This ridiculous defendant continously talking in circles about irrelevant nonsense, trying to tiptoe around the obvious truth which is that the cards were "stolen" while in his care and he is clearly 100% responsible 🤦🏼♀️
The defendant is definitely lying. There was no theft, he kept the cards because he knows that they are rare, and can probably go for a lot one day. We may not understand the value of these cards, but he definitely did. I think it was very reckless to put them in a bag and leave them unattended, also is super suspicious that the security camera guy wasn't there that of all days 🙄
A black lotus is worth $30,000. Beta cards my brother has are work $14000 and $8000 . They are very valuable I wrote this before watching this all haha
I knew a guy who had a $30,000 deck that he had an insurance policy for 100,000 on lol this is serious business, the defendant owes him all of the CARDS back
So just because he's been playing the game for 20 years, the defendant truly thought every single person in that room was honest, he could leave a bag with obviously high priced cards in it? And "Oh gosh darn" wouldn't you know the only guy that can access the video security ... happened to be away that day?! Irresponsible with a capital "I"!
@@crystalshaw8744 obviously it was a lie.. when he first started his story he was trying to blame it on the plaintiffs witness in a completely different story until Judge Milian called him out and said that wasn't the story he had put in his answer to the complaint. Then he changed it back to the stolen bag story. 2 completely different stories, no way he's telling the truth.
Defendant: blahblahblah blahadibla blahdiblahblah Judge: dear Lord guy!!! Get to the point already!! Defendant: so I blahdiblah and he blahabladah and blah Judge: that's it, I'm done! Stick a fork in me, I'm done! Judgement for the plaintiff for $$$$$!!!! Defendant: but blahblahblah gag gag done!
I love love Judge Marilyn Milian. She takes up for the little guy. She also does not tolerate people throwing out insults. I enjoy watching her do her thang.☺
Yup, and additionally, in my neighborhood, we would have called somebody like him a "mark". The defendant (and his friend too, he was in on it) set the geek up. They were thinking he would not pursue them. Good on him for not letting himself be taken advantage of.
My son has played Magic for years; he has many decks. Just yesterday I bought his Christmas present: 35 Magic cards. Also, defendant said "This is the original trading card game." Baseball cards are not traded to play a game. Magic really is the first GAME to use trading cards. Lastly, this is yet another case of "I didn't mean to do it so it's not my fault." I have no idea if the defendant is telling the truth about the cards being stolen, but I'm dumbfounded that he would think that if they were, then too bad so sad for plaintiff. Those cards were his responsibility; he owes the plaintiff their value for being so careless.
Defendant making up stuff along the way, you can tell by his body language. Also, throwing in irrelevant things to throw things off, that’s why judge said stop 🛑. He kept the cards for himself. Shame on him! And why would you leave a bag somewhere and leave it unattended. He needs to pay and he is responsible!
The defendant is a Liar. Watch him wiggle. As he talks he is looking all around indicating searching for answers. He is a very deceptive person. His word salad is going nowhere. No one do business with this creep! Possession is 9/10 of the law-defendant possesd the items. I think he sold them and thought his crazy words would save him. So glad plaintiff won.
Just into the intro and I know the defendant is going to be on the hook. Lying or not, he was responsible for those cards once they were in his care. My husband is an avid MTG player, there's some serious money in some of those cards.
Lol what..I'm commenting before even watching..of course you're responsible if someone gives you something and you lose it (which includes it being stolen). Especially when it wasn't something like being robbed at gunpoint or a break in, you left their stuff outside and weren't paying attention.
This guy's story changed so many times. "they got sold but he didn't get the money". "The bag got stolen". "It's not my fault". SO many people would love to get their hands on a Black Lotus. This guy obviously took it. "I didn't call the cops because they'd laugh". Yeah ok. I was pretty much DROOLING over that collection he was selling as a MTG player. He definitely stole them and am either using them or selling them.
This case...my god. As a former Pokemon and Yugioh card game player, I'm appalled at the Plaintiff saying that Magic is LIKE Pomemon...like, respect the King. Magic was there first. Also, i almost swerved off the road when Judge Milian started reading the names of the cards perfectly. Also, imo the Defendant was responsible for the cards until they were sold. So as of a judgment he's technically "buying" them at that moment. So making him pay fair market value as of filing is actually fair if you think about it.
