without fear and be who they are.
agree they are soooo shamelessly biased hypocrisy at its best
They are more worried about "NGOs"
Americans can do whatever they want . I feel that was necessary after the terrorist attack.
Just like India.
India is under constant threat because of Terrorism and Poor Managament in roads. No one use helmet or Rash driving in roads
So we need this to safe guard people.
Its very important for us!!
He is an activist and didn't knew that instead of asking WHY WHY WHY, He should have said a clear NO for taking his picture, if you said no, then any govt. body can't take any photo of you without any clear allegations
@@rishabhchaudhary3918 You don't know
about Indian Police. You must be an NRI ? 🤣🤣
Anti national , Pakistanis , and urban naxals like you help this channel by commenting and viewing it
@@rishabhchaudhary3918 Bhai Indian police wale apni galati ko bhi nahi mantee... saloo ko lagta hai ki jaise unhonee ne hee azadi dilwaii hai India koo ..😂😂😂😂
To be Frank enough,I actually felt impressed that India is ahead of even European countries in the race of data usage
I believe India will use it to make it more efficient
I also read about India's aadhar system
It's actually cool ,Go India 👍
Yes India is using data efficiently....in the last 5-6 years our govt makes sure to store indians data in India whether one using any foreign app that's why many US origin techno giants are building data centre in India....and we have two hostile neighbour Pakistan and China that's why it is necessary to track our misguided citizens and also terrorist organisations which work for Pakistan
Yup,
Way ahead in Spying on every Civilian.
We call that Data Usage because
Spying on Women Sounds Bad. 🤣
So many police station they don't have building in India. Don't trust DW news. Go on check the state government sites
Thank you. DW news should investgate their own country's policies and actions more.
DW's germany has more cameras than what India has
Unlike in the West, India has been affected hugely by terrorism. So surveillance isn't a luxury. It's a necessity. Plus it helps combat trafficking of all types.
lul,
bruh, have you heard of September 11th 😂
@@johnnydoe3603 Bruv! Have u heard of 26/11? Lol!
@@johnnydoe3603 That's one incident and the terrorists were those who were nurtured by US.
@@johnnydoe3603
Pathankot kot, parliament 2001, URI, Pulwama, 26/11,....
@@johnnydoe3603 terrorist attacks like 9/11 happen a lot in India we are neighbours wih China and Pakistan.
As an Indian I just want to say that this channel reports our country in negative light always and tries to build a perception maybe the people that rule over Germany or the ones who control this channel want the current govt to change
You are being overly sensitive. They report on bad things the USA and Russia and China and lots of others do, too. India is not perfect, just like everyone else.
Can u challenge it on facts
Truth Hurts 🤷♀️
@@anshuraj4277 Why would they ?
They are on the Payroll of the Same
Agency that Snoops on Indians. 🤣🤣
These guys are worse than TRT, BBC and France 24. Those channels have made it clear that they are anti-India, but these DW guys pretend that they are neutral but always intend to create a negative image.
When you're enemy is obsess and disagree with you then you are in a right path😁😁
Which enemy you referring to?
Lol you Indians hate the west so much but realize you have no other allies. China is currently stealing your land as I write this and Russia has no more military equipment to send you.
It’s just you and North Korea sitting there now like what next.
Orange flags will be only the beginning of the end of your country, just wait for the red ones
@@Ksgggg west
When a foreign state funded broadcaster is asking questions, you should know they have an agenda. Don't forget east India company and British rule, they were able to rule us for 200 years because of our internal differences. They were just 100000 British when India got independence, but there were 300 million Indians.
@@Ksgggg Pakistan
Hey hey in India Law and Order is State matter and the whole sample space you took of just 4 people don't come under governance of BJP which don't know why somehow popped up that brings me to question, Are you really publishing honest reports or are selectively cherry-picking
Governments and companies like Google and Facebook already have all the personal data, so there is no such thing as privacy. Just do no wrong and there is nothing to worry about.
Who will decide what is wrong ? what seems right for today's government will be wrong for other , google and facebook don't hold the same power as governments . Although data with both of them is a coz of concern .
@@SaraswatMajumder just 1
Advice stop getting manipulated by Duggal ratha
@@SaraswatMajumder and taking about power
You know how much data did Alphabet and MeTa have yours
@@SaraswatMajumder Google and Facebook have more power then a govt they so biased that they block people opinion on online not come under any govt laws
This should be replicated in every metropolitan city of India. Thanks dw news!
Anti national , Pakistanis , and urban naxals like you help this channel by commenting and viewing it
@@MrPokemonCheatandTech ok bot
Governments change, the system will be permanent, you might trust the present government and you can defend it but the future is uncertain.
@@MrPokemonCheatandTech Jhati?
India should have sovereignty over its own cyberspace.
Then tell India to disconnect from the internet that the USA invented. They can make their own network like China.
Silicon valley based big-tech companies is not accountable to Indian laws or its people. Having its own capacity in tech that impacts billions of Indians and their data is important and as you suggest having its own network like China is not a bad idea.
@@avishakdebroy937 That's Exactly What
Communist Party told Chinese before
they Implemented the Great Firewall
and a Surveillance State. 🤣
@@avishakdebroy937 Bro Americans do not have protection from our own companies, so it's not like our companies are picking on Indians. Laws are good but this is not some kind of data colonialism - they take advantage of Americans the most.
@@avishakdebroy937 And just steal all of the good ideas from the American companies like Indian and Chinese "entrepreneurs" are already doing, and then put a new name on it. Easy. "Fixed" with new problems.
first of all dw should be sued for showing wrong map of India.
I feel more than 90% videos related to india are negative on this news channel.
Everywhere because Indian govt. doesn't sue like China Turkey Russia for posting bs
100%
As a Indian..we support our govt .. India need to protect own citizen from terrorist funded by china and Pakistan...
This channel is becoming progressively more unhinged with its narrative about India and news related to India. The only real value this channel has for the news of Indian subcontinent is comical one.
Since the Germans, or the EU, couldn't get Modi closer to the West and NATO to be against Russia after inviting him at the G7 and did a European leaders tour, they decided to do an internal regime change to coup Modi out by spreading their propa to vilify anything Modi and India. Just like how they actively did to Russia a few months back.
BJP isn't even the ruling party in Hyderabad city lol 😆 so much for impartial news by dw.
Bro , i can't stop me for laughing
His background music is very funny 🤣🤣
@@GauravKumar-vr6nn
Centre has control over all states in India irrespective of state ruling party
@@ThE-vp4op kuchh bhi 😂 if Terrist ateck who will respond ?
@@ThE-vp4op no thats not correct....Centre can't interfere in state specially when other party ruled in state...
@Shines jihadi found.
When will Germany criticize US for the voliolation of human rights of Julian Assange
They can't criticise their master
@@AkshayKumar-nk8dw 😅👍
They are basically vasal state of US and DW is government funded channel. In a way, you can say this is just New York times' German outlet.
usa own germany
Pet dogs cannot questions their masters.
One simple thing I learnt with respect to the global south, if you are annoying the west, you're on the right track. If you're making Bill Gates happy, time to rethink your whole life.
100% true
Come on Masood! Take it easy man🤣🤣
Kudos to dw for furthering indophobia in Europe and Germany.
LOL! WUT?
@@Randy778 lol, see the reaction of Indians here.
Nearly all of them are angry because what DW is showing is literally opposite of truth.
@@krishnkant9477 Do you recognise India has a Hindu supremacist problem, lead by modi? Do you see why people are concerned?
@@krishnkant9477 ROFL! Sure a Modi spam team´s "proof". Evenmoreso as Petersburg newzcasaters happily jump on any bandwagon to spread their online gibberish.
@@Randy778 they have summarized and hypothesized by cherrypicking cases. Sorry not even cases but a single case. They have based an entire 20 min documentary on 1 paranoid individual in 1 city of india and they are trying to generalize for over 1 billion people. Instead of quoting biased individuals they should quote actual studies.
Maybe its time Europe grows over the mindset that the world cannot govern itself and hence its Europe's moral responsibility to lecture everyone how a country should be run.
@Limon Cello Like Europe colonizing most of the world.
@Limon Cello Germany.
Read a few dozen books about historical wars and how they occur and then you might understand why so many countries worry about stability in other countries. It is not because they want you to be perfect, or because they think you are worthless...it is because the world could burn the next time we hit a big period of world unrest.
@@hanmantpatil5721 Germans are still living in 20th century, I was dumbfounded when I was in Berlin that people are so less digitally uneducated in a first world country lik Germany 😐
You are free to believe what ever you want to.
There is a reason why no major terror attack happened in india except in J&K & Nagaland
Even i do agree there are a lot of issues with adhar card in terms of privacy
Wow DW documentry is on next level, he has done great job, i can't stop me for laughing he has done great research 😂😂😂
His background space and music is very funny like ghost story
Anti national , Pakistanis , and urban naxals like you help this channel by commenting and viewing it
😂😂😂
As they say... "Privacy is a Myth"
A line from Family Man
Though I admire the selection of topics on this channel I have a feeling they always have an axe to grind against India.!!!