But I'm NOT thinking about it. At all, in fact. Now what? Does that affect your opinion or response? Just thought it was important to be open and honest with you. Lol
@@MeSpawn297 Yeah, yeah. Gonna take the weekend off. Prolly do a couple little automotive jobs on my beater of a car. Get my car ready for the Canadian winter just around the corner. Thinking bout Halloween coming up too. Usually volunteer to work weekends but taking a break this wknd. Sort of. Lol. You? What're you doin friend? Lol.
@@dionst.michael1482 I actually have to work a little bit on Sunday which is a bummer. But I have a friend coming into town so we're gonna have a great time regardless.
Defendant is a liar and a Thief. He knew those cards had value and took them for himself. His defense is a lot of "who shot John?" 😳 Mr. Russo is kinda cute 😍 😆.
Best case scenario is that he’s a neglectful idiot…. more likely scenario, he’s a liar and a thief 🤥 Looks like he’s no stranger substance abuse either.
I love how seriously the judge took this case. Merchandise is valuable if the people say it is. And the internet is the voice of the people. $3k well deserved.
The defendant seems to think that if he just throws words together to make a sentence, and not have an actual answer, the judge and everyone else will be confused. These people are irritating.
Loving the after cases talks with Judge John and Judge Milian. Bonus with advice from Harve Levin at the end. Bravo on this format and making JM look like she in the court room. I feel sad for baliff , Douglas McIntosh. Is he actually in law enforcement? My understanding is like Judge Millian they were all in a “pool” to try for the part with real court officials.
My son-in-law is a die-hard magic player he has tens of thousands of cards. Buys wins and sells sells the prices of some of them are amazing! He bartered cards to get a DJ for their wedding
Another camper stole a deck of my child’s Magic Cards from his backpack at day camp in NJ when he was about 12. We were upset. We have over 500 of these cards in a box in the basement. I wonder if we have any rare cards?
This defendant is a perfect example of why the judge doesn’t want litigants that come before her to be wearing sunglasses. This guy had a harder time looking her in the eye than a dog does after getting into the garbage!😂😂🤡
The defendant is such a liar. You could see it all over his face. He mentioned how “they” are always laughed at whenever they try to report a card theft to the police…I guess Magic card theft must be running rampant in their town. 🙄
This is really sad because I really like the defendant's explanations up until the business about the cards and then try to paint the witness as a culprit. He is a sophisticated liar.
If it were truly a theft the defendant could have used the cctv footage as a defense which he didn't. This stinks of a SETUP, and I'm glad the Plaintiff won.
Holy moly @_@ My son has some of these that his god father gifted him and one card alone he has is worth 300 bucks and we have a dude wanting to buy it(he has duplicates of a bunch) I don't think it was his "lucky day"
Anyone who says "to be honest" IS NOT HONEST!!!!! The Defendant was scrambling and saying ridiculous statements. He sold them. He pocketed ALL THE MONEY.
$3500 for a few printed paper cards? One special printed paper card sold for at least a quarter million dollars? I don't know about you but if I had a quarter million dollars to blow on anything it wouldn't be a printed paper card. Ask yourself ,,, what would Charlie Harper spend a quarter million dollars on?
Very interesting. I had expected the judge to limit the plaintiff to the original contract, a maximum of $2,500, but it appears she placed a negligence tax on the defendant to get up to $3,284.95.
Ok but why was the shop keeper trying to run some story about selling the shop and the new shop owners had the cards and that the plaintiff's witness was asked by defendant to sell the cards to them? And that he has the money? That was such a confusing lie lol I wish she would have let him go into that more
This ridiculous defendant continously talking in circles about irrelevant nonsense, trying to tiptoe around the obvious truth which is that the cards were "stolen" while in his care and he is clearly 100% responsible 🤦🏼♀️
He’s on somwthing
The defendant is definitely lying. There was no theft, he kept the cards because he knows that they are rare, and can probably go for a lot one day. We may not understand the value of these cards, but he definitely did. I think it was very reckless to put them in a bag and leave them unattended, also is super suspicious that the security camera guy wasn't there that of all days 🙄
Good analysis 👍. I agree.
I was thinking the same thing
A black lotus is worth $30,000. Beta cards my brother has are work $14000 and $8000 . They are very valuable
I wrote this before watching this all haha
Sources tell me that his friend who was supposed to help with the security camera is employed at the same prison where Jeffrey Epstein “hung” himself.