You got it right.
Anti national , Pakistanis , and urban naxals like you help this channel by commenting and viewing it
@@Anuj10_01 Anti national , Pakistanis , and urban naxals like you help this channel by commenting and viewing it
@@Anuj10_01 But even if congress will at the government they will have taken this step .
First show real map of India . I request government of India if anyone use illegal maps of India then ban their content .
Lol what?
@@nenasiek 11:27 this not showing active borders.
@@jirachi-wishmaker9242 so if someone uses the wrong map the indian gov should ban all of the content on TH-cam? You guys need to chill, New Zealand gets left out of world maps and the just sigh and move on. Grow a bit tougher skin dude
@@nenasiek Indians are one of the most sensitive about being criticized, I'm not sure why. I think it is probably not even the normal people, but instead poorly managed psychological operations units.
@@nenasiek no I want India to make cyber wall just like China . These social media companies are tool of western agency to destabilise their enemy .
Like Germany we are not a vessal state of USA ,so we know what to do,
The US does not have "vassal states.". Your comment is nonsensical. I thought Indians were smarter than this.
@@ems7623 Western media will not tell lies because western media is free and fair, only Russian and Chinese media will tell lies, when western media criticize India, India should reflect on itself
@@ems7623 Otherwise why would Germany threaten its energy security for America's interests?
@@ems7623 Germany is a vessel state of US because it's not in Germany interest to sanction russia but still Germany sanctiond russia lol
@@ems7623 in Europe except France all are vassal States of USA
Since the Russia-Ukraine war started and India refused to join anyone's side, Western countries become a lot more conscious of India🤔🤔🤔
India is Russians side from the beginning, it's not showing that off directly.
I am also Indian and support Russian aggression on Unkraine.
We’ve been wary of the mighty west since before the war
Of course India is doing that and most Indians support it.
No matter how much hogwash you spread here about it, you can't delude Indians.
We are strongly standing with our government.
Why do so many Indians online take offense at any international media interest in their nation? This is very peculiar behavior and not a good sign of what might be occurring culturally inside India in recent years.
Not everything is an attack on India. The world is interested in India because it's a massive democracy and an ancient civilization. Calm down.
Western media will not tell lies because western media is free and fair, only Russian and Chinese media will tell lies, when western media criticize India, India should reflect on itself
YES BROTHER 🇮🇳🚩🙏
@@Shadowless_Kick You are right.
More surveillancing has reduced crime rates, and places are much more safer than earlier.
I have been to the capital city of my state and saw the drastic positive effects that a strong surveillancing system along with well trained cyber police has bought. Most parts of the city are now perfectly safe to even visit at midnight without any fear.
People has also became more sincere and are following rules and laws too.
Yes we Indians stand united and stand with our government
US, UK are leading along with Germany in the top 5 to 6… The documentary is talking about other countries only.. 🧐 agree that there is need to strengthen data protection laws, security and measures
Have you been or lived in US,UK, or Germany?
Yes. 7 years US. 0.5 UK.. Germany just on vacation though.
@@pmzqhg awesome. Glad you did that. Most people haven't and yet they have strong opinions 😆
Their problem is not data collection but BJP😭😁
librandu detected opinion rejected
cry librandu cry
When corporate western media think this way, that means our government is doing something good and useful to our country.
I was working in gulf countries one my friend car got accident . when my friend gone to police station the police already took the video footage of the incident and said it is not his mistake but other vehicle violated the rule . When he came to know that that route was important for transporting cash to the city ATM machines police started 24/7 surveillance of that particular road helps fetch the video footage of accident . But this channel chooses india for their propoganda. We indians I think should be serious to deal with these westeners.
These Westerner divided our country, our people in the name of religion and language. They looted all the wealth and left behind broken system so India can never rise.
This bigots salty about that we don't supporting this shameless hypocrite and supporting Russia, in frustration this German Shepherd doing all this.
I am so glad that you're not working in gulf country anymore. Phew close call dude!
Don't worry Germany (DW) we can understand your pain 😆😀
Yeah Germany is good at surveillance. They are probably good at giving advice on the societal effects of such a system.
This is a hit piece crafted by DW, as proved by the majority of comments from Indians- shame on you, DW. Jai Hind.
SO IN EVERY COUNTRY YOU MAKE A DOCUMENTARY WHEN A SINGLE CITIZEN IS PHOTOGRAPHED ?