Cards are worthless
I knew a guy who had a $30,000 deck that he had an insurance policy for 100,000 on lol this is serious business, the defendant owes him all of the CARDS back
He stole those cards. 😹😹
The defendant knows he is lying and knows they may be worth a lot more in the future. He can't give one straight look.
So just because he's been playing the game for 20 years, the defendant truly thought every single person in that room was honest, he could leave a bag with obviously high priced cards in it?
And "Oh gosh darn" wouldn't you know the only guy that can access the video security ... happened to be away that day?!
Irresponsible with a capital "I"!
I think tht was a lie.
@@crystalshaw8744 obviously it was a lie.. when he first started his story he was trying to blame it on the plaintiffs witness in a completely different story until Judge Milian called him out and said that wasn't the story he had put in his answer to the complaint. Then he changed it back to the stolen bag story. 2 completely different stories, no way he's telling the truth.
The look on his face after he heard what he owed is hilarious. He’s a scammer and justice was served
Defendant: blahblahblah blahadibla blahdiblahblah
Judge: dear Lord guy!!! Get to the point already!!
Defendant: so I blahdiblah and he blahabladah and blah
Judge: that's it, I'm done! Stick a fork in me, I'm done! Judgement for the plaintiff for $$$$$!!!!
Defendant: but blahblahblah gag gag done!
The Judge understands. The Judge understands this defendant for sure LOL
He's a liar. Nobody stole those cards. He sold them and didn't want to pay the Plaintiff the money.
Defendant can't look straight and sit still, I wonder if it is because he has a magic tweaker card in his pocket?
i thought some of the marks on his face looked suspicious
As soon as I saw his eyes, I knew he was on some kind of amphetamine or coke.
@@Lorcar86 👍
At this point Douglas mind as well be on screen lol
I love love Judge Marilyn Milian. She takes up for the little guy. She also does not tolerate people throwing out insults. I enjoy watching her do her thang.☺
The Plaintiff looks like a true geek with his glasses being crooked on his face!! lol!!
Lol. Damn! Couldn't someone have told him about his glasses!?
His ears are uneven
stereotypes exist for a reason
He's cute
Yup, and additionally, in my neighborhood, we would have called somebody like him a "mark". The defendant (and his friend too, he was in on it) set the geek up. They were thinking he would not pursue them. Good on him for not letting himself be taken advantage of.
Oh no🙄 my husband plays this game. I answered her question about the most expensive card before the defendant.....I want to cry 😢
I wish the plaintiff would straighten his glasses, lol. I remember being in 6th grade when Magic The Gathering cards got popular.
😂
He might be part of the uneven ears community. I know I am. And my glasses are always lopsided. 😂
My son has played Magic for years; he has many decks. Just yesterday I bought his Christmas present: 35 Magic cards. Also, defendant said "This is the original trading card game." Baseball cards are not traded to play a game. Magic really is the first GAME to use trading cards. Lastly, this is yet another case of "I didn't mean to do it so it's not my fault." I have no idea if the defendant is telling the truth about the cards being stolen, but I'm dumbfounded that he would think that if they were, then too bad so sad for plaintiff. Those cards were his responsibility; he owes the plaintiff their value for being so careless.
Eyes r the windows to the soul. The defendants eyes show me total dishonest creep
Jm’s hair is very cute today!
The dog ate my homework.
He's not irresponsible he's a thief and a horrible liar
Defendant making up stuff along the way, you can tell by his body language. Also, throwing in irrelevant things to throw things off, that’s why judge said stop 🛑. He kept the cards for himself. Shame on him! And why would you leave a bag somewhere and leave it unattended. He needs to pay and he is responsible!
The defendant's eye movements while speaking proves lying making it up as he is going along.
The defendant is a Liar. Watch him wiggle. As he talks he is looking all around indicating searching for answers. He is a very deceptive person. His word salad is going nowhere. No one do business with this creep! Possession is 9/10 of the law-defendant possesd the items. I think he sold them and thought his crazy words would save him. So glad plaintiff won.
I thought he sold them also and pocketed the money.
Anyway any of them can magically receive Grammer lessons
I appreciate Judge Milian for doing the research. I went to a convention in Detroit one time with a friend...Magic the Gathering is Not a joke!
I do appreciate her genuine curiosity for things like this that she comes across
I have magic cards, too: I say theyre worth a lot, they disappear, then money appears. Magic!!