Personal data collection has been going on from even before WWII. Good to know, people globally have become conscious about their personal data. Too late though.
correct the map first Dw otherwise I am reporting this video
How else police is supposed to catch thieves and criminals?
If you are law abiding citizens there is nothing to be afraid or have a problem...
this video is classic example of western world telling others what not to do, while doing it themselves ✨
sure, if you are a citizen abiding the CURRENT rules you might have nothing to be afraid of. what if the rules change however? what if in the future the political climate in the country changes and a government comes to power with more radical views, views that you might not agree with. and what if that government then starts to persecute its political opponents? Suddenly this massive amount of surveillance data can be used to oppress minorities and people with differing political ideas, like you. you don't even have to think of that drastic of a scenario. you might someday be judged for your past archived actions, which at the time were considered fine, but now are against the law or are deemed unacceptable based on new rules that you might not agree with. not even speaking about how a system like this prohibits societal change and creates a climate of fear because everyone speaking out against the status quo does so with much greater risk to themself. large scale surveillance is prone to be abused and must be kept in check and under regulations.
I am happy I still have some kind of privacy in the Netherlands. I am no criminal but that doesn’t mean I would like to be videotapes all time. It’s sad that they need those methods to keep power
@@MrWise23 prevention is better than cure ...
@@adied_2001
The West is already well under surveillance.
Klaus is happy.
When does a surveillance state become intrusive?
From the moment it is conceived.
When should it be stopped?
Before it starts...
I would rather live in surveillance state rather than in one with constant fear of terror. Life is important privacy comes afterwards
The fact that DW could interview Masood proves that democracy prevails in India and the data is well protected
@@vishvpatel899 Then go to China 🤣
@@vrutantshah7218 They also Interviewed Uyghurs. Doesn't mean China is a Democracy. Gobar Logic fails again. 🤣
@@ratnamani8228 Those interviews are of the family members of the Uyghurs who have migrated to Europe
before the spread of victim cards by minorities telangana/hyderabad is ruled by non BJP non MODI govt who have alliance with hate monger aimim, so they are doing this for own safety and ignore these paid ngos spreading lies of privacy bogey
Those Owaishy venomous hate monger brothers are activists and biggest liberal for this bigots dw.
"This is Masood"
Whole story is clear now🤣🤣
Yes there are face recognition camera in city ...am from Hyderabad and there are so many cameras around...this is good and for safety for us and for country safety and security...
It's better to get my photo taken than ending up dead from a bomb blast.
when your enemies has data of his 1.42 billion people you are bound to increase surveillance and ...remember a great man said ...............'Privacy is Just a Joke ' If jeff bezos phone can be hacked than anyone's can be 😂😂
so India must do it because China does ? .. what ?
@@coraltown1 this is necessary to learn the use of artificial intelligence for future warfare which will be based on cyber,space and artificial intelligence
@@coraltown1 this is 21st century and this is a part of modern warfare
@@coraltown1 no let Chinese dragon roam freely
@@coraltown1 as an Indian bi support that. I don't want want this demoncracy as it never did good to indigenous people. Thank you
Why DW never reads it comments
This entire video can be summed up in a 100 word article. Thanks for wasting my time.
11:26 India map is inaccurate. Arunachal Pradesh and J&K are part of India just like any other states.
DW is painting the western view on us with their "liberendu" agendas
No, they are disputed areas
@@dasgupta9288 they might be in the eye of China and west but whole of Arunachal Pradesh is india control and have indian ID..
Disputed areas like Tibet, Taiwan... I guess
@@dasgupta9288 kuch bhi you can easily travel in arunachal, ladakh, j&k how can it become disputed
India is a democracy in progress. New technologies keep pushing the boundaries of what's possible. Observing citizens is not a concern as long as the citizen is allowed to know what's known about him like we are informed who accessed our AADHAR info.
Wow Hyderabad police is under modi 😹
A day without wrong information and shame is a day wasted
- DW news
Well done India
SURVEILLANCE IS VERY IMPORTANT
This is not China. We elected our own government, it has every right to eye on its citizens for their safety.
Do dw realize bjp is not in power in Hyderabad
Indian Govt need not spy on People on CCTV Cameras, They already have a Big Database of Records of almost every Indian - Its called "Aadhar Biometric Database" which contains Personal Information like Photo, Thumb Print, Blood Type, Age, Name, Sex, Religion, Location and Educational Qualifications of every Indian to issue "Social Security" Cards called "Aadhar Cards".