Defendant = 🤥 🤥 👖 on 🔥
🤣🤣 .....this comment
Just into the intro and I know the defendant is going to be on the hook. Lying or not, he was responsible for those cards once they were in his care. My husband is an avid MTG player, there's some serious money in some of those cards.
Harry Pothead Vs. Con Weasley!
The plaintiff's glasses are not straight on his face. 😵💫
They need adjusting as his ears are different heights.
Plaintiff should of held on to those cards they’re worth 5082$ today
Lol what..I'm commenting before even watching..of course you're responsible if someone gives you something and you lose it (which includes it being stolen). Especially when it wasn't something like being robbed at gunpoint or a break in, you left their stuff outside and weren't paying attention.
Defendant definitely stole the cards.
Defendant is a con. He tried to put it on the witness. He probably sold them and they weren't stolen.
The defendant's face when JM rendered her judgement 18:29 😐😳
😂😂😂😂😂
My inner geek is so giddy to see a case involving Magic cards. I still have all of mine along with various anime cards. 🤓💖
This is ridiculous, tvs on a podium 😆. Poor Douglas.
What a liar the defendant is ! Glad the plaintiff got his money back !
Douglas is having a hoot with this case.
And I know now from my PC addiction...GET EVERYTHING IN WRITING! lol
he clearly stole the cards ! Crooked glasses wins!
Yay a case for the magic players
Lol 😂
I’ll expose my bare breasts for rare magic the gathering cards
Dude stole those cards. He looks a little oily.
This guy's story changed so many times. "they got sold but he didn't get the money". "The bag got stolen". "It's not my fault". SO many people would love to get their hands on a Black Lotus. This guy obviously took it. "I didn't call the cops because they'd laugh". Yeah ok. I was pretty much DROOLING over that collection he was selling as a MTG player. He definitely stole them and am either using them or selling them.
This case...my god. As a former Pokemon and Yugioh card game player, I'm appalled at the Plaintiff saying that Magic is LIKE Pomemon...like, respect the King. Magic was there first. Also, i almost swerved off the road when Judge Milian started reading the names of the cards perfectly.
Also, imo the Defendant was responsible for the cards until they were sold. So as of a judgment he's technically "buying" them at that moment. So making him pay fair market value as of filing is actually fair if you think about it.
But I'm NOT thinking about it. At all, in fact. Now what? Does that affect your opinion or response? Just thought it was important to be open and honest with you. Lol
@@dionst.michael1482 you ok? Having a good day so far? It's almost the weekend!
@@MeSpawn297 Yeah, yeah. Gonna take the weekend off. Prolly do a couple little automotive jobs on my beater of a car. Get my car ready for the Canadian winter just around the corner. Thinking bout Halloween coming up too. Usually volunteer to work weekends but taking a break this wknd. Sort of. Lol. You? What're you doin friend? Lol.
@@dionst.michael1482 I actually have to work a little bit on Sunday which is a bummer. But I have a friend coming into town so we're gonna have a great time regardless.
YTA. Don't watch TH-cam while driving.
Defendant is a liar and a Thief. He knew those cards had value and took them for himself. His defense is a lot of "who shot John?" 😳 Mr. Russo is kinda cute 😍 😆.
I always wondered if people actually played Magic lol my brother & his friends used to play it all the time
Defendant is a slippery liar.
Best case scenario is that he’s a neglectful idiot…. more likely scenario, he’s a liar and a thief 🤥
Looks like he’s no stranger substance abuse either.
I’m getting addict vibes from the defendant. 🤨😒
You were responsible for the cards, you failed to secure them and let them be stolen. If you agreed to the 2,500, pay him already
Yeah……already !
You’re the bad apple sir.
"Stop smoking!" hahahaha -- YES!
If they're worth around $300K, he's suing for too little.
I love how seriously the judge took this case. Merchandise is valuable if the people say it is. And the internet is the voice of the people. $3k well deserved.
He didn't steal the cards so he doesn't feel he owes him any many? Lol they were in his possession they're on him
😂😂😂😂 He probably sold them and kept the money, now he to pay it back...HONESTY is the BEST policy.
How does he think that he doesn’t owe the plaintiff anything??
I’m lost …why are they all on TVs? was this filmed during Covid?
I believe so…it is so odd!
The defendant seems to think that if he just throws words together to make a sentence, and not have an actual answer, the judge and everyone else will be confused. These people are irritating.
The defendant is as crooked as the plaintiff’s glasses
Loving the after cases talks with Judge John and Judge Milian. Bonus with advice from Harve Levin at the end. Bravo on this format and making JM look like she in the court room. I feel sad for baliff , Douglas McIntosh. Is he actually in law enforcement? My understanding is like Judge Millian they were all in a “pool” to try for the part with real court officials.
I am concerned about the plaintiff's glasses not being straight.
My son-in-law is a die-hard magic player he has tens of thousands of cards. Buys wins and sells sells the prices of
some of them are amazing! He bartered cards to get a DJ for their wedding
Wow 👏 good for him
Another camper stole a deck of my child’s Magic Cards from his backpack at day camp in NJ when he was about 12. We were upset. We have over 500 of these cards in a box in the basement. I wonder if we have any rare cards?
Lackey, that you?
I think that is him!
This defendant is a perfect example of why the judge doesn’t want litigants that come before her to be wearing sunglasses. This guy had a harder time looking her in the eye than a dog does after getting into the garbage!😂😂🤡
Defendant is weird af
He's correct about not calling police' they barely wants to come out for a fender bender
Defendant is high asf phuc. He is as all over the place as Donald Trump and makes just as little sense. Somebody get that dude some narcan.
All I gotta say is “they were stolen?” Or “they were sold?”
The defendant is such a liar. You could see it all over his face. He mentioned how “they” are always laughed at whenever they try to report a card theft to the police…I guess Magic card theft must be running rampant in their town. 🙄
What was that crazy story the defendant started telling before the judge reminded him what his original lie was. 😂
This is really sad because I really like the defendant's explanations up until the business about the cards and then try to paint the witness as a culprit. He is a sophisticated liar.
When he said poof and the bag was gone I’d imagine that he threw down a smoke bomb and vanished with the loot/Cards.
😂
If it were truly a theft the defendant could have used the cctv footage as a defense which he didn't. This stinks of a SETUP, and I'm glad the Plaintiff won.
Holy moly @_@ My son has some of these that his god father gifted him and one card alone he has is worth 300 bucks and we have a dude wanting to buy it(he has duplicates of a bunch) I don't think it was his "lucky day"
Definitely a first world problem.
I wish the plaintiff could have gotten more to teach that thief a lesson. He's correct in saying someone stole the cards.....He Did!!!
My only ? "Why would anyone sell any expensive rare magic trading cards in the 1st place?"
The plaintiff has been scamming geeks since he was in grade 1
Nerd vs. nerd!
I need the plaintiff to fix his glasses 😂
Defendant stole them
“It is if you wanna arrive at that sum of that equation..” BRO WHAT??
Happy Friday..watching from Australia
Hello, Have a grand weekend!
Happy day to you, not watching from Australia but I know where it is on a globe.
Good morning Bel, a marvelous morning here but the weather is going to change soon.
👋 from London
Amazing the crap people spend money on.
Can the defendant keep his eyes on the judge.
Anyone who says "to be honest" IS NOT HONEST!!!!! The Defendant was scrambling and saying ridiculous statements. He sold them. He pocketed ALL THE MONEY.
The plaintiff's looks like Colonel Sanders when he was just private sanders.
$3500 for a few printed paper cards? One special printed paper card sold for at least a quarter million dollars? I don't know about you but if I had a quarter million dollars to blow on anything it wouldn't be a printed paper card. Ask yourself ,,, what would Charlie Harper spend a quarter million dollars on?
I loved the look on his face and eye lift at the end was amazing, karma is a bitch!! 😅
Defendant overplayed his store ownership. likely showing off or trying to impress rather than defend his case. What a tool.
😂🤣The look of the defendant's face at 18:30 is Priceless!!!😂🤣
Hope that cigarette was worth it!!!😁
Very interesting. I had expected the judge to limit the plaintiff to the original contract, a maximum of $2,500, but it appears she placed a negligence tax on the defendant to get up to $3,284.95.
So he can't believe that someone in the community would steal the cards, but he knows how the police react when they're called about card theft. Ok 👌🏻
Defendant should also give up smoking because his voice is totally fried due to it.
Ok but why was the shop keeper trying to run some story about selling the shop and the new shop owners had the cards and that the plaintiff's witness was asked by defendant to sell the cards to them? And that he has the money? That was such a confusing lie lol I wish she would have let him go into that more
His right hand stole the cards from his left hand ….that’s how they were stolen ….lol
‘Within the community’ ‘sell the goods’😆😆😆. What a bunch of nerds