Dw correct indian map Kashmir and arunachal Pradesh.
Correct
Whole Europe is disputed territory between RUSSIA and US,india should remove the map of Europe lol😂
@@ADITYAKUMAR-mb5ht yes indian govt see whole border with Pakistan Nepal Bhutan Bangladesh Myanmar and china.
Use active border! Why are they showing enemy bs claims?
I think dw should know that is police is a state subject and under control of state government. There is no role of central government.india faced so many terrorist attack and Hyderabad is one of top popular city of india so its become very important to secure its security
Excellent step by India👍👍
Hyderabad isn't even ruled by bjp, i am sorry for pointing out the mistake of video don't want to sound very argumentative, but this sound like a propoganda video.
The EDRi network has commissioned an independent report from the Edinburgh International Justice Initiative (EIJI) which brings together stark evidence of abusive facial recognition and other forms of biometric surveillance across the European Union (EU). The research shows that harmful biometric mass surveillance practices have become worryingly normalised by law enforcement, other public authorities and private companies in Germany and the Netherlands, with Poland starting to catch up.
This new evidence comes hot on the heels of the EU’s two top privacy watchdogs, the European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS) and European Data Protection Board (EDPB), confirming that the EU must ban all automated recognition of human features in publicly accessible spaces, as EDRi has long argued.
A chilling set of revelations
The report shows that across Germany, Poland and the Netherlands, biometric systems are increasingly required for accessing public services, travel, shopping and other everyday activities. As a result, people are being given the false choice to either submit their sensitive data, or be excluded from society.
In one example, the report exposes how Dutch police have allegedly used financial incentives and ‘dark patterns’ to encourage people to share private surveillance footage with police for biometric analysis, as a way to evade current national laws.
“The faces of 1 in 12 citizens in the Netherlands are in the massive database of the Dutch police often without any justification. There are multiple cases where, under the guise of experimentation, legal frameworks are pushed aside in order to turn cities into “Living” Laboratories and citizens into guinea pigs. Current regulations are not adequately protecting our rights and freedoms. These toxic and discriminatory biometric mass surveillance practices urgently need to stop!” - explains Lotte Houwing, Policy Advisor at EDRi member Bits of Freedom in the Netherlands
In Germany, the report shows that authorities in the city of Cologne have deployed facial recognition systems outside of LGBTQ+ venues, religious venues, doctor’s surgeries and lawyers’ offices without any legitimate justification. The disproportionate deployment of such technologies against certain marginalised groups amplifies structural oppression in society and limits people’s rights to express freely, move without fear and be who they are.
this German government is more interested in showing bad things about India all the time. They are running a facist government in garb of democracy.
It's all about pointing other's mistakes. That's how state media works.
@@jirachi-wishmaker9242 they aren't pointing out they are doing this preplanned agenda to spoil the Indian image infront of world
Why the heck they are talking about india if their country does the same thing. it's good thing Indian sided with russia, Russian media don't do this type of things that why indians love russia and most importantly they aren't shamless hypocrite like western countries
@@jirachi-wishmaker9242 yeah, but that's why we should be doubly angry about our government doing it with our people! Even with all the concrete transparent framework there has been abuse of surveillance powers, how can we trust our government? In a population as sensitive as India?! How do we know they wouldn't use it to influence elections?!
@@AA-sn9lz lol how they can use mass surveillance to influence elections
First I will use this big data to track dw reporters🤣😂😂
Go and do a documentary on the biggest surveillance state of them all - USA...
Thanks DW, Indian Gov. need to apply this thing in every city
Public Surveillance is fine as long as their are data protection laws in place and a system to ensure no misuse happens. Those wishing otherwise are naive and will suffer the consequences
Seems Like DW is Obsessed With BJP These Days 🤔🤔🤔
Support indian government 👍
Surveillance is absolute necessary in country like India where there are lot of people. Without surveillance there can't be any law enforcement and ultimately citizens will blame government if any anti social activity happens. It is the duty of government and police to track down anti social elements, solve crime as soon as possible. Don't try to make horror video on this. This is happening in India for a long time time. And this is why we are safe here.
Masood posts pics and videos on facebook, twitter, whatsapp.... But a click by police is directly hitting and killing democracy.....hipocracy Ki bhi koi sima hoti h
Germany, USA,Uk etc are too doing these kind of stuff.... Make video about them aswell Or in this video you could have atleast add those countries name while you are mentioning democratic countries
1. Police is under control of the state government and not centre
2. Hydrabad is not ruled by BJP but a local party
3. Government already has Photo and biomatric data of people, including location phone numbers etc
4. A country that is divided and fragmented and crimes that go unsolved most of the time, we Indians welcome this
5. Unlike west we have to worry about terrorist activities
6. DW just hates BJP or its trying to push India bad agenda, its not hidden unlike the past people have internet and a good echosysem has formed proving baised reporting with proof
7. BJP won because people voted them and showed support in BJP's vision, next election in 2024 they will win again for 3rd time, are they perfect? no they are far from it, but BJP is solving some of the biggest issue India is facing, like building bathrooms, building roads and railways, providing electricity and water to every home, cheap internet, inclusion of poor people into digital economy, most of the indians dint even had bank accounts before, solving issue of massive curroption
8. And because of biased news like this is why alot of youth are starting to resent west
Lmao Germany talking about date privacy 😂😂😂 your own chancellor was spied by Danes for Donald Trump 😂😂😂
Dw news go and make a video about privacy in America and Germany why only focus on India
First of alI, I wonder, does Germany asks personal information for VISA or not? Second, Europe will never understand India, they look from their own templates on all matters, and think they are template for democracy as well. India is different country and people have different priorities and sensitivities.
Hmm, I do see lack of perspective in your strong opinion. Personal information for VISA? How else are they gonna identify you as a indian national in other coutry?
Bdw did you ever fill bank loan application ? or installed corona tracking app on your mobile?
Its Nice to see how much DW and German's are always obsess so much with india.
Dw India is emerging super power accept it and my advice to you dont be at bad side of indian viewers, cause when we start covering and exposing every domestic issues of Germany you cant bear it.
'Dw news' seems to have unhealthy obssession with indian politics.
I hope, Europeans should not tell the world about digital surveillance.
even as a BJP supporter I agree that the surveillance is kind of too big now but not a class issue its a crime issue most crimes take place in slums
Bhai 😂in Hyderabad there is no BJP government 😂🥴 they have no control over police it's state government is different party
Hyderabad is the same city where first hindu massacres started. Hindus were openly raped and Hyderabad is fairly radicalised. I see no problem. Btw Hyderabad not under BJP
Annually 150,000 people die on the roads.
DW should make a documentary on how India should stop using roads....
The 700 mio women who don´t have access to basic health care and hygene´s more interesting.
@@Randy778
The population of India is say 1.4 million.
Approximately near Half of that is women....700 million....
So what are you saying......
@@rohitkashyap7476 I know: logic is hard 😅
@@Randy778 I know right.....let me help you out... through
so you are saying.....none of the Indian women have access to healthcare ...like noone......
Go figure....Maybe U need special care....
@@Randy778 when u don't take studies seriously🙁!!
Stayed 3 years in UK, each and every home and street, each public bus and train, has a camera. So @DW you have anything to sensationalise and complain ???????????????
DW is dreaming about India after India showed Germany its place.
I doubt India showed Germany anything other than the horrible pollution levels in India!
Germany = an ordered disciplined society which is clean, developed, and technologically advanced.
India = an disorganised chaotic anarchic society where people are undisciplined and isn't developed enough.
What you are trying to say ? , only india do Surveillance ? What About US, Europe, China ?
Why not reporting on Kaniya lal : lodi media
DW tone down dude, learn to respect the vote of Indian people. Fear mongering ain't cool. And stop showing wrong map.
60 percent indian they are living in village without camera 🧐😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😁😁. And cities like Patna we don't have camera in our city.
The Yellow Filter used in this video itself is proof of the western media's propoganda against India. 😂😂
12:28 He looks more dangerous to me than Indian govt. ,look at his expressions 😂😂😂😂
😂
Law&order and Police is under state list ( For DW knowledge, India is a federal country), and thus the Telegana Government is empowered by constitution of India to make laws on police and order. And BJP is not the ruling party of Telegana 😅 thus the thumbnail proves the preconceived bias & blindness labelling of DW
11:26
If India does some BS claims on Germany's land. Will you shade your map like that?
Why not show Donbas & Crimea in Russian map then?
Because Germany does not agree with India's contested territories, and "Donbas & Crimea" will never be shown as Russian as it does not serve the narrative of Germany, by extension NATO.
@@porkysharma8423 Those are under control, not contested. India has Instrument of Accession of those states.
@@jirachi-wishmaker9242 Not for Germany and its allies.
@Earthling UNESCO refers to cultural heritage, not territorial borders.
Do you know which govt police force has power in Hyderabad?